MISTY ISLAND RESCUE IS SO MUCH WORSE THAN I REMEMBER

[@ABellEngine]

If Charlie were to get lost at sea, Topham would likely not care and get another engine to replace him.

[@marcuspautu788]

Same for Billy

[@PepsiTrain26]

Or he would have brought back Billy and we all would have been more upset! Funny enough, Charlie’s first episode was my first Thomas episode I ever watched so I kind of love Charlie.

[@Ninja11125]

I hope

[@ScottishTwinsFan]

Same with billy

[@ThomastheGOAT1975]

It would also be the same with billy

[@MarcusWhitelam]

9:18 Tunnel is ready to collapse Percy: two boiler explosions are better than one

[@mcnuggwtscreations]

Do Hero of the Rails or Blue Mountain Mystery, ACTUAL good Nitrogen Specials.

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

YES

[@moonlightrider24]

Please do more of these, this was comedy gold lol

[@BlakeRichardson-o2g]

In my rewritten version of this movie, the opening sequence features Whiff pulling a goods train to the SSRC. His brakes break while climbing Gordon's hill. Then a suspenseful runaway sequence happens. He makes it all the way to the tunnel. Whiff gets curious and ventures into the tunnel. Suddenly it starts to rumble, and tunnel starts to collapse. He makes it out just in time before the dirt pile from the climax forms. He tries to tell Sir topham hatt what just occured, but Hatt is too busy to pay attention.

[@snookerdooker471]

Such a great idea

[@BlakeRichardson-o2g]

@@snookerdooker471 Thanks!

[@eggmanishere]

When I pressed read more I thought it would be 57 paragraphs long

[@BlakeRichardson-o2g]

@@eggmanishere Well I have other ideas, like Diesel coming with Whiff and Percy, Removing the part where Gordon, Edward, and James search for Thomas, Having Ferdinand be a fatherly figure, and the reason why Thomas has to travel by ship is because the Vicarstown bridge is broken in its up position.

[@BlakeRichardson-o2g]

I also want to make Thomas more of a likeable protagonist, and make the Logging Locos less annoying, (Making Bash and Dash similar to Bill and Ben and making Ferdinand a fatherly figure.) And maybe give a backstory to how Misty Island was created.

[@nix-i3t]

All right! Thomas's smoke signal was seen! Now the pre-established rescue team which this movie is supposedly structured around finally gets time in the spotlight. Topham: "James, Gordon, and Edward.." Wait wha-

[@Wildcatt1999]

10:12 The only good line of dialogue in this damn movie

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

Correct

[@TracksideManiac]

I am SO glad I'm not the only one who thinks the main theme for Misty Island is just the Pirates of the Caribbean theme

[@ScottishTwinsFan]

“OH MY GOD, what are the odds?” SO FUNNY

[@ScottishTwinsFan]

It is time 4

[@ThomasConductor]

5:04 6:35 8:20 8:47

[@Enterprisingengine93]

That’s…correct

[@teaoftraffic]

how come a movie from THE NITROGEN ERA is worse than every new idea bwuhba introduced well except the walking bridge. that’s worse than misty island rescue.

[@mcnuggwtscreations]

That's right.

[@BigNate5404]

>:(

[@BlakeRichardson-o2g]

Please don't remind me of that bridge.

[@ErdrickFan2006]

Misty Island Rescue is better than All Engines Go.

[@Dinoco400Studios]

Mabey

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Agreed.

[@Mnly27]

Facts

[@edwardo6834]

Agree

[@TankEngineMedia]

I would rather watch any AEG episode or movie than this. At least I won’t be bored out of my mind, plus there are some actually good episodes in AEG

[@TheAdventuresOfJimiJaden]

I finally rewatched this, it IS worse than I remember. It was just bizarre for me, CGI Thomas kinda felt like a fever dream.

[@TheAdventuresOfJimiJaden]

Diesel’s voice is basically just Larry’s voice with a UK accent, I would love to see a Gumball UK dub.

[@ShaneC-kx6sv]

10:12 the biggest highlight of this movie

[@BlueSpino4472]

Take a shot for every time Sam says “wHaT ArE tHe OdDs?!?” XD

[@kevin-2.1]

The logging loco’s are not only crazy, but they’re railway is unsafe. The lumber zip line & the shake, shake bridge. As for the giant log tunnel, is kinda cool. Like I know it’s weird that someone would make that giant log into a tunnel, but looks creative to me. Also how did Whiff know about that tunnel that was right next to the search and rescue center? He haven’t been on the island that long? Also where is all the other Jobi wood at, it just disappeared and left with only three flatbeds full?

[@eggmanishere]

THATS RIGHT!

[@stuartbarclay7940]

To me, the film is on the levels of bad, meh, and decent. The rhythming is pretty bad. The Logging Locos are a little overhated. The chase scene with Thomas and Diesel was rather cool. The Fat Controller's line to Thomas is so wholesome. The final scene just after end credits was something that really took me off guard! So overall, MIR is not the best movie, but I wouldn't say that it's the worst (As I can think of a certain movie that is WAY worse... *Cough-Cough* BWBA...) How I Would Improve MIR: 1. Thomas' role is replaced with Fergus, Whiff's role is replaced with Glynn and Percy's role is replaced with Bill & Ben. 2. The Whole Movie is in the style of S5 and TATMR. 3. Ferdinand acts more like a father figure towards Bash and Dash. 4. Misty Island used to be a part of Sodor, however, during World War 1, the island got cut off from the rest of the world. 5. The controller of the Logging Locos is someone who doesn't really care much for safety. 6. We get a flashback on how the Logging Locos came to the island. 7. The only people, aside from the engine crews, who live on Misty Island are the staff, the townspeople and the Lumberjacks who all live in fear of the controller. 8. The Logging Locos and people all escape to Sodor with Fergus, Glynn, Bill and Ben. 9. After the Misty Island controller is arrested, the line leading to Misty Island is ripped up and the tunnel is boarded up. 10. The Fat Controller buys the Logging Locos and assigns them to work in Henry's Forest with Henry.

[@lucasm22]

Thanks for fixing the problem

[@ellavator3396]

I hope you do every thomas movie (especially the miller ones), this was hilarious!

[@wilsonmichael655]

The only thing I like from this movie is the Misty Island song as much as I hate to admit it,that song is too catchy to me

[@mcnuggwtscreations]

shake shake, make me quake...

[@DashkinsPreciousTigerUwU69]

Make me quake, until I shake! >w

[@SammySesame]

YIPPEE!!

[@TracksideStudios06]

taking a shot for every inconsistency

[@Engine9824]

Enjoy your hangover.

[@cdyvids22]

So I'm not the only one to notice whiff and percy turned around

[@Splendid_Studios]

This is definitely the worst Thomas movie

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@TheGingerEngine]

Great video my friend, well done ☺️🚂🚃

[@garrettthesmallengine4675]

“Oh my god, what are the odds!” “It’s time for me to get some screen time to justify my toys!!” lmao 🤣 also “Didn’t it show on the rest of the island too?” Great video Sam! I think a lot of us would like to rewrite this movie, it definitely needs a rewrite

[@matthewpowell2429]

The only thing I like about this movie is the idea of Dash, Bash, & Ferdinand as new characters. I'm currently trying to give them better personalities in my head canon.

[@heavyrailz]

Good ideas, bad execution This and sonic 06 in a nutshell

[@matthewpowell2429]

@@heavyrailz Agreed

[@Danominator]

Misty Island should've stayed lost tbh

[@harrisonallen651]

The movie still hasn’t aged well despite entering puberty this year

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@azuma892]

I ADORE this as a kid.

[@kyeoconnorred1423]

Your reaction to this movie makes it more enjoyable

[@eggmanishere]

Ferdinand is the best character to ever exist

[@DashkinsPreciousTigerUwU69]

UwU

[@CTTE06]

Misty Island Rescue will forever be the worst Thomas Film.

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@meciomontoya8440]

@CTTE06 bwba is worse than misty island rescue

[@CTTE06]

My opinion will never change btw.

[@heavyrailz]

@@CTTE06 famous last words

[@andydoms2001]

9 year old me was an idiot for not realizing how stupid this era of the show was.

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@MikeTotalDrama17]

Imo I used to like this movie as a kid I never understands the hate but as I'm now 17 years old and seeing it again, I fully understand like this movie is insulting! What the hell were they thinking? Changing almost every character from extremely likeable to extremely unlikeable, including the Logging Locos, especially I hate Ferdinand the most for his infamous quote "That's right!" That quote is so annoying! Thomas was also unlikeable!

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than AEG

[@MikeTotalDrama17]

@@heavyrailz true

[@meciomontoya8440]

I still can't believe I used to like this movie i was so shocked

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@amyrodgers4252]

If anything, Misty Island Rescue will always be better than All Engines Go. At least they all ACTED like trains in this movie.

[@FamilyEntertainmentStudios]

SamTheTrainFan Really Should Be A Comedian

[@heavyrailz]

ha ha

[@joegamer08productions]

I agree, but the song is a banger at the end-

[@traintrack3761]

Very good! Could you do Day Of The Diesels one day?

[@callum110597]

I honestly thought I'd enjoy the movie when I eventually saw it in 2015, but I was wrong. God, it's so boring, the rhyming is everywhere, Thomas is racist to Diesel, the Fat Controller takes three of his engines on a boat to Misty Island Rescue, so many problems! 😫 But great take anyway, Sam.

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@thawkade]

​​@@heavyrailzI don't even like AEG, but like, no it isn't lmao. Nitrogen stuff may be technically closer to what Thomas "is" compared to AEG but in terms of enjoyability it is so so _so_ much worse. AEG is perfectly fine as a kids show disconnected from the franchise, Nitrogen Thomas and MIR aren't good as Thomas media, and also aren't good as their own thing.

[@heavyrailz]

@@thawkade so we're just gonna pretend HOTR, tickled pink, BMM and others I could mention but natm didn't impress? you see why your fandom (and franchise) is losing popularity ?

[@thawkade]

@@heavyrailz When I said "Nitrogen stuff" and implied it was bad, it doesn't take much thought to realize that those were probably excluded. Since it evidently has spelled out, obviously yes, HoTR and BMM are great, but like, a few gems in a bad spot doesn't negate the fact the majority is still awful lmao. Mind you I haven't watched very much of AEG or even BWBA, I just think that the former is overall better quality media than most of the Miller era content in which I HAVE seen all of it at least once. AEG is a decent pretty standard kids show, and a bad Thomas show. Most (since I have to preface with this apparently) Nitrogen stuff is an awful and repetitive kids show, while simultaneously being a bad Thomas show as well. Regardless, this is all subjective and my own personal opinion so you don't have to reply with vaguely inflammatory responses that insuiate that it's somehow _my_ fault that the series is bad now because I personally think that one thing (which I still don't like btw) is better than another thing.

[@heavyrailz]

@@thawkade less so fans themselves ruining things and more so attitudes ruining things

[@Toysonicandfriends2]

At least this isn’t garage engine go

[@NitroIndigo]

I wonder what Top Hat would think of the convenient train raft?

[@GP30_Foamer]

The visuals are pretty good, especially the opening credits, but the rest is absolute trash

[@fairlyoddenginecreations]

DOTD next please, that one is much MUCH worse imo

[@mcnuggwtscreations]

I disagree but I respect your opinion.

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

I think Misty Island is worse, but Day of the Diesels is still terrible

[@RailRocketRicky]

Misty Island Rescue is certainly by far the worst Thomas & Friends movie with all of the stupid repetitive rhyming, which (annoyingly) went on throughout the Sharon Miller Era. However, the return of Diesel 10 at the very end of the movie was certainly a cliff-hanger!

[@TheLazyFusspot_3428]

And they effed up the premise in the next installment

[@heavyrailz]

@@TheLazyFusspot_3428still better than aeg

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@Razer_-fe9mo]

I didn't know Jobi Wood isn't real till I watched this video. I now feel incredibly stupid.

[@Ryder-a-Blaze]

Thomas is such a racist

[@fishpop]

If this was a discussion video then i would've watched it. But it's a watchalong and i don't want to be put through the cringe of this special.

[@SamTheTrainFan]

There’s not much worth discussing here!

[@fishpop]

@@SamTheTrainFan Fair point, this special is just awful.

[@Trainboy56team]

Uh no misty island is not the worst movie

[@Ninja11125]

Always has been

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg

[@NikoBellicDigital]

This is probably the worst Thomas special I've ever seen. The rhyming is at its worst, its moral is racist and insulting, every decision made in this film is as dumb as they get, the new characters are laughable, the voice acting and narration in both dubs are terrible, and the whole concept of the film and reasoning for its existence is absolutely abysmal. I do admit the animation was fantastic for its time, and I really love Topham's one liner at the end of the movie, but that's about it. Bottom of the list for me.

[@heavyrailz]

AEG: welcome to the death of your brain

[@levidarling5107]

I feel sorry for anyone who watches this and day of the diesels.

[@AtkataffTheAlpha]

So the real life basis of all the logging locos are slow. How the world are they going the speed of a conventional engine?!

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

Misty Island is still better than The Angry Birds Movie 2 (So what if it’s unrelated to this video, and so what if I always rant about that movie. The first Angry Birds Movie is miles better. Hell, I’d rather watch All Engines Go than watch The Angry Birds Movie 2.)

[@heavyrailz]

I take all three over fnaf

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

@@heavyrailzI actually like FNaF (Can’t say the same about the movie because I haven’t seen it.) at least the FNaF movie is faithful to the source. The Angry Birds Movie 2 is just a big fat middle finger to everything that came before, with a horrendous villain “redemption arc” too, and more character assassination than everything in the BWBA and Miller Eras COMBINED!

[@heavyrailz]

@@IsleofPigsStudios did you just contradict yourself? I'm sorry but the context, popularity and (how the previous one is still going after this I have no idea but it's unbelievable ) political choices from the… monster behind it are cringe

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

@@heavyrailzI said I liked FNaF (The Franchise) but because I haven’t seen FNaF (The Movie) I literally couldn’t have an opinion. Besides, The Angry Birds Movie 2 exists and it is steaming hot garbage

[@IsleofPigsStudios]

The Angry Birds Movie 2 is also cringe, with the whole Baby Shark Shit (I am allowed to swear here, the original video has swearing)

[@dinosandtrains909]

Watch this get coppaed

[@DodotheWishFanboy]

👍

[@DashkinsPreciousTigerUwU69]

Ó-Ò

[@NitroIndigo]

Is it just me, or do the engine's pupils move really quickly in Nitrogen's animation?

[@GregoryAmicar57]

I'm sorry but I disagree with you due to the toxicness the fandom has become

[@ABellEngine]

How does the "toxicness" relate to the video?

[@ToastTheThe]

@@ABellEngine fr

[@DashkinsPreciousTigerUwU69]

I'm guessin' since th' fandom thinks nae one can hae a positive opinion oan MIR... I agree with Gregory... Misty Island Rescue is ov'rhated...

[@ABellEngine]

@@DashkinsPreciousTigerUwU69 Who says no one can have an opinion on a movie? If people don't like a movie, then they don't like a movie. Simple as.

[@DashkinsPreciousTigerUwU69]

@@ABellEngine I'm juist sayin' th' majority o' th' fandom really sees MIR negatively, thit whin someone actually says a positive opinion o' th' movie, then ev'ryone gets mad... I've seen 'n' experienced this before...

[@johnarnehansen9574]

Why not add Ukrainian and Russian subtitles to this video?..

[@heavyrailz]

Don't even

[@duckno.8woodenrailway]

THIS MOVIE IS TERRIBLE

[@heavyrailz]

Still better than aeg