맑고 깨끗한 목소리(*´∀`*)ゞ 닝닝(NINGNING)의 〈If I Ain't Got You〉♬ 아는 형님(Knowing bros) 303회 | JTBC 211023 방송

[@aviyolanda1026]

She's insanely good. SM really hit the jackpot with Ningning in their company

[@hwyh5392]

Ksw

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

@@hwyh5392 🤮🤮

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

yes I see Korean comments says that ningning lee so man Pic like pada from s.e.s

[@solandluna7771]

Not anymore my dear

[@unicornio5956]

@@solandluna7771 ? She’s still in SM

[@jayvlv3800]

Aside from the highnotes her low notes also sounds so good! She's definitely one of the best 4th gen main vocal

[@flaxencerise_]

Trueee. Thankfully we can hear more of her low notes from savage

[@danissegomez7953]

Yup her low notes are sexy! Hahaha

[@awesome8163]

@@danissegomez7953 yesss i thought its just me hehe. same same

[@zukogf2337]

annoying that most kpop stans think that automatically if U do high notes your an amazing vocalist but they forget about the low notes, riffs the runs, and the fact that ningning can ace all of them is amazing.

[@danissegomez7953]

@@zukogf2337 true

[@bruno_malta13]

Her mix and upper notes are nice, but her lowers are a masterpiece. Probably best female vocal on the lower notes.

[@winda-oy9vc]

Yeah

[@C_mon_jungwoo_solo]

헉 닝닝아 이번 머리색 너무 잘 어울려..... 닝닝이 맑은 순수한 초미녀 얼굴이 빨간머리보다 더 잘 보이는거같음 ㅜㅜ 화장도 더 연한 느낌이여서 더 애기같고 귀엽다

[@민우-w2e]

닝닝이 머리 건강에도 좋구 오래해도 안 질리는 색… 넘 좋앙

[@치킨위잉-w9z]

ㅇㅈ 너무 이쁨

[@부밍시스템어어-o4n]

ㅇㅈ이요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@gongminjilove]

빨간 머리가 최고인줄 알았는데 이번에는 뭔가 더 여리고 소녀같아서 더 좋음 ㅠㅠ 밀가루 맞을때 진짜 청순 했는ㄷ

[@so_ju_]

근데 포에버 검머도 너무 너무 예뻤음ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ진짜 닝깅이 갈머 검머 내 최애 머리ㅠㅠㅠ

[@aeiouttymklb1341]

the fact that she is still a rookie and already has this voice, what more in the coming years? with more experience, confidence and practices, damnnn she'll be like her SM seniors who are THE main vocalists of their generations

[@queenning28]

Yeah, especially consider that the distractions and nervousness of performing in front of a camera and live audience can have a BIG impact on live vocal. It’s not the same as singing at home or in studio. More experiences and confidence will definitely improve her singing even more in the future.

[@jokerxback2633]

She is not a beginner, she is a child artist in china

[@aeiouttymklb1341]

@@jokerxback2633 i know that☺ I mean rookie in the kpop industry😁 She may have had a lot of stage performances in China but the kpop industry is different because of the pressure of having the main vocal position and having a lot of eyes watching you. She is a child prodigy in the music industry but a rookie in Kpop😁

[@beezlegacy]

@@14121834 Better get your ears checked.

[@willa9880]

@@14121834 Hello Ningning is A vocal Godess u cant even compare her to Anyone

[@클레오빡돌아-g6o]

닝닝 진짜 맑고 투명한 부드러운 목소리...ㅠㅠㅠ 듣기 진짜 편함...귀 정화되는느끰.. 반면에 윈터는 진짜 딴딴하고 어떨땐 포근한 목소리랄까? 더 빠박 박힘 한 번 들으면 안잊히는 보컬음색...진짜 너무너무좋아ㅠㅠㅠ

[@kalenraj]

She’s definitely main vocalist material, every time she sings she’s amazes me

[@crystalcastle660]

Well she is the main vocal

[@bitchesproofbarbie]

@@성이름-c5j6q yes but we know Ningning was introduced as the main vocalist just because the trailer

[@bitchesproofbarbie]

@@성이름-c5j6q ok you are right, but Ningning is still the best vocalist in the group

[@crystalcastle660]

@@성이름-c5j6q ningning was introduced as the main vocalist by SM in the website SM global shop. Also in this program they mentioned that she is the main vocal. Check your facts.

[@jeffersongabriellopes8936]

ROSÉ OF BLACKPINK

[@S1LVERCLOUD]

*Ningning vocals are heavenly.* Her vocal range is insane. This girl has got beauty & talent both! 🤍 her voice is angelic~

[@boorave]

SM has such good vocalists

[@imogen07]

@@boorave The Chinese members of SM Entertainment is INSANE! Hope the upcoming boy band of SM will have Chinese members and also I had a dream where SM ENTERTAINMENT new boy band 8 member band had one Chinese member (born 2011) and he was the youngest in the band so maknae and damnnn he was so handsome it was like he came from the Anime world

[@boorave]

@@imogen07 damnn what if your dream comes true?

[@abieffendi]

@@imogen07 hope so, but Wayv aint even get a chance to shine tho 😅

[@imogen07]

@@boorave It's definitely coming true very soon, by the way you all excited for wen jun hui of Seventeen upcoming romance Chinese drama? Edit: Omg guys Another k-pop Chinese idol winwin of NCT doing a Chinese drama vampire one starting filming tomorrow!!!!

[@spaceships.s]

She can reach high notes easily but her lower range is so full and rich I love it

[@enolaholmes5709]

ningning coming to receive the title Best Vocalist

[@justhuman4817]

닝닝이 목소리 정말 좋다..

[@eulalia3468]

Please korean mys , support Ningning, don't ignore her cuz she's Chinese, sm is already pushing her aside

[@단비는핑크색]

@@eulalia3468 닝닝 목소리 좋다니까 뭔 이상한소리야…

[@eulalia3468]

@@단비는핑크색 특히 한국 사람들은 그녀의 재능을 무시하고 보컬부터 랩, 댄스까지 모든 것을 할 수 있지만 한국 사람들은 그녀가 중국인이기 때문에 그녀를 무시하고 SM은 항상 한국 라인을 더 홍보하고 밀어붙입니다.

[@단비는핑크색]

@@eulalia3468 우리가 언제 무시했는데… 다 좋다고 하고 있잖아… 그리고 sm에서 중국인이라 차별 했을거면 애초에 같이 데뷔를 시켰겠냐…?

[@단비는핑크색]

@@eulalia3468 sm에 외국인이 몇명인데 닝닝 혼자 외국인이라 차별 당하는것 처럼 말해

[@user-li9vp7ki1j]

닝닝 이 헤어색이 진짜 찰떡인듯.. 원래도 이뻤는데 헤어색체인지하고 너무 예쁘고 계속 시선이감. 그리고 되게 사람이 세련되보임.

[@shabinarustam6126]

She is amazingg. She deserve get main vocal in aespa.

[@phoenixbird2032]

She is the main vocalist of aespa.

[@aklimab7]

does anyone notice in some angles she look like Jennie from Blackpink?

[@K_moreno1331]

@@aklimab7 true

[@knownoyy]

Ningning representing the 4th gen main vocal

[@200_ing]

아 진짜 닝닝님의 그 노래부를때 분위기가 너무 좋음.. 이 노래 그냥 닝닝님이 커버해주시면 행복할듯 맨날 10번 들을거야

[@joycelu1513]

Aespa all seem to be capable singers but Ningning is definitely the best in terms of technique and musicality. It's the small things -- like knowing where to breathe and how to phrase a verse. That's why she's main vocal.

[@achlys4751]

Yeah she trained the longest.

[@mansininixo1441]

@@achlys4751 Even before entering SM she was damn good

[@cheesecake5766]

her voice are so beautiful, she's indeed a main vocalist.

[@Prayersubmit]

윈터가 주목끌면서 넥레 세비지 윈터 보컬분량이 확 늘었지만, 데뷔때는 회사내에서 가장 인정받은 보컬이 젤 높은 비중을 차지하는법이죠 블랙맘바에서 압도적인 보컬비중을 차지한 닝닝이 난 늘 닝깅을 응원해!! 더 주목받고 더 떡상했음 좋겠다💓

[@ningaces8113]

when she said "god-given voice", she aint lying

[@cagtay.]

And this is why she‘s THE main vocal

[@hwyh5392]

وز

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

@@hwyh5392 🤮🤢

[@cthei8558]

@@layzhangismyhero4395 shut up man😻🙏

[@Fairyphobia]

@@layzhangismyhero4395 your mom when she saw who she birth

[@im_notshreyaa]

She's the Vocalist of Vocalists. She's more than a main vocalist!!

[@remruatibartowski3055]

dawt

[@sungjinwoo7173]

I hate this cuz they put autotune on it

[@jeannedemba6120]

@@sungjinwoo7173 OMG no

[@onestrike6582]

I doubt it she can't even reach the high notes, she's struggling

[@jeannedemba6120]

@@onestrike6582 no

[@소중한-h6g]

Her low register is so stable and impressive, from a singer's perspective it's really hard. Her mix can improve, but she definitely has a flexible ranger given that she's a rookie and is very young too. Keep singing Ningning 🦋

[@mansininixo1441]

She's is too young.. My voice developed after my teen so much.. We will see the improved Ning2 version soon🔜

[@jovenaceron5849]

Ikr, as a sing myself, I really love her lows. The mix is still good but it could be better, she still sound great tho. This kid really has a potential. Waiting for your improvement Ning ❤️

[@layism3857]

Bruh her low register sounds pretty developed. Like are you hearing that vibrato?? That is not easy and Ningning has a naturally high tessitura which make it even more impressive.

[@cheri8832]

@@layism3857 they are not being rude at all, let them have their opinions??

[@kim.jhyuck]

She’s a light lyric suprano and having good low register is definitely impressive! Her mix register is relatively good as she’s singing within her relax state, nothing too high so she’s singing with ease and definitely support is there.

[@willywonka2645]

The soul and her control with her vocals is insane af?!?!

[@nalbbong192]

닝닝아 목소리 보석이다...

[@musdalifah0425]

Lets be honest. Ningning's vocal really on the next level.

[@taengoo991]

Ningi always have crystal clear voice no matter what language she’s singing

[@user-tt8yf4bk8c]

수험생활하면서 이 영상 보고 정말 많은 위로와 힘을 얻었었음… 닝닝아 노래해줘서 고마워 항상 응원해

[@czenniewhattt3731]

As expected, our main vocalist. MYs pride

[@bsed1chayaganandrewjovica.832]

*NINGNING'S VOCAL* : _divineeeeeee_

[@madeinmoiselle]

Yung pang online class na acct yung pinangcomment hahahahaha

[@rh-le3pt]

얘네 보다보면 닝닝이 제일 괜찮음 얼굴 이물감도 없고 성격도 귀여워

[@jaannya]

씻고나서 와인 한잔하면서 듣고싶은 목소리다 진짜...닝이 솔로 어디쯤 왔니

[@ddnakdj]

넌 막걸리가 어울려 ㅋ

[@kingbunny9883]

Ningning sounds like an angel~

[@Lixoki]

Ningning Voice + english + high note = perfect vocal

[@vicvergelmarquez4608]

Her singing technique is the best ive ever seen, ningning vocal goddess

[@GreenEyedMantra]

This Birthday Girl is slaying as usual

[@susantoarismunandar1933]

Many Kpop singers can sing high or low notes. but Ning ning voice is a pleasure to my ears the most, like angelic voice.

[@Aminyxxxx]

I just can't belive she exist in real life She is sooo talent

[@rubyjane7914]

It's finally safe to say that ningning is the best vocalist of her generation.

[@uknowwho03]

i am multifandom but i say clearly that ningning is the best main vocalist of the 4th generation

[@karinangyoo9078]

I could literally play this thousand times a day. Happiest birthday uri maknaengie whose vocals never disappoint

[@emil_yo]

it’s such a flex to have THE Ningning as our main vocal!

[@user-dododo0luvu.]

이때도 잘하긴 했는데 지금 닝닝 노래부르는 거 들으면 많이 늘었구나.. 라는 생각이 저절로 듦

[@AB-yk2pq]

She's Chinese, she's learned Korean and her English prononciation is mostly good. Good job Ning! 🦋

[@aesparody]

You got the point here ... Proud of her

[@zoroleplusnul8286]

*Ningning got Xenogloss*

[@jennieschanelabaniko1393]

@@zoroleplusnul8286 she’s an ed hacker tho

[@bubblyjenna2321]

And she's very young too

[@rosie5816]

@@DevNicholson i think a lot of people thought that her Korean is so clear but she’s actually Chinese n is also pretty good at English it’s like what can’t she do

[@willywonka2645]

Vocal queen proving again why she is entitled that!!

[@hrjsbae4091]

ISTG HER LOWER REGISTER IS SO SMOOTH.. i heard suhyun's cover of this song, she struggles to hit the note on "just to play the game" part but ningning do it smoothly gosh

[@AznIntegra521]

Its that fine SM training. U can hate sm all u want But they will train the hell out of u to be the best singer possible

[@lanlili876]

ningning one&only main vocalist of aespa forever

[@egichany5483]

this is how a top tier vocalist sound and im sure this video will go viral and get millions views

[@haechiey]

Ningning really deserves all the love and attention, I hope more people will see her goddess talent and give ningning more popularity

[@fantanyam3815]

Her lows are so good imma cry😭

[@otakulife9275]

The best vocalist of 4th gen.

[@고양이-z3u]

닝닝이 최고야... 볼때마다눈물고임 ㅠㅠ 우리닝닝이너무소중해요...

[@aespacism]

Love how ningning mixed hers and ariana's style. The hymn just shoot me straight in the heart!!! Best vocalist everrrrrr

[@notfound-yc5zf]

와 진짜 잘부른다..!정통 팝 부르니까 느낌이 확사네..!!!!!!!!

[@똘이-h5l]

그럼 뭐함 곧 항미원조에 오성홍기 흔들면서 공산당 찬양 할텐데?

[@butpa9043]

@@똘이-h5l не будьте нарцистом

[@깽2-h7b]

풉 ㅋㅋ 개못함

[@jolinwenwen5707]

我同意✅

[@호크아이-g2z]

​@@깽2-h7bis this?

[@brown_own]

확신의 메인보컬 닝닝 음색 미친 개 좋다

[@WhitneyAustins]

She’s so talented

[@just_junkyu]

Everyone, the MAIN VOCALIST of her generation, NING YIZHUO!

[@vivianrodriguez7415]

@@sitihardiniuad9178 ningning in girls yedam in boys😘

[@yosangum1493]

@@sitihardiniuad9178 nope

[@GISELLEGOTXENOGLOSSY]

@@sitihardiniuad9178 why are you even here? Lmaooo

[@oliviahye7314]

ayo i love ur profile

[@olaabdelmoniem380]

@@yosangum1493 SM should take your opinion before making aespa debut and by the way ningning not only aespa main vocalist only but also 4generation main vocalist so go cry about it

[@saaha4399]

닝닝 무슨일이야 진짜ㅜㅜ 목소리 오진다..천사같음 노래부를때

[@x_astrid_x]

It sounds as if she was conveying a story, her lower register is so good!!!

[@ericaanngandeza4763]

Knowing Ningning has a very light and bright base in her voice, her lows are really really amazing. Truly, the best 4th gen vocalist.

[@늦게핀꽃이아름답다]

목소리가 독특하면서 시원하고 카랑하고 좋다.

[@sistarnsister]

She rank no.1 for MAIN VOCALIST of 4th Generation!!!

[@anishkason2226]

Ouh

[@mp-fx8nt]

No she's ranked no 4. Which is still good. No 1 is nayul!

[@wj7960]

@@mp-fx8nt who’s rhat

[@yvoneclairesalmorin7855]

@@mp-fx8nt who's that? And who ranked that list?

[@mp-fx8nt]

@@yvoneclairesalmorin7855 u can find out when u click the vid lol

[@seraphina1727]

i love her low notes, very soulful

[@noemi6600]

I wish Ning Ning could drop a full cover of this because her voice is so so soooo beautiful

[@rizqotulmr4843]

She is singing and here im crying 🥺 what a beautiful voice 😭

[@ajalmonte7758]

SM vocalists are really on a different level. From Taeyeon to Wendy to Ningning. They're exceptional.

[@eviyunachang3985]

And Bada 😊

[@yosangum1493]

And Lina and luna

[@An-xm1le]

From Bada to Lina to Taeyeon to Luna to Wendy to NingNing...and ofc other vocalist in SM too...

[@sherlykurniadafani1812]

@@An-xm1le Jessica too. She is 2nd Main Vocalist after Taeyeon 😊

[@An-xm1le]

@@sherlykurniadafani1812 yeahh that why I said "ofc other vocalist in SM too" bcs i just mention the main vcl😬..

[@wsa8014]

듣기 편하고 너무 잘불러 진짜 닝닝으로 입덕하길 잘한거 같음 ㅠㅠㅠ사랑해 닝깅아(♡ 오래 활동해줘!!

[@S1LVERCLOUD]

*Ningning Vocals are no joke!* Best 4th gen vocalist for sure. we're so proud of u ningning 🤍

[@Music-br3sn]

agreed.... she deserves the world our sweet maknae

[@Alexis-cf1fq]

No she ain't the best 4th gen vocalist, she's a great singer but Yedam of Treasure is the BEST 4th gen vocalist

[@yoongarden8287]

@@Alexis-cf1fq LOL. This is a comment that congratulates NingNing, make your own comment on your favorite video. Anyways, Ning Yizhuo best vocal 4gen ♡

[@divaqueening1940]

@@Alexis-cf1fq yedam aint even close to KingNing

[@fauzaneza6263]

@@divaqueening1940 yes that's right, ningning is too far from yedam, because yedam have more experience

[@Alice-tj2iv]

Ningning vocal is no joke💕

[@amandaoh8010]

okay y’all need to just appreciate ningning for herself and not compare her visuals to other people or compare her vocals to other people. ningning has her OWN unique visual and OWN voice. If she’s talented- she’s talented

[@andrewcolarri9177]

omg ningning is such a vocal queen

[@Yushi_kuri]

아니 닝닝 노래도 잘부르는데 진짜 노래할때 제스쳐랑 표정이 너무 좋음ㅠㅠㅠ

[@똘이-h5l]

응 느그 공상당 티벳 프리 홍콩 프리 타이완 남바원

[@oq3910]

@@깽2-h7b 지는 얼마나 잘한다고 ㅉㅉ

[@Andie1997]

So many people ask me why i am just natutally inclined to sm artists even if they just debuted I guess that is because you have that standard of choosing your taste in music and sm wont just let anyone debut, it maintains that standard and you wont be disappointed

[@mimosapudica5160]

preach 🙌🙌🙌💯💯💯

[@queenning28]

The line “some people live just to play the game” is REALLY LOW for women. I'm shocked that someone who nails the insane high notes (I think the highest is F#5) in Savage can also sing these E3 F3 low notes without sounding too breathy or shaky. I think she'll get even better in the future with more confidence and freestyle riffs and runs. Well done Ningning!

[@Bagel_Luv]

its not low actually lol or probably my vocal range is low hhahaa

[@ajreyes1262]

@@Bagel_Luv it's really low for a woman haha, i saw so many woman sing this struggle with low notes

[@exoservedmecoffee1036]

@@Bagel_Luv lol same but ningning is such a great singer oof

[@crystalcastle660]

@Getaway Minnie it's low for a soprano.

[@hexagonalc5703]

Actually she hits G5 in aenergy.

[@besharaisaacs8316]

her vocals are beautiful !!

[@kaw_ss1019]

To be honest, Ning Ning's cover is the best version of this song up to now. I'm impressed with her low notes.

[@nyz1964]

It's her birthday, but she's the one gifting us with this cover 😭💗

[@duyenss5090]

I love Ningning’s vocal so much. She is very talent

[@jimmyjimsvlog168]

Ningning vocal is no joke mix strong and soft voice best vocalist for me (no hate)

[@hadilkheimeis9827]

Ningning the 4th generation MAIN VOCALIST y'all

[@avegaillucero4702]

Best main vocalist!

[@haechiey]

Ningning future really so bright.. she has that angelic voice and the pretty visual 😭💓

[@우진-u3n]

우리 닝이가 잴 이뻐 젤 잘해 젤 사랑스러워 닝 하고싶은거 다해

[@alanbalcarcel5850]

Nobody touch her ! She got a different type of voice… I mean not the typically. Her voice remind me of powerful artists with big voices. 4th Gen Main Vocalist.

[@Rororo_1212]

아형 나온것 중에서 집중해서 듣는거 처음임 ㅋㅋ 노래 잘한다 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@guardian9271]

"when I'm recording a song, I'll think of various scenes in my head like a movie. What character am i potraying? What's happening? How am i feeling?. Little things like that. After i do that and prepare myself, then i go and record the music" - NINGNING

[@aesparody]

Sorry, but when she said this???

[@guardian9271]

@@aesparody on a magazine, i forgot between vivi magazine or singapore vogue

[@miakpop5671]

Istg she’s gonna be one of the most popular vocalists in Kpop! Her vocal range is insane

[@BTSsexyvempirejin]

Winter is actually

[@guardian9271]

@@BTSsexyvempirejin stfu, this is ningning's place

[@amerjamaludin4311]

@@guardian9271 his just hater

[@miakpop5671]

@@BTSsexyvempirejin Winter is also a great vocalist but Ningning has the best vocals in Aespa tbh…and her vocal range is insane

[@BTSsexyvempirejin]

@@miakpop5671 yes its true actually i fav ningning

[@languagedt9029]

난 한국커버중에서 닝닝이가부른게 제일 좋음 목소리가 애절해서

[@channe9600]

i love how ningning makes this song look so easy. as expected from our precious main vocal

[@phuonganhcao605]

I love her low notes as well as high notes!!!

[@sarahbungan.a.8223]

I swear, SM's main vocal so unbeatable even compared with other main vocal from another agency

[@kiraeyoo2959]

y'all i think she's gonna be the next jazz and rnb god in kpop

[@maratrishatarape7004]

EYYY REPRESENTING AESPA MAIN VOCAL, 4TH GEN MAINVOCAL !!

[@purpletima4769]

OMG her voice so clean

[@xihuanni3810]

OMG ningning. This song has a difficult technique and Ningning manages to sing it very well. I'm so amazed. wow. 😭

[@tomiechandesu]

When she can do both low and high note ✨✨✨ FLEX

[@eulalia3468]

I love you for being Mickey's and Ningning's fan , i've seen you many times before, my fellow otaku MY

[@startan5845]

and when I can't do both.. XELF

[@psy_loose]

@@startan5845 Lmfao!!😭 Fleeceeee!!!

[@taengoo991]

hopefully we can see more of ningning's singing content

[@sunnyshine5562]

Fact: *Everyone wants a full version*

[@patrickvasqueztuesta7670]

YES

[@lingth]

i forgot she is actually a Chinese, from Harbin, since she sings in English so well, and speak fluent Korean..

[@what76]

난 게임 닉도 닝닝이다. 음색 여신 김닝닝 사랑해

[@its.jenchulichaeng__4115]

we all get why she is the MAIN vocal!! 🔥