Me, Her, and the Bank Robber

[@softersideofc.c.5655]

I have yet to understand why ppl are still out here running their mouths about their settlements. If your get any type of money from a settlement keep your mouth closed.

[@Aries-tx3zz]

You're right about that!

[@Sbmeb]

I know how to say no if one found out I got a settlement(Which I did once and I said no).

[@Ms.HoneyH]

Speak on it. 👍💯

[@maxinevaughn-ayala8992]

C.C. Rose Exactly!!

[@CMM726]

Exactly bc all these supposed family and friends come out of the woodwork with their hands out. But he bragged about it bc he wanted up hook up with a younger woman. He's a dirty dog and she's a game player. Birds of a feather if you ask me..

[@Obeox]

So he is a violent drunk, a creep, but you still took money from him, traveled with him, drove his car and lived with him, like WTF. She got with the bank robber thinking he had money and when she realized he was broke, she switched her target real quick.

[@TheMsklg1981]

Spot on 🎯

[@TheSolitary1]

Dang you on it. 100%

[@crystalbush5273]

Exactly

[@helena3631]

he cant be that crazy she just finessed him lol

[@lilliewalker8879]

I believe he gave her that money bc he wanted a relationship with her & when she rejected him...he wanted the money back saying it was a loan

[@bossladiee]

Judge was wrong for this, clearly that woman owes that man!

[@nadegekenfack4971]

I agree that the judge should have ruled in favor of the man. The woman clearly owed the $5,000.00 and lied about it.

[@SavicksterTheTrixter]

Not necessarily, if he lived with her, Judge Judy would have considered his money as "living expenses".

[@seekingthemosthigh5978]

Dead wrong!!!!!

[@audrey7256]

@@SavicksterTheTrixter he needs proof he can't deny the truth. The judge didn't follow up on the living situation. I only heard verbal deviations as far as the loan went. All he needed was a text since he didn't get it in writing. He used his heart to help a friend & she stabbed him. It happens to the best of us. She is a hot mess.

[@garciabrown6799]

@@SavicksterTheTrixter true don't know whats wrong with j Mathis kmt...thats why i dont really watch much of him anymore..still love him tho...

[@kaytee4088]

Judge mathis was wrong for this ruling !! He wouldn't even allow the man to finish presenting his case with his evidence ! She clearly owes this man ! Wow ! 🤦🏽💯

[@Aaliyah-rq4xh]

He knew the man was tricking with the woman and wasn't innocent like he pretended to be.

[@marvelousmallory9462]

What’s wrong with the Judge? She lied over & over... it was obvious. He acknowledged it, himself. Come on Mathis..

[@garciabrown6799]

Yh don't know whats wrong with him from the other day..an taking everything for a joke come on now....

[@marvelousmallory9462]

Garcia Brown huh???

[@everythinglaurenlex5873]

Lately he been off! I noticed!

[@TommieGun71]

I guess a lot of people in the comments don't know that these cases have already been adjudicated, Judge Mathis has to go with the judgement that been handed down in a real courtroom.

[@marvelousmallory9462]

Jeffrey Phillips thanks for that info. That explains a lot

[@Shonda-vj7qb]

My heart is hurting for this man. I believe she played him real good. You just don't do people like that, especially the elderly. However, we never know, this may be his karma from something in his past.

[@Testifydesignfactory]

Karma....what? No he was judged wrongly by an arrogant and very rude judge who I once had respect for. He is as as gay as his son.

[@aprila6628]

No such thing as Karma Sista. Whatever we go through was already predestin to happen but i do like what u said about his past life aka regeneration, regenerate. That is definitely biblical but karma, not biblical. More like a small taste of his judgment. And the defendant, she will most definitely face her judgement because she's not gonna get away with it.

[@Shonda-vj7qb]

@@aprila6628 I have to agree with you on that, no such thing as Karma biblically. That’s the world’s way of saying “sins/wrongs/decisions of our past.

[@lastbreath9683]

He is an old pervert who got mad because she wouldnt let him smell her panties. He played his self

[@amandabarrett2472]

Karma it could be

[@royalheritage9254]

I hope she gets rapid karma for what she did! She was even surprised that she won, did you see her face? Judge Mathis with his emotional judgments... it’s becoming too much.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

Exactly...he needs to follow Judge Judy into Retirement. Her fake body hasn't 'enhanced' her life in anyway evidently....

[@khulaniafrost8359]

I wonder if he is losing his mind. These decisions be azz backwards.

[@Novapj53]

I totally agree with you..she was lying

[@LLStark]

Thats what i said. Karma will get her.

[@laurethacaldwell8649]

Royal Heritage FACTS 💯💯💯

[@ljackson24]

As wrong as she was, he lost his case when he lied. Once Judge Mathis catches someone in a lie, find out they beat women, or don’t take care of their kids, it’s a wrap!! 💯

[@rashardstallworth209]

Facts

[@ChosenVessel82]

The girl lied so her case should have been dismissed too.

[@Simplyher_]

VintageSista she actually had proof... he didn’t 😂

[@ramboslice7322]

Domi T All she proved was that he agreed to sign his car over to her but then chose not to. That shouldn’t justify her getting an extra 5k. Mathis should have recognized that and just dismissed both cases.

[@LayGraPhix]

fuck judge mathis he ain't no clear saint dammit

[@CarlaWalters]

He’s dead wrong for this ruling. I am shocked at how he ruled. She was clearly lying and stuttering throughout her testimony. 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@shawngilmore9700]

You have a pretty face,do you model ,I'm a model agent , let me know

[@patrickpaul5515]

Unfortunately for him, it wasn't in writing.

[@lesley5380]

You need to go to court with evidence, a judge cannot accept hearsay.

[@patrickpaul5515]

@@lesley5380 yes that's right.

[@truegrizzlesfan2292]

Dude said he's a model agent.. lol. Best case work for a porn industry or a weirdo who prey on women

[@tairag3870]

Man said “I paid for her stomach!!!”😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@shanb.9690]

She played that man and had him thinking he had a chance that’s why he was throwing his money around like that

[@heideggelmetayer9901]

You right.

[@bfighter8930]

I really don't believe he wanted to date her. Sometimes men do things for women, in a platonic sense.

[@madisonjones7212]

and that’s his fault

[@Virus-xm7qc]

@@bfighter8930 OH, PULEEEeeez

[@bfighter8930]

@@Virus-xm7qc every man don't want every woman. She's not 25, young, and attractive. They both admitted that he was messing with a young girl. Who needs a grandmother??

[@lookwhatjesusdid]

That witch is a liar. I'm so disappointed in Matthis's treatment of the old man. That judge has no social skills when dealing with people who are confused by the meaning of his words. When he said "transaction," the plaintiff probably assumed that meant the completion of money being exchanged for the car.that woman used that man and I'm so disappointed with the verdict.

[@vivianpatton5692]

Me too.

[@standmccray1037]

Im sorry i disagree with Judge Mathis in this case. If he lied she lied too.

[@peterp586]

Me too

[@LeshaFBaby]

Both should have been dismissed

[@peterp586]

@@LeshaFBaby No. Judge should have made her pay back the money

[@LeshaFBaby]

@@peterp586 they didnt have anything in writing anyway but she know it was a loan

[@knowitallnyc3241]

Stand Mccray 💯💯💯 kzbin.info/www/bejne/iXKypa2um897p68

[@tom11zz884]

Judge Mathis never ceases to amaze me with the blatant favoritism and bias he consistently displays for females on his show. Woman blatantly lied to him and he still grans her a judgement...lol

[@TheMrgoodmanners]

its mostly women who patronize his show, the big qstn should be why men decide to go in his shows for cases??

[@rs61434]

yo he came in the door snitchin' lmao. That bank robber's gonna be looking for him later today.

[@kekedream]

Yup 😂😂😂

[@teaneekambruce4226]

Rikeem Sholes 😂😂😂😂Lord 🙏🏾for Him

[@nmcn1210]

Rikeem Sholes you know it! Exactly why his witness didnt say a word at the end.

[@everythinglaurenlex5873]

😂😂😂😂

[@thankthelord4536]

He needs to retire.

[@singalingalongaling]

Judge Mathis was jumping to conclusions! He must not have taken his medicine that day 😂

[@Divagirl444]

She scammed that Man. Poor Judgement Judge Mathis. The ruling in this case was totally wrong.

[@mscece1900]

His ruling was fair. He had no evidence, so the judge couldn't rule in his favor. You can't come to court making accusations and have no type of supporting evidence. She had proof of the car transaction that he clearly lied about which was perjury

[@Prettygirl-c1f]

and that's what he gets. he know she was no one to trust to pay him back. 💯🤬🙄

[@jeremyjones8917]

She played him straight out the bank lol

[@naturalvirgolady6547]

This case was ridiculous! Judge Mathis just didn’t want the defendant to pay so he came up with a bogus way to discredit the plaintiff even after the defendant was clearly lying about not being asked for repayment🤦🏽‍♀️

[@akstylez_ak5037]

Natural VirgoLady I agree

[@crystalbush5273]

Facts

[@RyanSpringer1984]

She played that man and Judge Mathis let his emotions play out in the court room and rushed into a foolish decision.

[@TheOneLawgiverHolyGod]

...once again...

[@kerryanthonythompson4820]

At times I find Judge Mattis to be rushing his judgments. A bit arrogant....

[@tjohnsonz]

Kerry....ALL THE TIME

[@mlmlsmith2505]

Very arrogant...he’ll make the comment y’all bringing me this mess wasting my time..DUDE you wouldn’t have a show if people didn’t bring their mess to you !!

[@brigman18]

Kerry Thpmpson agreed

[@cecemaintainfanspage]

I hate when he interrupt them why they're explaining their case too 😩😩

[@AshleyAshleyAshley395]

TINA SAYWON I hate when he stop them from talking and take something they said the wrong way and won’t allow them to explain. He always cutting folks off. I still love the show because he’s funny but lately he been tripping.

[@irockabeard]

Based on how irate this man is at the end, you can tell that he being truthful. She suckered him into getting what she wanted, but that energy will come right back to her ten-fold. Mathis is absolutely wrong for this judgement.

[@leetravionblack4131]

Her silence on everything he mentioned said it all. SHE knew darn well that dude loaned that money to her she was hoping her looks and body would make him ignore/forgive the loan

[@TLive-ji5wf]

I enjoy Judge Mathis' show most of the time but I feel some of his verdicts are wrong, like this one. How are you going to determine the outcome of her owing $5000 for a tummy tuck to a receipt for car repairs? I feel his personal feelings determines the outcome of many of his cases.

[@08marsheaj]

Crackheads, tummy tuck and $5000. 🤣🤣🤣 I knew this episode would be a mess

[@kingali673]

I heard the pain when he said “your honor”😔

[@kekedream]

Ain't no man giving a young woman all them gifts without thinking he gone get something in return- we all know what that something is 🙄🤦🏽‍♀️

[@Aries-tx3zz]

Right. So if they both admit...they didn't..it had to be a loan then.

[@michellehubbard8865]

Thinking with the wrong head.

[@lateshiabrooks2180]

Exactly! Everyone seems to overlook that on this 1!! Only a fool would do so, he seems 2 b a smart man, but she outsmarted him!!

[@cboweniii]

Doyle busting out laughing at 1:40 is hilarious 😂

[@AshleyAshleyAshley395]

Aww this was messed up. This had to be for ratings. That lady is a liar and JM knew it. He even questioned her hesitating. But I think they both lied. Both should have went home with nothing.

[@LM-yb6yr]

An act of Judicial misconduct - Mathis needs to be penalized on this one.

[@charondscooper1720]

Yeah theses two been messing around. Someone. Not telling the truth .

[@tmston2]

I was thinking she prolly was jus let him see her nude and kept promising him the box but never gav it

[@queenredd420]

He lost because he lied to the judge about there being a car transaction. Once you blatantly lie, nothing you say can be trusted.

[@prettysmart9025]

She’s a user... dudes be watchful of these attractive women who come with they hand out And this is coming from a beautiful, fine ass chocolate woman with integrity.

[@nataliemscrzysxycoolharris9623]

Asia May SNAP SNAP!! YES QUEEN!!

[@rwomck]

Word?

[@citygurl0105]

I believe you but I wanna see your picture lol. I love chocolate women (and not like that) lol

[@kj3887]

@@citygurl0105 I wanna see a pic too. I need proof.

[@takeyatravels]

Most definitely. just sad

[@Exhibit_C_me]

It seems like JM got upset over the plaintiff yelling "No" like he did. But she was clearly lieing about the jeep ND pretty much everything else. She got away with one here thanks to JM.

[@kennethwilliams4909]

Boy judge you on your period !! You was totally wrong!!

[@taketan8858]

🤣🤣🤣

[@joneldaniel4084]

😂😂😂

[@laurethacaldwell8649]

Kenneth Williams lmao FACTS!

[@sereneamani1713]

Kenneth Williams Wrong, disrespectful, and rude comment. Unbecoming speech from a man speaking of another man.

[@vladimirjackson1272]

Mathis is a 🤡

[@chrissoulful7086]

I think he was just asking for money back because she probably didn't want him for nothing but money

[@SummitInsuranceUSA]

This is what happens when these old guys keep trying to mack on these younger women.

[@tomswill9189]

😂 😂

[@sylviasosoo74]

She's not young,she's just doing plastic surgeries to make her look young

[@traceyjackson4470]

TRUE THAT 👍🏾👏🏾

[@tonydavisthedj2day]

THIS MAN IS A WHOLE MIKE EPPS CHARACTER!!! 😂😂😂😂

[@cjohns1005]

This case pissed me TF OFF....JUDGE MATHIS owes me a fight. All this damn simping he is doing is ridiculous

[@Powerdriver777]

Finally yall mad like i was for the past year. He a straight up SIMP

[@CarlaWalters]

What’s simp?

[@tees4265]

Carla Carla a man that always takes a woman’s side lol

[@CarlaWalters]

Gaza Girl oh ok I was clueless lol

[@dbates7633]

Whoop his ass bro

[@gabrielleivie4585]

I think judge was teaching him a cold hard lesson the judge knew she was wrong judge teaching him not to be a trick ever again in life 💯

[@kay22100]

She know she used that man...

[@aball7654]

Yes it's obvious she tricked him

[@vladimirjackson1272]

@@aball7654 Well, he was TRICKIN

[@6Summerville]

I’ve been watching his shows for only a few days now and when I tell you he get in his feels....he get in his daum feelings!!! He be doing to much and his judgements be off and this one takes the cake. He be cutting people off without allowing them to make their point

[@ritamcvay2434]

You are so right, because I have seen other cases on here, when people have loaned people money before and turn around and loan them again, so what's up with that judge??

[@mildredfierce999]

First time I have disagreed with Judge Mathis' decision. She clearly loaned £5k from Pops. Pops got played chasing a younger woman. Don't trust a big butt and a smile Pops. You too old for that👴🏿

[@tjohnsonz]

1st time??? You must not watch this show too often.. This is Judge Fakeis all the time...

[@petduro]

what show have you been watching

[@chemereestes9791]

I totally agree.. I don’t agree with this at all

[@Powerdriver777]

When you at his age you really don't give a fuk

[@rodneybarnett3307]

She got $10,000 racks off his Ass lol 😂

[@MegaAli213]

He was stupid to give her anything. He must have wanted to be her sugar daddy. Their relationship is to bizarre and non foundational to have any historical character. I hope he learned his lesson.

[@johnnyrobinson8168]

He is too old to be played like that! Even if she is lying, how the hell you not going to have her sign something for the money? Hell, even she had some evidence! You never give anyone a loan without having them sign something saying that it was a loan. And lastly, you always have a witness there to see it all!

[@tomswill9189]

Facts true

[@vladimirjackson1272]

He had a witness and he even said his witness was there when he asked her about the money but, Judge Mathis being the clown that he is decides to listen to the woman! Her body and cuteness got Judge Mathis acting stupid too!

[@latonyajackson5698]

Lastly what was he reading in that Bible???? LMAO. Whole case was funny as hell. 😂😂😂

[@pearlinestewart1178]

She owes the money, judge your wrong in this verdict

[@AnneOhn123]

She was the one with evidence!! Get over it!

[@theculturalconfusion7748]

Ruling was justified. He lied and she had proof in writing to back her up. All he had was he say, she say 🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️

[@louisettefields6653]

Right!

[@HoneyMaguire]

They both lied! Only thing is she's the only one with evidence, and in court that's exactly what you need. The judge doesn't care about anything else but proof! Is it fair on the streets, no... but in the court this is fair, no matter how anyone feels.

[@treylaw7272]

I agree Brittany

[@unrulyme4002]

Brittany Morrison exactly!

[@lateshiabrooks2180]

True!

[@IG-BrainsBeautyBody]

Exactly....and then he was still giving her money/helping her out even after the 5k....sad

[@romain198426]

My my your fckn hot

[@wadewalker118]

Judge was right! No arrogance...

[@sheltonechols26]

He came in there straight snitching on everyone lol

[@brigman18]

I feel like Judge Mathis made the wrong call in this one. He’s so aggressive for no reason sometimes.

[@AnneOhn123]

He did it by the law...

[@ramiyna]

Something else was going on between those two besides what they say. You know he tried to get a piece.

[@vladimirjackson1272]

Yup and he paid for it in advance. She was supposed to return the money tho cause, she KNEW she wasn't gonna give him any LONG before he gave her that 💰! He wasn't licking his tongue at her for nothing 🤣🤣

[@marimartinez2672]

This case got me so mad 😠 I can’t believing his ruling. He should’ve won that case she was obviously taking advantage of him

[@honeyrolling8912]

They both lying some....BUT she owes dude.

[@rubytate2948]

Who has five thousand dollars to just give someone for no reason.

[@nannettedelas5251]

I concur, smdh!

[@joviamckibben6030]

Ppl tend to forget that in the court of law it’s not what you know, it’s what you can prove! The plaintiff had no way to prove that he loaned her the money. We know she played him but ain’t no crime in that. He played himself because he’s the sucker💯

[@earthangelwithlove444]

Right, I don’t understand how people don’t see that, I’m sure if he had proof that he loaned it to her and her staying she was going to pay him back, he would have won. He had no proof what so ever and the girl had one piece of evidence that brought her back in the game 😂😂

[@misstara322]

I think he gave it to her hoping he'd get some. When he didn't get none, it became a loan. Why else is an old man giving a younger woman he barely knew $5000? C'mon y'all!

[@peterlewis2881]

Old men have money and basically most of the things that they want in life. They understand how difficult life might have been for them coming up. Money really isn't the most important thing in life as it might be to a young person. So they have no qualms with sharing what they have...giving it loaning money to young people, but it almost always turn out to be a situation that they regret. Young people think they are slick and up on some slick game to beat someone out of their money , especially older people. She borrowed the money and he loaned it to her. He didn't think that he needed documentation. It was when she thought that she could be slick and not pay back what she borrowed, he had to take her to court. Judge Mathis knew that she had borrowed the money and as a sharp barrister he could have gotten her to admit that she said that she would repay. No body give $5000 without expecting to be repaid....Maybe $500.

[@clarenceedwards2866]

this is why the judge should have come down in the middle and deny both claims; how could he award her $5000.00?

[@BWillz]

What in the world is wrong with Judge Mathis??? He knew she was lying when she hesitated to answer that question but yet he skips over that just to try to catch the guy lying, thats ridiculous, I could tell that he was telling the truth because his testimonies just made more sense, and she even pretty much admitted that she owed the money and then she hesitated and tried to change her story, she is just a manipulative liar and im very disappointed in Judge Mathis for how he judged this case SMH, he was owed back that money..

[@AKY2011]

Judge mathis has a point though... if she already owed him 5k, why continue to help her with anything else 🤔 But I think she owed him the money though. Terrible

[@empressrosetarot1717]

Because he was still trying to sleep with her. He was giving her money in hopes that she would. She owed him

[@keithsimon]

@@empressrosetarot1717 hence the reason why judge mathis was leaning towards this being a gift, if he loaned her 5k why the fuck is he selling her a car, letting her drive his car, staying together, all this shit with a woman who he claims hasn't paid him back in months. The lie just wrapped it up.

[@ms.exclusive4076]

He should not continue to help her after not received any payments! Stupid by any believe from a judge they will not believe you after do such thing.That is why he lost his case,also he didn't answer the judge when asking did you loan her or help her with by giving her car to drive.That made judge upset

[@vladimirjackson1272]

He wants his money back cuz he finally realized that she ain't going to give him none but, I think he deserves his money back. She knew she wasn't going to give him none the whole time she kept taking his money

[@isabeld.3795]

TOTALLY agree with judge mathis ruling. He tried being a dirty ol man, dating and courting women half his age and he got played. That's what he gets!

[@nubiacairo8835]

This woman is vicious. But the man is a fool when you go to court you have to be able to prove your case beyond a reasonable doubt.

[@damyaaaa818]

“ you big liar” 😂😂

[@msluvbug13]

Lol you can tell she was shocked she won. Lol she may have fibbed but the dude straight up lied. 😂😂🤣🤣

[@stephsimone1953]

Oh my Judge Mathis is wrong for this one!! I’m certain Karma will meet her. 😩

[@SkidCudi]

I think Judge is getting out of pocket lately.

[@realdeal3202]

For all the people in the comment section saying the ruling wasn't fair please read a law book. She had evidence. He had none and he committed perjury. Case closed.

[@marshas-music-playlists]

Yeah, the ruling went right over a lot of folks' heads. Good grief.

[@angeldiannah8306]

I think she played him but why keep loaning money and doing transactions with someone who already owes you $5000? That’s why the judge didn’t believe him

[@shamondavis406]

I strongly agree with you!!!

[@MyDestiny1104]

Something people just have a good heart and people take advantage of them as she did

[@TheOneLawgiverHolyGod]

...if the man is an alcoholic...many will take advantage of his weaknesses...

[@sheskates6551]

@@MyDestiny1104 that wasn’t his heart that was his penis he was tricking and got tricked

[@Planetsoundproductions]

True dat

[@brucesmith2237]

Yall be killing me with the judge in his emotions/feelings theory, When JM asked bout the car, all he had to do was say yes and explain why she had it the same way he did at the end without all the aggression, he was going to win the case up until tht point.... Who continues to help when they hv been burn for 5K??????? ****They was more than friends

[@Zen_Nurse]

Get EVERYTHING in writing 💯

[@Aries-tx3zz]

Right! Even with Family!

[@melthomas6519]

Zen X Or don’t be stupid enough to give money. Especially not that amount. Especially not for someone to have silicon and fix a flat injected in them. Also, don’t chase after old men and old men stop chasing young girls

[@tomswill9189]

Yup

[@revettefarrow4111]

That's Some Of The Reason Why He Lost

[@Prettygirl-c1f]

Well he shouldn't gave her no money. If he know she was messing with a Bank robbery who been in prison. I wouldn't give her nothing. 💯😡

[@MegaDede1212]

Why would you give someone you've never been friends with and barely know money for a tummy tuck?? And she her body done and no car?? This whole case dont make any sense i feel bad for no one

[@vladimirjackson1272]

She needs her body done to GET the car!!!! That's how these trifling hoes 🤔 (Notice I didn't say woman cause, there are still some WOMEN out there!)

[@mscece1900]

Folks please learn how the law works in court!! A lot of comments are saying she lied about owing him, but that's not the issue. Defendant's are known to lie, but it's the plaintiff's burden of proof. This man had no evidence and thought she would actually own up to it which is dumb as hell on his part. A judge can't make a ruling without evidence. Then even if he did his case would've still got dismissed for perjurying himself with lying about the car transaction. Yall keep saying JM ruling wasn't fair, he couldn't rule in his favor based off his testimony alone, learn the damn law!!!

[@camij9371]

Yes she lied but I don’t see how he was dumb enough to keep having transactions with the woman like judge said.

[@TheOneLawgiverHolyGod]

...if his witnessed him asking her for the money to be repaid...the judge should have had him stand and testify if he had witnessed such...

[@latisharealtor5741]

Judge Mathis wrong for this one. That lady know darn well she told him that she would repay him for that tummy tuck!👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾

[@theartofmotivations]

She got 10 grand out this fool, she had receipts, he should have brought some other then the witness..🤦🏽🤣🤣

[@michaelbrooks7859]

Another miscarriage of justice...

[@tahjjj1488]

I’m a woman and I have to agree. No man who isn’t you father/brother will “give” you $5000. That was a loan. She’s going to reap a poor harvest for the bad seeds she’s sown.

[@CreativelyKia]

Whitney Thompson dont forget sugar daddy’s

[@godsgirrrl721]

She was clearly lying 🥲 BUT he was dishonest at the end too, when judge Mathis asked him a straight question about the transaction and repeatedly said no AND she actually had evidence of that, that’s where he went wrong & where he lost the judge 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@obiettalangley8726]

That man clearly said no in that moment because je saw that Mathis made up his mind already which was dead ass wrong

[@crystalbush5273]

Facts

[@goldieluxx9356]

despite how everyone feel in the comments section the old man didn't have any proof and the young lady did

[@jayclean-mean9400]

True. He should have had all of it in writing and signed by him and her.

[@SelfImprovementSis]

Ayooooo 😂😂😂 that expert opinion line was hilarious!!!

[@shaynation2634]

My stomach and head hurt from LAUGHING SO HARD

[@phillyphilly3148]

Mathis is my favorite judge but i just simply can't agree with a lot of his rulings lately man 😔

[@jaysmith61]

Lol shorty caught him lovely 😩😂😂😂😂😂😭

[@12Messenger]

They slept together they just agreed before court not to exploit each other. Her bf wouldnt know she cheated and he wouldn't get his ass whooped. No man just gives out 5k without a return of investment. Trust me

[@SlikkRikk504]

I will have to disagree. Men will give women money/gifts without a sexual exchange. I dont know their situation but speaking from experience it does happen. Especially if a woman doesn't come off as a gold digger. I have platonic male friends that offer and gift me things all the time and I often decline because I dont want to give off the notion that things will move to the next level.

[@EmpressNic]

I agree with that but he could've gave it in anticipation of wanting to be with her or having a desire to.

[@starrjohnson1327]

@@SlikkRikk504 that happens to me too. I have people who constantly offer to help me but I am careful. I never know what their motives are. I've even had people get angry because I don't accept the help

[@queenin9611]

Good ruling judge why give him anything with no proof of nothing that's considered a gift then after that gave her a car he was trying buy her liking and she gave him right wat he deserves

[@marshas-music-playlists]

Exactly. He played himself.

[@lisasmith742]

Judge is messy😂😂😂😂 Has me ROLLING

[@piacrudes2741]

I hate when judge Mathis gets like this he lets his emotions get the best of him and grants unfair judgement

[@oyeade7195]

The justice system is broken this judge is in his feelings this is why we don’t believe in the justice system thank you judge Mathis

[@ctoliver9378]

Yeah that was a bad call. They both we’re messy so I’ve would’ve split the damages 50/50. Ijs

[@KwizMatix]

This makes no sense… What a terrible ruling. I guess he wanted to teach the old guy a lesson but that woman is toxic AF & trifling as hell!!

[@spythe]

Man rough case, that guy clearly wanted some cheeks and she took advantage of that. She is wrong, he is wrong, judge was wrong.... this entire case was a mess With that said if someone owed me 5k, I'm not still doing business with them which is what the Judge focused on.

[@Ericasgaines]

There have been cases where people continues to loan money after being owed thousands and the judge gave them their money back

[@vladimirjackson1272]

@@Ericasgaines Exactly! Mathis just be on his period and is an inconsistent 🤡

[@Cometalktome]

That’s a gift!!!! Who loans 5,000 to someone a woman who’s dating another man in the house he live in. Turn around and drive her out of town and pay and wait for her to get her body down. Plies she’s driving his car. Something not right. Plus he making advances at her yet she leave out of town with him 🧐

[@Kiara_Lee1]

So let me try and some up the story.. they were involved period point blank. She met him through the mutual friend and saw that she could manipulate him. She pretended to like him and he fell for it. She eventually got money from him to get her body done and they probably made an agreement over beer and weed lol. She seems as though she belongs to the streets so she knows how to play and swindle and once she got Nudge Mathis on her side it was over from there. Judge should have listened to his side because he probably would have caught her in a lie. Once Judge Mathis’ mind is made up its a wrap!

[@monet5345]

The whole episode was hilarious 😂🤣😂🤣

[@rodericksears638]

I agree with this brother and i believe she got away with her lie.

[@kimistryx.4946]

I hate that the Judge never listen to them... this girls was lying and the judge knew that.

[@ShawnC.T.]

You see this guy's, "nice guy's", a.k.a. "simps", finish last, and in this case, empty handed, don't be the plaintiff. As for the narcissistic defendant, who attempts to pay for her looks, money in the end won't save you, it can't buy good health. Instead of getting tummy tucks, eat healthier, and incorporate more beneficial physical activity into your lifestyle, then there will be no need for quick fix tummy tucks, that you can't afford...

[@supream51]

He was arrogant. He chooses his own judgment on this one

[@nicholinaplange4750]

Y’all are being too emotional. Court works with evidence not feelings. 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@bonikamunga411]

That wy the reason I don't watch Mathis he thing is better to everyone this woman she tiling money from that old men the rea

[@cece5464]

Agree! But her evidence didn’t equate to the ruling of the case. She CLEARLY lied on multiple things yet when he did he lost the case for lying?