Mandir Movement | Ayodhya, Kashi, Mathura ,Why Do These Matter ? | Sanjeev Sanyal Exclusive | News18

Mandir Movement | Ayodhya Kashi Mathura , Why Do These Matter ? | Sanjeev Sanyal Exclusive | News18
Mandir Movement : Ayodhya, Kashi, Mathura, Why Do These Temples Matter. Join Sanjeev Sanyal , Historian, Author in an exclcusive conversation with News18.
#sanjeevsanyal #mandirmovement #news18
n18oc_india

[@driasalta4834]

If Hindus are told to forget their places of worship for secularism, then muslims can also be told the same. The responsibility of secularism cannot rest on the shoulders of only one community.

[@jeanminatchy1381]

WHAT A GREAT AND SMART ANSWER. PLEASE SPREAD YOUR ANSWER TO THE ALL TV CHANNELS AND THE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT.

[@saraswathimenon3516]

Sanjeev Sanyal! Salute! So far, secularism meant Hindus keeping quiet no matter what. Nobody said anything when our people were converted enmasse. Nobody said anything when Pandits of Kashmir were chased out or killed. Double standards. What suits the politicians.

[@kalyanpal1371]

Totally agree.

[@lathamenon2023]

What happened to the temples of Porkistan and bangladesh? Means we hv to bear secularism after giving two countries.

[@muralidharan7226]

It was congress party of Mohamnadans that bought the Places of worship act to checkmate Hindus vis-a-vis. Muslims. It was congress led by an Italian lady who slapped Hindu terror on Hindus by making friendship with Laksher o takba. Pappu praises Al quaida but hates Hindus

[@mohandaskizhakke300]

. Love to hear Sanjeev ji. He is brilliance personified. Nehruvianism was a curse on the nation & indian civilizational aspirations. Its high time to discard it and re-discover our national identity. Kudos to you for taking this touchy topic a national hearing. ..

[@shikhargupta4063]

Lol that atleast educated you. Savarkarism would have ensured that you were part of some lynch mob.

[@rakhimukerji7937]

Sorry.Nehruji is still my favourite

[@sivarajk1931]

Bullshit

[@philipeisenberg6984]

Great discourse in a nutshell by great Mr Sanjeeb Sanyal.

[@jatinsaikia2650]

CNN-NEWS18 Should telecast this type of conversation. The anchor is very smart and Mr. Sanyal has explained the real picture of Indian History.

[@NamanBastar]

Well conducted interview... Sanjeev bhai is a Gem of our nation.. Jai Hind

[@user-em2zb7mc6g]

Agree I wish I had his logical mind

[@orunabho]

Ask Muhammad bin Salman to come and see Kashi Gyanvapi structure - let him see for himself what Turks have done with the tradition of the Arabs.

[@aaryan_B055]

Let him deal with the kaaba 1st. Md those 300+ idols which were destroyed by a man.

[@mlg1279]

What has MBS to do with kashi? He is irrelevant

[@tshivaramakrishna7909]

Bhai they're offerings Namaaz all the day's they're very well aware off it, still they're offerings there every week they're themselves only burrying theirs offers, they said in there system they should not pray or occupied & demolished the other's properties only saying, but doing the same Against to their Law's (Community), no values to themselves. Rest off Courts will justisfy remaining what to do & to whomever it's should be hand over it will hand over to them only.

[@pallavarora7467]

Arab themselves given them this ideology... Look at the Banbhore Jama Mosque archaeological report. It was built by the Arabs on a temple site and threw temple idols and Shivalingam at the entry gate to the Congregational mosque.

[@gangatharanchinnan7257]

"By education I am English, by culture I am a Muslim and by accident I am a Hindu."' this statement made by Nehru, one can analyse Nehru' s mindset. He was anti Hindu.

[@DC-zi6se]

Source?

[@mlg1279]

​@@DC-zi6se Weren't Nehru's actions pro-mu-slim and anti-hindu? That's enough proof

[@ganesharvind867]

While nehru says accidentally he is hindu, he is cheerfully for covering his identity. Nehru family is a muslim family, days are not far , thus will be disclosed and people of this world will understand how nehru and his family fooled hindus of this country..

[@DC-zi6se]

@@mlg1279 No, I want the source of the statement in the original comment.

[@rakhimukerji7937]

Are not we what we are by accident? We have no choice in the matter.

[@jaychandrank6670]

Shivani is one of the best interviewers I have seen like Margaret Hoover. She made the conversation enjoyable, probing, and informative without pushing any agenda. Of course, Sanjeev is one the best modern times historians.

[@rl1900]

Pretty cute also🥰

[@premprakashjauhari2751]

Lord Ram, Shiva and Krishna are the core of Sanatan Hindu Dharma and our civilization. It doesn't exist without them. Hindus despite various differences in their way of living are bound together by them for centuries. Hence the three temples in Ayodhya, Kashi and Mathura are very important.

[@vinod24singh]

We wont stop till all temples r restored. Its not only related to our culture but also our history and Architecture.

[@prabhajagota3764]

Sanjeev Sanyal historian is very proud frank to explain Not shy to speak about Hindus

[@rajeshtanwar2445]

A very mature and objective discussion..🎉🎉🎉

[@aghost1410]

I love Sanjeev Sanyal so so so much.

[@bsmishra100]

Sanjeev Sanyal is incredible 🙏🙏

[@ravichandrantns3799]

If Moghuls can be called Barbaric, we should call the portugese more Barbaric in converting the Hindus. The Kapaleeshwar Temple at Santhome was brought down by the Portugese and the present St Thome church was built over it in Chennai.

[@hindurashtra63]

Except Portugese came as traders and took advantage of the right moement to capture Power. and persecute HIndus. Mughals came as Invaders, Their goal from the start was to destroy Hinduism and enslave Hindus and capture our Homeland.

[@manishashimla]

Sanjeevji as always clear and sharing insights. Recommendation to the channel, it's not important to share the screen between Sanjeevji and anchor. It's best to keep the focus on Sanjeevji, and a few times the screen can be shared with anchor. The highlight is the gyan coming from learned scholar.

[@agadurapparamachandra8291]

Lovely programme

[@senthamilselvam2421]

Sanjeev is knowledge n educated person

[@pradum_25]

AyegaToModiHi ❤🧡 Phir ek baar 300 paar❤❤

[@JD-lb8nl]

400 paar !!!

[@pradum_25]

@@JD-lb8nl I wish it will happen.. Par 300 bhi a jaye wahi bahot hai mere liye.. ModiHaiToMumkinHai ❤

[@bangaliyogi]

Very good interview especially at this time. Thanks. 🙏🏻💚🙏🏻

[@laxmankumardas719]

Excellent interview because of Sanyal sir.

[@hungrybeastt]

Secular essentially means Anti Hindu. That is the problem. it should be removed from Constitution. Indian been pluralistic society since centuries, no need of a term Secular. If political parties like Congress did not resort to shameless appeasement of Muslims and formed policies to reduce Hindus as second class citizens, this would not have happened. Issues could have been amicably resolved long back!

[@padmaganesh891]

Very well said. Pseudo secularism has been practised so far in India, with one community being pampered at the cost of another.

[@jsk767]

Secularism is separation of religion and state, and that should be preserved.

[@BraminWarrior]

​@@jsk767..so secularism being followed in real sense in India or is possible in religious based society in India? You are real id!ot

[@jsk767]

@@BraminWarrior to your first point: no secularism is not followed in India to the truest sense. If it was, temples wouldn't be under government control .In other words, India needs to be more secular. Secondly, state secularism means separation of religion and state( or matters of governance) and that is totally possible even if the society is religious( an example of this is the US)... If you don't realise this, you're the id1ot..

[@jsk767]

​@@BraminWarrior a religious country can have a secular government. USA is an example. Also India ought to be more secular, because temples are still under government control.

[@saradaajarananda1584]

It is Bharat history and we Hindus have a right to reestablish

[@indrajeetkamat6138]

Sanjeev da as awesome as he always is.

[@kotipilla]

One of the BEST conversations I have heard for a long time

[@ashishcodanda6572]

Brilliant and articulate as always Mr Sanjeev Sanyal👍👏👏👏👌🚩💪✌️

[@reghumohan]

Good conversation...We should do everything possible to get Kashi and Mathura back....

[@rooposhreeganguly4290]

Thank you Very much for this talk show with Mr Sanjeev Sanyal . It's always a great pleasure to listen to him .

[@smileplease3204]

Sanjeev Sir is great intellectual and he is flourishing my idea of India and Sanatan.

[@kalashsharma4344]

Have to say he may be one of the best speakers with a really good choice of words to avoid any miscommunication

[@sunilsawant4542]

Kashmiri Hindus- what happened to them just a few decades ago, can we forget? Temples have a certain energy and a deep routed spiritualism associated with them.

[@madhupolaki3087]

Great discussion and very informative. Good articulation by Sanjeev and sensible questions by the anchor.

[@nareshgoyal3938]

Very well explained the oft asked questions. More such discussions are required to enlighten and inform people 👏👏

[@Thakursahib123]

Three cheers for Shivani for conducting this interview with SS.

[@aditilahiri8069]

Great pleasure in listening to Sanjeev Sanyal.

[@haridasshenoy8334]

Great as usual. I am a Brahmin but not highly religious. But I am happy to learn about our civilization.

[@proudtobeaninfidelkafirand7471]

Stay Atheist or better yet Agnostic for the rest of your life. South Indian Hindus are pre-disposed to brainwashing by X'tian Missionaries. Please do not stray towards Vatican or Mecca or any Abrahamic desert cults. As long as you stay Atheist if not a Pious Hindu, we all will be good.

[@BraminWarrior]

Brahmin but not religious? Who you mock your mother publicly? 😂😂😂

[@haridasshenoy8334]

@@BraminWarrior Sir. I said not highly religious. I am religious. I pray every day in my own way. Sanatana Dharma gives me that freedom. I am not mocking anyone or anything.

[@CocoTube11]

The lady asked really insightful questions.

[@mexicanmomo]

We wont stop. We will provide proofs and take back all these places.

[@OrangeDurito]

Getting our sacred sites back is the matter of our identity which has long been suppressed and then twisted through foreign ideologies. We are on a quest to reclaim our title of ‘Vishwaguru’ and for that, it is extremely important that we reconnect with our glorious past, culture, traditions, language, scripture, Vedic science and rituals. One cannot be a leader if they don’t have a clear sense of their own. Sanatan Dharm is a way of life which tells you exactly how to lead on personal and societal levels. It gives you an unadulterated sense of direction about your purpose in life. And that’s why we cannot just sit and let these embodiments of ancient knowledge, spirituality, and religion be lost to time or resistance. We are inclusive who celebrate everyone and everything but we would and we must always prioritise us before others and this is exactly what we are doing. Remarkable interview! I am glad that he could give more of a historical, scientific perspective with examples form all around the world in a articulate way and I liked the questions you posed to him. Kudos on this job well done!

[@roshanjaindr]

Sanjeev sanyal is so well informed and clearly more intelligent and less under your skin version of Tharoor!

[@Odyvers]

हर हर महादेव 🎉🔥⚔️🇮🇳🚩

[@grkmurthy1157]

Thank you, Sanjeev sir and Shivam Ji, for this great conversation 🙏 and insights. All wrong notions and narratives are destroyed b

[@prescot12345]

What he said in the end was brilliant.

[@tusharvashishta]

Loved how Shivani keeps a smile through out the interview but still asks all the relevant/difficult questions and brings out his perspective, which is easy to grasp and understand. Sanyal sir is a gentleman. All in all one of the most perfect and crisp interviews.

[@bengali.indian]

Very well said... 👌🙏

[@fullaranag]

Wonderful talk

[@LaggardInLove]

Great conversation!

[@sahashranshubarik9204]

What a interview❤ what a speech❤. Let Sir Sanjieev Sanyal to write your true History and we must discard that Maulana Abdul Kalam Azad and Nehru's history.

[@ritukiran]

NEHRU WENT ON HIS JOURNEY WHEN HE WROTE DISCOVERY OF INDIA - EVEN WE NEED TO GO ON SUCH A JOURNEY ... AND DISCOVER THE PRESENT DAY INDIA

[@chitrareddi7121]

Well said!

[@ravirat]

Right person to answer those wonderfully framed questions...He answered intellectually and honestly....when one speak with honesty then he will attract everyone's heart ❤ 🙏

[@arindamchatterjee2816]

Fantastic Discussion.Mr Sanjeev Sanyal really is a real visionary.

[@amrsk1126]

Excellent

[@ravichandrantns3799]

Ayodhya - Lord Ram birth place , Mathura - Lord Krishna Birth place , Kashi - Lord Shiva Himself did the Prathishta of Shiv ling (one among 12 Jyothir Lingams). Leave the rest of the 40, 000 Temples. These three are very very important for the Hindus.

[@arnabchatterjee6566]

Kudos

[@drspyphysio]

Wow❤

[@Bharatabharati]

Thank you sanitary ji! This informations gave clarity.

[@shubhdeepkhanna]

Gud interview

[@sanilsingh8107]

The explanation of the reclaimation of the sites as important as sites important to other religions ...is fair and important to the Indic identity.. Jai Hind

[@Praful_Jain]

Wow

[@kannaninsevagan3415]

Great discussion, both q and a are good. And, (Not trying to be creepy), Shivani looks so pretty in this video

[@weathergenerator]

Many thanks for a brautifully prrsented program without any politicians.

[@pradum_25]

I love this man ..🎉🎉 He is economic advisor council in pmo❤

[@nintendoplayer8371]

Great guy 👍🏻 so knowledgeable and just

[@vish2553]

All temples have value and is not limited to three temples. Let’s get back all our temples and not just the three.

[@BallsOfSteel2310]

It is better for concentrating on development. You yourself alone go and get us our temples back

[@vish2553]

@@BallsOfSteel2310you have balls of pussycat unfortunately.

[@tshivaramakrishna7909]

​@@BallsOfSteel2310 Don't be angry on him friend he just expresses his openion, but Peaceful community not understanding the same it's really ours, no problem with other's they're standing with Nation firstly. Excluding these people.

[@pranavprakash8687]

😇😇

[@kunalseth6437]

🕉️

[@rajparmar8116]

Bharat jai ho

[@sanjayshah7776]

Sanjeev Sanyal is a brilliantly articulate, intelligent and hugely insightful historian

[@prana775]

We as a Hindu have right to resurrection - to protect our place of worship, values and traditions

[@ayushagarwal2000]

This journo is beautiful ❤️

[@manoranjandutta989]

A very cerebral discussion in contrast to sloganeering or headline seeking one's.

[@HollyMollyMusic]

Your generation is a curse on todays hindus😢😢😢

[@commonman821]

there is a small chance that the world is coming to get a far, faint glimmer of an understanding that if left alone , Bharat will create enough for everyone.

[@friendlyvimana]

Here from sanjeev ji's twitter.

[@r0071]

Hats off to this genius man… our great dharma has always respected other thoughts as opposed to narrow ideology of abhrahamic religions

[@colarunjoshi]

India has never been secular. It has suffered Nehruvian secularism where the bottom line is Crush the Hindus & and bend forward for the Muslims . Both Ashraf & Pasmanda.

[@tshivaramakrishna7909]

You Rightly said sir 🙏🙇.

[@user-us5gt1ug8h]

Reclaiming our culture and heritage which was unreasonably and unethically destroyed by people who were alien to our lifestyle is inexorable and imperative for our march towards being the Vishwaguru of the world,these symbols of our heritage gives us strength to assert ourselves and increase our prestige with other countries it's our fortune that we have a leadership which is very nationalist and selfless identify people like Sanyal and give them their place in shaping the administrative plans and goals

[@chrissingh4730]

It matters very much!!

[@user-us5gt1ug8h]

The Travancore kings called themselves as the dasas of Sri AnanthaPadmanabha Swamy just like the Ranas of Mewar who considered themselves as ruling agents of Lord Shiva

[@ottosaloon]

It is a traditional thought even today

[@murarivyas5735]

Interviewer too was good

[@gayatriugra4380]

You can now be switched off @21:00

[@SaraswatiMSarasa-pn7ci]

Hare Krishna hare Krishna hare hare hare rama hare rama rama rama hare hare ❤

[@karnatheempire6789]

We have a great future 🎉. Country is in Right hands .

[@grkmurthy1157]

Har Har Mahaadev 🙏

[@amrithkumar1918]

Ari Sanyàlas talj was specific &every one easily follow.

[@bambu3954]

Brlliant narrative for all of us to follow!

[@Nostalgicholy]

India is a new country but an ancient nation

[@pallavarora7467]

You forgot to mention Spanish Reconquista, Mr. Sanyal

[@hindupurprahalad1720]

Mindset of anchor is secular and all questions are based on that. Mr.Sanyal given fantastic answers. I hope the anchor had some change of mind after listening to him.

[@mohanvarma1310]

The civilization that comes first becomes unique in its real sense. Other that emerge later learn and take their essence from original or first civilization.

[@amitsarkar3019]

Even Journalists don't know, that the word "Secularism " was introduced in 1976 by Indira Gandhi during the Emergency time. It's a vague word meaning different things to different people. US constitution, like Indian constitution, doesn't have that vague word.

[@bpmalanadu7136]

During the partition of India it was divided in the name of religion. Pakistan became Islamic republic of Pakistan and India became democratic republic of India. It was the generosity of the Hindus that India did not became a Hindu nation but that does not mean Hindus have to suffer from the hands of the so called minority of 300 million Muslims in India. Muslims should have handed over the iconic places of Hinduism, like Ram Janma Bhoomi, Mathura, Kashi etc instead they tried to create tensions and riots. Muslims have more freedom and rights in India than in any other Muslim countries, do not forget that. Still they are moaning and involving in all kinds of anti national activities..

[@user-qr4po5nn5d]

Jai Jai sree ram ji💪💪💪

[@SaraswatiMSarasa-pn7ci]

Twelve jotra linga on that day sir this is true sir 🙏💐👍❤

[@shreek08]

who decides which temple is unimportant?

[@AjitKumar-of7pf]

The British started Control of Temples in 1925, but even after 1947, the Politicians of India continued it...Even Modi has not revisited the Prejudiced and Imperialistic HR and CE Laws of 1951....

[@ggfg8570]

It is difficult to digest the views of Dr. Sanyal that the temples built in India might have the influence of Greeks etc. for the reason that the temples built in Southern part of India were based on the rules/ principles laid as per the shilpa sastras and aagamas which exactly prescribed how the deity consecrated was to worshiped. Even Chola Kings decreed how worship had to conducted in the temples they build and same are still followed. In so far as North India is concerned they followed different styles of architecture and no such evidences are available to my knowledge or supported by archeological surveys that the architectural styles of these temples had Greek influence.

[@cssuntherrao]

The Al Aqsa mosque in Jerusalemhas a special religious & historical relevance to Muslims. It is not just another mosque. How will Muslims feel if Israel was to gain complete control of it & use it for their religious purposes. So is it with Hindus, with regard to their holy sites which were destroyed and Mosques built over them.

[@vpmanoharan2274]

Al aqsa mosque was built on the 2nd temple of jews. This is why the jews want to build their 3rd temple in or around al aqsa mosque.

[@cssuntherrao]

@@vpmanoharan2274 Do you mean Al Aqsa Mosque was built over a broken Jewish temple? Just want to know.

[@tarunksinha7467]

Why was it necessary to destroy these sites??? Please get the answer

[@Proloysaha36]

More and more big temples required like indonesia in our country and in every state of Bharat.

[@skarumuru]

You are too polite, why are we still discussing this??

[@gappauch]

If you ask a rustic from any corner of the country similar response would emerge...