Evolution of the Paris Metro & RER 1900-2035 (geographic map)

[@KakoyToChen2023]

I already know how I'll spend the next 22 minutes

[@marclacroix1365]

Same...

[@andreidobrican7445]

How ?

[@attasaravani3048]

Do you mean 23 minutes?

[@KakoyToChen2023]

​@@attasaravani3048ohhhh, right

[@marclacroix1365]

@l.a1532 why in the world did you go on 3 bis PS: who didn't)

[@magnetique12]

Small anecdote, the "Montparnasse" station was renamed "Montparnasse Bienvenüe", in homage to this hero designer of the Paris metro, Fulgence Bienvenüe, this station which serves the Montparnasse station, station of the train lines (and TGV) which are going to the Brittany region, Mr Bienvenüe's region of origin.

[@dien971]

Sauf que personne ne dit "monparnasse bienvenüe"

[@magnetique12]

@@dien971 Effectivement, c'est plus simple malheureusement.

[@dien971]

@@magnetique12 oui

[@thunderbolt8409]

@@dien971 bah si la voie de la 13 elle dit à chaque fois "Montparnasse Bienvenüe? Montparnasse Bienvenüe carefull to pick pocket"

[@dien971]

@@thunderbolt8409 jte parle des gens pas des voix du metro

[@Jeff_LD]

What a fantastic job, awesome !!!! For those who don't know Paris region transport system, there are many more lines with transilien trains, tramways and very soon the grand paris express and the cable line C1 ❤

[@johnbiltonpersonal4064]

Now THIS is the one I've been waiting for! Amazing video 🎉

[@SteevenKraichi]

19:09: This section has been transferred to Tramway line T12 (to be precise)

[@KyrilPG]

That's right, but the express trams are classified under Transilien.

[@SteevenKraichi]

@@KyrilPG In some lines: T4, T11, T12 and T13 and its affiliations

[@ronylouis0]

​@@SteevenKraichiT4 is not classified as a transilien, it has standard T+ ticketing and not origin - destination

[@Lodai974]

@@ronylouis0 The other tram lines too. The T4 is well affiliated with Transilien Est (based in Noisy le sec).

[@johannmada972]

Transilien is just an SNCF brand for the region of Paris, everything operated by the sncf is Transilien, even RERs

[@llllwwww75]

omg, I never realized how paris build those metros like crazy for the past 100 years, and continue to do so! We do take it for granted and complain for its dirtiness, but it's just amazing to visualize this way this gigantic project! Bravo on the video too!

[@robloxgday2024]

Paris has the balls to extend both during WW1 and WW2 The speed of development never really decreases, almost extending every year. Now I understand why this took three whole months. Its a lot of work!

[@cdrw92]

and it does not even include the whole network

[@robloxgday2024]

@@cdrw92 Yeah. Also trams. This just shows Paris actually cares about public transportation, unlike most cities in a North American country.

[@JdMsk]

The 90% of construction works of extentions of lines 5 and 8 were finished by the French themselves before 01.09.1939. They finished the rest without support of Nazis.

[@robloxgday2024]

@@JdMsk Obviously. Why would the Nazis support France in building the metro? I just said that during WW2/Nazi occupation, they still managed to extend the metro.

[@JdMsk]

@@robloxgday2024 I'm not in details of this period of the construction except the fact they had build the most part of tunnels before occupation in juin 1940 (I made the mistake, not to 01.09.1939). The Nazis let to finish the extensions cause all urban busses were confiscated and sent to the German needs. Then the first beneficiary was the German authority cause it facilitated movements of German soldiers in Paris.

[@S.M.Jean-Mahmoud_Ier]

*Little update guide to y'all, from the 2024 snapshot at **19:19** :* - Subway line 11 to Rosny - Bois Perrier : OPENED - RER line E to Nanterre - La Folie : OPENED - Subway line 14 to Saint-Denis - Pleyel : OPENED - Subway line 14 to Orly Airport (ORY) : OPENED - Aérofret station on RER line B : under construction - Subway line 15 : under construction - Bry-Villiers-Champigny station on RER line E : under construction - Subway line 18 : under construction - Subway line 16 : under construction - Subway line 17 : under construction - RER line E to Mantes-la-Jolie : early works - Subway line 18 to Orly Airport (ORY) : early works - Subway line 16 to Noisy-Champs : planned - Subway line 17 to Parc des Expositions (Villepinte Expo Center) : planned - Subway line 17 to Le Mesnil-Amelot : planned - Subway line 18 to Versailles-Chantiers : planned - RER line E to Tournan - Val Bréon : planned - Subway line 15's northern part to La Défense : planned - Subway line 10 to Ivry : planned - Subway line 1 to Val de Fontenay : planned - RER line B to Rouvres : planned - RER line C to Coignières : early works - RER line E to Meaux : planned

[@Lodai974]

At November 2024 - Subway line 15 south : last works , test trainsets, opening Fall 2025 - Subway line 15 East : Early works ,TBM for 2025 - Subway line 15 North : Early works ,TBM for 2025 but 3km tunnel already finished - Subway line 15 West : Early works ,First digging for stations,TBM for 2025. - Subway line 16: last works , first transet arrived in the workshop opening 2026. - Subway line 16 to Noisy-Champs : planned nope !!! under construction from 3 years tunnel finished. - Subway line 17 to Le bourget: last works , first transet arrived in the workshop opening 2026. - Subway line 17 to Parc des Expositions (Villepinte Expo Center) : under construction (viaduc and station are under construction now.) - Subway line 17 to Le Mesnil-Amelot : early works (CDG2 station early works , Mesnil amelot station early works) L18 will open between Massy and Saclay in 2026.It's first section.Workshop finished ,first trainset will arrive inT2 2025 - Subway line 18 to Orly Airport (ORY) : early works Nope! Under construction , tunnel finished ,stations finished at 55% . - Subway line 18 to Versailles-Chantiers : planned Nope!! under construction TBM is digging now One station under construction , the 2 last are in early works stage. RER E to Mantes , last Works!! Opening in 2026 or Winter 2025

[@KyrilPG]

Fantastic work! Wow, it must have taken you hours and hours to make this. It's probably the most detailed, accurate and nicely presented video about Paris Metro and RER evolution I've seen. Kudos! If there's an update sometime, it would be great to also include the tram network that recently developed massively and is expected to grow even more. (There are 360km of new lines and extensions to open between now and 2032 between all networks, excluding regular bus). Plus the Transilien lines for good measure. 🤣 This would be the ultimate spaghetti bowl with fruitloops colors. 👍

[@etbadaboum]

How many km of metro do you think will open in the 2030s?

[@KyrilPG]

@@etbadaboum We've yet to know the details and definitive paths of the proposed lines or extensions and the yet unknown new lines. The 360km I mentioned are "only" what's firmly decided and-or traced., like RER E West, tram extensions (T1, T10, etc.), proper busway bustram BRT lines, and the GPE, of course. It is IDFM's own estimate. For metro lines or extensions built in the 2030's, we'll have to wait and see what's decided in the coming months and years. Things like : The extension of the Grand Paris Express from Versailles to Nanterre la Folie or la Défense (and possibly to Saint-Denis Pleyel) that should be decided on in the very near future. The possible extension of OrlyVAL and probable integration into the metro network (with the addition of infill stations between Orly and Anthony). The 19th line proposed by IDFM recently. A series of extensions of the historical metro lines further into the suburbs as demanded by numerous elected officials from these locations. Etc. It's unclear if M1's Eastern extension will be built and opened in this decade or not. But it seems like it's going to be in the 2030's. As for the GPE itself, more than 100km of tunnels have already been built, out of 180km (plus roughly 20km at grade or elevated on M17 and M18). Since late February 2024, the entirety of M16's tunnels has been built. As for M17, all tunneling up to the aerial part is finished. And on M18, the tunnels from the Saclay viaduct to Orly airport are finished too. The chunk of tunnels that remains to be dug is mostly the Eastern and Western sections of M15 (plus the Northern most section of M17 after the aerial section and Western section of M18). These two sections of M15 should start tunneling operations soon as surface works have already begun in several locations. The most complicated bit seems to be the station under la Défense and should be the last one to be completed. The tunnels of M15's Eastern section should be completed in 2027 or 2028, even though they won't be ready for service till probably 2030. Personally, I'd love a continuous expansion, like a GPE 2, and 3, and 4... because, even with the current planned lines, the network is and will still be saturated. Especially if we want to reduce car use to the exception in the suburbs. So I hope the projects of RER F and G will be revived (there were some talks recently), and potentially another cross-city rapid line like M14 on another busy corridor. The SDRIF (Schéma Directeur de la Région Île-de-France) is full of projects that wait to be launched... each version is a goldmine of possible future developments. And often, previously abandoned projects (or pushed to the back burner) are revived and launched after being updated. The SDRIF for 2030 planned for +240km of new metro, +70km of new RER, +75km of new tramway. We seem to be pretty much on the right path to reach that goal. A version of SDRIF setting the goals for 2040 has been issued, including 70 public transportation projects and 750km of extensions. It's very interesting.

[@etbadaboum]

@@KyrilPG Gold comment! 🪙 You should get you own blog!

[@jacekkubiak4616]

Merci, c'est un très beau travail. C'est impressionnant de voir à quelle vitesse certains travaux ont été effectués surtout au début.

[@magnetique12]

Congratulations on your precise work! The Paris metro, and the RER, are so complex that it took a lot of time and patience to create your video! It's so complex given the huge number of stations and the fact that they are so close together! Fulgence Bienvenüe, one of the designers of the Paris metro, it seems to me the main designer, wanted everyone to have a metro station less than 500 meters from their home to benefit from much faster transport and without mixing with the surface circulation. Mr Bienvenüe wanted in particular to compete with trams and horse-drawn surface transport, with stops very close together. This is what makes this very Parisian particularity of the metro, and all the work that it required from the miners who did almost everything by hand, with a pickaxe and with lots of imagination, like the iron stations sunk into the ground by sinking with compressed air boxes!

[@krikol_77]

I love these videos ! And as a parisian, it’s so interesting to see the evolution of this network Thanks !

[@krikol_77]

Maybe a transilien video next ? :)

[@Conellossus]

Awesome video! Love the rework of the original Paris video. I even learned a few new things that happened in the past and some of the future extensions happening. Looking forward to more content from you. Perhaps a remake of New York is down the line? 🤔😊

[@MetroLiner]

Thanks always! New York will be the next remake. It might take some time though since I want to do some new cities in between.

[@compdude100]

@@MetroLiner Oh cool, looking forward to seeing a remake of New York and whatever other cities you plan to do in the meantime.

[@captainjake7417]

@@MetroLiner I know it’s been a while since you posted this and it’s probably too late but this time can you include the colors and names of the subway lines starting from the beginning to the end of the video also different services changes and the lines that went away for example (Brown)M, V, 9, plane train light blue, also can you add the path and air train for JFK airport. Oh, and the Staten Island Railway which is a weird subway, railway hybrid that is a part of New York City transit system.

[@DeskroNiker]

It's great ! Now we need the same video with tramway and Transilien lines 😃

[@Andrewjg_89]

The Paris Metro is still expanding with more lines being built and more trains as Paris’s population grows. I have been to Paris and it’s an amazing city in France.

[@benoitgoubin5191]

As a Parisien, I love it. A little mistake : on line 15, opening of "Villiers-Champigny-Bry" is delayed, maybe not before 2030 !

[@rinoga_k]

Me too

[@Ferro-Moczs]

Also Line E will call at this station in the next 3 years to add a new connection with the new line 15 there.

[@puccaland]

Great work but unfortunately a big part of the network is missing on this map. The Transiliens lines H,J, K, L, N, P, R, U, V which started operations in the 2000's, the tramways lines T1 to T13 which started circa 2010's. They are integral part of the local railway network.

[@etbadaboum]

It focuses on the metro and RER which it calls interestingly express metro

[@puccaland]

@@etbadaboum It's not called express metro. RER means Express Regional Network. It's a train not a metro.

[@etbadaboum]

@@puccaland Pedantic bickering. A metro is a train too. And the RER have a top speed up to 140 km/h, faster than most Parisian metro. You have metro overground and RER underground.

[@puccaland]

@@etbadaboum Facts aren't pedantic bickering. A train isn't a metro whatsoever and you just explained why the RER isn't a metro. Overground and underground never defined whether something is a train or a metro. All the RERs are way faster than the metro. Even RER A which almost always stops at every stations like a metro. The usage of a metro is completely different from the train.

[@etbadaboum]

@@puccaland Then why the GPE will be designed as a metro while going as fast as RER? You are just trying to put barriers where they doesn't exist. In Seoul there's the GTX, a high-speed metro and increasingly in Chinese tier one cities, three systems of metro with different speeds. These barriers only exist in your head, pedant.

[@IDF_RER_M]

Great vidéo 👏👏 the RER's history is very interresting !

[@puccaland]

As a Parisian I am surprised to learn that some stations were already built in the early 20th century. I believed that like what we've been experiencing those past 20 years they were added throughout the years. In fact most of the network was built in the early 20th century, then nothing, then the RER network in the 70's, then nothing, then line 14 and a few additional stations here and there, then the Transiliens, the tramways and now a massive extension of the network in all directions.

[@GoogoldingFan217]

The Line 11 extension to Rosny-Bois Perrier opens today!

[@EngAlperDemir]

Amazing work, I'm going to Paris this summer so I was familiarizing myself with the metro network, this surly helped a lot...

[@Marcos-Silva]

Incredible work as always! Looking forward to the day we get a video for Madrid's evolution :D

[@marnez_]

Madrid metro with cercanias, that would be amazing.

[@sergiovasquez8766]

I'm already to watch almost 23 minutes from this amazing channel

[@josanikik]

I'm fascinated by the history of this network. Great video!

[@masterclass3941]

please add transilien network next time :-)

[@Osthofen]

Plus Trams

[@guygodemont3258]

ca va ressembler a un plat de nouille :)

[@aymanla471]

transilien is just Pre RER ...alot of rer lines were transilien and then upgraded to RER standards

[@ohsosooooo]

​@@aymanla471 Yep, and that's just the start. RER will replace all existing Transilien. For exemple, the RER E extension from Chelles-Gournay to Meaux is only one of the existing "Transilien P" lines that does from Paris-Est to Meaux.

[@nicolascavadini3570]

@@aymanla471 i am really not sure what you call "rer standards". Transilien line J is far more : clean, reliable while having more trains at peak hours (at any hour really) than RER line C or D. The only RER "standard" is to go underground paris intra muros at some point, while transiliens stop at main train stations like saint lazare or montparnasse. Without transilien no daily commute for 90% of the peoples

[@DKJawed40001]

I love the music you put from 1990 to 2020, continue with this one

[@jasanand5597]

Nice video dude, I like the futureristic lines!

[@joraberanto]

Vidéo déjà prête pour 2035-2040 ! nice work

[@igorsiuda8108]

You forgot that the original system had 8 of 18 stations, with another 10 being infills.

[@khaziayin]

great video. please make one about the Kyiv Metro next, thanks!

[@danielenuzzo9786]

Paris in 1906 already had more metros than Rome now (and for the next 30 years probably)

[@LaurentSFN]

Great work. Miss the tramways and the transiliens lines for an exhaustive map :(

[@kanojune5754]

What's the differences between RER and Transilien??

[@LaurentSFN]

@@kanojune5754 Transilien are classical régional trains (Ter in french for train express régional) with terminus in Paris gares (Gare de l'est, Gare du nord, etc...). Rer cross Paris intramuros are connected with métro network and lines end in suburbs. Transilien are managed by SNCF, RER are managed by SNCF and RATP.

[@kanojune5754]

@@LaurentSFN sooo if it was Tokyo equivalent (my city's rail system is based on Tokyo), then the RER are rapid metro/subway/private railway and the Transilien are the JR East suburban rail lines?

[@LaurentSFN]

@@kanojune5754 something like that ;) except RATP is a public company.

[@kanojune5754]

@@LaurentSFN aha, i get it now, thank you for the explanation

[@tntmaster1104]

This was a great video👍 You gotta do Philly next! I would love to see the Evolution of the Metro System of the great city of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania!

[@jambon2730]

I do think that not including transilien makes the network seems a bit inaccurate. For example, the south RER D is planned to be fused with a new line S to rely directly Gare du nord and Malherbes branch way faster than the current RER D forcing to take another train at Juvisy

[@syldaviaball9545]

Definitely the most interesting metro in the world. At least one of them without a doubt

[@joseantoniobuitragominano3820]

I AM FRENCH BORN AND I LIKE PARIS....BUT I WISH TO WATCH TORONTO, CHICAGO, NY, BUDAPEST, SHANGHAI AND BARCELONA METRO LINES....TOO!!!!!! THEIR WHOLE HISTORIES!!!!! THANKS!!!!!!

[@IrinaDynov]

I LOOOVE PARIS! Thank you for this video I am highly addicted to it.

[@ivangarciaibarra7839]

Could you please do an updated video on Madrid? Including subway and cercanías, plus future expansions

[@nazard1284]

I would really like a video about the metro in Budapest.

[@МаксимПьянзов-г6р]

Класс ! 👍 В Москве тоже за последние 10 лет было построено ещё 160 станций метро. + Две нитки МЦД .

[@sonap004]

Amazing video! Can you do Athens metro next? It is a very underrated system and it's older than most people think.

[@m.o.t.s]

Impressive!

[@etbadaboum]

Fantastic video! Thank you.

[@Frederic7594]

Excellent video. But at 19:53 the proposed Aerofret station is nothing but a development proposition, and it hasn’t yet become an official project. And there is a second planned extension of line 11 to Noisy-Champs, but there is no given date for it.

[@Ellister29]

The line 11 extension is quite likely to be cancelled now though, no fundings have been given and the subject is carefully avoided

[@IsseKonja]

@@Ellister29 Elle va être prolongée en Juin …

[@Ellister29]

@@IsseKonja je parle de l'extension jusque noisy-champs !

[@Tortank-006]

Can you make the evolution of Brussels' metro and premetro??? (btw awesome video!!!!)

[@euroschmau]

Watch once for the metro animation, play again in the background for the music 😊

[@zoetseitline5983]

this is absolutely wonderful work, the only small thing is that at 14:37, when the RER A expands towards Poissy, it shows that the line diverges from the main one at Achères Ville, rather than the (correct) Maisons Laffitte I'm incredibly impressed by all this effort tho

[@StudioHonzasTV]

Good Video like always!

[@MetroLiner]

Thank you!

[@louiszhang3050]

Crazy how wextensive the Parisian railways were even back in the early 20th Century.... amazing.

[@nodog1961]

Can you do NYC Remake next with stops? (And possibly add Metro North/LIRR/NJT soon)

[@GoogoldingFan217]

Can’t wait to see! The next should be Kuala Lumpur and Shanghai.

[@GoogoldingFan217]

BTW, you forgot to use Wikipedia to check the opening of each station.

[@ado6017]

L'extension du RER D vers le sud en 1996,je m'en rappelle bien. C'était ma première année de lycée et j'étais presque tous les jours en retard. Les conducteurs du RER ne voulaient pas faire la distance à partir de Creil jusqu'au bout de la ligne. 1996 c'est aussi l'année de l'attentat du RER B à St Michel et 1997 celui du RER B à Port Royal.

[@BLACKSTA361]

Paris will have the best Train System in Europe and 2nd only to Tokyo in 2030. Keep in mind Paris also has an extensive Regional Network (Transilien) and Tram Network

[@JdMsk]

2:27 Please check the history of the station Monparrnasse-Bienvenue. The line 4 was not connected to the line 5 in 1910. There were two separate stations : Avenue du Maine on the line 5 and Montparnasse on the line 4. The line A came to Montparnasse the same year, 4 and A were connected each other but not the 5 on Avenue du Maine. The last were renamed to Bienvenue in 1933. With arrival of line14 in january 1937, platforms of 5 and 14 were connected but were still isolated from Monparnasse station of lines 4 and 12 (ex A). Six month later Monparnasse and Bienvenue were connected with long couloir and became the single station.

[@nicholascooper945]

Oh we're being FED today darling Also, I know as an American I have no stakes in this but watching the system develop made me turn into the "That's enough... THAT'S ENOUGH SLICES" meme.

[@tuivre3198]

It’s actually even bigger if you include the Transiliens (8 lines) and the Tramway (14 lines) :))

[@chasemartin4450]

Oh how I wish we could build subways at this pace here in the United States...

[@monkeybrainer1299]

I know you probably have a lot of questions like this, but what do you use to make these animations, because your work is really insane and I want to have a go at trying to make stuff like this myself. Keep doing what you do!

[@florianfasquelle5212]

amazing work !!

[@xeno_5887]

Very good video, well done ! However, you forgot about the second extension of line 11 from "Ronsy - Bois Perrier" to "Noisy - Champs".

[@envoyage6886]

Finalement c'est pas sur comme il y aura la ligne 15. Le projet a été remis en cause, les débats pour savoir si elle va se prolonger n'ont pas encore commence.

[@xeno_5887]

@@envoyage6886 Ah bon, ok merci pour l'info mais dans ce cas pourquoi il met le prolongement de la ligne 1 ?

[@timmccarthy9917]

Excellent job! If you take requests, Chongqing would be awesome.

[@Plab1402]

Who loves watching these while playing mini Metro?

[@RoboJules]

I love how it gets to 1154km without including the Trams and Transilien, which would have doubled the size. I'm pretty Sure Isle De France already has, or will soon have, at least half as much rail as Greater Tokyo, which is pretty crazy, as it has under a third the population.

[@leifkarlen8013]

what is it? Shazam is of no help

[@attasaravani3048]

One of the Best videos i have ever seen in my entire life.👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 Edit: well kind of.

[@KarlDeux]

Also you could/should (well it's easy to say) add something about the Transilien network and about the tramway lines. Maybe another video.

[@anatoleh1]

beautiful and so precise!

[@Hastdupech8509]

Jesus Christ, as an Italian I'm gonna go cry in the corner. Milan is a fraction of this, while the other big cities of the country with a huge conurbation on their backs, Rome and Naples, have shittier transit systems than 1930s Paris. Let's not speak about the other big cities, they're tragic. What can I say, well done, dear Italy. Well done. And congrats to the French for showing how you think and act grandiosely for your grandiose capital, even in public transportation. Che schifo.

[@arminpunyx]

I quite dislike the new way and positioning when it comes to the line information in this one tbh. In the past, the information were pinned in the down left corner. Now its all over the place and changes the position on the screen all the time, so its sometimes really hard to follow. Especially when you show all the station names when a line is brought up, it gets really messy. And on top of that, the line information is often hidden behind the regional map in the top right. F.e. in 5:38, 5:50, 6:30, 6:35, 6:50, 7:20, 7:40, etc. If you like to show all the station names when a line is brought up, you should keep the line information in a steady position again or at least keep it very prominent with a half transparend backlayer or something like that. And it shouldnt vanish in the background of the regional map. But, despite of all the criticism, good work when it comes to everything else.

[@MetroLiner]

Thank you for taking the time to write a feedback. I will try to adjust it in the next video.

[@MrMirtouf]

As an important note, all projects of extension to the east of métro and RER lines after 2030 is far from being agreed and are still being discussed for the best case scenario or only an idea that is coming back from time to time. The 4th Terminal for CDG airport is still under discussion and will unlikely be ready in 2030.

[@anteeklund4159]

Perhaps the best metro system in the world

[@ob0273]

Brilliant. Do you plan making Munich metro evolution?

[@champan250]

A recommendation, for the next city with that many lines, I will recommend lines that have similar colors to use some pattern lines instead of solid lines. I am having so much trouble trying to follow how RER Line C is heading into the city

[@CelineLeroy-hp2mj]

It's amazing! I want to create my own metro map. How do you do your videos?

[@josephdufresne6597]

thank you so much !!

[@lauri7130]

Es una ciudad única!!! Increíblemente con una inversión en metros y tren !!!

[@paulfeldmann3267]

12:19 technically it has been extended from viroflay rive gauche to SQY since the branch separates there

[@metalblind95]

Too bad this doesn’t show the tramway network, the biggest in the whole country

[@JoshAndJojoGaming]

Great video!

[@nodog1961]

Why can’t América do this

[@adwaitnaravane5285]

Carbrain

[@ayindestevens6152]

I just watched the original a few days ago and I was wondering was he going to do a re-master. Ask and ye shall receive

[@zziborac7748]

greater! please next to evolution Budapest Metro 1898-2040

[@Simster0711]

nice ! very good animation

[@GojiMet86]

Has there been word about the frequently talked about combination of the 3-bis and 7-bis into one singe line? I think it would have been a Line 19.

[@KyrilPG]

Possibly, but a line 19 has been officially proposed recently by IDFM and the region as an extension to the Grand Paris Express. This 19th line would link La Défense or Nanterre la Folie to Triangle de Gonnesse (and possibly up to CDG) via Argenteuil, forming a Northwest arch.

[@jayfielding1333]

I understand it was rescheduled to open in 2030.

[@peterzumthor4011]

amazing video

[@JulienBourdain]

You should do the same but with the tram in addition

[@eloyfortezavargas4353]

I love that cartographic system !

[@alexandrpoznukhov4395]

Ну до 2024 года - понятно, но планы - под вопросом. Спасибо за видео.

[@JdMsk]

Почему под вопросом? Стройка идёт полным ходом, без существенных задержек.

[@Anonymoususer_8823]

Paris is still expanding but I think it doesn’t need any more metro lines. Still nice work.

[@rebeccawinter472]

I love this! Haven’t seen your stuff - definitely a new subscriber! Question though - why not include the Transilien network (H onwards) as they carry 300k plus daily each in some cases? Also, small detail, historical accuracy I’d probably use the station names at the time as the main name and just change the names when the year happens? But that’s minor. I’d put a shout out for the Toronto subway and regional rail network - the largest single regional rail system in North America. With the new expansions to both systems - underway and planned there’s lots of stuff there. Tho it’s a breeze compared to Paris, 😂. Happy to help if I can. Are you on Patreon?!

[@bulldogs_]

Great video, I love it! May I request that you do Boston and/or San Francisco please? Thanks!

[@freonflex]

Awesome! Please do Montréal 😀

[@cuervo26923]

Hello, good video! You would have to take the Buenos Aires metro, my city!!

[@rankedcitizen]

you should make a video on the history and future of manchester's metrolink tram system!

[@worldwidebear1967]

Cool like always.

[@arreglosdemike828]

Which program are you employing to make this illustration?

[@NoLongerBreathedIn]

Inexplicably missing: the shuttle line from Porte des Lilas to Pré-Saint-Gervais (1921-1939), and the planned reactivation of that shuttle together with another single-track line from Place des Fêtes to Porte des Lilas to merge lines 3b and 7b (planned 2030)

[@NTLyesYT]

It isn't planned at all, dunno where you saw that.

[@NoLongerBreathedIn]

@@NTLyesYTnot sure, Wikipedia has it as vaguely scheduled for 2030 but that's as of 2013, so who knows.

[@NTLyesYT]

@@NoLongerBreathedIn Okay, just so you know, that's IDFM's way of saying "yeah, maybe, sometime".

[@NTLyesYT]

They haven't even launched any type of study on the feasibility/cost/usage.

[@mezziditrasportodimilanoit6874]

What do you use for make this videos?

[@hellohjbgjh]

Tout est centré sur Paris. Le reste quasi aucun réseau RER dans les régions françaises

[@davidbull7210]

Porte de Vincennes - Porte Maillot did open in July 1900 but Concorde, George V and Reuilly-Diderot didn't open til August. In September Charles de Gaulle-Etoile and Argentine opened along with 5 others, but not sure which ones. It's quite hard to get accurate info.

[@rogeriofernandes349]

Amazing!

[@maoschanz4665]

putting tramways on former RER C tracks and then wasting millions to build a "line 18" parallel to it (but in the middle of nowhere) might be the stupidest decision ever

[@holiamdebirbevoie9420]

Nn ça va être génial. Bon le tram ok c'est bof mais il a l'air d'avoir une bonne capacité.

[@maoschanz4665]

@@holiamdebirbevoie9420c'est jamais "mal" de construire des nouveaux trucs, mais c'est jamais gratuit : tout cet argent aurait pu aller au RER F, ou au défourchement de la ligne 13, ou à la connexion des lignes bis ou au prolongement de la 12 vers la courneuve, ou à une utilisation pertinente de la petite ceinture, ou à n'importe quel truc plus ou moins réaliste mais qui aurait été utile à des centaines de milliers de gens Là la ligne 18 qui zigzag en pleine campagne ça sert surtout aux élus et aux entrepreneurs qui veulent mettre en avant le campus de saclay cet argent aurait aussi pu NE PAS être dépensé, afin de limiter le coût exorbitant du pass navigo