Min Heejin's Leaked Texts are WILD! (alleged)

  Рет қаралды 16,829

Sonyeonstan

Sonyeonstan

Ай бұрын

Thanks for watching the video!
Like, Subscribe and comment below!
Link to source: / l4g1tpl
• 충격 단독! 뉴진스 자료 공개합니다
My second channel: / @sonyeonfan
Follow me on Instagram: @sonyeon.stan
And Twitter- @Sonyeon_stan
For business inquiries- sonyeonstan1@gmail.com
Check out my previous videos and Subscribe to my channel for more content!: / @sonyeonstan
Shop Yesstyle here! : ys.style/chp53MQcBfb
Code 'SONYEONSTAN7'
Follow me on Instagram: @sonyeon.stan
#kpop #bts #HYBE #minheejin

Пікірлер: 368
@taevistic
@taevistic Ай бұрын
Apparently Min Heejin did not deny these messages and just said that hybe invaded her privacy is absolutely insane to me rn, people need to wake up and see that min heejin is not the icon they think she is
@Existing5006
@Existing5006 Ай бұрын
The fact tht ppl in SK are supporting her...i srsly don't trust a country who is so appearance based nd misogynistic
@Usery5439
@Usery5439 Ай бұрын
and she is not giving up the company laptop either. that is not her property.
@Jia37
@Jia37 Ай бұрын
​@@Existing5006 no they are not now..don't forget Koreans love Njs nd support mhj for that reason a lot..I saw many people hate her now under the youtubers post which is mentioned in the description...so maybe the public is changing.. honestly good
@stduupie
@stduupie Ай бұрын
crazy 💀💀
@jK_ann9039
@jK_ann9039 Ай бұрын
Nah her saying that as if she didn’t do the same thing for weeks 💀
@loneeggtt
@loneeggtt Ай бұрын
Given how she responded when fans voiced concern about the cookie lyrics, by gaslight and how much she swore in the press conference, this sounds like her.😂 pride comes before a great fall
@eggiemybaby
@eggiemybaby Ай бұрын
After the nth room case I'm positive that MHJ is aware who her real target market is with all the concepts she has done all these years. She knows what will sell and she knows a lot of people in her country are fascinated with youth. Kinda effed up but I can say she's a genius in a twisted way. I feel sorry for the girls. They are surrounded by top level execs who are both egotistic and sick in the head.
@user-cs4oh7ro2h
@user-cs4oh7ro2h Ай бұрын
Wow so this texts exists and some ppl just turned a blind eye.
@madkmadk6809
@madkmadk6809 Ай бұрын
Of course they did. Because most kpop news outlets like allkpop and koreaboo are suspiciously skipping on posting translations or even non translated version of these texts. Same with that kookielit channel that thousands and sometimes millions of fans watch. NONE of them mention this. None of them point out that newjeans also plagiarized Shakatak's 'easier said than done' song to make bubblegum song. All of the media are currently doing media play on MHJ's favor so most of the public doesn't even know this. That's why they are blindly supporting her. I bet her support would be way lower if these news got exposure in those outlets
@iamweird-ei7s
@iamweird-ei7s Ай бұрын
@@madkmadk6809 stop new jeans plagiarized? damn well ok. thats news considering her claims against illit, riize, tws, etc.
@madkmadk6809
@madkmadk6809 Ай бұрын
@@iamweird-ei7s yeah you can go check out the two songs side by side and you'll realize the chorus is copied exactly melodywise. And a chotus is the main part of a song. Only the lyrics are diff. Even Shakatak's official twt account replied saying they had no idea about this bubblegum song(which confirmed that it's not a case of sampling) and they were not notified by MHJ side but that the bubblegum song sounds very similar to their song. My best guess right now is that since bubblegum is only on youtube currently and will appear on music sites on the 24th may, before then MHJ side will try to pay off Shakatak band to try and settle so that they don't raise a legal issue
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
​@@iamweird-ei7s Exactly! But the Korean news channels aren't pushing the content, just claiming that HYBE submitted a Kakao message and got scolded by the judge and they're still hating on BSH. I think MHJ shaman has probably done something to cloud their minds 😂😂😂. Because, what is this sorcery?😅😂
@ZareSamo-cn8pr
@ZareSamo-cn8pr Ай бұрын
Wait court ..not exept dis msg for evidence ... End you stile hire tallk about dis fabricate msg...with no reciver ...mehhh Dis laydi is fk up...bat bro dis Hybe is just mehhhhhhhhh
@preciouslyunhinged
@preciouslyunhinged Ай бұрын
The only victims here are the idols/artists....that's it period
@stduupie
@stduupie Ай бұрын
literally
@immealldayeveryday9425
@immealldayeveryday9425 Ай бұрын
No and hybe because y’all just listened to what this lier said and took it as fact but this is real evidence turned over by hybe who has clearly been saying that she is lying, but now we have proof not that I needed it, I could tell from day 1 that min is a lier her press conference only proved to me that she is a master deflector who spews word vomit to say nothing at all about what really needs to be addressed, she is a greedy conniving woman
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
Fancy knowing the person you trusted say such things about you those poor girls, way to go NOT. I just want her out and the girls given counselling and a team that truely believe in them and will build them up. It's now very clears she's been playing mind games with them.
@preciouslyunhinged
@preciouslyunhinged Ай бұрын
@eileencritchley4630 I was icked and shocked by what she said abt them too...that's totally 😳 😐 she is borderline mean .imagine finding that text abt you ..
@belaytriks
@belaytriks Ай бұрын
Exactly. They need teraphy ASAP.
@carolyncomtois7597
@carolyncomtois7597 Ай бұрын
Min claiming to be mother of NJ and spouting these messages is plain viciousness. Her messages are really nasty and reflection of the kind of person she is. Untrustworthy.
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
A REAL MOTHE WON'T USE HER CHILDREN AS A SHIELD ..
@isha.sarraf
@isha.sarraf Ай бұрын
Atleast hybe didn't dragged new jeans into it
@Staniel-123
@Staniel-123 Ай бұрын
Fr unlike mIn hEeJiN who says she treats the girls like hsr daughters
@nicoleloss7987
@nicoleloss7987 Ай бұрын
Hybe is trying to protect newjeans and save their career
@andreahl3494
@andreahl3494 Ай бұрын
​@@nicoleloss7987 Nah, let's not delude ourselves. I don't like MHJ but I doubt "saving" NJ is their goal rn. It's gonna be to clear their name. Unfortunately when behemoths fight, the grass suffers below.
@hoanhuynh7059
@hoanhuynh7059 Ай бұрын
I am sure she was laughing at the idiots who fell into her PR stunt after her press conference. I hope they feel stupid now for defending her. 😂
@iamweird-ei7s
@iamweird-ei7s Ай бұрын
nah the lawyers were hilarious like they looked stressed and like they regretted their life decisions.
@agustdtsugad
@agustdtsugad Ай бұрын
Nope....they're still riding for her.. idk how but they still actually are😮‍💨
@ekranabdi7465
@ekranabdi7465 Ай бұрын
These are fake dummy
@cuteme456
@cuteme456 Ай бұрын
​@@agustdtsugadwell afterall they are getting paid.
@Stella_louiseW
@Stella_louiseW Ай бұрын
The fact that this was out long ago and is the reason she came publicly to cry for sympathy and the korean netizens actually sides with her is shocking
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
​@@Llllllmmmmm Also, why aren't the news stations sharing the whole truth. Seems to me that they're all against HYBE.
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
mee too.. it's beyond my logic comprehension ..
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
@@royal_bee4534 Because they are not run by HYBE. HYBE has money but not the connections
@dann2348
@dann2348 Ай бұрын
If those messages are indeed true, that is utterly disgusting.
@hoanhuynh7059
@hoanhuynh7059 Ай бұрын
Of course, it's true if she just claimed an invasion of privacy instead of debunking it.😂
@_Wonnielvrs
@_Wonnielvrs Ай бұрын
She didn’t deny it she even said that HYBE invaded her privacy as if she didn’t do the same with Bang Si Hyuk
@minhmeo5010
@minhmeo5010 Ай бұрын
Looks like these are messages between her and her VP, someone she thought would be on her side. This is the ultimate betrayal of all time, from MHJ to NJ and the fans, and from her VP to her. Crazy drama 😂
@scheepersmonica
@scheepersmonica Ай бұрын
They are true but she always know to make excuses to twist with her words so her answer will be it was a joke i did not mean it etc etc. to manipulate
@LasVegasYT
@LasVegasYT Ай бұрын
These are indeed real. They were the Kakaotalk messages between CEO MHJ and her VP L that Hybe showed to the court during MHJ's injuction hearing yesterday.
@minhmeo5010
@minhmeo5010 Ай бұрын
Crazy! Looks like a betrayal from her VP L and MHJ can't never expect to see this. And imagine how shock NJ be when they learn about these messages 😮
@theblackKatKuro
@theblackKatKuro Ай бұрын
Too bad they weren't accepted from what I know..
@ZareSamo-cn8pr
@ZareSamo-cn8pr Ай бұрын
Wtf ??? Stop with lies...Court not acepet dis msg ... + dis fabricate msg ...with no reciver ...
@LasVegasYT
@LasVegasYT Ай бұрын
@theblackKatKuro They were accepted by the court. The only thing was MHJ side argued that they shouldn't be read out loud or or be shown to the public during the trail. So Hybe went around that by them leaking the chats to an SK freelance reporter that runs a YT channel with 500k+ subscribers.
@minhmeo5010
@minhmeo5010 Ай бұрын
@@LasVegasYT hmm, how do we know this isn't made up by the KZbinr or Hybe? anyway this really flipped the situation now. I can't imagine Hybe dares to make up something like this
@luckystarlight
@luckystarlight Ай бұрын
I have heard that there's actually worse texts than these and hybe hasn't shown everything yet, and leaving most of it to submit later without press to protect the members. The judge gave both sides until the 24th to submit evidence and Hybe has a lot more... I feel awful for everyone hurt by Min Hee Jin.
@Sonyeonstan
@Sonyeonstan Ай бұрын
I really despise hybe for a lot of reasons but if it's true that they kept the worse messages for private, then that's very respectable. Atleast someone seems to care for the NJ members' image
@cathydimaria6454
@cathydimaria6454 Ай бұрын
Why do you despise hype?
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
I thought the judge didn't accept the Kakao messages as evidence?
@user-xe7is7eq1s
@user-xe7is7eq1s Ай бұрын
​@@Sonyeonstanwhy ? Because a lot of people who say that put hate on hybe groups which is horrible just because they win against their favs in other companies so please don't spread hate
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
that's why from her side that keep releasing negative online posts backstabbing HYBE, Bang PD, n other HYBE Groups ..
@friendlybobbi
@friendlybobbi Ай бұрын
Right, MHJ is a catastrophe for NJ.
@vanessastein1689
@vanessastein1689 Ай бұрын
Even IF New Jeans were unmotivated to work, talking about them like that would NOT help the situation, especially if they found out what she was saying. That's not how you lead/guide people; your words have to come from a place of love and care, not contempt.
@wegotmonkey444
@wegotmonkey444 Ай бұрын
I usually hate the word "probably".... But they are probably just as hard working as any kid or young adult, it's just that MHJ is a psychopath
@GetMeToJupiter
@GetMeToJupiter Ай бұрын
I'm not trying to defend MHJ here, but this was obviously a private Kakaotalk conversation. It wasn't meant for the public. She didn't say all of this to motivate them, nor was this her attempt at leading and guiding the girls. While I do agree that she has to speak nicer of her employees, you can't tell me that you haven't had those days where you'd get irritated by your own peers and had to dump the load somewhere else. Especially with such a daunting and heavy task such as managing PR and events for one of the biggest Kpop idols of this generation.
@raybradburied
@raybradburied Ай бұрын
But this is exactly the problem, NJ are not her peers. They’re much, much younger than her. There’s absolutely no need for a woman her age to write incredibly vile messages like that about literal teenagers.
@soultune908
@soultune908 29 күн бұрын
​@@GetMeToJupiterthen why did she put out ss in press conference. Y'll are hypocrites
@Stella_louiseW
@Stella_louiseW Ай бұрын
From reading many articles i think the first few lines were for a female employee who complained about sexual harassment from ador vp but she cursed the female employee instead
@RiotGrrrl10
@RiotGrrrl10 Ай бұрын
No, cause the corporate part is important. That's why a lot of people sided with MHJ to begin with, it's harder to make an effort to understand the legal and corporate stuff than her crocodile tears. That's falling into her trap, cause she expected people not making an effort to understand what Hybe has been saying since the beginning. But aside from that, I really REALLY hope more people get to understand that MHJ is a narcissist and that NJ are not safe with her. I feel like most people who support her don't care about the girls safety and well-being, they are just afraid the music and style will change without MHJ.
@georgeallen4007
@georgeallen4007 Ай бұрын
😂 MHJ has no legal case against HYBE and she could get sued for breach of contract . Plain and simple she became aware of how much clout and money new jeans is capable of bringing in … I assume that’s the reason she wanted to leave through the back door anyway she could . Unfortunately for her HYBE seems to have all the legal basis to win .
@fidjdbdjficbfk7944
@fidjdbdjficbfk7944 Ай бұрын
From a Corporate Governance point of view, the situation isnt even debatable.
@katiaferreira4370
@katiaferreira4370 Ай бұрын
If these messages happen to be true? Of course they are and that woman is a malignant narcissist. Period
@immealldayeveryday9425
@immealldayeveryday9425 Ай бұрын
She managed to fool a lot of people, but not me, her press conference showed me that she only did it to gain sympathy as she never addressed anything she was actual accused of, instead she tried to deflect and she succeed but real proof is a powerful thing, these are true and hybe presented them in court yesterday
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
yes, it's from the court hearing yesterday (friday)
@a.198
@a.198 Ай бұрын
After those texts reveal, my doubt has turned into confirmation that mhj only cares about money and is a huge narcissist who keeps emotionally manipulating newjeans and their parents. That lady doesn't deserve to be near newjeans at all and the girls need protection. It would honestly be best if mhj is kicked out of ador and they get a new CEO. It will take time for them to adapt but these girls honestly need some time to heal and maybe that's why hybe was sending them into hiatus.
@joellez6832
@joellez6832 Ай бұрын
I don't follow NJ's BUT if old Min did truly care for her one and only asset as the "loving mother" she said she is to them, then don't you think she would've ensured NJ's was kept in a safe place because she knew exactly what was about to happen with her intent to get more money for herself only. Instead she uses them and their parents. If any of NJ's actually disagrees with what min is doing, what do you think she would do to them?? I honestly believe Min is holding NJ's in a very toxic and abusive relationship and if these email are actually true then NJ's and their parents need alot of support and time to heal.
@em5522
@em5522 Ай бұрын
The fact she never made any statements abt leaving all artists alone, even tho that was bare minimum, this whole time even with all the hate multiple grps she mentioned in the presscon had been getting afterwords. I knew she was fake for that.
@msbebelle07
@msbebelle07 Ай бұрын
I think that’s why Hybe want to put them on a hiatus, I think 18 months, that will help them heal, grow up more, concentrate on their work and be better and have a huge comeback with a better team around them. Hybe is thinking about the wellbeing of their artists because if the artists feel better it’s better also for the company.
@dfernandez3482
@dfernandez3482 Ай бұрын
​@@msbebelle07what if you're wrong? 🤔🙂
@sandrabates4507
@sandrabates4507 Ай бұрын
​@@dfernandez3482What if it is true, who knows?😮
@msbebelle07
@msbebelle07 Ай бұрын
@@dfernandez3482 I can be wrong, it’s just what I think, hope for them that what I think is right, because, in this sense the hiatus could be beneficial for NJ and with all this nonsense behind them the fans can continue to enjoy and support NJ in peace …and all other artists in Hybe would not be affected anymore, …as for me, I am an Army first and I support and appreciate other groups to, I would like all fandoms be at peace, I am 56years old so maybe that’s why I see thing differently, but if I was Hybe, personally in charge, that’s what I would do. So I guess we will see…
@blxcklab
@blxcklab Ай бұрын
Min Hee Jin communicated with BTS accountants several times, she even wanted the data for each region. She also wanted to become BH CEO..but Hybe refused...it's probably the reason why Hybe decided to have BHM as a private label. Ppl say ARMYs are inserting themselves in a situation where BTS is not relevant. But, the problem is...after the investigation and audit...MHJ was out to get BTS that was why sge was adamant to become the CEO if BH. Even Danamu/Naver outed her plans to Hybe.
@aplaraujo250
@aplaraujo250 Ай бұрын
If she actually cared about the girls, she wouldn’t put them in this mess…
@moonlightpaw5868
@moonlightpaw5868 27 күн бұрын
That is what I’m saying. People kept saying all Hybe care about is money. But in reality, money are important
@goponmogumder
@goponmogumder Ай бұрын
Criminal min hee jin 🤫🤬
@cleveycleve4501
@cleveycleve4501 Ай бұрын
Damn u the one who made the fake texts 😂
@goponmogumder
@goponmogumder Ай бұрын
@@cleveycleve4501 bro u r the one who made min hee jin famous 😀😊
@iamweird-ei7s
@iamweird-ei7s Ай бұрын
@@cleveycleve4501 broski she didn't even deny it. what r u on?
@KantorSaja
@KantorSaja Ай бұрын
​@cleveycleve4501 min church follower founded 😂 U easy to spot pal how's it going ? Does church leader haven giving instruction yet ? After bullying kids for months Who's the target next The reporter or the employee who's let hybe audited their company ?
@crisc1107
@crisc1107 Ай бұрын
Once when MHJ brought up all the artists' names on the table, she was already planning for public opinion and diverted the focus from her. What mother like, how good she was, were all bs.
@iamweird-ei7s
@iamweird-ei7s Ай бұрын
nah cuz why is there only 178 likes? people are manipulated so easily. New Jeans made a name for themselves but Hybe paid for all of the stuff for them. They would not invest just to try and take them down right after that. That press conference? I feel so bad for the lawyers. Its funny tho how they were actually sitting there thinking about their life decisions.
@ZareSamo-cn8pr
@ZareSamo-cn8pr Ай бұрын
Exaly ..Manipulation of HYBE with Fabricate msg... Mehhh not ive court exept dis msg like evedence !!! Bicos der ar fabricate + no reciver of dat msg.. Mehhhhh
@fidjdbdjficbfk7944
@fidjdbdjficbfk7944 Ай бұрын
They wouldnt. They would try low effort content. Why invest into a brand that leaves you?
@Rim._.
@Rim._. Ай бұрын
Omg save newjeans from all the disgusting peoples that are exploiting them they are so young they deserve better
@belaytriks
@belaytriks Ай бұрын
You mean their parents first? Their CEO? Their managment team? Hybe? Which one of all them?
@bdfhvxz
@bdfhvxz Ай бұрын
@@belaytriks Not HYBE.🤨 Why would HYBE spend a ton of money on NJ and WANT to see them faill?😳 There IS a clear villain in all of this mess.🙁 STOP sitting on the fence to avoid calling a WRONG thing a wrong thing and trying to equivocate between the parties involved.😵‍💫 HYBE and BSH have NOTHING to gain by blowing up the VERY Company he and BTS (💜) spent blood, sweat AND tears building! Common sense ARMY, common sense. . .😏
@minky2k
@minky2k Ай бұрын
@@belaytriks yea… all of them
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
​@@minky2kWell, unfortunately the girls have planted themselves right in the midst of everything! They signed a petition to block HYBE's right to vote
@msbebelle07
@msbebelle07 Ай бұрын
@@minky2k but Hybe couldn’t do nothing to them not even protecting them, they were not aware of MHJ actions because she took them into Ador spaces, her own management team, Hybe employees we’re fooled by her to, now that the cat is out of the bag everyone see that MHJ is not the good person, it just a facade, Hybe is now trying to repare the damage, Hybe is a conglomerate with subsidiaries and it’s the subsidiaries that works directly with artists, Hybe put the money, connections, and many services and try to help subsidiaries …my guess is they will help New Jeans members, that’s why they want to put them in a hiatus I think for 18 months, that time will help the girls to heal, to grow up, to concentrate on their work, dances, vocals, etc and be better, confident and stronger and ready for a huge and happy comeback with a good team around them, if the girls agree, they will be it the best position so..for their best interest the girls should side with Hybe and not the deceitful and hypocrite MHJ
@shelbieP
@shelbieP Ай бұрын
I saw a ton of people defending her, but right from the start, I knew this women was vile and didn't care about NJ. I just hope the girls are okay at the end of all this.
@nicoleloss7987
@nicoleloss7987 Ай бұрын
They have their families. Plus hybe has mental health clinics in the building for idols and staff to use. It is completely private.
@key-s6507
@key-s6507 Ай бұрын
​@@nicoleloss7987 Min Heejin had the parents write out a letter of their problem with Hybe. I'm on the fence with their parents because of Cookie.
@kathrynyoung7829
@kathrynyoung7829 Ай бұрын
No opinion? Then don’t say BOTH companies have issues. As I see it the fault lies solely with MHJ. She is bringing NJ into this, HYBE has said multiple times to leave the artists out of this and that they plan to support NJ through this time. MHJ texts show that NJ were a means to an end, she has no care for the girls, she is just out to cause as much damage as she can. I’m an ARMY, but I won’t say mean things about NJ. I feel sorry that they are in this situation. If these texts are real, and judging from evidence submitted in court yesterday I think they are, then it’s a massive betrayal by MHJ.
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
oh they are real as she said something really stupid that proved they are real. She opened her mouth before thinking instead of saying they aren't real she said 'Hybe invaded my privacy'. oppps dear you just admitted those messages are real.
@Skippbeats
@Skippbeats Ай бұрын
She confirmed the txt were true just taken out of context. She's horrible
@Evah702
@Evah702 Ай бұрын
I never trusted this woman I know that theres something weird about her.
@andreahl3494
@andreahl3494 Ай бұрын
Same. I tried to read about her conference at the beginning but I still couldn't side with her. I guess our gut feelings told us she was nasty.
@twixter0
@twixter0 28 күн бұрын
this was pretty much expected after the press conference she gave me manipulative vibes using new jeans as a shield and posing as the victim
@missluna___
@missluna___ Ай бұрын
I'm so worried about the mental health of all artists involved. I've been around K-pop since 2011 and I've watched this industry lose so many to the toxicity that comes with the industry. This needs to be resolved and it needs to be resolved quickly for the sake of not losing anyone else.
@AnneLives81
@AnneLives81 Ай бұрын
If even one of these texts is real, she should not be allowed near any artists. Period.
@raginfreckles4650
@raginfreckles4650 Ай бұрын
I am an Army but I honestly want to give NJ a big virtual hug right now. The betrayal will hurt them so much. I sincerely appreciate their talent.
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
Oh well, they'll definitely need a lot of that. Seeing that they've all signed a petition against HYBE
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
they choose MHJ side ok, .. backstabbing HYBE ? bang PD ..
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
ARMY also here and agree they've been used/abused and are controlled it's like they have become part of a new small cult. I just want them out of her hands and receive all the mental health care they require to be able to get through all this.
@bumbee-li6hb
@bumbee-li6hb Ай бұрын
Don't give another group or fandom a hug, you will regret it. Mhj did this so much shit to bts and those girls still supporting her. Why would you give them a hug? This means they are okay with her doing this as long as they are getting benefited. Once I adored them but what newjeans and their parents are doing is only done by selfish people who constantly thinking about them.
@fidjdbdjficbfk7944
@fidjdbdjficbfk7944 Ай бұрын
@@royal_bee4534career suicide. Likely parents involved.
@ridita5221
@ridita5221 Ай бұрын
It doesn't change my opinion. Miss Min looks crazy and greedy. I was on HYBE's side from the beginning.
@sky-il3cf
@sky-il3cf Ай бұрын
I can't contemplate newjeans and illit's mental health rn admist the whole drama.. Poor kids r being dragged into this. If MHJ was truly a mother to NJ then she would never bad-mouth about them to other ppl like this..
@NatalieMarie917
@NatalieMarie917 Ай бұрын
“If they don’t greet me, I think I’ll want to murder them.” Interesting… wasn’t she just talking about how they’re on her side, view her as a mother, and feel so bad for her? Idk the exact timeline of events, so maybe it was extremely circumstantial, but overall those two realities don’t fit together. As if we needed any more reasons not to believe her 😅
@beccal.5369
@beccal.5369 Ай бұрын
She calls herself the mother of New Jeans... what a joke. If that is the way she talks about them I would say she is their enemy. In praying Hybe can get rid of her Asap.
@andieherbert118
@andieherbert118 Ай бұрын
Fan war? New Jeans fandom can’t war with Army. That would be like a puppy trying to fight with a lion. Naturally Army will defend BTS, but quite honestly BTS should have nothing to do with this nonsense. All they did was support a new girl group and help give them exposure. So what is the war? The saddest part is New Jeans, their parents and their fandom actually believe MHJ cares about them. Even before these alleged texts, we could see that she was all about herself. How many raises did New Jeans get in the last 12 months? We know she got two, one in base comp and one is stock valuation. If she was about the girls, she would have been making sure the girls got new contracts too. IMO. I sincerely pray these girls don’t end up like Fifty-Fifty!
@KPOP73SpM
@KPOP73SpM Ай бұрын
She reminds me of the crazy lady from Squid Game.
@key-s6507
@key-s6507 Ай бұрын
Reminds me of Mother Gothel from Tangle the whole mother know best.
@valerieb2614
@valerieb2614 21 күн бұрын
apparently she just responded to them saying "i dont remember its not important" girl didnt even deny it
@sauravmitra7985
@sauravmitra7985 Ай бұрын
I hope nothing happens to NJ. Its been only a year since I fell in love with their music but thanks to this whole controversy I dont feel NJ will be NJ anymore.
@alessadolan5718
@alessadolan5718 Ай бұрын
New jeans is definitely over now :((
@sauravmitra7985
@sauravmitra7985 Ай бұрын
@@alessadolan5718 I will be mentally dead if that happens, though atleast for now How Sweet is releasing in 3 days and I have ordered their albums too. But how long will these keep me happy anyway. I want NJ to stay forever.
@Minni25655
@Minni25655 28 күн бұрын
They should have stayed neutral. If MHJ loses and is fired how can hybe manage NJ when they openly petitioned aganist them?
@raginfreckles4650
@raginfreckles4650 Ай бұрын
The fact that HYBE is protecting NewJeans is commendable.
@bbi2.052
@bbi2.052 Ай бұрын
I’m disappointed but not surprised
@funinartcraftzz
@funinartcraftzz Ай бұрын
i mean i wouldnt be surprised if she actually wrote that..
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
oh she did indeed type it it's in the logs plus the person she sent it to also confirmed it.
@LeoLinloeo
@LeoLinloeo Ай бұрын
Hybe owns 80% of new jeans if she really loved them she would let them go and give hybe i mean ador the ideas she had for new jeans sick and tired of her damn excuses free my girls from this predator and people don't believe this but we're so quick to believe the screen shots about "crushing asepa"
@video_battle690
@video_battle690 Ай бұрын
No way!!!😮 I can't believe. This is too wild disgusting. Nooooooo 💀💀
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
wake up!!!
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
I know it's disgusting but true.
@k1m0rq-thecoolest
@k1m0rq-thecoolest Ай бұрын
If these are true im genuinely gonna cry. Those girls genuinely trust her.
@rafaelsmith5737
@rafaelsmith5737 Ай бұрын
Bruh, honestly I never heard of New Jeans, I've only heard of them when there was articles about New Jeans as next BTS. Then I was quite surprised that there was a "high key" woman behind them who claims NEW JEANS success is all due to her. (Which is weird, cause she seems like Lee So Man who brags about creating the KPOP AVENGERS) Both CEO seems to be obsessed about the spotlight and taking credits for themselves. Anyways... She had lots of Pedo allegations too and also debuted minors a top of that. And the most interesting part is, they have a song called COOKIE, which is a not so innocent song if you really think about it. Not only that, she claims to be NJ mother figure yet still uses them as a shield. Everything she do for NJ is for her own benefit, if she truly cared about them, she wouldn't have dragged NJ name in the press conference. I don't like HYBE at all, but if people still sides with MHJ, I have nothing else to say.
@user-li5sv7bg7y
@user-li5sv7bg7y Ай бұрын
No podporniki Min Heejin ali vam je padla čeljust ob tej novici! Njena bolezen je denar in nič drugega. Kdor visoko leti, nizko pade in to zelo hitro.
@swagMan253
@swagMan253 Ай бұрын
Bruh how can people talk like this? It's wild.
@_Wonnielvrs
@_Wonnielvrs Ай бұрын
I bet bunnies are feeling real stupid right now they kept ranting about how MHJ is an angel and helped NewJeans while she’s talking shit about teenagers and fat shaming them
@blxcklab
@blxcklab Ай бұрын
They still believe her.
@KantorSaja
@KantorSaja Ай бұрын
Those Fandom is rotten from long time ago Never seen Fandom so toxic they need to present themselves on every other Fandom video or fanedit video even blink which people dubbed to be toxic have basic manners not to be toxic in other Fandom video
@_Wonnielvrs
@_Wonnielvrs Ай бұрын
@@Llllllmmmmm So true they’d save MHJ with all their lives instead of the members
@_Wonnielvrs
@_Wonnielvrs Ай бұрын
@@KantorSaja Even Blinks wouldn’t support Teddy of YG over the Blackpink members it just shows how little some bunnies care about NWJNS they got called fat pigs,b*tches,f*ckass fat b*tches by their own CEO yet they still protect MHJ instead of the girls it’s honestly sickening
@ZareSamo-cn8pr
@ZareSamo-cn8pr Ай бұрын
Way court not exept dis msg ? Mayby ...just mayby bicos der ar fabricate ....with no dammm reciver of dat msg.. Mehhhh ...end you call others stupid mehhh
@mmmky3204
@mmmky3204 Ай бұрын
NJ needs SUPPORT now more than anything else
@KantorSaja
@KantorSaja Ай бұрын
Nj need to separated from her first
@user-eo8ps7fs2h
@user-eo8ps7fs2h Ай бұрын
min heejin is litterly ysing new jeans fandom as a sheild, i feel like she might eveb be forcing the members to always say good things about her so the fandom supports during such a time.
@ikkietan
@ikkietan Ай бұрын
new notification omgg
@firstlastname1158
@firstlastname1158 Ай бұрын
According to Min hee jin leaking this is invasion of privacy but spreading artists number phones and private information is not.
@christopherculler1390
@christopherculler1390 Ай бұрын
Well of course that's how I talk in text about my only employees and breadwinners and describe my exact plans at the end...lol
@devinewave
@devinewave Ай бұрын
Danggg,, I hope my mother never talked about me to her friends like that
@The4pinksforlife
@The4pinksforlife Ай бұрын
Gosh newjeans members really loved her.
@kristirado5862
@kristirado5862 Ай бұрын
Min hee jin said this were taking out context/edited but didnt deny she said this... in what context u insult girls omg!
@nekosensei55
@nekosensei55 Ай бұрын
things getting spicy🌶🌶🔥🔥...i love it
@f0izan161
@f0izan161 Ай бұрын
just ignore the bad language and think about it if these chats are true then she just revealed the truth about working with female idols she might have just changed how we look at kpop but it can also mean she is purposefully telling lies
@bbi2.052
@bbi2.052 Ай бұрын
That’s a lot of words to describe sexism.
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
The are true it's not if but is true.
@fallenangelforever
@fallenangelforever Ай бұрын
I love NewJeans and I’m so tired of grown ass adults bringing so much hate into these young girls! More “fans” need to remember to be kind to one another and give the companies hate not the members as they are often victims
@hsk-zb2xw
@hsk-zb2xw Ай бұрын
The company doesn't hate Newzins But if you follow Min Heejin, that's the problem
@KantorSaja
@KantorSaja Ай бұрын
Lol you won't find other Fandom being toxic during all this drama except Bunnies they literally invaded other Fandom leaving malicious comment so yeah hope this teach these Fandom some humility
@fallenangelforever
@fallenangelforever Ай бұрын
@@KantorSaja you are being toxic right now!!! I’m blaming all fandoms for being toxic including toxic bunnies. I am a bunny and I’m so tired of seeing other bunnies being toxic. But I’ve seen plenty of other fandoms being toxic as well. ALL OF IT needs to stop.
@fallenangelforever
@fallenangelforever Ай бұрын
@@hsk-zb2xw what I mean by bringing hate to them is all of the drama these adults are creating is resulting in netizens sending group members hate messages. Netizens should be bringing their issues to the adults as it’s none of the groups making these choices it’s the adults.
@arinco6944
@arinco6944 Ай бұрын
MHJ is really narcissistic, greedy, and evil, yet does have an eye for talent. She should work for herself. She is not trustworthy or a team player.
@purkiplory
@purkiplory Ай бұрын
these are scary :( poor new jeans
@Alice-gr6ps
@Alice-gr6ps Ай бұрын
I wonder if NJ parents still siding with her
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
They sent a letter saying so but I don't know if they knew about the message when the did that. Somehow I doubt it as HYBE only just presented and had them accepted as evidence yesterday. I think their letter came out earlier.
@ZareSamo-cn8pr
@ZareSamo-cn8pr Ай бұрын
100% bicos dis not past on court like evidence...bicos der is only 1 side of msg ...der no hou recive dis msg...translate FABRICATE ...( fake ) ... end like KAKOO ...link dis msg on media platforms mehhh ... Last time wen ay chek KAKAO der make fake ...news about SOJIN from GIDLE..
@FallforcupidD
@FallforcupidD Ай бұрын
I hope the girls (newjeans & illit) and BTS are doing well, it may be especially hard to her someone who you feel cares about you and wants the best for you, to say such horrible things about you. Both Min Heejin and Hybe are wrong here. They don't care about their idols. (My wording was flawed, but this is my opinion of the situation from what I know. I don't hate Hybe or any company. Feel free to give your opinions respectfully, too. But MHJ is definitely the worst party.)
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
Don't drag HYBE down without HYBE all those idols wouldn't be Idol's. Just place the blame where it belongs at the foot of Miss Min and lets support the Idol's themselves and the Company that is try to do their best for them.
@clairekamau5650
@clairekamau5650 Ай бұрын
Explain to me how hybe doesn’t care about its artists and I’ll give you proof that it does. Don’t drag the label down for the fun of it.
@RiotGrrrl10
@RiotGrrrl10 Ай бұрын
I'm sorry but this is false equivalency. Hybe is not perfect, it's a company and I have no delusion of it being perfect and wholesome. But you're taking away from the responsibility MHJ holds in this case. Both are not equivalent when it comes to their behavior. It's too easy to say "whatever, both sides are equal" when one side is most likely guilty of a lot of wrongdoing.
@em5522
@em5522 Ай бұрын
​@@RiotGrrrl10I'd say both share moral blame (Hybe should've known better than to bed a snake in the first place, so that's one them that they got bit), but legal and larger moral blame is definitely on MHJ.
@nicoleloss7987
@nicoleloss7987 Ай бұрын
Hybe has always been transparent. And follows the law. The artist are most important.
@cindywhite3914
@cindywhite3914 Ай бұрын
How after seeing these messages can NJ members petition against HYBE and NJ parents are suing HYBE?
@Sonyeonstan
@Sonyeonstan Ай бұрын
Apparently it was a day after the petition, that these were released. But tbh she seems very manipulative so I wouldn’t be surprised. Look at the mhj Stan’s still supporting her despite her pedo activities and these texts all over Twitter. Making it a feminist issue when miss girl said she hated working with women.
@ro-zeea.8734
@ro-zeea.8734 Ай бұрын
And the drama continues. This is better then "The Penhouse" drama. 🍿🍿🥤
@footballfan7791
@footballfan7791 Ай бұрын
Why the kakao talk chats are illegitimate . The kakoa chat were supposedly found by hybe were from min hee jins laptop. If this is the case then why does the messages have her old sm profile,no timestamps, no messages of hers in yellow.? Min hee jin press conference showed that with her conversations with bang pd that her messages would be in yellow. So why doesn't it have it ?? It is very important to know that sbs when conducting an investigation on chu that one of the persons message would be in yellow. Not having this makes it fake and also the regular standard display and icons from the chats should look like what sbs put out. The font,lettering is also fake. If they got these originally from min, is supposedly legit coming directly from hybe then why is chat not looking like the one sent to chuu. Not having the time and date these were sent makes these messages illegitimate. If they really got evidence from her laptop then why doesn't it follow the standard formula of the chat. Context: we don't really know who she talked about the messages claiming she hates new jeans are true. It never specifically says “its about new jeans”. If she really does hate women then why is she beefing and being a obsessed hater on men such as bang pd,park jiwon. She hates bang becuase she finds him a fraud, stuck up,not a visionary. Its very clear that in the statements she put out during,before the press conference are all being bitter , hating on jiwon, bang pd. Hybe has an all male board. Ador has mainly more female employees/board. So its easier to claim she is a misogynist. The i am a girl but i hate girls and the supposed derogatory stuf she said. If a man wanted to frame/demolish the reputation of a woman (new jeans mom) the best way to do that is to frame her like she hates women.
@deniselee6334
@deniselee6334 Ай бұрын
You have a good logical point, but I believe some of the evidence submitted is a trap for MHJ’s lawyers. They will point these inconsistencies out and submit MHJ’s response. Then they will submit the actual facts or proof showed that can’t be challenged in time for MHJ rebuffs. Then judges will rule on only available facts. Smart legal move for Hybe’s lawyers. I’m not a NJ fan, so don’t have any opinion on either party. However, I can see the dishonesty on both sides, but based on all available info. right now Hybe is legally winning. MHJ is not a clean business partner, many business women can see her manipulative ways, but she shouldn’t have included NJ or any other group. I’m all for playing the game (business growth moves) but not if it will harm kids who can’t defend themselves. That’s when , as a business woman, you will lose my support/ respect because I have a kid in the industry here in the US. Hybe’s not innocent,but she’s showing poison behavior in any business setting. Being a vulture will only hurt in you the end because there’s always bigger, and stronger vultures to take everything away from you. USA international prospective
@RainbowSunDrop
@RainbowSunDrop Ай бұрын
Then why are the rebuttal complaints only about 'invasion of privacy' instead of 'those messages are false/made up'?! Also, weren't the messages presented at her press conference also cherry picked? The full conversations and full context was also not presented at the press conference, please correct me if im wrong.
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
Sending all these explanations when you guys took everything MHJ revealed in her Kakao as true without thinking it may be out of context is just time wasting. I didn't even bother reading everything you wrote, because it's useless. You guys only change narrative when it suits you. What kind of humans are these 😂?
@footballfan7791
@footballfan7791 Ай бұрын
it should not be revaled in court because it can be taken out of context ... she in the screen shots didnt say who this was about and people assumed it was new jeans. the youtuber has been involved in scandals and tried to hurt Jungkook's image. so i can see why ms min would not want that to get out. newjeans have filed documents in support of her . also hybe brought up the fact she used shamans when the naver charges came busting in. thier is a lack of transparency from their end. why say she revealed information to shaman when it apparently dumanu and naver lol
@footballfan7791
@footballfan7791 Ай бұрын
Font and design inconsistencies: The description of the font being similar to Comfort Sans, with a colored background (pastel) and childish-like writing, is a significant mismatch with the typical KakaoTalk app design. This is a strong indication that the messages are not authentic. Lack of time stamps and context: As you mentioned earlier, the messages lack time stamps and context, which makes it difficult to verify their authenticity. It's unusual for digital communication to lack these essential details. Character consistency: Your point about Min Hee Jin, as a woman, allegedly hating on other women (NewJeans) while waging war on a male-centered conglomerate (Hybe) is an interesting observation. It's possible that someone created a narrative to fit a specific agenda or to create a controversy. Motivations and motivations: You're correct that it's unusual for someone to hate on other women while targeting a male-centered conglomerate. It's possible that someone created a fake narrative to create a controversy or to further their own interests. The CEO and Hybe executives: Your mention of the CEO being a man and Min Hee Jin allegedly hating him and other Hybe executives adds another layer of complexity to the situation. It's possible that someone created a narrative to target specific individuals or groups within the company. Considering all these points, it's reasonable to conclude that the leaked messages are likely fabricated. The inconsistencies in font and design, lack of time stamps and context, character inconsistencies, and motivations all raise significant red flags
@emperorNB
@emperorNB Ай бұрын
Amazing how 2 hours press conference destroyed by less than 5 minutes video
@Staniel-123
@Staniel-123 Ай бұрын
Pick me vibes~
@layisslay
@layisslay Ай бұрын
This is why I'm not picking a side with Min heejin or hybe. Both are not innocent even if these messages are not true.
@nicoleloss7987
@nicoleloss7987 Ай бұрын
It is true. Min heejin is the only one wrong. Hybe puts artists first. Hybe has always followed the law.
@Gatekeeper201
@Gatekeeper201 18 күн бұрын
@@nicoleloss7987 That’s load of BS! If HYBE truly put their artists first, they *never* would have forced GFRIEND out of their label! And following the law? Ha! I’m pretty sure some laws were broken when HYBE forcibly terminated GFRIEND’s contract 6 months prior to its expiration! Then’s there the little matter of the HYBE data breach that exposed the personal information of hundreds of fans, which I’m pretty sure violated Korea’s consumer data protection laws too. Say what you want about Min Hee-jin, but don’t pretend for a second that HYBE is anything but a deceitfully underhanded, treacherous & greedy company that will kick out your favorite group the moment their execs decide they aren’t making the company “enough” money or become too much a PR liability for them!
@helenalee0613
@helenalee0613 Ай бұрын
I don’t really follow this drama but what annoys me the most is how because mhj cried and basically just used nj members in her emotional blackmail people started supporting her. I’m sorry but how on earth are people so gullible, the tears were already one thing and she proceeds to mention the girls?! Don’t bring them in this whole thing at all if you actually care about them. Don’t try to use their fans as a shield and unfortunately it worked she mentions the girls crying and says some emotional crap and people just think she’s a victim. I’m certain there are things HYBE could have done better and they definitely have some fault somewhere but that whole press conference just left a bad taste in my mouth. Like why are people still falling for emotional manipulation? And if nj fans really cared about the girls wouldn’t they be bothered about how she basically just mentioned them crying as one of her talking points? That just seemed like she was baiting people and people actually ate it up. I hope this all gets settled soon especially for the girls sake. I always wondered why people were against this lady but it’s starting to make sense. People forget that you can be a creative genius and still be a bad person or even a crazy manipulative one. Talent has never equated good behavior or sense.
@back_future.prospects_spe.d
@back_future.prospects_spe.d Ай бұрын
The ostensible issues at issue in the trial are the existence of serious breach of trust and contract issues, but... For the sake of the sustainable development of the K-pop industry, we hope that the important allegations and issues surrounding HYBE will be thoroughly clarified in court. Fraudulent marketing such as hoarding of HYBE, concept imitation methods, pressure on TV stations, etc.
@Lee-zz1yc
@Lee-zz1yc Ай бұрын
front and back of the texts are not revealed yet. it's too early to throw stones.
@SunRise-nh1kj
@SunRise-nh1kj 21 күн бұрын
Come here after she said she didn’t remember that chat and why would people talk bout those chat from three whole years ago🙄 she didn’t denied it yall as if she didn’t open up chat with bsh
@SnowyWinterbaby
@SnowyWinterbaby 29 күн бұрын
I wonder how the girls feel now after siding with her? I feel bad for them....
@Musicgeek97
@Musicgeek97 Ай бұрын
Please tell me this is fake ? I don't want to believe that she can be this vile.
@sheilaankrah9440
@sheilaankrah9440 Ай бұрын
It's real my dear it was shown in court so it can't be fake they Kakao chat with her vp about new jeans and she kept claiming she loves new jeans also convinced NJ parents to support her while she doesn't see them as humans
@immealldayeveryday9425
@immealldayeveryday9425 Ай бұрын
It’s real girl hybe presented it as proof yesterday in court messages from kakoe
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
Sorry but it's not fake and has gone into the court case. It's foul really foul no Idol's should have anyone pretend to be their mother to their faces then behave like that behind their backs.
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
its not fake, it's from yesterday court hearing
@ZareSamo-cn8pr
@ZareSamo-cn8pr Ай бұрын
Is fake...fabricate msg.. Court not acept dis msg ...bicos der fabricate ( fake) with no reciver of dis msg.. If is true is game set match for Hybe ...bat dis way with dis fabricate shit...is get iven worst for Hybe in court.
@wooyoungs_chest
@wooyoungs_chest 28 күн бұрын
They still want their kids to work with min hee Jin?
@fjnxtgdjsjeeh6073
@fjnxtgdjsjeeh6073 Ай бұрын
This is insane to the point i hope its not real, someone please save these girls from her😭
@kitten_cat327
@kitten_cat327 Ай бұрын
Noo i can't believe what she said to new jeans!!I just want new jeans to be okay,iam so sad😢
@aldreilargado545
@aldreilargado545 Ай бұрын
This is why I didn't stan both of them because they're both wrong and the people who will be effected are the group members, it's like they just think of they're self not the people around that is getting effected by this b"llsh!t controversy, I WISH THIS WILL END AND THE KPOP IDOLS ARE OKAY BOTH PHYSICALLY AND MENTALLY, THE DO NOT DESERVE THIS
@lazyegg9180
@lazyegg9180 Ай бұрын
That is why I think Hybe wants NJ to take a long hiatus to clear the air and have this girls mature more. This time around they really have to work hard for their fame.
@nicoleloss7987
@nicoleloss7987 Ай бұрын
Yes. They are trying to protect newjeans and save their career.
@shwetathakur2279
@shwetathakur2279 Ай бұрын
Both hybe ans mhj dont care about nj .in 1.5 year people will forgot nj and illit will replace them .it will be hard for them to famous again look what hybe doing with promis9 they are on hitaus for no reason. 3 to 6 month hitaus is good for there health . but when hybe stared to care there mental health when suga is in depression disorder he never take hitaus to cure his disorders
@rebeccaavoca9143
@rebeccaavoca9143 Ай бұрын
to give them time to pay the penalties .. if they want to leave HYBE & go with MHJ.
@ruthfischer7615
@ruthfischer7615 12 күн бұрын
@@rebeccaavoca9143 If HYBE insists they will have to pay quiet a lot more money than they have. I think there are text messages from MHJ about it when she tried to come up with a plan to get ADOR and the girls that speak about the kind of money that was put into NJ. It was a lot.
@royal_bee4534
@royal_bee4534 Ай бұрын
So sure more things will still be revealed.
@wandeesthoughts
@wandeesthoughts Ай бұрын
Min Hee Jin needs to go!
@angeleslopez5090
@angeleslopez5090 Ай бұрын
Im glad people are finally waking up, i never trusted her!!!!
@dfernandez3482
@dfernandez3482 Ай бұрын
We should do the right thing and believe these leaked texts are real. The more we believe then the more real it is
@ourglass488
@ourglass488 Ай бұрын
It's real tho.
@anseatery
@anseatery Ай бұрын
What?? I am astonished - this is beyond anything I could have guessed. Is this real???
@Odin4President
@Odin4President Ай бұрын
OMG, MHJ summoned the 4 horsemen of the Apocalypse (Allegedly) 🤪
@LARAREBECCA-yj5dw
@LARAREBECCA-yj5dw Ай бұрын
Not like defending min hee jin, she can be wrong we dont trust anyone rn but shouldn't the kakao texts have like time to when se texted this messeges or did those who released it hide it or absolutely faked this chats.? PLUS: NOT DEFENDING MIN HEE JIN!! IM AT NO ONES SIDE EXCPET NEWJEANS
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
the courts accepeted them so we don't get to really see them only what some people might put up on the internet
@ruthfischer7615
@ruthfischer7615 12 күн бұрын
These are recreations of the chat not the original chat. They were shown in court but because the artist needs to be protected (MHJ lawyer asked for it I think) they are not officially recorded for the press. Mind you we are talking about someone who has done this exact thing before and has been proven right many times.
@limnaee1812
@limnaee1812 Ай бұрын
I hope this is so fake
@deoxyribonucleicacidz
@deoxyribonucleicacidz Ай бұрын
now you know damn well that the girls and their parents wouldn't have signed in opposition of mhj's dismissal if all this was legit
@RainbowSunDrop
@RainbowSunDrop Ай бұрын
They allegedly signed in opposition before this was 'leaked/disclosed', so make of that what you will..
@footballfan7791
@footballfan7791 Ай бұрын
Lack of Full Conversation: Only excerpts of the Kakaotalk messages are shown. Without seeing the full conversation, it's impossible to know the intended meaning or what Min Hee Jin was responding to. Missing Context: We don't know the relationship between Min Hee Jin and CO-PDG L. Were they joking? Venting frustrations? The text doesn't provide that information. Source Bias: The information comes from a KZbinr critical of Min Hee Jin. They might be highlighting negative aspects and omitting positive ones. Figurative Language: Comments like "grow like pigs" or "want to kill them" could be sarcasm or exaggeration taken literally. These are just some ways the information could be misinterpreted.Lee Jin Ho's Background and Potential Biases Lee Jin Ho is a KZbinr who previously worked as an entertainment reporter [1]. Here's how his background might influence the situation: Focus on Controversy: Entertainment reporters often focus on uncovering scandals and generating controversy. This could lead Lee Jin Ho to prioritize sensational information over a balanced perspective. Motivation: It's hard to know Lee Jin Ho's motivations. He might genuinely believe the messages are real and expose wrongdoing. Alternatively, he might be trying to damage Min Hee Jin's reputation or gain views on his channel. Reasons to Be Cautious About the Messages' Legitimacy Unverified Source: The Kakaotalk messages haven't been independently verified. Without verification, it's impossible to know if they're real or fabricated. Selective Editing: Lee Jin Ho could have selectively chosen messages to paint Min Hee Jin in a negative light. Timing: The timing of the accusations is suspicious. They come right after Min Hee Jin positioned himself
@eileencritchley4630
@eileencritchley4630 Ай бұрын
The whole thing will be shown in court as evidence.
@footballfan7791
@footballfan7791 Ай бұрын
why do you follow like sheep blindly. i also have sumbmitted to hybe asking for clarffication on the returns for thier albums sales.they said they dont push albums However, by saying this , they may be revealing more inconsistencies and potential red flags in their statements. so i just have some thoughts. min hee jin accuses hybe of using new jeans for an album push to overtake aespa. hybe says they didnt do that. they have an informal conversation with min hee jin however. in hybes official statement they say we sold 43. whatever millions in 2023 then they refrence 2 of the 17 albums of 2023. they say that there only 70,000 returns on each of the albums totaling at 140,000. why are both returns the same and why were there returns in the first place? they mention things like market fluctuation,a spike in album sales. what does fluctuation mean and how come there is a big spike in sales when sales for entire countries ,artists lowered. what are they lying about? why did this informal conversation occur? why deflect from min hee jins main issue and reference that she produced 3.5 million albums and still has many millions left in stock?. that must mean hybe miscalculated the growth they supposedly saw. and i discussed how using umj for distribution is normal. umg is directly connected to umj. umj is japanese version of umg and bts promoted through thier as well. this is a normal promotional tool according to hybe. if its a normal promotional tool why bring that in at all. also distribution is not the same as artificially inflating sales through third party illegal means. Based on the information provided, here are some potential points that Min Hee Jin could use to counter HYBE's claims: Returns are not normal: Min Hee Jin could argue that the returns of 70,000 copies each of the two albums are not normal and are indicative of a larger issue. She could point out that this is a significant amount of returns and that it's unusual for companies to return such large quantities of products. Market fluctuations are not a valid explanation: Min Hee Jin could argue that HYBE's claim that the returns were due to market fluctuations is not a valid explanation. She could point out that the market fluctuations would have affected all albums, not just these two specific albums, and that the returns are not proportional to the overall market fluctuations. UMJ distribution is not a normal promotional tool: Min Hee Jin could argue that using UMJ for distribution is not a normal promotional tool, especially if it's being used to artificially inflate sales. She could point out that this is a red flag and that HYBE is using unconventional means to manipulate their sales figures. HYBE's production numbers are suspect: Min Hee Jin could argue that HYBE's production numbers are suspect and that they are not providing accurate information. She could point out that the company is producing millions of albums but still has many millions left in stock, which suggests that there is a significant discrepancy between their production numbers and actual sales. HYBE's informal conversation with Min Hee Jin is suspicious: Min Hee Jin could argue that HYBE's informal conversation with her is suspicious and that they are trying to downplay the issue or deflect attention from their alleged practices. She could point out that this conversation is not publicly available and that HYBE is only referencing it to create a narrative. According to the Nate Pann articles, here are some additional points that Min Hee Jin could use to counter HYBE's claims: Hybe said umj thing was regular promotion and that since new jeans does it why cant their other artists. They basically admitted they they doing payola for all groups haha. Hybe saying distribution related stuff a min hee jin spoke about artificially inflating sales. If you wanted to artificially inflate sales you wouldnt go to umj you'd do this in private or working with someone who does illegal activity. Wow, it sounds like HYBE has basically admitted to engaging in questionable practices, and Min Hee Jin is calling them out on it! It's hilarious that HYBE is trying to pass off their alleged payola activities as "regular promotion" because NewJeans does it. That's a pretty weak excuse, and it's clear that they're trying to deflect attention from their own questionable practices. You're absolutely right that if they wanted to artificially inflate sales, they would likely do it in private or with someone who can help them with illegal activities. It doesn't make sense for them to use a major distributor like UMJ, which is a public company that would likely be exposed to the shady dealings. It's also true that if you want to do deals behind the scenes, you wouldn't want to do it with a major distributor like UMJ in Japan, which is a big and reputable company. It's much safer to keep those kinds of activities private and under the radar.
@ruthfischer7615
@ruthfischer7615 11 күн бұрын
@@footballfan7791 Says the sheep. Does she pay you? MHJ made 9 visions of NJ current album with.... 2 songs... they sold less than the album before. The album before that she asked for 3 million CDs and sold a little more than half. She also for example talked UMJ to but 50 000 CDs more than they planed to. That is album pushing and pretty much everybody does that. Well... surprisingly HYBE does not do that. In exchange NJ ad a fansign (or something simlar) to help those extra copies. mind you this was pretty much a success. MHJ made stuff up for others to be mad about while doing this. She is mirroring what she does herself. Mind you someone in HYBE did take a return for albums - but that was illegal and should not have happened in the first place. They were sold without the stipulation that the distributor could "sell back" what they did not sell. What distributor buy is on them.
@aeeeeeeeecid
@aeeeeeeeecid Ай бұрын
It’s honestly disgusting how both sides are using this situation to hate on the groups when the main focus should be the mental and emotional well being of these idols.
@chocolatedonut6312
@chocolatedonut6312 Ай бұрын
I have a feeling as if it’s just a way for her to act out her toxicity by texting a close friend so it doesn’t affect irl life and work. Like unless she actually bullies people irl or says it to people’s faces I don’t think it’s good way of judging someone. I don’t know too much about the situation though. Edit: Ok the more i watched the more I doubt she doesn’t genuinely think that
@ruthfischer7615
@ruthfischer7615 12 күн бұрын
This seem to be (recreated) chat messages exchanged with her former VP.
@Ggggg1gggg
@Ggggg1gggg Ай бұрын
I actually want to vomit regarding these horrid text messages and the hybe cult allegations. God save NewJeans😭🙏
@srinivaschekuri7779
@srinivaschekuri7779 Ай бұрын
I don't understand but my doubt is min hee jin herself selected àll the members of new jeans but why is she calling them ugly in those texts i am not defending her but the texts bout nj members doesn't make sense for me
@nekosensei55
@nekosensei55 Ай бұрын
she's a narcissist...
@alessadolan5718
@alessadolan5718 Ай бұрын
@@nekosensei55100% 😭
@Rolanda4
@Rolanda4 28 күн бұрын
If these texts are true, then HYBE is doing the right thing. The removal of this woman is protecting the artists. Can't imagine what she says or how she speaks to them in person.. This is called "emotional abuse." Just hope the girls parents are trying their best or working with HYBE to get their children away from this individual.. For this type of behavior trait does not improve over time. "abuse of power" gets worse because the individual gets comfortable bullying and threatening the weaker persons.. The Red Flags Are There... Parents have to stop putting money and success over the well-being of their children.. #Praying
@geekyreader34
@geekyreader34 Ай бұрын
I heard these texts are true but supposedly she’s just joking. Seriously
@senu.
@senu. Ай бұрын
I'm trying to see where the joke is especially from a ceo in such a abusive industry
@richard6025
@richard6025 Ай бұрын
Shes is playing the neitzens
@arminbolt3683
@arminbolt3683 Ай бұрын
Have guys never been around Balkan martial arts teachers and see how they talk 😂😂
@Ines-sh9
@Ines-sh9 Ай бұрын
Please go all out for Namjoon comeback...this wicth is trying to destroy bts legacy and use those 5 girls as a tools 🙏please treat it as bts comeback ‼️‼️‼️
BTS's Digital Footprint is the WORST! (Cringe and Chaotic!)
12:32
K-pop Moments that make Me Uncomfortable and Upset!
10:42
Sonyeonstan
Рет қаралды 38 М.
Something is wrong with Min Heejin...
18:47
Asia's Animations
Рет қаралды 5 М.
Everything wrong with Min Hee Jin. Part 1
9:24
jimins jam
Рет қаралды 5 М.
female idols just can't stand men
10:03
bpeditor
Рет қаралды 331 М.
Is BeLift’s Case VS #minheejin Strong? When Will Source Music Sue Min Heejin?
11:41
Asian Entertainment and Culture
Рет қаралды 16 М.
wonyoung's queen behaviour vs. men
3:22
mitangbear
Рет қаралды 573 М.
Min Heejin: a disney villain wannabe
35:30
everglow-up
Рет қаралды 22 М.
(ENG)MIN HEEJIN, MOTHER OF NEWJEANS BREAKS BTS' HYBE #이지원변호사
9:33
Lawyer in SEOUL │ Lee & Law
Рет қаралды 9 М.
Этому парню 35 лет😂 #shorts
0:50
MEXANIK_CHANNEL
Рет қаралды 4 МЛН
Tom & Jerry !! 😂😂
0:59
Tibo InShape
Рет қаралды 40 МЛН
elim yara olduğunda benim haller #shorts
0:16
Mert Sarı
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Студия төрінде жобамыздың жемістері!
1:17:44
QosLike / ҚосЛайк / Косылайық
Рет қаралды 220 М.