Mario Party Superstars VS Original

I've played all 100 Mario Party Superstars minigames and I've decided to compare them to their originals, to see if you can get rid of the first 10 Mario Party games or if you should keep them anyways!
More videos
▶️Super Mario Bros. (SNES) No Coin - • Is it possible to beat...
▶️Super Mario 64 is SCARY - • Super Mario 64 is SCARY
• Buy Mario Party Superstars - shop-links.co/...
►Join TEAM BBQ and support me : / @nicobbq
►Mario in thumbnail by : / nintegadario
►Additional footage by : / nintendowiimovies
Follow me everywhere!
• Main Channel : / nicobbq
• Nico SHORTS : / @nicoshorts
• More Nico : / nicobbqlp
• Livestream archives : / @nicovod
• Twitter : / nicobbq
• Discord : / discord
• TikTok : vm.tiktok.com/...
🎶 Music Used 🎶
🎵 Mario Party Superstars Original Soundtrack
🎵 Aim
🎵 Couldn't Be Better
🎵 Ducking and Dodging
🎵 Hurry! Hurry!
🎵 Loud and Sweet
🎵 The Wide, Wide Ocean
Chapters
0:00 - Intro
0:34 - Free-For-All Minigames
8:01 - 1 vs. 3 Minigames
10:18 - 2 vs. 2 Minigames
12:17 - Duel Minigames
12:49 - Coin Minigames
13:49 - Sports and Puzzles
14:28 - Results and Outro
#MarioParty #Superstars

[@FletcherReedsRandomness]

“It’s the same game but it looks better, reboot!” “It looks better, but it’s the same game, it’s a tie.” Pls explain.

[@dragonball4ever2009]

I think he's saying that if it looks AND plays better then he prefers that version But if it only looks better and plays the same then it's a tie

[@liannehawkins5161]

Prepare to be sacrificed to the reboot

[@vladulo7649]

The comentary feels a little cringe.

[@Ruizon1]

I don't get it either... Based on what he said a lot more of them should have been a tie. All of the games on the switch will look better because the majority of these minigames were made on consoles that weren't HD/powerful enough so it should have been based on gameplay alone.

[@george60m38]

Some of them look substantially more better than others I guess

[@killer92173]

8:20 "Don't tell me what to do!" I just find that really funny for some reason. Lol

[@StoMoComedoPro]

Dang, I was hoping Retro would get to 64 points haha

[@parkerlee1893]

Hahahahhahahahahhhhhhahhahahahahhahahahhhhahahahaha

[@AnnanKamrans]

64 points: 1 stack of points

[@StoMoComedoPro]

@@owengibson5191 Yes, and hey, my comment is almost at 64 likes haha!

[@Suavs]

Almost 64 likes

[@StoMoComedoPro]

@@Suavs Yes, just 2 away

[@kotavelaz1987]

I think "shell shock" might've been changed because it was an actual thing that happened to people during WWI. At least that's the best thing I can come up with.

[@cubah1]

Or wants to separate themselves from the TMNT.

[@lemonadesnake]

Nico: Its just the same game with newer graphics, tie Also Nico: Its the same game but looks better, reboot

[@Ryno12345able]

Also he said that you are able to cheat at some games in the game but he still gave the remake the point, I call recency bias

[@marshall3314]

11:36 loved how you kept that "song" 🤣🤣🤣

[@luisandrescasassapalomino4737]

Nico: Not much has changed in Honeycomb Havoc... Coin: Oh, so you're ignoring me? I see how it is...

[@raythepretentiousnerd]

He likes the new version more because it has no coins.

[@wohao_gaster7434]

Nico: "Flash forward looks really good in HD" Nico 5 seconds later: "This one was already HD because it's from the Wii-U era"

[@mariajimenafigueroa233]

Thanks for not putting "X, Also X", that format used to be funny but it became a cheap way for commenters to get a ton of likes. So this is a breath of fresh air.

[@wohao_gaster7434]

@@mariajimenafigueroa233 np

[@robbiewalker2831]

8:12: You don't have to do that anymore, because they fixed the configuration problem with the control sticks, so that you can rotate it fast enough with just your thumb.

[@slyar]

"I'm all for difficulty, reboot!" "Doubling the A presses? Garbage. Retro!" Cough cough

[@denie_the_eemental_fighter7254]

I kinda agree because the heads in look away are so cute!

[@christopheredwards788]

Seeing DK play the minigames from MP 5-9 is satisfying.

[@asxmeggy5049]

It's the ultimate Mario party collection

[@FrostReach66]

almost… no GameCube boards and a huge emphasis on N64 minigames… should have more!

[@chadliterutherford9198]

@@FrostReach66 Mario Party 6 is still the GOAT they should just give 6 the HD treatment with some other Cube minigames thrown in

[@Ruizon1]

I find the switch version to actually be a little harder to control on most games. It moves much faster and seems to float more when you jump making the kicks harder to perform on the levels that allow it. I miss the platforming minigames and think that a couple of them should have been included.

[@TAYBR00K]

I've never really been a Mario Party guy but Superstars does look good.

[@luigielite6857]

You've really been a Mario Party guy?

[@TAYBR00K]

@@luigielite6857 Sorry typo

[@redx4361]

fun af lmao

[@chonperez9890]

By the the way in the chip shot challenge if you get a hole in one, lakitu holds a sgin saying nice, but it didn't return in the remake and top 100.

[@colingznetworkplus4618]

Monty’s revenge is pretty good

[@Diceyed]

Yeah, there are some confusing choices there. Omitting balancing and other features. Tidal Toss got improved 1 player effects. River Raiders lost the fun sliding animation at the end. It felt like this list was more of a "here are Nico's preferred games" but still i thank you for your work and this was cool to see.

[@cubah1]

Yeah, tidal toss for big time improved. It has less IFrames making it harder for the 3 players to walk forward

[@Sp3ctralI]

Look away remake wins in the way of the other teammates looking pissed at the one who looked the wrong way. But Yeah, why they didn’t just do heads is beyond me

[@mariajimenafigueroa233]

Full bodies is better then just heads

[@D1TB01]

Wow, I literally thought that this video would have no commentary from reading the title alone lmao. I only disagree with like 5 of the choices, didn’t keep track of which ones I disagreed, but I agree with everything else. Oh, and that pizza minigame actually made me remember that Nico is called NicoBBQ, cause most of his other recent videos aren’t about junk food, or even mention them at all

[@pikmintopia]

Nice vid, I love this channel and have just ordered Mario Party Superstars! I'm so hyped, its gonna arrive tomorrow!!

[@emme0731]

I think I most disagree with Balloon Burst, I really like how frantic it was on the N64 and hitting the sweet spot where you pump fast but not TOO fast to get tje best pumps was super fun. Now it just feels slow and boring to me

[@rockmanzeromodernday941]

I frantically press buttons to win by the way, or some good luck overall...

[@Ethansgames32]

I’m going to get the game for Christmas 🎄.

[@henrycarrillo7354]

Nintendo:(make bad Mario party for a while) People: Boo Nintendo: (make a good Mario party) People:yay

[@mtj8870]

Dude really said retro bumper balls is better when it literally always ends in a tie

[@shortsyt6071]

0:15 but mario party 9 and 10 are way different and fun! Even the best lol

[@ChrisVetro]

Boulder balls is so much better in the reboot because you don,t fall down nearly as far than in the retro making it much more fair.

[@Animefan20044]

This was uploaded on my birthday.

[@jtorres1764]

This game needs a massive amount of DLC. You can easily get tired of the maps and characters within days.

[@luisandrescasassapalomino4737]

In Balloon Burst, the Bowser balloon was very expresive, Retro!

[@cubah1]

Wait, how can some game be a tie and others be better just because they look better on the switch. By that logic, there should be no ties because all the games look better on the switch.

[@bananman9061]

this dood seriously did judge a game on how bad he is at it even tho he kept judging them on looks

[@courage1363]

I agree since he thinks Crazy Cutters are a FREAKIN TIE, well i beg to differ since they completely changed the shapes of all the enemies to make it a little tougher to win the minigame and they officially confirmed that you have to get the best accuracy than to cut the outside of the line now like the original, and plus Bumper Balls are no longer ties if theres more than 1 player remain now.

[@KL53986]

I love how the DLC statement ages like milk.

[@Light-Rock97]

Fun fact. Shell Shocked is the original name for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. There's a great George Carlin routine on this ever present softening of language through the years. Probably why Nintendo changed it here.

[@taraedwards-white5189]

You forgot something. The original Honeycomb Havoc has coins.

[@vince11harris]

I mean it looking better is not a valid reason to give it to the reboot. Of course it’s gonna look better it’s been over 20 years😂

[@Imaproshaman7]

Didn't expect this video, so nice.

[@colingznetworkplus4618]

Tipsy Tourney is pretty good

[@Gustavo-po9bd]

The winner has better graphics, has Online, is more balanced and it's funnier

[@MDE128]

You should make a DLC prediction video. I hope Nintendo adds more boards such as the GameCube boards, and I would like it much more.

[@ROYBGB]

I hope that they add more Mario Party 8 mini-games.

[@haquer325mh9]

@@ROYBGB ye, also koopas tycoon town board has to come back

[@ShursGarden]

Piranha Pursuit is the same. You can *only* jump over the rocks and just mash the B button in both versions, and still win.

[@kinguman308]

Mario Party: The Top 100: who are you? Mario Party Superstars: I'm u but better

[@luisandrescasassapalomino4737]

The tiles in Squared Away had a lot of more designs, and in Superstars, only one...BRUH! Retro!

[@lemonadesnake]

fun fact: the space ships in the leaf minigame are the same ones in the Mario Party 9 launch break minigame

[@markymark443]

4:06 what about the fact that it's not stupidly easy anymore to get a hole in one every time? The reboot is definitely better.

[@Dertoilet]

He uses Yoshi in every game

[@abrahamuribe4581]

How about superstars vs original vs the top 100

[@Mattbuddy0947]

I find the Minigames good in HD and 2, 4 and 6 was my Favorite Mario Party and OMG the Minigames are real cool but i find they edit a Little bit more Minigames from MP9 and MP10 I missed even the bosses from MP9 and the Story island from MP1 but this Mario Party is good

[@robertthechannel1799]

You take a Macy’s Float over an Expressive Balloon? Weird choice…

[@vladulo7649]

You know how much the old games cost and you want to throw them în the trash?Are you crazy?!1

[@grayelephent3633]

One name idea for Shell Shock is Cannon Chaos.

[@grayelephent3633]

Oops

[@grayelephent3633]

They used tanks but I call them cannons because a tank is a cannon on wheels, kinda

[@ezzekesmith2058]

Your joking right the music in look away is fire

[@Desinteresad0]

Classic shy guy says is more exiting. A and B made it easier to miss. So you had to keep double track.

[@PizzaSmiter]

How retro was so much better!?!!?

[@jacksgaming3039]

I love the reference to his video omnomnomnomnom at eatsa pizza

[@xxroyalprincexx6811]

8:14 You should listen to what the warning message said, you don't want to risk breaking your controller.

[@jayzorplays9081]

bob the prahna plant returns once again

[@nintendoboy3605]

Shouldn't Mecha Marathon have a point for the reboot cause the computers dont cheat anymore?

[@fionatony]

The fish in the retro version in Cheep Cheep chase is a big cheep cheep too because of the name of the minigame

[@antonystephanprancis405]

stairs were added to spotlight swim in the superstars version

[@Georgio_POG]

I think Mario party 10 just had the colors look different That’s just my thought tho

[@luisandrescasassapalomino4737]

Just like in Tube It or Lose It, Chip-Shot Challenge also had character-colored golf clubs, also, Lakitu would hold a "Nice" sign if you get a Hole-in-One. No more character-colored golf clubs, no more 69 jokes!? C'mon Nintendo! My point goes to the Retro!

[@julietaddo5261]

This is soo funny he keeps on saying. Tie every time

[@zachguyette3849]

I find it add that there’s hardly any MP8 mini games, but there’s lots of MP9 & 10

[@grayelephent3633]

I dunno why but I think the reboot keeps getting points for having shiny/better graphics

[@TicyPhenylFanClub]

I don't like that they ruined the cool fly guy colors in the wind-up mashing game

[@mariajimenafigueroa233]

That's with every minigame from 1 to 5, they used to have character colors for the objects (Mario: Red, Peach: Pink, Yoshi: Green, Luigi: Dark Green or Blue, etc). However, from Mario Party 6 and onward, they changed the objects to use players colors (P1: Red (Blue in some games), P2: Blue (Red in some games), P3: Green and P4: Yellow). What makes this so unnecessary is that the others Mario spin-offs still used character colors for their karts, tennis rackets and others stuff. So, why have this changed for Mario Party?

[@adam_1i1]

If you said you can sell it for 2 dollars, so i can buy from you Mario party 9 XD

[@leafycrossing4755]

Burnstile is not the best Doom and Gloom minigame. That's Granite Getaway.

[@cookie1004]

I love the new Super Mario Party game

[@louannatapia7466]

This is going to be good

[@colingznetworkplus4618]

Mario Party 6 is still the best Mario Party

[@remusserediuc9896]

The retro pokey pummel is more responsive. Now, fast mashing is worse than regular mashing because it can't pick up the inputs in the switch version. Retro

[@theotherdashmelted]

If there is one, add the top 100 reboot :)

[@AndrewHD711]

Wow, you give a point to the original cat minigame just because of no big boi heads popping out of cars. It should be a tie because the gameplay is the same

[@lielaniemations8438]

Bruh in the thing where you get the box the new is better bc its balance and fair

[@SpookyAppy1234]

NicoWhen I played archer the ultra was a computer and I won because I was on the other team

[@israelgamerfan1162]

Great awesome video like always nico a great way to start the weekend 😊

[@NutNutNotNot]

F in chat for Croozing for a broozing

[@yoshistar8985]

My switch froze on bumper balls (I think this is called a soft lock) right at the end of the minigame when everyone died. So I was treated to just the wind blowing and an empty stage and it stopped there

[@supermariof0521]

I still don't get why they continue to call "Toadstool Titan", "Mush Pit".

[@courage1363]

Its probably because they dont want to get sued by the person who made the Manga Attack of Titan or something like that

[@supermariof0521]

@@courage1363 Really? That person trademarked the word, "Titan"?

[@Gustavo-po9bd]

I can't throw the old games in the trash because they were downloaded for free

[@superagaming_064]

Can you also do a comparaison with the 3ds version of Mario party superstars AKA Mario party the top 100 AKA Mario party the top 100 vs original

[@markymark443]

ummmmm Piranha's Pursuit was equally as unbalanced on the N64 as it is in Superstars lmao. Literally no difference.

[@colingznetworkplus4618]

Tidal toss is so good

[@justinebidulopoutchini9774]

Love this game so much!

[@m.d._doe]

11:36 That was the seconds video Nico posted

[@Sp3ctralI]

Tracing one should’ve kept the color coded markers for each character

[@ezzekesmith2058]

Am I the only one who finds Mario party 10 to be the best one it’s so entertaining ngl (I’ve played both superstars and 10 this is not rigged)

[@gamereviewsandotherstufftoo]

Cool vid, these are the vids that keep me always looking forward for the next great Nicobbq vid!

[@antonystephanprancis405]

the paths of peril reboot was more better because of the opera music in the superstars version of the minigame

[@DarkAngelEU]

Do I need 4 joy cons if I wanna play this with 4 people, or can we just pass the controller taking turns?

[@thecoltenchannel]

One detail removed /added nico: PoinT gOretrO

[@TheArcoBoii]

2:59 The beehive thing looks like from animal crossing

[@ekbosch4]

the charecters sportsmen ship was good with mario party 9

[@HOLyBarney1]

Mario have a movie yay

[@colingznetworkplus4618]

Bounce and Trounce is so much fun!

[@goldenyoshistar1]

It is possible to win as the 3 in that minigame (8:38)

[@goldenyoshistar1]

9:52 I've won as the single player In SuperStars

[@Kakerate2]

3:14 did they change this game in the reboot? I swear you used to be able to collide a small ball with a big one and they'd cancel out. No longer the case now.

[@JorgeRomero.3]

3:00 That is all that matters :) Edit: Pt. 2 at 5:23

[@anaisabeja3592]

Obviously the switch version will win it has hd graphics and it plays better