Meteorite or MeteorWRONG? ☄️Compared to real Meteorites -Knowledge Bolide Crew Discuss

[@daxlog1685]

Thank You all for taking the time to share your vast knowledge. Could someone share the means with which you are lighting the samples for optimizing evaluation. Thank you again.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Dimmable 3000K-6500K Photo Studio Light Box 20"x20" www.amazon.com/Neewer-3200K-5600K-Professional-Photography-Backdrops/dp/B07X23MFCC

[@amywelsh8225]

Will you guys consider doing some more videos like this?

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Yes, there are already others on my channel. Have you tried searching?

[@amywelsh8225]

@@TopherspinMeteorites yes. I’ve watched them all twice or more. Fascinating! I don’t even live somewhere where I could find them (Wisconsin), but I’m still super interested. I’m curious to learn more about internal features that don’t require special equipment (beyond chondrules).

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I am super happy that you and others are enjoying the channel and learning more about authentic meteorites. You may know that my computer is down. My motherboard is out being repaired. As soon as it's back I am dying to be creative and get more videos up.

[@marcustsinnie9392]

Does the shergottite have a strong magnetic response to them?

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

No.

[@aladeismail]

I have example 2 , how to get you

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Did you have a comment or question about this video?

[@joncan2348]

NWA12953 looks like chocolate chip dough. 🍪

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I see that. Nice! I always thought it resembled biscotti. Thanks for watching & commenting.

[@AlvianFrangkie-uv7ck]

Whos can buy my meteorit iron stone.? Im live in Indonesia in Papua island. I have a meteorit iron stone atractive to magnet ✌️

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Please subscribe.

[@arielrojas1103]

How do I know that I'm holding a meteorite.i have more coliction how do I publish and sale.?

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

A lot of time must be spent educating yourself to know the difference. Please watch the hundreds of hours of educational videos on my channel.

[@benedictalandagora7364]

Hi I can Disturb you for awhile I have a noñe magnetic suspected meteorite do we have a favor to look for it and when it comes about from philippines

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Please read the description to any of the previous 290 videos I have loaded for the link and the directions of where to load your pictures.

[@stonescollection7703]

Can you help me to identify a few stone that I think it’s a Meteorite?

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Please read the description to any one of the 250 videos I have loaded for the answer to this question..

[@dirkjackson1267]

Thanks for the education. Very helpful.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Glad it was helpful! Should be mandatory watching before asking anyone for a rock ID. Thanks.

[@freshimpactco.8698]

Wow there is so little difference between the NWA 13366 and the terrestrial rock that it would be very difficult to see the differences, I would be also dwelling on their similarities.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

We tend to see what we are looking for. That is the problem. It helps to change your point of view to look for differences rather than similarities. I'm very happy that you're enjoying the content. Thank you for commenting.

[@AliAlzedawy-mf5cb]

حلقه مفيدة جداً

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thank you.

[@prafulkachhiya4152]

❤ very. Yusful video thanks for sharing,,,❤ great Riyal great knowledge

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around. We need a bigger audience for this great information.

[@justinparker7795]

Thank you!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Glad you enjoyed it. Are you subscribed to my KZbin channel?

[@justinparker7795]

10-4, I got some chondrites , I'll get some pic so you can check em out

[@ozzyoddity]

Oh wow! I'm blown away from what I just learned in 15 minutes from this video. Unfortunately, I now have to throw out about half of the "samples" I have in random spots in the house. You sure my wife didn't hire you to fab up a video on "wrongs"? Hahaha

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I had to read your comment out loud to my wife. She thought it was as hilarious as I did. Thanks for stopping by and commenting. Super happy that it was an educational video for you.

[@freshimpactco.8698]

😂😆🤣👍🏻 hahaha Yeap wives don't like rocks just lying around the house so funny.

[@erneogalit4731]

Hello sir, i want you to helping me for i dintifiy my stone, i say my stone in mountain but i need you to helping me to identify if true meteorite im seeling if true meteorite sir thank you.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Did you have a comment or question about this video that worked really hard on?

[@meteorite-meteorite9964]

I learn allot to your channel sir and that you for more information about meteorite more power👍👌👌

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Great comment - THANKS!! Thanks for watching & subscribing! It helps!

[@meteoritehunter7362]

Good advice

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks 👍 Are you subscribed to my KZbin channel?

[@HoboMinerals]

By triple junction, you mean square jawed alien faces? Cause that’s what I see lol!! And as much as I love trying to learn the science behind the meteorites, I like the explanation for the things you see and don’t see!! And it gives you a chance to show your audience that you mean what you know!! Know what I mean? You have so much knowledge and it shows!! I will be a forever fan for sure!! Already tried to subscribe harder, but can’t…

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Ha! You gotta subscribe harder!! Thanks for the comment. I try my best to help explain the features in the meteorites from a scientific POV. But, people always tend to 'see' things in some of the stones. I was just accused of selling hand carved Indian artifacts as meteorites because of someone's ability to 'see' a bear and a fish on a Gao-Guenie that fell to Earth ion 1960.

[@HoboMinerals]

@@TopherspinMeteorites if you don’t have haters, you’re not doing it right… Science rules in the end and I believe you’re truthful in what you do.. Why would you be educating people for FREE if you just wanted to scam them? Your information checks out for everyone else, even famous people! You’re out there changing lives, but that fool is visually impaired so you’re not truthful in what you do? Ha! I can see animal shapes in clouds, but it doesn’t make em rain elephants… It’s got to be frustrating trying to help people and they think you’re drowning them.. So to speak.. I hope you keep a great attitude about yourself and your wife because there’s lot of people that think you’re awesome, especially me! Thank you so much

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

If people only realized how many times I am contacted with wild claims about amazing finds. People go on to say how everyone in their life has left them, lost all their money, nobody believes them, scientist won't answer them, and people like me control the global supply of meteorites by stopping theirs. But, I will just keep doing what I do: try hard to share real meteorites & information with those eager like you - THANKS!!!

[@Curious_as_cats]

Loved this! So so helpful. There’s not enough content online discussing meteorites / wrongs with intelligent explanations and such great close ups. Thank you!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Glad you enjoyed it! I am hoping to replace all the crapy non-science videos and really offer some help. Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around. We need a bigger audience for this great information.

[@markmcarthy596]

Nicely done Topher & gang

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks Mark!! I see all the crappy videos with WAY too many views not to do this educational one.

[@markmcarthy596]

@@TopherspinMeteorites - absolutely. I’ve been overly excited myself before and meteorwronged

[@amywelsh8225]

I would love for this video to become a regular segment on your show. I love listening to the experts discuss and chime in and explain their observations. I love this channel thanks so much for all the knowledge!!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Rockhounding is a small slice of the meteorite hobby. There is a bunch to focus on. If people sent me samples, I would do more of these.

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

Kalau emang kirim foto atau video batu meteor ny cara ny melalui ny bagimana nyonya

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

How do I send the sample? The thing is, the stone only weighs 2 ounces

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Search my channel for "classification"

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

what is the name of the channel

[@to-kt9og]

Irudyum platinum ore not megnetic cover sir

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I am not the best person to cover that topic. Please subscribe.

[@shahmd.ferozahmed9980]

How can I upload a sample of ureilite?

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I don't offer free services to help ID stones. I am not a trained Geologist. Do you believe that you really have a meteorite? Submit pictures to: facebook.com/groups/isitameteorite or facebook.com/groups/meteorite.or.meteorwrong. The power of the Facebook Groups I recommend is that there are a bunch of knowledgeable geologists and meteorite people in there.

[@shahmd.ferozahmed9980]

@@TopherspinMeteorites So far I have acquired little bit knowledge from your presentations as well as from various online articles and demonostrations, I believed that I have meteorites. Trust me I am a very fast learner which is the part of my actual profession where there is no chance of doing single mistake. A single mistake of a Captain may result sad demise of numbers of valuable lives, billions of dollars assets. I have dominated all the oceans in the world very efficiently and visited every corner of the world, gathered their living styles, culture etc. I never ask you to provide me free service, which I hate. My life is full of struggle that's why I know how to honor a person. You may think how a simple person from a poor country say in this way. Yes, you can go through the history of Indian sub-continent which was civilized 400 yrs before BC but the history of US not that much rich and ancient. Thanks Mr. Topherspin. Be happy and live a prosperous life.

[@sharifbakhshi720]

من هم شهاب سنگ دارم میشه براتون ارسال کنم

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

English only please

[@coreyandsarahlynch]

#2 could be l6 impact melt

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks.

[@Grendel1974]

You notice on 1 has an x structure going to the center

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Sure. What does that mean to you?

[@angelitocapistrano7318]

wow...very informative.thanks

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Glad it was helpful! Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around. We need a bigger audience for this great information.

[@rogerhargreaves2272]

Magnetic influence, that’s what I can’t get across to people when they ask me. Thanks. 👍

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Right on! Another term is "magnetic susceptibility". Please subscribe & spread the word about our small but growing channel.

[@rogerhargreaves2272]

@@TopherspinMeteorites ✔️ done. 😀👍

[@sinyuabd.rahmanhjtammoyo8550]

That mean, IF that rocks similar with Martian texture inside and magnetic to, could be Martian meteorite topher??please give the respon personal to brother..thanks

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Without a timestamp, I don't know what you're talking about. Anything I called Earth in this video is Earth. Anything I called Mars or Moon is Mars or Moon. Mars is not attracted to a magnet.

[@jamitolopez7023]

Hello my name is Jaime Lopez I have found a lot of ancient rocks and meteorites some have writing a lot of them have faces I would like to know if you can help me or let me know what kind of rats do I have let me know in the comments and I will send you pictures thank you and God bless you

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

@jamitolopez7023 Thank you for reaching out to me. It's great to hear about your finds, but as a professional in the meteorite field, I have to be careful not to identify specimens without proper testing. I suggest reaching out to groups on Facebook such as "Meteorite or MeteorWRONG" for further assistance with identifying your rocks and meteorites. They have a great community of knowledgeable enthusiasts who can help you. Best of luck with your collection!

[@jamitolopez7023]

@@TopherspinMeteorites I have been studying these rocks and every day they get more interesting there's gold in them there's diamonds there's all kinds of minerals in it if you will help me I would like to make money with you I live in Mexico Monterrey it's a big city surrounded by mountains it's a long story the way I found them I would like for you to help

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

What did the Facebook Groups I recommended say about it? You did take my advice after asking for it and getting it. Right?

[@TenesseeTuxedo1]

This was a fun one. Wow so many views!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Yeah, it is a popular video and should only grow in time. It's about time!

[@alarikepler8738]

People what are You looking for? If You looking for pish of rear life planet you know all stones from Earth are so expensiv in galactic market. Think about how big is galactica and all cosmos how mach diferent posible materials there are? Earth samples are miljon time more rear. Think about it!?

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I tried my best to understand. But, Earth samples are not "million times more rare" than real meteorites on Earth.

[@mesaykekay0323]

I'm so many like that...how to buy this...pm.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

My available inventory can be found at www.tinyurl.com/topherspin

[@kaioken3691]

Thanks to you guys im even better - all of them confirmed as meteorwrongs except diogenite! I take this episode as personal test, so please more challenges like this!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I am super happy to know that you enjoyed this video and learn something from it. I am debating making more of these. With this kind of feedback I am thinking very hard about it.

[@shahmd.ferozahmed9980]

Wonderful lesson, Thanks

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

THANKS!!! Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around.

[@shahmd.ferozahmed9980]

@@TopherspinMeteorites Already subdcribed by signing on. But unfortunately I couldn’t sell a single piece without certification, although I have more than 100 pieces ready for selling.

[@arneldionecio9136]

A have one nwa 12953

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Who did you buy it from?

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

I have the stone, it weighs 2 ounces, I tested it with a sounding metal detector, but on the test with a magnet it didn't stick, if it's a meteorite I want to sell it, my roof has a hole in it because the rock fell

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

I don't offer free services to help ID stones. I am not a trained Geologist. Do you believe that you really have a meteorite? Submit pictures to: facebook.com/groups/isitameteorite or facebook.com/groups/meteorite.or.meteorwrong. The power of the Facebook Groups I recommend is that there are a bunch of knowledgeable geologists and meteorite people in there.

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

yes, I'm absolutely sure that I have it, ok, thanks for the advice, Mrs.

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

Salam kenal nama saya bary prima asal negara dari indonesia jawa barat,saya tidak bisa berbahasa inggris,tetapi saya pakai transleat,selamat bekerja Mrs.Greetings, my name is Bary Prima, from Indonesia, West Java, I can't speak English, but I use transleat, happy working Mrs.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Cool beans

[@coreyandsarahlynch]

Course grain basalt is what you expect to find from a segregated asteroid outer belt

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks.

[@mohamed19-g7w]

الصورة الثانية ممتلئ بمعدن بالميكا

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks

[@coreyandsarahlynch]

These all appear to be metamorphic so technically not meteorites but might have been

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks.

[@coreyandsarahlynch]

#6 most likely not unless knocked out of deep inside at impact

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks.

[@JP--pe4ny]

I'm loving the show guys everyone brings their own style on providing knowledge to newbees like myself. I just started looking for meteorites maybe 2 months ago maybe less and in that time have gathered at least 700-1k golfball sized or smaller rocks that "respond to a magnet" lol.. and respond very well actually. Next step is to try and get a few checked out before going back out. Thank again Topher and all u guys n gals for all the great advice and knowledge.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks for watching and commenting. The Crew is strong! 1,000 potential meteorites in 2 months?!?! Good luck filtering them down. Stay tuned...

[@ianmiller5027]

Very interesting and useful show Topher.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks so much Ian! It is nice to finally see a video like this on youtube. None of them that I saw have real meteorite side by side. That is truly how you learn.

[@Meteoritesanalyses-qq5hx]

5:55 this is not a meteorite!!! A not mars meteorite!!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Odd that my sample at the exact timestamp looks identical to the sample picture in the actual MetBull entry seen here: www.lpi.usra.edu/meteor/get_original_photo.php?recno=5819626 Trying to find a fake meteorite on my channel will drive you mad. There are none. Give up. I offer 100% lifetime authentication with money back. Buy a real Mars meteorite from me and read my signed Certificate of Authenticity. If you ever make another false claim against me, you will be muted.

[@baryprima-rm7ns]

good evening, sir, I have a rock, but it looks like my meteorite is from Indonesia

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around. We need a bigger audience for this great information.

[@MeteoricStoneofSouls]

My rock collection has a little over 1000 pieces. I have (I think) 14 pieces of meteorite. All of them are certified.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Collecting is a great hobby! Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around. We need a bigger audience for this great information.

[@MeteoricStoneofSouls]

@@TopherspinMeteorites Do you sell meteorites?

[@alshayb8029]

Nice video that helps to distinguish between meteorites. Thanks

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

You bet! That was my goal. I hope this helps people!!! Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe.

[@hamidaghan7492]

👍👍

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks for watching - Please be sure to subscribe and pass the word around. We need a bigger audience for this great information.

[@conancarroll4780]

😻👍👍💥...nicely presented. Excellent point about looking for differences, more so than similarities.

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks - that one fact is lost on many rockhounds.

[@coreyandsarahlynch]

7 is a breccia

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks.

[@mohamed19-g7w]

الصورة الاولى كوارتز

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks

[@mohamed19-g7w]

@@TopherspinMeteorites عندي سؤال عندي حجر عندي اسود اللون به تشققات وبه تجاويف مع نسبة احتراق قليلة في جزء منه. وقوي الانجذاب للمغناطيس عند تكبيره بالمكبرة تلاحظ به حبيبات حمراء فهل هذه الصفات توجد في معادن الأرض

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Please use Google Translate to communicate in English.

[@DitDhf-dx1gq]

👋

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Please subscribe

[@tudenjamir2028]

🙏👍

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Thanks. Are you subscribed to my KZbin channel?

[@marcelocosta192]

Tenho um meteorito raro pra vender ele é rochoso pq não pega imã mais tem um pouco de ferro

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Use translate.google.com/

[@paulkearns100]

MAN MADE

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Actually, nothing in the video was man-made. Everything was a naturally occurring rock that was found.

[@marcelocosta192]

Not English!!!

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

To change subtitles from English to any other language, start the video, turn on subtitles, click the settings "gear" icon and select "Subtitles". This will allow you to select the option of "Auto Translate". Now you can chose any of 50 languages.

[@coreyandsarahlynch]

Course grain basalt is what you expect to find from a segregated asteroid outer belt

[@TopherspinMeteorites]

Perhaps.