Maruti Suzuki XL6 vs Kia Carens - Which is the best MPV? | Comparison | Autocar India

[@saipraneeth9589]

Recently we bought xl6 alpha+ mt red n balck dual tone and we drove from visakhapatnam to chennai 864km one side and to drive it was fun and very satisfied to drive its smooth and reaponsive and i didnt find any problem to overtake we got a mileage of 21.2 km with full load of boot and 4people with 80-90 kmph. Totally we are very much satisfied with xl6

[@ducatimultistradav4850]

I like the way how Autocar India is not comparing the standards of MPV to a radical SUV.. Both are meant for totally different set of buyers...

[@amartyabasu1220]

Bought the top manual XL6 in October '22 and this video isn't making me regret it. More than ok with the power deficit, love the mileage (getting 20+ on some drives but usually between 15 and 18) and the service. 3 Lakhs and the waiting time were a huge deal for me.

[@stark469]

I bought Kia Carens 2 months back and fully satisfied with the performance it offered. I went to Bhimashankar with full 7 peoples capacity and luggage. It performed exceptionally well specially in uphill twist turns. And while downhilling it's steering feedback was amazing. Fuel is the little bit concern here maybe it will be better with next service. Pros - Better AC controls every seat has 1 AC along with spread and direct flow options which is advantage in this indian heat. Smooth and powerful steering feedback. All disc break makes breaking really better. Tried and tested on hills. Premium interior finishing makes feel good factor enhanced. Bigger and better infotainment touchscreen systems is really good. Entry to 3rd row witu just 1 button click seats folds. Cons - Fuel economy is less compared to Ertiga. My opinion on fuel may change with next service but yeah it is what it is at the moment

[@uthams2]

I recently did a 1500+ km round trip, Bangalore to Kochi to Munnar and back the same route in the 1.4 turbo manual Carens, and my friends who travelled with me were trumped with how good the car is, in terms of fit, finish, feel, quality, ride comfort, power, everything

[@sayanmaity4788]

Can we compare the comfort with the innova. Because i am planning for the carens nd we have a 16yr old innova nd the new gen is overbudget

[@deepikasrivastava1964]

You should compare 1.5 litre engine of XL6 to the 1.5 litre engine of Carens, because that would be fare and the current is not because you are comparing naturally aspirated to turbocharged.

[@JagannathMoorthy]

I bought my XL6 back in 2021 when the Karens was not launched. Even the XL6 was the earlier version, so I bought the base manual variant over the older 4 speed auto. However, if I was buying today, I'd probably still buy the XL6 auto because the thing that is more important is space. I find the space in the 3rd row and even the luggage compartment to be stellar in the XL6. You need to go up to the Innova level to get more space.

[@samfisher515]

Maruti seats are comfortable. Engine is very reliable

[@kowshikselvam]

XL6 is one of the Best MPV which i have been using from the past 2.5 years. Mileage friendly I'm getting an average of 15-17. Service cost is less. Like they said in power differences you don't felt that lag. Overall XL6 is best value for money.

[@Auchitya01]

I have booked XL6 in the first week of Feb. Hopefully will receive the car on Holi. In my opinion, if you travel with your family (5-6 people) frequently, then go for Carens. But if you have usage like me where once in a while you need the 6 seater option then go for XL6 because it drives like a bigger hatchback and doesn't feel heavy or like a big car while driving. A few more points to note: the waiting period for the base models of Carens is too high (more than 8 months) and the mileage is of course much better in XL6.

[@soham3679]

Me too....but the only confusion is that wheather the engine will be bs6 phase 2 complient or not...will the engine support upcomming E20 petrol??

[@samfisher515]

Maruti cars are reliable and tension free.

[@Auchitya01]

@@soham3679 Don't think so. K15C is the same 1500cc engine used in Brezza, Vitara etc. So, don't think it will support E20 petrol.

[@Auchitya01]

@@samfisher515 True. Hence, the preference over Kia.

[@TheZenith790]

@@Auchitya01 my 14 year old alto is running on e20 petrol ( i believe we have already achieved 20 percent mixing.....i read somewhere in the news) so there shud be no fuss about the e20 petrol

[@borisloki5833]

Watched every video in KZbin about cars.. Successfully brought XL6 automatic.. Love it.. Me and my family

[@ravi0389]

I own Kia Carens and it is best in all ways .. Super comfortable .. Modern design. premium feel

[@abhigyanbg5764]

Are you a doctor?

[@RohanSingh-ng6zc]

But those ac vents( looks weird and vintage) and seat comfort is not good

[@ravi0389]

@@abhigyanbg5764 No I am not a doctor

[@praveenpgec]

@Rohan Singh but they look good na. 🤣

[@abymathew295]

KIA as a brand is the prime example of how to design and build a car for Indian mass market.. Once a totally Alien brand to us, now turned the entire indian car market upside down, While Major players like Ford, Harley just quit after years of experience in India...WHAT A SHAME.

[@Vishnu-ji7sh]

The difference of 3 lakhs u mentioned is on the ex showroom which means its around 4 lakhs plus costlier than xl6 on road .diesel at full options costs near 24 from march.

[@eeshachandrapupadhya9160]

I'd rather get an Ertiga, I'll have total peace of mind. All necessary things I need are available and it'll be a lot cheaper.

[@kaival5]

Go for carens prestige model 1.5 na engine

[@vikanshvashist5121]

I purchase XL6 in 2021, the car is very good in terms of mileage and space. If I talk about the space then it is very good but if you are not using 6 seats everyday but for a family trip it quiet good and if i talk about the mileage then it is giving me approx 15-16 in city drive and 19-20 on highway if I use cruise control but it depends on your driving. As a owner i recommend that it was a value for money product.👍

[@krishlandge3574]

The main reason to buy carens is available of Diesel engine that is best part of it

[@psvasu23]

Somehow i felt that the verdict was given at the beginning itself !!!

[@ShubhoBose]

If I had stretch to 17 lakhs to get the Carens, I would just get the new Innova.

[@daniel-oc2kz]

Ertiga over both. Reliable, cheaper and practical

[@MrXxx008]

And also kills. U missed that part

[@jainamshah9497]

@@MrXxx008 aagaya tata ka choda

[@OmFreeRadical]

@@MrXxx008

[@iamshanif]

​@@MrXxx008 it has the same safety rating as these cars

[@V_S_Meti]

@@MrXxx008 Once watch recent carens accident videos. Even ertiga build quality is better than your plastic box Carens.

[@chaitanyachaurasia]

excellent review, my suggestion is that if you can include the warranty periods of the cars as mpv are used majorly for mile munching so having a longer warranty is surely a plus point

[@chandrasekhar4449]

If that is the case, then safari is just 3 lakhs above Kia carens and the best one and better features and safety too. Why don’t you compare with that ?

[@AkhilWalavalkar]

I was thinking that too.. 3 lakhs is a big amount, so in that way there can be comparison with Alcazar, Safari and XUV700 as well and even triber at the lower end. Basically cost matters a lot I feel.

[@90zkid]

India needs 5 star mpvs. Both these cars are good but 3 star crash ratings are a big bummer.i myself was going to book xl6 AT but changed my mind, now saving money to buy a safari.

[@gopalakrishnanraman475]

Maruti Suzuki should give 4 disc brakes to the xl6 alpha plus variant at least.

[@AkhilWalavalkar]

The last line of 3 lakhs more I guess makes a big difference.. 3 lakhs is a substantial difference. Maruti needs to bring sportier versions of their cars. Don't know why they don't get their turbo engines to india. Better Safety rating n a turbo engine is all they need. (And a sunroof I guess 😉😉)

[@chandrachurniyogi8394]

both the XL6 & KIA Carens could do with front & rear lateral strut bars for greater torsional rigidity & enhanced stiffening . . . resulting in more sure footed handling on twisty roads . . . a retuned suspension calibration will be an added benefit . . . the Carens could do with a pair of proper forward facing multi-adjustable leather trimmed captain seats . . .

[@biswadeepmahapatra6204]

Innova hycross is a much better option compared to higher models of carens . Further Kia is not known for it's built quality.

[@zenjm6496]

Neither is Innova.

[@VersatileStrings]

Diesel engine specs for Carens were not mentioned ?

[@Madhavan_kkl]

Carens is the best I would say..

[@अभय_अग्रवाल]

3 star safety rating 🤧 tata, mahindra, & skoda please bring something to this segment

[@peanutbutterjelly1368]

Mahindra had one and it bunked quite heavily.

[@amaljoe367]

@@peanutbutterjelly1368 which one? The shark inspired family mpv? 😂

[@OmFreeRadical]

@@peanutbutterjelly1368 marazzo?

[@SuyashKaul]

You forgot Marazzo like the market did ? 🙈

[@peanutbutterjelly1368]

@@OmFreeRadical yes

[@manoja538]

Carens feel like a more premium, luxury car than XL6

[@ducatimultistradav4850]

Carens is better in every way... But seriously both need improvement in safety...

[@praveenpgec]

Ok, be safe on your ducati 😃

[@pawangolevlogger]

XL6 is much better looking, better at crash test rating of 4 stars ( as built on a same platform as Ertiga), more fuel efficient (Maruti legacy), affordable than Carens, also the variants line up is much more understandable than complicated one’s on the Kia’s…

[@rudrak9101]

Agreed

[@SuyashKaul]

4 stars? Which universe? With the current updated norms, it will decrease to 2 while Carens can increase to 4 stars now

[@rudrak9101]

@@SuyashKaul Carens lene se accha scorpio n lena z6

[@manoja538]

Variants line up? Its easy when you offer only one engine...the carens comes in 3 engine options

[@aakashchoudhuri]

One doesn't even need to watch till the end to know the verdict by Autocar India. It is quite an absolute fact that Carens is leagues ahead of the XL6. Unless and until Maruti Suzuki ditches the "kitna deti hai" and "utilitarian" philosophy, it will continue to push average and basic amenities in its Nexa vehicles, thereby completely going against the premium platter that Maruti wants to offer to customers from its Nexa offerings.

[@MukeshMukesh-bz8pk]

Amazing small but thoughtful n practical features provided by kia in Karens just that 3 star rating is a big cons

[@prayasdash]

And I'd say, these cars are far better choice than Creta and Seltos type cars. Like literally, they're so comfy with adequate enough performance and get all required features....If u rly want performance get a sedan, instead of spending 24 lakhs on Creta it's better to spend on these.

[@TotalySidYT]

What about the Alcazar?? Even though it's similar to the Carens

[@pganmol]

Does it has Cruz control?

[@mahendra_akshaj]

Kia Carens interors are damn good n hv wow factor, xl6 is ertiga xcept head n tail lights

[@nostalgia9000]

Damn good but you sit on a stone😄😄n drive

[@Auchitya01]

Except for Headlight, tail lamp, 16-inch alloy wheels, all-black interiors, cruise control and the list goes on actually.

[@zenjm6496]

I like the instrument cluster on the XL6. It looks like it's been designed after an expensive watch of sorts. And the one on Carens is the worst design choice in an otherwise beautiful car. It looks like they took inspiration from Casio calculators. It looks awful.

[@P_95-77]

The carens it is more powerful more premium looking looks better is the longest in class cons bad safety headlight is weird not able to penetrate in night

[@kushsaraogi]

This Shud Answer Everybody's Questions .. The Perfect Video for those who travel with a Full Load .. My Personal Fav For Full Loader- KIA CARENS .. 🫡. I like the Conventional XL6, But In Terms of Features & Practicality & Also Ride Comfort| Refinement I Wud Pick the Carens .. ♥️

[@ramrajv]

Thanks for the great comparison. I would like to know about the maintenance costs comparison too. Can you include this into your video?

[@prakhar1259]

Difference between xl6 and ertiga?

[@kamalseth2322]

Carens best

[@dhruvshetty.95]

Loved the way the review was done, but i think it's a little unfair to compare the Xl6's 1.5 engine with the 1.4 engine of the Karens. Maybe another review with both of their 1.5 petrol manuals?

[@adityabhardwaj2237]

Xl6 1.5 is far better also the carens 2nd and 3rd row seats have no under thigh support so in terms of an MPV xl6 is clearly better

[@prakyathprakash5180]

Karens 1.5 is available only in the Base version, so it doesn't make sense to compare this with premium versions of XL6. Also the 1.4L is the real deal bcz it comes with a Turbo engine and is more powerful than the 1.5.

[@prasaddeshmukh0073]

XL6 is a Very Good Choice though the top model price is way too high Rs 17 lakh in road Pune

[@ashleygreen4244]

Look how crew members were trying to avoid Front camera while sitting inside 😂. That's funny!!

[@inRadhaKrishnaITrust]

It’s high time we Indians should let go of our obsession for Maruti before it’s too late. The global ncap ratings of swift and other Maruti hatchbacks already has proven how unsafe and cheap their build quality is. I myself own a 2019 Ertiga and I know how irritating it feels when fully loaded. Despite of a 1.5 l power train it feels so freaking underwhelming. I truly wish Carens had launched back in 2019 😢

[@Scither-]

Don’t fake it, i have driven both the cars on lease xl6 can do ghats on 3rd gear with ac on with almost full load and Kia has to down shift 😂. Kia is also good but if you compare ertiga and kia’s price you can buy fuel in ertiga for almost 5 year between the price gap for top spec with almost same features.😬

[@chanduramgopalakrishnan8765]

Actually what's the real purpose of a sunroof ?

[@raghu87animator]

When both cars are standing next to each other xl6 is smaller in height than carens but in details it shows vice versa??? Howz it possible??? Infact seating height is also higher than xl6..??!!!!

[@uthams2]

We got both in petrol guise, manual. I like the Carens over the XL6. The only place where the XL 6 is MARGINALLY, repeat marginally better is the seat comfort. For me it’s Carens PS: the Carens is 1.4 turbo

[@nagarajuj]

Never seen this one vedio..thanks

[@rutvijhedamba3908]

Yours videos are good, informative. You should try it in hindi.U will find more views and likes.

[@Unknown.Anonymous.]

The fact Maruti Suzuki india doesn't have a diesel engine across its offerings is very unfortunate. Even Carens Petrol has a much more powerful engine than XL6 And diesel is just too good.

[@RockerRoy]

I m missing marazzo in this comparison.mahindra should have worked on the feature list of marazzo and special on the pararomic sunroof. Mahindra u spoiled the great product

[@versusbattle5916]

What's the mileage for both? If anyone knows That shall alson matter a lot right?

[@MohammedSiddique03]

Kia's 1.4l turbo returns 9 - 10 kmpl on Highways with full load on the other hand XL6 1.5l NA returns 17- 18 Kmpl on Highways

[@navinkumar6388]

I feel carens is better than tribe. But haven't driven Ertiga or XL6. I feel Carens has less power than my XUV300 W8 2020 model

[@prajwalggowda5599]

After bs6 phase 2 1.4 turbo will not be offered in carens as per my knowledge

[@andrewm340i]

They will replace it with 1.5 l turbo soon

[@Aslam-xd3hu]

Xl6 ❤❤❤

[@shreyank4087]

I think what maruti needs is to add a turbo to their 1.5 liter engine

[@CTR2K]

Why why...when we have Triber best 3rd row seat 🎻

[@venukrithish007]

Sure but lack of power. Let's see if the turbo comes out

[@amaljoe367]

@@venukrithish007 might be coming soon. Nissan is going to launch triber based mpv soon

[@lokesh3428]

Marazoo best in segment luxurious Marazoo

[@paulpmathew847]

Exterior is good with XL6 than carens. Exterior of carens looks not classy.

[@rohitrao2812]

I will pick XL6.

[@taranshupattnaiktp3335]

If I would buy an MPV, I will choose none of them, because they are unsafe with 3 stars. I would rather save some money and get a Renault Triber. It is not powerful, t's engine isn't that strong, and won't feel premium as these unsafe MPVs, but it is decently well equipped, well pacakged and also most importantly, hs a 4 star safety.

[@dhanunjayd7857]

How about Kia build quality . I saw most of Kia build quality worst

[@amaljoe367]

Atleast better than maruti build quality I'd say

[@riteshnets]

The KIA feels a generation above the Xl6.So the price is justified.But terrible safety rstings for cars that are supposed to move families on risky indian highways.Thats a big deterrent.

[@abdulhakeem5381]

Kia & hyundai and automobile comparisons the winner is a fore gone conclusion 😬

[@fuzzylogger]

The Maruti twins are so boring interior wise. Also the service centre experience is really good at Kia.

[@ravi1447]

Comparing NA engine with Turbo petrol and complaining about lack in power.. don't know how logical it is.

[@someshbhalerao]

Diesel is not the future for Cars. Thanks Maruti for bringing XL6 in CNG, others should learn.

[@LUFFY09789]

Now, some people will come to give their knowledge about the now discontinued Mahindra Marazzo and Tata Hexa.

[@psvasu23]

Am not sure what's the thing about not having a type C usb port !!!! Are we buying a phone or a car??? We should not be even talking about what type of USB port is provided....!!!

[@amiteshbiswas7212]

Price matters!carens is expensive and low mileage.

[@vachan7069]

Suzuki is Pappu of 7 Seater cars in India

[@sameerraj5800]

I think that blue-shirt man was in trakin auto. I wonder why he left that channel. I was watching his every video there, but now the new person in trakin auto is not that good.

[@girishmani8577]

That bloody power window switch on xl6 came from 1947

[@KiranKumar-cg3yg]

Carens is the Winner.

[@omnostarmobilityINDIA]

Innova 😝🙌

[@boonswithbenedictions8468]

Carens kia way better.

[@sanurawat1651]

But XL6 looks bigger but its not

[@shantanubagchi1]

Carens is far far better than xl6. It's a no competition actually

[@MsRohitesh]

Both are unsafe

[@simonjoseph92]

MPV? Oh yeah just buy the Innova. 😂

[@manoja538]

Carens supremacy

[@tipusultan6342]

First comment

[@binohuan1162]

XL6 feels like a 2015 car. It is dated and poorly put together. And tbh the third row is worse than even the ertiga

[@thegreenbay..7930]

cant help out guys, its in our DNA , we indians still love neighbour wife when u married to beautiful women then her.😉

[@abhaychaturvedi650]

Safety is big disappointment with 3 stars

[@ommahajan1210]

I CAME FROM MOTOROCTANE CHANEL ... I LIKE YOUR REVIEWS MORE THAN , THEM BUT I DONT YOUR VIDEO LOOK LITTLE DARKER I DONT LIKE THIS

[@Ashish_Deotale]

XL6 garibo ki Innova hai 😂😂😂😂

[@ruchitagawade3573]

No for both

[@binuamKochi]

Xl6 looks mightier... Karens from back... Looks feeble

[@adarshbhavihal8658]

Both mid

[@vamsiakkineni4498]

Both are dabbasssssssss

[@V_S_Meti]

Even Ertiga/ XL6 build quality is better than Carens plastic ka dabba. Don't buy Kia cars. boycott Kia.

[@nayanekbote1255]

none of this score 5star in safety so why we have to consider this useless cars ..?

[@sagarmudrale7530]

2 cars build quality Zero 👎👎

[@blackcloud1990]

None, because they’re both crap at safety !

[@rakeshchoubey823]

Ofcourse carens