Top Water Resistant Mascaras

Top 4 Drugstore Tubing Mascaras Under $10!
I was on the market for a great water-resistant mascara perfect for everyday. These water-resistant mascaras are tubular which means the mascara coats every single strand with great results. Tubing mascaras are supposed to be flake-free, smudge proof, long lasting, transfer-proof, sweat-proof, etc. I found 4 different mascaras all under $10 with all these claims and more. The best part about tubing mascara, they are supposed to come off with only water when you’re ready to remove your makeup at the end of the day. Let’s test these four formulas together.
Products Used/Mentioned:
*L.A. Girl Volumatic Mascara: bit.ly/3ALM5GS
*Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes! Mascara: bit.ly/3O0e5th
*No7 Mascara Stay Perfect Waterproof: bit.ly/3axFTrf
*Maybelline Snapscara Washable Mascara: bit.ly/3uHXuUc
*Essence Lash Princess Mascara: bit.ly/3xMTDGb
*Juno Skin Cleansing Balm: amzn.to/3P9wWUc
*Naturium Niacinamide Gelee Cleanser: bit.ly/2Zqrt3b
*Makeup Eraser: bit.ly/3c6dpkC
*White Braided Headband: bit.ly/3PtF3KU
*Affiliate link from RewardStyle and/or Amazon.

[@lexiejames3514]

I’m British and have to say I was rooting for the no7 😂. I’ve been using the brand for years and all of their products are pretty consistently good

[@Youcanrelateto]

You work so hard! I appreciate that u post consistent videos.

[@jenniferferreira9061]

I keep asking this. Looking for a good skin care for my hubby. I know Andrey does a skin care routine. I would love it if Andrey would do a video of him doing his skin care routine. Also I LOVE how you explain everything. God bless your precious family ✝️✝️💟💟💙💗

[@buffy6749]

So happy you liked the No7 as I love using there products 😍🇬🇧 x

[@judymastrullo4348]

No 7 was a clear winner. I've used in the past. Guess I'll be going back to it again. Thank you for the reviews.

[@sassy8948]

I am so happy you did this video! I've been using L'Oréal Doubel Extension Beauty Tubes for an eternity because it's such an amazing tubing mascara that makes me lashes gorgeous and also lasts through everything, funerals.. weddings.. swimming.. and now L'Oréal decided to discontinue it and I'm struggling really bad to find a good new mascara. I used Mirenesse Secret weapon mascara in the past and that was also amazing but they stopped selling it in my country. I've been looking at different options and I'm absolutely going for the No7 one, it looks like exactly what I want. So thank you again 💗 Love your videos!

[@littlebluejayx]

I LOVE the essence bye bye panda eyes mascara, it’s my favourite for everyday use. I also love the volumizing one which looks very similar

[@DianeMcInnis-xw4vj]

I took snapshots and I think the LA Girl looks better on her vs No 7. I understand from a performance at the end of the day the difference between the two, but looking at her lashes the LA girl mascara is extremely impressive! This was an excellent video! Thank you!

[@Onlinemakeupacademy]

Thank you for your hard work on this video!

[@lifenlunacy5833]

Omg yes! I am so excited for this one because I can only wear specific types of mascara but it’s all water repellent style because of an allergen in mascara. That being said , the ones I have used are water proof and they flake like crazy! I have been hoping for someone to do one of these videos and I know you give an unbiased review.

[@Mrssavagegeese]

What is good for you? I need waterproof or resistant for contact rewetting due to extreme dry eye but the formulas also irritate my eyes! Do you have a few favorites? Thanks in advance!

[@MilliDavison]

I don’t generally like a waterproof mascara as I find them too hard to take off, but for transfer and smudge proof I LOVE the elf big mood, I use it in most of my videos on my channel… it’s so volumising and thickening, really dramatic and it stays put 100% even through really hot long days at work! They do it in a waterproof formula but I haven’t tried it 💕

[@tamarareid6170]

just use any oil like olive oil or coconut oil to remove the mascara

[@baileydubs]

I’ve tried the essence one and I felt like it barely did anything. Really didn’t like it. But thank you for this video as I only wear tubing mascaras and want a cheaper option than thrive

[@huhn7142]

I love the essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes. Been using it since years. Thanks for the video 😊 Edit: mine are never a dry formula, so I wonder if we have a different formula in Germany 😅

[@phoebeharris1130]

Love to try waterproof mascara

[@MilliDavison]

I’ve tried an essence mascara recently on my channel it’s not the same as the one you’ve tested here though, it was called ‘another volume mascara… just better!’ And it was fantastic, really long lasting through the day but came off easy. I remember the snap scara, I hated that one so I’m interested to see what you think of it!x

[@SatsukyMirabelle]

You definitely got some old product with the Essence Bye Bye panda eyes. I had it before and liked it a lot, it got dry after some time not right away. I think it looks better than the LA Girl as it doesn't look fake and heavy but effortless and natural, everybody prefers different look and to me my lashes but better is the goal. (and not to transfer ofc, which it didn't in my experience.) Might give it a try again, thanks for the video.

[@tamarareid6170]

I actually need a review of these products being used throughout the day as I keep buying these waterproof mascaras which after 4+ hours inevitably start to smear dark black around my undereye so I haven't ever really managed to find something that is truly waterproof especially in drugstore till today

[@papuche6908]

I am using 2000 calories mascara for years. It stays through everything!

[@Opalescenttreeshark]

I’ve read tubing mascaras are not meant to be layered. I find I only get flaking if I allow it to dry down and then try to add another coat.

[@serabella779]

I bought Essence's I Love Extreme Volume Waterproof mascara earlier but haven't tried it yet, hoping it stays on because it can get really humid in Florida and I want my eye makeup to stay on my eyes in the summertime

[@lifenlunacy5833]

Question have you ever tried taking a wand from #4 and formula from #3 to see if it is a winning combo?

[@christinunya72]

I've found that tubing mascaras don't layer very well. I usually stick to one layer with them or they just clump and flake badly. A non-tubing mascara usually works fine under one though.

[@luisaruiz5030]

I'm a swimming teacher and I'm in the water most of the day. I use the brand Prosa, waterproof mascara with silicone bristles, it doesn't fall off or stains my eyes. It is very easy to remove with make-up remover oil. it costs 39.00 pesos (about 2 dlls)

[@Sbannmarie]

Oh I’m a swimmer too… whether to buy Prosa? thanks!

[@darlarohde1010]

HOLY COW are you still using the Grande lash growing serum? Your lashes are soooo long and beautiful!!! Using mascara makes your lashes seem like false lashes!! Please let me know because I’ll start using it!! Xo.😍🥰

[@chrissiedunlap431]

The ordinary now has a lash and eyebrow growth serum that is just as good or perhaps better than the grande lash and it is WAY cheaper. And it doesn’t turn your skin red.

[@tanjabastigkeit2078]

Why is not every mascara a bye bye panda eyes mascara? Who wants to look like a panda?

[@constanceriley6644]

Have you had any issues with the Juno Cleansing Balm? I checked it out on Amazon & there were some negative reviews on how the product arrived ~~~in a melted liquid state????

[@tracisetter2164]

I hated the Bye Bye Panda Eyes...so annoyingly dry and I felt it did next to nothing for me. Way too much work! Lash Princess is WAY better! Can't wait to try the LA Girl and No7 mascaras! ETA the Snapscara looks interesting though too!

[@jasminacevedo5254]

Caliray Come Hell or High Water is awesome but it’s almost $20.00

[@momrocks9971]

Thank you!!!! Can we get your opinion on water proof or resistant eyeliner? Wet n Wild H2O is the only formula that can stand up to my eyes, but I'd love another style. I think I have tried every high end, luxury, and drug store brand recommended by most people but I keep thinking a better formula will be developed. I need everything water resistant - particularly around the eyes due to allergies and also due to melting in the hot Texas sun.

[@DianeMcInnis-xw4vj]

I love Ulta Besuty Collection gel eyeliner pencil. It glides on very nicely, you can smudge it right away, if you like to smudge. Then it sets down very very nicely! I love the color mink if you like a brown. The black one is equally as nice. I choose this one because it stays on all day long. I never have to reapply it.

[@christinunya72]

I don't understand how a tubing mascara can be water resistant or waterproof. It literally comes off with water. I have sweated off and cried off tubing mascaras. Maybe they makes different ones that are water resistant idk, but I know the ones I wore def weren't water resistant.

[@LauraLVTGW]

I only use water proof mascara to "hold up" my lashes. My lashes grow straight and otherwise they will fall almost immediately. Have you tried the Cleo Kill Lash??? It's a very inexpensive Korean brand. Would love to know your thoughts on this brand. Thank you! 💖💖💖

[@LauraLVTGW]

**Clio* darn auto correct!!!

[@cleocatra9324]

I dont use waterproof but i still like these videos

[@margaretdillinger5090]

I hate almost every mascara I’ve bought. I’ve big names through FabFit and hated them. Flakes, clumping and gumming up the lashes.

[@fionakarbel258]

I can’t do waterproof, too difficult to take off and I lose too many lashes scrubbing!

[@papuche6908]

I use oil based eye make up remover for these. From Nivea for example and it cleans up perfectly :)

[@Javainthebox]

Just use some sweet almond oil. It comes right off after letting it sit for a tiny bit. No scrubbing and non toxic. Good luck!

[@darianabrannan4563]

I love the Maybelline mascara. One of my favorites! Why spend all the money.

[@alicebrown2007]

The no panda eyes is great formula, but it smudges on me !

[@IAmDasani]

wish you wouldn't rub off the flakes/smudges then we can really see how it looks

[@Ninuss1407]

Which lash seeum do you use? Any recommendation?

[@chrissiedunlap431]

The ordinary has come out with a lash and eyebrow growth serum that is just as good or better than the more expensive brands. And it doesn’t turn your skin red.

[@jeanettesmith765]

The first mascara looks very clumpy.

[@shoshyLovely]

Oh lord the No.7 looked scary when you wash it…Thanks for your efforts 🤍

[@evelinperez8015]

I love Snap mascara I love how my eye lashes look good long and curl. I been using it for couple months already.