MILGRAM / “Magic -Es Cover-”

[@chokobo_ko]

感情がこもってないおかげで逆に歌詞が頭に入ってくる。 「いい子になりたい」じゃなくて「いい子になるしかない」なんだよなぁ🤔

[@Kamenrider40]

@ugoktenp親が宗教にハマってるって説が一番有力

[@粥味ドメ]

一ミリも誓ってなさそうな上に幸せでもなさそうな歌い方好き

[@user-milkteaprsk]

それなぁ

[@sh-hatsunemikufan]

なんか嫌々キレイゴトを歌ってるみたいな感じが好きです

[@くれあ-l7o]

「ずっと」が「じゅっと」に聞こえてエスくん可愛い

[@まぃ-z9t]

タバコをどこかにジュッと押し当てられるオシオキでもあったんでしょうね…

[@crorico]

⁠@@まぃ-z9tゑ

[@helloex-6767]

2:15 ここアマネちゃんの気持ちがあって自分を責めている様な感じなのにエスくんが歌うと ｢お前はホントにもっともっと頑張ればいい子になれると思っているのか？実は一番甘えたくて普通な子に幸せになりたいんじゃないのか？ そんな事で自分を責め立てるなんてバカバカしいとは思わないのか？｣ みたいに更に追い打ちをかけてきている感じに聞こえてきて鳥肌すぎましたし怖すぎた

[@miina8]

解釈すきすぎて10回くらいいいね押してました……😊

[@白雲そら]

@@miina8解除してるやんけ

[@crorico]

@@miina8せめて9回

[@ppi_mi]

このエスくんの「ちゅっだよ！」 に救われる命がある。 最高かな。無機質感が良すぎる。

[@招き猫の鈴]

1:16　ここの"歌わされてる感"たまらなく好き

[@user-jn9zl8ez1z]

「自慢って程でもないですが　私は幸せです」の「幸せです」の歌い方が少し低く聞こえるから、やっぱり奥底では幸せじゃないってアマネも自覚してるのかも

[@元素L]

2:55 エス君のちゅっ！だよありがとうございます！！！！！

[@miri9716]

エスが歌うとお仕置き受けて現実的に「あー ここ最悪だ」って気づいたけど 逃げる方法見つからないし言うこと聞いてればお仕置き受けないから幸せのふりしてる感あって好き

[@user-sj6kz5tk8t]

アマネちゃんって確か赦さないだったよね？ 考察で赦す人はしっかりと歌って赦さない人は冷たく歌うっていうのを見てからこの歌い方もアマネちゃんへの皮肉みたい(？)でなんか深いなぁと思った。アンビリカルとかは結構優しく歌ってたのに対して事変上等とかは結構な皮肉だし使い分けしてるならほんとに凄い！

[@はらまき-p5n]

もっといい子になれたなら〜ってところが気持ち苦しそうに歌ってるのってやっぱりアマネちゃんの思いが反映されてるのかな......

[@ayato_]

今までのエスがカバーしてる曲よりMVが鮮やかになってる？？？？ 完全な白黒じゃない気がする

[@田中-r3r1s]

2:16 2:31 2:48 歌い方の使い分けが天才

[@Rim_chan]

一見無感情に聴こえるけど奥底に怒りがあるような、「幸せです」とか「怖くないですよ」とか言わされてる感もあって自分ではどうしようもないっていう諦めがあるような、 アマネちゃんが歌っているときには感じなかった胸の苦しみがすごい

[@lisajin5804]

It's very interesting how people said those voted guilty would get red thumbnails colouring their face, but this disproves the theory because Amane is green and yellow. Note also that Jackalope laughed at us for voting her guilty to 'realize her sins', so maybe Es doesn't really think she's guilty? Or maybe rather than Amane being solely guilty, she's also a victim. Also it sounds like they're genuinely singing, much like how they sang the other innocents. Rather than suddenly going flat or down a tone from the original. It's interesting. I'm excited to listen to all covers.

[@ZIxZaven]

Colours are actually based on their colour palettes, not wheher their guilty or not. On the note of "Realizing their sins" - Its the fact that Amane is a firm believer of her faith. Would voting not forgive really shake her firm beliefs of the faith that she had grew up with? Thats the question. And the answer on Amane's 2nd trial "I am disappointed". All in all, for Es himself, I believe he doesnt care. All he needs to do is judge.

[@cyntheziser]

Nope,the reason is actually main color + extra color in the album if you get what i mean

[@zzz-js3ez]

この曲、こんなカッコよく歌えるんだ… 0:59 1:51 2:39 2:55 ｢めっ！｣と｢ちゅっ！｣

[@crorico]

誰かお博たてといt

[@teor4_68]

2審までの間にバンバンエスくんカバー増えてて嬉しすぎるなぁ… HARROWまで全曲カバーされるといいな

[@huwarari9926]

早くカズイおじとコトコしゃんエスくんカバーはよはよ

[@プレシオサウルス-k6y]

再生頑張りましょう！

[@oo-dd1cx]

再生リストでも再生数カウントされますか？

[@user-白-16]

@@oo-dd1cx 確かされる

[@くるみっと]

誓いますっ！って感じだったのがエスくんの無機質な声によって誓います。みたいになっててとても怖い...けど好き...

[@しきし丸]

これだ…我々はこれを待ち望んでいたんだ…

[@yasumi_na21]

yurina has the ability to express melancholy even when the song or beat is not particularly sad. this somehow feels sorrowful and desperate like es’s cover of after pain did…

[@tres_bienn]

愛なんですよの時みたいに感情こもってる曲はすごいお経みたいに淡々と歌ってたけど、おまじないでは全然ちゅっだよのところも普通に歌ったってことは、勝手な想像だけどマヒルさんはもちろん思いが本当にあるけどアマネちゃんにはその思いがないのかな？やっぱり悪いって思ってるからこそ嘘をついて明るく振る舞ってるみたいな.. どっちも明るい曲なのにエス君は愛なんですよでは歌い方テンション低かったのはその嬉しい気持ちを代弁するのが嫌だったからかな？

[@桜綴]

素敵な考察だなって思いました！ エスくんの感情のこもり方、気になりますよね！ 個人の考察失礼しますm(*_ _)m アマネちゃんは洗脳されてるのではないかと思っているのですが、 もし洗脳だったとしたらアマネちゃん本人の感情が無いのではないでしょうか？ 原曲で歌っているのは洗脳されたアマネちゃんで、エスが歌ったのはアマネちゃんの本心だったりして。 と思いました 失礼しました┏○ﾍﾟｺｯ

[@kajiyamas]

i feel like there's a lot more energy in this cover!! but amane being voted guilty shoots a hole through the theory es is more energetic in innocent prisoners' covers 😭 maybe it's because she's a child?

[@monolinny1817]

I wonder if metavoting has something to do with this? But shidou's isn't so I guess it might not be the case..

[@Whail2dots]

Maybe because we know she's a victim

[@yinyekieru]

amane：I am not a child！

[@thebingus7243]

i disagree, it doesnt feel like energy but more so sadness? like es feels bad for amane which is to reflect the metavoting where peopel dont think shes bad but just want her to realize the flaws in her cult

[@hearts.22]

@@thebingus7243 yes!!!

[@jl8417]

This is another fun cover! It seems a bit faster than the original, almost as if Es is embarrassed by such a cutesy song and trying to finish it ASAP Kazui still needs ~80K views so i don't think we'll get another Es cover for a while, but when we do, Kazui's thumbnail gradient will be blue to white

[@coltonturbville3851]

I’ve been noticing the shift in colors, even match another prisoner Haruka1️⃣💙🧡 Yuno2️⃣💖💙 Futa3️⃣❤️💛 Mu4️⃣💛💚 Shido5️⃣🖤🤍 Mahiru6️⃣🧡💜 Kazui7️⃣💎 Amane8️⃣💚💎 Mikoto9️⃣🤍❤️ Kotoko🔟💜

[@chimes023]

how did you know?

[@unknownmothergoose7909]

EVERYONE LET'S GET THE OLD MAN TO THE TRESHOLD

[@monolinny1817]

@@unknownmothergoose7909 LESS GOOOO

[@jl8417]

@@chimes023 Not sure if you mean me, but if you do, then the gradients can be found on the prisoner's CDs (each song gets released in Japan on CD and each CD has the main song, DECO cover song, instrumental version and voice drama)

[@ゆき卯]

このエスくんの歌わされてる感のある無機質な歌い方がすごく好き

[@milk_koucha]

アマネちゃんに対してちょっと怒ってる感じが伝わってきてる？感じの歌い方好きすぎる🤦‍♀️

[@aliciaofdiamonds6655]

LETS GOOOOOO AMANE COVER TIME!!!! EDIT: OK IVE LISTENED TO THIS FULLY es sounds so agressive in this cover in a good way and it may be basically a sign of how the guilty voters are to amane's situation and feel agressive towards the ones that caused amane to become who she is and at times the agressiveness tones down as if to pity and feel sad for amane but that's just a theory, a milgram cover theory

[@senritsujumpsuit6021]

Seems plenty legit

[@31nic]

yeah! i've been thinking from time to time, maybe how es sings isn't based on a guilty or innocent vote, but based on OUR reaction to the prisoners! i didn't feel aggression, but i felt es singing like they mean it and understood it.

[@METEORBELT]

mikoto's cover came out before the votes where set. this theory is bad

[@aliciaofdiamonds6655]

@@METEORBELT i mean. even then mikotos were mostly guilty from the start (somewhere like below 30 percent for innocent), but since amanes was later on, it could fit on her end and not for the others

[@senritsujumpsuit6021]

@@31nic that is also plenty legit if not more so :3

[@leelouvel]

I really can't get enough of Es's covers. can't wait for the second trials.

[@hearts.22]

I'm so obsessed with their covers they're so perfect

[@thewildmonarch]

Unlike the other three guiltiers, magic doesnt really have any emotional bits that es can monotonize, so the tonal shift is likely with how aggressive es sounds here (i noticed it pretty much right away,,)

[@Buli-Nika]

〝 無感情〟おまじない待ってたからめちゃくちゃ嬉しい！ あまねちゃんすごい笑顔だけどこの表情のなさそうな歌い方と荒い画面で闇感が増してて好き！！

[@mikangoyaron]

きたきたきたきたああああああ！！！！！！エスくんの！！！！ちゅっ！！！だよ！！！！！これをずっと待ってた！！！！！！！！ いやーそれにしてもこの棒読み感…好き…曲のテンポが速いのもあるのかもしれないけど他の曲よりぶっきらぼうに歌ってる感じがして好き…本当にただなぞって歌ってるだけな感じがして非常に…好き…

[@食パン-h8z]

エスくんの｢めっだよ｣｢ちゅっだよ｣待ってました🙏相変わらず感情無くて良いねぇ〜！(？)

[@nattama78]

ほんとに……………それなです………………………

[@yorimilgram]

0:50 1:42 2:30 es’s ‘yaaaay” extended my lifespan

[@ジャパニーズピーポー-r6d]

エスが歌うと命令に従順に従う兵隊みたいでより宗教感増すね

[@人-k5l]

すんげぇ良いなぁ どんどんエスくんのcover増えて嬉しいです！

[@sakuma__14]

ついにっ！エスくんの「おまじない」がっ！

[@森っこ]

エスくんの｢ちゅっ！｣が聞ける！？！？？？ ありがとう…ありがとうございます……

[@jellifygirl]

1:16 you can just HEAR es rolling their eyes before saying "I'm happy" 😭

[@0nae]

되게 강단있게? 단단한 창법.. 너무 좋아.. 담백해.... 아이다카라, 예~~ 이런부분ㅠㅠ

[@SunnyBakes]

i have a theory about Es's singing. what if the way he sings is the way HE thinks we should have done. most times, he agrees with us. but this time, it's different. we RUINED Amane with the guilty verdict, so Es sings like she's innocent, because that's what he believes. he may not remember stuff, but he isn't blank. he has biases and opinions too, he just can't really voice them. maybe it's pity, maybe it's how he just feels, but it's a fun idea to entertain.

[@So___]

これ聴くまで死ねないと思ってたんです！やったー！これからたくさん聴

[@ievercallyou.811]

†┌┘墓└┐†

[@Petagumidayolo]

となりに入らせていただきます... †┏┛墓┗┓†

[@雨宮-z9c]

エスくんのちゅっが聞けるとは!!🥲 2審までにエスくんカバーどんどん増えてて嬉しい😿

[@lisajin5804]

Just realized that at the same time that Amane's colour scheme for the thumbnail isn't red as someone voted guilty, her colours also match Muu's. And Muu very much considers herself victim in her music video, while Amane considers herself utterly innocent. Two sides of same coin?? In the way that they both think themselves in the right, and both were driven to the point they HAD to kill the person that they did. It also might just be coincidence cuz Muu's sand is green and Amane's is obv green themed lol but. I want to imagine it was intentional.

[@shin9562]

It's a bit weird since an older person (Es) is singing this while the annoyance can be heard which is cute heheh it is kind of eerie too

[@れう-r8f]

きちゃった…きちゃったよおまじない…！！！ 相変わらず裏切らないエスで最高でした でもイェーーイ！が思ってたよりイェーイ！！！！してて好き かわいいってよりはぶっきらぼうな態度の子って感じなんだけど、やっぱり…かわいい……(支離滅裂な思考・発言)

[@user-rd3xl2fy6l]

おまじないのエスくんcover待ってました‼️

[@sakuma__14]

1:51 2:55 エスくんの「ちゅっ！」です

[@imukin]

エスが1番ファン多い気がする

[@みこみこちゃん-p6p]

Woah another cutesy cover from Es that actually sounds lively 😅 Mahiru is shaking 😂

[@天音-u4u]

エスくんのカバーだー‼︎ この曲好きだから嬉しい😊 エスが歌うとまた違った見方で聴けるから良い✨

[@DaisukeSN]

Amane (Tanaka Minami posted about this) song was the one that hinted me about milgram project so is kinda nice to have been in the early stage to watch and hear the ES cover, as someone said I do think the pace of the song is a little bit faster and I also think ES sounds kinda angry but not in a way that it makes the song a messy . And is that same emotion that fits, but at the same time changes drastically the feeling of the song. But is still good =w=

[@mai-vj3zk]

全部エスなんだよなあ… 当たり前なんだけど、全部それで歌えるのがすげえ

[@Ian-ey1su]

Don't you just love when singers decide to come clean and monotone?

[@kana.6802]

エスくんからの｢チュッ｣いただきました🙏✨

[@questh6893]

Ah! I'm 4 hours late! But holy- This was way more nicer than I expected. Es sounded bored in the verses, then a bit aggressive in the choruses....I also found it kind of...faster? Maybe it's because of how people voted Amane guilty to make her realize her mistakes and her cult's brainwashing. I mean, the staff is very observant in how we vote, so Es may be a bit more energetic in here than in TIHTBILWY because of the reason we voted her guilty. Or, the other choice, that Es just wants to get this song over with, thus sounding bored and speeding some parts. Either way, Es/Yurina's voice fits this song well too! Now we gotta get half to 1 mil. Half, one of my favorites. I'd love to see Es cover it, so I'll be waiting for that!

[@popypopy6041]

可愛い世界観(内容はあれだけど)だからこそこう歌う方や、映像が少し変わると、ゾッとする(いい意味で)

[@user-bd5kj7iu5e]

きたぁ！！！！！！！！まってまし

[@user-bd5kj7iu5e]

た

[@saltyshima1354]

THIS COVER IS SOUNDING AMAZING AHHHH

[@saltyshima1354]

I LOVE IT

[@latteemoji4570]

ONE DAY... ONE DAY... WE'LL HAVE AN PURGE MARCH ES COVER, I'M SURE

[@わぴ-z9d]

待ってた……ずっと待ってた…最高

[@uzozozozo]

やっぱ真顔で歌ってる感じ好きだわ

[@hiwelcometochilis2331]

Es seems to be putting a lot of energy into a song for a prisoner that was voted guilty…..

[@idontknowwhattoput5851]

maybe its because Es knows that the reason she was voted guilty was bullshit and sung happily out of pity for Amane

[@esqulre__]

well ppl did vote her guilty for her to realize her sins so

[@monolinny1817]

@@esqulre__ I doubt it would really work since Amane implied that she didn't care one bit of how we think iirc. But if it does work, then this theory might work out.

[@esqulre__]

@@monolinny1817 fair enough

[@0riginal_zer030]

To be fair, this was meant to be a very energetic song to begin with.

[@SW-2114]

エスの「チュだよ」が聞けるの！？ あっさりしてたw エス、歌ってくれてありがとう。 歌詞が影響してるのか基本無感情で歌ってるエスの声に合うな。

[@雨谷-s4g]

「幸せです」のところ？アマネちゃんに対してどうしようもないなって感じがしてて好きです...

[@rikarabitto35]

アマネちゃんかわゆいんですよねぇ✨ フータくんとこれからも仲良くね❤

[@D4DJ_2525]

あー！！！すき！

[@亜人-f6q]

無気力に歌っているのに、なに、それ、可愛い。。

[@Kamenrider40]

キター！！！

[@addicat30]

lyrics so I can learn the song 💪💪 Ano shiawase no yubikiri wa yaburuto totemo itai Iya tte hodo ni shitekuremashita Gomennasai no omajinai wo Demo zenzen kowakunai desu yo ai dakara Gyaku ni ii kanji tte omoemasu hora suteki deshou? Kamisama konnan datte ii desu ka Watashi mo amaechatte ii desu ka Chikaimasu yabucchauda nante warui ko wa me! Da yo Sorry datte iemasu yo Watashi datte kibou wa aru n da yo Chikaimasu mou ii ko ni naru shikanai! Desu yo Jiman tte hodo demo nai desu ga watashi wa shiawase desu Mata tte kao wo sarenai you ni kakugo wo kimemashita Demo zenzen kowakunai desu yo ai dakara Honto ii kanji tte omoemasu hora suteki deshou? Kamisama kouiu no tte ari desu ka? Tama ni wa yowakutatte ii desu ka? Chikaimasu mamottekureru ii ko ni wa chuu! Da yo "Mou ii" nante iwanai desu Waraiatte yurushitekuremasu ka? Chikaimasu mou ii ko ni naru shikanai! Desu yo Motto motto motto ii ko ni naretanara Kitto kitto minna egao ni naru Zutto zutto issho ni iraretara ii na Kamisama konnan datte ii desu ka Watashi mo amaechatte ii desu ka Chikaimasu yabucchauda nante warui ko wa me! Da yo Sorry datte iemasu yo Watashi datte kibou wa aru n da yo Chikaimasu mou ii ko ni naru shikanai! Desu yo Kouiu no tte ari desu ka? Tama ni wa yowakutatte ii desu ka? Chikaimasu mamottekureru ii ko ni wa Chuu! Da yo "Mou ii" nante iwanai desu Waraiatte yurushitekuremasu ka? Chikaimasu mou ii ko ni naru shikanai! Desu yo Mou ii ko ni naru shikanai! Desu yo

[@apo_8282]

2:54 一番待ってた　2:55

[@blueshylove3438]

I'll be honest this might be the only Es cover I prefer more than the original

[@mifa117]

楽しみに待ってました！

[@Камико_Ацуно]

Мне кажется, или эта песня звучит чуть эмоциональнее других и чёрно-белый фильтр имеет меньшую степень? Цвета скорее приглушённые, чем абсолютно монохромные. Это забавно, учитывая, что степень виновности Амане -- около 50% т.е. её признали виновной с большой натяжкой и она намного невиннее других обвинённых.

[@hanezu796]

何気に1番待ってた

[@れい-s8g6l]

まーじで粛清マーチのカバーたのしみにしてる

[@amiandkaguya]

Aku sangat menunggu Es menyanyikan lagu imut inii!!!.. Aku pikir akan Jadi apa jika Es menyanyikan lagu ini, rupanya ini melebihi pikiranku

[@d_SUKI]

👏

[@se-lm6ef]

ES SOUNDS AMAZING AS ALWAYS ILY

[@spiritwarhol707]

This actually sounds better than I was expecting

[@the.k1ng108]

Haruka - v Yuno - v Futa - v Muu - v Shidou - v Mahiru - v Kazui Amane - v Mikoto - v Kotoko 2 left!

[@wawan261]

Still no Es cover

[@プレイリスト-q2b]

無感情気味なのがすごくいい…

[@potepoteto_014]

この曲のエスが1番好きかもしれない…笑

[@MunouMaruBakao]

ｵｱﾜ!待ってた！

[@nutlut]

yay another one of my beloved es covers

[@elyann8005]

Always happy to see another Es cover ✨

[@ru-ru-uwu]

大好きありがとう😭😭😭😭😭💗💗

[@MM_mumu]

めっちゃ嫌々歌ってる気がして思わず苦笑いしてしまう…まあしゃーないとも思うからなんとも言えぬ気持ちだ

[@milleypana]

I always adore es' cover of this sm

[@essugram]

AMAZING ES COVER AS ALWAYS WOOHOOO

[@kitsuchii5825]

I've been WAITING for this one! WOO!

[@アール-27]

好きだぁ！！！！

[@maxboop]

oh this sounds so fresh... es did so good here

[@五斂子]

なんかアマネちゃんの本音って感じの歌声だな……

[@azulazldck1673]

I believe in Es supremacy

[@Lil-y-pad]

Woo! Another lovely cover. :)

[@oo-xg8hw]

超待ってた🫶🫶

[@しょーや-c1x]

待ってた...

[@_ririririly]

きちゃぁぁぁぁぁぁあ！！！！

[@小人光る-u8b]

アァァぁカワィィィ

[@nursyazaadriana1546]

Yosh! Another amazing cover from Es-san!!

[@ks1399-y3u]

i'm so saad to see her beaten like that after the first trial😭