Man Re Tu Kahe Na Dheer Dhare I मन रे तू काहे ना धीर धरे I Chitralekha, Roshan, Md Rafi I Javed Ali

[@narenb123]

Everything is there but the soul of the song is absent... Rafi sahab ke alawa wo koi aur nahin la sakta wo feeling.. Is gaane ka maalik bas wahi hai....

[@zameerullashariff2369]

@@narenb123 💯 % correct

[@garybhatia4798]

jyada alaap marne se feelings nahin aati rafi sahab rafi sahab hai feelings lane mein doosra janam lagega 😢

[@zameerullashariff2369]

Kya baat kahi hai aapne ..100% sahi

[@Vidhayakgaminglive9797]

दूसरे से भी काम नही बनने वाला यू ही कोई रफ़ी नही बन जाता

[@alk6709]

Vocals are lost in the music. What makes Rafi sir amazing is that every word of a song is clear to the ear. You can write when he sings.

[@riyazeiein2008]

compared to others javes has done justification. you are wrong

[@sadashivsardesai7008]

@@alk6709 quiet right

[@AbdulRahim-r4o]

I have respect for all those singers who gives a shot at Rafi Saab's songs. Because they will always fall short. And they know this very well. Knowingly they try to sing his songs. Not to outsmart him which they know they cannot. I think they strive to do their best out of sheer reverence and devotion to the man. That's why i respect Javed and scores of other Rafians.

[@swarnkotwal1969]

Zyada alaap aur murki lene se Rafi sb ko touch bhi nhi kr sakte 😊

[@syedaslam16]

Rafi Saab is only one. No one can achieve even 10% of his level Syed Aslam

[@klkumar9801]

Koshish kar ke bahut dekhi par khojne par bhi wo mithas wo gehrai wo aatma wo saral or effortless singing aur bahut kuch jo kaano me aur man me basa hua hai nahi mila.Ah!!Rsfiji we miss u whenever someone tries to sing like you R.I.P sir.🙏🙏

[@zameerullashariff2369]

💯 sahi kaha aapne ..

[@govindmatwani2513]

What a beautiful composition by Roshan saab / Rafi saab. I think Javed Ali has done full justice, hats off. I've met this talented youngster at one of his concerts, he's down to earth and very pure soul.

[@brahmanyadebchakraborty]

Not Circus. A new dimension of the song. what a performance !

[@Anantmusicaldreams]

Thanks

[@ataathusain267]

4:11 Rafi sb was a jewel by all means.

[@mohammadqasim9178]

Bhai tu rahney de ! Rafi sahab ki aawaz mein jo gahrai aur oonchai thi wahan tak toh abhi tak koi nahin pahunch saka hai !

[@bizzmantra]

Great efforts. Let's not compare with Rafi Sahab. Simply superb. 🌹

[@rajendrajoshivlogs6009]

Jawed Ali always underrated singer in bollywood

[@nasserbabader4508]

بہت خوب چہوٹے رفیع صاحب 🌸🌸🌹🌸🌸

[@prakashpandit6996]

True in our childhood we only had a radio.we wud write down the lyrics when our favrt song came & then learn it to sing after practicing the tune from memory and words from that copy

[@rajkishoreguru9218]

That was the only way for us.very right.

[@rajendrachopra4159]

Sahir-Roshan -Rafi combination was marvellous.Besides this, remember Barsaat Ki Raat and Taj Mahal !!

[@spotifyloverpk]

Where is feel and soul...Totally missing 😡

[@tomingamlin9963]

No doubt sings very well n in one's own voice texture n set of mind regarding the mood of song. But Rafi to me was n will always remain soulful n very very soothing to ears a genius natural god gifted singer . Kishore das Toronto live in year 1982 paying tribute to Rafi Sahab n singing this song in his own style n voice too is worth listening indeed a natural genius god gifted singer too

[@sadanandgote5544]

True

[@shahidrasheedkhan5554]

Flute Player ZABURDUST ! BEHTAREEN SONG & WONDERFUL SINGER JAVED ALI ! 💖💖🌻🌻🇵🇰🇵🇰

[@sumandebroy8968]

Too much mastery of classical music destroys the soul of a beautiful song!

[@mohammadqasim9178]

Bhai, aap ney pyaaz (onion) ko itna chheel diya ki pyaaz hi ghayab ho gai !

[@zameerullashariff2369]

Bhai Rafi Sahab ne Itna perfect Gaa diya hai ke dunya mein aur koi unke aas paas bhi nahi ja jaskta ...aap ka gala achcha hai classical bhi bahut achcha hai aapka but song ko bigado mat bhai...

[@Anantmusicaldreams]

Thanks

[@karta9275]

साहिर के गीतों में गायक की आवाज़ हमेशा म्यूजिक से ज्यादा होनी चाहिए। साहिर की कविता में अद्भुत रहस्य छिपा रहता हैं। इसीलिए गायक की आवाज़ हमेशा म्यूजिक से ज्यादा होनी चाहिए। जैसे की इस गीत की सिर्फ वो लाइन ही अद्भुत है - कोई ना संग मरें।

[@rohanpanigrahi3463]

As the song is based on raag Yaman, Javed ji started with the famous bandish of Yaman nd then sang the song, this shows the class of an artist. Amazing Singer . Pt Ronu Majumdar ji Ko mera pranam.

[@praveenvyas4937]

Bansuri vadan shaandaar.

[@reetabagga2761]

Excellent performance/flute music is marvlas

[@rajendrachopra4159]

This too is excellent presentation

[@manohartembe6201]

Excellent singing

[@singerdharmeshpawaiya238]

Aapne antro mein wahi ehsas Diya sach bahut sundar

[@navketan1965]

Sahir Ludhianvi was FIRST A PHILOSOPHER who wrote poetry to convey his GOD GIVEN WISDOM & life experiences of his own to common man for his/her welfare in his poetry. Every word was carefully crafted & inserted in the right context to convey true message from that great thinker for A given situation (issue facing common man under similar circumstances).Not even one other published poet in any language has addressed so many diverse issues facing the mortals in his/her work as Sahir has done in impeccable manner & forceful combination of words. Einstein’s Quote about Mahatma Gandhi fits perfectly well about stature of Sahir Ludhianvi’s Poetry & Philosophy in Literature & Bollywood history-- “Generations to come will scarce believe that such a one as this ever in flesh and blood walked upon this earth. (said Einstein of Mahatma Gandhi)” Sahir’s poetry & wisdom would shine on this earth long after we have perished . SAHIR= Wisdom of Aristotle+Brilliance of Einstein

[@dhananjaydas9400]

Love you Sir. God bless you. Keep singing Sir to make this beautiful world beauty.

[@mohammedjahangir3993]

Very good performance of flute by pandit ji and also classical singing by Javed Ali sab

[@meenajain3256]

javed sir kya gaaya hain aapne aapka geet sunkar man anand se bhar gaaya hain thank you for singing this very beautiful song.

[@shailendrajohn160]

Osm

[@Privolti]

Lot of unnecessary circus for a very deep philosophical song. This has to be sung with a very philosophical mood which is not at all there ...the original song was perfect. The protagonist is talking with his "mann". It has to be very delicate and soft. These days people sing all harkats without considering, bollywood singing is not some classical signing exam. One has to sing with the perfect feelings and thehrav.

[@prakashbhagde1689]

सही कहा आपने.... ❤

[@NutanSunilchitte]

Very. Good

[@zameerullashariff2369]

Absolutely

[@ajaychib036]

Gud try man re tu kahe Jai rafi sahab

[@khalidsheikh474]

Amazingly beautiful performance 😍👌👌

[@ritapandya8239]

Excellent Javedali and orchestra He is my favorite singer

[@FlubDubFilmsVarunSingh]

Main bs gana sunne k liye aaya tha or ye to 😍🔥🔥 next level instrument players 🔥🔥🙏

[@HareshDholakia-b8f]

What a singing. Lajawab Haresh Dholakia.

[@umeshgupta352]

Music so loud and no feelings in song . Only and only Rafi ji soul touching voice penetrate heart and soul

[@mayakhadatkar4288]

Atishay sundar❤

[@garybhatia4798]

musicians kamal ke hai awaz khadi hai without feelings

[@syedashfaqueahmed4441]

Masha Allah khy khanay bhout khub Ya Ali Madat

[@sadashivsardesai7008]

Very well sung.

[@anamikavyas3633]

Excellenttttttttttttttt both of you sir

[@prakashkalbandePatil]

JAI RAFI SAHEB..................

[@khalidsheikh474]

Great Javed Ali sahab 🙏🙏🙏

[@radhikapant9738]

Very nice I like your voice

[@singermobin7796]

Bahot khub jawed saheb aap ki koshish ko salam 🌹

[@sixthsense66able]

Is the flautist Ronu Mazumdar? Each cover rendition of this song underlines Rafi's uniqueness. No one comes close. That he did not know the lyrics by heart and made a mistake undermines the enter effort.

[@kumarsapan]

बहुत सुन्दर !

[@kumarthakur9372]

Waah Waah Waah soulfulness voice Masha Allah ... Full of feelings ... Brother your voice always touch my heart .. 🌼🌼🌺

[@Privolti]

Why saying Masha Allah? Will any muslim say Jay Shree Ram? Spineless person.

[@kooooswaldgodwinfernandes2212]

Trying to become MHD.RAFI, zameen aasman difference. Try to sing in your voice.

[@musicislobb]

Javed sir ❣️❣️❣️music volume is more than vocals 😔

[@altafpeerjade474]

Javed sab you are complit singer in the filmi line is wajase aap rafi sabjike song shirf aap hi sahi tarikese gate ho aapki voice main mithas hai jo kanon ko acha lagta hai Alta pirjade

[@arihantslife3155]

Beautiful performance

[@aliranmal7150]

Nice sung but Mohammad Rafi is will always be the best.

[@lallitasingh616]

Nice song

[@aparnagaikwad8820]

Classic artist..sung so well touched d sole

[@alokkumaragrawal9484]

The spirit of the song is lost in the musical circus. This performance is neither Indian classical nor light or semi classical music.

[@shambhunathmukherjee9995]

Very Nice Sung with Classical Music Mode.👍

[@vadanbhaipandya2861]

ખૂબજ મજા પડી ગઈ.

[@shirishpaithane5496]

Best song is lost in crowd of music. Original song is with only two instruments, and that shows the magic of words, Composition and singing.

[@D.R.Bhomawat]

Very nice

[@girijasamantaray5640]

Too much effort to mach but Rafi saab is a magician 💐🙏

[@sunilbhaisurti2473]

Very nice singing by you ❤️❤️💐

[@spiderman3086]

Extra efforts of classical singing, singer's under performance and loud music killed the song. Only flute player is effective.

[@simmysharma6845]

Flute in the beginning ❤❤❤❤

[@happyhours4523]

What a performance !👌. Kishore kumar 's fans should watch this video . 1000 kishore kumars can not compete with 1 Javed ali . Classical music makes a person a true singer . Without classical music Singer becomes dependant on music director's mercy .

[@irshad3452]

Don't compare kk he is the great himself

[@Anonymous-ku8vo]

Kishore is far better than Javed. Tell your Javed to sing mai jhoom jhoom jhumru, Neele neele ambar par, etc songs. 😂🤣

[@manassinha8808]

R u mad? Kishore Kumar is the greatest playback singer ... Javed Ali himself will be ashamed if he sees ur comment

[@BalwinderSingh-qu3vw]

Good singing

[@rameshdixit2264]

Super

[@Anantmusicaldreams]

Super

[@kumarrs9980]

Rafis original is best Next comes kishore effort

[@shohabnaqvi8164]

बहुत खूब

[@shahbazkhanshahbaz6359]

👌👌👌❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@manumehta1911]

No doubt melody is there but the soul of song is missing.

[@Stingray1953]

Good, but something is missing, Rafi is Rafi.

[@KPRavi-ps1uu]

Satish Kumar • Ji, that something is Rafi sahab's emotion. Rafi sahab had mastered the art of bringing out the emotions of the character the actor was playing on the screen. That's called Rafi Magic. It is impossible to recreate Rafi sahab's magic. Nevertheless Javed bhai sang the song very well . We have to encourage highly talented singers like Javed bhai who are carrying forward the legacy of the incomparable Rafi sahab.

[@bhagwanborde4878]

Nice

[@keshavamurthykl4273]

👏👏👏👌👍

[@nishiprasad5973]

Noisy orchestra

[@sudhirmathur7226]

Javed Ali undoubtedly is a good singer but he has not done justice with this beautiful song of Rafi Sahib.

[@siddharthgager5883]

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@keshavamurthykl4273]

👌👍

[@Udaynad]

Best next to Rafisasb. Jite Raho, Gaate Raho.

[@nitinnassa5135]

A re Ali 🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@nandlalbajaj5624]

Can we have Javed sir only

[@FarahMalikVlogs]

Original flute was by Hariprasad Chaurasia nd sitar by Kartik Kumar .

[@singhgymgym3109]

Kishore da and Rafi ko koi bhi copy nahi kar sakta. God hi Aisa kar sakta hai

[@torankumar408]

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@monu-vq4rk]

Acting achai hai

[@drrajeshchaudharyinfertili9526]

This song is only for Rafi.

[@shkhanamm7651]

Javed ali bhai thik hai rafi sahab se bohat zayda door nazar aarahe hai aap ko fir koshish kar ke gaana pade gaa dobara

[@mitboricha9]

Singing starts at 4:52

[@siddharthgager5883]

😂😂😂😂

[@siddharthgager5883]

This type of comment is more required on Education Chanels

[@zameerullashariff2369]

Jitne bhi singers ne Rafi Saheb ke gaane gaye hain unme 'soul ' ki kami hai technically to sab theek hain..Lekin Rafi saheb ka andaaz kahan se laoge..

[@Anantmusicaldreams]

Thanks

[@FarahMalikVlogs]

Raag yaman kalyan

[@firdossdomah5973]

Why on earth he try this immortal song not his level

[@sanjoysingharoy9618]

Where is his vocals?

[@avinashjadhav1377]

I would like u all to listen same song by Saurav kishen and see the difference in feelings with due respect to Javedji, i here don't want to criticize.Hope everybody understand this.

[@RavindraSingh-ps8cg]

Inki aawaz bahaut surili hai , Sonu Nigam to kuch nahin hai inke aagey par taqdeer bhi koi cheez hoti hai jiske aagey kisi ki nahin chalti hai . Jis jagah par inko hona chahiye wahan koi aur hai , ye sab naseebon ki hai baat .

[@samparker334]

listen this before commenting on Sonu Nigam. Bro Sonu Nigam is currently the number 1 singer of India in terms of singing capability and knowledge, no one is ahead of him. He is an institution. And no one can do justice to Rafi Sahab songs better than Sonu Nigam.

[@jayasankar1948]

Ask Arijit Singh to sing this and you will see what a low singer he is. He will kill this beautiful song.

[@dj05kabul96]

Bhai jan rafi sab ke bandish in yaman mai hau or aap pira alaap ghalat raag mia kia hai aap seetna ghat umid nai thi

[@alkapuri5124]

Don’t compare to the original. Enjoy different voices and styles -

[@bluesky2760]

I love Javed but he is struggling with very low notes