4 Reasons Your Cream Eye Shadows DON'T Look Good

[@CrystalMyrcas]

I've become allergic to powder eyeshadow but can tolerate creams for the time being so I really appreciate the number of cream eyeshadow tutorials you've made. Thank you.

[@Stephanie-hl8jo]

Within 2 seconds I went straight to the description box to see what you used to get your gorgeous peachy lips!!! love!!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

haha what's funny is the shades I used aren't peachy at all but I think a lot of colors just translate that way on me!

[@Stephanie-hl8jo]

@@ShelbeyWilson I guess the brownish lipliner with light pinky gloss could create peachy lips. Makes sense :) LOVE your channel.

[@Katebrown112]

You're a breath of fresh air. Very informative. I've yet to master one cream eyeshadow.

[@ShelbeyWilson]

You can do it! :)

[@suzanstorm2982]

I can't get it either!!!

[@spearageddon3279]

The ByTerry ombre sticks have a great formula also, awesome on mature eyes, though they are pricey ... I am 50 with hooded and wrinkly lids, and just got a couple of these .... I can actually wear the shimmer without it aging my eyes because they are not super shimmery like powders and don't settle into lines, just love them! Worth the money, in my opinion. I like to mix them with the LM caviar sticks, my combos.... -> LM "Fog" as a base with BT "Mercure" on top of it; -> LM "Khaki" with BT "Mercure" -> LM "Cashmere" with BT "Frozen Quartz" -> BT "Bronze Moon" on its own is gorgeous.

[@pamburkey6252]

Ditto! My lids too crapey!

[@kimmy0868]

Cocoa is LIFE!!! And I went through almost exactly the tips you’re giving, but once you get the application down pat they are amazing! They last like no other!! Don’t give up on them ladies!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@suzannedaher2092]

Agreed, Cocoa is my favorite as well, and I’ve collected a ton of shades, so that’s saying something LOL

[@Donna-cc1kt]

Ooookay, I’ll try - again. 💕

[@jcs1090]

Does cocoa have a purple tone in it?

[@jenniferharris7633]

The reason why YOU get so many recurring questions about cream shadow application is because YOU are the only YTber that even gives cream eyeshadows a side glance.

[@erinnswan7063]

Amanda Z is a great cream eyeshadow lover. You may like her channel. I love her. Check out her channel.

[@jenniferharris7633]

@@erinnswan7063 Will do. TY.

[@canary177]

I also came here to reccomend Amanda Z! The whole reason I got into her channel is because she has the same style as Shelbey.

[@pamcooke61]

Totally agree!!!

[@donohoe0]

Which Bobbi Brown cream eyeshadow stick colors do you recommend?

[@jackienolan9142]

Found this video months later. I really enjoyed the advice being given here. The things I have learned with makeup and eye makeup specifically: practice makes perfect; definitely take time to tweak certain things like placement of crease color / blending color higher or lower on the crease depending on your eye shape and how you want your eyes to look; if you doing your own makeup for an event make sure you give yourself plenty of time and do your eyes first and then your face; less is more!

[@tonidoll7955]

That color on your shirt really makes your eye color pop!

[@hallievanoutryve3109]

Please try the new elf cream shadow sticks, Shelby!!!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Video using those is coming next week!

[@katrinadessavre5293]

I tried these tips with my caviar sticks in caramel, cocoa, and metallic taupe and my eye look has never looked better! These tips truly made a difference for me, thank you!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

So great to hear!

[@natatatt]

I love cream eyeshadows. They are the eyeshadow product I use 90% of the time. What works for me is using my fingers for initial application (spreading the product across my eyelids), and then go in with a small brush after for blending. I use the Revlon Colourstay Cream Eyeshadows as I only buy drugstore products.

[@angieagentlesoul]

Didnt care for those. Didnt care for the way they bended

[@shantig1983]

I love the matte Bobbi Brown Shadow Sticks but for the life of me I cannot prevent them from creasing within minutes of application (even if I powder my lids first). Do you have any tips?

[@AlwaysInlove211]

I swear by cream eye shadow (charlotte tilbury eyes to mesmerize in star gold) GORGEOUS and easy. I pat it down on my lid and blend it quickly into the crease with my finger. I add bronzer into the crease to help make the transition smoother. I personally think cream is amazing.

[@juliaw7515]

Thank you so much! This is perfect timing for me as I recently got a cream shadow and am struggling with application

[@Josh-pe5pl]

You are SO good at giving your logic for the points u r making, describibing what various formulas do, and simplifying your topic for us. 😘

[@Donna-cc1kt]

I agree. It’s all on me - failure but not defeat.

[@najetteroberts5553]

Dang woman don't you just look beyond breathtaking today!!!! Just saying. Love your eye look here. Love how I always learn something! Also got a new color combo 🐱 to try.

[@ShelbeyWilson]

❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@neeneeintexas]

Macy's has Caviar and Bobby Brown sets on sale for holidays right now.

[@pinkformarie]

You are truly my go to cream eyeshadow queen! Thank you ,your content is always very thorough

[@jfr7160]

I have been slammed... so glad I finally got to see this!!! I love the Laura Mercier Cavair Sticks and have found they are worth the splurge! I agree the key is in the application! Thanks Shelbey!!

[@Purplenpinkk]

I love your channel. For me, you are up there with Wayne Goss, Lisa Eldridge and Alexandra Anele. These are extremely helpful tips - thank you. The only problem with Laura Mercier, Bobbi Brown and CT products are that they aren't cruelty free. I'm really trying to avoid cosmetic products that aren't cruelty free. I bought some of the Kiko Milano - who, BTW, have awesome customer service - and one of the e.l.f. ones...so, still experimenting and will try more of your tips. I read in one of your comments that you are going to do a video of the e.l.f. sticks? Also, I have lips like yours, and it's so refreshing to see a YT who hasn't gone the road of lip fillers. It's very helpful!

[@donnagill7346]

LM “Cobblestone” is my jam!! Love it!! All thanks to you! 💛

[@unmellowyellow]

THANK YOU for this video. I just started wearing eyeshadow during quarantine (boredom + middle aged skin), and I am still learning. I got a couple Pixi cream shadow stick on clearance at Ross, and my mom and I loved them (one of them is the same exact color as CT’s Walk of No Shame!). Then I got a Bobbi Brown one with Sephora points and really liked that too. Now, I have to order some Caviar sticks next! Have a great week everyone!

[@cait_lynne]

This is so helpful! I just got some of the caviar sticks and they've been looking really bad - now I've realised I've been applying way too much! Excited to try again with the proper technique.

[@ShelbeyWilson]

❤️❤️❤️❤️ good luck!

[@Kindlyone777]

I really needed this tutorial. I love cream shadows but I always look like a hot mess. Messy and muddy. I agree I think using the right tools due matter and make a huge difference. Thank you 😊

[@paddymcmarlar]

So helpful, Shelbey! You look beautiful!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Thank you! ❤️

[@alivingston2490]

My goodness! That lip product looks gorgeous on you!

[@AnnathePiana]

Completely agree. I went straight to the downbar to see what it was! 😃

[@pamburkey6252]

Me too!!

[@Brigitte_Cantin]

Thank you I love cream shadows but definitely need to work on my application. 💖

[@Donna-cc1kt]

My cavier sticks have been abandoned for several months but creme is so much better a look. Ooookay, I’ll start again. Thank you.

[@s13rr4buf3]

I would love it if you could do a video on cream eyeshadow and older eyes or hooded eyes. I know you are young and perfect, but maybe you could give us some helpful tips anyway.

[@DLF1122]

I have Caviar Sticks and I have the ones from Beauty Pie and they are pretty much exact in formula. Give them a try. Beauty Pie has great skin care too.

[@sborstner44]

I agree that the Beauty Pie shadow sticks are great dupes for LM & BB sticks.

[@danaa4450]

your eye look in this video is amazing!!!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Thank you so much 😀

[@marybolles251]

You look stunning Shelby! 😍

[@murberdraws]

So strange! I didn’t get an alert that you had uploaded your video, but yay I found it anyway! Love your techniques. 💗

[@sharonamadi7076]

Girl I just came across your video. Really enjoyed. You are such a well spoken young lady. Very relatable to a broad range of women. Thanks so much.

[@lorigeorge7430]

Looking so gorgeous Shelby! Your eyes look so green with your hair dark. Love it ❤️

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Thank you!!

[@sonyavs455]

Such great advice! I am new to cream shadows and am finding it a little challenging. You answered all my questions. Thank you!

[@AlyHollywood]

Bobbi brown often have them sold as minis in sets of 3. Great way to get a lot of colors for an affordable price because they sell the set for the price of a full size.

[@sherribrooker4119]

You look beautiful today! Great color on you and your makeup looks awesome

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Thank you ☺️

[@pickoftheglitterkatiedonne8946]

This is perfect timing-I just purchased Cocoa and Metallic Taupe last week with a gift card from Christmas! Intense Amethyst and Intense Moonlight are already on their way to me. My first foray into cream shadows-you convinced me. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Wonderful! Those are awesome shades!

[@suematulewicz1923]

Hi Shelby I like creams but I always get crinkle lines on my lids eyeshadow is a pain but eyeliner is worse never comes right thanks for this any advice?

[@AllyKit]

Hi Shelby. You introduced me to the caviar sticks and I love the ease of application. However I have mature hooded eyes. My question is how far to take the transition shade or crease color up the lid? I find that when I do, it looks too shimmery and emphasizes the texture, making my lids look crepey. (I use the original colors not the Amplified) I watched the video you did with your mom a while back and I noticed you didn’t really put anything on her upper lid to make her hoods recede. Am I wrong? When I put all the color on the moveable lids, my eyes look more deep set. I have to add powder on the hood but would prefer not to. Help! Would love to see you do more videos with your mom, with the close up angles you use on yourself. Because everything looks great on you but for us mature ladies, the struggle is real!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

I would suggest a really small amount of something like Caramel in the crease if you want to bring a shade up further. I think it's totally fine to define your crease but probably most flattering with a completely matte color.

[@AllyKit]

@@ShelbeyWilsonThank you, I’ll try it! Caramel is next on my list. I’ll never get sick of your cream eye shadow videos. I watch them on a loop lol

[@Deanna.G]

@@AllyKit same!

[@Moonwing72]

You have the best tips Shelby! I always learn something from your videos. Thank you 💜

[@ShelbeyWilson]

I'm so glad! :)

[@MsBuggyness]

nice! I've been struggling with the kiko shadow sticks. can't wait to try out your suggestions tomorrow am.

[@Maryyeung12894]

Could you do a video on mixing powder and cream shadow look?

[@prettykiwikawaii1995]

Definitely need that brush ( Flat but not too stiff brush ) I’m going to buy 4 of them. Thanks hun.

[@kristyearnest6620]

She is so much thorough and informative.

[@jenniferbagg5062]

This was a very helpful video. I implemented #1 and 2 this morning with great results!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Fantastic! :)

[@ruthy102]

If you have dry eyes cream is the only way to go.It also looks much more youthful!You look gorgeous Shelby.Green is your color!

[@kleatherman1017]

Are you using the new 217? I’m reading reviews on MAC and many people are not happy they changed the brush

[@sylvierozon3402]

Still working on my application technique. Do you use the same brush, do you need to clean it between applying different color?

[@tennymusgravebrown8797]

Hazel eyes poppin’ 💜

[@MTB603]

I'm liking Julep eyeshadow sticks. Found on Amazon. Very long wearing and affordable.

[@kosmosbjm]

Those of us who have more mature eyes need help with applying the caviar sticks, especially with the shades that contain metallic or shimmer. I definitely do not use the intense shades.

[@maryrose7842]

Thank you Shelby for explaining about the cream eyeshadow. I like the Charlotte Tilbury Jean it’s easy to use .but I struggle with the Laura mercier caviar stick original Amethyst on my mature hooded eyes I think I have used too much and perhaps I will try a different brush as you have suggested it. I find using my finger is easier to spread it but I lose the shape. I also find it quite a dark colour.

[@jennipitt7964]

Hi, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the Beauty Pie cream eyeshadow sticks

[@debradowling800]

I have both, and they are the same.

[@Liznvx]

Thanks for your advice! It’s really useful. I’ve never been very good with powdered eyeshadows. I’m more of a one and done type of chick. But I love the multidimensional look. So I’ve recently started using creams. They are a real time saver. And they look amazing. The only issue I have is that there are barely any good palettes out there. So I’m building my setup from scratch. It’s costly but it saves me time and that’s what I love the most!! ✨✨

[@jennwald4469]

This was such an informative video. I’m reaching for the Bobbi Brown more then the Laura Mercier these days but I’ll always have both in my collection. Love a simple all over wash with a little pop of shimmer for everyday but am using your technique on the outer corner/crease to add drama for evenings out (whenever we go ‘out’ again).

[@AllyKit]

Jenn Wald Love the BB Rose Gold Perfect color for a one and done shade 🌸

[@barnes-md7mf]

Me sticking my finger in a moussey pot of shadow, smearing it all over my eye and wondering why it never looks good. 🤣🤣

[@ShelbeyWilson]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@goharmartirosyan15]

Story of my eyeshadow game haha

[@daynad8104]

For real! 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@YourDailyDoseofJillish]

My life lol

[@edinagaspar722]

Girl, I am travelling now and I forgot take ANY brush with me (except 1 for the face) and I have to use my fingers...yep, not the best resuppts 😆😆😆

[@carabara84]

I know I'm a few months late on this, but I'm hoping you can answer the question: Do you use an eyeshadow primer with the caviar sticks? If not, how long do they stay creaseless? Do you have oily/normal/dry lids? Thanks!! Very helpful video ❤️

[@tonidoll7955]

I like the LM sticks, but I think the Nudestix pencils are really similar and it’s really nice that the nudestix come in kits and you can get them at a better price that way

[@alcoholly18]

lol her demonstration of adding too much cocoa is exactly what i did with my first cream shadow - cocoa! - a few weeks ago, and which brought me here 😂

[@carolmanning3043]

Do you clean your brush between colors? Or something like one for dark and one for light? What brush is the light colored brush you used to apply the light colors? Also, what products do you use under them if any? A moisturizer? If so, which one?

[@wendyraye]

Do you put the pot shadows on with your brush or finger? I don’t know if anyone could get it to look as you - ethereal look.

[@ovalteenies93]

Thank you for the great tips Shelbey x

[@lenkahuckova1951]

Hey can you please share the name of the lipstick you are wearing? Many thanks❤

[@pamcooke61]

Do you recommend a primer before using cream shadows?

[@conniepleasantnails]

Hello Shelbey, what about the cream shadows in a pot. I recently purchased one and haven’t tried it yet. I think its a Maybeline I also saw other brands making them. I actually want to buy one of each brand like Cover Girl, Maybeline and whoever else makes one. My favorite so far is still Bobbi Brown. Just wondering if you have a video on pot shadows? ❤️

[@angieagentlesoul]

Love cream eyeshadows!

[@DanaRipperton]

Thanks for this video, @shelbeywilson ! Once you have more time playing with the Auric smoke reflects, could you do a video on how you get those to work well? I have two of them and love them, but feel like my technique could definitely be improved. Thanks!!!

[@wljackson45]

What kind of camera and recording software are you using? It is so clear!! Great video

[@TheTtooter]

You are the cream shadow master. Thank you for this video... very helpful!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Thank you 😊

[@clbloyd]

I love the LM hands down but the Julep stick in Putty is one of my favorites and easy to use.

[@ShelbeyWilson]

I’ve been meaning to try those!

[@marlanap674]

@@ShelbeyWilson Yes!! Please try the Julep cream shadow sticks!!

[@simisimisimi]

I don’t know about anyone else but I also like the boring and meh side! 😅

[@Falalalalalalala]

Me too!

[@ShelbeyWilson]

I actually use that method a lot - it's not wrong but it's definitely more one dimensional and "smudgey" so I was trying to show how to clean it up a bit haha

[@simisimisimi]

@@ShelbeyWilson yep totally get you! 💜

[@MissLizella]

Hippie style

[@amberfrazier575]

Yup like them both neither is wrong or right both look great! Then again there is something sweet and fresh about a face with just foundation bronzer and mascara. It truly is an art, it’s all about interpretation.

[@nataliekiefer]

Hi Shelby - a newbie here so I apologize if this has been asked before. Do you use an eye primer before applying the cream shadow?

[@alicialundberg3216]

I have some cream shadow sticks from Bobbi Brown. The one I am struggling with is the color Golden pink. It looks good on the back of my hand (smooth and beautiful) but on my eyelids it looks dry and patchy. What am I doing wrong 🤷🏽‍♀️😅

[@isabelleprice6719]

I think the trick is to build up in nice thin layers as you say. The matte one's are a bit boring to me but nice tip on adding the sparkle shadoe on top.

[@kathyahaines4749]

Thank for this valuable video. I think I've been using the wrong brush. I got a 2 pack of the caviar sticks for Christmas 🎄 I love them, but don't have your technique down yet. I'll keep trying 😂

[@staceybeaver9751]

Hi Shelbey! I find your videos enjoyable and relatable even though I’m approaching 50. Thank you for incorporating some tips and tricks for those of us in the “mature” age range. Love me some cream products and have had my eye on the caviar sticks for a while, but can’t settle on a combo to try (even though I watched your combos video). Also, I’m wondering if they would wear well on me because I struggle with creasing and my lids tend to “eat” shadows. BTW...I check your Instagram stories daily hoping for an appearance from the pickle!

[@hr8779]

I have a vision impairment that makes applying make up a challenge. Hard to know what it looks like when you can’t see it well. I’m hopeful the cream eye shadow application will be easier to see and apply. It’s a struggle to do anything eye makeup related but I’m looking forward to the challenge of doing better with these products. Thanks Shellbey!

[@Gotoworkkk]

I’m just wondering if you wear glasses like I do?

[@swood2603]

Very helpful tips and demo. Thank you.

[@lynseyallan387]

Hey, I’m wondering what your favourite cruelty free recommendation would be for a ‘pop’ cream eye shadow? Thank you so much ❤️

[@ElleBeeArr]

I bought my first Caviar Stick today! I bought Cobblestone, because I knew it would be a safe choice since Ulta isn't allowing testers at this time. I'm wondering whether you tried the eyeshadow sticks by The Balm? I picked up one a local cosmetic shopquite a while ago. I believe the shade is Batter Up (they have baseball names) - a pearlescent purple, not full on shimmer. I find the blendability to be quite good, all day wear, and they don't dry out in the tube like my two Stila did. Mid range price.

[@xtinea3406]

Thanks so much for sharing your expertise! Great recommendations!

[@janerochfort2134]

You look very beautiful today my dear....

[@lyndaolney1475]

Ok, so in your opinion, what cream eyeshadows are best for not creasing in the lid?

[@heidithomas8158]

Hi Shelby, Could you recommend an eye primer under caviar sticks? The colour always seems to slip off or gather in my crease. Thank you!

[@shannonstark8837]

I use the Nars eyeshadow primer and find it works really well for both cream and powder.....

[@amaizeingndn]

@@shannonstark8837 I second this, the Nars one is amazing and worth the price. Nothing else works as well.

[@heidithomas8158]

@@amaizeingndn thank you :)

[@heidithomas8158]

@@shannonstark8837 thanks v much :)

[@spearageddon3279]

I have mature eyes (50) and find the Sigma eye primer (cream stick) works great for me.

[@irinaedwards5156]

Do you use the eyeshadow base with the cavia sticks?

[@kristinj6298]

Yes very helpful! Thank you for explaining it yet again!

[@s13rr4buf3]

How do Caviar compare to Julep?

[@christinap5148]

Do the caviar sticks last a while in the actual sticks? I mean do they have a long shelf life? I know the Bobbi Brown does and the Clinique chubby stick

[@ShelbeyWilson]

Yes - some of mine I should have thrown out ages ago but they're still as good as new haha

[@mystidawn2723]

Shelby!! I love your channel!! You have to tell what the lip color is, I need it for my beach wedding. Keep up the beautiful work ❤️

[@swedishlina]

Look in the description box where she lists both lip liner and lip colour 😊. Good luck with your wedding 🤞🏼

[@kathybrou1340]

Great video! Thanks!

[@denisewouters9139]

Thanks for the video Shelby - you give some great tips! I watched the video on your favourite caviar stick combinations and bought the cobblestone and sanglow as loved the look. I'm disappointed with the sandglow colour though as it looks nothing like it does on your eyes. On me it looks a dull flat colour (just disappears) with no sheen. On you it looks a different colour and gives a lovely shine which stands out. I've followed your application technique and tried with and without primer. Any ideas why this would be? Thanks

[@godsgirl0019]

How do you prime kids before cream shadow????

[@sandypalmer4071]

This was really helpful. Thanks!

[@giadigeorge1255]

Thank you Shelby, wondering how your pregnancy is coming along? You look beautiful ❤️

[@kimbullett3293]

Have you tried any Clinique chubby stick shadows? I have 3 but haven’t quite figured them out yet lol

[@aaryavaidya3556]

Are u gonna try the jouer creme eyeshadow crayon anytime soon???

[@thisproagestyle]

Thé Jouer stick shadows Arte great! My new faves are Trestique!

[@DanaLisa10]

Love ❤️ shelbey tips

[@keepfitgirl8191]

Thanks - v helpful video. Emma x

[@dianegreiner4054]

Always find your suggestions so helpful! 😊

[@ShelbeyWilson]

I'm so glad! :)

[@merraki5991]

Love your videos and I have been watching casual for many years! I love cream shadows. I mostly use the Tilbury one but I want to try more. You really look like Mandy Moore here. I am sure you get that a lot lol.