Mariah Carey Without You Ending Through out the Years

[@TheLegendofMariah]

7:05 Typo!!! this was 2010 not 2015 sorry

[@DaydreamCarey1234]

Omggg I actually believe that was 2015. Cuz they had the same body 😭

[@DaydreamCarey1234]

Alsp not you lowkey shading infinityriah

[@winxnights5281]

The last 2015 performance always makes me cry for 2 reasons : 1- it was the last time she sung it live 2- despite her "unpleasant" tone, i think she did a great job, and she looked so sad during that time which makes it so emotional 💔😭

[@DaydreamCarey1234]

Yeh she literally crying. And she even looked a bit sick.

[@ie2428]

0:22 It seems weird to see primeriah struggling

[@AngelLopez00]

i love when she takes that breath before the belt, it’s like she literally can’t give anymore😭

[@TheLegendofMariah]

Nobody: No seriously nobody Mariah: KEN LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@NG-sz2xi]

😕

[@iurii2059]

😂

[@squishy8634]

the 2003 ones are my faves😍, she did so great.

[@charmbraceletworldtour1503]

It’s not easy being the best tour😙

[@squishy8634]

@@charmbraceletworldtour1503 period!

[@kijanayoung2000]

@@charmbraceletworldtour1503 Can you imagine. You're the longest tour But babe what was up during Chicago? Lol It was like you were in spiritual warfare

[@butterflyriah2930]

@@kijanayoung2000 she still slays the whistles tho-

[@ajayyy6060]

6:04 the enunciation 😍😍😍

[@rhodaruiz5657]

2:49 Woe, look at that pretty suit!

[@chaneatsallsumptuousstuff2960]

0:09 really shocked me tbh! Goes to show Mariah's prime voice wasn't always perfect. She had a fair share of bad vocal moments too.

[@nonchalantdewiness]

That really wasnt bad tho, but yes she was struggling

[@bandolinfufuy3978]

yeah , i think she was sick

[@whitepaper5241]

I mean, she has always been inconsistent since her debut, and that's because of nodules. Not to mention she was always tired and forced herself to sing and go out of her limits just to prove herself. Her "Without You" performances from 1995 and above were so much better than her "Without You" performances from 1993 and 1994.

[@butterflyriah2930]

2003 Shanghai makes me cry(5:39)

[@Solo-vh9fm]

The first clip reminds me of how Mariah used to sing in general in 2015-2017

[@pieropinoo]

0:23 sound like 2014

[@MC-wd7jc]

Thattttss what I saidddd it does sound like her current voice or like 2014

[@rosemont2283]

More like 2016

[@kijanayoung2000]

Years in order considering technique, tone and overall delivery: 1.1995 Madison Square Garden- incredible. Just alil winded at the end but best so far. 2.1996 Rotterdam- Great. Just flat on the Eb5 "I" but okay generally. 3. 1994 1st performance-great just alil raspy 4.1994 2nd performance- Great...phrasing could get better 5. 2003 Charmbracelet Tour China 6.2003 Charmbracelet world tour clip 3 7.2003 Charmbracelet Tour clip 2. 8.2003 Zurich Charmbracelet Tour 9.2005 TEOM Promo 10.1998 Butterfly World Tour- Great tone. 11.1993 2nd performance- pitchy and inconsistently supported. 12. 2008- winded and in my opinion I can't stand her tone here 13.1993 3rd performance- winded 14. 2000- winded and tired 15. 1993 1st performance- winded and jetlagged. 16. 2006 TAOM tour- Winded and poor tone quality The rest follow but I love Morocco 2012 that note change was epic. Overall Charmbracelet World Tour had great consistency even though she lipped this song all the way to the very end.

[@cr3413]

I actually don’t hear that Rotterdam note as being overly flat. I mean, minimally, yes, but nothing significant.

[@trynagirl685]

17. 2019- Beautiful gowns

[@Yourlocalcatlover-rz6ks]

Even though she has vocal fails, her worst are our best..

[@Chrick_]

Why the end is so sad i want to cry😭

[@FIRMVN15]

Milan probably my top 3 along msg 1995 and shanghai charm tour❤

[@sandhyanagarajan]

MSG 1995 was definitely the best. It was the most fluid and most effortless. Also loved 1996

[@winxnights5281]

UNPOPULAR OPINION : I like when she runs during the climax.

[@adamd6648]

NAH SAME

[@doniell3807]

i love her voice

[@trent0292]

Gotta love ken leeeeeee😇😇

[@leon8160]

2000 and 2003 very impressive after her prime.

[@DaydreamCarey1234]

I feel bad for 2015riah for crying 😭😭😭

[@JohnNoverMagana-eg8jc]

Same i think the last one is After her Divorce

[@ie2428]

1. MSG 1995 2. Charmbracelet Tour Clip 4 (this one is my personal favorite) 3. 1996 Rottterdam 4. 1994 clip two 5. 1994 clip one- a little raspy and needs better phrasing, and I don't know what happened towards the end 6. 2003 Charmbraclet Tour Clip 3 7. 2003 Charmbracelet Tour Clip 1 8. Butterfly Tour Clip 2 9. Butterfly Tour Clip 1 10. 2012 Clip 2 11. 2003 Charmbracelet Tour Clip 2 (although it could also take the tenth place as well) 12. 2008- I hate how she sounds but vocally its alright 13. 2005 14. 1993 Music Box Tour Clip 2 15. 2015- the tone isn't the best, though 16. 1993 Music Box Tour Clip 1 17. 2010 18. 2000- she was very tired but those runs were beautiful 19. 2014- Nice runs 20. 2012 clip 1

[@uditsahu4537]

No way 2012 is low she tried soo hard😭

[@ismaelm.mbaangue9147]

I love 2012's ending😍

[@musicislyfe1672]

I'm more and more convinced that 95-96 were her peak years vocally

[@squishy8634]

omgggg I was just watching without you performances😲

[@sir3958]

.... Damn did not know she performed this song so many times😳😳 Well here’s another entry in the lost files of Mariah💛🐑 Interesting she didn’t attempt the ending run until 2013+

[@daydreamsg5278]

slaying ken leeee dulibo doucho through the years, what a queen of resonance

[@isaacdelgado7252]

1:40 Mariah: 😲😲😲😞

[@suprememegemar]

😆😆😆😆😆

[@sergioflorian]

*Underneath the Stars* driftiiiiiiinnnnnn compilation please!!

[@TheLegendofMariah]

ill make this my next upload! thanks for the suggestion

[@BakugouGam3s]

I Love This Song, in live IS Better that Studio

[@Suijiro99]

I was not ready with Charmriah Zurichrey

[@paulbrianinfante1346]

MSG undubbed is more emotional than the dubbed version!♡︎

[@facuuaf]

Not 4:15 horseriah breaking the line cuz she almost cracked

[@ibra1000]

I actually love the 2014 one

[@Hoodriah]

If beyonce had mariah Carey in black is king LAWD

[@winxnights5281]

1:40 Her biggest lip syncing fail 😂😂

[@winxnights5281]

@Daydream Era I was just joking, its definitely not lipped, but there was something wrong with timing in the vid

[@jared3970]

It’s not lipped. The TV channel put a slo-mo effect on the performance.

[@winxnights5281]

@@jared3970 I KNOOOOOW, IT WAS AAAA JOOOOOOKE

[@legitmimifan]

Charmbracelet 😘

[@charmbraceletworldtour1503]

😙

[@withyouonemogen]

1:44 ???? help? whats going on there

[@alextresor]

How do you think was the ending lipped in 2016 Sweet sweet Fantasy Tour performances? I'm not really sure, but It sounded too similar in all shows of that tour...😢

[@adamd6648]

She stopped doing the ending live in 2016, last time she done it was 2015.

[@cannadineboxill-harris2983]

Hi There my name is Mr C. T. Boxill-Harris, I just needed to know if you and your Band are still Remixing and Re-Extending the Original Background songs and Re-writing them in your Own extended Word Lyrics but sing it differently and Re-use those original Extended backgrounds Versions of those Particular songs By Andrew Gold and The Korgis, Never Let her Slip Away and Everybody got to learn Sometime, why don’t they just Replace the Synthesizer Strings Sound with a Two Deeper Musette Accordion’s sounds and make this Musette sounds for the Two Accordion’s 4 to 7 and a half times more Deeper than the Original Synthesizer Strings Sound that they have used for this particular song called Everybody’s got to learn sometime by the Korgis, also Replace the Xylophone Sound to 17 and a half Times More Deeper than Chime Bell and Even 23 and a half Times More Deeper Still Drums Sound, Because it is Still one of my Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Very Favourite Song Ever Since I was about 10 Years of Age Thank You and I Love you’re Singing Voice Mariah Carey and make you’re singing voice 3 and a half times more Deeper Pretty Please X X X X X X X

[@theroof6538]

MSG '95 UNDUBBEDRIAH. GODBRACELETTOURRIAH '03. MOROCCORIAH '12 WAS SO GOOD (but the audio from the official streaming really sucks and makes her voice sound dry, the audio from the audience footage sounds much bettter).

[@butterflyriah2930]

Perth 1998 is probably the best(if only we have the audio😤😤) . . . . . . Yeah i know we already have but 💀

[@theroof6538]

Music Box Tour LMAO 😂 Honestly I don’t remember 🤭

[@bzl9194]

7:04 I think this isn't 2015....

[@TheLegendofMariah]

it was a typo its 2010

[@ryanallen8455]

The vibrato was no longer existent from the charmbracelet era even though she could hit the notes

[@adamd6648]

Yep so sad, she stopped using vibrato after 2001. I think her stopping using it so much is one of the main reasons she can barely use it now.

[@lukas7307]

why aint the caution ken leeeee not in the vid

[@TheLegendofMariah]

lipped

[@lukas7307]

Quarantine Era every?

[@TheLegendofMariah]

luca yup since 2016 shes lipped this part

[@lukas7307]

Quarantine Era ahhh didnt know tht hahah i mean i think she still could do it live

[@Liamresume]

@@lukas7307 she can but, in Caution World Tour, it was the last song she performed (after 18 songs)

[@a-9748]

The voice cut out lol

[@TheLegendofMariah]

Which year is your favorite? mine is 2003

[@trent0292]

I like 1996

[@trent0292]

Daydream Era Oop- Np lol😊

[@butterflyriah2930]

Why you didn't use Milan 2000?

[@TheLegendofMariah]

4:06

[@butterflyriah2930]

@@TheLegendofMariah there is a full performance audio on YT

[@uditsahu4537]

@@TheLegendofMariahthat’s not milan

[@winxnights5281]

First Edit : im third

[@charmbraceletworldtour1503]

4th

[@charmbraceletworldtour1503]

Daydream Era it’s you again dahhling😙

[@butterflyriah2930]

I'm kinda cringe on MSG and Rotterdam's movement, she knows she was recorded so she try to act...beautiful..!!! Pls don't hate me

[@alvaroandrade7853]

First

[@winxnights5281]

7:05 Is this really 2015 ??? Lol

[@joblanskymangumjr1430]

It seems 2010 ish

[@TheLegendofMariah]

its 2010 i can believe i did notice that when making the video lol