Mariah Carey - O Holy Night - Live At The Beacon Theater - 2014

[@jozzleandro]

Those 90's voice has REALLY COME BACK!! THOS NOTES & WHISTLES OHMYGOD!!!

[@dellafone]

She could have sang the entire song in the original voice like she did many years ago, but holding that kind of upper register in her chest voice might prove difficult especially with a key change and aging vocals. Still, Mariah is Mariah, she can sing like an angel on her worst day and sound better than 90% of the 'artists' currently out there.

[@daviddaviddaviddaful]

100 % live ! Mariah you're really the best voice in Pop music ! Indeed,you're unbelivable !

[@danielh34]

3:49-4:14 unbeatable

[@rebeccacicilia]

So amazing... love ur voice so much.. :)

[@danielh34]

Unique voice

[@aleshitop16]

Amazing!

[@rodrigomoratto]

Mariah's voice is 99% she sounds amaaaazing, she only has problems at the very upper chest voice which is not constant, sometimes she hits it and sometimes she doesn´t because she must save her voice. She isn´t fearless anymore because she has nodules. I wish she could just have surgery, thing is it could take yrs for her whistle notes to come back, or maybe months or maybe never. But her chest voice would be 100%. She wants to take no chances with her whistle register which is her trademark!

[@rodrigomoratto]

I just love her so much...I am very greatful for the yrs of music she's given us!

[@jeffhealea5145]

Does she even have a whistle register right now? I agree with you, she should go ahead and just get the surgery. If it doesnt work out or even makes her voice worse, she can just keep on lip syncing like she does now. I wish she never would have started using drugs.... :[

[@Eddy6159]

+Jeff Healea she didn't use any types of drugs lol

[@antoniosingsadcc4]

Well deepsoul69BC, if it was prerecorded how does there were some of out of tune phrases, and those changes that she did, doesnt sound like it was prerecorded. If you have the doubt, go and ask her to sing that song in front of you.

[@truongphan90]

LOL, that would cost 1 million dollars. She sang live though :D

[@deepsoul69cb]

Sm part of the song were prerecorded and not live at all... U can tell by the resonance of the music/ mycrophone...

[@whoaflamit]

Thnank you for adding some sanity to this discussion. It seems to be severely lacking around all the videos of Mariah Carey "live".

[@misaghhernandez7391]

You just can't believe how good she was. She was no ordinary singer even when her vocals are not perfect anymore.

[@faithoffaith]

Nope it was 100% live I was there!!

[@whoaflamit]

faithoffaith I mean no disrespect by asking this, but could you please explain how you could tell she was singing live at her concert. The more details you can give behind your reasoning the better. This is all very fascinating and it would be great to hear from someone who was there.

[@rogl3W]

@@whoaflamitthey are somehow not particular with what they listen or delusaional for not being able to notice the difference

[@iamnobody7325]

I love Mimi's studio version if her voice. Live? I, somehow would believe some vocal stunts she efforted were fake.but still I love her voice.

[@antonhamilton2189]

I love Mariah but im just wondering, why can't she do the original whistles in emotions but she can still hit the whistle in this song?

[@Eddy6159]

She can, it's just not consistent from performance to performance

[@Fr3derick88]

Whenever she whistles, her fans start screaming ; c'mon I have to listen clearly to that ..

[@ste.b.7400]

I know what you mean, if I was there I wouldn't even breath because of my respect for this singer, I enjoy the song remaining in silence if I go to see her live

[@ElusiveAries]

Ste.B. have you seen her yet? it’s so hard not to scream i’ve seen her 4 times in the last year and she sounds 100x better in real life it’s so shocking that you can’t help but scream and want to cry! lol and i’m only 19 so I wasn’t alive during her prime but she’s my everything!!!

[@ste.b.7400]

during the whistle the audience istead of sitting down and listening to enjoy that angelic sound no, they scream like somebody is trying to kill them, perfect way to miss parts of the song