MG Comet vs Tata Tiago EV - Which is the EV for you? | Comparison | Autocar India

The radical-looking MG Comet does turn heads everywhere, but how will it fare against the sought after and more conventional Tata Tiago EV? Saumil Shah finds out.
Cameraperson: Roshni Manghani, Harshad Panchal
Editor: Mohit Sharma
0:00 - Intro
0:30 - MG Comet exterior design
0:42 - Tata Tiago EV exterior design
0:56 - 5 exterior comparison points
2:13 - Boot space comparison
2:40 - MG Comet interior
5:36 - MG Comet rear seat
6:14 - Tata Tiago EV interior
7:14 - Feature comparison
7:18 - Tata Tiago EV rear seat
8:03 - MG Comet battery and motor
9:00 - Performance comparison
9:19 - Refinement
9:50 - MG Comet top speed
10:03 - MG Comet regenerative braking
10:28 - Visibility
11:07 - Braking performance
12:08 - Tata Tiago EV battery and motor
13:27 - Tata Tiago EV regenerative braking
13:52 - Range comparison
14:14 - Charging times
14:49 - Price and verdict
SUBSCRIBE to Autocar India for the hottest automotive news and the most comprehensive reviews ► bit.ly/AutocarInd
Autocar India is your one-stop source for test drive reviews & comparison tests of every new car and motorcycle launched in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content, including weekly news, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Website: www.autocarindi...
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Instagram: / autocar_india
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
New car reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-NewC...
Comparison tests ►bit.ly/ACI-Comp...
New bike reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-Bike...
Features ►bit.ly/ACI-Feat...
#autocarindia #carreview #carcomparison

[@chakranshuyadav3104]

Ok so one is bigger, a lot faster, drives a lot better, stops a lot better, music sound is miles better, has four proper doors, better seats, more boot space, faster charging and a lot safer and the other one has better looking screen and LED lights. Hmm close one...🤔

[@mike619rocks]

Comet vs Nano would have been a rather good comparison😂😂😂

[@sathyaki]

It's an insult for Tiago to be compared against that abomination from MG.

[@shravanpoovaiah9329]

Exactly 💯

[@adeshwarmuruganathana36]

Just for the fun of it, Do compare Comet and Mahindra e2o! Both are 2 door EVs!

[@samridhtiwari8044]

Comet isn't a CAR, its a CARtoon

[@VijayKumar...]

Exactly, agree with you 😊

[@leokartikrajkumar9109]

carTIN

[@PankajSharma-gz9gb]

Please compare tata nano and fortuner next time.

[@amitchaudhri2515]

Not expecting this type of comparison from autocar. Like in the starting we all know that tata Tiago is a better practical buy option for most of the people, so doesn't make any sense to bring these two for comparo

[@BuluBiker]

I wanted to buy the Comet but the only thing that is restricting me is the lack of Fast charger support, and so the price is not justified. Tiago is a full size compared to this But Tata after sales service is not great with all our past experience.

[@arup4490]

That's exactly why you buy an EV. You simply don't need to go to the service shop often (unless you're unlucky).

[@imaysin97]

@@arup4490 when you have a tata service centre becomes second home.

[@yogeshbodar8722]

Sir, please do consider warranty as well, Tata will give you 8yeard Or 1.6 lakh km on battery and motor both. Mg want offer you that. One more thing, sir in next 2 years tata is building separate service department and technician in all Tata showrooms.

[@elemental9039]

Different doesn’t always mean good. Case in point: MG Comet

[@90zkid]

Tiago over comet anyday.

[@utkarshkaushik617]

Tiago ev just seems like a better car in every aspect in comparison to the mg comet tiago is more practical have better range and many other things

[@edwinharvey2226]

Its undoubtedly the Tiago EV which is practical for Indian conditions. Comet is just a 3 lakh wulung air sold at double the price cheating customers

[@pramodkumarkb5508]

This comparison is more MG baised, even a 10 year old kid can recognise which one is better just by looking at them.

[@vikhneshar104]

So basically the MG Commet is just a rich man's toy

[@ramspace]

When I get my mid-life crisis, I will not drive a convertible, I will drive the Comet.

[@Sachin-iox]

Price is a key factor for switching to an EV. Considering the price, both the Comet and Tiago are acceptable. However, in terms of features, the Comet is not a good option due to its limited boot space and lack of fast charging support. On the other hand, the Tiago falls short in terms of interior looks and after-sales service. So, I would prefer to wait and watch for better EV options."

[@rovinchakravorty679]

How can you compare legend tiago with a Dabba.

[@nishanthsurendran7721]

8 lakhs for that? I do agree that it's cute, but the price is too damn high for what we get .

[@navaneethmalaiyappan]

Comet looks like toy car only one good thing modernised interior, Tiago not outdated interior it’s current generation one

[@adibik9809]

MG looks more like a Golf Cart

[@abhishekpanchal3211]

Does mg's side mirrors can be closed or they are fixed? If they are fixed then it hampers mg's practicality alot.

[@vishalkripalani8859]

If mg would cost between 6 to 8 lakh that would be perfect 2 door for extra 2 Door 8to 12 lakh Tata

[@sharwansingh7285]

What is the safety rating of each car?

[@MikeJa-tf7fo]

Same on the road price for both?

[@GarlicbreadmanOP]

What we have here ladies and gents is an electric car and a washing machine with wheels and LEDs.

[@rashcamindia956]

Wuling air EV vs Tata Tiago EV

[@swapnilpupulwad9445]

Very much awaited comparison.

[@bellhop3158]

3:37 3:42 range has come down from 142 to just 80. Whats the actual range of this car ??

[@ProfAVanHelsing]

Comet ya uske jaisi dikhne wali car lene se achcha ek e-rickshaw le lunga.

[@arrai515]

For a new drive or the ladies its very easyro drive and vary practical on city roads parking. I would have bought the base model pf it very value fpr money

[@telljuliet1]

The comets right price is 4 to 5 lakh rs. Its priced too high.

[@mackisbrocklesnar]

Comet is interesting second car for those living on metros.

[@jalilgnaniar3674]

It should have been the m&m e2o/ neo nano/ mg comet

[@pradeepmuniandi]

MG comet is car or costly toy? Where's the practicality? Whats the purpose of having this car?

[@harshanit]

The comet is a no brainer from MG 😂

[@nilaysingh3585]

By the way...comet is a product via MG and not KiA

[@harshanit]

@@nilaysingh3585 thanks for that.

[@roshroy23]

Tata looks and drives way better. The problem is the quality control on the car and its difficult service from Tata.

[@amargshukla]

Um what is MG charging this kind of money for?

[@bali963]

Thanks for the information.. both r good city cars... I prefer MG comet tall boy look... My wife & I can take to market for local purchase... Bangalore find parking is big issue... Its a complete city two peope car

[@stevendesouza369]

A very good review of both cars... Thanks

[@sri198507]

i noticed the paint quality of comet is so good

[@the90shyperrider37]

Bring back TATA NANO.EV and kill the market all over again.

[@akashwaghmare8697]

Waiting for Tata Nano ev to compete with comet

[@burnttoast9890]

The MG is probably the best city car for women

[@elemental9039]

Source- “trust me bro”

[@burnttoast9890]

@@elemental9039 do you have a reason to disagree with my opinion?

[@k.mohammedfazid4702]

Tiago hit like

[@PrakharRSingh]

My guy has a very strong urban India pronounciation of the word, "really" where it sounds like "rolly" 😂😂😂

[@vinnvinn88]

proper car vs toy car :)

[@ramithraghunath1073]

Makes the tata nano look like an SUV..

[@manikagarwal9264]

Good comparison dude

[@animeshmiri8593]

Tiago is sense but Comet is non-sense

[@apandit1961]

You guys are doing an excellent job! Thanks for the review, very helpful!

[@siddheshtulaskar7132]

Tata Tiago EV rules the small cars segment in India

[@imviiku]

Wow ! TATA Claimed 315km range and gave only 187km , that's just False Marketing. I hope goverment take some action on that . Atleast give 250kms , 187 is a Joke.

[@yogeshbodar8722]

Sir, that's wrong figure, there two variant of tiago 250 km and 315 km range. Please check some tiago ev owner, they will tell you the Trueth

[@niveyshak]

Drive a car and not a cartoon from MG

[@dharamveersinghgill5315]

At 10 lakh I will buy jimny 😊

[@Youknowwho56847]

the mg could have been a steal with a lowered price around 5 lakhs .

[@kishorekusupati2796]

Tiago is best although looks classic structure

[@shan24shan]

Always range is question mark, since based on driving quality only can expect the provided range.

[@SAVI872]

If the government wants to promote EVs, they should control prices. EVs, with just a battery and fiber material, cost 20% more than petrol cars with complex engines. We need better range (300-500 km) and fast charging. Current high prices and low resale value are major issues. #EV #India #Sustainability

[@anandagoswami7373]

Seeing all the adverse comments about the nano, I'm inclined to think it may have been a good car if it was made by someone other than Tata.

[@suryakantpatilofficial9570]

Please bring the velar fecelift drive review 🙏🙏

[@piccolo_4u]

Only tata ❤

[@professor3092]

MG looks like Japanese "KEI Car".

[@nikhilpulsarmania]

Trust me MG will soon eat autorickshaw market with this car😂

[@kumaresh5962]

tiago ev is for ppl who want a primary car. comet is a secondary car only for city ride

[@techyshubham9393]

I like Tiago more

[@surjomondal9996]

Tata❤❤❤

[@lifesucess7731]

Tata Tiago ❤❤❤❤

[@nitinkale560]

This is a city car. Should not be more than 5 lakh. What about safety?

[@foxtrail975]

MG should reduce price of comet by 2.5 lakhs... it cannot be compared with tiago ev...

[@rajpawar9343]

Both Tata and MG were mocking eachother. Calling them cartoon car and taxi.

[@nitinkale560]

Tata Nano was an affordable car for middle class/lower middle class. It is irrelevant to compare it with overpriced MG Comet which doesnt even have four doors.

[@saleesh0089]

Tiago ❤

[@shantanugaur9180]

Good price could be 4.5 - 5 lakh for these kind of cars

[@solobiker_sanjiv]

Any day tata tiago ev for its better ride and handling

[@jagadishdasari6466]

Very clearly TIAGO!

[@mohnishr481]

Simple Buy Tata Tiago

[@nosom7]

NCAP left the chat.

[@rajatsinha4280]

Does it makes sense to compare this EV whatever be the name wit TATA TIAGO😂😂

[@palabinash]

It looks like a concept car; not for sale.

[@rajkumarsahu8337]

MG Comet mujhe to sahi lag rhi hai. Features awesome hai aur interior mujhe kaafi achi lagi. Iss price me itne saare features are really good.

[@whiteface_studio]

it looks like a repainted maruti wagon r 😂😂😂😂😂…

[@yogawithkullu7123]

Comet

[@shrieshanthis4239]

Comet is a modern copy for nano 😂😂

[@uploader541]

Hi

[@luizfranca9800]

❤

[@manjunathams8865]

Comet is an eye candy😍

[@greenphoenix56]

comet

[@rohietthakur6466]

No comparison to Lord Tiago. Cartoon Chinese Car 😂😂😂

[@zubaazu8814]

auto vs car😂

[@aimanfitri0iv]

both are very special but comet is so beautiful 💖🥰😊

[@theitmantra]

Comet should be compared with auto rikshaw

[@sbhadra25]

Who the hell...is going to buy the comet! 😅😂

[@pramod6898]

Tiago is a car. Comet is a toy.

[@hiteshyagnik7285]

I can say that MG is offering great value for money with the Comet EV. No other EV on the market offers the same level of features, range, and design at this price point. The interior is also fresh and stylish.😁😁

[@sanjeetsingh-iz1rb]

MG is a joke !!

[@saygr8]

MG Comet: what an absolutely ugly car. 😅 reminds me of the Fiat Multipla, another ugly car. 😅😅

[@gautamsinha5998]

What a bogus and impractical car that MG seems...

[@anandagoswami7373]

EVs are for people who lack basic intelligence. To run around with a huge fire prone battery for the lifetime of the car is sheer idiocy. The bait is the cost per Km which does not factor in the cost of replacement of the battery before the end of the life of the car. But then again there so many stupid people to buy these batteries on wheels.

[@cruizer0861]

Design ..boring...?well hello...look again.....

[@cruizer0861]

just a novelty bias statement.

[@luizfranca9800]

❤❤ Tata