Mel Kiper & Field Yates RE-DRAFT 2024 NFL Draft Class 👀 | First Draft🏈

[@mt_baldwin]

Oh stop with the situation stuff. Before the season started all these "experts" universally agreed Caleb Williams was going to the best spot for any rookie QB ever (their words) and Jayden Daniels was going to be the sacrificial rookie QB, going to a team with a bad O line, few weapons, a defensive and reheated head coach and to team also known for fumbling young QBs. Jayden Daniels talent shined through all of that and elevated everything around him, just like Stroud did with the Texans last season (a very similar situation). Talent shines through even in bad situations, like Matt Stafford for the first decade of his career and even Drake Maye's talent is shining on a way worse situation on the Patriots.

[@chrisk3405]

I agree and disagree. Jayden is better than Caleb, it’s delusional to think otherwise. But everyone was wildly wrong to say Caleb was coming into the best situation ever. Having a bunch of great receivers isn’t what a young qb needs. He needs a run game, an OL, and a coach who can help him get rid of some of his bad tendencies. The only thing the bears are close to having of those is a run game

[@MUTV2]

💯

[@johnanthony1465]

Hindsight does exist so lets enjoy it

[@jayy88]

@@chrisk3405he should have a run game and he has a great defense. Now people want to act like they didn’t say what they said. People thought Jayden wouldn’t even start the season.

[@nottodayimbusy7146]

Jayden Daniels did not go into a bad situation going to Washington I felt that even before the season started I'm a commander's fan by the way so I may have been a little biased

[@jacobclark2532]

The disrespect for Nix continues lmao

[@HsjajJjsnzns]

He trash just white privilege..

[@thegreatrenaldo7718]

He's a game manager throwing for 100 yards supported by a great defense. Stay delusional

[@jacobclark2532]

@thegreatrenaldo7718 lmao, keep spewing utter nonsense.

[@hanoimoyoy4744]

@@thegreatrenaldo7718 It’s crazy you commented that after he just threw for 300 and 4 tds

[@holiday42020]

@@thegreatrenaldo7718Weird time to comment that. Dudes weekly and monthly awards at the moment

[@YorkshireRaider]

These re-drafts are awful. How is Brock Bowers or Quinyon Mitchell not in any of those? McCarthy hasn't played a snap of meaningful football and neither has Penix

[@TheUndefeatedOfTheEast]

The raiders need a QB so it makes sense for them to move up in a redraft and get 1

[@donmon808]

@@TheUndefeatedOfTheEast they needed one during this draft too. No one who is a fan of the raiders wants penix over the clear best rookie weapon in the class

[@andrewptob]

No Quinyon Mitchell in the top 10 is wild

[@Oogaboogaoogaooga]

Im still taking Caleb #1

[@isaacvandyke7569]

Drake Maye over Caleb Williams all day every day, and we just saw it play out.

[@coreycallahan4474]

It’s not even close, Drake over Caleb. Maye has the size and the superior makeup over Williams . Drake a better NFL QB today and is 2 years younger. He can play on time and make incredible plays and is doing it with far less than Caleb.

[@geraldochi7945]

Yup, CW has a very iffy arm over 25 yards. He'll hit some, but others do it much better.

[@kinggkongg9694]

Quinyon Mitchell is one of the most impactful rookies and already a lockdown corner

[@DetroitTyler]

Im a Lions fans and I wanted Verse, Terrion or Quinyon. Quinyon is the real deal and his speed and strength for a CB are high level, he has all the makings of being one of those yearly pro bowl type dudes. Terrion has struggled with PIs, but seems to be in position most times to make a play, Arnold just needs to work on locating the ball.

[@MrMusick84]

I’m a Ravens fan and I REALLY wanted them to draft QM. Unfortunately we got stuck with Nate Wiggins from Clemson.

[@BiggieTrismegistus]

​@@DetroitTylerI was happy with the Terrion Arnold pick and he's already cut down on the PIs that plagued him earlier this season. I agree that he needs to locate the ball better but for a rookie CB I can't really complain about how he's played. I'm also interested to see what the Lions have in Ennis Rakestraw. If he develops into a reliable starter the Lions could have a good and very young secondary that could potentially play together for years.

[@juniegyllenhaal3937]

Take it easy

[@TyesDad]

How the heck can you not have Quinyon Mitchell in the top 10 BEFORE Nabers considering Mitchell gave up only 1 catch to him? And he would probably shut down Harrison too. WR’s vs Quinyon Mitchell: Drake London: 1 catch, 5 yards Chris Olave: 2 catches, 23 yards Mike Evans: 2 catches, 19 yards Amari Cooper: 1 catch, 10 yards Malik Nabers; 1 catch, 9 yards Ja’Marr Chase: 2 catches, 19 yards CeeDee Lamb: 1 catch, 5 yards Terry McLaurin: 0 catches

[@lobsterlarry6481]

Someone needs to put together a compilation of the 40,000 passes Caleb has missed by more than 3 yards off the receiver after 3/4 seconds of holding the ball

[@GraV21]

GIVE ME A BREAK. “Is it more of the situation Jayden is in Vs what Caleb is in?” Are you kidding me? Before the season people were saying Caleb was going into the best situation a first (overall)round pick had ever gone into. The Bears won almost twice as many games as the Skins did last year. Nobody was expecitng the Skins to be any good this year and talking about the lack of playmakers and stuff, yet now it’s Daniels in the better position? The flip-flopping is absolutely ridiculous

[@nottodayimbusy7146]

You should have known this was coming people can't just say know what I was wrong they got to make it seem like they knew the entire time and everybody else is dumb for not saying it cuz everyone was saying that Caleb Williams was going into the bat situation any rookie QB had ever gone in like you said now all of a sudden no one thought that it's wild

[@petersmith1591]

What a great qb draft. Probably going to be top 5 qb draft since I’ve been a fan in 1985. 2021 is probably the best but 2024 could be number 2 or 3

[@EternalReich88]

2021?!?!? Do you mean 2020?

[@petersmith1591]

Yeah, I meant 2020. Got the years mixed up. I just looked at the 2021 qb’s drafted in round 1 and got a good laugh

[@UltimaKombat]

1. Daniels 2. Maye (and honestly could switch 1 and 2) 3. Nix 4. Williams

[@ryanallensworth3734]

@UltimaKombat that's idiotic to say that this early in those 4 careers. If you look at their stats to date Caleb , Bo and Jaden are all similar on paper as Drake has not played enough . Now look at 4th quarter stats when the game is on the line and it's obvious Caleb is far better than all 3 other Qb's. In fact he is top 5 in the NFL this year when the game is on the line in the 4th and has broken the NFL rookie record for most passing attempts without an interception. CALEB the right pick at 1

[@UltimaKombat]

@ I’ve watched Caleb make more questionable decisions, and take more crucial sacks with a significantly more talented roster than Nix or Maye. I really don’t get the hype, granted I’ll admit I’ve only watched a few Bears games so maybe I just haven’t watched closely enough. But stats aren’t everything. Id take Williams over Nix for the future though.

[@edwardcanavan]

Mel can draft after the draft but don't trust his pre-draft advise. The most important question was asked, would we be talking CW now if he went to Wash due to better couching, but Mel passed saying we don't know. Great analysis Dr Obvious. Chicago is notoriously a place for Rookie QB's to go and bust.

[@MKfutboler41]

Quinyon Mitchell is LITERALLY a shut down corner, proven against elite WR competition this season, and he isn’t even a top 10 pick??? CB is a premium position, crazy he isn’t even a top 10 pick in a redraft

[@azikkii]

So called experts time and time again failed to say what I had been screaming about Williams all last season. Caleb solely relied on improvisation so it was impossible to know if he had any ability at all to go through progressions and reads, the most important part of a QBs toolkit. He’s never had to scan the field from the pocket and go through progressions and I said all last year he was going to be a huge bust and that Daniels Maye and McCarthy would end up having better careers.

[@chadplack9912]

No

[@WordAte]

The problem in Chicago is not Caleb Williams. The problem is the Bears organization. They have screwed up two other great prospects in Fields and Trubisky.

[@Bethbutucancallmechandra]

Its obvious now trubisky is not good and fields has severe flaws

[@economicsmadeeasy5266]

@@Bethbutucancallmechandraand that Caleb has big issues

[@WordAte]

@@Bethbutucancallmechandra I have not seen the alternative universe footage where Fields and Trubisky were drafted by competent organizations and still failed to fully develop. Can you post a link to this video?

[@davidcoppedge9667]

You are right and wrong... williams is not the problem.... I truly believe he was rushed tho

[@WordAte]

They definitely rushed him before he was ready. That is an organizational problem. They would have been smarter to keep Fields there for two or three years to give Williams someone to learn from. But we are happy having Fields over here in Pittsburgh. He will be elite in 2025 or 2026. And he is an outstanding backup right now. I had hope for Trubisky two years ago. But he was too broken, impatient, and stuck in his trauma. He was fleeing every pocket even in good protection. And he was doubting himself and not throwing in time.

[@BludMun]

I think yall are being too generous to Caleb Williams. I think there's a good argument that Washington takes Drake Maye in the redraft.

[@hendrikw3380]

Then New England will take Bo Nix

[@Eclipse-ss7ko]

Caleb is going to be a BUST. Attitude, entitlement, not a true leader.

[@JackThomas-t4m]

I’m so glad that everyone still says twitter

[@Luke-bj8mr]

How does Bo Nix not move up more?

[@broncosstampede494]

BO NIX IS THE BEST QB OUTTA THIS DRAFT MINNESOTA WOULD'VE RUINED HIM, BO NIX IS MORE THAN WHAT SEAN PAYTON CALLS , HE IS SPECIAL.

[@AmusedGarterSnake-yz1hm]

Bo Nix is not better than Drake Maye relax ......

[@broncosstampede494]

@AmusedGarterSnake-yz1hm Bro What!?! Look At The Stats, Plus Bo Nix Played Every Game, And Didn't Have To Play Back Up To Jacoby Brissett.

[@Jakery1057]

Ahhh NO, Maye and Daniels are better than Nix. I'd argue Nix over Williams and that's about it.

[@Jadiddy96]

Yeah bro, Nix has a decent o-line, a 1-B reciever (sutton) and an excellent defense that allows Nix to not have to force things or play from behind too often. Skill wise, Jayden and Drake are far better than Nix. Maye is in the worst possible situation for a rookie QB

[@Jadiddy96]

Also the difference between starting Maye was that jacoby has decent starting experience where jarret stidham has an absolute terrible track record when playing the position in general

[@ryanallensworth3734]

Williams was the right pick for chicago. It's way too early to say anyone of these picks are busts and this guy should have went here instead of this guy. This is ridiculous but this is ESPN these days

[@wesmckenna8287]

Hey Greeny, prepared to have your Jets get whipped by Drake Maye for the next 15 years lol.

[@neighborhoodtay1845]

I hope so

[@rcornell5457]

Man a lot of you jumped off Caleb Williams. Last 2 weeks 5 TDs. Set the record for passes without an Interception for rookies. Looks like a different QB under Thomas Brown. Especially vs Detroit and Minnesota..

[@GillieWilson-ze2df]

Caleb Williams was the deserved number 1 draft pick in 2024 . He has already set numerous Bears team records and several NFL all time records . Over 3,000 yards passing, 19 TDS already and only 5 interceptions . He's set an all time rookie record fo consecutive pass attempts at over 300 !

[@WOLFENCT]

Love it, my Eagles not only got Q. Mitchell, but also Cooper Dejean!

[@jermainerodgers]

Drake maye is legit..

[@mrjonsey]

I would take Maye #1, no offense to Caleb and Daniels, I’m going to take the bigger guy when everything else is close in comparison.

[@isaacvandyke7569]

Hot take, but I actually agree. He looks like an absolute stud.

[@Ljberkow]

He’s not only bigger, but also has a stronger arm. He’s a better passer in tighter windows and does that with one of the worst receiver groups in the NFL. Maye does need to learn when to just throw it away better. He’s much younger than the other two. I really like Daniels and the comparables to Jackson are good.

[@No_Excuses_Boss]

Bo nix Roty incoming. Not even in top 10 this is dumb. He is clearly better than maye and Williams and is getting closer to Daniels each week

[@muddnorris4306]

LOL

[@Jakery1057]

Your a funny dude

[@neighborhoodtay1845]

@@Jakery1057a very funny dude

[@oneputt4152]

Caleb being a bust is just getting more funny every day

[@davet3659]

Dude was so full of himself going into the draft, it’s quite funny to see

[@SkyStormNL]

He’s my goat 🤤

[@jayspeed2068]

Wrong. The Chicago Bears are a bust.

[@rab5567]

Like you being in your 30's and still living in your parents basement

[@chrisk3405]

Caleb has sucked, but calling a qb a bust after 9 games is crazy

[@Ljberkow]

Drake Maye would be picked first on a redraft by GMs. He’s already right with the other two and has a much bigger upside. He had 26 college starts and his arc is there. He can run like Daniels, but the hope is that he doesn’t.

[@Tfly33]

I can’t wait to revisit this video in a year or two

[@MichaellMcNair]

The god father, Mel kiper jr,he,s the best, no matter who you pick, love this show,Yates is good also, much thanks Greene

[@noneexisting258]

32:38 I’m good on that I’d rather take bowers again and grab shedeur next year rather have sanders over penix

[@Cammdontjamm1]

Malik nabers is better than Harrison jr couple drops whatever before he got the concussion he was killin everything

[@tylerhenry5537]

Wow they sure are overrating Daniels he has been good, great for a rookie but hes not already one of the best Qb's in the league he has like 13 total tds hes been very quiet the last few weeks

[@GillieWilson-ze2df]

Yeah, this is 1 month old . Caleb now has19 passing TDS, still only 5 interceptions, over 3,000 yards passing, and a rookie record of over 300 passing attempts with no I terception .

[@jacksmith5562]

The difference is QB should stay in college longer at least 4 years

[@jayinmaine]

As a Patriots fan,I was thrilled when Chicago chose Williams. I was afraid that if they took Daniels, then there was a chance Washington would have taken Maye. I wanted nothing to do with Williams. I did my own research (I’m a nobody) but I was not impressed and was seeing bust written all over him, even though he was anointed as the best

[@lsu_siegel2837]

Taking Rome Odunze instead of Brian Thomas Jr is CRAZY. BTJ has the best stats out of all the rookie receivers this year and he is in arguably the worst situation out of all of them..

[@kingbirdIII]

the most transcendent player with the absolutely superstar stamp from this draft is Jared Verse and I think QB needs aside Verse is the number 1 pick in this draft.

[@ericmartinez3422]

These guys won't admit they were wrong about bo nix. Watch what he does going forward. Brock Bowers is amazing too.

[@ricardofarinha1428]

Bowers=chargers

[@bocamax]

Michael Penix would be drafted #2 if there was a re-draft (above Drake May, Caleb Williams, Bo Nix, and JJ McCarthy).

[@Jakery1057]

Maye clearly goes ahead of Caleb Williams without a doubt. The question is does Nix also go ahead of Williams?

[@petermarshall6577]

Caleb is an outside the pocket QB, if he's contained in the pocket his height and vision down field suffers. Justin Field has the same issue dangerous outside the pocket and limited inside the pocket.

[@wildo326]

Masterful Hail Mary pass 😂😂😂.

[@cleomacy4402]

Bo Nix is the best QB in this draft.

[@codylambeth4051]

Bro can we all agree that the 40 time at the combine is the most over valued test? Kamari Lassiter is a DOG for the Texans so far this year. How did he fall to the second round man?? That was a steal!

[@sinbrown8742]

Lets do this at the end of the season because williams looks better then all of them right now

[@brandond8197]

As a bears fan, I do not want Jayden daniels. He will not last long the way he runs. Great qb no doubt but I’m fine with Caleb.

[@IEdjumacate]

IMO, jury is still out on Drake vs Jayden. We’ll see how this pans out over the next 5-10 years. Personally I believe Drake is the best QB in this class.

[@nottodayimbusy7146]

There no comp between thise two except maybe for you guys I expect Drake maye to be a good QB but nothing more than that obviously I disagree on who is the best could be in the class it's obviously right now Jayden Daniels and to be honest it's not really that close outside of bo nix

[@Shelhaun]

Bo, Drake, Bowers

[@travisnelms6120]

5 years ago caleb williams is having a pretty good rookie year. Now a days they're talking about benching him

[@Adrenaline4P]

Caleb still #1

[@Aaronak3]

Malik over Marvin y’all smoking prisoners of the moment, make sure you revisit this 5 to 8 years from now

[@brianschanne6941]

No cornerback when it’s a receivers league and one is already a lockdown corner. Forgetting about Quinyon is crazy

[@BefuddlingRuins]

Why is Yates always so…I dunno how else to say it…whinny?

[@chrislewis7]

The Bears should have traded the first pick. I said it prior to the draft and I still think it. We could've had J.J. McCarthy or Bo Nix and a huge haul for the number 1 pick to build out the offensive and defensive lines and still bring in a very good receiver lower in the draft if deemed required.

[@EternalReich88]

I said prior to the draft they should trade down to #3 and take Maye.

[@calvinsholey2585]

All this surroundings talk, it’s almost like football is a team sport. Really happy about the fact that people are realizing the impact of coaches on the game though.

[@MaxxTitan7]

The Ladies love Mel Kipe Jr.

[@SilFord-o9f]

Mr Yates, NOT everything is STATS, as in regards to Mahomes stats this season, his INTANGIBLES, SUPERCEDES his average stats this season, because, great players find a way to win, even if their stats are not the best #TEACHINGTIME #ESPN #SAS #Feinberg #KCCHIEFS #mahomesMVP

[@jjr3162]

Yall are old men stuck in your old opinion. Bo Nix is going to run the NFL in the next 3 years.

[@GUAP1DD-DEESKI]

Naw bro Jordan love gonna run the league next watch out fam, but love Bo nix he’s nice

[@Alan-bk7ie]

@@GUAP1DD-DEESKIlove throws too many picks he won’t run anything . Murray Daniel’s and mahomes will be the top qbs next year

[@BludMun]

lmfao

[@elliott8881]

😂😂😂

[@GinoCorleone]

The weed in Colorado is next level

[@NicholasKotsianas]

Drake to Washington Williams to NE should be the redraft

[@bryanabdallah6246]

Marvin still goes at 4, one team is winning, and one team is one of the worst in the NFL

[@fAnaticZpodcast]

The biggest mistake the Bears made was letting Kliff Kingsbury leave town without a contract.

[@chucklee2507]

Bo should be higher than Caleb and definitely Maye

[@JoshC619]

Brock Bowers not in top 10? Wicked work here

[@JupiterAshurbanipal]

YALL JUST RUNNING OUT OF THINGS TO YAP ABOUT

[@geraldochi7945]

JD has a much better long ball than CW.

[@bigfamilyX]

Saints Got the best LT in draft btw 🌚

[@rickpeterson8224]

The NFL’s leading receiver doesn’t make the list? Brock Bowers has more receptions than anyone in the NFL and more yards than the three wideouts that made the list. Yes he is a tight end but that just means he blocks too.

[@Lilb.savage]

Draft experts 😂😂😂

[@KornbreadD-v3b]

This is why espn is just not good anymore

[@JohnGraham-tb8zm]

Maybe shell out $100 for Mel to get a camera that works

[@brandongeber7767]

How is projection with no snaps in the NFL better than Snaps with highs and low point so far. this is what is messed up when ranking players.. McCarthy is still in the top 10? What about the fact that he had a season ending injury and he still the top 10 player in May 3 when he’s only had a few games and hasn’t even really been all that good …give me a break…

[@Reallyfrm215]

The generational talent in this draft was daniels who looks like Lamar 2.0

[@Blood-Fartz]

He looks like Jayden Daniels 1.0. Lamar and Jayden are very different players, and have completely different superpowers. Lamar is an elite playmaker, even amoung other elite playmakers. Jayden is an elite game manager, who happens to also have elite play-making ability. Through 10 games Jayden has thrown 2 interceptions. AS A ROOKIE!

[@ShinefortheCam]

Man shut up. They both are great​@Blood-Fartz

[@pl33]

More like rg4

[@yfbotha]

Daniels played FIVE years in college as a QB. This is his ceiling, he isn't going to get much better. Caleb sucks. Maye will be the cream of the crop in two years.

[@jayy88]

You realize he’s an mvp candidate right? How much better is he supposed to get

[@Jones11b]

Brian Thomas jr is better than the other receivers

[@RobertSmotherman-e1f]

Where's Todd field is lackluster

[@bobbyj7156]

Jaden has the same numbers as Caleb in a way better situation, Jaden isn't even the best QB, Nix had better numbers. And I'm sorry but Jaden in Denver isn't having the same success as Caleb or Bo on their teams.

[@JJ-zr6fu]

I hate redrafts not even through the rookie season. I bet the colts are still kicking themselves for passing on rg3

[@Vinylfromtheunderground]

I have drake maye at #2 over Williams who will be a poor man’s Russell Wilson in this league

[@AmusedGarterSnake-yz1hm]

What are these three doing? Have they not been watching the entire season up to this point ? Drake may has outplayed both of them.The last three or four games., but all 3 would still take drake, may third I don't get it #1 Drake Maye #2 Jayden Daniels #3 Caleb Williams Anybody else agree ?

[@EternalReich88]

I’m a skins fan. I agree. I said it prior to the draft.

[@jaken6603]

Brock Bowers might be the best player from this draft. He is outperforming all receivers from it and has poor QB play

[@taylorpack7705]

Caleb isn’t the problem

[@Blacklat58]

Dang the season isn’t even over for rookies to turn it around or finish flat!

[@GluckGluck300]

Maye gonna be another version of Allen in this draft. Daniel’s gonna be another version of Lamar

[@parkmahathey7332]

Legit might just get to a point of where you like them both the exact same it’s just personal preference of which play style you like better lol

[@jayy88]

As a pats fan I’ll take Daniels because he turns the ball over a lot less

[@Leb-9]

@@jayy88L fan. Already rather have a different qb after 5 games🤦‍♂️

[@jayy88]

@@Leb-9 not really I thought Daniels was the best QB before the draft

[@pl33]

Daniels is still too thin and frail...I think drake will be the best qb of the class

[@PaulVisionLee]

Don’t ever forget field Yates thinks last yrs JJ McCarthy would be taken first in this upcoming draft. 😂 I’m sure he prob thinks Lamar is still not a qb as well.

[@goodfella637]

Rams with another steal

[@michaelryan3412]

As a bears fan I’m still riding with Caleb. But I am drafting a LT instead of Odunze

[@AlejandroMuniz-h5z]

Seriously, redraft before the first season is complete.

[@donmon808]

brock bowers is trhe best receiver in the class

[@fathead8165]

The fact that Brock bowers is not in the top 10 is 🤡🤡🤡

[@brandongeber7767]

Qb is 50% coaching/ scheme

[@anovaguy]

Amazing that even with hindsight, these experts are still clueless

[@WesleyC-mn6ln]

give drake maye dj moore, keenan allen and deandre swift or scary terry, and commanders o line and drake maye might even be ebtter than jayden daniels

[@DaveHarbaud]

No nix is pretty good

[@TahitianTreatt]

Jayden Daniels is built like a twig. him behind that bears OL wouldve had him with a blew acl in week 2. id be shocked if he goes 3 years minus a injury in Washington. unless he improves as a passers, and can do more than hit open guys . ive yet to see him thread the needle like a QB with elite precision

[@jayy88]

Hahahaha watch the bengals game my guy dude was dropping dimes. Watch more games

[@Austin-cc7gw]

Bowers would go before Odunze and MHJ

[@Blaq_in_the_hat]

Thank God! No more generational

[@timpo717]

These guys cant even get it right with the benefit of hindsight. Not having Brock Bowers and Quinyon Mitchell in the top 10 of a redraft is embarrassing. Remember when ESPN was great in the 90's? You can get better insight from the mailman who does a YT channel on the side these days.