M&P Compact vs M&P Shield - Buying choices/decisions

The M&P compact and new M&P shield are pretty similar guns. This video shares my thoughts and opinions on the similarities and differences between the 2 and some thoughts on which to get or if its worth getting both.
Here is a review that my friend wrote about the M&P Shield
thrumylens.org/featured/review...

[@rickypastille]

This is one of the best, most thorough and balanced gun reviews I've ever watched. So good I've watched it twice. Congrats and thanks.

[@SnareMan]

+Ricky Pastille Thanks Ricky!

[@LeopoldMidas]

+Ricky Pastille I agree. Also, this does seem to be a really nice 9mm pistol at a very reasonable price. very high quality.

[@1000mcm]

yep

[@SnareMan]

Thanks!

[@fitzworld18]

I recently bought an M&P compact 9mm and thought about carrying the smaller shield. I am glad I went with the compact. It is a bit more heft but the more I wear it the more I am used to it. I also like the idea that I have more bullets in the mag and I can change the back straps to customize it. Well worth the money.

[@AcoraZ3RO]

I'll be honest, I hadn't heard of Bowie Tactical, and I was really confused when you talked about David Bowie concealed carrying.

[@jpyglesias]

Just saying excellent video, I've been in the army for 6 years with two operations in Iraq, and you explain firearms like a range officer. The manual safety isn't an issue for me because all of our firearms have them including the m9. For everyone worried about not having enough time to get the safety off, it's not just carrying a sidearm that keeps you from harm, you should be moving as your drawing, try incorporating an instant sidestep as you draw to add to there target acquisition time. Thanks again, looking forward to more of your videos.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for the kind words and for your service Brooklyn!

[@DieselRamcharger]

sidestep while drawing is a bad habit. and it doesn't get you off the X

[@jew_world_order]

This dude probably has more experience doing this than some random range officer in the military.

[@hillshepherd9444]

I have been on KZbin watching/learning gun/pistol videos now for 3 years. This video was published 4/2012, I'm seeing it for the first time 5/2018. "BEST" to the point, video quality, & especially, " PRESENTATION " between these two guns, 6 years later, of ALL presentation I've seen !! Very well done ! Thank-you Liked & Subscribed Hill Shepherd

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for the kind words and sub Hill!

[@sammigrunow1972]

I have the full size, compact, and shield! Carry the shield, keep the compact in my truck, and the full size at home!

[@skiggy007]

+Sammi Grunow - Does your full size M&P 9 have the 4.25" or 5" barrel? Have you had any accuracy issues with it? I'm considering getting a 4.25", but I've read about some people having accuracy issues and I'm not sure if Smith & Wesson has gotten it completely resolved yet.

[@SnareMan]

I just shot my full sized in our weekly league last night and thought it was more accurate than my compact with the red dot. No problems at all.

[@SnareMan]

I have the 4.25. I think I bought it a little after I made this vid in 2012. :-)

[@skiggy007]

Thanks, I appreciate it!

[@sammigrunow1972]

skiggy007​​ I have the standard 4.25". I have had no problem with it. I think if people are having accuracy issues with a full size pistol it's probably not the gun lol. I put an Apex trigger kit on mine so the trigger pull is about 3 lbs and reduced the overall travel by %50. Honestly the trigger upgrade was a massive improvement to the gun and did help me shoot better. Personally I think the 4.25" is perfectly fine unless you're maybe doing competitions or something

[@FriedChickenBlowout]

Just found this video as a recommended video from KZbin. I'm quite impressed, well presented and well spoke. Great points. I have extensive experience with the M&P line, having owned 10 of them (5", 4.25", Compact, and Shields) over the last 6+ years since they were released. I've got many videos on my site about them and I've worked on about 50 different M&Ps for friends, family, co-workers and students of mine. My take after owning 10 of them, is that now I only own 2 x M&P9L and 2 x 9mm Shields. I sold off 3 compacts that I had over time and 3 x 4.25" full size guns. The Compact was the most intrinsically accurate M&P that I've owned. But I never liked the overall grip length and always used the finger extension. I prefer the grip length and size of the Shield without or with the longer mag. I normally carry the longer mag as my reload and carry the gun with the short mag. I refer the lighter weight of the Shield, loaded with 124gr ammo it's more of a difference than presented in the video. I also prefer the narrower profile. And went fitted with the Apex Sear and USB, the trigger becomes very nice and accurate improves. I've also found the Warren Tactical Night Sights are the perfect fit for the narrow slide profile. Narrowing down my collection of M&P pistols was on of the better things I've done, I see no point in the 4.25" full size and as such sold them. The Compact however does have a role. If someone asked me to help them pick out a single gone that can do it all from home protection, carry and even IDPA type matches, I alway suggest the compact if they can only afford one gun. It does it all, shoots like a full size and can carry a light if needed. The capacity is very good and takes full size mags like you mentioned. It's a good gun and like you said, your mileage may vary. Thanks for the well done video, just adding my take for those those trying to decide.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for the comments and the kind words. You've had quite the collection! I agree on adding the Apex trigger to the Shield. I have one of them in one of my Compacts and they are pretty nice. I like carrying the Shield, but I agree that the Compact is a great all around gun.

[@davidb8397]

I agree I put talon grips on my shield and on my 3 mags really makes a difference just fills your hand better

[@medicalpiff803]

I conceal carry the .40 shield. I was carrying my Springfield XD, but one touch of the shield and I was hooked. The shield is so comfortable, and lets face it if you need more than 10 rounds to escape you are in trouble.

[@arisn32]

Jonathan Wiggins If you’re in the fire fight, you’re already in trouble, I’ll take more rounds any and everyday. Plus at the range, it’s time consuming. The argument “if you need more than 10 rounds to escape you are in trouble “ is something a leftist would say. What if you face 12 gang members? You gonna throw it at one and fight the other? Not to mention, if they have guns. You’re done.

[@johnblaze6269]

Lol why would he face 12 gang members? You sound angry lol “Sounds like something a leftist would say” pshh moron

[@jellyfrosh9102]

@@arisn32 He isn't saying "nobody should own a gun with more than 10 rounds" he's saying he doesn't think he needs more because at that point a compact pistol isn't the tool for the job.

[@winterallen8770]

ARIS the man is just coming with some innocent humor (and obviously making a point while doing so) and here you come fumbling into making no damn sense. Because he looks to be African American he’s automatically assumed a leftist and will face bangers!? Nah fam. Your opinion is all that was needed AT MOST...none of the idiotic extras. Smh.

[@carlitosmtz665]

ARIS if you’re in a fire fight with 12 gang members, you have zero awareness. Concealed carry is meant as a last resort. If you’re concerned about 12 gang members than you shouldn’t be carrying an 8 round ccw. With that logic, it’s no wonder you blame ideologies due to your fallacies. It’s common sense and OP had a point.

[@sillyturd44]

Awesome video. Straight-forward, precise information. I appreciate someone who just gives all the facts, and lets the viewer decide which is best. This is exactly the video i was looking for. Thank you!!

[@stephenhulse5138]

I have both of these guns. Both are excellent guns. My edc is the Shield (or my P238 Sig). I take my compact to the range and have two 17 round mags with the pinky extension. Great range gun. In the colder months I will cc my 9c from time to time. Imo, you can't go wrong with either choice.

[@kmanick]

Great video ! I decided the Shield was the better option for EDC. I use a pinky extension on the flush mags so 7+1=8, only 2 rounds less than legal limit here in the socialist republic of Mass. I may pick up a compact at some point to do some comparisons of my own as I have fairly large hands so I use a pachmyr sleeve on my shield. gives me a grip almost as thick as the double stack grip without sacrificing the "thinness" of the rest of the gun. ***edit** recently picked up a 9C. Now I rotate them in and out of my EDC. I am more accurate with the 9C, it's definitely softer shooting. I also have the new Magguts +2 kit so now I have 10 rounds on the shield as well. Clothing options are what now dictate which one is on my hip. I love both of these firearms. :)

[@paulruth83]

Very well done. I have already decided to go with the 9mm compact over the shield. I have a S&W mod 60 .357 that does a good job of a pocket gun and would not gain enough round count to go with a Shield. You did a good job of thoughtful comparison between the two. Both are great guns.

[@Ronboclaw]

Thanks for the comparison. This video review was right where I'm at and definitely gave me the info for consideration since the shield has come out. Keep up the good work!

[@MrJmeisternixon]

I use the M&P full size 40 for work and it has a trigger reset...i really enjoyed this review. very in depth!

[@Daekwonjones]

james ryan i got an M&P 9 full size. but for my cc i got the M&P 9c with an X grip so i can still use the full size clips like he did... try it out i think youll like it

[@adaniel2224]

^^magazines bro

[@MrShou5]

I own the whole line M&P 45, 9 C and SHIELD 45, 40, 9 and I just purchased the Performance center Shield 9mm . Love em all..

[@SnareMan]

They are great guns!

[@killaproject844]

do the mags fit in the shield and 9c

[@johnnypea5369]

Getting started with concealed carry I got the shield and now shopping for a full size M&P. The shield shoots very well, I am happy with it, and plan to still use it.

[@CWB1863]

Well, it was the best of both worlds as of 7/21/16.As much as i liked my Shield, i realized the 9c is my favorite CC firearm in my collection.Picked up the 9c May of this year and it's been my go to ever since(with the Sig P320sc coming in a close second). Went to my local gun shop and they had a 9c in FDE.Thought to myself..."I gotta to have it! I've pretty much been carrying double stacks exclusively for the past several months with my Shield and PPS on the back burners.I ended up with an even trade.The Shield and PPS for the 9c along with $75 and two extra mags. I thought i would regret this decision, two guns for one, but i'm completely happy with it.

[@charlessheldon7733]

CWB1863

[@DarkmanXSincere]

CWB1863 you traded a shield and a pps for a m&pc AND you gave them $75 on top of that?.. man that gun shop really got over on you.

[@CWB1863]

Haha... no, sorry about the confusion.I received $75 and two mags in the exchange for the two.Ended up getting some Ameriglo night sights with the $75.

[@SimpyLibs]

I had an instructor show me the difference between a standard MP9c vs. Shield 9 vs Shield 9 with the talon gun grips applied and it makes the shield feel exactly like the MP9c. Increased grip and frame width makes it almost identical to the MP9c but with the added benefit of the 1in profile for CCW. The Talon Grip makes up for the lack of interchangeable backs on the Shield but made it feel much more secure in your hand. Just an idea for those who like the slim profile of the Shield but didn't like the grip (I really disliked it) and its only $20.

[@WarrenGrannis]

I went from a full-size M&P to a Shield, thinking if I was going to downsize to a lighter gun for daily carry, I might as well get something that wasn't just a regular M&P with a smaller capacity. After carrying the Shield for nearly a year as a lefty, I'm finding myself switching to a compact instead of a Shield. Two main reasons: I miss the slide stop on the right, and the fact that the mag release isn't reversible (although it looks like it could be!) on the Shield, have just slowly chaffed at me every time I practice. For anyone who's left-handed, I strongly encourage you to give the compact another look before you settle on the Shield. I thought I'd be okay without the full ambi options the other M&Ps offer, but it just did me in.

[@WarrenGrannis]

I've been looking at ambi 1911s as well, but it's mostly a wishlist-type dream for after the kids finally move out and head off to college.

[@AzuMentch36]

Have you looked into the Honor Guard by Honor Defense? It's similar to the Shield, except it has a ambidextrous magazine release, ambidextrous slide lock and a optional ambidextrous safety. So far, the only problem I hear is that it can fire if you drop it, but I hear that company is fixing the problem.

[@stingygunner]

Fantastic. One of the best reviews (overall) I've seen on youtube. Thanks!

[@SnareMan]

Thanks!!

[@Chrisrico1]

Awesome review. A note for anyone who is not an experienced CCW person, the thickness of the pistol makes a HUGE difference in ability to conceal without "printing". The Shield will allow for a greater variety in clothing options due to it's slimmer profile. But, if you're willing to work around the issue by adapting your wardrobe, most experienced trainers will tell you to go with the gun with higher ammo capacity. Plus, with the M&P you have the option of adding Crimson Trace laser grips!

[@charlesmarshall2697]

Everybody I know carries their Shield with MagGuts modded mags as a 9+1 pistol. They are both great guns. I carry the Shield most of the time, but the 9C with a 17+1 configuration carries great in a coolux undertec shirt.

[@Front-Toward-Enemy]

Ive owned a a full size m&p9 and in my experience. It isnt the width that made it difficult to conceal in nor was the barrel length. Rather it was the grip due to its longer 17rnd magazine. For me the m&p9c is a better choice because trading round count for less width just isnt necessary. the M&p9c hold more rounds, is still light and is small enough to conceal yet big enough to be able to fight with.

[@lovemym16]

tommy gun only realy advantage of the shield is that it is thinner and this more comfortable to carry. But only marginally

[@TheMichaelGrace]

Got the M&P Shield .40 as my first gun and will be my daily carry. Thanks for your thoughtful review. The gun has been amazing so far and I love it.

[@Dlighte2]

Wow, This video was incredibly thorough! Thanks for the information and extremely detailed comparison. I've purchased an M&P Shield thanks to the information in this video. Keep up the great work!

[@SnareMan]

+Trevor Spradlin (SRT-Bunny) Glad you liked it. THanks!

[@bobjustbob5220]

My M&P9c, first gen, has a very nice, audible reset, my favorite carry!

[@MairinGoBragh]

I sometimes carry in a purse… it is absolutely NOT a problem to carry a larger firearm… I put a S&W M&P full-frame in there with no difficulty.

[@arisn32]

missmorganphoenix purses can be stolen. Never would I ever recommend that.

[@laguirre27]

THANKS SO MUCH,i studied up 5 hours last night the semi autos you listed,and i think youre dead on with youre review and reply. MUCH APPRECIATED!

[@jawjww]

perfect video. I have a shield and love it. was curious about the compact and how it compares. you answered all my questions. thanks for a good side by side comparison.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks! Glad you liked it!

[@hepgeoff]

Great review. I didn't have either, but ended up buying the Shield for CC.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks!

[@johndough7160]

Drums and guns. I can dig that man.

[@SteelPolymernBrass]

Excellent video...I just picked up a MP Shield 9mm & love it...I also have the MP40c..love it too...good idea for a video..thanks good comparisons..

[@themattgorman]

Having only the shield (in a 9 and 40) this was very informative re the nuance differences. Thanks! 95% of my carry is IWB so I feel good about my choice. Additionally I learned some differences I didn't know (tigger reset for example). Good video with clear elocution.

[@MindOverEverything]

Why not both? Then when you have both, why not a full-size, too? Then when you have one of all 3, why not get one more of each? :-)

[@SnareMan]

Yes, I'm guilty of that. :-) I have all 3 sizes and 3 of the compact.

[@ThePROFESS10NAL]

Lol

[@2wheeleddemon999]

I can't stop 😨

[@concretewhisperer9877]

SnareMan I’ve had the compact in fde for a while love it my next has been leaning towards the shield 2.0 hopefully soon lol

[@arisn32]

Facts.

[@shj2000]

For me its a hard choice. Recently I sold my Shield to my brother. He already had one, but wanted another for a "New York Reload". I've gone back to my M&Pc (its actually a 357sig, but I also have 40S&W and 9mm barrels so I can carry any of those three calibers). The Shield is thinner and lighter, but surprisingly the M&Pc carries just as good. And my particular M&Pc has a better trigger. And I like having more rounds before needing a mag change. I really liked the Shield. Who knows, I might wind up buying another. But for now, I'm in good shape with the M&Pc. Both are fine guns and either will work for CCW.

[@MikeHJr]

"New York Reload" 😂😂😂

[@edoration]

This was a really helpful review. I was debating these exact two models. Thanks for the video.

[@kappakumplete]

Sweet GMT! I've got a Speedmaster Professional and love the way it looks with the Shield in hand. Thanks for the video. New firearm owner here and this was helpful.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks! I've wanted a Speedmaster for a long time now, but haven't been able to talk myself out of the money for one yet.

[@Coach49217]

excellent review. easy to follow and well paced

[@SnareMan]

Thanks Stephen!

[@amacro11]

Just noted this was posted in 2012 and still a relevant conversation. I'm sure you're aware that S&W is coming out with a Performance Center ported barrel and slide for the shield not sure about the compact although that would be a nice option, I'm leaning toward the compact I have a borrowed Shield and it seems "too" slim I've yet to shoot it, will do this weekend. The shield reminds me of the Walther PPS. Great review and subbed Al

[@SnareMan]

+amacro11 Thanks for the sub Al! I actually hadn't heard about the ported barrel for the Shield. THe downside of a ported barrel for self defense purposes though is if you have to shoot from chest retention position (one handed with your hand on the side of your chest) you are going to get a bunch of baddness blowing up into your face. It's unpleasant enough with a regular barrel.

[@amacro11]

SnareMan Thanks for the tip makes sense I did get to check out the M&P compact this PM and t's very nice a little "chubby" for IWB but doable Al PS I'm probably going to go for the 9mm I'm sure it will be a sweet shooter

[@SnareMan]

+amacro11 It's a great gun to shoot!

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for watching! Glad you found it useful! Sounds like you have some experience with the different models, so that should help with your decision.

[@conrad505]

Excellent comparison as I drew the exact same conclusion after owning, shooting 15K+ rounds, and carrying the 9c for several years. The shield is a nice shooter, but not worth the tradeoff in firepower/mag cap, especially when you can use the full size 17 round mags of the M&P9 as a back up.

[@Surg717]

+Sinister1 This is exactly why I just picked up the M&P 9c. Not only can it accept the larger mags, but it feels much better in my hands compared to the shield/glock 26.

[@jaf00181]

+Surg Hell no, not me. How the shield could feel uncomfortable to someone blows my mind. It's so easy to hold and just feels perfect. The damn compact is short and fat and even though I have big hands, the Shield just feels so much better. And if you're conceal carrying, the shield in an IWB is waaaaay more comfortable than the compact in anything. I don't care what specs are on paper, the shield feels way slimmer. The Shield, by the way, isn't the same gun as the compact or full size only smaller. It was totally redesigned from the ground up to be different from the others.

[@badjujuR6]

I love my M&P 9mm compact. I carry it appendix, holstered in a G-CODE INCOG with MagCaddy. I run the 12 round mags, 1 in the MagCaddy and one in my pocket. Personally I see no benifit to the Shield....

[@Amy75261]

Very good video for this new shooter who's starting to think about CC. You have done a great comparison of these small guns, and have me leaning toward the Shield. It looks like it would be small, but effective in a CC purse/bag. Thanks so much for the good info!

[@SnareMan]

Yep.:-) I thought I wanted a Glock til I shot it. Great guns, but just not for me. Love my M&P's

[@dragonsofthunder]

Amen

[@johnhope9319]

4 oz is a big difference when carrying. Especially when you get under 20oz. Pick up a gun that weighs 20oz, now pick up a gun that weighs 16oz. Very big difference. Shield carries much better than the M&Pc. Not as bulky. When you start talking about IWB carry you feel a major difference. I can feel the M&Pc, the Shield you hardly know its there. Every little difference in size makes big differences when it carries

[@shawnhart9215]

+John Hope I would rather know its there.If you cant feel, it, then what if you drop it? many People carry while outside, and working while being bounced around, so if you drop it , you won't realize it.

[@demonizedemoboi]

+Shawn Hart I hope your not serious about dropping it..If so you may want to buy a better holster

[@libertyprime9307]

+Shawn Hart My Shield isn't "dropping" unless somebody holds me upside down by the ankles and shakes me up and down. Even then, they would probably have to grab it and pull it out of the holster.

[@abshire79]

4oz is not a big deal if your mindset is I need to carry today as usual. What a dumb statement. I'm as completely comfortable with a full size M&P 9 as with a Sig P938. 4oz.....really?

[@techdivaful]

I have had both- prefer to carry the Shield.

[@pastorjerryk]

Thank you very much for the excellent video on comparison of the Shield vs Compact. I've been looking to buy one but first wanted to see a legit comparison. I have subscribed to your videos....keep making them. I learned a lot. I'm leaning toward the Compact 40 for myself.

[@SnareMan]

You're welcome! Thanks for watching! The shield is indeed a great gun! I carry it when I want something small and light to carry.

[@prettigedag]

Good video. I am going to get a shield for my purposes.

[@digitalskill]

+Eric Hoogeveen This video helped me realize I want to get a M&P9c. We all have our needs!

[@MWash-yr1xe]

You should never carry in a purse or bag, always have the weapon on your person.

[@Commasoncommqs]

Waistband

[@alex.buechel]

Awesome review. I just bought a full size and now I'm having a hard time finding a way to conceal it. I was thinking of picking up a second and was torn between these two. The key for me was here in your review where you show with the mag's in the fact that the compact shows less due to the tapered angle mag. It has the advantage of capacity. Thanks !!!

[@J.Wick.]

This should be revisited now that the Shield Plus is available, and available now with 10, 13, and 15rd magazines. I have a Shield Plus, and a 40c. Also have a 9c barrel and mags for the 40c. I like both, carry both.

[@57HEMIviken]

the compact is the obvious choice here and so many people are just falling into the it's a single stack it's smaller and exist to carry when really it's taller the hardest dimension to conceal and holds less rounds

[@57HEMIviken]

*easier

[@SnareMan]

I think so too, but there are times when I for some reason just want something small and light and grab the Shield

[@trewten5579]

if you cant stop a threat with 7 or 8 rounds then maybe its not the gun you need to be worried about. lol

[@swmovan]

My thoughts, exactly. And many others I have talked to say the same thing. Unless, I suppose, you are in a gunfight against several people. Then you're probably in big trouble, anyway.

[@amerikhan8507]

there is such a thing as missing.

[@SnareMan]

That's crazy talk!

[@marktc01]

I understand the concept of your comment, but I like having 12 rnds in a concealable package.

[@MrHeavyMetalRocker1]

Have you ever seen someone on pcp? I've seen people take 8 shots of .45 hp center mass and still fight off 6 officers who were trying to cuff him.

[@stevecraignet]

Great video! I've been thinking about the S & W Shield; didn't know the differences between it and the compact. Thanks!

[@jaredgralton4811]

did he say david bowie?

[@logansmith4215]

that's what I heard

[@CHAD-RYAN]

He just passed away, yall leave him alone, too soon...

[@revolverden]

For the viewers who haven't made a purchase yet, do yourself a favor and seriously consider the .40S&W over the 9mm. You give up nothing in size but get a better defensive caliber.

[@johnrigano6138]

How many rounds (capacity) do you lose though?

[@SnareMan]

How many rounds (capacity) do you lose though?

[@revolverden]

1.

[@mattsbord]

why not go one better and get the 45......same old rant 9 - 40 - 45....

[@temmenj100]

Why just a .40 S&W? 10mm's where its at!

[@egmjag]

After watching this video, I'm glad that I finally "got" my Shield yesterday chambered in .40. I love the look and feel of it, and the grip angle. The way it felt in my hand was just perfect! The only other subcompact pistol I was considering chambered in .40 was the XD Mod.2, but I never had the chance to hold it. Interestingly, my brother gave me a black Smith and Wesson watch last year, and he didn't even care about firearms. So maybe it was a premonition that I would eventually get a S&W firearm. At that time I really wanted to purchase a 4-inch S&W 686 Plus revolver but decided to get a semi-auto because of several obvious reasons. I first got a Springfield XD Service model with a 4-inch barrel chambered in .40 over a year ago. I went in to get a Hi Point chambered in 9mm but ended up trying to get an XD chambered in 9mm. Ended up getting the .40 full-sized model because all 9mm XDs in SoCal were sold out at that time. I'm happy that I got the .40 and I love practicing with it. Then I really wanted to get the Mod.2 subcompact in .40 a few months ago. Couldn't do that because they're illegal in Commiefornia. So after watching another video exclusively about the Shield chambered in .40, I felt that it was a better fit for me and for conceal carry, even though the Mod.2's magazines are double stack. But you sacrifice weight and size as a result, so I'll be very happy when I finally receive my Shield next week. I can only hope that I'll finally get my CCW...in L.A. County! Got the official response letter from the L.A. Sheriff but no denial. Just saying that they're waiting for the Peruta ruling.

[@dag221]

Nice video ! I chose the Shield as my carry gun in addition to my standard M&P9. I like the thinner feel on the shorter grip over the wide one on the Compact. It's ( the grip width) not as noticeable on a full size gun like the M&P but is ( at least to me ) on the smaller gun. Also I really liked the safety on a carry gun. I know some people don't but it wasn't a problem for me, in fact it was a selling point. I like the single stack clip for it's size and it was a good trade off versus the extra weight carrying almost twice as many rounds. The Compact seemed to be almost like a full sized gun with just a tiny bit taken off and even more so with a larger magazine and I didn't want a carry gun that was practically the same size as the gun I considered too big to carry comfortably already. Quality guns all of them though........

[@ronhodge3916]

Nice, informative video that had some input in questions I had considered - recoil and tradeoff of capacity for size. Thanks for the info!

[@SnareMan]

You're welcome! Glad you found it helpful!

[@AlexS71192]

SnareMan Can you make a video. With all three of the M&P series.? Full size M&P, M&P Compact, M&P shield?

[@Crab53]

Very nice,great comparison. I wish I would have found your video on this subject 4 months ago. I placed a deposit on a 40 cal Shield in July and got tired of waiting . I ordered a Ruger SR40c instead. The SR40c came in and after doing the paperwork and paying for the Ruger, the owner of my LGS placed a Shield 9mm in the display case. This was the first Shield the had gotten since late May. My wife looked at me and said"Put a deposit on it and maybe I'll carry that one". I'm still in shock.

[@bezerker34]

I bought the mp9c about two months ago and took it to the range with my sig 2022 and I fell in love with this gun, it is just as accurate as the sig and i absolutely love the trigger on the MP, which some people seem to hate for some reason.. This gun just feels perfect in my hand..

[@SnareMan]

They've definitely improved the triggers over the years

[@HUNTSPOINT.]

About to purchase my second SW MPC 40. LOVE the trigger and the recoil. Amazing durable firearm that I do carry concealed. The 10 round mag is enough and it gets the job done. No complaints over the last 10 years. Oh yeah don't forget to load hollow points.

[@LordFenixBloodstone]

This was a well done video, I like to just see what other think of M&P line-up Great job!

[@SnareMan]

***** Thanks Frank!

[@mariodattilo375]

I have both the .40c and the .40 shield and they are both good for different things. I prefer the shield for carry due to it being slimmer but like he said the weight is more than you would expect. I carried the compact for a while and it was too thick for someone who is slim built and I wear lite clothing in a warm state all the time making it harder to conceal without printing. Compact is now my home defense/range gun. Good video.

[@Nemesis459]

Went to buy a Glock 26 today, and was introduced to the M&P Compact.. Thanks for this video.

[@SnareMan]

You're welcome Sam!

[@jaydawg116]

Spring/summer carry is the shield. Fall/winter is a Glock 19. Love this gun. Had to change out the trigger because it sucked apples, but honestly this little gun is one of the most comfortable carries I’ve ever had. Props for the video. Thanks mate.

[@einyv]

Great video, bought the shield on the 4th of July to celebrate and love it. I am interested in the 9c especially after seeing the ability to use the 17. Round magazine. Decisions, decisions! The M&P 2.0 looks very nice too, trying to decide. The shield is my EDC but want something I can use also for home defense with more rounds. I have a shotgun but would like a handgun with more capacity.

[@ironvista]

thanks a lot for such detailed info. Have a wonderful thanksgiving buddy!

[@beags12]

Thank you for that video. I know its a year old but I am a recently new gun owner and have been looking at obtaining a good carry firearm. A business associate recently purchased the Shield and absolutely loves it for carrying purposes. Yes, the magazine is less with just the 7 and 8 but again for carrying purposes he feels it should do the trick if needed. I looked at the compact today but feel the shield would be more appropriate for carrying purposes. You helped me make my decision.

[@abc-wv4in]

My M&P 9C (original version) came with two 12-round mags; one flat base and one with extension. I like it and also like my Shield 9 2.0. There are usually great discounts on line for the Shields for some reason.

[@Briathos1]

Good choice. I just bought the compact in 40 cal, I loved that it had replaceable back straps as well as an ambi mag release(I am a left handed shooter). I have to agree about the different magazine selections as well.

[@basskicking4532]

Thanks for the video. I have the Shield and I love it when I am carrying it but hate it when I am at the range shooting. Just like you said I ran out of bullets way too quickly. I am now forced to buy more magazines (even extended ones, which are impossible to find for the shield) so I do not have to keep loading the magazines every minute. Shield: Positives: Carry/size + price + accuracy = great! Negatives: Training at the range (100+ bullets) is a nightmare. I hope you would not need more than 1 or 2 shots if you are defending yourself, but just remember that 7 or even 8 rounds are way too little, you can run out of bullets in a very very short period of time.

[@MrBkunert]

I found you searching for this comparison. Well done!

[@MJF1800]

Great video. I agree with your assessment. I had both and just sold my shield yesterday. The compact is better to own for most people. Thanks for the info. Keep up the reviews...

[@keving52002]

Great video. I was always a glock person ,i have experience with the glock 17 , i was in the market for a glock 26 for CCW. However now the S&W mp9 C is really captivating me, and the price it really making it a worth wild choice. I also still love S&W J frame revolvers. Im very good and proficient with both. any viewers have any comment on which to chose form CCW?

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for the kind words and the sub! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@williemcmeans4003]

I’m a proud owner of a Shield 9mm I’ve carried it more than a year. I’m looking for more round capacity so I’ve rented the 9c and I’m on the fence with purchasing one however I’m pulling the trigger literally on the 9c. It will become my home defense and range gun. Thanks for the table top comparison.

[@atomicdog71]

Excellent review of two of my favorite firearms. Very nicely done.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks!!!

[@NymRoddd]

Great video, very informative, I think you covered just about everything there was to compare between the two.

[@sdeeut69]

I bought the 9c yesterday after lamenting months over paying WAY too much for a shield from those who have been lucky enough to find one. I just happened to check at Scheels where they had one for $549. That was up $20 from the last one they had, but still, it's the first time I have seen one anywhere! I bought it after seeing this review a while ago.. and I'm glad I did. It conceals VERY well and with the extra capacity, it just makes sense. Now I can quit lamenting! Great vid.

[@pcwillyt]

Thank you for the comparison. I will be a first time buyer very soon. I am going for a concealed carry weapon that both I and my wife would become practiced/proficient at using. We also have four little ones that I need to teach to have a healthy awareness of guns in general so I am hoping that the shield or the compact would work- with all the home "safe" gun keeping tools as well.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for the comment and for watching. I figured this would be quite a popular gun for them as soon as it came out. I do wish it was slightly smaller though, but I guess I could go get a bodyguard...

[@S4M4R1T4N]

Very good review. It has definitely helped me decide seeing the two handguns next to each other and learning that the shield is only a few ounces lighter. I have the M&P9c already, and I think I'll buy a Kel Tec P11. I need something light that I can comfortably carry while running.

[@rogerstruthers3799]

This is an absolute great video on the differences of these guns. I appreciate the straight talk without the macho personal stuff, just the facts. Wish I had seen this video sooner. I did buy a shield with some questions but have come to love it, Since I live in CA cannot buy the larger gun. I am totally satisfied with my shield. We here are really limited to choices and I am glad S&W has made this CA compliant.

[@SnareMan]

Thanks Roger! Glad you liked the vid!

[@SnareMan]

Thanks for the sub and comment Bob! Glad you found it helpful!

[@RandySavage50]

I have Shield, 40 and 40c... definitely prefer 40c over my other two Smith’s

[@mmssanders1]

Great video, well presented points on both, I was leaning towards the compact and this sealed the deal, keep up the good work

[@horribleNebraska]

That shield has every feature that I've wanted in in ccw gun. Good job S&W. I've been waiting for someone to finally design my gun.

[@nightmonkey2779]

Great video! Do you think m&p 9c would work as an ankle rig? Im looking for a bug & was considering the shield to carry ankle, but if the 9c works i'd rather have the capacity.

[@MikeSmith-cy7jw]

Good job, I enjoyed your video you made some rock solid comparisons.

[@BustedLeaf]

I just purchased the compact version. I am not able to handle the gun with the flat magazine. Any suggestions. And where should I get the 12 round magazine for that. Thx.

[@SnareMan]

You're welcome! Glad you found it helpful!

[@gtracer6629]

I just traded up to a Shield from a Kel-Tec P3AT which was my BUG. My first line EDC is either a 1911, a Taurus 840c, or a S&W 469 (depending on clothing choices or my mood that day). So the limited capacity is not a problem. I sometimes even carry a S&W 5906 as my main defense pistol. The P3AT was smaller but I feel better with a larger caliber. Also that $100.00 price difference helped me decide against the M&P compact.

[@Jonathan_Knight]

Thank you your bid helped ALOT. I haven't purchased yet BUT I think your bid has helped with my decision .M&P 40c

[@SnareMan]

You're welcome! Great choice!

[@mikenevermon9041]

Thank you for that explanation. As a newbie, I wanted to know.

[@joehuff4025]

I’ve carried the 9-c for 8 years, bought the Shield plus when they came out. Love them both and carry them both. Great shooting guns, never had any malfunction from either, they eat whatever you feed them.

[@SnareMan]

I know. I forgot that when I did the fit. Or the time I mentioned it didn't make the final cut somehow.

[@wesley_makes]

This has definitely been the most helpful Shield vs M&P 9c video that I have seen. watched it multiple times in the past few months.

[@johnrigano6138]

Thanks Wesley!

[@SnareMan]

Thanks Wesley!

[@SnareMan]

You're welcome! Thanks for watching!

[@timsawyer7443]

SnareMan - This is a great comparison video, but is now older. Have you made another one with the M2.0s of each gun? I can't find it, and I'm having the exact same question now (which one to buy, for me as my first CCW), but of course with the M2.0s. If you haven't done a new one with the 2.0s, then have you tried the 2.0s, and do you have an opinion about them? My guess is that even with all of the improvements, you might have the same opinion as you had of these. Thoughts? Again, great video, and thanks for your contribution!

[@SnareMan]

No, I somehow forgot to mention that in the vid. I think it was in in one of the cuts that didn't make the final vid.