Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, Celine Dion - Vocal Trinity C5-G5 Best Live Belts Comparison Reaction

[@DiscoverEverydayOfYourLife]

DISCLAMER : THIS IS NOT A VOCAL BATTLE THIS IS JUST SHOWCASING VIDEO OF THEIR VOCALS SO STAN DONT EVEN TRY TO DEGRADE ANY ONE JUST FOR THE SHOWING OFF THAT YOUR IDOL IS THE BEST THAN THE OTHER RESPECT ALL THREE OF THEM THEY ALL ARE LEGEND AND MEMBER OF VOCAL TRINITY FOR A REASON ITS MEANS THEY ARE EQUAL TO ONE ANOTHER BE GENTLE BE POLITE PRAISE YOUR IDOL PRAISE HIS REACTION THATS IT

[@invisiblelathatatlan]

But you are a Celine fun. Um?🤫 #whitneyisthebest

[@DiscoverEverydayOfYourLife]

@@invisiblelathatatlan did i ask?? 😂

[@charissanomdeplume6475]

This is true…

[@user-ll6zg9wb1m]

that D5 of celine was so pretty

[@loyalpaname4458]

Mariah has something spécial in her voice ... Maybe her beautiful tone

[@oaisabtwenyfour2232]

Queen Whitney touches my soul!

[@GeloMeme]

Mariah Carey is the soundtrack of my life. Her songs relates to me most, and I think that's the most important thing a singer should achieve. High notes and vocal acrobatics are only there for you to be impressed, but to be able to connect and relate to your listeners while doing all this things is on another level. Mariah's songs stood the test of time, and I'm glad she also wrote her songs.

[@LiTim17]

C5- Tie between Celine and Mariah C#5- literally all of them are perfect… D5- Celine Eb5- Whitney and Celine absolutely E5- idk, didn’t like any of em frfr but Whitney I guess F5- Mariah F#5- Slight edge to Celine, otherwise I’d say tie. G5- Whitney duh.

[@8ktv475]

thanks bby

[@brianleclerccampbell]

They are not called Vocal Trinity for no reason right, still my fav Whitney is on top of the game for me 💎

[@jahybarrosneto7418]

Celine Dion won for me!! 😃

[@loyalpaname4458]

Whitney is better

[@DuongNguyen-gt7ry]

Mariah carey for me

[@akudakenshin6216]

We all know how Celine sings, I love her nasal the most, everything is not about high notes, it's the emotions that we need to see as well. The stage presence, Celine knows how to control the stage, the choreography, connection with the backup singers, dancers, and even the instrumentalists, they're all enjoying on stage, she's really giving enough recognition to the "unimportant" people on stage based on most people who only cares the famous ones, and if staying still is better. She can add up humor, sadness, excitement, confusion, or any other complex emotions (some dramatic is better for Whitney, lively and exciting music was very suitable for Mariah's sweet voice, but what I think is great with Celine based on her voice is that it's on the middle, not too light, not as dark as Whitney, but has a great range not higher than Mariah or Whitney, dramaticness that is very versatile, from negative to positive emotions). She is the one who plays the MOST (obviously the other two does, but Celine really gives out a better one most of the time) with the fans, she's very humble, even if she's the least popular in the US areas especially when their on their own primes, she's just enjoying her performances (but obviously, the French industry loves her, she literally carried it. Celine lasted the longest because of her professionalism and great techniques not just to sing effortlessly but to preserve her voice as much as possible, successfully trying out almost genres and killing all of it, with and without high notes. I think her best concert yet is on Stade of France (Au Coeur du Stade ).

[@materialgworl212]

My fave songs she made that has great choreography are probably Love Can Move Mountains, Terre, and Treat Her Like a Lady, especially at the France Stade.

[@materialgworl212]

Also, you forgot that she's the best at sustaining notes with different qualities, the strongest, highest, and longest yet is probably All By Myself studio recording, others can do it, but not imitate how Celine does it, live or studio.

[@DiscoverEverydayOfYourLife]

CELINE LOWS RANGE IS WAY BETTER THAN MARIAH AND WHITNEY AND HER MIDS GO TOE TO TOE WITH WHITNEY HER HIGH BELTING RANGE IS MORE HIGHER THAN MARIAH AND WHITNEY SHE CAN GO UP TO C6 HER HV GO TOE TO TOE WITH WHITNEY WHAT R U TALKING ABOUT??

[@greyskyplanet8299]

They are all great but Mariah is on Top for me ❤️💪

[@ON-ck9eo]

Whitney is the queen! The others came out sounding like her,modelled after her. The other women are great

[@royalpanther6391]

Arrogant and delusional..... Eww

[@ON-ck9eo]

@@royalpanther6391 Whitney had 2 diamond albums from the 80s before Mariah released an album or Celine sang in English. Mariah was called the white Whitney when she came out, she worked with all Whitney producers too. Whitney is in the rock and roll hall of fame and the others ain’t. How’s that for reality.

[@s_shaleh]

@@ON-ck9eo I'm a huge fan of all 3 women but seriously? The age gap between them are not that far apart for one to say that Celine and Mariah were modelled after Whitney. Sure, their labels must have aspired for Mariah and Celine to be as successful as Whitney, but it's not fair to say that they sounded like her. They all had their unique voices but just because they are all women and they have powerful voices, the media played up the comparisons between them and created some sort of rivalry that never really existed. Celine had been singing before Whitney even became huge so she had already developed her own style. As for Mariah, she had been writing and recording her demos before she even met the producers who worked with Whitney. Besides, Mariah typically had only one songwriting partner in her pre-Butterfly era. The first was Ben Margulies whom she had worked with before she was even signed to any label (and with whom she wrote many songs that were distinct from Whitney's music) It was only after she was signed on to Columbia that Tommy Mottola roped in Walter Afanasieff to work with her, so no, she did not "copy" Whitney. She had her own ideas and style. More importantly, she already had a vision of the kind of artist she wanted to become. To say that they were essentially copycats really diminishes their talent. Also, Mariah has been inducted into the songwriters' hall of fame while Whitney hasn't. So again, I don't see your point. As for Celine, she's a legend in her own right.

[@TheVocalTrinity]

They all won👏👏👏 I'm so tired of seeing comments that compare these 3 legends. They are all great in their unique ways. Céline, Whitney, and Mariah are the best period🙌🙌🙌

[@bryancorea3240]

celine always kills it. she is so amazing.

[@CarloRodriguez10]

OMG Celine 🔥🔥🔥

[@mariahcanary6788]

Mariah is more on the R&B side, soft tones, and complex melismatic approach but she can also be loud, resonant, and belty if she wants to. I understand why people would put Celine and Whitney above her. The 2 sustains B4 note and above with vibrato like the rent is due. That's one of their many strengths. They would usually blast off their power on those areas which many people would see as a great attribute for a belter. However, Mariah's strength in terms of sustaining belts is different from them. For me, her sustained belts with vibrato shines from A4 to D5. Above it, she would usually just phrase the notes or hold for a few seconds then she would scale down through a riff or run. Many listeners that are non-lambs would feel like it's unsatisfying, kind of limited, or like a cliffhanger. But personally, I am satisfied with how Mariah sings. I like her style. It's like a roller coaster ride. Her voice takes me to different levels of highs and lows. I get excited whenever I hear her songs. It doesn't mean that her strengths are not the same as Celine's or Whitney's, she's already at the bottom. She's just in a league of her own. 😍 This is me just stating my opinion once and for all as I have seen many non-lambs would discredit Mariah's music and vocals just because she's not like their ideal belter they expected her to be.

[@materialgworl212]

Lol, everything is not about high notes, you can sing without hitting the highest of all notes, of the three singers, it's clearly Celine who's versatile, from ballad, rock, pop, French etc. She just can give the right feelings to it while still hitting notes not just effortlessly, but with emotions. It's evident that most of her songs have something she can relate in real life, Whitney's presence in singing is coming second for me for the dramatic types, while I think Mariah is great for the hardcore or positive type of songs the most. I mean you can only feel it when you're not a hater or something while what's good with Mariah is that she has a wide vocal range to hit effortlessly most of the time especially when she's on her peak, then Whitney's strength and resonance is great (larger voice compared to the two). Your nearly pointless opinion is clearly making it sound that Mariah stomps the two, clearly not. Obviously you're a "fan" of Mariah, "Mariah Canary." I wouldn't even bother explaining too much with Celine or Whitney's vocal technics or approach since you're that one biased Mariah "fan" who can't appreciate the other two since you only think about the technicality of performances, being a great technician doesn't put you already at the top. You're a great technician, that's it. Even in other genres of singing, such as opera, you won't give a great performance to those who actually understands music if you only focus on the ornamentations too much. Of course it's enjoying to listen to high notes, but it's not always that we should give attention too much.

[@mariahcanary6788]

@@materialgworl212 No need to be hateful. I was just simply stating my opinion. It's never in my intention to stomp the 2 other singers while lifting Mariah and influence you and other people with what I have to say. The context of what I said is that Mariah's strength is not the same as the other 2 and it doesn't mean she can't do certain things that the others can, she's already below them. You can idolize Celine as long as you want. You're also free to believe whatever you want to believe about them and about music. I will not take that away from you. But no need to be triggered and hateful towards me just because we don't share the same opinion. There are also parts where you assumed things. I never said that it's always about high notes and that's the 1st thing you said to me in your comment. Whatever you're going through, I hope you will heal. Sending love. ❤️

[@theovanua]

@@materialgworl212 lol Mariah is versatile too, no need to be a bitter hater. You clearly have not listened to her extensive catalogue which she mostly penned herself btw - Something which can't be said for the other 2. Also that's rich, when your own and other comments here make it sound like only Celine matters, oh the hypocrisy of it all.

[@LacosteAlain]

I love them all but to me Celine is on the TOP of her art....so VERSATILE...and BTW you did a great with your comments as always...we have to be mature and NOT comparing them cause at the end of the day, all 3 are part of the TRINITY

[@tasosGRvocals]

Τhank you so much for reacting to my video, I'm glad you liked it!!! 🥰🥰🥰

[@itschensplace]

It was great! I enjoyed it☺☺

[@tasosGRvocals]

@@itschensplace I love your channel too!! ☺️☺️

[@billyboy4774]

Good for you. The truth is always preferred. I respect a person who knows his own mind and expresses it.

[@Hugecdfn]

I love your honesty, and you have your own opinions, so if you don't like someone or something... don't dare apologize for it. That said... thanks for the reaction, you're awesome

[@itschensplace]

❤🙏❤

[@Idek12675]

Mariah clears

[@mikelyee1934]

I love Celine but it's quite evident that Whitney stands out. They are all great but Whitney's voice quality is exceptional.

[@Curtainstag_e]

what about mariah

[@mikelyee1934]

@@Curtainstag_e she's also a superb vocalist just like the two but she's my least favorite. :)

[@Curtainstag_e]

@@mikelyee1934 Whitney is the greatest voice ever ( male or female ) without a doubt. This tone is something else. But Celine has an indifferent, dull and kind of boring tone-timbre to me compared to Whitney's

[@torrico4363]

But for me Celine really stands out. She has that timbre and power on her voice that the other two don’t have.

[@torrico4363]

@jvn328 Whitney has the weakest spot in giving her voice a style. I would prefer give it to Celine or Mariah.

[@s_shaleh]

I can't and i won't choose! I love all 3 of them equally!

[@JohnDeLeon28]

The choices for Céline is either short and bad. Search “The Resonance of Celine Dion Part 2” and “part 3” for better clips

[@Yahlaymusic]

Mariah

[@davidg2573]

Mariah could belt and she could definitely hold her own against Whitney and Celine specially in the 90’s BUT Mariah’s songs are not as belty as the other two.

[@JMJS137]

Thank you so much for all your reactions ... I very like these great artists... Do you know the greatest singer in the world ( according to major international specialists ) Dimash Qudaibergen ? He sings higher than Céline Dion, Mariah Carrey, Withney Houston etc... He has an extraordinary vocal range. More than 7 octaves. He even reaches the rating D8 You can hear covers sung by him such : SOS d'un terrien en détresse ; My heart will go on ; Show must go on, all by myself ; Adagio etc... Unbelievable !!! Stéphane (from France ) ❤😊

[@whitneyhouston1122]

Just because you have more octaves doesn't make you a better singer. And he is not the best singer, more like the worst. He literally strains. And Mariah hit a F#8! Which I believe is higher than a D8! Mariah and Whitney will always be better than he could ever. Shoot! Even Beyoncé's better. Even Aretha. Patti. Sohyang. All them better.

[@Neonlike0]

They all have something special about them -all do an amazing job at hitting these notes. I'm not going to put them against one another and kudos to you for not doing the same.

[@crazybill2128]

Whitney Houston

[@grazianicyril9784]

Whitney love you forever

[@goldranger5182]

CELINE DION THE POWERHOUSE QUEEN

[@brianna7810]

Lmao all of Mariah's footage is either she's old, or the video is bad. I could find tons of better videos for her. It's clear the uploader is a fan of whitney.

[@letsbetheoppositeoflonely5139]

Thats what i observed too. The uploader made it sure mariah would sound weak of the three.

[@Curtainstag_e]

which notes of mariah do you think were not good?

[@Curtainstag_e]

@@letsbetheoppositeoflonely5139 which notes of mariah do you think were not good?

[@letsbetheoppositeoflonely5139]

@@Curtainstag_e which part did i say that i thought the notes were not good?

[@Curtainstag_e]

@@letsbetheoppositeoflonely5139 u said the uploader made sure mariah sounded weak of the three which basically means the same thing

[@jeffclarin1742]

Mariah Carey all the way ❤

[@nikkos34]

Céline all the way.

[@DuongNguyen-gt7ry]

Mariah queen

[@AuygayhuHnhuquyhq]

Whitney is 😮

[@cmkislay2133]

Mariah doesn't/can't sustain belts. She has the best runs though! Whitney and Celine win as power belters!

[@garyhollander1]

There are far better videos comparing the three

[@henry1088]

For me mariah won, omg that tone 🤌😍

[@materialgworl212]

These aren't even their best notes...

[@LiTim17]

Now watch the vocal quartet’s comparison, the fourth member being Lara Fabian, it’s great and showcases great notes all throughout(some of course you’ve seen like a few clips in this video will also be in that video) but nevertheless, it’s my favorite showcase of these 4! kzbin.info/www/bejne/mGOYmX-ZmbpsfMU

[@lenstgelais7376]

Well withney is dead Mariah doesn’t sing live no more because she simply can’t sing her own songs no more only Celine has a 100% of her voice still today so it’s really not difficult to say that Celine is on top of withney and Mariah 🤷‍♂️

[@kaingchhaylong2762]

Oh come on Celine can’t sing live either . She lip syncing all the highest part in her song since prime era . Stop with that nonsense

[@lenstgelais7376]

@@kaingchhaylong2762 lies

[@invisiblelathatatlan]

🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️ Maybe, but just maybe you could show some respect: Whitney. True art lives forever. This is the essence of art.

[@ravdog5265]

@@lenstgelais7376not lies, her own fans called her out for lipping so much and trying so hard to make it real.

[@MargauxChanning]

I would like to suggest that you give Gabriel Henrique - the Brazilian King of Whistles - a listen. He covers songs from each of these divas - in their original keys - and has a killer whistle register. You can find him on KZbin.

[@itschensplace]

There's a Playlist with Gabriel Henrique reactions on my channel check it out if you like 👍

[@steffenbeier3321]

My favorite is Celine, Whitney is just as good it’s all a matter of preference. Mariah was exceptional back then but somehow she doesn’t do it for me 😅

[@jalonwatts]

Funny opinion lol she’s the most soulful and artistic of the singers featured here…maybe you’re a bit or a lot uneducated?👀

[@letsbetheoppositeoflonely5139]

Shes still exceptional until now i mean of the three Mariah is the only one who can write songs, can still whistle and can still chart 4th decade into her career. I think thats what you mean by "exceptional".

[@PRAISEBIBLEFLY]

i don’t understand why people have a double standard towards mariah’s decline. both whitney and celine also declined vocally as they aged, especially whitney that sounded really bad during her last years. yet, people overlook their shortcomings while criticizing mariah for not singing how she did when she was 20 now as a 50+ year old woman, it’s ridiculous.

[@operadad]

i will say this... i have seen more than a dozen better clips of Celine Dion for each of those notes showcased... poor choosing by whoever made this compilation

[@royalpanther6391]

Mariah's clips here are mostly audience camcorder or low quality video. 😐