True Detective // "Time is a flat circle" (Apparat - Goodbye)

[@suncore598]

I like what you did at the end

[@TonyEdwards1010]

brilliant wasn't it

[@lucassaueressig1411]

Yup

[@Dragon-Slay3r]

It wasn't me 😂

[@ryanwilliams8352]

"Death created time to grow the things that it would kill."

[@TonyEdwards1010]

Always wondered if there’s some truth to it. Usually the uncomfortable truths and possibles are to us just impossible to fathom being true but our fears are simply that they are true.

[@konstantingeorgiev7521]

@@TonyEdwards1010 Read some Schopenhauer first and then Nietzsche and you will be able to form your opinion about this a lot easier. Especially about time being a flat circle and everything repeats itself. In fact, Albert Einstein believed this. See, existence has three pillars - Time, Space and Matter (The Holy Trinity if you prefer religion terms). This is something that both science and religion agree upon. And while time and space are infinite, matter is not. There is always a specific number of people, animals, objects, etc. Like when you throw 2 dice, there are only 36 combinations that can come up. The more you throw both dice, the more often the same combinations you will get. If you throw them for eternity, they will repeat forever. Thus when you have a limited amount of things, existing in an infinite universe for an infinite amount of time... they are destined to repeat. Again...and again....and again...

[@jacobjorgenson9285]

@@TonyEdwards1010 Look up Thomas Ligotti’s book “ The conspiriacy againts the human race"

[@randyjero4664]

@@jacobjorgenson9285 saw your comment. Thank you for recommending it (not 2 me but anyway)

[@thetruththewayandthelife803]

Death is the wages of sin

[@naneohanyan]

“Once there was only dark.If you ask me, the light’s winning.”

[@xavierrenier4140]

Jhon 1.1 Light always won.

[@thebugman8696]

@@xavierrenier4140 John 1:5

[@batuhandemir2225]

I am in love with DARK and i love true detective's 1 season this is like a perfect match, thanks for the vid its perfect.

[@gerhardtfunk4463]

Sie passen perfekt zusammen. Glaub nie etwas anderes.

[@gumustas]

This is literally the best Cohle edit. Sometimes i watch it 10 times in a row.

[@garyluchansky2674]

IMO this first season of True Detective was one of the best shows and performances I’ve ever seen! Both Woody and Matthew were phenomenal in this!😊

[@mertcanpekcay7440]

Definitely one of the best recaps of Season 1, with one of the best choices as the soundtrack.

[@mertcanpekcay5416]

Edit: The best recap out there. Can't avoid watching it every day.

[@lucassaueressig1411]

A yea

[@axeldunal1439]

It’s perfection at the finest art of editing. Rhythmic, meaningful, deserves the plot on a technical level, original in its form and dares to propose a another view over the moral behind the story (that Rust depicts in his words…). Good job is not enough words to describe this piece of art. Congratulations!

[@lucassaueressig1411]

Yes

[@lucassaueressig1411]

Enought cigarretes 10/10

[@ludvigpaulsson2843]

Totally agree, think i've seen this 20 times now 🤩

[@Adino1]

The ending starting over from where it started, great editing Time really is a flat circle

[@CharlesVeitch]

This is maybe one of the most underrated videos on KZbin. I don't say this lightly Video proves its title at the end. Kudos to the editor here. You reached me

[@steobrien2907]

Spot on Charlie. Love listening to RUSTISM on evening walks.

[@VvendigO.]

This edit is a treasure for eternity! LOVE every second of it!

[@Verwaist1998]

That last bit was so simple yet so brilliant. Fantastic work.

[@marknicholson2718]

3/26/2024 my son wrote this flat circle and took his life at 11:56 p.m. Sam was everything to me, my hero, my little boy, my future, my best friend.

[@vg3996]

So sorry for your loss. 😢

[@gokhanozcan880]

I'm so so so sorry man...

[@endgamefond]

I am sorry for your loss. Did he leave a note like in the show? I am so sorry if that's okay to ask

[@crazypantz3492]

Sorry for your loss

[@Enol_S]

"It is better to d*ie sooner with less suffering than to d*ie later with more suffering."

[@justinkyle5091]

I respect the hell out of this tribute. Fantastic work.

[@SentientSoy]

".. A dream you had, about being.... A person." damn.

[@Taxman613]

Well played at the end , it takes a strong mind to understand brilliance in a simple thing

[@Ailend166]

Wow, the music, the monologue, how you edit it, just wow!

[@yashmeshram6943]

Instantly transported 3 yrs back , masterpiece hands down👏

[@FOREVERSTAKEN]

I keep coming back to this.

[@Courier7425]

The best True Detective video I've ever seen, I've been looking for one this good for a while, excellent work.

[@gergoegres3387]

This feels diffent after a few glasses of whiskey...

[@jolek1989]

One of best edits on youtube, great job !

[@alchemist678]

I am responsible for at least one of 63 thousand views of this masterpiece

[@GageClift]

Best True Detective edit I've seen. Props. This season is literally my favorite piece of art ever created.

[@Nasir_3.]

This is pure perfection

[@worldneedbadman]

Молодец! Уже вторые сутки не отпускает это сочетание кадров, монологов и песни, ты отлично прочувствовал!

[@kimmyfreak200]

i have never missed a grouchy negative pessimistic but truthful rant more than Rust... i smiled ear to ear just now at the beginning...i miss this show...i need to re-watch this season...first time i saw the teaser i said THIS IS GONNA BE SPECIAL... they both deserved those emmy wins woody and matthew were amazing

[@SarostonFaramon]

You reminded me how much I love this song, plus a wonderful CMV of True Detective! :D

[@amestel19]

Watched a lot of True Detective fanvids and this one is still the best. Love the emotion, love the last part, it makes me think of Life is Strange somehow. Awesome work!

[@NokkOnWood]

This is easily the best true detective tribute (& one of the best tributes) I’ve ever fuckin seen

[@lifeisberserk9566]

Have you seen the night call video that's my favorite

[@whitebeard8129]

insane this ist just insane what a phenomenal work

[@Abhishek_5harma]

This is perfect, just perfect.

[@nightdreamer7509]

gorgeous, brilliant!

[@jofubar2763]

Nice.. best tv shows.. Dark and True D. ses1..

[@Ifzirzurz]

See everything outside our dimension...that's eternity. Eternity looking down on us. Now to us....its a sphere....but to them... it's a circle

[@decoratus8club21]

Очень крутые видео...все! Отличная работа, которую хочется пересматривать...и пересматривать....и пересматривать...

[@MentalistRUS]

Спасибо!

[@veerkharod]

True Detective x Dark = beauty

[@mehdir4954]

Woof!

[@tannedbrunette1]

Great video. This was a great tribute and I love the music used in. You did a really awesome job with this video.

[@crazypantz3492]

This is extremely well done

[@r.mukherjee3445]

O shit this is good...really you proved the philosophy ..

[@miller4216]

surely the best edit i've ever seen

[@finecallmejane]

Perfectly done. Well and truly!

[@pseudointellectual8992]

Awesome work man

[@tylerdurden8640]

Listen to me, there's bunch of TD-S1 tributes out there, with lots of views and likes... trust me mate, this is one of the best that I've seen and I watched it all probably. Great connection. Rust may be the best character ever made on TV.

[@shingnosis]

Probably the hardest hitting writing on any show or film I've seen. It's so hard and so good that I don't recommend it to any of my friend before they're 40 years old, really.

[@RagingCajun985]

Genius awesome 👏🏼 bravo I love it

[@Rookie-2552]

This is an awesome edit, one of my favourites

[@Bohani]

Absolutely incredible edit!

[@janinekaretai4306]

Loved it. Work of art

[@lucassaueressig1411]

wow man. nice editing!

[@BijiMustardGas]

Powerful edit my friend. Inspiring.

[@alonzoprovider2987]

Part from 3:00 is masterpiece, great video!

[@lucassaueressig1411]

Hell yea

[@shesaidshewaslvl18]

Season 1 is the best tv you'll ever watch

[@cloudfl9518]

It was all the same thing, It was all the same dream

[@ju-df2ou]

wow this is beautiful

[@gouravsingh520]

Love the ending 😍

[@rickygillies28]

Masterpiece

[@shadow_self8564]

This video itself is amor fati

[@serbarristanthebold]

Def the best td edit ❤

[@naimulhuq5128]

Legendary

[@sauce556]

This is art.

[@aiden_adams]

Amazing edits! Welldone.

[@giulionatali3968]

4:12 / 4:13 subliminal spiral appeared. A great video btw, ciao from Italy

[@mohankn7372]

If there's any video on KZbin which justified its title is this one. I really loved what you did at the end. I could watch this all day. Perfect song and editing. True Detective, The GOAT ♥️♥️

[@someoneyouneverknew222]

Masterpiece.

[@SawII565]

Nothing is ever over

[@SawII565]

Don’t walk away now. Mentalist. I noticed there was a deflection from your friend.

[@pilholski]

Can u imagine being on 1 of the seasons after #1 and trying desperately to match it, but inevitably failing bc it’s essentially not possible lol? 😅

[@copamatique]

perfect tribute ❤️

[@nothingno5759]

Underrated

[@neilsonlea9343]

I really enjoyed the editing here. Lots of smooth transitions - particularly when Rust is shooting the tommy gun.

[@lucassaueressig1411]

Here again And again

[@keithgordon3823]

Great job, man!!!! Best show & character, ever! EVER!!!! 🤘

[@yourbrain5685]

It just struck me, with the perspective of the dark series, and Rust himself saying "I tell myself it's to bear witness." Thats what he is throughout the series. The witness and commentator, who feels powerless. Whenever he tries to become a part of life it blows up in his face. The death of his daughter, and the end of his relationship with Lori. Which it is revealed in a deleted scene was caused by his unwillingness to bring children into the world. This video perfectly shows how Marty is the one who thinks he's so important. The participant of life in stark contrast to Rust. Rust thinks he has life all figured out but doesn't truly live, and Marty lives but knows he has nothing figured out. In the end, this show is about perspective. Flat circles, dead children, stars against black skies, dead gods - old and new. We're forced to bear witness, along with Rust, to the worst of humanity. Even Marty with the benefit of hindisght is finally a Witness to his own life rather than a mindless participant. Finally arriving at the nihilism of the show. Stating as a fact that there's no purpose, no ultimate meaning to the immense suffering depicted. But we who are witnesses, finding perspective in a world we're often powerless to change.

[@lines170]

Best fucking McConaughey's character of his whole life 🤚

[@danzo3879]

This is genius 😭

[@hollyiii2939]

Awesome!

[@EverythingIsaboutyou]

lmafo, so funny...... love it!!!!!

[@cjrr9255]

Amazing work

[@RizaJR]

Top

[@Nergal_Slayer]

You're gifted

[@NightBreakerDK]

".....Surly this is all for me. Me me me, I, I, I..... Im so fucking important,.... Right"

[@dalmar23]

4:12 look at hes forhead

[@davidcurtis9110]

I caught it too....

[@oculus4521]

i thought i was on 1 lol

[@kitsune-lb2ft]

What if the music for "DARK" was used in "True Detective"...? Fantastic.

[@pandahsykes602]

The first season of this series was so gritty, poetic and exciting …. I really hope the 4th season does the same but it already looks like it’s trying to fill quotas instead of be good .

[@Batrick.Pateman.45]

It was dreadful mate

[@m.shuster7711]

Прекрасная музыка и прекрасная нарезка

[@arshadur.r.tayebb]

Listening to this as a song.

[@AlphaBravoDingo]

very good pairing

[@valeenoi2284]

4:13 You put that mark on his forhead.

[@qontoh2s872]

I caught that too! Again...

[@jeffwhite3625]

@@qontoh2s872 Surprised that more people did not catch the image of the "Flat Circle" at 4:13. Truly a fucking masterpiece of film making and writing !

[@sinjin1259]

Well done.

[@hulismotrish1]

like it.

[@MentalistRUS]

)

[@gerhardtfunk4463]

Gestern, heute, morgen folgen nicht aufeinander. Sie sind in einem ewigen Kreis miteinander verbunden.

[@naneohanyan]

💙🌀

[@queentee2806]

I could listen to Rust Cohle talk all day literally and I would agree with everything he’s saying even if I don’t actually don’t agree with him 😂

[@jordipas3921]

Súper!!!

[@rodneyginokc]

Maybe this is why we have so much Deja Vu.

[@simonlarkin7296]

Nice liked & subbed and saved to favs immediately This is the content! this kinda thing... is what enriches the youtube experience!! Not like all those media/corporate snippets NOT like the bs in YTs Short Fk that format now & forever that fkn toxic flim flam that sickening saccharine snik snak that makes me sick as a pike Not to take away from what I just said , but I feel what Cohle says is a lot important than the nice background music so any chance you could turn the bg music volume down a bit in the mix please

[@diamonddestiny704]

Fuck this tribute make me fully realize how deeply distorted Rust perception of reality and how it stems from scarring life experiences.

[@annalisavajda252]

He said himself he had PTSD and was in a psych ward but much of his problem is he is more intelligent than his co-workers or most people so he's alone with his thoughts too much and because he's so smart and sulky it makes him seem suspicious himself so he's not paranoid he just has heightened awareness. It is an ugly world too he's seen ugly things so many maybe he can't see beautiful things anymore. Marty is too casual a partner for him too he lost his family tragically and Marty just willingly throws his away.

[@imaB2kool4uTWO]

The ultimate pessimist

[@xxxthetruthxxx4765]

they shouldve never produced another season. its impossible to live up to what they did in season 1 as far as story telling, character development and overall acting goes.

[@Edward_G_Popey]

Exactly. 🖤 This is something Else.

[@xxxthetruthxxx4765]

@@Edward_G_Popey started rewatching season 1 for the 3rd time yesterday and it still gets me.

[@khokhoiasem3500]

If we see life from Rust perspective. It new and very interesting.l love it.