Macallan 12 battle (Sherry Oak, Double Cask, Fine Oak) Whisky in the 6

[@josephsaims1251]

I like how your truthful about your reviews

[@andrewyew4700]

Very accurate review. The Double Cask and the Sherry Cask are head to head depending on individual's preference, both are strong on Sherry. The nose of the Sherry Cask is much stronger than the Double but the palate of the Double may be superior. The distant third is the Fine Oak (or Triple Cask) which contains sulphur. I was shocked by how good the Double was as I thought nothing could beat 12 years of Oloroso in European Oak. Oh and Elijah Craig is really nice too.

[@seanwelch8870]

Great battle! I saw your El Dorado 15 review, would love a review of the 12- nobody I know drinks the 15. Would also love for you to try Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva rum! It's a little sweeter but very on par with El Dorado and arguably smoother.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

I like to do rum purchases in the summer. I'll definitely keep an eye out for Diplomatico. Cheers.

[@bongboyz6468]

The double cask is my first Macallan (and my first premium scotch, I'm a novice), I gotta say I love it. It's very smooth. Every time I drink a glass I pick up a new note.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

It’s definitely smooth. Perhaps too light for my liking.

[@bongboyz6468]

@@WhiskyInThe6 that's good to hear for me. My palettes not developed enough to try out the more flavorful stuff so I think I won't be disappointed for when I do :)

[@Joop175]

Which is smoother and sweeter? I want to buy my first Macallan. Great review.

[@keithpetersen560]

W6, although I've never had the 12 yr fine oak and its been over 10 years since I've had the 12 yr sherry oak, I would probably agree with your assessment. I recently bought and finished the 12 DC and that was very good for $60... It was better than the Mac Ed 2 when price is figured in. Great review

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Keith Petersen thanks buddy. I really enjoy the DC. Great stuff. I recommend giving the Sherry oak a shot though. It's really good as well. Bigger nose on it.

[@keithpetersen560]

W6, I will probably pick up a bottle sometime. There are so many on my list to buy, that I have to prioritize them. Such hard choices.

[@seangalloway4179]

Trenny and C coaster? Saw the Mac 12 Fine Oak in Mexico, but had now way to get it home. I was bummed since the 15 is one of my favorites. Interested to try the Double Cask, but waiting for a local bar to pick it up and sample it that way.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

They are fellow whisky reviewers. I highly recommend the Double Cask. Too bad you didn't grab the Fine Oak.

[@seangalloway4179]

Whisky In The 6 I have my own set of coaster, too! Good guys. I'll keep an eye out for the Double Cask.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Nice. They are.

[@dennismhac23]

I agree. Macallan Double Cask is less bitter and very smooth compared to Original Macallan 12 on the palate. I will be buying the biggest bottle!!!

[@WhiskyInThe6]

+dennismhac23 it good stuff.

[@josephsaims1251]

The Whiskey Tasting I agree with you guys

[@brandonduckworth8836]

Nice Review Rob.. I just picked up the Mac 12 Sherry 43% from Total Wine for.... $46.99. I couldn't believe the price. It goes for $55-$75 at other stores in my area (Orange County, California). As long as the price stays under $50, its a good deal I feel. The Mac 12 DC I had a sample of, and I really enjoyed it. Sweeter and The finish was a little nuttier, but shorter. Could be do to the 40% ABV it had. I wouldn't mind picking up the DC, but it is about $55. The Glendronach 12 which i have, and is excellent, goes for around $57. I'm going to keep stocking up on the Mac 12 Sherry 43% so long as it stays under $50. I'm guessing there is just a ton of stock here in the States. Even Walgreens has it lol. I'm just amazed at the price difference VS other areas/countries. TWE sells it for $78 and it's 40% one. When i got to the register I was waiting for a higher price, thinking it was miss marked haha. Nope. $46.99. Hell of a deal. Cheers.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Brandon Duckworth that's an incredible deal. I need to load up on Mac 12 the next time I'm in the US. We get the Double Cask here but at a lower abv.

[@brandonduckworth8836]

haha yea man, heck mise well move to the States, no LCBO and can ship from TWE/MOM. Altho, it is pretty crazy in Cali lately lol. I'm hoping Macallan comes out with 15/18/21/25 yr Double Cask. I emailed them asking, no reply yet. I think they will though, i mean the 12 DC is selling so well.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Brandon Duckworth they just might. I'll email the Ambassador.

[@brandonduckworth8836]

Whisky In The 6 awesome, thanks for inquiring.

[@jeremyh4710]

I'm a big fan of the 12 Sherry. The Double Cask reminds of Balvenie 12 Double Wood a lot. I don't think the 12 Fine Oak was ever released in the US market, or if it was, it's now discontinued there. I haven't seen a single bottle anywhere online (except in the UK).

[@WhiskyInThe6]

I saw the Fine Oak in Florida a few years back. The Sherry oak has really grown on me.

[@jeremyh4710]

In my opinion the Macallan 12 is the best 12 year old sherried whisky on the market. Ive seen it as low as $45 USD, which is great value. I wonder why we don't see the Fine Oak 12 in the US now.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Jeremy H not sure. Should have had my brother pick me one up. It was at the same time that he got me the Sherry oak. I wasn't there personally but he took pictures of what was available.

[@jkim010100]

Look for 15 Year Fine Oak. I never saw the 12 either.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Joo Kim must not be remembering correctly. This was three or more years ago. I definitely could be mistaken.

[@foodquig]

Will the ECBP be making it to BC and Vancouver Island? I don't care if it costs $200 after hearing Bart singing about it... I'd like to save myself two ferry crossings and a round trip to Total Wine in Seattle...

[@WhiskyInThe6]

foodquig I'm not sure. Ontario is only getting 99 bottles.

[@foodquig]

Only 99 bottles for the entire province? That's a tease...

[@WhiskyInThe6]

I'll begrudgingly and uncontrollably buy one if presented the opportunity. Not happy about the price.

[@foodquig]

I concur.

[@lyacoubian]

The Fine Oak 12 is not available here on the West Coast.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

It’s not widely available. Hard to find in most countries.

[@peterwhite507]

I see that 500 ml bottle of Dillon's Rye in the back, shame they released it at 43% when the last release was cask strength. $40 for a 1/2 bottle of young rye versus $40 for a Lot 40. Let me know if it is worth the purchase.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

peter white I think it's worth it. It's hard to be a Small Batch mom and pop Distillery in this country.

[@peterwhite507]

Well, the bottle is really cool, I will give it a go.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

It's a summer dram. Light, sweet and grassy.

[@WhiskyWhistle]

Good job Rob. I'm sure that fine

[@gman5986]

Thanks Rob for the great review. I really enjoy your honest straightforward reviews. I just purchased and tasted now in 1/2020 the MaCallan Edition No. 5 and was very disappointed by the lackluster flavor and off putting alcohol burn of a very young whisky. I'm hoping it will open up to a better profile after the neckpour is gone and some oxidation occurs.At $140 I have to say I was very disappointed and can buy much better whiskeys at that price point. Have you tried this one yet and what was your impression?

[@WhiskyInThe6]

I honestly really liked the Mac 5 brother. Hope yours gets better after some time open.

[@gman5986]

@@WhiskyInThe6 That's what I am hoping for. I have noticed that some bottles get better in a short time while others like my Dickel Bottle in Bond have taken up to 6 months to really shine. Whats been your experience??

[@WhiskyInThe6]

G man literally no formula. Some are great throughout. Others need a little and others a lot. No way to predict really.

[@gman5986]

​@@WhiskyInThe6 It's so crazy and interesting. Just learning over the last two years. On another subject how do you balance this whisky hobby and health regarding what's healthy in terms of drinking every day and how many ounces or spacing days. or just on the weekends.

[@jeffcoole741]

ECBP is getting to be closer to $70 or a bit more in the US now in many places, but still a far cry from $150. 😳

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Jeff Coole ya it's stupid. I'm probably going to stay away just for principle.

[@douglaspettit2456]

I like that your reviews cause they aren't full of hyper BS that the regular drinker doesn't understand....

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Douglas Pettit thanks buddy. I try to make them to the point as much as possible. Cheers buddy.

[@douglaspettit2456]

I really like the 12 year sherry cask. Waiting for your full review on it.

[@josephsaims1251]

Douglas Pettit I agree with you whiskey in the 6

[@SuperMisterbond]

Hey Rob, few years ago i read that the 12 YO Sherry is discontinued, but they are still all over Europe, Asia and now America as well? So the news was fake? Was it just to get people to buy them?

[@WhiskyInThe6]

I think what happened was that there was a shortage. It never fully stopped being produced. It was pulled from many ordering lists around the world to ensure that there was enough stock for the Asian and American markets.

[@pncKing]

Mac 12 double cask is not for me. The ginger and citrus 🍊 is over baring and leaves you with a short and dry finish.

[@jeffcoole741]

I have to admit that I think I'm starting to like the Macallan Double Cask better than Balvenie Doublewood.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Jeff Coole the DC is great stuff.

[@Seattle206723]

Read the comments and there's no 12 fine oak in the USA. The 15 Yr Fine Oak sells for about $89.00 around here. I've had the other ones myself. I think there good :) Shared on Twitter ma man..

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Seattle206723 interesting. Could have sworn my brother sent me a pic of one while in Florida a few years back to see what I wanted. I remember it being $15 more than the Sherry 12.

[@WhiskyWhistle]

Oops fine oak is nice - just got the 15 which is my second favourite Macallan. Sounds like your boy is having a good time haha! Cheers bud Mark

[@WhiskyInThe6]

WhiskyWhistle the 15 is really nice. Something is wrong with this sample of Fine Oak 12. Nothing like the rest I've tried.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

WhiskyWhistle my son is always up to no good lol.

[@gustavoortega746]

Why does the sherry cask have a weird robbery after taste I dont like it

[@WhiskyInThe6]

+Gustavo Ortega there’s a touch of peat.

[@gustavoortega746]

@@WhiskyInThe6 Dude I cannot drink this whiskey, it tastes like how a condom smells. I just dumped it to the trash, keep up the reviews

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Gustavo Ortega lol there’s a new tasting/smelling note I haven’t heard yet.

[@sd3gunner]

I sure do miss your old set.... 😭 you just dont seem as happy like you are in you older stuff.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Travis H I’m still happy. You’re right though, something ain’t right. I’ll find my grove. Thanks for caring Travis.

[@jamesduprey2719]

American version. 40%ABV.

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Odd that they did it that way.