Minecraft Bedrock: (Broken) Easy WITHER FARM Tutorial! Safe & Easy Wither Killer! MCPE Xbox PC

[@silentwisperer]

*UPDATE: as of 1.19.10 this version is broken, due to changes in how the wither breaks blocks. Do NOT use it! NEW TUTORIAL OUT NOW!* kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJPdi6idiaqUfMU Thanks for watching :D My older wither killers using the gateways still work fine, but they shoot wither skulls ALL over the place, which isn't great. The odd skull can get out of this build, but it'll hit the surrounding endstone for the most part:) Not sure who originally found this method, I know its from java and like 3-4 years old though! Still works great! :D

[@jasoncarman3480]

Does the 12 stacked iron farm still work? Also great vid btw

[@PhantomPhoton]

Great tutorial! Can I use the Nether Roof to do the same thing, so that I'm not endangering spawn or wrecking the area near the end portal?

[@silentwisperer]

@@jasoncarman3480 yes it works, just super hard to make 👍

[@silentwisperer]

@@PhantomPhoton maybe if you find a 3x3 of flat bedrock with nothing else in the way. good luck haha

[@thedagenator2006]

@@silentwisperer hey silent I've been building your new ghast farm from I think it was a month ago and I have a bit of a problem, in the kill chamber the ghasts don't take damage, when I look at it it's like they dont move over enough to actually hit the trident, like they get stuck on something

[@Tom-oz7wk]

This is my new favourite video. I didn't know this was possible on bedrock edition so thank you for making this tutorial for us. I'm already gearing up to take on the dragon and I can't wait to use this afterwards Edit: I did it and it is terrifying but it works and it's safe for the player. A few notes: -I play on normal difficulty but I still got the 3 wither roses -I traveled to spawn after and found a pile of blue skulls which seems a bit sketchy. Amongst the pile was also the 4 torches from the end portal which makes sense. The 4 blocks below the skulls were behaving weird too; I couldn't break them from above and had to break them from the side, as I was doing so, the skulls disappeared. I haven't had any crashes since using this method but I'm still concerned about how broken this method feels

[@pearlcommodore4772]

This design no longer works, Mojang patched it. Found out the hard way.

[@58pablo]

Same my end is done for

[@jal7748]

same

[@glassofoj4853]

Thank god I looked at this comment before I tried it

[@Zombi_RL]

@@glassofoj4853 same

[@omhar78]

Lol I just found it out 🙄😂

[@toastedwaffle8622]

I haven’t watched the full thing; just the intro, but in advance, THANK YOU KIND SIR. The previous wither trap I used was super glitchy and caused damage if you went near it. Can you use a knockback sword with this, or will it free them?

[@silentwisperer]

they should be totally stuck in there, and have no way to escape. but play it safe!:)

[@silentwisperer]

Just tested, knockback swords seem to be fine!

[@tylerkovalskas9780]

@@silentwisperer i tried something similar a while back, but i don't remember if I used obsidian. long story short, my end portal area was absolute chaos for close to an hour, and i had an insanely difficult war against the wither. i was under the end portal trying to hit it when possible as if i was in a trench being bombed by the stupid wither, and i died like a million times, but i eventually won. i think next time I will use your video as an exact guide instead of taking any chances. also, could lining the surrounding area completely with obsidian help?

[@nealio6458]

The Wither can destroy obsidian that’s next to it, so no, unfortunately.

[@tylerkovalskas9780]

@@nealio6458 that's no big problem. i have plenty of obsidian so I'll probably use a little extra since I don't want to have the wither escape again. the more confined it is, the better.

[@hurryingglint23]

Awesome, I’ve tried doing this a long time ago on bedrock and it just popped out and killed me.. so glad this finally works

[@justsomerandompersononthei2595]

For anyone who finds this tutorial: This no longer works as of 1.19.10. The wither can now explode obsidian when it spawns. I think the end gateway ones might still work but IDK. Edit: The end gateway one (there's a tutorial) does still work as of 1.19.10. Instead of fighting a wither, just grow a crimson/warped fungus underneath it which will break the gateway portal. Then you can build it. Just be wary that for each wither, you need resources to rebuild after the explosions and blue wither skills can escape. You also have a risk of falling into the void and losing everything you have in your inventory.

[@karsenb8954]

Haha figured that out rip netherite Armour

[@windolite]

Yeah I just did this twice in a row and the wither escaped

[@jacobcrowder2600]

Saw your comment about 20 minutes too late, Wither is currently wrecking my End

[@tbd14]

Same boys, same. Absolutely destroying my end right now. Oooops.

[@graydawg6949]

Rip

[@fatalexception4730]

Just to give some of you that MAY be on 1.19.0 still... I just attempted this in creative and then figured out an adjustment and successfully had the wither suffocate without escaping n MCPE bedrock. Once the obsidian cross is made from center beneath the portal as shown n the video, I added the one obsidian to the west, I added one directly above that one and then the 1 on both sides of it... instead of increasing the length another block as is directed n this tutorial. So it’s only 4 blocks wide in westerly direction and the rest is the same. Got my wither rose and star and now headed back to the nether to get more skulls so I can get rinse and repeat hehehehehe thanks for the tutorial !!!

[@aaronstalter7687]

Great video silent! Yours are always the best! I was using another method that was just like this one the other day and unfortunately the guy that made the video I watched didn’t mention the part about the wither escaping if you logged out. I did and the next time I logged in I was at one heart. Thankfully I escaped into the center portal and came back later when I was better prepared and killed it but it cost me two totems. Partly because I forgot I had the difficulty set on hard mode but it wasn’t fun. So do NOT log out or you will have a wither flying around your end island when you log back in.

[@dillonvandergriff4124]

Thanks silent! My dad was just asking if I knew of a tutorial like this. The wither killer I had been using is basically the same as this; I found the method in a Jcplayz tutorial a while back :)

[@uwucotc]

Never use anything build from jcplayz , his content is pure garbage and are mostly bad farms

[@dillonvandergriff4124]

@@uwucotc There's a few gems in there, but yes, his tutorials are a bit simplistic.

[@deusvult6920]

@@uwucotc he has a few decent farms but generally they're bad and his voice is *so* annoying. And his videos are all just the same farm over and over again lmao.

[@Farhan7]

@@deusvult6920 not really he uploads the same farms with some changes because of the new updates.

[@4P0CA1YP5E]

Imagine your friend just invited you to their world. They don't know where you'll spawn in at since they never really cared about the world spawn. As soon as you load in you are instantly bombarded by wither skulls.

[@Tom-oz7wk]

Has this happened to you before. I'm nervous because I traveled to spawn and found a pile of blue skulls on the floor and the blocks below were acting weird. Is all this stuff normal?

[@4P0CA1YP5E]

@@Tom-oz7wk I wrote this as a joke. I have no idea how the whither skulls would react as I haven't tried this whither killer yet. Sorry.

[@Tom-oz7wk]

@@4P0CA1YP5E ah my bad. I mean I knew it was a joke, I just didn't know if it was based on experience. Still, I appreciate the reply

[@mikewill18]

Great video, as always! For those who are unaware, if you make a mistake and the Wither gets out run and hide and set the Difficulty to Peaceful. Peaceful mode will cause the Wither to despawn. Just an option for those who don't want to waste the resources (and the risk) fighting it.

[@bigboiboomeryt]

Bruh I killed it on hard

[@IIchuckN0rrlsII]

Perfect timing. Just got my first 3 wither skulls in my 1.18 world

[@armaansandhu1427]

In mcpe ?

[@luculentname4300]

Wish I read the comments before doing this. I regret everything and lost everything. The wither skeletons stole all my god tier armor and my sword, and the either runs rampant in my end. I would have been fine if it weren't for some bug. Like I got him to half health, he exploded like he should, but the EXACT frame he exploded, he dashed at me and INSTANTLY killed me, with God armor btw. I hate bedrock wither with a burning passion. He needs to be scaled down immensely. Or heck, make this wither be in Java too. They need a challenge since they got everything easy anyways.

[@scottalmond5321]

Good vid, but you missed the opportunity for the wither rose farm. Setup a layer of air blocks below the obsidion floor. Then a layer of hoppers surrounded by a wall of obsidion. Then crack 40 or so eggs in there and seal it up with a final bit of obsidion. Spawn the wither and profit. Rinse and repeat. The obsidion protects all the hoppers but the chickens die and drop wither roses.

[@NFann]

Great vid, I've always used this method, find it more reliable but mostly cause I don't like breaking portals lol. a tip if any1 want to keep the room small, make a layer of water around the walls to stop the explosions from destroying blocks, with an obsidian floor or layer of water and fill it full of chickens for more wither roses 🙂

[@Tom-oz7wk]

Hi, I hope you don't mind but I'd like to ask a question since you've used this method before. Have you had any weird behaviour or crashes as a result of using this method? I only ask because when I tried it and then later traveled to spawn, I found a pile of blue skulls that weren't moving and the 4 blocks below couldn't br broken from the top. The skulls quickly disappeared and the blocks are fine now (I think) but I'm still concerned about the aftermath of using this method

[@NFann]

@@Tom-oz7wk I've never had it crash on me and I usually have my spawn set to my bed at my base or at the end portal so personally nothing weird for me but I have read about it from others on reddit about the skulls at world spawn, it was a year or so ago I seen it but I think someone was saying its a visual bug

[@Tom-oz7wk]

@@NFann thank you, that's really helpful. I didn't know it could be a visual bug so this gives me a bit more hope that my game will be fine. I'm cautiously optimistic for now, tho something will probably break anyway given how many bugs bedrock edition has

[@kalenstone]

My first attempt at a wither killer and this is the design I chose. Worked on the first try. lol (I'm not really good at stuff like this. I'm more of a miner.) Thanks for this little tutorial. Now to find your iron farm tutorial.

[@mre3654]

It worked on 1.17 but then was broken in the 1.18 update (to my horror as I was chasing a whither in the end). Glad to see it’s working again

[@featgoose972]

Does it work in 1.19?

[@auxeriaaim]

you are seriously the best bedrock survival youtuber out there, you save the community with ur videos :)

[@boxingkanga8352]

This is great. My previous wither killers have relied on finding the right bedrock configuration in the floor of the overworld.

[@silentwisperer]

thats such a pain isn't it 😅

[@jordanalt]

Just tried this method and it kinda worked luckily it did get stuck in the spot but wasn’t taking any damage automatically but after getting it with bow to half health and swooped in with a sword was no problem thanks :)

[@reunguju7501]

Thx. Really helpful! also you can use the top of torch to determine the direction, which is more convenient as torch is such a common item. The brightest pixel to the darkest pixel is due south.

[@nicovanzyl2363]

Hey silent I found a way to break bedrock in survival. If you make a nether portal and go to the nether, break the portal in the overworld and go back, it will make a new portal in an area close to where the original one was. This has a chance for the obsidian to break the bedrock. It does require filling in every other available block to spawn. Edit: I had a lot of help by a friend with testing.

[@silentwisperer]

interesting 👀

[@CUBS1only]

Been using this for awhile now, however before if you hit them they would escape so that's a nice thing to know. Thank you 😊

[@angcl1908]

Love it soooo much. Ty. Just got an idea for an add on. If you could like siphon the wither skellys and get them with a charged creeper. Dunno if this is possible but just an idea. Love the vids so much. 😆😃

[@noahcarlisle4470]

I've been collecting wither skeleton heads for weeks and yesterday spent some time killing 63 withers😂 This works well!

[@ChocolateMan142]

Thank you soo much!! It is next to impossible to defeat the weather normally especially that the wither effect bypass your armour (which is a bug) and Withers as a whole are a lot harder on bedrock And to top all that off I am playing on a mobile so when the wither does his special attack and the break all the blocks around him those entities crash my game So thank you this will change my life

[@Skydejavu]

Silent pretty please with sugar on top bless us with a new witty wither killer design, I beg of you good sir!

[@supernova5712]

Me : thinking it’s time for a beacon but don’t want to fight the wither. Silent: Say no more.

[@RamzaHeretic]

You make the best farm videos for bedrock right now. Works great 👍

[@pancake891]

YOOOO I was just testing ways to smack the wither most effectively myself this morning!

[@MajinNiki1988]

Hi silent just wanted to say thank you first 😁 and I think I have made improvements to this farm with water tubes to auto collect the stars and boxed the with in more so less damage to surroundings and yourself be good if could get it automated but would be hard if not impossible but tysm i love your videos

[@kallimiddlestetter207]

Hey Silent, thanks for everything you do. I wanted to give a heads up, as of today, May 15 2022, this wither farm is not working. I tried it a month ago when this video was first uploaded, and it worked flawlessly, so perhaps a recent update is to blame. The wither is not trapped in the fountain, and gets free. I quadruple-checked that everything was in place exactly, and not a single wither of many attempts in both creative and survival was trapped. A different configuration of the obsidian works. Place a 5x5 layer of obsidian under the fountain with a 2 block space above it. Build the soul sand blocks exactly where they would be on the “T” part, but don’t build the “T”, just place the single soul sand block for the body under the center block on the western edge of the underside of the fountain, and place the 3 soul sand blocks on the west side of it, lining up with the upper rim of the fountain, there should be a one block space between the 3 soul sand blocks and the upper rim. I’ve tested it dozens of times now in survival and it has worked every single time so far. I’ll be keeping an eye on this with future updates, and will edit this comment if this is fixed in the future for me. Thanks again Silent, I look forward to more of your incredible ingenuity with this game!

[@nikkiofthevalley]

Thanks for this, from my testing in my creative world (tested it 20 times) it seems consistent. I've also tried it in my survival world, it also seems consistent there.

[@1doge3..]

I'm so confused on what u mean by the western upper rim can u be a little more specific 😵‍💫

[@nikkiofthevalley]

@@1doge3.. They mean to place the soul sand and wither heads in the same position as in the video, but with the structure they described instead of the one in the video. And "western upper rim" refers to the rim of the fountain, specifically the western side of it.

[@mr.saturday]

Pakk Dat came out with this almost a year ago for Bedrock after being asked about it in his twitch stream, IDk why he never made a vid on it. He showed people how to build it while streaming and I've had it in my world ever since.

[@TheWallynl]

awesome just a question if you gonna kill him your self when he is traped can u use a knockback sword or not ?

[@lucassalinas1165]

Have you considered using charged creepers to get wither skulls from the wither skeletons he creates to make it self sustaining (ish)?

[@silentwisperer]

Yes i've done tutorials on that before:) they use to summon 4 w skeles, so you would profit skulls. its not really worth doing now days tho. my fortress farm is a MUCH better use of charged creepers haha >3

[@snmfsquirrel87]

Great tutorial for my 1.19 world! Thanks!

[@therealofficialcaz1900]

This seems super easy…love it!

[@RiNe7279]

No way. I was literally wondering early today if I could attack the wither while he was stuck or if it would out him out. Thx for the great vid!!!

[@dishantalokxiic2978]

Just make sure your weapon doesn't has knockback or punch enchantments because they can push the wither out of the bedrock.

[@BallinExe]

I have already killed the wither too many times on this one realm and nealy died . I tried another version I made a while back but it didn't work. So this will help so much thanks💯

[@Wogsmawp]

It works fine for me the ones who say it doesn’t work are probably doing it wrong and they should learn before you do anything in a survival world make sure to test it in a creative world first just get the materials and switch that world to survival to test it

[@impishkitten904]

We used one of these recently on our server. It does work, but a quick caveat. We're not sure if it was related, but when we left the end instead of spawning at our beds we were sent to spawn. We did see the escaped heads kind of spinning in one square there then they despawned. About 5 minutes after leaving the end we had a complete server crash and roll back. The shulkers we placed between leaving and the crash were lost completely.

[@Tom-oz7wk]

I'm sorry to hear about the shulkers. I hope you didn't lose anything too valuable. I read your story before I tried the wither end portal method and I should've taken it as a warning. I also found a pile of blue skulls when I traveled to spawn and the 4 blocks below the pile were acting sketchy. Like in your story, the skulls disappeared but now I'm very concerned about the effects this might have on my game. I'm glad I've got a nether star but I wouldn't recommend this method to anyone

[@impishkitten904]

@@Tom-oz7wk we lost basically everything we were farming but the admin reimbursed us. The server suffered a fatal crash related to the nether like a week later so the two events may have been unrelated.

[@Tom-oz7wk]

@@impishkitten904 I'm so sorry. I've never experienced anything like that on multiplayer worlds although on a realm I joined, that was the first time I experienced the entity despawn bug which I now know is unrelated to multiplayer. I lost some good librarians but it can't be anywhere near as bad as the crashes you've experienced. When you say "fatal crash" do you mean that was the end of the server for good or could the world be recovered?

[@impishkitten904]

@@Tom-oz7wk we were able to reset back about a week and a half but we elected to start over rather than rebuild all of the progress we had made before the crash. It had stopped saving backup files so that was the earliest we could hit. Also the librarian bug sucks big time. I was running a full compliment that boot and when the end crashed we lost half of them when we relogged.

[@Tom-oz7wk]

@@impishkitten904 I would say it's weird that is stopped saving backups but I dunno enough about minecraft or technology to know if it is actually weird. I don't blame you for starting new, I would be fed up with a world that keeps crashing. The worst part about the despawn bug is that it also took my cat (my minecraft version of my irl cat) and my horse. I've been too nervous to have pets and villagers since then, especially since it's supposedly related to mobs moving between chunks but my cat was sat down all the time. I also lost an armour stand with the armour I wore for the dragon fight in that world. That's a trophy/memory lost forever and I dunno how chunk aligning would've prevented it. (I say lost forever but I do have a backup of that world I haven't played on)

[@Sodomann]

This didn't work for me (Maybe there was a change in latest update?). However, instead of building a stair step off of the end of the "plus sign", I put a 2x2 square toward the west and that seemed to do the trick. In short, I spawned the wither one block east (the 3 wide soul sand should be directly under the bedrock) compared to this video and it worked fine. For some reason the wither skeletons took an absurd number of hits to kill though.

[@slattyslutt]

if you don’t mind may you please show a video on your KZbin

[@Bestedits_0]

"I wouldnt recommend spawning more than 1" Me: builds wither skeleton farm

[@TiberiusOni]

just found out the hard way that this is broke and had to look it up. thanks for the update

[@jackcarr7880]

Would it be possible to put some chicken eggs in dispensers to spawn loads of chickens allowing them to die to farm wither roses to?

[@yamitonelli]

Came here to ask the same question, I've seen people doing sth similar but they poisoned the chicken first. But I think it was Java, I wonder if this would work in bedrock.

[@isaaclearningtominecraft4751]

@@yamitonelli Yes it does work.

[@hfc_thijs4412]

Plz make stacking Raid i need it lol btw nice vid and yeah its possible to make stacking Raid in bedrock

[@luuk.]

i have just tried this 3 times (as of june 26) and it still works

[@sethsmith2608]

it didn't work for me. i just tried and it failed

[@luuk.]

@@sethsmith2608 mhhmm that’s strange, what didn’t work exactly? Did he escape?

[@sethsmith2608]

@@luuk. he spawned below the bedrock and not in it, and wouldnt take damage. So I had to shoot him with my bow and the bow knocked him out of place, and alas... I have to deal with the wither in the end now

[@Ooooscar278]

This video was very useful, thanks!

[@aonemesis1682]

Ive always hated battling the wither. First time I did it in the nether by the roof before the enderdragon and it went smoothly. More recently Ive been facing difficulties despite having way better gear, although it is a fight in the sky using elytra.

[@Tom-oz7wk]

I've only ever fought it on easy difficulty because the skeletons don't spawn in when the wither is at half health and the skulls it fires don't give you the wither effect. I'm a coward for sure but I needed to get the achievement I've since used silent's method to defeat it on normal difficulty and aside from some odd game behaviour, it worked fine. I guess I could've done it on hard difficulty but I didn't wanna fight the dragon on hard mode to free the end

[@AlexanderTome]

Cut to me building this one block off alignment and frantically trying to kill the wither I released as quickly as possible without any potions or anything, because hubris.

[@TheEverWickedWonder]

I've been using the one by vlofast here on youtube for a while now. Still works as well to get wither roses if you put some chickens down.

[@vtronv3486]

great video. could you make a tuturial on a stacking raid farm

[@Breathtaker5000]

Ima try this as soon as I remove all of the end crystals from my portal after obtaining some bedrock a few updates back

[@5RVM5]

Hey silentwisperer, can you please make a afk raid farm? I would really love it if you do. Im asking this because sinds the new update of the raids, my raid is everytime lvl 3. So i hope that you find a way to make a good efficient raid farm! Btw love your vids

[@LeoSengerRyanCooper]

Silent, I have a question, let's say that I have some totally not suspicious stacks of bedrock lying in my chests from some previous updates, could I be able to make this wither trap in the overworld?

[@Zaffre52]

Theoretically yes, since the blast resistant property should still be there

[@FrostBite46]

finally now the wither is much more doable thank you so much silent for the farm

[@silentwisperer]

always happy to help out:)

[@jorendaleliquigan]

OMG thank you I just got 6 skulls I got the 3 accidentally 😂 and I took the 3 and fought it underground but failed I've turned on peaceful mode then turn back on because I had no choice so I will do the dragon then the wither thank you so much I've tried it at creative and it worked!!

[@reddragonemperor1442]

This farm along with the wither skeleton farm has gotten me more than a stack of nether stars. Thanks Silent!

[@joho8838]

Does this still work in 1.19.2? I just did a test in a creative world and it doesn't seem so anymore

[@reddragonemperor1442]

@@joho8838 I'm just on the standard version for mcpe at the moment not using any version switchers and it worked fine. I'm not sure if I'm on 1.19.2 though but you should make sure you were on the west side as that messed me up a bit.

[@Axe3649]

Yh this don’t work in 1.19.2

[@Eclipticaaa]

Hello silentwisperer.I wanted to ask you to do a stacked raid farm please. Thank you 🙏

[@Llamamanllama]

With this you can spawn multiple and use it in a farm to get 100%drop rates, the only issue is that your end portal becomes more dangerous.

[@phantomski1]

Hey silent, can you make a bedrock edition wither rose farm? Thanks! (Maybe 2 versions, 1 with chicken egg farm and 1 with enderman farm connected

[@silentwisperer]

i have one, but it uses a gateway. thinking of making one using this method:)

[@phantomski1]

@@silentwisperer yea it would be really awesome if you could release a design that doesn't make people break one of their end gateways, because many people wouldn't want to restrict their travel in the end like that, so If you could come up with a wither rose farm that's like that it would be "absolutely fantastic"

[@Skyrem22]

Tried this a while ago, at first it seems ok then the wither broke the obsidians that I laid. After rebuilding it (exactly like the first one) it stopped working, the wither cannot move but it's head is not stuck in the obsidian. Edit: I fixed it! I just broke all the blocks underneath the portal. Yes even the ones on the sides, as for some reason, this blocks "pushed" the wither down.

[@shieldhero9407]

I recommend looking at Silents update I didn’t and I got two stacks of obsidian for it

[@silentwisperer]

yea they really busted this method >.

[@jkplays8512]

Thank you silent and for this farm it is super easy to build and btw how can I trap the wither to make other wither powered farms like wither rose farm???

[@sophic1844]

Finally we can do this now too. Thanks for the confirmation!

[@_Unknown_369_77]

thankyou so much bro i fight wither without potion and smite 5 sword

[@call_me_rushy]

Never thought safe and wither would go together in a bedrock edition video

[@zachmerrill807]

I just need to ask for all of your easy mode wither cages, does bedrock work instead of obsidian if I want to play in hard?

[@silentwisperer]

you can't get bedrock blocks right now. but yes bedrock does work, of course:)

[@zachmerrill807]

@@silentwisperer lol, also thank you so much for what you do, I hope the algorithm will show you to people more often. All of us who use bedrock really do appreciate what you do, and I think I’m free to speak for all of us on that. :)

[@buckethead60]

I still remember those sketchy wither killers using end gateways lol. This is so much better, thanks! Edit: Didn't see that you mentioned that when I was writing the comment. I thought using mushrooms to break gateways was fixed? I might be wrong though, because last time I used that method was when you could get rid of portals using dispensers and water buckets

[@silentwisperer]

dispensers was fixed, but mushrooms probably wont ever be fixed haha. mushrooms have work on java, bedrock, and legacy console for the better part of 8+ years now

[@Creative_Handle9]

I SWEAR I WAS ABOUT TO BUILD A DIFFERENT WITHER KILLER! THANKS! (Also 2nd comment)

[@kleigster675]

For the "tons of wither skulls" a falling water in front of a wall surrounding the gateway killer prevents those nasty skulls from getting out. For the most part the water prevents the wall from breaking. Also, if the wall is tall enough I noticed that the wither did not shoot.

[@bunny1780]

I have a very similar wither killer like this and if u surround the wither up to 2 blocks above the portal then make walls of water surrounding it, itll reduce exploding damages, and also i have had blocks destroyed at world spawn, but its never been more than the exact 4 blocks that silent showed

[@DSTARC__]

Please make a wither rose farm tutorial. One of those enderman powered wither rose farm cuz chickens type are kind of slow.

[@mitch85714]

Has this design been nerfed yet? I know your latest video talks about 1.19.10 but my main screen is showing me 1.19.2 so I'm assuming that update has been released. Thanks silent for all your videos anytime i need anything i know you got a video for it.

[@mitch85714]

Can confirm this setup is nerfed. Went a head and tried it in a copy world and the wither summoned in the obsidian not on top of it. Broke some end stone and managed to get free in about 15 sec.

[@silentwisperer]

this still works in 1.19.2, but might be broken in 1.19.10

[@DreadedFrog]

Just tried this twice on switch 1.19.2. broke out both times. It's worked 2 days ago... Idk. Shadow patch?

[@johnc7234]

Mojang changed this in 1.19.10 version, the Wither can now break obsidian :(

[@corytucker6788]

you could also use a pumpkin, it's stem on bedrock edition will point northwest

[@blufish4077]

Wow amazing guide I would recommend this to anybody thank you so much

[@xanderscales0]

Silent, as of 1.19.10 all wither farms have been broken, can you find a new one for us. Much appreciated brother

[@silentwisperer]

yes, new wither killer is on the way:)

[@justsomerandompersononthei2595]

His end gateway one still works though, you can use that in the meantime. Though I only tested it in creative so I'm not sure how safe it really is compared to this one.

[@Mem3nto_M0ri]

did excatly what you did, ended up escaping and i had to fight in in the air only for it to drop the star offmap

[@johnc7234]

Mojang changed this in 1.19.10 version, the Wither can now break obsidian :(

[@Stickynotepad1]

Oh man I loved this farm

[@AnilKumar-st7iv]

It's super easy to cheese the wither in java but bedrock is another case. I use another wither killer. That one has an automatic loot collection system and the wither dies faster. And water is placed to prevent the wither from destroying the sides and you can't hit the wither that would destroy the whole thing. But it is used more resources and it's a lot harder to build but I think I will stick to that design.

[@Sabarbah]

if you don't want nearby block destroyed just put a water wall around the killing chamber

[@Tom-oz7wk]

If withers can't break obsidian below their feet, would you be able to trap them in the nether roof as well. Also I'm terrified of doing anything wither related, one person already said their server crashed after doing this

[@mrtrending8478]

Finally a better way thx bro

[@arjunshrivastava2652]

Can you make a gunpowder farm for bedrock edition the mob farm is working but many of us need gunpowder so please make a farm ❤️❤️❤️🤗

[@silentwisperer]

checkout my recent mob farm:) 11k items/hour!

[@danielferrara7693]

great video thanks man

[@juliam9759]

Can you use this method to farm wither roses (maybe by placing a bunch of chickens) or will that mess it up?

[@silentwisperer]

you can! Was gonna do another tutorial for that:)

[@danielgrundy7475]

I use the top of the nether. Plenty of little pockets in the bedrock to trap them and then wack with knock back and smite sword. 40secods per wither stack of beacons in a hour.

[@DG_x_iiNSANiiTY]

Does this not work on realms? I just tested 2 withers in my realm and nether got stuck in the bedrock. They would both just float on the obsidian and escape.

[@silentwisperer]

it works! Make sure you do it exactly as shown!!

[@sweetiesue5648]

I love Minecraft. I've NEVER been able to o beat it in survival, sadly, because once I really get serious, Minecraft ends up crashing and I can't do penmy game. I'd love to be able to get it done, and it saddens me that all the new features have taken front seat and old issues are still not getting fixed. I just want to play my game!! Btw, I'm on PS4 and after about a gig of game, it is unable to load.. this has happened 3x now.. idk whether I will try again... Boo

[@sweetiesue5648]

Can't open* sorry for typo

[@Miss_Trillium]

Nice! I used a similar design a week ago, but I didn't get any wither roses :(

[@silentwisperer]

i think you only get them from the with skeletons dying:)

[@Miss_Trillium]

@@silentwisperer I'll keep that in mind! Working on getting more skulls currently, but I'll be sure to pay attention

[@isaaclearningtominecraft4751]

If you really want wither rose, just get some mobs (eg chicken) right below the obsidians and poison them to one heart before spawning the wither.

[@duaneingrouille1703]

I've been using this for a while now to cheese the wither. But I learned never have the knockback or punch enchantments. It is possible to push the wither out of the portal.

[@mr.glizzy9903]

THIS IS AMAZING ALREADY!!

[@Zaffre52]

I had to figure this out the hard way, and I decided to do this in survival like an idiot. If only I could have waited a year or two...

[@hammerjoe33]

You are just awesome!!!!! Btw still no way for getting bedrock?

[@silentwisperer]

we need reliable bedrock breakers to have a chance of farming bedrock

[@chubbayboy]

I used someone else’s tutorial and the wither is running around the end. Any advice on how to beat this beast? I jumped into the portal and did a full retreat when I realized it was loose.

[@wolfy2478]

Silent your spawner mob farm workers so well I didn't use your trident killer (it's laggy and noisey ) Instead I used a bubble collem Still it works pretty well

[@casperghost9808]

Could you get iron golems to smack it around? Or would the knockback let it escape.

[@silentwisperer]

i was thinking about using them 👀👀 need to do some tests to make sure its safe, but i am looking into creating an automatic version of this!

[@oaksparoakspar3144]

I use Iron Golem to kill my withers for me. I try to find a good place in the nether roof, clear out an area, build a secure room with a thick floor, thick walls, and flattening out the ceiling all with obsidian - 2 to 4 layers thick and big enough for spawning in golem and the wither. I put the sand down to make sure I have room when the place is packed with golems and I try to spawn in 64 of them (4 stacks of iron block, 1 stack of carved pumpkin). A 1x2 door lets me get in and out without golems or the wither doing so. The bedrock ceiling keeps the wither from flying out of reach of the golems (which is why you want an area where the bedrock is a flat as possible so it can't carve out a hold out of range. The golems tend to do a good job taking it out, though most will die on the final blast (which means lots of wither roses as well). It takes a lot of obsidian (I usually take about 12 stacks worth). If playing in hard mode, having a small room inside the obsidian made up of something weak like netherrack that will shield the golems from the opening blast but absolutely will be destroyed and out of their way is a good safeguard.

[@DecayPlaysTv]

Hi silentwhisper, I have used this method for the past 2 years on xbox one, in both single player and on a server however it no longer works, the wither just escapes. I've tried it several time now and I will put out a video showing the different adjustments I tried and also to show that it used to work but no longer does. DECAY

[@silentwisperer]

this works:) it needs to be done exactly as shown though!

[@DecayPlaysTv]

@@silentwisperer I've done it 100s of times in the past IT DOESN'T WORK ANY MORE. do you think I would post if I didn't know what I was talking about?

[@DecayPlaysTv]

@@silentwisperer solution found, its very simple fix, where you have the plus sign shape of obsidian put a 2nd block on top of the back 1 and the 1 to the left and right of the centre block. have tested is 30+ times and no escapes. and just a small note, I didnt comment originally to say hahahaha youre wrong. it was to let you know so you can let your viewers know there is an issue on xbox 1 with this wither killer. I watch 90% of your videos and I use a lot of your farms but as a small content creator I dont have the reach you do to get the word out. respect my man

[@LieutenantByrd]

5:12 if you have cords on, minus X is the West direction.

[@isaaclearningtominecraft4751]

Minus y (i.e. north) also works.

[@reamondewit5892]

sometimes it would be better for me to read the discription of the video carefully lol haha i tried it and half my end island got destroyed. i did kill the wither so no worries but it scared me pretty good haha. anyway thnx for the content non the less i enjoy it grtz rea