LSU "right above it" vs Southern "Right Above it" Comparison

[@MrTaylor6422]

Both bands are great for their style. A lot of LSU Band members respect SU’s band and entertainment. I think we should realize that the 2 best bands in their particular styles are both from Baton Rouge! Geaux Tigers and Go Jags!

[@Exceptional555]

Lsu not better then Ohio State so how you can compare them with the Jukebox IDK1😂🤣

[@lsubandtrumpet2014]

@@Exceptional555 step aside nobody

[@mikedaflexta]

I'm from Louisiana and I'm just so proud of all the Louisiana monsters. SU, LSU, Grambling, Noasb, OPW, Karr, St. Aug, Southern Lab, and all the other bands that hold it down for the state.

[@andymayeuxproductions]

mikedaflexta best state for bands hands down

[@landensewell4401]

Scotlandville band cold too

[@andymayeuxproductions]

Landen Sewell facts, don’t forget LLI too

[@orlandolucero1537]

I heard the LSU band playing this right before their game against South Carolina so college football 🏈 honestly brought me here to listen 🎶 to this & is sooo 🔥🔥🔥every single one of these band members from both schools should be proud as FUCK!!!

[@Oharsh0928]

Both are great. Definitely have their own style and sound. Very enjoyable to listen to.

[@rantaviouswilliams]

When the drums start playing in the beginning 😰😳 gives you chills

[@Kdl5049]

Finally someone who really realizes just how wicked that drum part is 🤷‍♂️🤣🤣🤣🤣that shit 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥...💛💙 #JukeLyfe504...

[@jj3a1]

Two distinct styles and sounds. I love both of them. LSU has always been one my favorite PWI bands, and SU's history of dominance speaks for itself. And please dont come on here with that "all hbcus do is play loud" crap because not every HBCU band plays this way. We just like to put air through our horns in the SWAC :)

[@ericscivicque]

Only other Band to come close to SU would be Talladega.

[@MrKingpin1205]

@@ericscivicque Talladega be sounding out of tune sometimes so nah

[@yobartenda]

@@ericscivicque Tallla who? Man stop that. Them people needs a lot of practice.

[@SilverCometMedia]

HBCUs just have a different sound. May not sound like the recording but man it’s a special sound. Been watching a lot of marching band videos lately and FAMU and Southern have an amazing vibe with them

[@charleswilliams8248]

LSU been watching SU believe that! They have gleaned from SU, learned SU, now LSU is doing it! LSU have learned well!

[@bibbiana4Lyfe]

Their Band Director graduated from Jackson State University (Sonic Boom)

[@aswadmalik1740]

INDEED!

[@SirSaxy]

Well, this comment section is surprisingly positive. I think a piece of me is almost disappointed. 😂

[@juanneugent6174]

Su🤦🏽‍♂️

[@erboch7124]

I think most can acknowledge that both of these are good lol

[@rahkeemthompson4548]

It's just starting. I feel like if we give it a few years, almost every song pwi's play will come from HBCU'S.

[@TheXquizid]

Its because the bands are mainly people that were raised in the N.O. metro area or baton rouge. Its a melting pot of different walks of life that you grow with living here. Musicians respect each other, no matter the color of your skin.

[@staceyg798]

Same. I wanted some tea. I will admit that I always find anyone that does marching band amazing but LSU's did not slap as hard

[@darionpope1876]

LSU version sounds more like the song I like them both

[@i3trii423]

Lsu rlly sounded like the actually song

[@TheXquizid]

Different sryles. Both are great. In the New Orleans metro area, we have both styles and they respect each other. Im sure some of those members come from that area. As a high school drummer in a marching band, I challenged every drummer that I could. Its apart of our culture down here to show out, but still respect the opposition.

[@yolofolksidc126]

LSU’s tubas were pumping at the end

[@chxser6]

Yolofolks Idc that’s nothing compared to them cranking at the natty

[@marionmarion6852]

lmao sound like bland

[@ceyoung504]

Can't wait til they play each other. It's gonna be one big family reunion

[@brandon3491]

The tailgate goin be lit

[@ericscivicque]

SU can win the band compo but their football team would get trashed.

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

LSU play southern in a spring game this april at mumford stadium in baton rouge. . Hopefully both bands go!!!!!!

[@GarenteedTires]

LSU doesnt play Southern. They are playing themselves at Southern. LSU field will be getting new turf do they are playing on the bluff

[@anaircondicer]

@@GarenteedTiresl lsu and su have a confirmed game sometime either this coming school year or the next year sometime in the fall

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

@@GarenteedTires that game cancelled due to corona

[@GarenteedTires]

The scheduled game between the 2 schools is 2022 in Tiger stadium...its a regular season. Im already there.😂 I attended both schools but I bleed Blue & Gold!!!

[@marionmarion6852]

we play them in 2022

[@suebyrdd8094]

I am currently in LSU band & to be honest we have NOTHING on Southerns band, we simply just don’t compare!

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

I love what y'all are doing. Wish y'all had the proper coverage other marching groups receive.

[@ashleymeggan]

Who else cannot wait for LSU Southern?

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

Its going to be epic. Especially when southern play Neck 😭😭

[@shirajai]

It’s here!!

[@betaomega04]

I marched with Tiger Band...and I have no problem saying that The Human Jukebox is the best band in the south. Like...it isn't even up for debate.

[@brandonallen4806]

The land, but I completely agree with you!

[@mexicanmayo3450]

Totally agree except those northerners also can’t compare to southerns sound. One thing is for sure, tiger band and the human jukebox make Louisiana have something to pride over!

[@shirajai]

I wish the title wasn’t “comparison” It wasn’t comparison at all. Two bands from the same area appreciating each other’s musicianship!

[@Dawgteam07respeck]

Both bands sound good the main difference I can hear is that SU shoe cases their tubas more, while LSU tubas are being overtaken by the band however they resurge toward the end. The other difference is that SU sounds more soulful when playing but you can definitely see that both bands are having fun while playing

[@steve7131]

0:06 and 0:18 yessir 🔥 kane would be proud

[@JPandher]

Love the energy. I am from South Georgia High School I am a baritone.

[@pierrelandry9613]

I’m a 51 yr old white guy and Southern’s version kicks f-in ass.. gives me chills.. I always had killer lungs playing trumpet.. just not great range like these guys

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

They play each other this fall in baton rouge at tiger stadium

[@pierrelandry9613]

@@KPicotProductionsEnt Cool.. I’ll have to look for it

[@ericscivicque]

It don't hurt that they are all #1 chair trumpet players on the line. SU can blow that's for sure. But I LOVE both bands.

[@MrKingpin1205]

@@KPicotProductionsEnt Actually Southern plays LSU next year, not this coming season

[@bonechrusher3427]

The thing is, each time the opposition plays a song, everyone in the band tries to figure out wat they do wrong. I know this because I am in a band myself

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

How do I go about being apart of LSU media team💯💯💯💯

[@chriscitizen5457]

Both sound good arrangements are totally different SU you can hear every instrument while they play with power LSU has over 30 tubas and can barley hear them.

[@keepingupwithnasaun7782]

It’s called balance something southern don’t know bc lsu tubas can blow they do it at the end

[@lionessbeauty727]

I Love them BOTH! 💙💛 💜💛

[@1stsarge303]

Clarity, fundamentals, articulation, and musicianship goes to SU!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@davidfouse1820]

Love the comparison clip, but I would’ve used SU from BoomBox 2010. The MarchingSport video.

[@fordtruck4512]

NUFF SAID!!! SU Band4Life!! God is good!!!!

[@andymayeuxproductions]

The best band of PWI schools and HBCU schools. Compare LSU’s “Boogie down” and JSU’s

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

Ok will do

[@andymayeuxproductions]

Alliyah Harris the definitely weren’t better. Go back and listen to it

[@andymayeuxproductions]

Alliyah Harris nah

[@jasonsan9517]

@@andymayeuxproductions JSU’s version is better!

[@quieneselpatron790]

2:18 Are those Q Dogs repping behind the bass drums....hahaha omegas are everywhere.

[@ShotByDEBO]

1:35 💨 dats preshhhaaaaaa! Geaux Tigers

[@chadcas]

Love both bands but I give the nod to LSU here.

[@Nawfside99]

I like LSU arrangement

[@prestonval4439]

This is like comparing a Kid Bop Track to a Bourbon street Performance. Give me the swagger of the Juke and Fabulous Dancing Dolls all day.

[@KeoTheCupcake]

I like em both.

[@ericscivicque]

You can't compare because 1 LSU is in a block U facing each other and SU is in a square block facing forward. LSU is on the ground and SU is in the stadium. Then you need to record with the same mic system. If you want to compare put them both in the same position and use the same equipment. Plus they are not playing the same arrangement. Anyone who knows music will tell you that. But as a LSU fan I still don't think anyone can blow louder than SU but that is just my opinion. I LOVE both bands.

[@geegee8407]

You can put SU anywhere, it doesn't matter lol. They will out perform.

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

@@geegee8407loud does not equal good. Lsu might not be able to play louder, but at least you can hear the articulation

[@EnergyShift-kv4eu]

go listen to SU play the Batman Theme. One of my favs. I don’t even rock with Batman like that. Lol

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

SU smashed that Batman theme

[@DenverHardaway]

SUs was amazing..but LSUs was right above it.

[@marionmarion6852]

lmfao right above what ? with that unseasoned shit

[@otf-trunks5944]

Yup👌🔝🙌

[@Katt36]

Nice pun

[@Exceptional555]

Thats a 2010 version of the Human JukeBox.. the tudes white.. Have had white tubes in 10 years.. And yall comparing LSU' band decade old sound and style that's long gone.. lol.. laughable 😂😂😂 but that's what happens when you set the trands..

[@mexicanmayo3450]

@@Exceptional555 I would say it’s not a comparison. Having heard both bands live at the same time there is no comparison possible. They have completely different styles and they both are exceedingly great at what they do. Both bands have a lot of skill and both bands are the pride of Louisiana. Further than that you can’t really fairly say much else comparison wise. They’re just two insanely good marching bands

[@dee13lee]

Both bands and crew are talented. LSU sounds just like the original and the dance has great precision. Southern has their own style and made it their own.

[@TheKing-qt3sg]

I'm grad of LSU but how can you compare Southern to LSU. LSU couldn't even put the type of soul that song need.

[@westtexasmike]

my high school band is modeled after southern’s band. my sister, who played in the band, used to bring home tapes of southern’s band. i find lsu’s version much more melodic. lsu might be the best band in college football right now.

[@jhonjhon-sf8ft]

Lsu has their tone quality perfected and su has the power! both immensely talented bands

[@Yaboy485]

SU arrangement was 🔥

[@grod6998]

LSU just adds that extra oomf to it.

[@woox317]

Neva thought the would sound like this fr

[@clintdelcambre8683]

Both are great;

[@keandrabrigham8428]

Both good but something about LSU hits harder

[@snapedz2734]

U trippin

[@keandrabrigham8428]

RaCa ir sounds more like the song

[@snapedz2734]

keandra brigham ok buddy

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

@@snapedz2734he’s right

[@mikedior3089]

2 different styles, both sound good.

[@NjPWC221]

1 Band 1 Sound always 👍🏼

[@sharonmallett9244]

Lsu is going so fire ❤❤❤ i am a big fan

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

I rather LSU’s. It’s more heavy and I much rather that over not being able to hear the band when the trumpets play. Just an opinion tho, both are great

[@hitstickproductions7050]

Anybody else here in 2022 ready for saturday

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

Yes it's going down

[@likkfrmthav]

YESSIRRR BR LIT THIS WEEKEND

[@edwinbatiste7550]

There is no comparison. I’ll take Haymer everyday All day!! Shoutout to LSU though!! Keep doing ya’ll thing!!

[@mattt2862]

No hate on southern because I love them with all of my heart. But.... LSU tore that up.

[@HGL33]

i wanna be those guys in the lower right part of 0:19 highkey vibin af

[@treylebl]

louisiana might be a sucky state but we definitely have some of the best bands. ive even seen middle schools with good bands down here

[@ATLienForLife]

For me, it was LSU hands down!

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

Southern vs LSU 2022. Tiger stadium.

[@jeffharris66]

The Nod Goes 2 LSU On This One and I'm always down 4 SU, and They Did take a Big Page from SU, and if LSU faced the camera it would've been Louder

[@jamesmena5508]

LSU tiger band and Human jukebox have their own unique style

[@laparllc6559]

Can't really compare the two, because one is when the song first came out and one is now. One was written by the band director and one was not.

[@jojoanderson89]

Living in Tennessee but Louisiana will all be home...Grambling State University tho

[@treeezy05]

LSU fye tho

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

True. They get crunk.

[@vivecasufan4life595]

Why even compare LSU to SU LSU is not in no HBCU League just my opinion

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

@@vivecasufan4life595 we are going to find out in 2021 and 22 God say the same since they are scheduled to play.

[@vivecasufan4life595]

@@KPicotProductionsEnt LSU is not all that I'm not saying they bad either just not on our black schools level thats all

[@TomazHilton]

Keep in mind that LSUs BD is from JSU...

[@treylebl]

two different styles but they both played great

[@romana1747]

Ngl I play tuba for my highschool marching band (we in Louisiana) and we play LSU’s version and it seems a lot more fun rather than southerners :/

[@Sheismeanttobe]

Southern ain’t no joke baby!!!

[@caripescadr533]

Lsu is a good band but I will forever always be a jukebox fan

[@sillygal25]

Both are good, but hands down, SU for da win! Way more musical and soulful

[@erboch7124]

It's so rare that I prefer a PWI's arrangement to an HBCU's...but then again it was probably some brothers putting it together for LSU. Both had great arrangements, it was just LSU's drumline that took the cake.

[@erboch7124]

@@TheSaintsfan16 Makes sense

[@Damariun224]

Director went to Jackson State

[@bakerbuff2474]

SU easily. Better arrangement and execution.

[@user-xw4vg1vy5e]

nah they couldn't even execute the drum rolls correctly.

[@stevenwoods5787]

both are good, i prefer LSU more...

[@dr.goodsnatchphd.405]

On team LSU, I love the boom and clack from their drum line, however SU's horn section has so much richness and soul!

[@sharonmallett9244]

Lsu is going so fire❤❤❤❤❤ i am a 😂

[@trippmediamolle]

LSU all the wayyyyy

[@i3trii423]

Both good tho

[@jay1two33]

They are both 🔥🔥🔥 but LSU’s band always beast this song.

[@andrewanderson1777]

If your head doesn't bop to this, then just gtfoh

[@KPicotProductionsEnt]

Exactly cause they go hard

[@Bentonbandkid]

Ok I like LSU more then SU but the only reason is the high pitch is messing with me

[@baseballnerd4139]

While I appreciate the incredible talent of Southern's band, their version was in a higher octave than the actual song and lacked the drums that really drives the song home for me. It just sounded like everyone was trying to see how loud they could play their instrument. I liked LSU's version much better this time.

[@kingcizea7292]

Don’t care 🤷

[@Him_1]

Actually SU's range is perfectly constructed and used at the right time, Simmons makes sure of that. It's just soulful thats all, they still the best band inna land 🐆

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

I agree with you. SU is loud=good and I don’t like it. My ears jit bleed when the trumpets play

[@bennieficial_9579]

In this video....an HBCU has been dethroned. LSU band murdered this selection

[@mcdonoghrahloh459]

I kinda preferred LSUs version as well.

[@TheKing-qt3sg]

No SWAC band has every being dethroned by a PWI band.

[@bennieficial_9579]

@@TheKing-qt3sg Until this video came out lmao. Southern sounding like shit trying to crank to sound better. 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@tashatiger5463]

You tried it. Compare them both in the stands. I'm an LSU Grad and I prefer Southern's version. You shady af

[@juliocesarriveraguillen5896]

southern god

[@DRAE1FR]

This is the only song LSU band knows 😂😂😂😂

[@alejandroreales9326]

SU POWER FULL

[@quintusjones4740]

“Ight ima head out 😒”......SU

[@jada9401]

Quintus Jones but for real this was a murder I would love to see both bands battle it out now. so pwi can see how truly gifted SU really is “often imitated but never duplicated”

[@rafe1482]

@@jada9401 LSU already knows how good SU is lol. They collaborate a lot behind the scenes

[@pierrelandry9613]

You forgot to put the L in front of SU

[@Sayphatt_]

band wise, southern gon always enjoy betta den lsu 😂 get mad

[@SuperleggeraV4]

1st one was better than the 2nd one

[@jamesgathers2166]

Yea lsu was good

[@ryantaylor477]

Umm cultural vaulterizm at its finest but only imitated never duplicated

[@jada9401]

“You can’t compare where you don’t compete” LSU tried I’ll say that

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

Tried and did better🤷‍♂️

[@JustParyss]

You can’t compare SU to LSU it’s just not fair SU has a bigger band first and then there have more sound so it’s not fair but SU 😫👏🏽

[@mcdonoghrahloh459]

You're joking right.LSU has close to 400 members

[@Keitheykinz]

@@mcdonoghrahloh459 the juke also has close to 400 members lol

[@mcdonoghrahloh459]

@@Keitheykinz C'mon keif,SU has never passed 300.A full 300 for SU would be incredible.They will get their chance on Sept 10,2022!

[@Keitheykinz]

@@mcdonoghrahloh459 What you mean? Southern's band has been a 300+ piece band for the past decade. But hey, I'm just saving the date and I'm gonna let the juke do the talking lol

[@mcdonoghrahloh459]

@@Keitheykinz Brah no!270, Haymers last year was the zenith.And they've been around 250 since.I mean, how are you going to be close to 400 with 192 on the field.Cmom Keif;

[@sandyshaker3250]

Lsu killed it.

[@dariodavis6572]

😳😂😂😂

[@coreylowery8118]

Both bands are good but I think LSU was better

[@upt_s4l3ward77]

Lsu version better listen to their drums everything just like da real song

[@bryanthandy1396]

Lsu made a rap song into a pop rock song that shit was hard to listen to . look at some of the band members they think its a rock song .

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

Theirs sounded better though. Sure, if you want loud noise, take SU, but if you want music, LSU takes that by a long shot

[@GoldenBeauty33]

If there was a white band to have a lil soul they would be from LA lol

[@1411MEDIA]

LSU’s arrangement just sounds bland. No style or soul

[@Lord_SQUIDIOUS]

Because they didn’t blast?

[@markbienvenu7864]

LSU’s was wayyyyy better, it sounded like the song

[@snapedz2734]

STOP DA CAP

[@snapedz2734]

Listen to southern songs and rap mix