Podcast 07 | IIT Bombay professors on Mathematics in India | Ft. Krishnan S. and Niranjan B. | Eng

[@abhishekmajumder6582]

This is the kind of podcast the country needs...

[@tp_2o23]

most useful comment here ..

[@randomguywhatever]

Couldn't agree more

[@ajittiwari2331]

Right

[@diwakarpant4664]

IITs are so over rated.....Can you imagine these so called genius people cant solve the pollution problem of indian cties...

[@tp_2o23]

@@diwakarpant4664 yup fair point.... i just saw on news that the "Yamuna" has toxic foam all over it - wow - great going - the care and stupidity it staggering - keep destriying the env - good job

[@jackram123]

The true GEMS of India, incredible humility despite accomplishing such tall feats in Mathematics....hats off to to prof Niranjan and Krishnan....you make all of us proud!

[@mohammadinamullah9380]

India needs to develop mathematics based economy because mathematics has it's application in every sphere of human activities.

[@balbirsingh.]

Very true sir❤🎉

[@dhwanitashar1684]

We don't have a single credible masters programme in econometrics, (except ISI MSQE), and most students get into private sector rather than policy making.

[@aritradasgupta4461]

Prof. Niranjan took my interview for the PhD program in IITB. Even though I wasn’t selected, I genuinely appreciate how supportive he was throughout the interview and open to my propositions and claims. I came out of it thinking what a nice person I had on the panel. Glad to see a longer conversation with him here!

[@Ckar-n7t]

Humble request, do you remember some questions. Would be grateful, if you can tell some.

[@Dragon-xe2fr]

​@@Ckar-n7t he is lying might be cause he hasn't replied 😂💀

[@Maverick-i5e]

Questions please

[@Dragon-xe2fr]

@@Maverick-i5e why Mediterranean orchids shows an astonishing resemblance with bumble bees what is the exact mechanism of such evolutionary change ???

[@rimurutempest2130]

Bro what were you planning for , I want to pursue as well . Also mention why IITB and future scopes

[@Maths_3.1415]

I’m incredibly proud to have had the privilege of speaking with Arjun Gupta, the IMO medallist. It was an inspiring experience! ❤

[@anshumanawasthi8693]

Arjun Gupta is really a genius, what did you spoke to him?

[@Maths_3.1415]

​@@anshumanawasthi8693 Look, I discussed a lot of different topics with him, and it's really hard to mention all of them in the comment section. But to confirm that I really talked to Arjun Gupta, I was one of the members of the official IMO 2024 WhatsApp group.

[@anshumanawasthi8693]

@@Maths_3.1415 ohh, I thought u met him somewhere and then had a little conversation with him. Arjun is really brilliant and inspiration for upcoming IMO participants.

[@Maths_3.1415]

​​@@anshumanawasthi8693 All six members of the Indian IMO 2024 team performed their best and will be an inspiration for all mathematics enthusiasts. One day, India will also receive the Fields Medal.

[@saurabhsuman7417]

I also had an opportunity to have lectures from Arjun

[@samyakgupta5773]

although im not very good at math im always interested and fascinated by people who are highly knowledgable in it

[@nrusimha11]

Thanks!

[@devendersinghattri4654]

Mathematics has always my bugbear since childhood! I had many douts in my mind but could not be clarified mostly due to fear of asking questions from teachers but some extent due to inexperienced teachers. First doubt I l i got was - 2+2=4, 2×2=4 meaning that multiplication & addition is the same. But why 2×0=0. Similarly, was the circumference of the circle ! I had sneaking suspicion that if we convert circle in to a straight line, length of the line should be the equal to the circumference! But I never ventured to ask this doubt to be clarified from teacher nor the teacher ever tried to !!!! But I clarified this dout at my own after retirement. My point is to say that at the initial level where we need the most experienced teachers- there are the least experienced.

[@deepakbharadwaj5590]

Loved it.... my daughter who is in class 4th listened to it along with me. Hope i am able to inspire he to be as good as you all are. Thanks for bringing this incredible talk

[@robustk1220]

Hopefully you will be a good parent and let your kid decide her future. Good luck.

[@Ishanmathur-l8g]

​@@robustk1220 he said 'inspire' so he might be

[@H_A-q2r]

​@@Ishanmathur-l8gIn India, parent saying "inspire" means... pushing.

[@deepakbharadwaj5590]

@@H_A-q2r agree she is young for podcast....I was watching it so she joined in. I was explaining to her what they were talking about. I was just trying to challenge her thinking. Appreciate your point

[@dharma2025]

If she can sit and listen to this podcast, then I am sure she already is brilliant. Just remember what the professor in the blue shirt said. He said that even if I was not a mathematician, I know I would be the best in whatever I do. That's the basic mantra they need for their entire life and you will see how they blossom even beyond our expectations.

[@jigsaw2281]

1 International Mathematical Olympiad 2 International Physics Olympiad 3 International Chemistry Olympiad 4 International Olympiad in Informatics 5 International Biology Olympiad 6 International Philosophy Olympiad 7 International Astronomy Olympiad 8 International Geography Olympiad 9 International Linguistics Olympiad 11 International Earth Science Olympiad 12 International Olympiad on Astronomy and Astrophysics Inko bhi bula do sir

[@rajanipurandare8307]

Thank you for getting mathematicians from IITon board. Everybody needs to compete weather wins or loses. Not only for MIT Harvard. It relates to every thing we do in life Numbers game. Vernacular schools in free India we were good at it. We did not have this type of competition. Thank you for all you guys Hard Work. Thank you you all from Delaware USA

[@MaheshPatil-lr7wv]

Tx for having mathematician on ur podcast,no one did this before.

[@Maths_3.1415]

This is one of the most amazing podcasts I’ve ever seen. Thank you very much for creating it for all of us!

[@suryanshbhadoriya2109]

One of the best podcasts for maths lovers or for the one who wants to be Mathematician

[@rajendralekhwar4131]

Most awaited podcasts.. Among all podcasters , Nityanand misra sir .. Essentially, because u bring mathematicians to the podcasts.. I love to see the conversation of mathematicians , physicists , ( in general , men of all kind of pure sciences) , philosophers , polymath people, sanatan philosophy… Scholars of Veds etc … U took interview of gold medalist 2024, Rushil Mathur , as well.. which has again been the superb one ..👌🏻👌🏻 Pls keep inviting our such prodigies, sir … Younger generation will be very grateful to you…

[@goidol]

We can motivate at rural level participation of students by making elementary mathematics a fun experience and organising mathematics festival on weekly basis on village level.

[@AdityaGupta-ms5hy]

both of them have taught me. prof krishnan combinatorics and prof niranjan data structure.

[@archieus7752]

Great to have representation of mathematicians! I was one of those who never heard about the Olympiads until it was too late. Luckily I did join ISI nonetheless. Statistics is not mathematics, but you can't do real statistics without maths! (And, statistics will actually make you money lol)

[@swapan]

I would say Statistics is the other side of the coin where one side is Mathematics. Math deals with surety while Stats deals with uncertainty. Eg. while lots of Math is involved in Physics but when you go to quantum level, it involves Probability. Same thing is happening in Economics & game theory (Sanjeev Sanyal brings about this insight very well) and many more disciplines.

[@msbhat]

A must listen. A very free wheeling discussion.

[@PrabhatKumar-jn2rc]

You are inspiration of all imo students,your simplicity is better than luxury

[@swapan]

The reason why IMO students in US can dedicate more time (5 months) for preparation is because talented 12th grade seniors have completed their college applications and almost finished high school. Either they relax and enjoy the last semester or dedicate time for such pursuits as this or others (eg. on job training / internships / leadership / mentorship etc ).

[@anubhavgoyal1381]

Great one Nityānanda ji. Also loved the answer on Manukya Upanishad by Prof. Krishnan.

[@rajivsharaf99]

20:25 thanks. These type of podcasts is the way social media can be useful for spreading knowledge and awareness. This will help bringing our glory set by Aryabhatt and Ramanuj. Thanks for the prodcast

[@SmartRPh24]

What a refreshing change listening to these brilliant minds. With podcasts on every thing in the world, I find this to be very interesting. Thanks for having these brilliant Mathematicians on your podcast

[@akhileshpandey1531]

One of the best podcast I have watched so far.Thanks Nityānanda ji

[@-AkhilTej-]

🎯💎🏆 Great insightful & fruitful video 🏆💎🎯 लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु ( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )

[@lathaswaminathan1435]

@NityanandMisra :- The JEE syllabus may be vast but its nothing compared to what is there in IMO. For example IMO people learn a lot of unknown geometry and combinatorial stuff which is unimaginable.

[@Premium_Youtube_User]

If starts asking thats types of questions competition gonna 📉

[@ShivamPandey-wf2pj]

bro thora dimaag lgao 3 subj poochna hota hai bacho se tino oly level dene lge toh ho gya

[@champu823]

​@@Premium_KZbin_User suicide rates 📈📈

[@YashrajSingh-cf7jc]

​@@Premium_KZbin_Userwhat I think so it will remain almost same as people will start concentrating on Olympiads more

[@shashikalakamath]

Brilliant !!!. It was a treat to watch and hear three great minds speak. Nityanandji your videos are educative & inspiring. Thank you for this wonderful effort. The session with Rushil was also great !

[@Soul-cu8zn]

Continue this man people need to know theres much more than jee

[@vjcsit56]

Thanks

[@suhaniverma6583]

it is so nice to see someone talking about mathematics

[@MaheshPatil-lr7wv]

@@suhaniverma6583 it doesn't happen in india often.

[@Sumesh-e5q]

Sir Namaskar! I am a regular viewer of your program . Your program is very informative. You describe everything according to our Dharma Grantha.Sir, I am a patient of meningitis. If there is a treatment method of this disease in our Dharma Grantha, please make one video so that all suffered people would get advantaged. 🙏 

[@neerajamb]

Excellent conversation! Enjoyed the last part especially:), Niranj and Krishnan seemed to have a lot of fun ❤

[@thiruvaliseshadrishrinivaa5781]

Quite an informative talk. Though I was a math background at Bachelor degree level but got lost into job market. Further, at Bachelor degree level we studied Mechanics, Astronomy, Differential Equations, Real Analysis, Complex Analysis, Linear Algebra, Linear Programming etc . We also had Numerical Mathematics and Mathematical Statistics. We all had these with no practical 😂 in real life situation. Because of mathematical knowlege, logic and reasoning are our basis which enable to succeed in any non- math life.

[@tejas1828]

Absolute Eye opener! We are so proud to have gems like you!

[@DHAiRYA2801]

I feel lucky to have found your channel. Please keep bringing such guests. This is exactly what the youth of India needs.

[@ayushpandey7746]

good initiative. hope, colleges in india get more inclusive for such events rather than solely relying on all india level exams.

[@vasuvasudevan1827]

The glint in Shri Misra's eyes when Prof Krishnan explains what a gamaka is - just priceless. I can only imagine the joy the Sanskritist feels when he sees how the supposedly arcane language he studies survives so nicely in the vocabulary of music!

[@beethoven6185]

Time stamp?

[@ExmuslimNowAgnostic]

This is what a quality content means!

[@gobonkers100]

Awesome podcast. Hope this podcast has most outreach and inspire the young generation and their parents

[@theoneaboveaall]

loved every second of this podcast. thank you profs for what you are doing. ps mandukyaupanishad was mind boggling for me too.

[@LeukemiaTP53]

Incredible. Loved this podcast so much.

[@namantenguriya]

Indian yt space needs more of such intellectual talks about Maths and Science. Thx sir for inviting these brilliant minds. ❤ Pls bring more such podcasts..

[@vsdktbkm5012]

lots of good info toward the end. For instance Sage in lieu of Mathematica. May I have a large container of coffee. Discovered that I am not alone in my feeling about Mandukya Upanishad.

[@anuradharao2880]

Very inspiring! Only wish schools in India had such profound teachers of the subject ( as above) to enable the students to overcome their fear of the subject and make them love the subject.

[@vlogehome8677]

thank you so much sir for having this podcast it give a very interesting insights and encourage me

[@vprayaga]

India government also need to have privisions for the medallists to be awarded admission into IIT's e5c can really help boost participation and encouragement...

[@kachapah]

I thoroughly enjoyed this podcast! Every episode is engaging and insightful.

[@RishiRaj-hu9it]

Even the host is so well read on Mathematics ❤

[@Supriya-y-t2o]

Thinking about IMO entey is only for CBSE,IGSE students in India,Found this truth as my state board never take efforts for priamry level maths,but CBSE,IGSE level does take efforts at primary level ,please help all kids # mother

[@chiragr1336]

Thank you for the informational videos on Olympiads. Very few know about them and even fewer attempt. Hope you peek and challenge young minds. 😍🙏🚩🇮🇳

[@Way02infinity]

I met both of them at the Second Meru Conference on Combinatorics @GEHU, Bhimtal, Uttarakhand ❤

[@siddhantmisal4115]

Now this is the podcast we needed and wanted

[@fnmfnm2896]

Nityanandaji, this is a great episode. It would have become better if you had 1 portion discussing why Bharat needs ganitashatries.

[@Maths_3.1415]

India's performance in the International Mathematical Olympiad (IMO) faces challenges due to how the education system is set up. In India, there is a big focus on exams like the Joint Entrance Examination (JEE), which stresses quick problem-solving and memorizing over understanding and creativity. This focus makes it hard for students to develop the problem-solving skills needed for success in the IMO. There are also many fake Olympiads, like the SOF IMO, that can mislead students and take away time and resources from real preparation. Additionally, many students feel pressure to pursue careers in engineering and medicine, so they don’t focus as much on mathematics. This contributes to why India doesn’t have as many celebrated mathematicians or Fields Medal winners. Unless the education system starts to focus more on creativity and exploration, India's achievements in international math competitions will likely continue to lag behind other countries.

[@Maths_3.1415]

Another point to note is that when I speak the truth, some obnoxious people reply that I can’t clear the JEE, which is why I must be saying all this nonsense. They claim the JEE is the hardest exam in the world and dismiss any criticism, insisting that the JEE is the best.

[@Maths_3.1415]

By the way, I forgot to mention that this podcast was absolutely fantastic! 🎉 I really enjoyed it and found it incredibly valuable. Thank you so much for putting it together for all of us! 🙏😊

[@divyanshgarg5434]

@@Maths_3.1415 I have seen those kind of ignorant people. Thankfully, they are not in this comment section. Jee glorifiers

[@Maths_3.1415]

​@@divyanshgarg5434 Yes, even professors are saying that the JEE is one of the factors contributing to the decline in mathematical achievements in India, such as the absence of Fields Medal winners.

[@aryanshriv6510]

​@@Maths_3.1415kuch log Lund reh jate hai jee is a high school exam whereas u win fields medal after PhD in research so comparing doesn't make sense just an advice don't do drugs funding in our universities is a big promblem solve that saying jee as memory based exam is kind of stupid ya u will find some questions in coaching but the questions which really differentiate between air under 50 to air 500 are kind of olympiad style and don't forget olympiad medalist are mostly jee top rankers just Google even 2024 india physics , maths , chemistry olympiad medalist all were jee top 200 rankers

[@viharivemuri7202]

I look forward to more interviews of mathematicians. Thanks!

[@shubhammishra8760]

Quality Content ...!! Thanks

[@Dynamite_mohit]

These are people India needs to listen.

[@Harsha0827]

I have huge respect and regard for one’s who are excel in Maths 👏

[@sananthakrishnan6913]

Excellent podcast, every word informative

[@Dr_RVS_Classes]

More power to you nityanand sir❤

[@sajanphilip8221]

This is the Podcast we want! Great Minds

[@prashantvipul]

Last two podcasts of yours are my favourite. Do some more podcasts on academics. Do bring at least Prof Siva and Prof Niranjan one more time on show and discuss in details about philosophy , bird watching and their favourite books.

[@MaheshPatil-lr7wv]

If I become millionaire I will certainly set the 1cr prize for those who win Olympic medal .this way it will help maths to get popularize n more people take it.

[@somethingsomething2825]

meanwhile Fields Medal winners declineing to take award money

[@MaheshPatil-lr7wv]

@@somethingsomething2825 indian parents wouldn't let them do that 😂

[@descendantofbharatbharatva7155]

​@@MaheshPatil-lr7wvIndia haven't yet seen any fields medal winner in its history

[@AsuriSaran]

If Board exams and JEE clash , is it difficult to change the timetable...May be we need to look at these things holistically....Because in my opinion Medals are not the be all and end all. How these students contribute to the mathematics in their life time is a very important aspect ....Once we were the pioneers in many aspects of mathematics and Astronomy... We need to reagin ....Excellent program... Hats off to all the professors who are toiling hard to contribute...

[@nehalkpd1]

Thank you so much for this podcast Sir. It’s Truall inspiring for parents as well.

[@Satya_mev_jyte]

This podcast need to be viewed by our youngs

[@SanjeevDDandekar]

My cousin's grandson, Santanu, was one of the coaches of 2024 Olympiad team. I shared this podcast with his parents. Unfortunately my cousin is no more. Shantanu graduated from IIT BOMBAY.

[@nidhichauhan4978]

Respected Sir Your videos are highly informative and I appreciate the way you're creating awareness about Sanskrit and Shudh Hindi language. Kindly guide about the career options for school students interested to study Sanskrit as their main subject/specialization. Regards

[@DevinePlay]

I really enjoyed the whole podcast very much. Thanks for bringing it to us.

[@AshishRanjan-jn7re]

"The mathematical problems are the kind of problems you want to have in your life" -- wise words!!

[@chowdhsk]

most private schools in India focus on SOF IMO. There needs to be more focus and visibility of the actual IMO.

[@kennytheripper2526]

If you win a silver medal for China in IMO, the other people will laugh at you. - a Chinese IMO Gold Medalist

[@Maths_3.1415]

Perfect scorer*

[@JatinRawal2]

the ioqm in 2023 in rajasthan had the cutoff of only 12% . that means 12/100 marks

[@harish-guda]

This was such a good episode. I thoroughly enjoyed it!

[@DMuxNot]

Math and Computer Science departments should offer direct admission to IMO medalists.

[@itsbhaskarmaths5838]

Great Conversation sir, i thoroughly enjoyed it. Please continue this.😊

[@goidol]

I would like to request through you from Govt of India to translate entire Kvant journal in English verbatim and make it popular among Indian students in problem solving.

[@ananttiwari4298]

Very good initiative sir, please call some physics and biology proffesors.

[@samarth-robo]

Nityānanda ji’s face when Prof said pythagoras theorem was discovered by the greeks: 😬

[@paperclips1306]

But that's Pythagoras theorem not sulbasutra. Sulbasutras are from Vedic age.

[@paperclips1306]

Pythagoras, for whom the theorem is named, lived in ancient Greece, 2500 years ago. It is believed that he learned the theorem during his studies in Egypt. The Egyptians probably knew of the relationship for a thousand years before Pythagoras.

[@neerajamb]

Great podcast! Niranjan and Krishnan- fantastic job 💕

[@descendantofbharatbharatva7155]

​@@paperclips1306Egyptians knew about it much before prior to sulbasutra was created

[@paperclips1306]

@@descendantofbharatbharatva7155 yes they did. I don't deny it. Egyptians are the cradle of civilization. I have no question on one thing. The so-called Pythagoras theorem was very well known by the time Pythagoras existed . This is undeniable.

[@jagadishsaligram9551]

What Prof. Niranjan Balachandran says about the reasons haw china is able to perform so very well in Maths Olympiad is very true. It is equally true about their achievements in Olympics, innovation & manufacturing, infrastructure building, etc. The totalitarian system, and the burning ambition and focus of the CPP to dominate the world in all aspects of life drive the chinese in all their endeavours. Candidates with high Potential and promise are scouted for, and those identified and chosen are put through extremely rigorous and gruelling training. Obviously there will be several who fail to one successful candidate in every field. While the successful ones win medals, accolades and international prestige to china, and are well taken care of by the state, those who fail are ruthlessly left to fend for themselves. All the achievements of china come with great human cost but the CPP relentlessly and single-mindedly pursues their international goals completely disregarding the consequences to their citizens. This approach of the CPP does not bode well for china in the longer term, but CPP's failure may be in the interests of rest of the world.

[@itsachyutkrishna]

Brilliant Podcast. Loved it.

[@AJ_42]

Really enjoyed this episode. Inspiring talk.

[@Endangereds]

Indian students should be given a chance to attend exam in a delayed date in such case. Or possibly our selection committee is waiting for the students to do better in their exams and consider those marks for selection too.

[@whaddoiknow6519]

Excellent discussion and all power to the youngsters and their teachers/coaches. Please do not go the way of the Chinese and kill the joy of the subject. I have a suggestion re the work of Madhava and his school. It seems that examining the corpus of this work requires a team, with expertise in Math, Sanskrit, Malayalam, the religious practice of the time, geography of Kerala, and history. All this is beyond the reach of a single person. It requires a sustained collaboration across these disciplines.

[@ayushrajc2new]

Underrated channel ❤❤

[@fnmfnm2896]

Great content Nityanandaji. Jai Ma Bharati

[@Sumesh-e5q]

Namaste sir! It is Kushe (Desmostachya bipinnata) Aunsi of hindu religion today. I would like to request you to make us light on this topic and the importance of Desmostachya bipinnata(Kush) in the point of view of Ayurveda.

[@somrnayak701]

Worth watching ❤

[@adithya7843]

Please invite physics Olympiad team also❤❤ , AIR 1 Jee advanced, Ved was also a part of the team 🎉🎉

[@सौरभYadavendra]

नित्यानंद जी, कृपया पूर्व की भांति हिंदी तथा सनातन संस्कृति पर वीडियो बनाएं, मेरी आपसे विनती है। this podcast is good.

[@ShriNidhi-zu2im]

ಅವರು ಹಿಂದಿಯಲ್ಲಿ ಮಾತನಾಡಿದರೆ ನಮಗೆ ಅರ್ಥವಾಗುವುದಿಲ್ಲ! ಇಂಗ್ಲಿಷ್ ಬೇಕು.

[@सौरभYadavendra]

@ShriNidhi-zu2im अगर आपको समझ में नहीं आता तो मुझे कोई दिक्कत नहीं है। अगर आप चाहें तो हिंदी सीख लें।

[@ShriNidhi-zu2im]

@@सौरभYadavendra ನೀವು ಕೂಡ ಇಂಗ್ಲಿಷ್ ಕಲಿಯಿರಿ! ಯಾಕೆಂದರೆ ಕೇವಲ ಇಂಗ್ಲಿಷ್ ಮಾತ್ರ ಭಾರತದ ಎಲ್ಲಾ ರಾಜ್ಯಗಳಲ್ಲೂ ೨ನೇ ಆಡಳಿತ ಭಾಷೆಯಾಗಿ ಒಪ್ಪಿಕೊಂಡಿರುವ ಭಾಷೆ (ಆಯಾ ರಾಜ್ಯ ಭಾಷೆಯಗಳ ನಂತರ)

[@github921]

Superb podcast. Please also have an episode on Memory Championships - I'm not sure if people from our country participate in it. But it will be incredibly interesting.

[@swapan]

I see that TIFR conducts IMO-IND but not sure if they are sponsors too. I think the Indian IMO body should approach TATA / TCS or Infosys to build brand value around it just like what has happened in chess. I think it will be complimentary to their Chess sponsorship.

[@whaddoiknow6519]

K R Parthasarthy was the head of math at IIT Delhi for a while, sorry to hear he has passed away. I can't remember the name of the fellow who taught us Laplace transforms. I believe he was an algebraist (we vaguely understood such specialization even back then), but he was delighted to be teaching a bunch of very smart would-be engineers and scientists -- he could barely keep his feet on the ground. Looking back, I would fault the faculty at IIT D for not engaging the students in research -- faculty in the US would commit serious felonies to compete with each other for the chance to have such talented students.

[@abhijitchavanapcchemistrym4470]

Pl prepare interview of chemistry , physics and biology olympiads as well

[@Gem-In_Eye]

1:13:40 Note to myself

[@tikarambhusal8657]

Proud to be in this Program

[@HTSR1913]

Prof Mishra ji Please ask with such supremely bright people how to make Ramanujams among them

[@g.sunilnaikg.sunilnai7996]

I really appreciate this podcost

[@treasurebrain9448]

sir please use podcast mike ,so that we can hear each and every word clearly.