Mahler: Symphony No. 3 - Radio Philharmonic Orchestra - Live Classical Music HD

[@ScottESchmidt]

Mahler 2, 3, and 8 never fail to produce tears...

[@juergensteiniger5118]

Das Werk Gustav Mahlers hat in den Niederlanden, wenn ich mich recht erinnere, eine große Tradition. Daher freue ich mich außerordentlich über diese schöne Aufnahme der dritten Sinfonie. Es macht Freude den Musikern bei ihrem engagierten Spiel zuzuschauen. Dank auch an die gelungene Bildregie.

[@dennisschwartzentruber3204]

My favourite Mahler symphony ; it has everything one could musically want !

[@Happysongkla]

日本東京からです。もうじき日本も夏です、夏が来る前にマーラー三番を映像で聴こうと思い聴いています。 CDのような音の分離がないので本当に演奏会場にいるような気分です。素晴らしい演奏をありがとうございます。

[@jaywalker552]

i performed in this years ago… i was in the children’s chorus of greater dallas for 7 years… i think this was the first performance i did with the full DSO symphony orchestra… beautiful.

[@michaelpatterson2955]

The entire work is magnificent, but the dreamingly beautiful final half-hour movement is worth its weight in musical gold. It stirs my heart, calms my mind, and causes me to look upward.

[@antoniocostanza570]

Condivido confermo con lei anch'io

[@kendanziger8072]

Thanks to everyone involved. A privilege to watch.

[@karlheinzkirchmann6469]

Das ist eineMahlerSinfonie. Mahler macht sein Seelelenleben zum Gegenstand seines sinfonischen Ausdrucks. Dieser Ausdruck erlaubt der Interpretation grosse und breite Spielräume. Insofern hören wir hier unterschiedliche Interpretationen von anima und cor. Jede Interpretation hier ist ein Meisterwerk. Kritik verweise ich in dieKathegorie WICHTIGTUEREI. Leute die nicht ansatzweise den riesigen Mahlerschen Kosmos begreifen,

[@jean-christopheMiquel-ef3ur]

J agree with that.

[@MicoDeTube]

A beautiful rendering of 3.

[@PhilipFClark]

One of the most resonantly powerful live recordings of this work; every note lives on its own, and the entire recording is captured in vivid detail. So happy to have listened and watched this magnetic performance!

[@brsbku]

indeed!

[@erictetrault6637]

Certainly one of the best 3 I have heard.

[@IvanGreindl]

Let's admire the Maestro!!! Hundred minutes of concentration do not affect his smile. What a performance! The orchestra, choirs and soloist are just wonderfull too.

[@mudgebauer]

|He looks a lot like Gary Busey.

[@lucienr7931]

1:34:17 I like how the clarinetist looks up like: "is this heaven?" Well, he's right. Great peformance!

[@jobvink]

0:00:00 Kräftig. Entschieden. 0:33:50 Tempo di Minuetto, seht Mäßig, ja nicht eilen! 0:43:08 Comodo. Scherzando. Ohne Hast. 1:01:11 Sehr Langsam. Misterioso. Durchaus ppp. 1:09:50 Lustig im Tempo und keck im Ausdruck. 1:13:59 Langsam. Ruhevoll. Empfunden.

[@antoniocostanza570]

Condivido confermo con lei anch'io

[@sokanet9]

Just Great Performance. Thank You All The Members of this Orchestra~~~!!!!!!!

[@kunzklingsor9156]

Very warm conductor, no wonder love and smiles are in the air... Bravooooooooooo

[@eduhbas]

The best work from Mahler, in my opinion...

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

That is the the great thing about Mahler. All his works are his best. It totally depends on the mood one is in. Sometimes I think it is the 6th. Then for a long time I was convinced it is the 9th. Then I come back to the 1st. Then I keep on being swept away by the 2nd. And then I return to the 3rd, and say to myself: "Nothing beats this". Only to fall in love with the 5th a month later. It keeps shifting and shifting.

[@leslieackerman4189]

At the time of composing Mahler came with these tiles in the manner of symphonic poem. He dropped them at the time of publication: I. "Pan Awakes, Summer Marches In" (itself as long as a Mozart or Beethoven symphony!) II. "What the Flowers in the Meadow Tell Me" III. "What the Animals in the Forest Tell Me" IV. "What Man Tells Me" (mezzo-soprano solo) V. "What the Angels Tell Me" (children choir, mezzo & no strings) VI. "What Love Tells Me" I think they still work.

[@voranartsirisubsoontorn9010]

Wind blows soft and hard wonderfully here, wow.

[@herculesharalambides2040]

What a great reading of the 3rd. Absolutely delightful. Compliments!

[@mirtaholz8120]

Incredible feeling of being transported to a magical adventure through glowing forest/ jungle... Mesmerizing

[@alys6023]

A beautiful piece which brings people into connection with their souls.

[@fayneplaysdrums]

The last note was spectacularly spot on!

[@cmw9876]

Played this on the off chance it would be well recorded because they're used to playing with microphones for broadcasting. Yes, they are. This was a hundred odd minutes well spent, a great introduction to Mahler and a stunning production. My thanks.

[@joeppeeters6222]

Dreams come true when there are eight horns

[@suhuani9449]

Joehoep Pjeter

[@newueelnavmip]

What about 8 pauken? :) and two players!!

[@HLsch]

And those double basses!

[@johnvaughan7096]

Say what you like, how good is youtube bringing us so many great versions of this magnificent symphony? I've listened to Lan Shui, Bernstein, Dudamel, Andres Estrada, Abbado, Rattle, Barbirolli, Jansons, Haitink and both Jukka and Esa Pekka. All the orchestras they led were brilliant although Jukka needs a little passion I believe. However, love them all as I do, I have never had such a big tear in my eye as I had listening to these wonderful people. Comparisons are odious but, if there is a more magnificent symphony than Gustav's number 3, please let me know!

[@starryepidemic2532]

Rachmaninoff symphonic dances is my personal favourite that too the particular performance of oslo phil

[@anandsamuel1978]

Symphony no. 2. However my impression is that all Mahler's 9 symphonies are magnificent!

[@DLCaster]

Outstanding! A fabulous work very well played, indeed.

[@reijoturtiainen5067]

This is perfect.

[@jeffbawden7901]

I haven't listened to this for 50 yrs

[@angelalfonsorojasquiroz5936]

Que sinfonía, como lo dice su autor, la trama al igual que la naturaleza es impredecible,armoniosa, exuberante y melancólica.

[@navrozelalkaka8457]

So utterly beautiful

[@ruicao9805]

1:31:46. Amazing dark sound by the lady.

[@creamcheeserecords]

Bravissimi tutti !! auch Mahler ist sehr bravo !!!

[@jean-marcrodrigues3673]

Une interprétation enthousiasmante. La puissance et la grâce.

[@barryguerrero7652]

Stenz is among the best Mahler conductors out there and hardly anybody knows it. Maybe when Muti retires from Chicago, they might get lucky (and smart) and grab Stenz.

[@leestamm3187]

As a long time CSO fan, I think Stenz would be great. Muti can't retire soon enough to suit me.

[@rudolfschmid5981]

What a great alto soloist: Tamara Mumford - fantastic

[@wwemario12345]

trombone solo is at 7:28

[@joeppeeters6222]

Nothing better for Chrismas

[@samnelson8280]

Joehoep Pjeters Agreed.

[@jeffbawden7901]

Beautiful

[@jfranbazaga]

Me encanta esta 3º Sinfonia de Mahler. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@grzegorzhincmann1547]

Widać i słychać doświadczenie z wyczuciem na prawdę wspaniała orkiestra 😁

[@jeffbawden7901]

So powerful

[@ljiljanastanic9076]

W o n d e r f u l performance!

[@ricardoallendw292]

Ejecucion espectacular...

[@nanard111]

remarquablement filmé..et enregistré ! :)

[@MultiPhanthomas]

Mahler was able to encounter heaven, before he was even part of it..

[@MDzmitry]

I love seeing how into the process the conductor is, 31:25 for example

[@giginorman1955]

May my heart sing to thee o Lord.

[@Discovery_and_Change]

22:57 24:19 Intro again

[@patrickcardiff7811]

This is a relatively quiet and fine version of 3. The ensemble is very tight, the alto Ms. Mumford seems proper for the strength of the lower registers required, although she mispronounces some of the German, which seems "fresh" for some reason, and the kids are alright. I suppose much depends on the sound recording, but the tones are crisp and bright coming from a smaller scaled orchestra, which is all to the glory of the players. This is one for the history books, definitely. And thanks to AVROTROS for putting it up.

[@christiaandhooghe]

Patrick Cardiff I have to agree about the alto, she has a great voice. She sounds more to me like a mezzo then a contralto. But still very good.

[@cmw9876]

It is indeed a fine recording. The orchestra and others know afterwards that they "nailed it!" We live in the most amazing times. My thanks to all.

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

@@christiaandhooghe There have been odder choices. Helga Dernesch on the Solti recording for example. A dramatic soprano singing this? And it still works.

[@delopera6044]

Astounding.

[@jsuzuki308]

GOOD

[@quinto34]

01:01:47 'O Mensch'..

[@VisiontheMindNumber]

1:09:52 is when the children's choir comes in

[@insertpseudonym5311]

hi friends! forgive me if this is a dumb question (i'm pretty new to mahler and i don't know much about this piece at all) but is that an 1812 overture reference in the trumpets around 4:40?

[@1tbo]

I'm not hearing one, and I can't think of a reason why there would be one.

[@serei_oque_serei]

💛💛💛💛💛💛💛💛💛💛

[@lesgibson969]

1:14:00 buradan itibaren dinle

[@apollosaturnv17iss75]

Can’t believe the audience at the end of the symphony. It seemed, not one knew when the song ended... and I think that was outrageous! For an orchestra who was able to place sounds in my ears and make me tear up at times, there should have been a timely standing ovation.

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

What the hell? They were extremely attentive. Stenz kept his arms up. He didn't want them to break out into applause right after the sound was over he wanted them to remain silent for a moment. And they waited until he lowered his arms. Anyone breaking into that silence would have behave like an oaf.

[@dsdfsdfdsfsdfds3800]

she has a very good voice.

[@vesteel]

4th movement

[@davidkelly5343]

Bliss.

[@antoniocostanza570]

Compositore Gustav Mahler periodo tardo romantico 1860 Repubblica Ceca - 1911 Vienna , nove sinfonie scritte composte

[@istamptimes8112]

00:04 33:50 43:07 1:01:08 1:09:50 1:13:56

[@andrewnguyen1220]

45:29 what

[@aspencrest]

I think someone dropped something in the drum section. What is your guess?

[@bernardlaurent4237]

Wie is deze fluit spele naast de hobospele ?

[@uff7733]

0:00

[@aenyx_]

32:12

[@uff7733]

31:00

[@liliewhite]

1:09:48

[@uff7733]

1:23:00

[@sueallot8292]

1:06:34 - is that John Bolton on double bass? Thought he was undercover in Iran or Venezuela. If he has taken to Mahler, then there is hope for the world. Trump next???

[@GeorgePiazza]

John Bolton should be used for the Mahler anvil - FFF. And someone please lock Trump in a room and play the 4th and 5th Movements 24/7 for a month. If the Alto soloist doesn't reach him (O mensch. O mensch. Gib Acht. Gib Acht.) perhaps the Knabenchor will awake some long suppressed ember of empathy.

[@ryan_cowan]

Trump will probably get caught listening to Wagner and then we'll have to suffer through everyone talking about Nazis for the millionth time in the last few years

[@krzem3532]

Do not involve Mahler in your dirty politics. Disgusting!

[@Dmichoacan]

lol. The Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra has a clarinet player that probably looks more like John Bolton.

[@jeffbawden7901]

Can go by

[@armandogonella2770]

U N G E N I O ! ! !

[@최진호-o6t]

우와~~~ 멋지다.

[@cmw9876]

☺YES!☺

[@jeffbawden7901]

Marina

[@jeffbawden7901]

Frightening how 50 yrs

[@김상동-e6f]

아름 답다

[@notaire2]

Klingt leider nicht so erregend wie die Aufführung derselben Sinfonie vom hr-Sinfonieorchester unter der Leitung von Andrés Orozco-Estrada.

[@TheMahlerfan]

+ notaire2 Da muss ich Ihnen Recht geben. Und was halten Sie von Mahler 3 mit Esa-Pekka Salonen mit dem Philharmonia Orchestra aus November 2017 ?

[@notaire2]

Danke für Ihre Zustimmung und nette Information. Ich will die Aufführung vom Philharmonia Orchestra auf KZbin finden.

[@notaire2]

Listening to the recent performance of Mahler's 3rd symphony led by Esa-Pekka Salonen, I feel it has the same problem as this performance. In a word, both performances are lacking in some kind of passion or energy which the performance by the hr-Sinfonieorchester has.

[@TheMahlerfan]

+ Notaire2 Danke für die Antwort. Bei beiden fehlt mir die "Wärme" und "Leidenschaft" von Andrés Orozco-Estrada, die in der Musik vorhanden ist, besonders im Finalsatz, wo Liebe spürbar wird.

[@cygilman6679]

I actually think that the Salonen performance on KZbin is one of the best I have heard. Salonen has an impeccable sense of balance, the sonorities blend and the voices come out perfectly. Mahler is by nature massive and emotional, and I would rather a beautiful and controlled sound than a conductor who happens to look more 'passionate.'

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

Beginning too slow. It may be "Kräftig" but it definately does not sound "entschieden".

[@papagen00]

I think this is Mahler's Worst symphopny if not the Most Boring, way too long at nearly 2 hours.

[@catholiccrusader5328]

Great performance but not the best Mahler's best; too repetitive.

[@pcardriff7278]

Actually this is an uncharacteristically bad version of three. Especially in the opening, it's ponderous and, when the brass loses tempo, cringeworthy, mistake-filled, almost laughable. They should have practiced much more before attempting this. I'm sure Mahler fans will be non-plussed, as this is not the way Mahler wanted it reproduced, sorry to say. Strange for an orchestra from Europe to be playing so slowly.

[@andrewtaylor9610]

Oh for goodness’ sake. No one cares about your opinion, so stop being so crass and boring.

[@markantioho7545]

I do not believe it is ponderous, or should I say slow. It seems that the other Mahler 3 postings on KZbin are about the same running time, in fact, this one is a little shorter than the average, or should I say faster. Tempo is a matter of interpretation and you either like it or do not. In any event, I am enjoying this recording.

[@jamestowmsn]

A somewhat uninspired performance I thought. Technically correct but lacking in emotion.

[@jeffbawden7901]

Beautiful

[@yvettekraft2371]

40:58

[@bearinthehouse7525]

1:08:12