簡單解釋何謂命運、悲劇！人生的宿命是如何構成？到底人有沒有自由意志？《蕭若元：書房閒話》2024-04-14

[@freddiekwan3899]

希望蕭生講多啲呢類人生，歷史，舊聞趣事話題啦

[@瑞雲-p7j]

在解釋層面下，選擇這個行為定義在表層定義仍然存在，但往深層次選擇在因果中是不存在的，所以因果決定選擇，但不否定行為選擇本身的存在性。可以同時合理。因為在大概宏觀下，我們用選擇這個定義來解釋有其意義存在也簡略了很多解釋，有理解上的方便性而有益於生活層面上的解釋，但在深層次的實際運作上是不存在因果隨機選擇性的。所以自由意志在不否定決論的情況下仍可視為一個生活層面上的合理解釋，只是仔細度不足，不一定能憑此推敲出準確結果。

[@karenng6699]

好喜欢聽閱歷豐富的蕭博士教導人生道理受用無窮謝謝分享👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@liliu7816]

此讲，我看完又看。希望有更多这样的讲解。

[@karenng6699]

感受人生階段由無知愤怒抗拒到接受和绝症差不多领悟後就能處之泰然謝謝分享

[@black_yellow115]

祖母生於清末，成長於中華民國，民盲，爲避戰亂東躲西藏，品性善良又勤勞，一生清苦渡過，死於中共時期，跟很多國人般，經歷三個朝代，無奈的是，生命沒有一刻能自控命途。

[@xpxp2839]

Same as me

[@marcowu6322]

如我祖 母 😂😂.少小父母亡.族人将其卖予别人为妹仔.中年丧夫😂.一生清贫.终生生活在乡下.

[@kfc9291]

期待下個主題

[@lokchiuho2242]

深入淺出👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@candyho1358]

好聽👍🏼

[@paktinlam]

Mr Shiu is my fountain of knowledge, thank you! Looking forward to the next episode!

[@memehongkong]

Glad to hear that!

[@saulinlaw8989]

因果俱時,意味著永恆凝聚於目前的一瞬間。 佛說生也歡喜、死也歡喜。

[@alexchan7011]

命不定，唯人心取向，即使命定，仲有因果業力，行善可改命運！了凡四訓已經實踐了。

[@瑞雲-p7j]

蕭生都係講人生，歷史，理論講得比較好。

[@mocha8232]

Interesting topics which have their own profound meaning behind. Very scientific. Really like these! Thanks!!

[@memehongkong]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@gofishingfun7669]

老肖越老越讲真的。anyway, 都系比较真诚的。

[@hungfaili19]

Support and like Mr Shiu thanks

[@Alfred_Eye]

Mr. Shiu, you are so knowledgeable and make very good presentations. You are my favorite youtuber.

[@memehongkong]

So nice of you

[@nychan2939]

蕭生以為radioactivity係quantum mechanics，其實係兩樣嘢。

[@treepeonies01]

荷馬史詩 “The Iliad” 和 “The Odyssey” 都沒有包括「木馬屠城記」（Troy 的滅亡）的故事。二書最好的英文譯本，所知的，是 Robert Fagles 的，The Iliad 1990年由紐約 Viking Penguin 出版；另有有聲書，很好聽😊。（據研究，Troy 是在今天土耳其半島西岸西北部。）

[@chunwahchan8783]

逍遙派代表人物 蕭生👏

[@RayWong-takgorgorshow]

人生咁短暫…人想得太多了…一笑置之！

[@GoldieCheung]

❤

[@tungminglee5979]

👍感謝分享🙏

[@henryha10]

哲學？！🎉😂❤

[@wingcheungtsang1188]

命不好无论多努力不会成功一后来辛苦过去够用算了体才知道幸福、不要强求不是你的？

[@andy60185]

好期待蕭生再同陶教授做直播

[@jontsang7334]

For most, their opinions were assigned by their leaders. Thus they have neither free will nor liberty.

[@treepeonies01]

不單祇人的終結，就是人- 任何人，不論人種時空 - 的 birth，已經不是自身的決定，即使父母也無可能決定。但，在人生數十年的光陰，還是變化萬千，fatalism 宿命論很多時候僅是不負責任 irresponsibility 的托詞，香港人喜說「整定」，hurray! 之後什麼也不用再談了，這也是唐人的「天命觀」的一個版本。（天命觀，在『書經』中已出現，由來已久，大概已成了唐人民族性的一部分😐。）

[@treepeonies01]

Really 感慨良多，1949、1997、2020，是人為？抑是命運（天意）？Joe Chung has got it right，「來生不做中國人」，但何能今生無悔？Roman Tam 說『我也是過路人』，合情合理：kzbin.info/www/bejne/m4mZcomddtVnjsUsi=XKOwciFRy-dCxVRt

[@treepeonies01]

🫡

[@Jim-mv2hz]

生命重要的是過程，而不是結果。

[@alexchan7011]

生命意義在於存在，活着就是意義。

[@klee5457]

生命的意義 是繁殖與延續，這些機能消失後生命再沒有意義

[@edwardlai3329]

命運 本身不存在選擇........

[@heungwingpang4292]

👍👍👍

[@tzicheung5462]

Being “人” 既有命運使然，更時有悲劇串連。環看維港香江一小島，紅海邊沿加沙一地帶，東歐接壤俄國烏克蘭等疆域，青藏新疆被滅絕，究竟「地緣」是否同樣接受命運的捉弄，更陷於悲劇的煎熬？講 “自由意志，決定論”？講「自決」? 講 fate 講 destiny？嗚呼哀哉，聽天由命，逢時不祥，自求多福吧！

[@mytempuser7210]

many well-known quotes in King Lear - "As flies to wanton boys are we to th' gods: They kill us for their sport"

[@mrslcom]

Entropy (disorder) increases over time. When you know the cause, you can predict its effect. But when you only know the effect, you might not be able to know the cause, as many causes can result in the same effect. Inside the black hole, the laws of physics breakdown and the relationship between cause and effect may not hold true.

[@charling2429]

🙏🙏🙏

[@humanidentity89]

分享一位智者的話給大家，也是我的宗旨「人們應專注於生命中我們能夠掌控的部分，不在掌控範圍的事情，盡力了，之後平常心對待。」 喜怒哀樂也是人生體驗。像電影，勾畫出你「最想要」的人生故事。

[@dudleylai778]

There has been controversies over 'freewill' in church history: In the 4th century Augustine vs Pelagius; in 16th century Martin Luther vs Erasmus of Rotterdam. The Bible speaks about human freedom UNDER God's sovereignty. Martin Luther is more explicit in denying such thing as human freewill in his book 'The Bondage of the Will', which practically set up the foundation for calvinism which emphasises God's predestination, especially Calvin's 'TULIP' doctrine. So fundamentally Protestantism initially insisted that absolute freewill is God's prerogative, beyond human's pay grade; but modern Protestant churches again treat the topic as controversial.

[@philipchin3589]

甄妮曰 命運是對手 永不低頭，你好命就自然熱愛生命架拉，唔通叫人家水深火熱嘅苦命種去熱愛生活？黐交線咩。。。

[@yangmiemie8]

🙏👍👍👍

[@gofishingfun7669]

我希望你更激进点with智力。多谈谈台湾。

[@jennywong7704]

在蕭貓貓買嘢的時候，常常都俾唔到錢

[@mokkent1]

😂

[@mokkent1]

😂

[@mokkent1]

😂

[@張君好]

習包子同祟禎就係人民嘅悲劇

[@Mimifox150]

😂

[@kevinlung]

Human were given free will. Per Sumerians, fate can be changed, destiny cannot be changed. The administration of the world has changed. We are in a transitional period. Old things need to give way to new stuff. Future can be changed because time can go backward. Because humans have freewill, future keep changing. I heard we already escaped one huge earth changing calamity events could have destroyed most of China, US, Europe and eastern Asia at about 2020. The night sky is so dark but supposed to be very bright like day light because of the future it keeps changing because of freewill. Only a very small amount of star lights can reach your eyes because of changes. Death can be delayed, ancient Anunnakis in Mesopotamia area have no predesigned life span.

[@anthonywong7217]

你點能知道哂所有野呀 知道大多數就得

[@aliceleven3656]

今日考试先考完，酒神 悲剧 崇高美；日神 喜剧 滑稽美