Mariah Carey performs Circles at The Celebration Of Mimi in Las Vegas on 4/14/24.

[@Eddo128]

She sounded awesome

[@b.k.471]

She fully lipped the whole show

[@NeeraMilanesigumo]

@@b.k.471I am a diehard MC fan and I was there on Saturday, April 13th. I just miss the Mariah I knew growing up. She just changed after 2022. She’s not even trying to convince everyone that she’s singing live. I love her so much but it just breaks my heart seeing her like this.

[@Eddo128]

​@Broadwayriah I'm not even going to respond to haters. This was completely live. This performance. And even if it wasn't. It's her voice.

[@TherealKenKaneki]

@@NeeraMilanesigumoeveryone changes.

[@Ivansooze]

Real fans show up for their fave artists regardless

[@ashandspirit9736]

She is singing more live ok she has changed elements of most songs to suit her tone and voice but musically they sound great if your gonna hate go listen to someone else and just leave her alone lets face it none of us can sing like her on a good or bad day

[@Eddo128]

Amen. Brandy, Beyonce, Monica, Celine, ect.. Pre Record their vocals. It's called working smart. She is recording new music. She has to preserve her vocals

[@carrymore7952]

Did yall buy tickets to it ?

[@MsMslujan]

Lastimosamente son pistas pregrabadas, ella no está cantando mucho en vivo en esta residencia, pero se valora que nos de estos regalos ❤

[@Zumaidi-hb5ef]

If she alone..she never get money lol

[@lelediamondASMR]

She really isn't singing live. It's pre recorded live vocals.

[@iconk66]

I saw this on Facebook and gasped 🫢😮 this is one of my absolute favorite Mimi songs …. And I love the current tone of her voice now , whether parts are lipped or 100% live she ate this . Wish she would sing a snippet of “for the record” from E=MC2

[@przemekpuciennik3263]

I think she cannot control her voice anymore higher than A4 note :/ because of nodules her voice is probably cracking all the time but that’s just my theory :/

[@kazzuhiko123]

Everybody’s talking about the vocals but here I am fixated on that hair. Idk if it’s just the lights but that ashy shade suits her so well. Maybe it’s just a wig but oh boy she should definitely wear it more often.

[@Gregzotik]

Was blessed to catch the show twice, once with boo. It’s hitting me so hard right now. Thank you.

[@TheMrKingAlex]

You’re very welcome.

[@DanielleA2023]

Genius songwriter 🦋 Greatest voice ever 🎶 Game changer 💪🏻 Global icon 🌍 still making and breaking records ❤

[@ciarrajohnson3849]

1:50 I wish she did the whistle in the background LEADING TO THIS…😖😖😖#OMG #Genius

[@anthonyd2303]

I was hoping for it too. I bet she could've done it easily

[@ciarrajohnson3849]

@ Can’t do both parts @ once. She woulda had to follow the background with it like in on the track and she NEVER DOES! Even during REHEARSAL, she didn’t even show off & do it😄😄That’s why I said that’s one thing I expected that she actually N E V E R did…❓💯

[@bmw3842]

34 years into her amazing career .My girl never disappoints .........We have aged together through pain and heartache and joy.I love you 😍🥰❤‍🔥❤‍🩹🤎

[@lastfirst233]

She really set the bar so high on belting high notes that even she can't hit them anymore.

[@blaque843]

It doesn't matter. She still did them.

[@lastfirst233]

@@blaque843 exactly, just like your comment that no one cares at all

[@blaque843]

@@lastfirst233 🤣🤣why so upset?

[@aurisayadian5294]

She sounds so happy ❤🎉 0:23

[@deegonzalez9229]

THE QUEEN WITH THE ANGELIC AND HEAVENLY VOICE THE ONE AND ONLY MARIAH CAREY👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼💙🤍💙🦋🦋🦋💋

[@stevenbrown236]

My favorite part of the show! I saw her in Seattle for first leg, and I'm headed to Berlin for Euro. Ride or Die since '86

[@FreeIndeedMusic836]

From someone who has been following MC from the start of her career, my opinion is this - when she began facing vocal challenges and unpredictability with vocal range, all she needed to do was take the much-needed vocal rest, make the adjustments to her songs into the lower keys that would better suit her current voice, and be confident in the fact that she still is and always will be one of the most creative, gifted, and talented singers of all time. Remember, she is A SKILLED VOCALIST, A REAL SINGER - not an entertainer like some they refer to as "singers" today.

[@Malicia-scunt]

Shes still lipping to a prerecorded vocal

[@TheYoungdedy]

AMAZING!!!

[@clarkdomingo739]

It is her tone, dahhling.. makes me giggles

[@facediva]

Mariah is a TECHNICAL STUDIO PERFECTIONIST SINGER. live singing isnt her PASSION compared to other greats before or during her time. Her main focuses are delivering a flawless illusion of a live performance rather than giving her audience a performance filled with emotions and her RAW TALENT rather if she was in a good vocal state or not! Iconic she is, BUT AT THIS POINT, SHE DOESN'T CARE!

[@marilynwhite6286]

Standing ten toes down...sing Mimi!!🎤🎶👏💞🥰

[@Sejuani89]

Its good that she arranged it so that she dont have to lip the high belted parts! It makes it all 100% live!

[@robd5713]

I agree. I’d rather hear the songs lowered than to just hear her lip the entire song or most of it.

[@cempla]

Loveeeeeeeeeeee

[@camilagothy]

My fav song by my fav female singer 🥰💕💕💕💕💕

[@Beautiful-Gorgeous]

Beautiful

[@jassyourservice]

Always a fan for you mariah

[@scootabean]

YES MIMI!!

[@NeeraMilanesigumo]

I am a diehard MC fan and I was there on Saturday, April 13th. I just miss the Mariah I knew growing up. She just changed after 2022. She’s not even trying to convince everyone that she’s singing live. I love her so much but it just breaks my heart seeing her like this.

[@normanilyrics1311]

This is live. You ain’t a fan.

[@coquiangel]

Pretty ❤

[@IsmaCarvantes]

This is the thing (same with VOL) The two perfomances we've gotten this far are slightly different. Shes either live or has rehearsed the two different versions down to every mouth move. Also ive noticed whenever shes about to lip she looks down to her prompters. As if they indicated which version of the lip she has to do (long whistle, short note, this run, that run) But that would be way to damn much I honestly dont think shes got all that going on. Instead her mic is EQ'd different than ever before and she's shown agility just not stamina.

[@CR-xu2mw]

I'm trying to decide a vacation one of which would be seeing Mariah in Vegas

[@taurussian4591]

Sounds good Mimi

[@asyraq_2004]

She doesnt care anyone opinion..go Mariah

[@porchamitchell7447]

I loveee❤️

[@luizbritto4143]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@aasiaabal9179]

❤

[@jessicajonesAngel]

Goddess ❤🎉

[@ChrisSalvador-r5v]

mother!!!

[@HarryJohnson-p1r]

She must tell us the truth it can set her free

[@philippillis9393]

To me this sounds live. But idk maybe shes very good eith pre rec vocals

[@blkdevil20]

It could be voice preservation if she’s recording new music. However, I do agree that she really does lip a lot now. Even VOL is lipped in some parts.

[@DavidPeralto]

😃😲😳😥😭🤗

[@tristiantreysenmamaloggins1698]

She sounded gd 2 me ❤❤

[@benc8896]

I think when people are paying a fortune to see you, miming just doesn't cut it. That was a patchwork of previous performances

[@direfranchement]

She can’t sing this live anymore. Seems like she’s even having trouble with C5 and D5 now.

[@alejandrogonzalezakamintyt2242]

This isn't a patchwork of any previous performance as she had NEVER performed Circles up to this point lol This was recently recorded

[@orangecloudzzz]

What? 😂 This is her first time doing this song live. Y’all will say anything.

[@facediva]

What we are hearing is a NEW PRE RECORDED LIVE STUDIO VERSION OF THIS SONG. THIS ENTIRE CONCERT WAS 99.5 % LIPPED 😢😢😢​@@alejandrogonzalezakamintyt2242

[@jx346]

@@facediva proof?

[@afacurtis7928]

coolezt and dope. though age is trying to tell on her. Still LOVE U darling

[@ryanallen8455]

Just as i predicted. She gives a tiny live snippet in rehearsal but lips the entire show ffs

[@ClaudineiGarciaManhoso]

ESSA MULHER NEGRA ARRASSA!!!!!

[@Sean-qr8bi]

This is live

[@b.k.471]

Delusional???

[@jessejameslatimer8686]

She’s only been doing this on her later years tbh

[@lelediamondASMR]

Mimed as always.

[@Kenyon712]

She’s always been a studio product. With all the engendering in the studio, she sounds great.

[@Bailey110489]

Who are you?

[@ulradeja5380]

*the greatest dub vocals specialist, Dubriah*

[@tyey25]

Love Mariah’s music - used to love searching KZbin for her live performances which were often better than the records. But alas, her performances just don’t hit anymore. It’s all just a bit boring, stale and repetitive.

[@sincereessence9646]

Ur words hold merit

[@ChosenOne777-k7e]

Blame the Alcohol

[@jeffslocs]

I don't understand these new singers losing their voice by 50.

[@whitneyhouston1122]

Mariah ain't new. She's been out for over thirty years and she has nodules so it's very unexpected of how her voice is that day.

[@thepopfiles4294]

Why the lip sync? I accept it from Britney because she doesn’t have the chops and dances. Mariah however, vocal legend, but the lip syncing, ruins her legacy. Even if she can’t sound like she used to. Train and practice, make the effort. She has the ability. This feel lazy and exploitative to fans.

[@Jlr327]

Nobody cares about your short story opinion.

[@thienphuvovan9364]

Wtf, this is 100% live

[@robertquindiniso4120]

Just go away hater! 💩

[@thepopfiles4294]

@@Jlr327 you cared enough to respond 🫶🏼

[@thepopfiles4294]

@@thienphuvovan9364 umm yea ok 🙄

[@Przemek16l]

lipped to pre-recorded vocals + autotune

[@KKYLERMOTANA]

Girl bye your wig is off

[@Shaaay88]

I see her lip syncing to the track into of live singing. She needs take a break. She’s over doing it

[@jx346]

where's your proof she is lip syncing?