MAYBELLINE Superstay Skin Tint Vs. L'OREAL Tinted Plumping Serum! In Depth Comparison & Wear Tests!

[@feminineheart]

There is no shade 34 in maybelline skin tint

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

Hi! Where in the world are you? In Europe we definitely have 34. However, I just looked over on the US website & it seems the shades are numbered differently! I didn’t realise. The best thing to do is to look at the shade description to find the best match 💕

[@feminineheart]

@@CarmelNicoleBeauty I live in USA, I would love to know what shade that Maybelline is in USA.

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@feminineheart I had a quick search on the US website but couldn’t find an identical match- which is really strange! Give me until tomorrow & I’ll find the best shade equivalent for you ☺️

[@feminineheart]

@@CarmelNicoleBeautythank you, I googled it also and couldn’t find anything

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@feminineheart Hi there! So I did email Maybelline but didn’t hear anything back as yet. I’ve trawled through the shades and I think the closest match for you would be 220. This is described as ‘light medium with warm subtle olive undertones’. It actually sounds like a great option if you’re a similar shade to me! These shades are somewhat flexible, so I wouldn’t overly worry if it’s not exact. Sorry if that’s not helpful! Please do let me know how you get on and I’ll let you know if I hear back from Maybelline ☺️

[@wwfarmhouse9055]

Such an in-depth comparison. I was surprised by the longevity of both. I think I am leaning towards the L’Oréal 😊

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@wwfarmhouse9055 Oh I can absolutely see why, it’s so light & natural looking! Hard to pick one for sure 😄 Hope you have a really lovely week ahead 💕☺️

[@DoraSometimes]

Wonderfully thorough video! You've covered every single detail...fantastic review. Thank you so much! ❤

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@DoraSometimes Thank you so much for such a lovely comment! You’ve really made my day ☺️💜

[@melaniefitzgerald8044]

I love that you recognize that everyone’s skin is different. I just threw away my L’Oréal because I always chose the Maybelline over it; way better for my 57 y/o skin!

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@melaniefitzgerald8044 Ah thank you Melanie! ☺️ Although the tints are similar, I think there are significant differences & I can see why you would choose the Maybelline! I bet they both look beautiful on you though ☺️💜

[@debnmom]

I owned the Maybelline for ages, but hadn’t tried it until the other day. I really liked the finish when I applied it. Great video, enjoy your weekend! ❤💐

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@debnmom Oh that’s fab, I’m glad you really liked it too! It has such a beautiful finish & I imagine it looks absolutely stunning on you 😍 Thank you so much, hope you have the best weekend too! 😘🩷

[@AngelissimaASMR]

Hi Carmel! The L'Oreal looks so beautiful and airbrushed on you! I remember it oxidizing when I owned it a couple years ago. I didn't love it at the time when I lived in humid, tropical Florida 🌴🏖☀but my skin is much drier now. I've been looking at the Maybelline tint and much prefer the shade range. I think the Maybelline is very skin-like on you! Both are so nice. I do agree that the L'Oreal wears into more of a skin-like finish on you but the Maybelline looks a tad more makeup-y as the day went on. Very interesting! I think I will have to try the Maybelline now.

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@AngelissimaASMR Hey beautiful lady! ☺️ You always have such interesting experiences with makeup to share and I absolutely love hearing about them! ☺️ The Maybelline is definitely heavier, but still ‘light’ feeling too…it’s really confusing 😂 If you ever get round to trying it I would love to hear your thoughts on the two! Thank you so much for sharing, as always 😘💕

[@AngelissimaASMR]

@@CarmelNicoleBeauty Aw thank you so much, lovely! Yes they look so similar on camera and to the naked eye they probably look even better but thank you for always giving us a closer look! your tips always help me decide on items I've been thinking about. I'm a slow shopper! Have a great weekend 🌺 💕PS I love how you upload on Saturday mornings (my time) because then I can watch your video as I leisurely get ready for the day! ☺☕

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@AngelissimaASMR Oh wow, this is such useful information about the timings! I know I’m a nightmare with being inconsistent with the days in which I post- but it’s because I can never figure out which day is best! 🙈 Most of my viewers are from the US though so what you said would make perfect sense. You are literally the best, thank you doll and have a great Sunday! 😘💜

[@gomezrujanor]

Hi Carmel! I love the Maybelline one! Thanks for the review!!! ❤ Hugs from Texas!!! 🥰

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@gomezrujanor Hi lovely, thank you so much for sharing your opinion! ☺️ I know that I’m late to the Maybelline party but it really is beautiful! Gosh you’re in Texas, wow! I have family from Texas visiting us here in Ireland at the moment- they’re happy for a break from the heat 😂 Sending you much love from Ireland 😘🩷

[@gomezrujanor]

@@CarmelNicoleBeauty OMG Texas heat! 🥵. We also had a Tornado and a Hurricane. I wish to visit Ireland someday! My husband was there for work 6 years ago, and he said people are very nice and friendly! Also loved the beer! 😁 🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@gomezrujanor Haha, most people love the beers & pubs! 😅 You’d love Ireland, but maybe not the rain so much 😄 Wow, a hurricane & tornado? That sounds super scary- please stay safe 😘🩷

[@Houseofgamine]

I purchase a three pack of foundation bottles with a pump from Amazon because of those droppers and extra benefit is Ivan mix two shades into them for my perfect shade. Great review

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

The pumps are a must, I’ll never get used to those droppers- they’re so messy! Oh wow, that is such a clever tip for mixing shades 😅 thank you so much for sharing! 💜

[@audreyso1201]

Hello Carmel, I will have to try the Maybelline product because I find it has a very natural effect on the skin. I have roughly the same skin tone as you with olive undertones too and it's very difficult to find a product dyed with an olive undertone. Thank you for sharing

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@audreyso1201 Hi Audrey, I totally agree 😊And I honestly don’t think you could go wrong with either of these tints! You’re so right, being an olive can be a real struggle, so I’m glad it was helpful in some way ☺️ Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts too 💕

[@jillianpurdy2542]

Hi Carmel thank you for your thorough testing (I've come to expect from you 😊) of these 2 products. I haven't tried the Maybelline yet but am intrigued by the olive shades available as all previous tests I've seen have leant towards a pink toned finish (of which I'm not a fan 😬). I think I would be tempted to try this as I like a light product but prefer the coverage of the Maybelline over the L'Oreal. Having tried the L'Oreal I wasn't a fan of the oxidisation, the amount needed or the messiness, but did enjoy the serum feel of the product. Much love as always! Xx❤

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@jillianpurdy2542 Hi Jillian! Aw thank you so, so much! ☺️ I absolutely love how much we have in common when it comes to our experiences! And I definitely remember you telling me that the L’Oréal oxidised on you -you obviously have a much sharper eye than me! I think you’d love the Maybelline, it’s definitely more of a foundation for sure! Hope you’re having the loveliest week Jillian! Lots of love ☺️💕 xx

[@sarag.7156]

you looks so beautiful also without any make up! thank you for your detailed reviews

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@sarag.7156 Oh my goodness, such a kind thing to say! 🥹 Thank you so much for being so lovely, I so appreciate you! 😘🩷

[@gymrat2022]

i love the Loreal skin tint. Its so comfortable to wear all day. I want to try the Maybelline skin tint now after seeing your video. Both shades look very nice.

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@gymrat2022 Oh the L’Oreal is lovely…but so is the Maybelline! I really don’t think you could go wrong with either of them. Thank you so much for sharing your experience 😘🩷

[@fionadavis9526]

Iv finally bought the maybeline. Trying it tomorrow

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@fionadavis9526 Oh wow, hope you love it! It’s definitely on the heavier side of a skin tint, but is really beautiful. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts…and keeping my fingers crossed for you Fiona! 💜

[@fionadavis9526]

@@CarmelNicoleBeauty put it on this morning was really nice . Definitely a keeper. Thankyou ❤️

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@fionadavis9526 That’s so great to hear, Fiona! 🩷 Hope you continue to love it the more you use it! Definitely keep me updated 😘

[@sandydrewserrano4855]

I used the L’Oreal and I agree with you, I just bought the Maybelline tint, so I’ll let you know.

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@sandydrewserrano4855 Hi there! ☺️ Oh that is very exciting and yes please do come back once you’ve tested it out! Would absolutely love to hear all about your experience with it ☺️💕

[@sandydrewserrano4855]

Omg!! I love Maybelline’s skin tint!! I love the way my skin looks when applied and I don’t have to use a whole lot of it.

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@sandydrewserrano4855 Hi Sandy! It’s beautiful isn’t it and hard to believe it’s drugstore! Love hearing your experience with it, thank you so much for sharing ☺️🩷

[@micheledelorenzo4603]

I have both but use L’Oreal because of my mature skin- less makeup, the less you see those lines! I bought replacement PUMP CAPS for those droppers! So much better!

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@micheledelorenzo4603 You’re so right, Michele - the more makeup I apply, the more those lines show! I still haven’t invested in the pumps, thanks for the reminder! Adding them to my basket now! 😄

[@TraXs.]

I have medium-deep skin with a cool olive undertone, and the L'Oréal is one of the few drugstore foundations that have a shade that matches... So obviously I love it and I use it most days. The only things I don't like are the dropper (I bought one that works with the Estee Lauder foundation, and it helps to control the amount I pick up) and the fact that it has alcohol as one of the top ingredients. I was wondering about trying Maybelline but your review convinced me that I already have a good one 😊

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@TraXs. Hi lovely! It’s great how aware you are of your undertone. Most people believe that olive undertones are always ‘warm’, when in reality it’s such a huge spectrum! The dropper is annoying, but as you say, always a way round it. Thank you so much for sharing 😘🩷

[@TraXs.]

@@CarmelNicoleBeauty it took me years of experimentation to find out that olive undertone is a spectrum in itself. Not being able to find a match because of this helped me discover olive-friendly brands and learn how to make things work. I think they will launch a new version in the future with a pump change and increase the price at the same time 😅 Thank you for all the helpful work you're doing around here 😊

[@jackiestone5808]

Great video pretty lady!❤

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@jackiestone5808 Aw Jackie, you’re too kind! Thank you! Hope you’re doing great ☺️🩷

[@amouramor644]

I’m just wondering did you use any skincare products before apply both brands 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@amouramor644 Hi there! ☺️ my pre makeup skincare routine is the same every day - I use a glycolic toner, firming serum & then moisturiser (my Charlotte Tilbury Magic cream) and if I’m not filming, SPF too! Hope that helps 🥰🩷

[@amouramor644]

Thank you so much 💗💗

[@enierosales-sy5yr]

Maybeline for me on my third bottle

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@enierosales-sy5yr I can see why, it’s absolutely lovely! Thanks for sharing! 🩷

[@katemurphy5773]

I love a day that includes a video from you! I have to admit, even though I guessed correctly, I couldn't tell a big difference in the two on your face (I think that'sdue to your skill in applying them). If I had to choose, I would have to go for the warmer of the two. I think I'm a touch more yellow olive than you. Thank you for your in-depth reviews! Still adore you...sent you my email. Did you receive it?

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@katemurphy5773 Hi beautiful…ah you really are just too lovely! ☺️ And very clever too in guessing correctly, well done! 😉 No Kate, I haven’t received an email from you? I just checked my junk folder too & nothing there. When did you send it? I would’ve definitely replied! Double check the email address? 🩷

[@Laura_Stern]

Why don't you apply it with your fingers? If you use a brush, you waste the product unnecessarily because a lot of it gets stuck in the brush. You would also have to wash the brush after every use (because of bacteria/impurities) so that it doesn't cause skin impurities over time. This is much more time-consuming than simply blending the product onto the skin with freshly washed hands. The warmth of the fingers also helps the product bond better with the skin. So I don't see any advantage to using a brush or other beauty tool.

[@CarmelNicoleBeauty]

@@Laura_Stern Hi Laura! I think it’s just personal preference really. I don’t like the feeling of using my fingers to apply makeup and I find the natural oils in my fingers can shift the product around on my face. I personally get quicker, higher and more even coverage with a brush ☺️ What works for one person doesn't always work for another, especially when it comes to makeup! When you find something that works, I say stick to it! 😊