MACALLAN 12 SHERRY OAK vs GLENDRONACH 12

[@balab7721]

dear sir You share great information. But Please do not provide background music to your video. It disturbs listening to videos. And if you want to play music, play it in low volume.

[@sanjeevarora7909]

Love your reviews and the passion with which you do them... God Bless

[@Houman7]

Here in U.S. Mac 12 comes at 43% and I tell you it’s still not as good as GlenDronach 12 and it’s twice as expensive. If you can find those old bottles they are amazing at 43% but really hard to find and quite expensive. Recently found 2015 bottle for 100$ and it’s amazing but for the same money I can get better bottles. Sadly Mac quality has dropped noticeably and many enthusiasts stopped buying them.

[@MaltActivist]

Unfortunately you're right. Old school Macallans were a thing of beauty. They lost their way trying to become mainstream.

[@Snikkari]

The Macallan has handpicked sherry casks ... what is the alternitive .... like machine picked, or foot picked or .. just tell me.

[@ironmantran]

Instant LIKE #48 : glad to have found yr channel. Great comparison. . . always wanted to know...

[@MaltActivist]

Thank you for stopping by! And please subscribe.

[@jeffmill999]

I have both of these.. My Glendronachs are from early 2016...Billy Walker was still there. I bought a liter today for $57usd. I bought The Macallan 12 sherry cask just to give it a try...I really like it. $73.50usd...700ml... I give the victory to Glendronach 12.. But, I like the Mac a lot more than you do.

[@Lester_DorEes]

Nice video! Can you see if Macallan states that it’s chill filtered on the bottle’s label? At 40% I doubt very much that it’s non chill filtered but there have been claims that they don’t. I’m skeptical.

[@MaltActivist]

Doesn't say anything on the bottle. I suspect they chill filter some (travel retails mostly). I dont know specifically about this one.

[@krishnar3493]

You said it right there, that Macallan is WEAK. 43% US version would fare much better but prices outside of US are ridiculous

[@MaltActivist]

True. Very true.

[@kallumama75]

Great review and comparison...cheers!

[@MaltActivist]

Thank you!

[@zhongminfan6367]

In Australia, Macallan 12yo Single Cask costs 30% more than Glendonach 12yo, and definitely not 30% better. Besides, Glendonach is unchill filleted (maybe) and natural coloured with extra 3% ABV. Which one is the pick? No brained.

[@MaltActivist]

I agree 100%

[@davidowen2834]

Good comparison review, liked it. It might have been a close run but the macallan is probably more than double the price of the Glendronach. Ahh and that word smoooth, yes I know where your coming from. Cheers.

[@MaltActivist]

haha SMOOTH. tell me about it.

[@welshtoro3256]

Wonderful review and comparison. I completely agree with you conclusion. Cheers my friend. WT

[@MaltActivist]

Cheers WT. Thanks for stopping by.

[@christophershreiner5114]

I just matched these up last night but the Macallan is now 43% so it was an even match up. I felt the nose on Macallan 12 was far superior. However, the taste of GlenDronach 12 absolutely blew away the Macallan. Not because GD was just so amazing but because Macallan was so lacking. I didn’t pick up much of anything interesting in the Macallan even with a few drops of water. The GD had more flavors burst out with a few drops. IMO, skip The Macallan and buy two GlenDronach bottles.

[@MaltActivist]

Thanks for sharing!

[@VICTORMacalintalakaIAN]

Great review! Good enlightenment to be informed :)

[@MaltActivist]

Thank you! Thanks for stopping by and if you haven't subscribed please do - I'm doing a lot more videos in the future. Cheers.

[@scottyblog]

The Macallan certainly ain’t what it used to be.

[@MaltActivist]

Sadly, I would have to agree.

[@Joop175]

Turn the mic up bro

[@MaltActivist]

Hi! Yes, thank you for that feedback. Have fixed the vol issue in subsequent videos.

[@richardgillette5759]

The music doesn’t have to be so LOUD

[@MaltActivist]

You're right. And I've fixed it in all subsequent videos. Thank you.

[@apotravel9583]

Great video but very bad sound 😢

[@MaltActivist]

apologies -- this was one of my earlier ones. Sound is good now!

[@vangstr]

Please get rid of the background music. Don’t need it.

[@MaltActivist]

Fixed