MA. v Karen Read Trial Day 23 - Trooper Proctor Cross Examination

[@maryellen303]

I was a detective for 30 years. There is not one officer I know that would not have run out of his house if anyone, no less a friend , was found dead on my lawn. These people are awful. Proctor got every bit of his supposed evidence from Jen McCabe, including her medical conditions. That is the only thing he used to make his decision that Karen was guilty. There was no actual investigation, only what they could make fit into their theory. They even tried to influence the medical examiner. The only truth told in this case was by the people unrelated to the Canton PD.

[@judithmcgill3913]

Fully agree how unethical was that? He's a slacker doesn't want to do the work. Doesn't want to use protocol.

[@warriorb_yotch]

But he got emotional SMH 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 🤦🏼‍♀️ 😂

[@krystalbrooks3418]

These people are really something else. I have very strong suspicions that Mr Higgins and Mr. Albert know exactly what happened. They talk about the Trooper finding or planting tail light pieces…what if someone other than the Trooper planted that evidence…nightmare investigation like no other.

[@janeevans1859]

@@warriorb_yotchwhat’s the point?

[@warriorb_yotch]

@@janeevans1859 sarcasm

[@TeresaLovesRetro]

The fact that Proctor says the word "integrity" with a straight face is amazing to me. The fact that the whole court doesn't burst out laughing when he says it is even more amazing!

[@ashieloveful]

Apparently a juror laughed at it 😂

[@hnraj9441]

​@@ashieloveful that's fabulous!

[@YouTuberight-t5j]

I couldn’t believe that he didn’t know what integrity meant. He gave an explanation that was the most absurd thing that I have ever heard. I’m stunned.

[@shelby477]

​@@KZbinright-t5jWell it could be part of it, but he doesn't even do that. 😂

[@johns1625]

Also "compelling evidence" 🤮

[@melz3671]

If he developed compelling evidence against Ms.'s Read then where the hell is it and when are they going to decide to show it to the jury and everyone else!?!?

[@GreenEyedGumby]

Hold your horses, I’m sure it’s only 25 witnesses away!

[@Diamond1234]

Yeah, where IS that "overwhelming evidence", Mr. Proctor, because from where I'm sitting, none of the evidence so far says points to Karen Reed, if anything, it's pointing toward literally everyone else because EVERYONE IS ACTING SUSPICIOUS! All the butt dials and "we TOOOOTALLY didn't talk to each other about this, heck, we don't even REALLY know each other" and getting rid of evidence like our phones and dog, as well as the botched evidence that can't be trusted because it's all contaminated or gathered in the worst possible way! Other than the clothes tossed into the corner in the medical place because that's normal, you screwed up EVERYTHING in this case!

[@melz3671]

@@GreenEyedGumby 🤣🤣🤣🤣 you right! I'll wait.... Oh wait, that was for the defense, nevermind! 🤣

[@CoffeeLoverRx]

@@GreenEyedGumby😂😂

[@joshn1678]

It's shocking, like why haven't we heard any real evidence. The taillight pieces don't seem believeable, they're HUGE lol, and no one said her light was broken like that. Where is the medical examiner showing the injuries and how the CAR caused them?

[@rachaelreis6530]

I find it irrelevant that Karen drinks on top of her medical conditions. It's hard to be sick. People cope in different ways. Not always healthy ones. It's not any different for people with health issues.

[@kalkal6125]

Amen

[@MimiDidi121]

Also, those glasses of during were clear liquid. We don’t know if she was drinking water or soda between alcohol drinks. We did see her pour a shot in them a timer or two. I do the exact same thing when I’m out drinking. I have ulcerative colitis, which is different, admittedly, Crohn’s, but alcohol absorbs faster when you large intestine is inflamed. If she really drank as many drinks as they counted, as small as she is, she would be staggering. Plus, I saw an a live chat. One of our students say that she had gone out to drinks with her twice and she always orders a drink and then water once or twice before cocktail. I’d like to order the mixer and the alcohol separate so I can control how much alcohol is in there. Some bars make them very strong.

[@Amelia_Rose_333]

@@MimiDidi121 according to Karen herself she had 4 drinks that night. This is from her interview with ABC news (I re-watched last night.) 4 is not 9 (or whatever ridiculous number the cops are trying to say she drank.)

[@SilverDraco]

She has no colon, hence the colostomy bag, and idk how alcohol digests anymore. School was a long time ago! 😂​@@MimiDidi121

[@swantron4335]

Totally agree! I also have gastrointestinal issues but don't *not* go out because I want to be involved in social events with friends. I often get drinks that mix with sprite or ginger ale so that I can ask the bartender for only that but my glass looks the same. Easier than explaining to everyone.

[@GoblinsAreAGirlsBestFriend]

I'm really puzzled why some people still seem laser focused on Karen being guilty. I don't know if she's guilty - neither do you - and we never will thanks to the shoddy policework. If you care about justice, at what point do you direct your focus to the people who completely compromised the investigation?

[@okoriesgirl6391]

Amen!!!

[@Diamond1234]

Who knows, maybe they want attention from chat and/or Emily, I see a lot of randos saying "In my opinion, Karen's guilty!" and that's it, which tells me that they are hoping someone will ask why or get mad so they can go off lol.

[@hnraj9441]

I think some of them (not all) are from the community and invested in some way. Possibly some of them either know the McAlberts or even are one or two of them. I'm sure there are some but I honestly can't even understand how anyone who came into this neutral could actually be convinced she is guilty based on the evidence. I've asked some people and never gotten much of an answer other than they don't think a coverup is possible or they don't see motivation from other people.

[@NottyAries]

Probably a weird mixture of confirmation bias and sunk cost fallacy.

[@mitch6969123]

⁠​⁠@@Diamond1234for sure

[@NottyAries]

The judge didn't like him saying "shame on you sir" because it wasn't a question. He should have said, "have you any shame!?" 😂

[@judithmcgill3913]

😊

[@JackiSueM]

Bingo!!!! What if any shame?

[@NottyAries]

@@JackiSueM 😂😂😂💀

[@mininjas]

I guess it's "argumentative"

[@lauraventerosa3010]

She does not like him. He pushes it

[@lizzimmermann7164]

I haven’t seen my brother’s best friend in like 20 years but if you asked me if I know him the answer is “yes, that’s my brother’s best friend.”

[@sammurphhhhHH]

Yeah I think I could pick out my sibling’s friends from about that far back too. If you have a good relationship with your siblings then you’re going to cross paths with their best friend enough time to for sure know who they are

[@ravenzyblack]

@@sammurphhhhHH- Considering Trooper Proctor texted his sister more than his wife. I’m sure he knew everything about all of her friends. They texted back-and-forth at least eight times a day…EACH DAY!!

[@MykenGarciaBeauty]

Am I the only person, when he kept trying to insert, “we had compelling evidence that Ms. Read did it.” SCREAM at the screen, “what compelling evidence!!?!?!?! Show me!!!!”

[@hnraj9441]

Definitely not the only one!

[@supergran62]

I was yelling “what evidence other than your prepared and oft repeated script”

[@joshn1678]

It's insane, we know the Tail light pieces were planted, NO ONE saw her brake light that broken lol. So we need some kind of evidence, have a doctor tell me a car could cause Johns injuries, because I just don't see it.

[@JulieeeB]

Exactly what I said out loud too! WHERE. IS. IT.

[@helenat2446]

And supposedly had the compelling evidence within 16hrs. Even though they were picking up tail light pieces for weeks 😵‍💫

[@okoriesgirl6391]

I don't know about Proctor, but I love Yanetti! I love how he is just watching Jackson having a very good day in court. Lol

[@here.for.the.music.]

Same 😂 when proctor was talking crap about him he couldn’t look more unbothered 😅 kind of looked like he was thinking THIS guy thinks I’m an @ss? 😂 the audacity.

[@deannetronsdal409]

Same! It was pretty decent camera work today - covering the witness and those he was sh*t talking about!

[@simsadie14]

I like Yanetti’s style more than Jackson’s but god they’re both so intelligent and passionate

[@joshn1678]

Yeah, I like Yanetti, he seems like a good dude. Jackson has that fast speaking lawyer feel, but honestly, he's done a great job for Karen.

[@tashiaredd3421]

I love Yanetti as well and how he turned his body so the jury could see his face and reactions. Especially when he was shaking his head no on some of Proctors answers. I wish he would’ve been the one questioning Proctor. Seeing as how Proctor “still doesn’t care for him”.

[@toddmurphy523]

The socks could have been important to place in evidence and tested. If Victim had gone into the home, most people would have removed their snowy shoes. The socks could have collected the german shepherds fur/hair and testing them could have answered the question if victim DID enter the home.

[@Stephanie-yp9vl]

OMG... that is a wonderful point. I cant believe they didn't do that... i wonder if it was not taken on purpose

[@Pray4USA]

UNDERRATED COMMENT!!! 👏👏👏

[@MShaiqable]

Well shit... damn!

[@katharinamonch4223]

Or if they put cleaned shoes on him…..who is not wearing socks in this wheather???

[@toddmurphy523]

@@katharinamonch4223 He was wearing socks.... that's the whole point. The socks were not placed into evidence like everything else the victim was wearing.

[@AliceM6192]

The fact that you paused the stream, right in the middle of a wtf moment, to help your son, makes me love you even more!! ❤

[@bcastle2397]

Me too!!!❤

[@larkgraham9522]

Oh yes, your son was adorable! You work from home girl! Do your thing

[@helenat2446]

I was listening in the car and thought someone had come into court to say the pest inspector was there 😂

[@cosacita]

Same 🥰

[@brittanybozard1783]

The only report that anyone can locate in this case is the weather report lol😂

[@mamasaurus564]

😂😂😂

[@JackiSueM]

😂😂😂

[@DaniSouthMS]

Yep, and it was snowing. 😂

[@MsBermudababy]

"Exactly."

[@lzk22]

Literally 😂

[@mitch6969123]

Every time a witness says “absolutely”, they seem to be lying…

[@sharontriffitt7031]

And all the liars do a lot of sniffing too

[@dikshaedythe6042]

It's like they spoke among themselves and unconsciously are repeating absolutely after JM used it over and over. They all have the same intonation on absolutely.

[@Sidra_193]

Exactly. It's become the hint. It would just be a no instead of a resounding absolutely not it just screams defensive.

[@bonesonstones1]

It sounds SO disingenuous.

[@tcorris]

Absolutely is a lot like a witness saying “to tell you the truth” my next statement will be a lie.

[@Amelia_Rose_333]

I find it SO maddening that all of these witnesses “can’t recall” their prior testimony, even if it’s just a few weeks or months before. If it’s the TRUTH there is no reason to need to “recall” the information because your testimony always stays the same. What you’re saying today would be the same as what you’d already said. 🚩🚩 🚨🚨🚨

[@mamasaurus564]

Exactly!!!

[@NottyAries]

Heck, Proctor forgot a statement he made to one of AJs questions, just 5 minutes later.

[@mininjas]

Seriously. It's hard to forget court; it's slightly traumatizing

[@susanlprince]

That's my thinking. If you testified truthfully, why do you have to recall what you testified to? The truth will always be the truth.

[@Honestfeedback1]

Thank you! I’ve been saying the same thing.

[@ginagruber1732]

After today I would be ready to acquit if I was on the jury. I felt so bad for her when they went into her colon issues. AND THE AUDACITY of proctor to complain of his character being attacked by Yannetti after what proctor said about Karen!

[@judithmcgill3913]

no kidding

[@judithmcgill3913]

they are using his testimony to bring their case, but why she was guilty very poor lawyering

[@judithmcgill3913]

Observing his body doesn't tell me that he was in a car accident with no bruises or fractures no bruises on his legs where the bumper would've hit him

[@Classic-Ov3rThinker]

Even Johns dad left when they started going thru the messages about Karens medical condition 😢

[@joshn1678]

​@@judithmcgill3913Yeah, to me he simply doesn't have the injuries of being backed into. It's possible, but just seems unlikely.

[@dollarstoreloudiamondphillips]

This dude is the reason why so many people don’t like cops and don’t trust them.

[@Stephanie-yp9vl]

100%

[@pandorah1801]

Absolutely!!

[@trishnickles2236]

Truly. Cops act like this and then wonder why people despise and don't trust them. Yah, right. "Back the blue." Only if you're part of their little crew and they like you.

[@silikon2]

He's becoming the very poster child for police corruption. Some sort of monetary corruption is obviously bad, but railroading this woman into prison into what looks more and more like a frame up is way worse. I have now zero faith in Massachusetts police, but luckily don't live there. Look how calm and convincing he can be when not having to go through his astonishingly offensive texts. How many people has he put away like this.

[@dollarstoreloudiamondphillips]

@@silikon2 imagine all the people who doesn’t have the money to get a proper defensen that has been railroaded by cops like this.

[@Heatherboothe]

Sooo.. Proctor kept an open mind going into this investigation but called Karen the c-word 16 hours in?

[@thomasgcampbell]

Really wanted to hear Action Jackson ask him how many times he called JM a “C”

[@TheAverageSavage1021]

Not even that- but was 100% certain she was going down for it- and was a whack job. I’m not a mass resident- but I need to find out where and whom we can write to- the hopefully not corrupted higher power about this demon being employed; about this da, prosecutor, and judge- this investigation; the civil rights violations- it’s unbelievable- seriously this would be a corny Hollywood movie because it’s so ridiculous it wouldn’t ever get the Green light because it’s unrealistic. Karen loved John- and John didn’t deserve this. Every day this case isn’t dismissed the more I fear for our safety and judicial systems

[@Heatherboothe]

@TheAverageSavage1021 I was thinking about that! Who can we call? If anyone finds out, I would love to know. I don't want to be a Karen but this is completely unacceptable.

[@MsBermudababy]

"Exactly!"

[@joshn1678]

Wasn't even that long lol, 10 hours later he said she was going to jail for this. Makes no sense.

[@deannetronsdal409]

Alan Jackson - “Shame on you.” Holy crap!! That cross was 🔥!!!

[@sabbathsermonthetypist]

When did he say that

[@CoffeeLoverRx]

@@sabbathsermonthetypist4:57:30

[@christinanielsen9445]

Jacksons "SHAME ON YOU SIR" was so freaking personal🙈😂 Go get him, AJ! I absolutely loved it🤷🏽‍♀️😬😁

[@helensmusings]

Whether it was appropriate for the court or not, I have so much respect for Jackson for doing that. He's making it clear where he stands and what he's standing up for

[@Violet-xg4bb]

Frigging 💥 moment.

[@christinanielsen9445]

Exactly ​@@helensmusings.. and maling it very clear, that the behaviour is absolutely outrageous coming from a Trooper!

[@bethmccrae2714]

Alan Jackson attacked Harvey Weinstein rape victims. Shame on Alan Jackson

[@bdylan225]

And the look of disgust he had on his face when he said it made it even more impactful!

[@5boysmomma]

Alan Jackson looks and sounds disgusted with trooper Proctor. And honestly I can't say that I blame him. Proctor has changed my perspective about police.

[@timroberts6695]

Texting with all his friends, some in other states, and his co workers has exposed how great police corruption is. I would find it hard to trust any cops motives now after watching this trial.

[@amandamosteller1371]

He didn't change my perspective on police officers but rather homicide detectives.. smh

[@nicolepsy]

Not every cop in every department, state or agency is bad. Generalizing is a dangerous thing.

[@5boysmomma]

I'm not saying that all police are bad. In evert profession you will find all kinds of corruption. What I'm trying to say is for the better part of my life I have trusted the police. Remember when we old ones were young and your parents were telling me if you get lost look for a police. And I think I have been looking at them like thank you for doing what we can't. I wouldn't want anyone in Massachusetts in law enforcement to make sure I get justice, because I don't think John O'Keefe family members have got to be cringing by now

[@melindapye7435]

I mean, he represented Spacey so while we are disgusted, I doubt he is. This is a huge gift to the defense and I imagine he is delighted.

[@deannetronsdal409]

Alan Jackson’s inflection skills are top notch! He could make anything sound suss!

[@susanharrington8715]

“exactly”

[@Raven1303x]

Thankfully these people have been so shady on the stand he doesn’t have to try too hard. 😅

[@deannetronsdal409]

Anyone else rethinking the casual way that they text message others? 😬 😅

[@carrier8620]

@@deannetronsdal409YES!

[@xzio5728]

Alan Jackson when to bat for his client with full emotions and in my book knocked out of this world. The ending especially was impactful with the point of Proctor dehumanizing his client was masterful. The look on Proctor's face as Jackson barraged him with his own words says it all. When Jackson asked about Proctor dehumanizing Karen, the look on his face was something. But when the prosecutor objected, there was this quick flash of relief to the point he almost smiles! Then when the Judge said "I'll give you this one Mr. Jackson", the look on Proctors face was priceless. Then that "Shame on you" comment at the end, damn.

[@heathermcgovern1529]

Should have said “sorry your Honor, my emotions got the best of me”

[@larkgraham9522]

Imagine having Jackson & Linetti going to bat for you!! ❤❤

[@jjgirl3715]

@@heathermcgovern1529 hahaha that's brilliant! 👏

[@bcastle2397]

I have watched every minute of this court case with Emily. Is anyone else so exhausted and disillusioned that you just don't care anymore? Is that Lally's tactics to drive everyone to madness???😵‍💫 Does the jury feel that way??? Bless their hearts!!!

[@sunshinemitch]

YUP,YUP and i pray the jury feels this way. ugh

[@eztalkz7069]

lally has been so boring i wanna dyyyye my baloon knot

[@lindajohnson7675]

Yes!

[@deannetronsdal409]

The only thing that would redeem Lally at this point is if he’s actually torpedoing this case from the inside because he knows it’s garbage! 😂

[@BlessedInTX248]

No! I'll never give up on the verdict! I'll not stop caring no matter how boring watching every minute of this trial gets! You guys & gals are obviously not as obsessed with this case as me. TBI survivor with obsessive tendencies. 😂

[@Katelyn02217]

I was pulled over by a Mass statie a few hours ago as I was listening to the end of this. (I forgot to put the new registration sticker on my plate. Oops. All good, though.) He was so kind, but I hate that I immediately wondered if he was like Proctor. That man has caused so much damage to the integrity of our state troopers, and I hope he suffers for it.

[@timroberts6695]

And you question with good reason. Remember Proctor said in one text “as the chief would say”, the corruption runs deep.

[@drddianesbryant]

I’m 72 and, like my Mother, have lost any filters I ever had. I would have told the trooper what I was listening to and asked him if he knew Proctor. 😝

[@Alexis84DE]

While everybody else is focusing on those vile and heinous text messages (and I really can’t condemn them enough!!) I have two takeaways from today : 1. If Karen and John got into an argument, why did she return to HIS house? The kids were away at a sleepover. She wasn’t even supposed to stay over. When I get into a fight with my boyfriend, I go to MY home, not back to his 2. Proctor testified that he interviewed somebody together with Higgins. Why is Higgins, an ATF agent who does not work for the Canton PD and may be a potential witness to the events of the evening, interviewing people???

[@xxtinkerbell91xx]

Kayliegh was home. It was only the youngest at the sleepover. If you believe she's innocent, she's had the argument, gone to watch kayleigh and freaked when he's not turned up. If you believe she's guilty, she's pretending everything's OK and staying over for a cover

[@willcochrane6949]

I’m team Karen, but playing devil’s advocate, I think number 1 has a couple logical explanations in favor of the commonwealth. 1) She knew she hit John, and he wasn’t coming home to take care of the kid. 2) She didn’t know she hit John, but definitely hit him. Then she realized she was too drunk to try and take the much longer drive to where she was supposed to stay. Number 2 you’re spot on though. Even if Karen did it, and did it on purpose, the carelessness with the investigation is disgusting.

[@jackiefoulk9982]

Only the Nephew stayed at a friend's home

[@Mrs.Pittforever]

She had been complaining about being responsible for the kids too much. She wanted to go to her own house because she wasn’t feeling well. John was supposed to be home but instead he chose to go to this party. That’s what she was upset about.

[@Mrs.Pittforever]

That’s also why she was sleeping on the couch and not in bed. And I don’t know about you, but I’ve woken up in a panic in the middle of the night when somebody hasn’t come home.

[@MelsDivination]

I don't usually comment on live streams after the fact but I'm catching this late on the replay. I am a Rhode Island local and we have a local news station here called "WPRI 12" that I used to like and follow until last night! Last night I saw they reported 2 separate things about Proctor's testimony on Monday and they left out every single negative bit and made him look like a HERO I couldn't believe what I witnessed! I left several comments on BOTH videos because really? This is our local news source and court tv, a national program is delivering more transparency! So for any of you not local to the area, even the RI news outlets are covering for these people even now!! And the comments towards Karen being 'clearly guilty' were disgusting. We are not even 1 hour from canton here and they could easily see KR and her family at any time and automatically have passed judgement from a news source leaving out all the key negatives... This trial has really blown my mind. I dated a RI correctional officer for a while and witnessed some gross things being swept under the rug while I was with him for his buddies, I knew they 'take care of their own' but this is beyond anything I ever expected.

[@deannetronsdal409]

Oh wow! That’s so frustrating to hear! I’m glad you (and all of us!) have a reliable source here!

[@annhank128]

Disappointing. Makes you wonder who the news station people know… tentacles everywhere..

[@shkrjam84]

A lot of people woke up to this type of deception by legacy media during Depp v Heard. Some of them were shocked just how different the spin in the news and headlines was compared to what was actually happening in the trial. Really makes you realize just how easy it is to be snowed by local, national, and international media if you trust that they are delivering news for the purpose of good to the public, instead of what they’re actually doing - delivering what sells and what supports their own beliefs and narratives. They might be media corporations, but never forget they are corporations. 💵 talks.

[@hnraj9441]

That's so shameful coming out of local news and local reporters. The depp heard case taught me not to trust news reporting regarding trials but local news is usually better than national. It's just disappointing. Ugh.

[@erinavery4577]

Most news is bought and paid for

[@janewaysmom]

6:07:31 honestly, such a relief. This was by far, the biggest, most confusing part of the story. After 7 people telling me it was snowing, I thought, "but wait, what was the weather?" After 13 people telling me it was snowing, I thought "was it maybe a little snowy?" After 75 people telling me it was snowing, I thought "Maybe it was snowing." Now, finally, the weather service itself has told me, so after all those witnesses plus this, I finally know it was indeed snowing.

[@rascal342]

finally i understood why the state decided to bring this case to court

[@jennmoslek921]

Just when you think Proctor couldn't get any worse, AJ comes out swinging & knocks it out of the park! Lally should have saved his breath on re-direct because there was no fixing anything Proctor said or did.

[@laimanarbute4188]

I am on redirect of Proctor, and as soon as I think it can't get any wors, I am beeing proven wrong every time.

[@Greeneyed1]

"Proctor and the Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Day"😅😅😅

[@deannetronsdal409]

Underrated comment!! 😂 Good work!

[@lauradeshotel3303]

This is why Higgins ditched his phone. Higgins was a little shady. He should be investigated for other crimes...just saying.

[@FrankieSmith-zv8ci]

What I keep thinking about is how emotional Higgins was about the kids. If he was the one to do it then it would make sense if he was regretful about the impact his actions had on kids

[@helensmusings]

For me Higgins is suspect number one given the msgs to Karen Reed. I have a feeling due to the covering up of Colin being there, that whatever started Colin joined in

[@mitch6969123]

@@helensmusingshe should of been because of those messages. In what world would the guy hookin up with the victims girlfriend not be investigated..

[@hnraj9441]

​@@FrankieSmith-zv8ci i thought the same thing during his testimony. The was him feeling guilty about putting them through this. He had a hand in it, either the death or the cover-up, and feels bad about how it impacted the kids though he feels justified about the rest of it.

[@hnraj9441]

​@@helensmusings at this point I am thinking Brian Albert, Colin Albert and Brian Higgins were involved and then the women got involved to help protect them and cover it up.

[@thecatlimitdoesnotexist]

You know…now that we’re 23 business days into this trial, if they were going to give us any compelling evidence before their case is closed, I don’t think the FBI would be investigating this case...

[@LexieJay00]

Alan Jackson just moved up to my FIRST favorite Alan Jackson 😂 “Shame on you.” 👏🏾

[@jessicawinsor4751]

I love his pause and look before he says it! Sooo effective

[@deannetronsdal409]

I bet Proctor wishes he was “way down yonder on the Chattahoochie….”

[@JRay.R]

@@deannetronsdal409 💯

[@IrishGoodbyes]

I never heard the term balloon knot before and I never want to hear it again.

[@ravenzyblack]

I could have gone my whole life without hearing that term and lived just fine.

[@davewade30]

So basically Ring told him he could delete videos and no one would ever know. Wonderful!

[@diverightin9243]

Yep, I caught that too!

[@joshn1678]

Lol, Exactly I was like, thanks Ring, you just saved this man from going to jail and put her in jail. Nah, I don't even believe him, I want to hear from Ring.

[@diverightin9243]

I took it as HE deleted it and we will never know. He had the access. Karen did not have access to the ring camera.

[@OMGKitteh88]

Did you notice how Proctor tried to pull off McCabes trick and fish for sympathy by telling a story of harassment? xD This time the judge cut this off quickly.

[@jenniferchoo9413]

Thank god we got official weather reports...I was starting to wonder what the weather was like.

[@deannetronsdal409]

But was it snowing? 🤣

[@Npvisqueen]

I wonder if it was snowing

[@polivepea]

😂😂😂😂

[@E-magineMySurprise]

The weather report will surely show that the snow was actually inverted. Snow was leaving the ground and returning to the sky. It also took some tail light pieces with it. When that snow fell again, bringing pieces of tail light every once in a while, we dutifully collected it as it came back to the crime scene.

[@Quiteinfamous]

@@E-magineMySurpriseflawless deduction 😂

[@321_Relax]

I haven’t been a huge fan of Jackson’s style and much prefer Yanetti, but he did a masterful job on his cross of Proctor - especially the end. He had me on the verge of tears feeling horrible for Karen. Very powerful. Great job 💙

[@GonzoMom]

Same! I cried for her. Karen has handled all of this with much more grace and poise than I ever could.

[@laimanarbute4188]

And during Murdaugh trial everyone was saying SLED did very bad investigation. No no, they did almost excelent investigation - no rehomed home, phones etc.

[@bathingcatsonacloudyday]

Canton Police and Massachussets PD made SLED look like the best investigative team ever.

[@Hollister74]

Right, SLED is looking amazing right now. SLED needs to send Proctor a gift basket, maybe with some balloons, solo cups, and OTC pain relief for the reaming he just got from Jackson, and maybe Lally is going to give him!

[@theenchantedgardendream8787]

Shame on you was the chefs kiss on cross!! He said what we all were thinking.

[@nancycoelho4426]

I laughed, screamed, went into a rage - all from today's court day

[@adamjarvis7353]

the commonwealth should dismiss this case tomorrow

[@Sabrinasolomon_xo]

Yes. They’ve wasted everyone’s time and states resources. Not to mention what they put Karen thru and no justice for John

[@KayD]

They should have binned it months ago

[@shmo_de]

Today was wiiiilld 🤯. Thanks for riding with us, Emily & team!

[@mariannesouza8326]

Very generous. 👍🏼

[@GoblinsAreAGirlsBestFriend]

If I hear "juvinile and unprofessional" one more time. Try tasteless and dispicable. The way he kept repeating those two terms was so rehearsed... and after all that rehearsing he couldn't have come up with better words for it? He clearly thinks he did absolutely nothing wrong. He shouldn't even be allowed to try and sell that.

[@timroberts6695]

Just what you are looking for when you hire state cops, people who are juveniles and unprofessional 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@Julia-uh4li]

"He clearly thinks he did absolutely nothing wrong!" Yes, I whole heartedly agree, and I can actually picture him walking into work after these days of testimony, being clapped on the back by all his buddies, and them telling him he did a great job. Then laughing about all the texts. I have no doubt everyone that's associated with him, including his family are all quite similar minded. God, its truly dire. Imho!

[@smileymama04]

I HAD to come back to rewatch. Today was THAT good . 😂 Thank you Emily ❤

[@beachgal2]

I enjoy “rewatching with Emily” for the snark and legal Aspect!!!

[@smileymama04]

⁠@@beachgal2I do too . Listening while at work I sometimes miss things 😂 The snark is EVERYTHING.. Alan’s swear word enunciation was JUST …. 😂🤣😂

[@soartsyfartsy7874]

AJ shocks me with the speed of his wittiness. He lets his disdain show but keeps it classy. Very few people can inspire others to cheer for them when they’re being snarky - but I cheer for him!! He has an amazing way of using his voice inflection to hammer points in without seeming “angry”.

[@chicagodoll]

Alright... replay crew... lets go!

[@chicagodoll]

"So 16 hours in you knew that this wouldnt implicate in any way shape form or fashion, another cop correct?" ... "yes" Because that doesnt SCREAM "ive made my mind up and will make sure the evidence fits rather than actually following the evidence.

[@chicagodoll]

16 hrs in, before going to the scene and interviewing only 3 people, "you had this case wrapped up, didnt you?" "Yes." MY DUDE.

[@chicagodoll]

So he didnt even entertain the idea that others could be lying.. that he could be wrong.... this is the epitome of NOT ***following*** the evidence!

[@chicagodoll]

Good grief, im only 21 mins in on replay!!

[@chicagodoll]

"Have you ever seen a person hit by a car with no bruises" Super massive long pause. He did NOT want to answer that question, you could see it in his face.

[@NicholasMcKinney]

WTF, we have the weather report but no cause of death!!!! We live here now.

[@jimbarry145]

I would’ve gave Alan a standing ovation

[@astrialindah2773]

He would have gave him a standing ovation?😃

[@CrazyAsian_303]

I would be fired as a lawyer. I agree with AJ "Shame on you" I would've said "F-- you. Your're the Cu Next Tues. How dare you... Shame on you. You're not a man... You're worse than scum" I'm an emotional person and I have a bad sass mouth and this judge would hate me and I would not give two fucks. One of your officers died and you don't give two fucks and you and the Alberts and McCabes are in a tight circle and that evidence definitely shows for me and they got very evasive or defensive on a lot of things. FIRE them. they don't deserve their position

[@Gringa_L]

Emily, I hope you don't run yourself ragged keeping up with streams. Your audience will be here no matter when and how often you stream.

[@Coreythegreyhound]

Yannettis face during cross is correct. He’s so angry. Me too babe, me too

[@creativitybytrisha6819]

I've been watching this case on the replay crew. And I am completely flabbergasted! Every time I think these officers can't get any worse they do!

[@lindahadley2798]

I have been a lawyer for almost 40 years and this trial and how it’s been presented by the DA seems less like real life and more like a novel

[@E-magineMySurprise]

If this were a novel, I would have returned it for a refund! There are too many plot holes!

[@susanharrington8715]

Having just watched the Chad Daybell trial and the Alex Murdaugh trial before that… this judge is just so all about herself… has to have everybody waiting for her entrance, refuses to allow grounds for objections to be stated and for her rulings on same, everything’s a sidebar with her… she seems like she made a massive error at the outset, not granting a continuance which was requested by both sides… was totally unprepared for the level of publicity this trial would garner and wants to keep as much of her reasoning and rulings on the down low cause she’s really not sure of what she’s doing… especially given the, oughta be illegal, level of incompetence of law enforcement, the very real possibility of some kind of cover up that’s come to light and of course her own questionable conduct, her obvious bias against the defendant and her attorneys… she actually seems intimidated by them which would explain a lot…so they’re gonna bear the brunt of her errors and insecurities, her massive irritation with the keystone cops which she seems loathe to acknowledge instead taking out her super sigh hurry it along on the defense… sad to watch her behavior regardless of how impatient or intimidated she is… it’s disrespectful to the victim, his family, the defendant, her attorneys… to the judicial process and ultimately to the truth of whatever happened to that young police officer.

[@ronniweatherford4232]

💯

[@hnraj9441]

I get the impression that she is mad that the defense pointed the whole world toward the incompetence and corruption in the Canton police department.

[@hnraj9441]

Or at least at the attention it brought.

[@Alabanzas159]

He is funny he says we collected evidence. What evidence? Erasing videos

[@Fifi_Is_My_Name-O]

Alan Jackson didn't need to bring a lunch today... he had Trooper Proctor for lunch!

[@caroline-brisbane8577]

He was full from the grilling in the am before lunch.

[@rebeccaglasgow1324]

I have never been so disgusted with the treatment of Ms. Reed, as Proctor spoke of her. He has a wife, maybe a daughter, wonder how he would feel if someone treated them that way

[@hnraj9441]

The worst part for me is how soon into the "investigation" he decided to hate her. The rest is awful and wrong, but the immediate jump to conclusions based primarily (imo) on Jen's version of things is what discredits the investigation.

[@Julia-uh4li]

I'd imagine he's married to a mean girl as well, so she probably isn't offended by what he's said. The kid or kids, as well. To answer your question though, he'd probably do things that are quite illegal if he found out someone spoke about his daughter the same way he did about Karen. I would hate to live in the same town as that group. They're vile.

[@KayD]

​@@Julia-uh4liHis sister seems to be the mean girl. The 'she knew what she signed up for' comment after procter said his wife was alone with the children for so long.

[@PartanBree]

That massive pause after Proctor was asked if he investigated anyone who might have had motive/means/opportunity spoke VOLUMES

[@judithmcgill3913]

It's amazing how shut his open mind was

[@lukerobeson9957]

Imagine if the Albert and Higgins didn’t re home their phones… I bet they would look just like Procters

[@hnraj9441]

It all comes back to jen fing mccabe. Her story was all proctor needed for evidence.

[@hnraj9441]

Nevermind that John looked beat up, that didn't fit jen's narrative & Karen couldn't have beat him up so it was disregarded. Jen said John hadn't come in the house, so he didn't come into the house. But he doesn't think he was conflicted and wants us to believe this was a fair and neutral investigation.

[@JaimeUsey]

No... I'd say force Proctor to be in a room with Clhoe posing as a stranger for about 5-10 minutes.....

[@melissacoulter708]

But the “taillight” pieces would have been visible to ANYONE in the house that night!! Bright red against the white snow yet no one saw any of the million pieces that were collected!?

[@saradf4890]

And several people drove by that area where JO was supposedly on the lawn and no one saw him! How do you completely lose one's peripheral vision?

[@Lynn-vy9xr]

I just can’t wrap my head around the fact that we have more evidence that it was snowing then we have of this crime 🤦‍♀️

[@JRay.R]

Wait…when did they say it was snowing…? ❄️ 🤔 😂

[@Lynn-vy9xr]

@@JRay.R 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@clareofford6306]

Proctor is about to say that he doesn't consider being married to his wife a relationship 😂

[@JulieeeB]

What if anything is a relationship? 😂

[@trisHa6666]

Although I feel for the OKeefes, the sight of his mother laughing when Jackson is reciting the vile comments made by proctor, is very disturbing.

[@astrialindah2773]

I've seen a lot of comments like yours, I didn't see her do it but to think that she did is really disgusting! I wonder how she gets along with Paul's wife?

[@courtneyjohnson8407]

I agree. She lost a lot of empathy. She has continued to do this and should be warned she can get kicked out of the court room.

[@mombear5116]

Proctor claimed he did not interview Colin until 2023 because Colin left the house before John arrived. So why did he interview Colin's parents, Julie and Chris Albert, 12 days after John died - when they were not at the house AT ALL that night?

[@myquest666420]

I think they were at the bar when Karen and John were there

[@mombear5116]

@@myquest666420 I thought about that. . . But then why didn't he interview Caitlin Albert (also at the bar AND at the house) until July 2023? I think it is worth mentioning in closing argument to point out Proctor's "investigation" appearing to be more of a "getting stories straight" cover-up than a "fact finding" process.

[@myquest666420]

@@mombear5116oh yeah, you’re absolutely right. That’s why I believe he was there talking to them. But I’d just imagine that would’ve been his answer if he was asked.

[@JRay.R]

Excellent catch!

[@LauraJReicher]

Thanks so much for the gifted membership !!! Unemployed and ill at the moment. I have celiacs, IBS, a dizziness issue, and ADHD and I walk proudly with Karen! FKR👏👍

[@kathybechtol5889]

May we rehome Proctor?

[@MrsCCake]

😂😂 😂

[@bathingcatsonacloudyday]

But far away from Chloe, please.

[@JRay.R]

Consider him rehomed!

[@KatieFlynnBrandt]

I bet he wishes he rehomed a lot of things before today…

[@obsessedwiththetruth7016]

Up to the end of the proctor testimony- the audacity of the see you next Tuesday to thank the jurors! Intimidation much

[@susanharrington8715]

exactly!

[@BlessedInTX248]

This makes no sense to me?🤔

[@beachgal2]

Just showed his true colors to the Jurors. Very scary & alarming.

[@MLA56]

Lame attempt at trying to look like a decent person.

[@obsessedwiththetruth7016]

@@MLA56 yep and the “thank you jury for delivering justice, you’ve got this, find her guilty, we are on the same side, both fighting for justice” vomit vomit vomit vomit vomit

[@AshleighGOz]

Karen’s stare down of Proctor as he walked out at the lunch break. ICONIC

[@kdid271]

I would love for the defense to ask for a dismissal of all charges immediately based upon the fact the Proctor never went into the house and never properly interviewed the Alberts and everyone in the home that night. Really horrible investigation. I can only imagine how many innocent people go to jail because of assholes like this!

[@karmennash7479]

Exactly. Infuriating.

[@bdw7254]

He didn’t entertain any other possibilities. Even when Karen said that he was beat up. That’s should have been their cue to look into that as well as their guilt because they knew they’d need to go to trial

[@mininjas]

I think they can petition for dismissal after the prosecution rests

[@jjgirl3715]

They always ask after the prosecutions case. I doubt it would be granted though. If they found probable cause to take it to trail and that was accepted by the court it is very rarely overturned.

[@DegrassiInstantStar]

Watched thislive at work, and am APPALLED at how much worse Proctor's cross was in comparison to what we were made to believe. And thank you, Emily, for being there for us Law Nerds, and it's also helping me spread the word of this case and your streams to those in my life!!! And the look on Karen's face when Proctor discussed him wishing she'd un-alive herself was heartbreaking, and then seeing Mrs. O'Keefe mock Yanetti really pisses me off, too.

[@amandameekhael]

John’s mom keeps laughing every time Jackson mentioned those texts. She won’t be laughing when she hears NOT GUILTY.

[@carlamabry6944]

I saw that😡 they deserve no justice

[@hnraj9441]

​@@carlamabry6944 They do deserve justice. And I can't hold it against the family for believing what they have been told about this case. I've heard that jen cozied up to John's mom after the fact, so that conniving manipulator has been in her ear this whole time. And her son was a cop. She's going to want to believe in the cops. Believe that they'd look out for her son and honor him after he's gone. That much cognitive dissonance is hard to get past. Especially at her age and with all the grief she's lived through. She might never be able to see the truth. Or maybe eventually she will. I have more hope for his brother though. I could be wrong but I feel like maybe he's starting to have a few doubts.

[@Woeiswhoa]

I have been scouring the comments for a comment about his mom. Did you see what she did at 5:01:06? I know I should feel bad for her, but all I could think was, “Wtf is wrong with you?”

[@MShaiqable]

@@Woeiswhoa It looked like she was doing that at Yannetti as he was walking up to the court right after Proctor accused Yannetti of being at his wife's school yesterday or something

[@MShaiqable]

Were they laughing yesterday because I went back through to try to find where they laughed and I didn't see it?

[@jenabeal3219]

Had to be replay crew for the second part of the day and just got to weather reports. 😂 Way to go Lally! Between excessive testimony, multiple pictures and videos where I could see it with my own eyes and now the official weather reports, you have convinced me beyond a reasonable doubt that it was snowing!! ❄️

[@deang8017]

"If you ordered Kevin Albert not to look at the recording and your orders are always followed then why was it necessary to conduct the interview in the conference room?". DID YOU ORDER THE CODE RED!!!!!!!!!

[@trisHa6666]

You can’t handle the truth !

[@GenZedsMother]

YOU’RE GODDAMNED RIGHT I DID! - Proctor Hahahaha

[@ambergerber5162]

​@@GenZedsMotherI was actually waiting for a jack Nicholson moment like that. 😂😂😂 considering this is like a movie about police corruption. At this point there is so much crap that even if she did do it, which I doubt, it doesn't matter because you can't wade through the crap enough to get to what really happened.

[@heatheryates4105]

Loved hearing you on with Karson & Kennedy my favorite morning show!!!!😊

[@sarahhakesmusic]

I’m pissed today. How dare the state drag John O’Keefe’s family through this mess.

[@Christine__D]

Mr. O'Keefe looked devastated and heartbroken today. There will never be justice for his son.

[@carlamabry6944]

They are sitting there laughing! I’m disgusted by their actions!

[@courtneyjohnson8407]

​@carlamabry6944 exactly his mother has lost all my empathy with her daily actions and she technically should be warned or removed from the court room.

[@annabordelon6663]

His mother doesn't care about justice

[@sarahhakesmusic]

@@carlamabry6944 if she was laughing because she took pleasure on Proctor take cheap shots at Karen that’s pretty messed up, but she still gets some grace in my book. Even if Karen Read is innocent (which I believe that she is) it sounds like she and John O’Keefe may have had a somewhat toxic relationship and there have been some less than flattering things that have come out about Miss Read in regards to the way she treated John and the things she’s said about the niece and nephew. Mrs O’Keefe has lost her son, and the woman he was with before he died was possibly disingenuous and possibly disrespected him in the days leading up to his death. That alone would put a bad taste in her mouth for Karen. And seeing as we’re in the thick of this trial, I imagine she hasn’t had a chance to fully process her grief for the loss of her son. I’m sure there’s a lot of anger. Not to mention cop worship is real in this country, I imagine especially amongst folks whose fallen son was a cop and by all accounts a hero. I think it’s going to be extra hard for the O’Keefes to be reasoned out of trusting police with that much emotion tied to it all. I say all of this not knowing much of anything about the O’Keefe family. I just think that we do things in the throws of grief that we may not be proud of and I don’t want to be quick to cast judgment on a woman who is sitting through a mess of an eight week murder trial for her sons death

[@Badwolf143]

The timing of EBD's child and the pest control people was hilarious 😂

[@agent_ninety9]

Emily, not that we don't thoroughly enjoy your witty commentary, but I have to say the little inserts of Griffin were a breath of fresh air and added some happiness & sanity to the effery that we have been enduring together the last 8 weeks. We got the "bruh" comment too! Sums it up!

[@Lilli_Jewel]

Lally's strategy has been & IS to "run down the clock." No one will be able to convince me otherwise. Especially since the Defense asked the jury to "wait to hear their side" in their opening. Lally is hoping the judge is so angry about the schedule that she's short & rushes the Defense. That's the only thing that makes sense to why he continues to go over irrelevant & cumulative BS.

[@annamelvina216]

"Shame on you" - Alan Jackson

[@LexieJay00]

Mic drop 🎤 Epic moment! 👏🏾

[@simsadie14]

*June 12, 2024 I bet the jurors found it as cathartic as we did

[@user-xy7ui3wo6e]

What time did he say that? I hope I did not miss it! Awesome lawyer

[@annamelvina216]

@@user-xy7ui3wo6e At the end of his cross! Trust me you won't miss it!

[@simsadie14]

@@user-xy7ui3wo6ego to 4:57:00 but the preceding 3-4 minutes are good too

[@NerdyDogMom1]

I don’t know or have a relationship with this chick Stacey. We did work together on a podcast, we hangout laughing and joking together, occasionally, drink together and we text and call and go out socially, bump fists at the gym, ect….. Yep don’t know her or have a relationship. Stacey who?

[@JackiSueM]

😂😂😂

[@whocaresreallly5886]

We have 3 kids and have been married 17 years but i wouldn't say i know her

[@buntybaggins536]

Jackson lost patience with Bev at 5.51 with the 'it was a good one the first time' 😂

[@JackiSueM]

😂😂😂 they are both sick of her lol

[@hazelangus]

Alan Jackson - yelling, "SHE'S FUCKED" is great. He's making the tone of the texts so nasty, spiteful, downright gleeful, with a delightfully nasal, whiny mean girl tone to some of it. It's perfect. It's even more perfect when he pulls all of that back in and asks a question in his normal voice. If you've just been humiliated with your own words spat at you, and seconds later you've got the lawyer back, a disappointed dad quietly asking you if this was really necessary and did you truly mean that... I would have CRAWLED from that courtroom.

[@laurasalmon706]

UK replay crew 💜 thank you for covering this EDB . I still don't really understand how we got to this point. I really want to see the ' overwhelming' amounts of evidence that they have. Trouper P is a walking poster for how not to cop 🤦🏻‍♀️ I feel so sorry the JO s family, such a disrespectful and unprofessional investigation 😔

[@LovetheLed]

💜 my International LawNerds💜💜

[@gigisielaff]

Fact finders? Is that what Proctor calls this shat show investigation? Honestly, the shadiness of Proctor alongside his occasional willingness to own his egregious behavior whilst simultaneously defending the “integrity” of case is giving me flashbacks to Alex Murdaugh’s testimony.

[@warriorb_yotch]

You are absolutely incredible at breaking everything down and picking out the important points in testimony! Love ya girl 💜❤️💜❤️💜❤️💜❤️👍🏼

[@JWildberry]

I thought it was fitting for pest control to show up during Proctor's cross.

[@MrsCCake]

Brilliant! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@hnraj9441]

😂😂😂

[@karolpage4880]

😅😅😅

[@mellylo]

😂😂😂😂

[@bathingcatsonacloudyday]

I thought someone from the public or even the jury was taking things in their own hands 😂

[@miclynn78]

Had anyone checked to see if it was really snowing though....it could've been a beautiful, sunny day! Arrrrrrgggghhh!!! Love to the replay crew!

[@carliesmith3252]

At this stage I believe it if someone tells me they’re all lying and it was sunny

[@Amy_Stanmore]

Someone had a news bulletin picture LOL it would be funny if they called a meteorologist who advises the local news station 😂😅

[@candywhite511]

Czar​@@carliesmith3252

[@carliesmith3252]

I haven’t been emotional listening to this but I actually just burst into tears when Jackson said shame on you. I am so glad Karen can afford this defence, I don’t know the truth but I do know this so called upholder of the law is a disgrace.

[@carliesmith3252]

I do wish they’d have leaned in more in the gaps in investigation on cross. Like driving home the point that he’d decided this within 16 hours when all he had was Albert McCabe testimony and what?

[@JenBee1]

Yes!! Jackson has a 96% win rate & he lives in California. I am really curious how much he charges for this entire case. Freedom is priceless. It's sad that more people than not wouldn't be able to afford such a prestigious attorney. He's probably one of the best defense attorneys I've seen in action. You can feel his level of mad for his client, & all the nasty comments that were made about her. I truly beleive it's 100% genuine. ❤

[@Julia-uh4li]

​@@JenBee1 I caught earlier in the live chat that she's being charged $2,000,000.00 Now I'm not 100% sure that's correct, but, it was mentioned.

[@JenBee1]

@Julia-uh4li Wowzers! I wonder if you can make payments on that? Haha. 😄 Didn't Karen Reed have a go fund me account to help pay her legal fees? Do you know if she's out on bond by chance? I'm probably the only person who doesn't know much about this case. I'm learning about everything & forming an opinion right along with the jurors. There was so much drama surrounding this case in the beginning. I run from the drama & circus 🎪 like I'm running from a snake! 🏃🏼‍♀️💨 Haha 😄 Edit: Thanks for responding to my comment! It's very much appreciated! 🩷

[@adamjarvis7353]

he never thought the texts would make it here.

[@jeanwinders9556]

Thank you to the Feds and the Internal Affairs cops

[@Blackened30]

Its his own fault for using a personal phone for work purposes. Its a very stupid thing to do, and a guaranteed way that all of your personal life is going to be raked over the coals in detail.

[@candelalluvia1711]

I am living for EDB commentary. Thank you for bringing light along with sincere compassion for this entire case. It seems like you are one of Officer O’Keefes biggest advocates.

[@chicago1779]

I was gifted a membership!!! Thank you who ever you are I really appreciate it!!!!!!

[@LovetheLed]

Lucky Duck 💜💜💜

[@Stephanie-yp9vl]

Wicked Pissa my friend

[@LovetheLed]

@@Stephanie-yp9vl Wicked Tuna is one of my favorite shows 💜

[@Stephanie-yp9vl]

@@LovetheLed love that show

[@ruxandramariatonea6498]

Me too! 🥳

[@shelby477]

I'm so relieved all the witnesses and pictures in evidence weren't lying about the weather. That certainly clears up this entire case for me! 😂

[@maritzapierreaponte8538]

More than anytime before, I think everybody is afraid of the Albert family ESPECIALLY Big Brian like there's some kind of Mafia.

[@MimiDidi121]

There was a tweet from a reporter that was in the courtroom said that John’s mother was laughing and elbowing her son, or whomever was sitting next to her when they would call her charisma, uniqueness, nerve and talent. She thought it was funny when they talked about her shitting herself. It makes me really sad that they have turned that hard on Karen. Part of me, understands it if they really believe she murdered their son, but what scares me is, his mom and dad have been together for years. It seems his dad doesn’t hate Karen. I was told by someone who was in the court that he sat with Karen’s family one day, and hasn’t been back to court since. I have no way of knowing, but it scares me that this may be causing friction in a relationship. That would make this doubly sad.

[@bathingcatsonacloudyday]

I would like to think that maybe it was a moment to relieve stress for Mrs O'Keefe. I don't think at this point the family can know for sure that Karen killed John. Paul, his brother, has changed his disposition these last couples weeks.

[@carlamabry6944]

I saw it and I’m disappointed disgusted by their actions! All 5 of the front row was laughing!

[@carlamabry6944]

All of them were laughing especially when dumb proctor was talking about Yannetti

[@esindirik4447]

timestamp? everyone says she laughed no one gives a timestamp.

[@KayD]

She won't be laughing when the verdict comes in, nor when proctor is stacking shelves at the grocery store 😏😒 karma always comes around

[@MoonDragon1]

The most chilling is John was a friend of the people that lived at the house. They knew and not one person wanted to come out of the house?

[@karolpage4880]

Replay crew from NH. I am not surprised that 1 juror is down. I am almost so so done with this case but I've been here since the beginning so I have to see it through now. I can't imagine how the real jurors are feeling about all of this nonsense! Thank you EDB

[@mommahype]

Never had to watch replay….TIME STAMPS ARE BAE!!!💜💜💜

[@mariannesouza8326]

Scorched earth cross-examination! 👏🏼👏🏼 I can’t believe Proctor thanked the jury, as he stepped down. Does he think that helps fix his image, somewhat, with them?’ 😂