MELANIE MARTINEZ Tag You're It/Milk and Cookies REACTION! - Jersh Reacts

[@renojams9672]

she isn’t the one on mrs potato head, she was watching Tv.

[@malcrosz5482]

See I hate when people she's Mrs Potato Head when you can obviously tell the difference between the two

[@igertlee8790]

Sir PlatySaxAncona imao

[@bastioncory6740]

It's been a while since he seen that MV. Give him some slack Haha

[@brandonpadilla5402]

Sir PlatySaxAncona I feel like because you watched that first I think he believe that was Melanie and then I think he thinks they make her look older but it’s just a different person lol

[@lovve_buzz]

When I first watched Mrs Potato Head I wasn’t really a fan of melanie, and I thought they were the same (I was like eight) but when I watched it again I realized the difference-

[@arturopita8873]

She actually threw milk at the crowd during her concerts. I was lucky enough to get covered with it

[@stevenrecinos1708]

Eeww 😂💀💀

[@dutchik5107]

Oef. Am happy that with orange juice she just threw orange parts.

[@meIatonin]

Andrea Betances lmaooo

[@lacybartley6438]

*I SHALL NEVER WASH AFTER BEING BLESSED WITH HER MILK*

[@Hey_Jamie]

I’d be pissed. Lol

[@talesaraujopielli3864]

Actually, in “Mrs. Potato Head”, she’s at home and the mom is drunk, that’s why she’s alone

[@ninasangwoo2512]

Tru....🥺

[@gucci6316]

She never turns into an adult‼️ she’s still young at mrs.potato head

[@dani1330]

And then she finally goes to school!! K-12! That makes a lot of sense now lol

[@Llama_Loca]

But she Is 9 years old in pity party (9 candles) and the Plush friends she has in mad hatter represent her K-12 friends

[@Mya11.l]

@@dani1330 yep, in recces she will become 18 but I say when u become 20 it's when u become officialy adult =w=

[@maplehockeylove6339]

Wolf is a metaphor, like when you'd say a guy is a "dog", but more violent and predatory. He doesn't want her dead, he just wants *her*. Milk and cookies is her revenge song. "I pull off black so well" - her attending his funeral "Honey, do you want me now" - like the "How do you like me now?" saying, but mixed with like "Do you still want me [sexually] as I murder you?" She wants him dead for the pain that he has caused her

[@palomaroggeri8680]

The black eyes have alot of meaning, its all going to make sence in the last song, there is a reason why the woman with black eyes knew to gave her the poison Theres also a special meaning to the wolfs cave beeing made of ice Crybaby is actually singing that she is going to poison him not the opposite Also the person who called him to distract him is going to be reveald in the last song Edit: 100 likes???? Wow wasant expecting thet kk

[@madisongilbert197]

I listen to a lot of Melanie Martinez but I still don’t know why the cave is ice or who called to distract him

[@palomaroggeri8680]

Madison Gilbert ice means abscence of love, and non humanaty, a way of saiyng that what the wolf is doing is so terrible, cold and cruel that he has no love inside him, he is so evil that his actions make him not human, a monster with no compassion and no feelings, only obssesion and hunger. the one who calls the wolf to ditract him is the black eyed woman, I dont know if your familiar with the theory of why black eyes and how crybaby, the doctor and the woman in the shopm got them, but basically its a way of showing self exceptence and beeing in peace with your actions, they all been throught difficult things and they all ( at least the woman of the shop) have been victims of the bad wolf, thats why she knows that she needs to give crybaby the poison, and the time that the bad wolf asks her to bake the cookies

[@palomaroggeri8680]

Madison Gilbert all the meanings of the musics and details are in a 54 minutes video but it is in portugues

[@igertlee8790]

Paloma Roggeri uh I think you look to deep into things

[@palomaroggeri8680]

oscuro animations kk yeah I always like to overthink stuff kkkk its what I enjoy most! Kk

[@alphabetboy8569]

"The Big bad Wolf" is a metaphor for a Predetor

[@Kementine]

Also!Its the same house she had the party at!And!She's throwing away the party stuff

[@dutchik5107]

You mean crybabies house?

[@melindaflores1622]

Dutchik yes

[@Kementine]

@@dutchik5107 its her house not alot of crying babies so it's Crybaby's not Crybabies

[@dutchik5107]

@@Kementine k. Thanks for proving your english language capabilities are vastly superior to mine. Well done. You deserve the upmost respect.

[@Kementine]

@@dutchik5107 I didn't say that now did I?I was correcting you,now we can both carry on with our day.

[@redwiinesupernovaa]

So basically the person in miss potato head isn’t crybaby/Melanie so yeah.

[@kidatanakafan]

"Hey I'd like to order a pizza" "I don't know, what do wolves eat?" im dying rn 🤣

[@renojams9672]

can you react to A million men by Melanie???? its an unreleased song that has nothing to do with the albums

[@babyj7446]

such a underrated song !

[@teddybearyy]

Also I think he would love dear porcupine

[@RachelHargitay]

love this song

[@elliewilliamsbae680]

DAMNN I LOVE THAT SONG

[@IAMLUCKYESC]

When you’re done reacting to Cry Baby I would recommend listening to the deluxe tracks (Cake, Teddy Bear and Play Date). Play Date recently went viral out of nowhere which is pretty cool. After that I’d recommend reacting to the songs from K-12 which is her newest album which came out last september. All the songs are about Crybaby during her school life and there is even a movie of about 90 minutes that goes with all the songs. Alsoo, please start reacting to the Kurdish/Dutch singer called Naaz, she’s amazing and did the pre act for Melanie’s shows in Europe ^^

[@coopersteven9105]

Don't forget gingerbread man

[@keiko6155]

play date went viral because of timothée chalamet lmao

[@coopersteven9105]

@@keiko6155 don't mention his name

[@immapotato4045]

Ha Timothee Chalamet even tho I call him Timothee chandler

[@cryoranges3441]

For sure those are my fav deluxe song from crybaby💞💖

[@109helo]

You'll not be sad when it's over because you'll get to watch her "k-12" movie!!!

[@cryoranges3441]

Yes maybe he dont know about the movie😢

[@yn2258]

I like how everyone who looks at this song for the first time so "THERE'S THE KNIFE"

[@acadia1592]

“aNd i BuRy yOu aLiVe LiKe tHe mOnStEr i aM.” The ending though 😂

[@lilypop8315]

as soon as i saw a notification pull up on my phone for this video, i clicked on it right away cuz i was so excited and happy!

[@phroggy1484]

I was thinking "your mama said to pick the very best girl and I am" could be highlighting how ridiculous it is that victims are told that the type of attention they got was a compliment.

[@isabellacortesasenjo4072]

Hey after this crybaby album can you react to the k-12 movie by Melanie Martinez it’s my favorite movie of all time and I also love Melanie she’s my favorite singer

[@whosregulus]

@Laura Martin-Falla yea his reaction are actually good lol

[@lillymoo557]

Ikr❤️

[@lifewiththatonepreppy]

She's my favorite singer too!

[@Llama_Loca]

Its also one of my favorite movies but its sadly not the Best,the storyline seemed weird and some songs didnt Fit with what was going on,but for her first movie its amazing 💛

[@larisaarshinskaya7989]

Same

[@psycho_logical8652]

10:20 I've always thought that her being in the glass (like the rose on Beauty and the beast) means that the person who took her innocence (metaphoric) just kept her to be their prized possession/trophy girlfriend, but idk if that's it.

[@daniekz]

First of, i love your reactions and how you start the video of explaining the last video. In Mrs potato head, she isn't an adult, shes maybe a teen wanting to be like all the other girls in the tv with the blond hair and skinny bodys ect, but after watching that on the tv she realises thats not what she wants.I think shes a teen in Mrs potato head as she has diet pills, but is still child like. At the start of this video so is throwing away her birthday party streamers so she must be still 9 in this song. In the line, "Next time you're alone, think twice when you grab the phone" i believe i read that is a reference to the movie Scream, and to one of her songs. There may have been a hint to this song in the music video for Pity Party, which was Cry Baby having milk and cookies while writing birthday invitations.

[@gerrynolan8739]

Yessss I love melenie reactions

[@ivanalcorchas6110]

I love when you open your eyes all wide lol, you’ve done it in every single video for Melanie so far, and you should react to her movie! K-12

[@ApfersPL]

11:24 it's not even close, but suddenly i had flashbacks to that old video "hello potion seller, i want your strongest potions!"

[@kylawatts4427]

The parts where it's just her head on a table is a reference to the line "I'll cut you up and make dinner" in tag youre it. Also, can you react to something by little mix?

[@watsername]

I think it's a little bit from his perspective of like jersh says having her for dinner on a silver platter, and a little of a traumatic experience like that it's like your head is separate from your body... Because you are trying to run from the situation but can't so you kinda distance yourself.... Either way as someone who was assaulted at 15 this song hits deep for me tbh..... And the amount of times I've poisoned him in my mind is unreal, its why it annoys me when people say she's glorifying rape somehow, when she's just saying its a reality people will take advantage of any vulnerability, but you can take back the power.

[@kylawatts4427]

@@watsername yeah I think that could be it too, but that's just what I read it was supposed to mean. Also I'm sorry that had to happen to you I hope you're doing okay now 💖

[@neuwah]

I cant wait for the k12 reactions! I hope you just watch the full movie for more context on the songs.

[@isisaqui5288]

Me too

[@andyd3447]

Not sure how interested you are with Melanie as an artist but she recently did an interview with the Grammy museum and talks a little more about her artistry and the approach she takes to making music. Its a pretty interesting insight into her creative process.

[@cryoranges3441]

Love you crybaby😍💖

[@insertcoolusernamehere995]

Your jokes on him picking up the phone was adorable

[@ninablack1954]

Tag you're it is my favorite song 💖💖 innocence takes a dark twist...

[@dj-ff9su]

FINALLY its someone who's favourite is tag you're it ❣

[@jessicalogan777]

The poison was given to her by the girl in the store in tag you're it, she used it when the wolf looked away to poison him and escape

[@TheMonia666]

In Mrs potato She's not adult and she's also not the girl that got botched, she's just watching what happened to Mrs potato on TV.

[@ichihimekuroue9745]

Hey! I’m pretty much sure that the black eyed girl that actually gave her the poison without explaining whatsoever is a metaphor for her craziness. And as we can see it’s thanks to her craziness that she gets away with the wolf man in milk and cookies... That’s what I thought about once I finished watching mad hatter...

[@re-red0]

The black eyes symbolize how crybaby lived in many bodies before and that she has powers. The balck eyes are expalained in the k-12 movie by melanie

[@ichihimekuroue9745]

Antonio Karam oh ok... I still think that if my theory was right it would’ve been super cool to see that she gets through k-12 in one piece because of her craziness.... but thank you I didn’t know that ^^

[@gucci6316]

This is right after pity party, you can see her throwing away the decorations in the beginning (no time jump)‼️

[@PrinceDuCiel7]

Sad when the album is over but there’s a whole other album with videos to watch! So it won’t be over any time soon if you move into k12 after~

[@danielaordonez5979]

You can see in the beginning she’s throwing away the decorations from pity party. So she is still 9 in the video. This song is taken place after the party :p

[@etherealnerd]

Jersh: Posts Melanie Martinez video Us: *Rushing over to be the first explain what Jersh missed*

[@g-harmony]

IKR

[@kidatanakafan]

true lmao

[@Gimmie_my_legoz]

Facts

[@g-harmony]

This is legit facts thooo

[@ShotoTodoroki-sv1cu]

Etherel nerd TRUE DAT

[@trash_man_rizuberry]

If anybody here didn't know, the girl who gave Crybaby the poison in Tag, you're it is the same girl who played Angelita in the K12 film

[@milesberkhof]

in tag youre it she is taken and abused by an abductor, and in milk in cookies he makes her make cookies, that she poisons, and finally feels impowered when she kills him

[@cycnical]

in milk and cookies, its's basically cry baby (melanie) making cookies for the wolf, because she has to. she then realises about the poison and plans on poisoning him so she can escape. which is why she probably says 'im fucking crazy' (the song is a follow-up from tag, you're it, hence why they're in a double feature)

[@PettyPerkins]

Dude creep stuck with me for a long time. What a great concept for a film.

[@CarolineForest]

In mrs potato head, its crybaby watching the TV, metaphor for watching her parents. The married couple is her parents, her mom started off happy and in love, then dad is making her feel like shit and starts cheating, and mom starts drinking, and then she had crybaby and her brother. For children, their first influence of beauty and love are their parents, so at a super young age, crybaby was learning to doubt herself... so there is no huge timejump as you thought

[@Kementine]

After you listen to cry baby album listen to k-12

[@cryoranges3441]

YES😍

[@TheNraveles]

For anyone confused about the story, look at her CD booklet "story of crybaby" here on youtube. Explains it very quickly

[@ho5468]

In “Tag, You’re It” when it says “Eenie meanie miney mo, you’re mother said to pick the very best girl and I am.” It’s talking about how he took what his mom said literally.

[@obarraco4047]

Love "Tag, You're It"! Towards the end her voice gets more and more raspy, You can actually hear the rage. Btw, when you said "dating is hard, hun?" I CRACKED hahah Man, It is hard indeed. Also asking You pretty please: consider reacting to "Pienso em tu Mirá" by Rosalía. The video, man. The artistry. You really have to check her out at least once. Trust me See you next time, Jersh! Thank you

[@uncreativenamebcmymindisbl4805]

In milk and cookies there are two nursery rhymes represented in it, the counting like: "one two melatonin is coming for you" is based of the nursery rhyme, I forgot what its called, but it goes "one two buckle my shoe" and than the next one is "ashes ashes time to go down" Is like "ashes ashes we all fall down" I have no idea what those nursery rhymes are called

[@lovely.gamora790]

9:24 just made me laugh so hard LMAO 😂💀🤣 and by the way it's just a character I don't think she's that crazy in real life

[@sailor_brat]

Jersh being sad that Cry Baby reactions are coming to an end and me sitting here like ".....oh I can't wait till he realizes there's a whole ass K-12 to go through"

[@psycho_logical8652]

"Dating's rough huh" I DIED HAHAHAHHA

[@flashoflight9175]

I think the head in the case is a beauty and the beast reference. Like the rose that he keeps in the glass.

[@dj-ff9su]

I am going to watch every single one of your melanie martinez reactions. As soon as its uploaded, I'll be there. Once I get that notification that you've reacted to one of her songs, I'll be there. When you pause the song to dig into her lyrics, I'll be there. When you make a weirded out face cause she just did or said something disturbing, I'll be there. There I will be.

[@julianfvaldiviesogomez219]

The song was after pity party since she has all the decorations from pity party she's throwing them away

[@codylperry]

“Swore I saw you grab the phone” means that she saw the wolf take a phone call and she did some stuff while he wasn’t looking (: and the woman that was at the grocery store look like her friend in her film 😁😅

[@hannahbentley_05]

I was waiting for him to get that the second song was all about her preparing to kill him. Which was the whole line about how he shouldn’t look away - because that’s when she was going to poison the cookies with what she found.

[@Kementine]

Yay!TAg your'e it tag tag you're it

[@dj-ff9su]

LOL same

[@fernandaAaAaAaA]

"i pull out black so well" is like when you go to a funeral you wear black, and the song is about her killing the man (or the wolf lol) so she's basically saying she will enjoy going to his funeral??? like look good wearing black, idk i mean that's how i interpreted it

[@songbirdrosie]

He looks so concerned

[@Hey_Jamie]

When she says ‘next time you’re alone, think twice before you grab the phone’ because that’s when he took his eyes off her to answer the phone and she slipped the poison in the cookies. He missed it because he was distracted.

[@dino6743]

In mrs.potatohead the couple was a show she was watching on the tv

[@flashoflight9175]

Pure love is all consuming...but some people get fucked up and obsess over this idea through a materialistic lens’s...which is expressed in acts like consuming literal blood like it will make you like your victim. Like in fairy tails the evil queens would bathe in the blood of enemies like dark magic type stuff also like all kinds of other wired stuff but to me this is why some killers will ingest literally thier victims. It’s a fascination with certain errors in thought like repressed ways that they could never get through or release they end up having fixations instead

[@henriquejambu]

Yes!! These are two of my favorite videos, happy that you thought they were fun. Really excited for “pacify her” it’s my absolute favorite and I really hope you like it jersh :)

[@TECfan1]

Nah she isn't making poisonous stuff for him, she's just supposed to make normal cookies for him to eat. But when he was on the phone she snuck poison into it.

[@TheNraveles]

The entire Crybaby thing is of her being very young. K-12 is when she goes to school. So during Mrs. Potato Head she isn't older, thats just the character in the TV.

[@sunshinelove-c3q]

I got so excited when it posted.. THANK YOU!

[@matiasdv8848]

Side note: Creep is amazing, !!!

[@captainteeko4579]

That cashier lady returns in her k-12 film as a recurring character if u ever react to that. each song is a reference to each year of school from kindergarten they senior year and it puts together a lot more plot as a film

[@quianuribs6538]

Big fan of your reactions ❤️

[@SuperJersh]

I’m glad you enjoy the videos! :)

[@kalyanifae8331]

shes got a second album ^_^

[@angelap.mateor.9199]

I was waiting for these ones since you started this serie!!

[@vickd9879]

Can’t wait for “Pacify her” next Saturday 🙏❤️

[@gacharaven1205]

I love all the twisted nursery rhymes and little kid games like tag and ring around the roses and Iny Meany my knee mow because it adds to the twisted little kid vibe that has been in all these songs.

[@imcharley]

Okay so in the crybaby album when someone else is talking or it's someone other then Crybaby's point of view the sound is distorted. Thats why in Tag your it the wolf's pov is way deeper than Melanie's actual voice. So Milk and Cookies is from Crybaby's perspective, meaning the Wolf is not trying to poison her, he's trying to use her and just have her as his own I guess, Crybaby is the one who wants to kill him because she's angry (rightfully so) and wants revenge (again, rightfully so). Also, like many have mentioned in Potato head the story we see isn't Crybaby's. In the beginning, she sees all these ads about how to look perfect and she's incredibly insecure so she buys all of it. Then she sees this story of someone who did all of the things she was trying to do to earn love but it ended horribly- which allows Crybaby to see that it's not worth it and it's okay to love yourself for who you are. Crybaby's entire journey is as a child. (Another thing, these two songs happen immediately after pity party so there's no time jump, you can see her throwing away the party decorations at the very beginning. At most it's been a couple days in between) Edit: One more thing lol. A way I'd say to help decipher what's a metaphor and what's actually happening is if it's straight forward or not. Like in training wheels, there's a bit of interpretive dancing and even the lyrics aren't matching what's actually happening (the lyrics are about getting more intimate in a relationship and what's shown is Crybaby teaching Johnny how to ride a bike without training wheels). In tag your it and milk and cookies the lyrics are telling a story (lyrics: making cookies. What's shown: Crybaby making cookies. Lyrics: think twice before answering the phone. What's shown: The wolf picking up the phone while Crybaby pours poison in the cookies. What you're hearing is what you're seeing). Pretty much all of this is applicable to her songs expect for Mad Hatter, I can't say why cause spoilers but that one isn't either metaphor or reality.

[@marielaoquendorodriguez670]

Two of my favorites 🙌🏼❤️❤️ next one it’s Pacify Her 💪 you have a lot way to go still so be prepared!

[@sydfeta12]

Dude you are so entertaining and you make great videos but some of these interpretations are very easy and you just WHOOSH

[@SuperJersh]

Its Syyyd since the point is to find my own meaning in the song I’m never wrong, thx for watching :)

[@Andrei-gf4lj]

Pacify her is next. Also I can't wait to see him react to k-12 it's coming up so soon, can he please react to the whole movie

[@cottoncandyheart7509]

Thank you!! I just waited for that. Keep watching malenie’s songs. And she have a new album... so you can check it out

[@onlyme8780]

"Pull off black so well" It's the color you wear to funerals.

[@ObnoxiouslyAngel]

tag youre it takes place right after pity party, you can tell it showing the mailbox where she sent out the invitations and her throwing away the party decorations at the beginning of the video.

[@brianlucero7656]

I always took the "Milk & Cookies" video a this dude abducting her and trying to force her to give her innocence to him, you know. I never thought of her singing in the table as him looking at her as if she was served in a silver plate for him! That's really interesting! I think you only have Mad Hatter left now. You can do the deluxe tracks. These dont fit in the narrative but can be taken as glimpses on Cry Baby's life.

[@mafuyuki_n25]

The Big Bad Wolf is a code for predator. Just a fun fact. Also in Mrs. Potato Head Crybaby is NOT an adult ~Next is Pacify her👶👱‍♀️~

[@maplehockeylove6339]

This is probably my favorite video from her

[@ashleydelizrioscaraballo575]

Well, wait till you get to the second album which is all a full movie, it's not that you can't find separate videos i can't remember if they're all out but the album came out as a movie if I recall correctly

[@alienboi9498]

I was so hyped for this!

[@elibadillo9413]

Loving this reaction!! Can you react to the Blue Neighborhood Trilogy by Troye Divan? It has a story like Melanie's videos, and the music is really good!

[@faris2497]

Is there anyone who’s going to tell him that her second album have a full movie??

[@lilmeowmeow8935]

She wasn't an adult in Mrs. Potato Head. She was like a teen because she was watching a commercials about beauty but after trying to fix herself she goes back to the tv and sees the whole music video.

[@norahherrmann7500]

Gosh I'm so excited for Mad Hatter

[@lyandaespadas]

I believe Pacify Her is next! Also after you've seen all the songs for CryBaby, please react to K-12! She also has a movie for it. It's all based on CryBaby's journey through school!

[@ventglatormmos669]

Can we take a moment to appreciate in the beginning of tag you’re it you can see her throwing the decorations from pity party in the trash.

[@palomaroggeri8680]

After you end the album and before you watch the k-12 movie you should watch the deluxe songs from crybaby: play date, teddy bear, cake and ginger bread man. They have no direct conection with the album but they can be interpreted as realationships that happend with crybaby. They dont have video clips.

[@andrewlim9357]

The head on the table in🥛 & 🍪 may represents, if she didn’t bake cookies for him (tried to run away but failed) or after she bakes it without putting the poison, she will end up like that

[@LuLu-Sil]

"Tag, you're it" is hard to listen to for me. For the darkest reason I still get nervous just hearing it because it reminds me of that day.

[@kirstiebriggs3068]

Her head is on the table cos it's a metaphor for the saying 'head on a platter' which basically means shes vulnerable ❤ XxXxX

[@Dirtybird143]

Pleeeease do her newest album to after this, those songs are even more connected and has a movie :)

[@yikes577]

Idk why but getting the notification that you uploaded gets me excited lol 😂

[@mandydirksen]

omg yes! Creep! It was so scary and funny when he just stood there with a wolfs mask on

[@Tatum311]

I just saw an add for my queen Elliot lee... CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW UNDERRATED SHE IS???

[@mundain8818]

YESSSS IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONE

[@PauloHenrique-kc6tn]

PACIFY HER is the next.. my favorite

[@peytoncooke1334]

I can't wait for the K-12 reaction videos! Keep up the good work :)

[@mela1378]

Did you see at the start she throw away party things so i think she finished her bday