Modi implements controversial ‘anti-Muslim’ law in India

On the surface, a new law in India that gives fast track citizenship to minorities in neighbouring countries seems admirable.
But critics say the law has been framed to exclude Muslims leading to fears that it will legitimise harassment and violence against them.
There have been a number of protests across the country, coming just weeks ahead of its general election.

[@fusionquerico]

Muslims got separate state Pakistan. How is CAA anti muslim?

[@shehnazshaikh2736]

Jabhi to inn k autarein hamare muslim ghro me dhona dhote hai

[@subhashb1443]

Kitne din khathe hindustan ka chod do

[@kaliyugasurfer]

Those object caa have similar laws in Their own countries

[@ShivanshuTyagi72981]

The same people cry when we talk about Uniform Civil Code for all religions. This is not rational at all

[@user-db1fn8uc5s]

Jinna devided India and Pakistan on religious ground we welcome c,a,a❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@OnetoZero777]

As an indian I support caa

[@Xy1sto]

Should have said "as a lindu fascist"

[@indianballanimations6734]

@@Xy1sto Sorry we follow democracy and national security [ anti-terrorism] here. You may go to Pakistan or Bangladesh.

[@nish8756]

@@Xy1sto I can imagine what kind of joker you would be

[@Xy1sto]

@@nish8756 I'd be the joker in my life. But you'd forever be an andhbhakt. no doubt!

[@Mahadev_Kaa_Chela_Hu]

​@@Xy1stoNot joker ISI agents Terrerist 😂😂😂

[@prasoonpradap]

Biased reporting

[@arcan762]

Based reporting

[@user-pv2xy1og8h]

We Bharat not listening to hypocriting fake news of Britishers like BBC or Chanel4! Hindustan Times or ANI only! Jai Hind! Jai shree ram!

[@jessynoronha9104]

​@@user-pv2xy1og8hthen why hindus living in UK? All hindus should come to modi' s hindu rashtra😂

[@irfannazir4831]

That is cld godi media fake media

[@vikramvega]

1947: Muslims shouldn't have to live as a minority in India because they will face oppression. We need to create Pakistan (and what became Bangladesh) 2019: Muslims are also facing oppression in Pakistan and Bangladesh. Why doesn't India take them back?

[@AO-xd2ml]

Misleading title. This law gives citizenship to Hindu, Parsi, Buddhist, Jain and Christian refugees fleeing persecution. Most of them are coming from Pakistan or Bangladesh, where their religion is not given equal status under the law.

[@Khubii]

But why not for the Rohingya of Myanmar..I mean Rohingya are most persecuted minority according to Un...Also Myanmar is a neighbouing country of India.

[@rosskrizevac9777]

@@Khubii Rohingya's are not people of Indian origin, this law applies to persons of Indian origin affected by the partition of India. Myanmar was never a part of India.

[@VoteReformUK822]

​@@Khubii the most persecuted religious group is Christians all of which in Islamic countries

[@user-de5xy2rz4y]

​@Khubii this law is for persecuted minorities in the erstwhile territories of India which became Islamic nations by partitioning India. Myanmar was never part of India.

[@hindurashtra63]

@@Khubii Ask this question to Qatar and 56 other Islamic Nations - Why are they not accepting Muslim refuees ? Why push them to Non Muslim countries ? Rohingaya are not our problem, India is not Islamic Nation.

[@user-lc3js8ki4b]

Victim card started as usual 😂

[@artschool673]

No. It is Islamophobia.

[@willythemailboy2]

Muslims are the only ones who play the victim card even more often than Israelis do.

[@ImBatuKumAhhh]

​@@artschool673there's no such word as Islamophobia. Fear against Islam is based.

[@artschool673]

@@ImBatuKumAhhh Facepalm. Massive facepalm

[@joeysal007]

@@artschool673Boring. Come up with something more logical and new

[@vivekacharya3652]

This channel is pro al qaeda

[@cocosworld1868]

I agree.

[@NoOne-tg9tk]

Yes it's a Muslim brotherhood s channel

[@MBBSDoctor-rv5kk]

And All other channels are pro RSS.. NDTV believes in Equality ❤

[@DesignSpringBusiness]

True

[@ankushsingh4262]

They are tie wearing English speaking Jihadists.

[@vegqueen747]

Shame on you Channel 4 for spreading lies!

[@irfannazir4831]

Then godi media is spreading truth hahahahhahahahaahahhah

[@trollface7998]

​@@irfannazir4831yeah Earth is Flat 💯😂

[@vegqueen747]

@@irfannazir4831 you would not have a clue. So biased. Use your intelligence if you have any. Don’t have to listen to any media.

[@cocosworld1868]

Channel 4 has been doing this type of reporting for years. Have a look at some of their Gaza reports the are as bad as Al Jazeera.

[@Ijustfindout]

​@@irfannazir4831there Is Not A Single Channel Which Isn't Purchased By Congress Or BJP In India They Have To Do This Cuz Indian News Channels will Go Bankcurrupt If They Done That Stupid Folks Haa Ha Ha 😂

[@Prasanna-6557]

No one is telling Indian muslims to leave India, than how is it anti-muslim ?

[@tate.daulang]

But gov will decently do this

[@srikanthsv79]

But won't help Muslims that are I'll treated in other nations

[@hamidhamidi3134]

@@srikanthsv79 When Muslims don't leave others to live in peace in Muslim majority nations then someone has to take them in.

[@lifePaultheball]

​@@srikanthsv79 Yeah maybe but that's not our problem. This law is for Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh. Not sure how are muslims facing persecution in islamic countries. If they are they can still come to India and take the longer route of 11 years to gain citizenship

[@srikanthsv79]

@@lifePaultheball why that discrimination though? Aren't you aware people face discrimination within religion itself? Can't you see that example in Hinduism itself?

[@esprit8419]

This peaceful community is offended by everything but ashamed of nothing

[@tennistron588]

you've picked that up from all the anti-zionist comments and now think you are clever using that here?

[@shobhitdagur1086]

​@tennistronFear of Islam is not Islamophobia but common sense

[@tennistron588]

@@shobhitdagur1086 not really, that is the reply of the ignorant and uneducated.

[@unitedhindu403]

​@@tennistron588ha... knowing Aisha was only 6 years at marriage is .. u educational...hm... very nice

[@tabularasa7775]

​@@unitedhindu403Yeah but that doesn't change the fact that 40,000 children were r@ped in India in 2022 alone.

[@Lolllzz..]

Victim journalism.

[@major2707]

Victimcard celebrations 😁

[@mojojojo2524]

In a Hindu country, their laws need to be respected.

[@AlladinMclovin2334]

Hindu is not a religion my man. Who worships stones and cars?.

[@mojojojo2524]

@@AlladinMclovin2334 it’s more of a way of life rather than just believing a set of dogmas, but more or less it’s considered a religion.

[@bat__man__.w]

@@AlladinMclovin2334oh so you mean worship a letter is a religion how can god be shapeless

[@rice4550]

India is secular get that through your thick skull

[@FallenMetsubu1992]

​​@@mojojojo2524 U still can't decide cuz u r so confused as well as u r confusing people at the same time. Sometimes u say its a religion, sometimes u say its a way of life🤨🤨 which one is it? If it's a religion, is worshipping everything u see ur religion?? n if it's a way of life what is ur religion??

[@np2917]

In last 78 years minority in Pakistan drop from 30% to 1.2% Why you people don't report that.... Where this minority people gone from Pakistan and Bangladesh?

[@TSSIII]

Saudi paying them

[@AnthonyNickson-pt8jq]

They fleed to india and living in refugee camps for long time

[@vegqueen747]

@@TSSIII Saudi is trying to progress. Listen to MBS.

[@ronskip]

From 30% to less than 1%.. Pls correct your numbers

[@np2917]

@@ronskip yes you right

[@tmk7832]

Will soudia give Hindus citizenship??😂

[@rahul0898]

Even Saudi don't give citizenship to muslim 😂😂

[@knowledgetechnology2286]

Dungeating at its peak

[@Libyan_Tripoli]

They do so stop lying ​@@rahul0898

[@wretfsfvd]

@@Libyan_Tripoli india also give citizenship, if they merry a Indian citizen's (exclude Pakistani)

[@dr.strange8735]

Does Saudi has 20 crore hindu c০w w০rshippers?

[@Jennyeq]

We need the same in England.... the preferential treatment given to muslims in the UK needs to end.

[@ASH9366]

Yes 👍

[@wjumeau]

Agreed… Sick and tired of the ANGLOPHOBIA …..

[@Tigerlily242]

Then stop colonizing countries

[@user-de5xy2rz4y]

It is not about giving preferential treatment. Muslim refugees can continue to apply for and get citizenship by normal methods with documentation This particular law is only to help religious minorities facing persecution in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan which were historically part of India and became Islamic nations. Not all minorities in these countries could migrate to India in 1947. However that doesn't mean their next generations will not be able to. However the law should also apply to ex Muslims, agnostics and lgbtq communities who face most persecution in Islamic lands

[@izayoi-cx8mr]

Yes

[@yte549]

Propaganda West... You are not the boss anymore

[@RAHULKUMAR-wn7hl]

Channel 4 is pro Muslim☪️️ channel

[@skywalker8940]

True

[@zw9802]

that's a fact.

[@Shrav-sj2cv]

Funded by qatar and other middle East countries

[@ikmz6951]

A good channel

[@e.t.ethics1771]

Pakistan instituted an anti-HIndu law a long time ago. What about that? How about Saudi Arabia? Other Islamic nations? Pakistan was carved out of India so that the Indian Muslims would have their own nation; which they did and made it an Islamic State. India has the right to protect and nurture it's original culture and religion. Also, India's population is out of control. In fact, there has to be controls on the population.

[@TSSIII]

They call it spreading their religion

[@carkawalakhatulistiwa]

Saudi is a kingdom, not a democracy. that's why no one protested.

[@HM-rz8nv]

If your whole argument is "what about X, Y or Z" country, you've already lost, because you aren't making a logically coherent argument that suggest that this decision has anything to do with fairness, justice or ethics, and directly advocate for oppressing religious groups if you believe another country also oppresses religious groups. this is completely 1d!0tic reasoning.

[@sovonnaskar268]

​@@carkawalakhatulistiwastay calm and don't complain then 😊

[@artschool673]

You're basically justifying xenophobia. Just because others make mistakes does not mean you have to make them too.

[@user-bw1ls3zj1u]

This showing jealousy of foreign towards India 😅

[@DalitisHebrewnotHindu]

Their colonial hangover !!

[@iracture]

exactly only Christians and Muslims apparently can get good things. If anyone helps a hindu it is called as anti-muslim. What kind of sick mentality is this. Boycott all media houses that publish this rubbish approach.

[@major2707]

Anyway religious people don't care about so called secularism 😏

[@rice4550]

Yeah man exposing discriminatory laws makes channel 4 sooooo jealous doesn’t it

[@DalitisHebrewnotHindu]

@@rice4550 +. your interpretation of discrimination and discriminatory laws is a mirror image of who you are . Your Abrahamic colonial empires who until today pretend to be peaceful on the surface but are anything but behind the curtain

[@epicroyal01]

Biased report, CAA is simply to provide faster citizenship to oppressed minorities from Pakistan, Afganistan and Bangladesh. Please correct yourself

[@weswheel4834]

Did they invent the document that they quoted from?

[@greathey1234]

Smelly 😂

[@socspmiala]

​@@greathey1234 the only thing that smells is your rotten unused brain. fix that.

[@baibhab_k]

@@greathey1234like your moms 🐱

[@nish8756]

These jokers don’t read the law but love to make comments

[@VoteReformUK822]

So you lot are bothered that India wants to rescue persecuted people But not bothered that all other religions in those neighbouring countries are persecuted

[@artschool673]

Two wrongs don't make a right. If you single out a particular group, you're being xenophobic which is being pretty dumb, since there are 200 M Muslims in India.

[@VoteReformUK822]

@@artschool673 and yet this isn't about those in India it's about rescuing those outside India do you even know what this is about? rescuing persecuted minorities from NEIGHBOURING countries

[@shobhitdagur1086]

​@@artschool673That group has already given two Islamic nations which are bankrupt now

[@artschool673]

@@VoteReformUK822 And singling out a specific group. Xenophobia.

[@artschool673]

@@LiberalsTakingLs I might have done that in a video about Pakistan, don't you think? Perhaps I could come here and talk about the Oscars...

[@kampunia1617]

How dare you say.this how are minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh treated why dont you focussing on that

[@user-pv2xy1og8h]

We Bharat not listening to hypocriting fake news of Britishers like BBC or Chanel4! Hindustan Times or ANI only! Jai Hind! Jai shree ram!

[@detectivesroy]

Ab nass pakdoge to chillaenge hi

[@major2707]

​@@user-pv2xy1og8hjai bharat 🙂

[@rice4550]

So Pakistan discriminates against minorities therefore india must also what sort of sewer logic is that

[@kalaasmna9116]

​@@rice4550your logic is sewer,not ours. Pakistan and Bangladesh is singling out certain communities,so we give them shelter. Muslims dont have problems in those countries,so why should they come as refugees? Also,if a Hindu or a Sikh or a Buddhist wants to go take refuge in a country,no country except India would accept them,because all other neighbouring countries are islamic and don't accept those "kafirs"

[@zkykmxgj7490]

The likes of Channel 4 News and all other western media houses should stop interfering with India's internal policies ....Besides here's the new confident Islamic front: The recent coming together of the Islamic nations and Muslims staging world wide protests over the plight of Palestinians show a new found confidence they can rely on each other for protection and thus, will not consider India as a destination for protection.

[@pallascat1743]

It's reporting on them not 'interfering'.

[@DoubleDogDare54]

Smart move on the part of India. Just look what happened to other countries that took in Muslim "refugees". You don't want to repeat what happened in those cases.

[@IronThreads9]

Germany assimilated over a million and is doing fine. Maybe countries shouldn't treat them like undesirables and help them to socially integrate.

[@tda7294]

​@@IronThreads9 let Germany take Rohingya refugees 😊

[@DoubleDogDare54]

@@IronThreads9 I seem to remember over a thousand German women being assaulted by some of those fine, assimilated, socially integrated newcomers on New Years Eve a few years back across 10 cities, particularly in Cologne. Cops did nothing, there were few arrests and nothing much was done to those that were arrested. Four convictions, light sentences and those were suspended. Good times in Germany with their ME guests.

[@urrasscal8380]

damage already done ... not doing population xchange in 47' partition was a huge mistake from iindian side.

[@Themystery321]

​@@IronThreads9why do so much effort for these people who will kill u in a second? These people are not worth the effort. Just ignore them till the ideology dies

[@Samurai-ke5ie]

All the Muslims majority countries have similar or even worse citizenship law so what’s the big deal ?

[@greathey1234]

UAE? 😂

[@weswheel4834]

Are you saying that we should model our laws on those of "all the Muslim majority countries"?

[@KumarK-cn1sj]

@@weswheel4834 Are you Indian ?

[@weswheel4834]

@@KumarK-cn1sj You're right. I should have said "Are you saying that your country should model its laws on "all Muslim majority countries"? You seem to be saying so.

[@k45rt789jh]

@weswheel “ Our “ laws ?! In India I don’t think we have “Our” laws . There are certainly laws that make particular sections “ Special “ . So ya, there are no “ Our” laws .

[@chriser555]

India gives hope to other countries 🙏

[@SaccoMabowles]

Finish kindergarten and stop being so angry about having a tiny thingy.

[@hosaipopal1872]

@@SaccoMabowles😂😂😂

[@quwipyui6519]

true Islam should be out from UK

[@SaccoMabowles]

@@quwipyui6519 you wouldn't feel that way if you had self confidence, son.

[@ShivanshuTyagi72981]

Well the dp is good😂😂😂

[@ankitsoni1811]

Jealousy leads to lie reporting.

[@sdatta123]

Indian Central Govt should take steps against fake news like this one. Please report this content as "Spam or misleading".

[@sumit.halder]

No it should be reported as Hateful and abusive 😂

[@biscuits.cookies]

Done

[@priyankakumarisingh4511]

already did

[@amon5124]

CCA is a law to provide legal rights to live in India to religiously prosecuted minorities in India’s neighbouring Muslim countries who entered India before 2015 to avoid further prosecution. It is not religion but humanity driven law as these prosecuted people are human being also. Please have some sympathy towards the suffering of human being and human life. Thank you.

[@Vishalkumar_h]

Human rights will also be applicable to other countries too. Why not raise their voice for them? Is human rights applicable to one particular religion?

[@amon5124]

@@Vishalkumar_h In this case, the protection extends to any minority religion Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, Jain, Parsi and Christians - again a humanitarian angle - religion agnostic. Please read the law. Thank you.

[@happyvalleyroses8145]

India is already the most populated country… how will the new immigrants be integrated without proper planning…. won’t border states like Assam suffer a lot? India isn’t really in a position to accommodate more people…. Anyway, I hope the people are given states according to their forefathers… most should go to UP, Punjab….and Bengal

[@amon5124]

@@happyvalleyroses8145 These people are already in India mate. They are just stateless victims of Nehru and Gandhi’s failure. It is not a crime to be born as non-Muslim in the subcontinent - I hope. I respect Islam. I have many Arab friends and they are lovely people and respect non-Islamic religions.

[@happyvalleyroses8145]

@@amon5124 they can be integrated according to their forefathers’ states. Overlooking everything else, they cannot be cramped into border states esp Bangladeshi immigrants to north eastern states. They can go to Bengal.

[@PongTV_]

Free india from ISLAM

[@user-rx2gf4nx9e]

Free the world from Islam!

[@deepanshunegi8742]

Free India from both Muslims and Hindu bakhts

[@udayanbaruah1512]

Dont Spread Lies ....CAA is nothing to do with Muslim... We Support CAA .. From. Assam... Jai Hind ... 🌏🌏🕉️🕉️🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@johnohara197]

Good for India! Supporting you from Ireland! ☘

[@patriciareid1159]

It's not anti-Muslim, anti illegal immigration. But anyway India root is Hindu .

[@user-pv2xy1og8h]

We Bharat not listening to hypocriting fake news of Britishers like BBC or Chanel4! Hindustan Times or ANI only! Jai Hind! Jai shree ram!

[@deepanshunegi8742]

no India is a land country, not a religion

[@patriciareid1159]

@@deepanshunegi8742 Hindu born in India and been embraced it's culture values by kingdom/empire or dynasty. Kuru kingdom 1200 BCE, Anga kingdom 1100 BCE etc. Please read your owned Historical root of culture, except in the past before Islam took over your India never been in the reign power governments exist, only tribes and jungle life.

[@deepanshunegi8742]

@@patriciareid1159 Then Hindu people should be welcoming to Islamic people, in our culture we are taught to welcome others then why arent we?

[@patriciareid1159]

@@deepanshunegi8742 They did historically .. before they discover that Islamic people got a duty to jihad applying ideology to conquer the world under one rule and change all the cultures values. It's very clear to me , Islam is not a religion, but politic ideology wrapped by you call a religion.

[@harendrathankey788]

Get your facts right. It has nothing to do with Muslims. ,and not anti Muslims. Stop propagandas

[@satsatdown]

Why doesn't the news report the persecution of minorities form neighbouring countries that are fleeing to India? Forced conversions and blasphemy laws are the norm in neighbouring countries. Muslims thrive and are an integral part of India, do you see any Muslims wanting to leave India for Pakistan?

[@AyamAyam-tx7xu]

Kuch mahina phele aik admi apna beta ka sath Pakistan shift howa edhi centre mein India chor kar kyo ka usse marna dhamki de police nah aur politicians nah kyo ka wo aik saysat dan tha

[@spudspuddy]

yes, millions of them are flooding into europe and causing huge problems

[@priyankakumarisingh4511]

@@AyamAyam-tx7xu Then please bring CAA for muslims of india🥲 I bet zero muslims will migrate😂

[@satsatdown]

@@priyankakumarisingh4511 exactly

[@anshurawat6320]

Yepp pak should bring CAA too for these Muslims.​@@AyamAyam-tx7xu

[@Gamer-zv4xd]

It's ammendment only for oppressed minorities of neighbouring countries not for majority Muslims who oppressed minorities

[@RedBot-fv7lb]

exactly!!!!!!

[@freddymercury2259]

That would be a valid point if the current gov didn't oppress the minorities in their own country as well.

[@ABESAALE]

​@@freddymercury2259Show me where it oppressed??

[@thecooked8121]

​@@ABESAALEthat's what it's really doing right now

[@freddymercury2259]

@@ABESAALE labelling farmers as terrorists, forcing Punjabis to only teach hindi in schools, censoring the media, trying to convert Sikhs, jains and Buddhist to Hinduism, by erasing and misrepresenting thier history with pro-hindu propaganda... Should I go on?

[@partharoy9161]

The law is not anti-muslim. Non-muslims are tortured in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan. India is the only country for Hindus and Sikhs where they can go. India was divided in 1947 on the basis of religion. CAA or, NRC do not kicking out any Indian Muslims out of India. India is the mother land of Indian Muslims. They have every right to stay in India. They are contributing to India's growth. Evert Indians respect Dr. Abdul Kalam, irrespective of their cast and religion. Every Indian loves Sharukh Khan, Salman Khan, and Amir Khan. Every Indian feel proud for Indian Army soldier Abdul Hamid or Auragazeb. Mohamad Sami is the backbone of Indian Cricket team's pace attack. INDIA is blessed by Lord Siva, Allah, Guru Nanak, Jesus Christ, Lord Budha, and Mahabeer. India is the only country in the world that is blessed by all the gods.

[@mirzadanishbaig7418]

Sir the problem is NRC when an Indian Muslim can't prove his citizenship with legal documents he is sent to refugee camps whereas Other religions who can't prove their citizenship they can still get in via CAA this is the problem the BJP government is Islamophobic they follow the idealogy of Hardcore Hindutva movement which States India is only for Hindus and Muslims are second class citizens of India

[@user-to8yg2yz8d]

Leading University, what a joke.

[@major2707]

Western liberals joke 😁

[@rice4550]

Of course education isn’t popular with you lot

[@stephenmurray8559]

I wish Britain had this law

[@major2707]

Majority of British people interested in securalism

[@rice4550]

Don’t like Muslims here do you Stephen that’s alright you should move to india where they share your sentiments

[@real_MacrocosM]

Good. Common sense is starting to prevail...

[@rohangupta5126]

There are 57 muslim countries they should provide citizenship to Rohingyas, Palestinians and others. We are a secular country and protect minorities of some so called Muslim nations.

[@vegqueen747]

All the interviewees and presenter raise your voice regarding the Hindus, Sikhs and Christians being decimated in certain Islamic nations. This move will keep at least some of them safe.

[@ASH9366]

We love dictator Modi 🔥💯🔥

[@GayathriK-re7wt]

​@@aladnan5757So go to central asia or turkey 🦃

[@deepanshunegi8742]

@@GayathriK-re7wt India is a country, not religion, India has both hindu temples and mughals

[@sharath6689]

@@deepanshunegi8742 Nehru and Gandhi decided that not Indians

[@MrMurugesan]

CAA is not an Anti-Muslim law, INDIA is offering citizenship to an asylum seekers of minority people from PAKISTAN,BANGLADESH and AFGHANISTAN

[@johnyas5327]

Ok but what this normal indians standing against for...and why they r fighting with government for what....plz, explain everything.....about this topic....i want to know....😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@NitishSingh-si6xs]

​​By this law ,hindus , christian, Buddhists,jains,jews,sikhs nd other non Muslim people can get citizenship in india... Afganistan,pakistan, Bangladesh were they kill minorities, minorities get no rights there....in 1947 there were 27% hindus in pakistan now pakistan have less than 1% hindus ...same with Bangladesh....afg....This laws doesn't effect any indian Muslim because they are already citizen of india....but other illegal immigrant( Muslim )who came here after 1950 will leave INDIA....a@@johnyas5327

[@MrMurugesan]

@@johnyas5327 opposition party and their supporter blindly opposing the new law which is baseless.

[@user-pv3pz4od3h]

Thank you for remembering and protecting the Christians!

[@aryanraina700]

Our war is against Muslims. We love the Christians here❤

[@sonucherian7559]

Calling this "anti-Muslim" is quite disingenuous if you consider the content and context of this law. The condition of religious minorities, especially women from these communities in the neighboring state is incredibly dire. All this law does is fast track the immigration of these minorities who moved to India before 2014. In my opinion, that is literally a bare minimum.

[@berniv7375]

It is quite clearly anti-Muslim in any context. This is not the way forward for India. Only bad things will come from this legislation.

[@weswheel4834]

It's Modi playing to the gallery. It implies that all Muslims are oppressors, all non-Muslims are oppressed. Ironically the law proves otherwise.

[@crazyrobert2472]

@@berniv7375lol Muslims are lawless wherever they are

[@sonucherian7559]

@@berniv7375 what are "bad things" that come with fast tracking and prioritizing immigration of vulnerable minorities from historic India? Please do tell

[@AO-xd2ml]

@@berniv7375 You are incorrect. Pakistan and Bangladesh are the parts of India that became declared Islamic nations. This is to give citizenship to persecuted Hindus, Christians, Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs who were left behind in those countries. Simple.

[@ThePenguin30]

Some context: this law speeds up the citizenship for minorities fleeing from persecution in Muslim countries such as Pakistan or Afghanistan. Why would there be Muslim refugees who've faced persecution from a Muslim country? And the law doesn't mention other religions such Judaism or other religions, does that make India ant-jew? Biased reporting as always.

[@Lolllzz..]

Why are you sending people from ravanda back, Europe problem is world problem and world problem is not Europe problem 😎

[@MoviClip-hl9lk]

I am not from India but i respect india for this law❤🎉

[@iamrobot396]

Much needed law. Minorities have almost been eliminated in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Maybe channel 4 should look into minority persecution in these countries

[@abc_cba]

Look at the condition of Christians in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh and tell me how is this bill against Muslims when it provisions to facilitate Christians to have citizenship as asylum seekers in India? Also, tell me if these are Muslim majority states, why would they feel the need to be in India after the partition? Also, tell me about the last census of Jordan where Christians were less than 2% of the population in 2021 from 5% in 2011 and being 20% in 2000? How did Turkiye have no Christians, the lace where Antioch and Constantinople were, the birthplace of Orthodox Christianity! Also, tell how Coptic Christians of Egypt, Maronite Catholics of Lebanon, Syriac Christians of Syria, Chaldean Christians of Iraq - how are they almost down to be nothing more than to vanish? Just like they did for Arab Christians of Najran and Jubail (Saudi Arabia), Baharna (Baharain) and Beth Qatarye (Qatar)?

[@m.sgamingm.sgaming9897]

And how did all these countries whom you are talking about were Christian? Why arab and Egyptians and the birth places of Christianity become Christian majority ? Who Christian reach India and Pakistan? Why majority of Africa is Christian? Who European whom were tribals become Christian? Whose gonna answer this? Who did Americas and Australia and Canada etc which were not even known to the world till 13th 14th century become Christian? 😂😂

[@abc_cba]

@@m.sgamingm.sgaming9897 1) you clearly don't know about Western and Eastern Christianity. All the places I talked about are Eastern centers and they're Orthodox (meaning, they don't convert followers, but if someone wants to enter into their religion, they allow that). 2) Talking about America and Australia, I don't care, because they're to be answered by Europeans, who went there not by me, I do not have European background, nor am I a Western Christian. Not sure how is your comment countering my OP comment above? Then I checked your profile picture and came to find out that you're from the Muslim faith, so then it was understood. This video is on an international forum and it was duty as an Indian to dispel the myth and rumor, so, that people know what's the fact. Kindly, be informed that it's my Freedom of Speech and Expression that I'm exercising.

[@romeob.8369]

As a Bengali Christian, I was not a fan of the BJP, but Modi got my vote for implementing CAA. Thank you, Modi 🙏Down with the Islamists and Far-Left 🤛

[@lifePaultheball]

​@@abc_cba Thank God Me too a Bengali. I am glad you understood it. I was so left till probably 2018. Suddenly my opinion changed.

[@abc_cba]

@@lifePaultheball I am not left or right. I am not in favor of BJP since, they're overdoing a lot of things lately. But I am in favor of them on this stance of CAA.

[@user-rx2gf4nx9e]

LONG LIVE INDIA! LONG LIVE MODI THE GREAT!🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺

[@felixyoghurt3291]

Modi needs to go to UK and teach them how to deal with the *religion of peace*

[@wft15]

@@felixyoghurt3291please! Rishis useless.

[@deepanshunegi8742]

modi the great 🤣

[@sharath6689]

@@deepanshunegi8742 u are ka2 we in fake bot

[@sararahul3140]

The law which is being talked about does not concern muslims in any particular manner. The law is to give citizenship to the minorities who are persecuted in countries like Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh. Muslims are not given a space in this law as they already have a lot of countries to go to. The western and international media should stop their propoganda against the present Indian government.

[@phoque121]

Why wouldn't India want more religion of peace?? I cannot think of 1 reason 😨😨😨

[@felixyoghurt3291]

Nobody can, world wide vile religion

[@internationalnewsandentert5404]

Wohi to pak Bangladesh afgan to mila hai inko phir bhi

[@shobhitdagur1086]

​@user-om7ou9fx1bit's synonymous to Islam

[@daveray5655]

So India is giving people who suffered religious persecution in countries known for religious tolerance refugee status? There is literally nothing wrong with that.

[@Judah_889]

This critics says that india is descriminating muslims Just because india will provide citizenship to minorities of Pakistan Afghanistan and Bangladesh. Any muslims from those country if seeking citizenship can live in india for eleven years and then opt for indian citizenship like the Pakistani singer Adnan Sami lived in india for 11 years and then became indian citizen. God knows from which angle this is anti muslim when Afghanistan Pakistan Bangladesh are officially Muslim country whose constitution starts with the verses of qoran

[@deepakhada1553]

How is it anti Muslim when it doesn’t concern Muslims at all? Way to go for unbiased reporting😂

[@jprasad.]

Shame on you channel 4 for misleading headlines .How this law anti-musllim .pls explain??

[@jumpingfrog4323]

Sheltering minorities from nearby countries is already a good deed. London is already out of hands. UK should look out for sharia law. It's not a question of if but when.

[@BigBoiiLeem]

Shut up, you know for a fact that Sharia Law in the United Kingdom is an absolute joke that could never and would never happen. Aside from the fact that the UK's constitution is deeply intertwined with the Church of England, it is just patently ridiculous to think of measures of Sharia law passing through both houses of Parliament, the courts, and the monarchy without someone saying "hold fire on that one, chief".

[@wjumeau]

It’s already in my Chinese takeaway believe it or not. A certificate on the wall saying all meat is sourced from a Halal source and slaughtered in accordance with Sharia Law. Haven’t told them yet that I was a customer for decades and currently boycotting them, because I don’t think they would get it…. The thing is most of the customers aren’t Muslim….

[@SurendraYadav-ov1mu]

Channel 4 News is an anti-Indian News Channel. Don't give wrong interpretation of CAA. This law is very beneficiary for India.

[@moholah3745]

O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends; they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people. Quran 5:51

[@al3zmi]

@@moholah3745 you must understand the context of this verse. . The outcome of the conflict in Arabia between Islam and unbelief (kufr) had not crystallised. Although Islam had become a formidable force owing to the daring, courage and sacrifices of its followers, the forces opposed to it were also tremendously powerful. To an objective observer it must have seemed that either party had an equal chance of success, and so the hypocrites, apparently an integral part of the Muslim body politic, sought to maintain good relations with the Jews and the. Christians as well. They expected refuge and protection from the Jews in case Islam was defeated. Moreover, the Jews and Christians held the greatest economic power in Arabia insofar as the banking system and the greenest and most fertile regions of Arabia were in their possession. For these reasons the hypocrites were keen to maintain good relations with them: they thought that to regard the conflict between Islam and unbelief as crucially important, and to sever their relations with all those currently in conflict with Islam, would be too great a risk both politically and economically. short answer: hypocrisy of some of the Muslims who do not believe or faith in their own people and God.

[@shobhitdagur1086]

​@@al3zmiSo why this channel is crying for a kufr nation India and not leading by example of hizrat

[@al3zmi]

@@shobhitdagur1086 because it shows the hypocrisy of Indian government... They claim to be Socialist Secular Democratic when they deal with Arabs or the West. Religion shouldn't matter when people escape discrimination. Hatred and death. India is not allowing Rohingya after they suffered genocide within their country. Instead, they were accepted in Bangladesh even though India should have accepted because of U.N agreement

[@moholah3745]

@@al3zmi The Jews say, “Ezra is the son of Allah,” while the Christians say, “The Messiah is the son of Allah.” Such are their baseless assertions, only parroting the words of earlier disbelievers. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺? Quran 9:30

[@user-ur9zn3gp5n]

The Muslims got Pakistan and bangladesh for their belief if they don't like the new Bill they can go to pakistan bangladesh where there are more people of the same beliefs.

[@baibhab_k]

India will be a safer place now.

[@JamesSmith-qs4hx]

Why can't we do this in Britain.... seems pretty based❤

[@aidonger42069]

Seems pretty xenophobic to me, if you want Britain to be more like India in this case than I’m willing to bet your in the minority

[@Granty_lad55]

I’ll take that bet

[@mwd331]

You’d like anti Muslim, Hindu nationalist policies in the UK? Or the alternative is that you are a simpleton I suppose..

[@DeepChand-qp9tl]

U just wait how modi give citizenship to all religion except puslim 😂😂 , and we fully support 💪 MODI

[@sonucherian7559]

​@aidonger42069 Islam is not a race nor a nationality. It is an ideology with followers, and thus any criticism of the merit of the ideology or its effects on society is not xenophobic or racist.

[@jiminseuk2730]

In this era who is real culprit? Media this types of media fuel riots

[@shantanushukla8023]

Please document the conditions and atrocities on minorities in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan. CAA is for minorities. Killing people in the name of a specific religion is humanity?? 😡😡😡😡😡😡Answer me @Channel 4 News????

[@sirjohnpiraan1662]

How can you be so racist by accusing India of this? Have you read the entire CAA act Channel 4 ? Afghanistan,Pakistan,Bangladesh are “Islamic Republics” and not a secular country like India, the UK etc - unlike like lives of those muffin eating grandmas in the UK ; minorities are persecuted based on religious beliefs in these countries, and India is granting them citizenship on the basis of persecution, not religion - these includes Christians, Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs who are condemned en mass ❤

[@Clydeb_9994]

We desperately need that in Europe and the US as well! We need something much tougher than that, tho!

[@artandimages353]

Channel 4, you are so interested in Muslims in India, but never have you ever spoken for the Hindus of Bangladesh or Pakistan or the Hindus and Sikhs in Afghanistan 😂

[@maninst7145]

Dont like modi but he's got this right!!!

[@aswinjayakumar885]

Misleading tilte for the video.🙄

[@bobby4395]

Misleading title of the Video. It is not Anti Muslim but to give shelter to oppressed minority in bordering country of India. Have some shame for putting misleading title

[@mayankmuthannamonnanda9030]

1:21 this is because Muslims are in Majority in the mentioned countries (Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan) and the minority communities such as Hindus, Christians, etc are being actively persecuted. Muslims who can prove that they were a citizen of India (Either by Birth Certificate, Adhaar Card, Ration Card, Voter ID, Driving License) will remain as a citizen of India, if they fail to produce those documents they can produce 3 witnesses. This bill was introduced to prevent voter fraud and to safeguard minorites in these Muslim countries because, for eg, In PAKISTAN, at independence the Hindu population was around 10 - 14%. But now it is less than 1.6%.

[@greatexpectations6577]

Is this Chanel owned by Saudi or Qutar?

[@abusufiansiddik567]

At least not by modi for sure. If you have guts use your own name and then comment.

[@bluesm4271]

I swear this channel was unbiased content 4 months ago they've got to be getting paid by aljazeera

[@weswheel4834]

You can't just throw your toys out of your pram because an independent news channel says something that you don't like. (Well, you can, but it makes you look a little bit silly).

[@thecooked8121]

😂😂😂 just because they expose your dung of brain you revert by must be Al-Jazeera or Qatar

[@BigBoiiLeem]

Channel Four is an independent state-owned enterprise of the United Kingdom. It is funded by its commercial operations, receiving no taxpayer money.

[@J.R.S.G.S]

Wrong reporting.

[@Rohitjokchand007]

the Citizenship Amendment Act, calling the act ‘anti-Muslim’. The claim is misleading. CAA will not take away the citizenship of any Indian citizen irrespective of religion. It’s not against any single religion/ community. It’s an enabling law only to provide citizenship to persecuted minorities from neighbouring countries - Afghanistan, Pakistan & Bangladesh,”

[@puneswag]

Let’s see what this media channel reports when India implements uniform civil code which will mean everyone is treated equally and no religion gets special laws.

[@seeker816]

Report this video for false reporting

[@anandshah8761]

Totally misleading information, shame!

[@officeboy9779]

Why do not your Channel recommend the U. K government to invite Indian and Pakistani MuSLUMS?

[@johnpatrick1702]

We have plenty of both in the UK. Those of Indian origin are highly respected and hard working, As for the latter. No thanks.

[@BESMARTER-il4kn]

PLEASE WE WANT TO HEAR REFUGEES NARRATIVES

[@VinodVukkalam]

Please explain how this law is anti-muslim? Just don't spread malice here. Do responsible journalism.

[@AtheistEve]

It paints all Muslims as inferior. Everyone should have the same rights. Also, religious nationalism is a slippery slope into fascist totalitarianism.

[@sonucherian7559]

That requires them to bring up conditions of minorities in Muslim majority states of subcontinent, they're just not ready for that harsh reality.

[@weswheel4834]

Ooo, I dunno. Maybe like they explained in the video, because it listed most other religions except Islam? "Journalist said something I don't agree with, it's so unfair!".

[@namewithheldforprivacy7107]

@@weswheel4834 it also didn't list satanism or Pastafarianism - so why is it not Anti stanist law? WHat about the people that worship the satan? or the people who believe in the church of the flying spagetti monster? Your argument is too weak

[@NobodySomebody-cr4qb]

@@weswheel4834That is because non-Muslims are persecuted in those countries. Do you understand that protection of Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhists, Christians was supposed to be guaranteed by 1952 Nehru-Liquiyat act? India did that, but Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan did not.

[@binitdubey6528]

Misleading title and content .they should work on their r and d fst.

[@user-iy9eo7dj9r]

How did the Hindu population of Islamic Bangladesh decrease from 23% to 8% in 50 years? How did the Hindu population of Islamic Pakistan decrease from 15% to 1% in 50 years? Que: Are MUSLIM's oppressed in ISLAMIC COUNTRIES of Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan ?

[@Vishalkumar_h]

Why Indian Muslims are so worried about other country Muslims? That means they like Pakistan and Pakistani Muslims? Is this a upcoming threat.

[@user-pf2de8pp4u]

*The CAA is aimed to do justice to the families whose Indian parents or grand parents were the victims of the partition of their mother land against their wishes in 1947(thus excluding Rohingyas, Sri Lankan and Bhutanese while Ahmadiyas who were considered Muslims in 1947 were among other Muslims demanding a separate nation for the Muslim only) and happened to be minorities like Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains whose ancestral homes were suddenly declared the new Islamic state Pakistan in the name of TWO-NATION theory despite their stiff resistance against the inclusion of their regions like North-West (now K-P) and Sylhet state in Bengal by voting against the inclusion of their state in Pakistan but lost by a thin margin in 1947 followed by the slaughter and exodus of minorities from Eastern and Western parts of the United India in 1947 to the main land India while some entered Afghanistan also. So Muslims of the united India (the parents of current Muslim residents of Pakistan, Bangladesh and even from the states like UP and Bihar who voted 95% in favor of Jinnah in 1946 elections) got their own country in 1947 on the basis of two-nation theory (while only 5% Muslims migrated to Pakistan) and if we allow the so-called "persecuted" Muslims of Pakistan and Bangladesh in the CAA, you will find millions of Muslims from these countries legally landing in India with made up cases of persecution. So the CAA does justice to those minorities whose land was declared as the Islamic country under Sharia law which was never demanded by them and no one from the Congress consulted them or made arrangements for their safe migration to India their motherland. None of the Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists wanted to live in an Islamic state with their status as DHIMMIS or DHAJJALS if not KAFFIRS with no religious freedom. The partition of their motherland India by the Congress made them suffer persecution for many decades and now Modi government has done justice by bringing the CAA for the children of those minorities who have been persecuted all along. Google how many minor girls of Hindus are kidnaped every year in Sindh and forced to convert and marry Muslim men. Those girls are not even allowed to see their Hindu parents back ever. Have a heart for these helpless Hindus in Pakistan if you have daughters. There are other laws which cover the Muslim refugees from Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan and Sri Lanka and they do not lose anything by the CAA for the persecuted Hindu, Sikhs and Buddhists*

[@adamallen3099]

As a Chinese, I 100% support Indian and Modi do whatever it takes to protect their people from cult.

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

When Rohingyas Muslims are given citizenship then no issue but when Poor persecuted Hindus and Sikhs from Pakistan/ Bangladesh and Afghanistan are given citizenship then problem arises.

[@KKL456]

India divided into two nation (religion) theory, Hindus got India & Muslims got Pakistan.

[@sujanangadi6301]

Better change your thumbnail it's not anti-muslim

[@major2707]

😁

[@mohan2074]

How can something be anti-muslim by Giving citizenship to minorities escaping from india's nieghbouring countries due to religious prosecution 🤔🤔

[@flunchh]

If there are more Muslims it is simply because people understand the truth. Islam will win, don’t worry ❤️❤️

[@arpitaghatakmaitra5111]

CAA is not Anti-Muslim….CAA is for those people \ those minorities (Hindus , Christians , Buddhists , Sikhs , Jains ) who were persecuted in the neighbourhood Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan….this is for them to give them Indian citizenship.

[@Ek.t]

First understand the act before making comments.

[@priyankakumarisingh4511]

They were silent when minorities hindus, sikhs, budhists, christains etc. were persecuted in Pakistan, bangladesh and Afganistan. But they have problem when they are getting help. Hypocrites.

[@sanjeevsood531]

This is an anti India propaganda video. Viewers should not be misled by such channels. What a shame that the British have stooped so low.

[@namewithheldforprivacy7107]

As an Indian, India is a HINDU RASHTRIYA!

[@BigBoiiLeem]

Even though you're a Hindu nationalist and won't see sense no matter what I say, I am going to point out a couple of facts about your country that you might not like: 1. Currently, in India, there are roughly 241 million people who practice a religion other than Hinduism, 172 million of those people are Muslims. However, there are also Jains, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists, and all kinds of other creeds and faiths worshipped in your country. It does not now and has never belonged to the Hindu majority. It belongs to every Indian equally. 2. Muslims have lived in India, alongside Hindus, and people of various other faiths, for the past 1,300 years. Many major religions can mark important turning points as occurring in India. They are not new, they and their ancestors have lived on the Indian subcontinent for millennia, just like most Hindu Indians. 3. Muslims have also, in the past, ruled over large swathes of the Indian subcontinent. Their contributions to fine art, industry, trade, and the development of a vibrant culture in the region are incontrovertible. The contributions of Indians of all religious and ethnic backgrounds over the centuries is what made possible the flourishing and unique culture and story of the people of India. You cannot speak for all these people, you can only speak for yourself. Do not presume to speak on behalf of all or even the majority of Indians, there are 1.4 billion of you, and I'm absolutely certain there is more diversity of opinion among you than that. 4. India is a secular state. The constitution of your nation enshrines this as an unalterable and unchallengeable standard. To abandon this standard is to abandon all the principles of the constitutional system that has allowed India to develop into a powerhouse on the world stage, and become an archon of global science, politics, and culture. I will end on this: you will not win. Hate never does. It may temporarily gain sway over the state of affairs, but soon enough, people will see what you are and what values you lack, and kick you to the curb. Just you remember that.

[@prathmeshgujar]

How much did you recieve to post this video? @Channel 4 News

[@bhootpurvmanusya]

hypocracy. anyone of any religion can ask for citizenship in india.(muslims were able to and still can apply even after caa) CAA fast tracks those who were religiously percecuted. how can muslim be persecuted in muslim neigbouring countries to get their citizenship be fast tracked for india

[@ShivanshuTyagi72981]

There is celebration in India. Persecuted Hindus from Pakistan and Bangladesh are celebrating. But yes, propaganda doesn't stop anyday.

[@saikrishnaannapureddy8611]

These British broadcasting never waits to shed the venom against India. You guys should be shamed of yourself putting that title without knowing the facts

[@sodatta11]

When you shout a lie 10 times, it starts sounding like truth. This act allows religious minorities in India's neighborhood to get indian citizenship, how is this 'anti Muslim'? Do India's Muslim neighbors give equal rights to its minorities like india gives to its Muslim minority? In india a Muslim can become president of the country, can a minority become president or PM of Pakistan and Bangladesh?

[@KashiXlegend]

Congress opposes because of its selective. Muslim communities are not allowed.