Opera Singer Listens to Moonlit Occultation from Punishing: Gray Raven

[@narushio]

5:31 THIS IS WHAT I want everyone to hear! THE VOCALS! THE INSTRUMENT PLAY! THE WHOLE PAY OF BUILD amazing analysis Marco, like always 💙

[@Taessive]

You're here! :D

[@Ssilhouette73]

just everywhere

[@Rilind_CH]

Moonlit Occultation and In My Memory are, for me, the bests OSTs that PGR has to offer (And god how good they are in general). It's insane how GhostFinal (and Fluorite in this case) never disappoints

[@Kanethedragon]

I also quite like Fallen Concerto as well (part of Flame of Hope). It has a really strong instrumental piano and strings lines.

[@Nakirakira]

@@Kanethedragonthe piano rift in Flame of Hope was so good . Sad that it’s an underrated theme

[@DUCK-3076]

FINALLYYYY SOME RECOGNITION FOR IN MY MEMORY

[@jaderabbit898]

This is basically a big deal for Luna since her chapter years ago in Fake Ascension. It also starts a major shift in power play for PGR that I’m not willing to spoil for following chapters.

[@panchino003]

I’ve heard great things about the game, but I’ve also heard the power creep a INSANE for new players. Is this true? I’ve only played Hoyo games, and WUWA so not too

[@Argent_Nure]

@@panchino003 not really I played as new player in 2 or 3 months manage to keep up, the generosity of this game are very kind for new players, and you can get a lot of Black cards (currency for the gacha) pretty quickly and a lot of events for helping you to build characters. You should try first and you won't be disappointed for not only gameplay itself but others like music and lores.

[@dannyzein6448]

​@panchino003 nope pgr global usually powercreep them a year 😅

[@akward8246]

@@panchino003 power creep does exist, but thats a year later for both CN and global, so your character gonna be in meta for a long time before something op come up

[@sium4364]

​@@panchino003 consider that the game gives you enough time to guarantee literally every single character has to come so you can get every upcoming characters if you manage to keep up with the pace of the game, the problem is getting older characters, they give you some S rank selectors sometimes but it's still hard to get the ones that are already released

[@raveelemental4928]

The bits of Holy Moonlight in the theme, IT'S SO GOOD

[@pixelchrome2]

holy moonlight is my favourite theme in pgr tbh

[@tohrubo]

5:30 That Piano, That Dubstep, That Vocal. Every part of it is in Ascending notes, that combination is really really good.

[@keizuna1097]

Lesgoo...PGR ost reaction...next ost would highly recommend - In The Memory - To The Limit

[@KhangNguyen-qn4bh]

Instertice oath or Burning Vow.

[@sacharoset8134]

genius call from you to put the gameplay video as well, i'm sure it made more people stay to listen to the incredible music and analysis

[@probablyenzoh]

FINALLY OH MY GOD IM SO HAPPY SEEING YOU COVER THIS SONG! This is my favourite song from PGR. It grips me for its entire run. How the choir at 4:04 has more tension and dissonance. The HYPE drop and piano that comes with it. And the triumphant choir and brass at the end serving as the emotional payoff, setting the scene of an awakening completed. One of GOATfinal's best works

[@FrizFroz]

Heard this with your OST discussion with BranOnline, glad to see that Moonlit Occultation now has its own video, what a treat!

[@knsrulz]

GhostFinal - Last Resort is my favorite song from this game ... but that short part right there @6:20 is the best of all!

[@julien1er]

You analyses are always spot on, Marco. Luna's future path has been heavily foreshadowed in the latest Global patch and your takes seem quite close to it. Can't wait to see where it goes!

[@ben-taobeneton3945]

This track is brilliian! Whenever the chores kicks in, I'm in heaven! I feel like I'm ascending! 👼 Thank you reviewing another PGR song. Been waiting for this. 🙂

[@ZonzaAce]

This is one of my favorites of their more recent tracks. Vanguard’s ability to capture the story, setting, character, boss, and raw emotion in each ost to create an identity for PGR every patch is fantastic. Wuwa team you’re getting better, but keep taking notes. We need more game defining tracks like this as the story unfolds. ❤

[@aryabratsahoo7474]

Atleast WuWa has good exploration and non combat tracks. But yeah they definitely need to have better combat music. The new illusive realm track is fire.

[@Deus_Emperium]

Feels like without Vanguard wuwa music doesn't hit like PGR. They really need to up their game.

[@OrRaino]

@@Deus_Emperium I have noticed Wuwa soundtracks are not big nor they build up like Pgr does.

[@CheztaAhmad]

This music is so nicely fit into her new look. Floating gracefully yet captivatingly striking with that red color and a wing.

[@weertangel7231]

Its such a great song and it fits the new version of Luna as well, dark, foreboding like the dark Angel she has now become and so different as she was in the beginning.

[@divinestorm3562]

No matter how many times I hear this it gives me goosebumps

[@kaiden2876]

This OST easily took my first place it's such a beautiful masterpiece

[@NoEsc4pe]

I'm so excited to play this patch on global next yeah! 🔥 and this kind of top tier OST is exactly that what I miss in Wuwa!

[@zffrailgun1630]

We really need a To The Limit reaction.

[@MarcoMeatball]

It’s filmed!

[@zffrailgun1630]

@@MarcoMeatball PEAK!

[@thatnohrianscum6475]

​@@MarcoMeatballYESSSSSSSSSSSS

[@takebacktheholyland9306]

LETS GOOOOO

[@castronimussi6050]

I really recommend you "Endless Path" is a really emotional end epic PGR song

[@ForsakenMidnight]

I second this! Uncle and his theme deserve more recognition

[@Istreakilaz]

Pretty much any upcoming patch music tbh. they haven't missed a single one since Lamia. And then you add the fact that In My Memory is a 4* character, and To the Limit is not even for the character, but the boss

[@p4ntom87]

im always happy to see your pgr reactions

[@jo3y960]

This is my favorite PGR track I'm recent memory alongside new Hikari holy shit this music is so good

[@SheruMuko]

I cannot believe I had Moonlit Occultation on my playlist before you.

[@Terrastrial]

THANK YOU SO MUCH I LOVE THIS OST SO MUCH

[@AnonymousKnight-ve3op]

Worth the wait🙆

[@ifune]

you HAVE to listen to In My Memory next, i have a really strong feeling you'd like it more than usual

[@danjin27]

I think yui gonna love "In My Memory"

[@Kramer8]

Endless path from Watanabe patch is beautiful, Hope you can react it later.

[@mehedi8331]

Imagine all these cool animations coming to wuthering waves 😻😻😻😽😽😽😽🙀🙀🙀🙀

[@zalin2000]

I been listening to this every single night for the last few months..

[@yuugiri1995]

Next PGR ost in my memory please marco

[@indanindan358]

you know when i first time hearing Moonlit Occultation especially on part 5:34 there is a beat that really reminds me of one music that i really love it but forgot what music is. After 1 hours search finally found it and it's Lindsey Stirling - Crsytallize

[@truongthan6593]

I've been waiting for this for so long!!!

[@Hyukju_Cha]

WE ARE ASCENDING MARCO WITH THIS ONE

[@aznbrownie]

Marco, my GOAT!! I've missed seeing you, great video!!!

[@anmoldembla4743]

It's been a hot minute since I saw a PGR music here lol

[@VincentLloydM]

Always love watching you break down PGR music! I actually never fully listened to this since I only saw gameplay with this Luna, so it's so cool hearing and seeing an analysis on it. PGR music absolutely amazing as always. On a separate note... What in the like ratio is happening here?

[@hijodelsoldeoriente]

4:46 I wonder what instrument is this? Is it electronic? If so, what does it mimic? For some reason it reminds me of Nier. I feel like I've heard it from Nier Replicant. With that being said, listening to PGR's music more and your analysis makes me understand why I prefer its boss music more than WuWa's. Specifically the boss music since ambient exploration music is probably composed differently from music intended for boss fights which most of PGR's OSTs are made for. I have no background in music but I feel like it has more layers. More interesting composition so to speak. Even unused music from WuWa like Antinomia by Anti-General and Flow from Vanguard Sound are comparable to Ludvig Forssell's composition in Death Stranding. At least to my ear. Many music from WuWa are still interesting though imo considering their intention as exploration music hence more ambient and tamed like Narfall Barrens' OST or even Jinzhou's theme. Great video btw Mr. Marco! I'm always looking forward to it whenever you drop PGR's music.

[@Istreakilaz]

I mean... given that one of the biggest inspiration for PGR's worldbuilding, was Yoko Taro's work... yeah lol, they have a habit of putting nice homages to NieR, be that from their characters and setting, or just the music tone. Even as far back as during the launch, with tracks like Bad Connections, you can hear the inspiration. VGS just completely went open with it after they got involved.

[@Aregulargameplayer]

When I listen to this, to me the piano represents Luna. The heavy choir in the beginning represents the punishing virus. You have Luna's innocence at the beginning but the Punishing Virus brings corruption, power, rage, and liberation. These two aspects are fighting for dominance, working together, and splitting apart and testing each other until you have the one women wail, a powerful cry that to me represents Luna's will winning out and now the two parts are back in harmony, stronger, more vibrant, more epic than ever before.

[@jasonsalim2544]

Great Video! GoatFinal just never dissapoints, does he. And Marco, if you're planning on reacting to another PGR music, In My Memory should be your top priority. You will not be dissapointed with it.

[@MUIJohny]

Final Fantasy 16 DLC Echoes of the shadows and The Rising Tide Leviathan theme plz next all 3 phase theme of Leviathan

[@piepie5633]

In my memory plss

[@AnggaOblivion]

finally!!

[@MegaDragon1983]

I have ascended once again with this one.

[@lovelution_]

in my memory and endless path pls 🥹

[@codeno.071]

Moonlit occultation is good and such, but my most favorite PGR theme is gonna be 暮日战歌 or War hymn of the dusk because damn Hikari orchestral is heavenly good

[@Celica_42]

He has a reaction to it Type Marco poralis Bond

[@fabianosorio2540]

for me this sounds like battlefield 4 theme+ phantilya with pgr leitmotif.

[@RinrinFran]

My Queen Luna may be dethroned for now with Lamia but she WILL return when this patch comes out!!!

[@NikLoveGaming]

Endless Path! By the way have you heard Farewell Rayakshi ost from Reverse 1999? so good. 😂

[@andreusteles488]

Bro you have to listen burning vow

[@dankhorizon]

PGR music reacts? sign me up!

[@Nakirakira]

To The Limit is truly the limit

[@megatron4612]

Next ost: to the limit or in my memory

[@SamAventoIRL]

I have the "Return KZbin Dislike" extension on my browser, why has this video received so many dislikes compared to his other videos? Currently, it shows about 450 likes and 400 dislikes, but I don't see any negative comments in the comment section. What happened?

[@MarcoMeatball]

I have an idea but it’s not really important.

[@SamAventoIRL]

​@@MarcoMeatballHello! I wasn't expecting a response from you lol, but it seems there was a glitch with the extension showing many dislikes for this video only. I've just rechecked and it's back to normal now with just a few dislikes. Sorry for the off-topic question, I wish you a great day sir.

[@Celica_42]

Its been a month...

[@cesarvelasquez8528]

To me if she's coming. I will have to be prepared to get Luna: oblivion

[@chronostasisch.7]

You need to react to Adversity (by FLuoRiTE & GhostFinal) at some point too! It's a track that really tells a whole story from start to finish even if it might not be as "epic" as some of the other PGR tracks

[@j-aalex]

Lowkey want you to hear Lucia crimson weave gacha coating - lobby ost That one's 🔥🔥🔥

[@alastellabears8083]

Hey if I can recommend some music to react or just listen to in your own time, is the limbus company/library of ruina/Lobotomy cooperation OST’s all the games are made by the same company and take place in the same setting so that’s why I group them together, personally I would recommend starting with “In hell we live” it’s a very good song produced by mili

[@jacktalks2me]

Try to listen PGR Vonnegut boss fight (all phases) - that's the latest chapter and that music OMG

[@gamesixio2146]

You should try listening to the OST of Amid Evil. It’s very orchestral and I think you might like it.

[@SunflowerPvZ-]

Let's go PGR content!

[@maqna932]

Always has been

[@S.E.R.A.P.H]

Where is the reaction to in my memoris?

[@RinrinFran]

Eyy I heard this before with the gamer guy!!! VGS THE GOAT!!!

[@gilvinland219]

Parts of this track heavily reminds me of Copied City from Automata

[@dedididadada]

oh wait i hear it too😯

[@DarkieOps]

You should give the main theme of Ender Lilies: Quiestus of the Knights, a listen it's really good.

[@rune_7]

oh yeah.

[@deus2645]

Try Wuwa Mt.Firmament ost with vocals

[@4g3nt06]

Global players will see this in one year or less aged like milk.

[@meigaria]

pgr music goin crazy in 6/8 time sigs

[@nar7389]

how about "in your memory" ? celtic vibes

[@MyNameIsDin]

Waiting for your react to new Warframe login theme

[@snehilmallick4680]

Hey Marco! love your work! Will you please react to the ost of remuria world questlines? They are soo soo good! Remuria tracks are in Genshin album Cantus Aeturnus.

[@MarcoMeatball]

Yup!

[@minhtran8816]

Try Exorcism From PGR pls

[@Trigger_5508]

Please react to We remember from Halo: Reach next

[@eyrys3039]

Please react to Echoes from the Abyss next time

[@mugiwaranolamka6761]

Adversity from vgs please

[@naprag7386]

One week! Of asking Marco to react to Splatoon music

[@hhexed]

took u long enuf

[@Preymatrix]

Better late than never rii😂

[@АнатолийКнязьков-р6я]

Damn I realy dont like this song XD Snare and kick are so on the nose, that I have to do a double take if Vanguard did the music. It starts to hit on 6 min mark, but before that it just some how repetative mid. You can hear drummer square clearly and nothing else.

[@hana827]

Another PGR OST review by Marco! Yay!