Mohammed Hijab vs Ashaari Visitor Speaker's corner Hyde Park

[@mortalorb4524]

Hatun standing there and acting like she understands everything. You can see the laanat on her face.

[@dragon4397]

hahahahahahah...brother calm down

[@DelPiero-us7su]

Be gentle broth. Allah might guide her

[@nabildridi7750]

😂😂😂😂 exactly

[@mrakhan9516]

Brother she Maybe guided so don’t be so harsh, Your hiding your own face arent you? LOL

[@nareeri]

Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk indeed you made me to laugh very loudly

[@mohamd3818]

she is annoying even when she in silent 😂

[@YTN_Zaq]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣

[@christopherwells3426]

Why is she even standing there. She doesn't understand 99% of what is being said.

[@anon4738]

My thoughts exactly

[@daxionpc3375]

wow never seen Hatun quiet for so long, 14 minutes most be a record!

[@pictureperfect7476]

AHAHAH!

[@davidsmith-ln1rp]

Because she has no knowledge about what they are talking about..😂😂😂🙏

[@reefmohammed3553]

Shoul we give her guinness world records?

[@TheRepublicOfGaming]

😂

[@kalijasin]

Hatun covertly brought her expert on the Ash'ari to refute the Muslims and he ended up getting schooled. LOL!! 🤣

[@tiloshah4778]

Hatun realised that this discussion was too deep for her. Yet she found time to scribble some deceit she will like to use to misguide others. Lol

[@fareed3764]

Hatun is trying to make a face of someone who understand the debate , She is Jahil .

[@PoeticSonic]

This guy is a really good guy. He has been having a question in his mind that has been bothering him since some time ago and just wanted to confirm his doubts, I hope he got it confirmed.

[@abulailaalshishany9249]

Yes he got his doubts answered and said shamsi has helped him come to salafiya!! May Allah bless shamsi ameen.

[@JustObserving7860]

The Legendary Outdoorsman did he really say that? Because a few days ago he was slandering Shamsi and spubs.. any video ?

[@firefire786]

Yes he did. He confirmed on twitter last night alhamdulliah

[@JustObserving7860]

Mehrin Shapla alhumduillah!!! can you share the link akh

[@zemphz]

Mehrin Shapla give me his twitter I want to see this proof

[@julkernyne8925]

Hatun: I want to ask a question! Hijab: I have to pray Maghreb now. Hatun: Only 2 minutes please!! Hijab: Well, You wanna pray with us!? Hilarious!! 🤣🤣

[@asamulia4240]

u realized how satan tried to distract us from shalat

[@Ak-so6ng]

Muhammad Hijab was clever and he knew why Hatun was standing there and used Arabic so she doesn't use inter-islamic discussions to toy with it.

[@-algerino-1205]

Miracle in Hyde Park : Hatun almost kept silence during this conversation

[@palemoonlight9109]

xD

[@punchfrank3676]

Syaithan within Hatun has ackowledge MH, it says, good, keep it up

[@killakristian7084]

The title should be, hatun broke the world record for not interrupting.

[@searchrightthings.947]

Masha Allah I felt very happy when hijab Felt the Haters. And started Challenging them by changing English to Arabic. Masha Allah Aleyk Mohamed Hijab

[@shazbossman1744]

look how hatun paying attention loool

[@dannyyo7948]

she didnt wanted to go for prayers... :(

[@wael4070]

At least she spared us her sooooo annoying voice this time

[@admiralesevic6305]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@yellowbeez93]

May Allah give her guidance. Let us not insult her pls guys.

[@PoeticSonic]

@@yellowbeez93 true, who knows she might eventually become a Muslim, and if she does, I bet the muslim community in speakers corner will make a big feast because they wouldn't get headache being harassed by her😂😂😂

[@skysevendz360]

Hatun is admiring M Hijab in the background

[@bunnationalism8035]

Deep subject , good discussion between the two. Hatun was quiet throughout first time wow its a miracle!

[@hsdjsdshdhsdnsmsd6247]

The scholars of Ahlu Sunnah did not allow these kinds of complicated issues to be discussed if laymen are present. You can confuse people. And I dont think that al-Juwayni brought a new ashari aqeedah. Al-bayhaqi had a similiar aqeedah.

[@tamimi8085]

Hatun is not interrupting. !!!!!! I must be dreaming .

[@mytrahana]

Wow Hateun is just watching and listening without shouting... Amazing

[@mrji1680]

Wow Hatun is quit for the whole time.

[@adelbelaifa5492]

that's her sister!

[@spoolindsm127]

Because she has no clue what they're talking about

[@MrAlbroooz]

So nice to see hatun just listening for a change , like a good learning student 😂

[@ever1ast]

Nearly every single comment on here is about Hatun 😂

[@MT-ns9jq]

Without watching the video I know Yusuf (the blond visitor) is gonna talk about Ma’na and I sincerely hope this young man will grow old and will find the Ma’na of Hand and Running before he dies. Such pity. I life will go by snd before you know it you look back and see that all you have been doing is focusing on little, irrelevant piece of our deen and making it subject of a conflict and discussion and putting all your effort and time in it

[@zakaria87100]

Yeah subhannalah this video showed me how ashaaria is a bridge to sufism, cause not enough talking about tawheed , and then sufism is a bridge to shiismw etc. May Allah guide this guy, and guide all of us.

[@Lifelearne]

I feel like I dnt know my own Islamic history when I listen to these two have a discussion

[@sharkyh7327]

It’s deep, Islam is a way of life and their is so much a lot of people don’t know about inc myself but we must always try gain knowledge, I feel like this is the big difference between Islam and all other religion.

[@johnyhoxa5920]

Read up Carl Sherrifs reason and revelation, it’s an overview of Ibn Taymiyyahs Dar Ta’arud, check out the history section there. Or Yasir Qadhis Dissertation on Dar Ta’arud, you can check out the history section there too, I heard it’s quite detailed, didn’t read it myself but I read Carl sherrifs work. Knowing such matters I believe , shows you the vast intellectual basis of Islam and the scholar. Islam has a rich intellectual history.

[@Lifelearne]

@@johnyhoxa5920 does this make a different into knowing Islam or not? Because I thought it's as simple as reading or trying to understand the Quran and hadith if one believes in it. What additional knowledge does this benefit the lay simple Muslim?

[@Lifelearne]

@@sharkyh7327 but I thought islam is simple- trying to understand the Quran and hadith if you believe. Why do we need this additional information...I thought Islam is simple especially to the ordinary lay man Mulsim

[@johnyhoxa5920]

Dawood S it benefits the lay Muslim by just being aware of what the great scholars had to go through in order to preserve the deen. Theological discussions were a result of that, preservation and protection. There were times of great fitnah in the past due to which the scholars stood up to codify. Islam is simple, yes but the sciences are for the purpose of preservation and protection. You can pick up the Quran and Hadeeth and read and understand, but do you have the knowledge of let’s say Science of Jurisprudence to be able to give a Fatwa(s)? Not undermining you but that’s the reality. Lay Muslims are not needed to know everything if that were the case we would be destroyed. We stand on the shoulders of the giants ie scholars. But if you wish to choose the path to specialize in a specific science you can do so, but is it compulsory ? generally no. It’s a Communal obligation not individual. However there could be a situation where it’s individual obligation ex you’re the only Muslim in a society, then many things that are general not and individual obligation, becomes. But it’s always good to be familiar with the sciences just so that the enemies of Islam, deviants etc don’t manipulate you. It’s better to be aware than to be naive. That’s all. The discussions that scholars had with the deviants to prevent staining the theology of Islam was something I believe good to be familiar with, it helps you appreciate your situation. Just like the Prophet Muhammed who had to go through a lot of hardship for Islam to what it is now. It’s just that. These theological discussions above aren’t compulsory on you to know, but if you’re familiar it’s good for you. You can Go to a Shaykh and ask him questions on this matter and learn.

[@majorpremise]

All the Hatun comments have me in tears 😂😂😂

[@UltimatePiccolo]

Why is almost every comment about hatun?

[@jessejames9441]

It seems that most viewers are here for entertainment. This conversation isn’t providing that.

[@syafiatulkhusnah2903]

we're surprise to see her zipped her mouth for that long 😂😂

[@noorsnotes3467]

Hatun is a character.

[@medhaniebuzuamlak2333]

She is lion

[@user-us9iw6rt7b]

She lives in their heads rent free.

[@efaz71]

After reading the comments Seems like most were paying attention to the Hautoon then listening to the brother Hijab, by the the way it was deep discussion.

[@johnyhoxa5920]

This discussion is beyond the knuckle head non Muslim preachers on SP ex Hatun. great to listen to some real classical theological discussions on SP.

[@SylhetBAULA]

This Aashari is a professional speakers corner troll, Hatuns employee.

[@PoeticSonic]

I wonder if hatun is aware of herself....

[@dabaddybeats8118]

Hatuns face destroyed the video..stood there like she understands english 🤣😂

[@mariza101_]

anonymousTV 1 even English is too much for her

[@hosediabald4552]

Mohammed Hijab you are much better than Shamsi in terms of wahabi stubbornness but you are mistaken, the sahaba did not say that Allah is above his throne, they simply recited the aya and kept silence, meaning they did not do t’aweel that’s it, but you cannot say it or translate the literal meaning of “istiwa” because that is t’aweel which the Sahaba haven’t done

[@saadusman6617]

@@youtubeaccount0x073 no Allah is not like his creation. We can stay in fixed position but Allah is nothing like his creation

[@salzshady8794]

Hatun thinking she understands all of this

[@mariza101_]

Salz Shady 😂

[@ozairtahir9276]

The reason why the later asharis adopted opinions different to the former (mainly taweel) was because of the doubts the layman were having

[@30251]

Citation needed.

[@mohsinakhtar7876]

1 I get what your saying but... If you say Allaahh does not have physical existence You need to establish that with proof (that’s a claim) Just like you don’t accept (connected or disconnected) You should think about this as well that why?? Imply?? He doesn’t have a Physical or does have a physical existence Because it’s possible that Allaahh has a physical existence not the way we can imagine that is perhaps why He mentioned his characteristics like يد , وجه, etc (Face, Hand etc) Although I’m not implying that these qualities of Allaahh are meant literally but rather we just believe in them but the meaning, and how, Only Allaahh knows best. On the contrary it is also possible that He doesn’t have a physical existence rather has a metaphysical existence But then you get into the argument of superiority of physical vs metaphysical. And in reality we can’t understand these concepts beyond our limited capacities. So we obviously would choose physical (but) good arguments can prove that our perception of the physical existence is very subjective and The objective is beyond our perception therefore metaphysical is actually objectively superior ... And if Physical is superior because it’s existence is empirical then you would have to add “Devine”Physical. Because this Physical is beyond our empiricism. BUT... The FACT of the matter is that Allaahh is Infinitely independent of All Nonsense that we attribute to Him. وأعوذ بك منك لا أحصي ثناء عليك أنت كما أثنيت على نفسك Allaahh is Above and Beyond All this. SSSsssOOOooo.... it is a lot easier and safer to say, in fact we are told by Allaahh to just submit that we believe the way it is revealed and Allaahh knows best (والراسخون فى العلم يقولون امنا به كل من عند ربنا)) You said: “Not in space, place or direction” This statement you used to support your claim “Allaahh is not physical” Needs to be looked at carefully It’s interesting you didn’t say “Time” Because if you did I would remind you of the Hadith al Qudsi Where Allaahh عز وجل says (أنا الدهر) So Don’t curse time... meaning more or less We know Allaahh has No beginning nor an end but rather is The Beginning and The End. Because He is infinite in terms of his characteristics 1♾1 This Time is beyond our comprehension We can only understand our Time in the context of our(solar system) or imagination but not beyond. You said “space and place” But the Quran says clearly (الر حمن على العرش استوى) Literally “Arsh” means Throne But we don’t understand this quality of Allaahh (استوى Ascension) literally but rather we again raise our hands and admit intellectual defeat and submit that Allaahh knows best(الله اعلم) You said “direction” but The Quran says (أينما تولوا فثم وجه الله) “Which ever direction you turn to there is His Countenance” So again this is also from the Ambiguous verses which we can’t comprehend and therefor submit That Allaahh knows best. adam legends “The clock has a hand” When human beings say that it is not taken literally because we understand things from our own subjective perspectives And that is we in our minds make a point of reference and that is our own hand/s So we human beings don’t refer to a clock having a hand (Literally speaking) We just call it a hand but any other name could be given. Like a pointer/direction/angle/intersection/sticks etc... Although these names would not be the best choice because we can relate to the word hand in personal level. Therfore it seems to be the best choice comparatively. Similarly Allaahh is speaking to us to relate with us on our level. (Hadith teaches us to also انزلوا الناس منازلهم ) اوكما قال عليه السلام Therfore the words (يد وجه etc) Are to be accepted and believed in without any Tashbih, تشبيهor Ta’ateelتعطيل Without any argument But it is safer to stay away from تأويل and to say all تأويل Are haram/wrong/batil etc Is too extreme Therfore that (تأويل) Which the Quran says is allowed and doesn’t contradict the Quran and sunnah and the ijma It is JAIZ. For example some scholars Say that When Satan said”خلقتني من نار و خلقته من طين Allaahh said : لما خلقت بيدي This kalam is تمثيلى comparatively. And the purpose is “special attention” (اعتناء بالشان) There is principle that when someone gives importance to something they give more attention to it. So the point is that Allaahh created Adam with special attention and care. Which is not the same in your creation(Satan) Thefore there is no Ikhtilaf 😁

[@mohsinakhtar7876]

1 Not really it’s common sense Things evolve Not the scientific evolution (that is blind faith) But the general evolution that we see in a daily basis Like from a sperm to fetus to a baby to Achilles to teen and then an adult etc... Similarly our great grand parents didn’t use cellphones now human beings do So this evolution in the world is not contradictory to the Quran or the Sunnah In fact many of these things are propheciezed

[@30251]

@@mohsinakhtar7876 Akhi, please forgive me but I am totally confused, I don't even know why I wrote the comment asking for citation in the first place, maybe I was half-asleep Allah knows best, but your comment was still very good and useful maa shaa Allah even though im not sure why it is directed to me. anyway. Regarding your comment on evolution, i mean the scientific one, it is widely accepted as a fact, and just on that basis assuming it is a fact, can it be reconciled with the Quranic narrative? what do you think?? i want to explain it to my students that they dont have to leave islam just because the mainstream view is that we evolved as a species.

[@30251]

@AH03 i agree totally akhi. your last sentence says it best and sums up my view. im not a scientist, i dont know much about this stuff in all honesty. i teach quran and arabic to some very intelligent teenage girls who have lots of interesting questions and they tell me about how atheism is being forced on them in school. i want them to be confident in their deen rather than insecure. when it comes to presenting the proofs for islam i can do my best, but when it comes to science things and the apparent controversy im really limited. thank you for your time!

[@J-u-n-d]

First of all, this so-called ash'ari is a zaydi. Second, MH is spouting salafi nonsense again. His claim that "nobody said Allah is physical" is a false claim. Our salafi brothers clearly state Allah has a direction (jiha), boundary (hadd), and sitting (julus and istiqrar). You will find even salafis stating He is in a makan. The salafi scholars state clearly the sifat al-khabariyya are الأعيان which means physical. You will find other salafis the yad is an آلة so what is this man talking about. One can find dozens of examples by Shaykh ياسين بن ربيع who is active on Facebook.

[@kaziamzadhossain7920]

Ha Ha Hatun is (in)famous just coming at Speaker's corner! Hope oneday she will realize the purpose of life.

[@khadarducaale1584]

Why does this kid brings this discussion to the park? What is he trying to find from these brothers in the park? There are other places to meet to discuss this

[@samvali5143]

My thoughts exactly. I think the Daees shud refrain from these Aqeeda type polemical discussions. Concentrate on non-Muslims and remove their misconceptions!!

[@samvali5143]

@Alex Sunderland waste of time and waste of energy. This guy was asking everyone in the park this one question about Aqeeda? If he had asked 100 Imams from 100 different Mosques, that would've been greatly understandable, that means he is sincerely seeking knowledge and he is seeking it from Imams who are paid to deal with these things. But this guy is using up precious time of the brothers and denying the right of sincere non Muslims to learn about Islam from the park. May he fear Allah next time.

[@notknownmirza743]

Bro his question was simple

[@samvali5143]

@@notknownmirza743 Hyde park is like a sales retail floor, the non muslims are your customers. Try to reach every customer. Spend the time wisely with them. This guy came last week and used up valuable time from two other daees on a very technical question, there are so many Mosques with Imams who are very qualified and paid by the Mosque to deal with his query. These brothers use their spare time on a Sunday to speak to Non Muslims out of love for their religion. Why does he need a camera for his question? Make contact with an Imam and seek your answer privately. Khalas.

[@samvali5143]

@Apex88888888 Firstly, this geezer came last week with the same question. Why is he checking up on what Aqeeda these brothers have? They are using their free time to stop Islamophobia by correcting people's bad impression of Islam. There so many Imams who are receiving a salary to deal with those questions, if he was sincere than he would sit down with maybe one, two or three very learned Imams in one day, instead of reaching 100, I stated it as an example but u took it very literally, rather foolishly shall I say. Sometimes people just want to show off their knowledge, and Hyde park is full of cameras nowadays.

[@roomforthefiiixins2491]

Hatun definitely has a crush on Mohammed ❤️ You can see it in her glaring albeit evil eyes

[@osmanabucar8189]

Some people just come to the park for argument not interest in DAWAH..... guys let's invite people to Islam instead scaring people away! .....

[@coffeeloverr.a1546]

You Want to come pray with us..😂😂😂

[@mohyaldin6492]

Thank you Ashaari Visitor. You asked Hijab the question I wanted to ask him for years now. Please visit the park again.

[@mohsinakhtar7876]

I get what your saying but... If you say Allaahh does not have physical existence You need to establish that with proof (that’s a claim) Just like you don’t accept (connected or disconnected) You should think about this as well that why?? Imply?? He doesn’t have a Physical or does have a physical existence Because it’s possible that Allaahh has a physical existence not the way we can imagine that is perhaps why He mentioned his characteristics like يد , وجه, etc (Face, Hand etc) Although I’m not implying that these qualities of Allaahh are meant literally but rather we just believe in them but the meaning, and how, Only Allaahh knows best. On the contrary it is also possible that He doesn’t have a physical existence rather has a metaphysical existence But then you get into the argument of superiority of physical vs metaphysical. And in reality we can’t understand these concepts beyond our limited capacities. So we obviously would choose physical (but) good arguments can prove that our perception of the physical existence is very subjective and The objective is beyond our perception therefore metaphysical is actually objectively superior ... And if Physical is superior because it’s existence is empirical then you would have to add “Devine”Physical. Because this Physical is beyond our empiricism. BUT... The FACT of the matter is that Allaahh is Infinitely independent of All Nonsense that we attribute to Him. وأعوذ بك منك لا أحصي ثناء عليك أنت كما أثنيت على نفسك Allaahh is Above and Beyond All this. SSSsssOOOooo.... it is a lot easier and safer to say, in fact we are told by Allaahh to just submit that we believe the way it is revealed and Allaahh knows best (والراسخون فى العلم يقولون امنا به كل من عند ربنا)) You said: “Not in space, place or direction” This statement you used to support your claim “Allaahh is not physical” Needs to be looked at carefully It’s interesting you didn’t say “Time” Because if you did I would remind you of the Hadith al Qudsi Where Allaahh عز وجل says (أنا الدهر) So Don’t curse time... meaning more or less We know Allaahh has No beginning nor an end but rather is The Beginning and The End. Because He is infinite in terms of his characteristics 1♾1 This Time is beyond our comprehension We can only understand our Time in the context of our(solar system) or imagination but not beyond. You said “space and place” But the Quran says clearly (الر حمن على العرش استوى) Literally “Arsh” means Throne But we don’t understand this quality of Allaahh (استوى Ascension) literally but rather we again raise our hands and admit intellectual defeat and submit that Allaahh knows best(الله اعلم) You said “direction” but The Quran says (أينما تولوا فثم وجه الله) “Which ever direction you turn to there is His Countenance” So again this is also from the Ambiguous verses which we can’t comprehend and therefor submit That Allaahh knows best. adam legends “The clock has a hand” When human beings say that it is not taken literally because we understand things from our own subjective perspectives And that is we in our minds make a point of reference and that is our own hand/s So we human beings don’t refer to a clock having a hand (Literally speaking) We just call it a hand but any other name could be given. Like a pointer/direction/angle/intersection/sticks etc... Although these names would not be the best choice because we can relate to the word hand in personal level. Therfore it seems to be the best choice comparatively. Similarly Allaahh is speaking to us to relate with us on our level. (Hadith teaches us to also انزلوا الناس منازلهم ) اوكما قال عليه السلام Therfore the words (يد وجه etc) Are to be accepted and believed in without any Tashbih, تشبيهor Ta’ateelتعطيل Without any argument But it is safer to stay away from تأويل and to say all تأويل Are haram/wrong/batil etc Is too extreme Therfore that (تأويل) Which the Quran says is allowed and doesn’t contradict the Quran and sunnah and the ijma It is JAIZ. For example some scholars Say that When Satan said”خلقتني من نار و خلقته من طين Allaahh said : لما خلقت بيدي This kalam is تمثيلى comparatively. And the purpose is “special attention” (اعتناء بالشان) There is principle that when someone gives importance to something they give more attention to it. So the point is that Allaahh created Adam with special attention and care. Which is not the same in your creation(Satan) Thefore there is no Ikhtilaf 😁

[@mohyaldin6492]

@@mohsinakhtar7876 My evidence: سورة الشورى (السورة رقم 42 من القرآن الكريم) ، الآية رقم 11 أعوذ بالله من الشيطان الرجيم بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم " فَاطِرُ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضِ ۚ جَعَلَ لَكُمْ مِنْ أَنْفُسِكُمْ أَزْوَاجًا وَمِنَ الْأَنْعَامِ أَزْوَاجًا ۖ يَذْرَؤُكُمْ فِيهِ ۚ لَيْسَ كَمِثْلِهِ شَيْءٌ ۖ وَهُوَ السَّمِيعُ الْبَصِيرُ ﴿١١﴾ " Holy Qur'an, Chapter 42 (Ash-Shūrā) , Verse 11 Muhammad Marmaduke Pickthall Interpretation. I seek refuge with Allah from the accursed satan. In the name of God, Allah, The Most Gracious, The Most Merciful. " 11. The Creator of the heavens and the earth. He hath made for you pairs of yourselves, and of the cattle also pairs, whereby He multiplieth you. Naught is as His likeness; and He is the Hearer, the Seer. "

[@testplay9628]

@@mohsinakhtar7876 how will all this would effect your Deen ?

[@mohyaldin6492]

@Faysal El Addouti 1. I will Check/Skim through the book. 2. I believe GOD doesn't change, and I believe that GOD exist before places were created, as for the "throne" ... the word "اسْتَوَى" in Qur'an 20:5, has many meanings, more than 10, one of which means "sovereignty". 3. "Infidels" is not an Islamic terminology, but what you mean to say is "Kafir" which means "disbeliever". 4. Mus'haf: collection of paper sheets. Qur'an: Recitation. So they have a point. 5. I don't care much about Labels, but in order to assume disbelief I need to know the belief first (Some might call themselves Shia but all their beliefs are Sunni, OR call themselves "Muslims" but they contradict the clear versus of Qur'an or Authentic Hadith (Example: Qadiani). And that is besides that terms mean different things in different times (Example: Shia now are not "Sunni-Shia" that preferred if Ali were 1st Caliph/Imam instead of Abu Bakr without denying "The ten to whom Paradise was promised" (May GOD be pleased with them).

[@mohyaldin6492]

@@testplay9628 Sorry for the (VERY) Late reply ... The effect on belief is the difference between Monotheism & Polytheism/Paganism, ... if you attribute physical behavior to an imaginable god then you are associating partners with GOD, hence Paganism & disbelief.

[@islamislam9763]

If you don't know Hatoon you would say that lady is sincere and trying to learn 🤣🤣 i can't believe she didn't yell and shout.. something fishy here

[@nahidulislam9497]

Not sure why he had to mention shamsi and Rabi'e madkhali in such a way, still burning inside I see. Shamsi refers to THE salaf ( Sahabah tabieen atba tabieen ) more than anyone else in the park

[@linkup901ify]

Seems like language games as the Throne doesn't have a where either, none of the metaphysical does. We still understand what people are saying when they ask such a question and we can explain our answer so that they understand it's not a where in a physical sense. It's like asking where does the mother place in the Muslim family and the answer is three times higher than the father, but that's got nothing to do with actual location.

[@blackmancool9983]

Correct. But the deeper question is why are both so worried about physicality???????? Answer : It authenticates the Christian message. That God can come into existence as a physical (man)

[@linkup901ify]

@Epicmoment Watch the debate, it's not hard.

[@blackmancool9983]

@Epicmoment Correct.

[@taherramzan4978]

14:24 - You want to pray with us?

[@Csense-se5ke]

Thats An invitation to Islam

[@pashaj92]

Come back to Islam Hatun

[@pashaj92]

@@Csense-se5ke true

[@pashaj92]

@Cincinnati Reds my guess is that she was born Muslim in or around Turkey, she tries to keep very quiet about it.

[@mohamedmylastnameisibrahim1606]

Cincinnati Reds I mean there are many Muslims who say they believe in Allah and his Rasool that can’t even read Surah al Fatiha. I’ve met some of them in person, so maybe Hatun was born into a Muslim family and never believed in Islam to begin with 🤷🏾‍♂️ only Allah knows

[@JamesSmith-vj9ou]

I think hatun is lusting after the lion.

[@mubassirshaikhji4433]

Eiiw , brother rinse your hands and mind for thinking and writing it.

[@fahimbakhtiar]

i don't understand what Hijab is saying, but im here just to see him talk fancy. im a simple man.

[@SaidMetiche-qy9hb]

he says nonsense towards the end

[@testplay9628]

Hahahahahahahaha Same

[@testplay9628]

@@SaidMetiche-qy9hb oh how so

[@SIGSEGV1337]

You can google most of the words he's using and get a rough idea

[@Joker-fz5bt]

​@@SaidMetiche-qy9hb just because you can't understand what he's saying doesn't mean he's saying nonsense

[@agulm6625]

Hope this conversation goes above hatun head ,else she be nitpicking

[@mr.a1285]

I doubt she understood 1 bit of it

[@mohyaldin6492]

I hope she understands everything & become a Muslim

[@samvali5143]

I really hope this brother is reading, there is absolutely no need to drain their mental stamina, and use up the precious time of the phenomenal Daees in Hyde Park, u can easily make contact with them and visit them in their homes or Masjids, these are important questions for different places. If these Daees are not answering questions on science and existence of God, they are doing so on philosophy and religion, when they are not answering questions on that, they are doing so on comparative scriptural of religions, and when they are not answering questions on that, they are debunking the old age myths and misconceptions on Islam and our Nabi saw. There are millions of Imams who are qualified to answer ur question on Aqeeda. How many non Muslims will ever come across Muslims with whom they can have a rational debate with. Know your limits and priorities. Otherwise, u are there to sow seeds of fitna, and no wonder these evil DCCI are enjoying it, they are happy with these unnecessary diversions, so they cud preach their evil lies to the uneducated.

[@johnogroats3318]

sam Vali as a non Muslim this is one of the most interesting discussions I have heard so far.

[@adelbelaifa5492]

Hatoon smiles from time to time as if she understood something from the conversation and believe me she is completely lost. When the white guy mentionned Takiya, she offered a nice smile beacause she like the term. By contrast, the white guy knows about the stuff and that's why he is questionning Mohammed Hijab.

[@misterpete8001]

Lol they love the word taqiya

[@hahazim34]

9:52 look at her face

[@DefendersofGod619]

Lmao its the girl that got slapped at the end

[@sekkataziz1644]

Hatoon is lost LOL

[@aaaaaawda]

Why let two amateurs talk about Ashari aqeedah?? Let a scholar of aqeedah (Ashari) come and discuss these and explain it . Hijab saying i dont follow anyone expect sahabas books??? What is he talking about? He is now qualified as a mutjahid to go to those sayings and extract aqeedah from it?😂😂😂 these people are to funny , and hijab is saying that he dont want to use 'kalam' ??? Yet he is using kalam every single time when it comes to debating ahteits christians etc to many fools and ignorants in the park. Why are people afraid of not using kalam? Kalam saved the ummah of jahiliya and ignorance. Without kalam the right aqeedah would never be attained these fools with their claim: ' follow aqeedah sahaba' you cannot follow that in these day and age because their understanding can never be achieved except the scholars studying them wich they did and therefore the Ashari school came out as the sunni islam. Is this so difficult to understand???????????? Its not higher mathematics people

[@anonymoose9322]

Let's compare your own opinion to what the Salaf said regarding Kalaam. Imaam ash-Shaafi’ee (d. 204H) said, *“My ruling regarding the people of theological rhetoric is that they should be beaten with palm leaves and shoes and be paraded amongst the kinsfolk and the tribes with it being announced, ‘This is the reward of the one who abandons the Book and the Sunnah and turns to theological rhetoric (kalaam).”* [Sharh ‘AqeedatitTahaawiyyah of lbn Abil-’Izz, p. 75.] Ibn ‘Abdul-Barr said, *“The people of Fiqh and Aathaar in all the various towns and cities are agreed unanimously that the Ahlul-Kalaam (People of Theological Rhetoric) are (but) Ahlul-Bida’ waz-Zaigh (the People of Innovations and Deviation). And they are not considered, by all of the above, to be amongst the ranks of the Scholars (in truth).”* [Reported by Ibn Qudaamah in his Burhaan fee Bayaanil-Qur’aan.] Imaam ash-Shaafi’ee (d. 204H) said, *“That a person is put to trial with everything that Allaah has forbidden, besides Shirk, is better than that he looks at Kalaam (theological rhetoric).” He also said, “If people knew what (misleading and destructive) desires are contained within theological rhetoric they would certainly flee from it as they would from a lion,”* He also said, *“Whoever showed boldness in approaching theological rhetoric will never prosper.”* [Reported by Ibn Qudaamah in his Burhaan fee Bayaanil-Qur’aan.] Aboo Yoosuf, the companion of Aboo Haneefah said, *“Whoever sought knowledge by kalaam (theological rhetoric) will turn a heretical apostate,”* and Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. 241H) said, *“The person of theological rhetoric will never prosper. And never do you see anyone looking into theological rhetoric except that in his heart is a desire for creating mischief.”* [Both narrations are reported by Ibn Qudaamah in his Burhaan fee Bayaanil-Qur’aan.] Muhammad Ibn Seereen (d. 110H) said, *“They (i.e., the Companions and the Taabi’een) used to consider themselves upon the path (of truth) so long as they held onto the narrations.”* [Reported by al-Laalikaa’ee in his Sharh Usolil It’iqaad, no. 110.] Shaadh ibn Yahyaa said, *“There is no path which is more straight and direct (in leading) to Paradise than the path of the one who travels upon the aathaar (narrations).”* [Reported by al-Laalikaa’ee in his Sharh UsoolilIt’qaad no. 112.] ‘Abdullah ibn alMubaarak (d. 181H) said, *“I found that the affair was Ittibaa’ (following and imitation, i.e., following and submission to the narrations).”* [Reported by al-Laalikaa’ee in his Sharh Usoolil-l’tiqaad, no. 113]

[@aaaaaawda]

Anony Moose when i saw that pseudo-scholars name Abd ' Izz i did not even read the others , Izz is an unknown in the Hanafi he s a salafi pen worker

[@anonymoose9322]

@@aaaaaawda Subhaanallaah! Keep living in denial! I also mentioned Imaam Ahmad and Imaam ash-Shaafi'ee (may Allaah have mercy upon them), but you completely ignored them due to following your own desires. The following Aayah came to mind after seeing your delusional comment: *And when Our Verses (of the Quran) are recited to such a one, he turns away in pride, as if he heard them not, as if there were deafness in his ear. So announce to him a painful torment.* [Luqmaan, 31:7]

[@aaaaaawda]

Anony Moose why do you pick and choose opinions of scholars which you know nothing about???? Go and study their books in Arabic and then you will see what Kalam is about. Dont pick and choose some translated extracts. When you salafi fools will understand??????

[@anonymoose9322]

@@aaaaaawda Let's see who's picking and choosing, shall we? In Imaam Ahmad's treatise, 'Usool as-Sunnah', he (رحمه الله‎) lays down 75 fundamental principles of the Sunnah. And from principle #15 and onwards is a total condemnation of Kalaam. And for the purpose of being concise, I'll just mention principles #15 to #20, instead of the whole treatise. The following is principle #15 to #20: #15 And whoever does not know the explanation of a Hadeeth and (whose) intellect [does not have the capacity] to make him understand it, then that would be sufficient (i.e, to just merely affirm the Ahaadeeth and have faith in them] since [everything from the religion] has been perfected for him. And it is necessary for him to have faith in it and to submit to it, such as the Hadeeth of the truthful, the believed and whatever is similar to it in the matter of al-Qadar. #16 And also like the Ahaadeeth regarding the Ru'yah (the Believer's seeing of Allaah in the Hereafter), all of them, even if they disagree with people's hearing and [even] if the one who is listening to them feels repelled by and is averse to them. #17 Certainly, it is obligatory upon him to have faith in them and not to reject a single word from them nor from other [such] Ahaadeeth, which have been reported by reliable, trustworthy narrators. #18 And that he does not argue with anyone, nor dispute and nor should he learn [about how to make] argumentation [in such matters]. #19 For indeed, (indulging in) theological rhetoric (Kalaam) in the matter of Qadar, the Ru'yah, the Qur'aan, and other such issues are among the ways that are detested and which are forbidden. #20 The one who does, so, even if he reaches the truth with his words, is not from Ahlus-Sunnah, until he abandons (using) this mode of argumentation, [and until he] submits and believes in the Aathaar (the Prophetic narrations and those of the Companions). And if you're brave enough, I suggest you read the whole treatise, if you still think this is all 'picking and choosing'.

[@rumzih9179]

Hatun was silent for an entire video. I'm actually shocked. Sheill go down in dawah history, as the sudden silent HIENA.

[@AlHaqAhleSunnah]

Im ashari and was pleased with mh response.

[@TracyAlanBridle]

Akhi Yusuf speakers Corner lol wtf love it bro ahhhh know that voice and eyes lmao Those eyes give it away my man :) Salam Alaikum young brother ;)

[@p0li5]

Hatun just want to ask hijab if he can repeat the whole conversation but summarize in 2mins bcoz she is getting dizzy the whole time.. poor Hatun...

[@littlelion]

Peace be upon you all. What is the brand of microphone brother Hijab is using? Jazak Allahu Khairun.

[@greyzstah]

All Muhammad hijab is doing is stating books and scholars names to sound intelligent. He’s not answering the basic question which the brother can recognise.

[@jslj5774]

greyzstah the guy asking questions is ignorant himself and dosent seem to have studied the ashari belief

[@أمالياأفندي]

you must have watched another video for he answered the question and the brother thanked him and shaked his hand. Hijab's intelligence is getting him much of hate ;it is called Hasad "envy".

[@hafizhalimable]

Hatun in her mind is rearranging Hijabs word and mashes it all up so she could spin and twist them in her questions.

[@h45-m9y]

If there was a face that annoys just by being there...

[@palestinianmaytr48]

Muhammad Hijab (AKA Mr. "In My Opinion") is clearly an undercover Ash'ari and just proved it in this video and even went to mock Shamsi and Shaykh Rabee for defending and clarifying the Aqeedah of the Salaf...amazing how no one else caught that. But alhamdulillah that very same person Hijab mocked (Shamsi) ended up being that person, by the Tawfeeq of Allaah, guiding Yusuf to Salafiyyah.

[@أمالياأفندي]

get immediate help!

[@EM-tx3ly]

Possibly so......

[@5thdawg917]

Bruh, I have no idea what Hijab is on about but I agree with him lol

[@kingklmak]

That's called blind faith and your a sheep! Following the evidences (Quran and Hadith) not the words of a man.

[@mohsinakhtar7876]

I get what your saying but... If you say Allaahh does not have physical existence You need to establish that with proof (that’s a claim) Just like you don’t accept (connected or disconnected) You should think about this as well that why?? Imply?? He doesn’t have a Physical or does have a physical existence Because it’s possible that Allaahh has a physical existence not the way we can imagine that is perhaps why He mentioned his characteristics like يد , وجه, etc (Face, Hand etc) Although I’m not implying that these qualities of Allaahh are meant literally but rather we just believe in them but the meaning, and how, Only Allaahh knows best. On the contrary it is also possible that He doesn’t have a physical existence rather has a metaphysical existence But then you get into the argument of superiority of physical vs metaphysical. And in reality we can’t understand these concepts beyond our limited capacities. So we obviously would choose physical (but) good arguments can prove that our perception of the physical existence is very subjective and The objective is beyond our perception therefore metaphysical is actually objectively superior ... And if Physical is superior because it’s existence is empirical then you would have to add “Devine”Physical. Because this Physical is beyond our empiricism. BUT... The FACT of the matter is that Allaahh is Infinitely independent of All Nonsense that we attribute to Him. وأعوذ بك منك لا أحصي ثناء عليك أنت كما أثنيت على نفسك Allaahh is Above and Beyond All this. SSSsssOOOooo.... it is a lot easier and safer to say, in fact we are told by Allaahh to just submit that we believe the way it is revealed and Allaahh knows best (والراسخون فى العلم يقولون امنا به كل من عند ربنا)) You said: “Not in space, place or direction” This statement you used to support your claim “Allaahh is not physical” Needs to be looked at carefully It’s interesting you didn’t say “Time” Because if you did I would remind you of the Hadith al Qudsi Where Allaahh عز وجل says (أنا الدهر) So Don’t curse time... meaning more or less We know Allaahh has No beginning nor an end but rather is The Beginning and The End. Because He is infinite in terms of his characteristics 1♾1 This Time is beyond our comprehension We can only understand our Time in the context of our(solar system) or imagination but not beyond. You said “space and place” But the Quran says clearly (الر حمن على العرش استوى) Literally “Arsh” means Throne But we don’t understand this quality of Allaahh (استوى Ascension) literally but rather we again raise our hands and admit intellectual defeat and submit that Allaahh knows best(الله اعلم) You said “direction” but The Quran says (أينما تولوا فثم وجه الله) “Which ever direction you turn to there is His Countenance” So again this is also from the Ambiguous verses which we can’t comprehend and therefor submit That Allaahh knows best. adam legends “The clock has a hand” When human beings say that it is not taken literally because we understand things from our own subjective perspectives And that is we in our minds make a point of reference and that is our own hand/s So we human beings don’t refer to a clock having a hand (Literally speaking) We just call it a hand but any other name could be given. Like a pointer/direction/angle/intersection/sticks etc... Although these names would not be the best choice because we can relate to the word hand in personal level. Therfore it seems to be the best choice comparatively. Similarly Allaahh is speaking to us to relate with us on our level. (Hadith teaches us to also انزلوا الناس منازلهم ) اوكما قال عليه السلام Therfore the words (يد وجه etc) Are to be accepted and believed in without any Tashbih, تشبيهor Ta’ateelتعطيل Without any argument But it is safer to stay away from تأويل and to say all تأويل Are haram/wrong/batil etc Is too extreme Therfore that (تأويل) Which the Quran says is allowed and doesn’t contradict the Quran and sunnah and the ijma It is JAIZ. For example some scholars Say that When Satan said”خلقتني من نار و خلقته من طين Allaahh said : لما خلقت بيدي This kalam is تمثيلى comparatively. And the purpose is “special attention” (اعتناء بالشان) There is principle that when someone gives importance to something they give more attention to it. So the point is that Allaahh created Adam with special attention and care. Which is not the same in your creation(Satan) Thefore there is no Ikhtilaf 😁

[@mohsinakhtar7876]

Abdul Kalam Relax

[@emindemiri2706]

Bro Mohammad Hijab is a very intellligent and open minded individual. i would love it, if he would go deeper into the ashari creed for us layman to understand. the fact of the matter is, that there werent and there aren't scholars in saudi arabia only! i want to know what the creed/aqidah/believe of the first three centuries of islam was!

[@aadil373]

Very detailed explanation on this topic can be found on channel of ustad abdur rahman hassan

[@786ghostface]

Is hatun waiting for a bus ??? 😳

[@gonzospidy5869]

This ashrai sounds like a fake ashari sounds more like who he's standing next to

[@hardcoreholly1161]

He’s Zayidi 😂😂😂😂

[@yur3k847]

Why are people going in on hatun.....you never know maybe this is the start of her guidance to Islam......so guys lets b civil here

[@athar5110]

Muhammed hijab just confused the hell out of me I’m tryna learn this topic it’s interesting

[@Makhachevo]

He self is confused of what he said.

[@killakristian7084]

@@Makhachevo as are you and hatun... Hence her silence.

[@naz2you]

That’s falsafa for u. It’s simple apparent meaning is the desired meaning.

[@killakristian7084]

@@naz2you your comment makes about as much sense as an ashtray on a motorbike

[@Joker-fz5bt]

​@@naz2you it's not even falsafa loool

[@Ali_7.8.6]

Daily Reminder: Try to supplicate these duas every single day habitually 1. Dua That Guarantees You Forgiveness (Sahih Al-Bukhari) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: "Whoever gets up at night and says: La ilaha 'illa Allaahu, wahdahu la shareeka lahul mulku, wa lahul hamdu, wa huwa ala kulli shayin qadeer. Subhana allaahi, wal hamdu lillaahi, wa la illaaha ila Allaah, wa Allaahu akbar, waLa hawla wa la quwwata illa billaah. There is none worthy of worship in truth except Allah Alone, He has no partners, He has the Dominion and for Him is all praise, and He is capable of all things, praise is for Him, and Far is Allah from imperfection, and There is none worthy of worship in truth except Allah, and Allah is the Greatest, there is no capability nor is there any power except with Allah. "Then he says: Allaahumma aghfirlee. O Allah forgive me! Or he supplicates and his supplication is answered, and if he makes Wudhu and prays, then his prayer is accepted. 2. Dua That Guarantees You Jannah (Sahih Al-Jami, An-Nasa'i, Ibn Hibban) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: "Whoever recites Ayatul Kursi, verse 255 from chapter number 2, Surat Al Baqarah after every obligatory prayer, then nothing is stopping him or her from entering Jannah, except one thing: Death." 3. Dua That Wipe Away Sins (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Muslim, At-Tirmidhi) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: "Whoever says: Subhana allaahi, wa bihamdih How far from imperfections Allah is, and I praise Him. "a hundred times during the day, his sins are wiped away, even if they are like the foam of the sea." 4. Phrases That Are Heavier On The Scales Than An Entire Morning Of Recitation (Sahih Muslim) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: "I recited four words three times after I had left you. If these are to be weighed against all you have recited since morning, these will be heavier." These are: Subhan-Allahi wa bihamdihi, 'adada khalqihi, wa rida nafsihi, wa zinatah 'arshihi, wa midada kalimatihi. Allah is free from imperfection and I begin with His praise, as many times as the number of His creatures, in accordance with His Good Pleasure, equal to the weight of His Throne and equal to the ink that may be used in recording the words (for His Praise). 5. Dua To Stay On The Right Path (Sahih Muslim) Ya musarrifa-l quloobi sarrif qalbi ala ta’atik. O, Allah! The One Who turns the hearts, turn my heart towards Your obedience. 6. Dua To Be Save From Totrments Of Grave Allahumma inni wa a'udhu bika min adhabil qabri O, Allah! Saves us from the torments of the grave. 7. Dua For The Best In The Dunya And Hereafter Rabbana atina fid-dunya hasanatan, wa fil'akhirati hasanatan, waqina 'adhaban-nar. O, Allah! Our Lord give us all the good of this world, and the good of the hereafter, and Save us from the punishment of the Fire. 8. Dua To Help Pay Off Your Debts (Sahih At-Tirmidhi) Allahum-makfinee bi halaalika 'an haraamika wa aghninee bifadhlika 'amman siwaaka O, Allah! Suffice me with what You have allowed instead of what You have forbidden, and make me independent of all others besides You. 9. Dua Of The Treasures Of Paradise (Sahih Al-Bukhari, At-Tirmidhi) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: "Shall I not tell you of a word which is one of the treasures of Paradise?" La hawla wa la quwaata illa billah There is no power and no strength except with Allah. 10. Dua To Literally Boost Your Energy Before you sleep recite: Subhana allaah 33x, Alhamdulilah 33x, Allahu akbar 34x 11. Dua That Protects You From All Evil, Magic And Affliction (Sahih Ibn Majah, Abu Dawud, At-Tirmidhi) Bismillaahil-lathee laa yadhurru ma'as-mihi shay'un fil-'ardhi wa laa fis-samaa'i wa Huwas-Samee'ul-'Aleem. In the Name of Allah, Who with His Name nothing can cause harm in the earth nor in the heavens, and He is the All-Hearing, the All-Knowing. 12. Dua To Get Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) Help in Yawm Al Qiyamah (Sahih Al-Bukhari) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: "Whoever says the following, after hearing the call of adhan, the call of prayer I will intercede for them yawm al qiyamah." Allaahumma Rabba haathihid-da 'watit-taammati wassalaatil-qaa'imatah, Aati Muhammadanil-waseelata walfadheelah, Wab 'ath-hu maqaamam-mahmoodanil-lathee wa'adtah. O, Allah! the Lord of this perfect call, and the lord of the prayer that is about to be established, grant Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) al waseela, Resurrect him with that status, that is so praise worthy, which you have already promised. 13. Dua Forgiveness All Believers Allahumma ighfir lil muslimeena wal-muslimaat, wal-mu'mineena wal-mu'minaat, al-ahyaa'i minhom wal-amwat. O, Allah! forgive the Muslim men and Muslim women, the believing men and the believing women, the alive from them and the dead. 14. Benefits Reciting Surah Ikhlas - Reciting 3 times a day is equivalent to reciting the whole Qur'an. - Reciting 10 times a day and Allah will build for him a house in paradise. 15. Sayyidul Istighfar (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Sahih Al-Jami, At-Tirmidhi) Prophet Muhammad SAW (PBUH) said: If somebody recites this invocation (given below) during the day, and if he should die then, he will be from the people of Jannah. And if he recites it in the night, and if he should die on the same day, he will be from the people of Jannah.” Allahuma anta Rabbi la ilaha illa anta, Khalaqtani wa ana 'Abduka, wa ana 'ala 'ahdika wa wa 'dika mastata 'tu, A 'udhu bika min Sharri ma sana'tu, abu'u Laka bini'matika'alaiya, wa abu'u laka bidhanbi faghfir lee fa innahu la yaghfiru adhdhunuba illa anta. O, Allah! You are my Lord! None has the right to be worshipped but You. You created me and I am Your slave, and I am faithful to my convenant and my promise as much as I can. I seek refuge with You from all the evil I have done. I acknowledge before You all the blessings You have bestowed upon me, and I confess to You all my sins. So I entreat You to forgive my sins, for nobody can forgive sins except You. 16. Dua For Protection From Shirk Allahumma inni a`udhu bika an ushrika bika wa ana a`lamu wa astaghfiruka lima la a`lam O, Allah! I seek refuge in You from knowingly associating partners with You, and I seek your forgiveness for that which I do not know. Brothers and Sisters please memorize these duas and surahs with proper tajweed with the intention of pleasing Allah SWT. Please copy and paste this comment so that you may benefit the brothere and sisters who come across it as well as yourselves. Remember brothers and sisters even though it seems like the whole world is against us, if we are on the straight path, sincere and do not waver from the straight path, we will be victorious inshallah

[@a.a.8572]

Fear Allah brother Hijab. Don't mock other Muslims, and especially the ones that are not there to defend themselves. May Allah guide you and myself and help us to be respectful towards each other and don't mock one and other.

[@Wenutz]

look at you making judgement on Mohamed Hijab when he's not here to defend himself. Hypocrite much?

[@a.a.8572]

@@Wenutz it's advice. You should read more English

[@Wenutz]

@@a.a.8572 I gave you advice. You should also read more english....

[@muhammadusamaumer7143]

In Full Video my eyes were in Hatun. She is Trying to Understand. But Big Knowledge for Small Brains

[@adilghazanfar519]

Why is Hatun even there..... legit there to try find loopholes

[@thanostitan8696]

Hatun, pls come and pray together. Who knows, you might get hidaya from Allah...

[@noorsnotes3467]

MH was too comfortable with arabic in this conversation. Some of the verbiage I wasn't familiar with and he didn't translate any of them.

[@thecristal2557]

These type of discussion are non sense because this type of knowledge can only be taught by mukachafa.

[@mnscd1657]

loook this little sneaky hatun smiling

[@Farhan_in_Delhi]

1:06 well hatun seems to be having fun

[@hamdiguler378]

She is a devil subhanallah

[@winkfish]

Please br sam dawah blur out hatuns face or sensor it, i cant handle it.

[@angosalvo5734]

For the first time I disagree with Mohamed Hijab. Actually, saying that one is on the belief of the early generations isn't clear nowadays. A lot of people are making this claim and it's just going to confuse the listener. Ibn taymia is the barometer to me. Because he was and still is in the front line against all groups of innovators . And they are making him as a target to their attacks against mdh'hab Al sallaf. Of course , ibn taymia has mistakes, but if we read his letters like Attadmuriya or Al wassitiya and so on, we find that his Creed is conform precisely with assallaf. One should''nt go find his believes in his long debates with philosophers and mutakaemeen

[@conjugatemethod]

Ibn Taymiyyah’s views on this issue were heterodox in the extreme.

[@angosalvo5734]

@@conjugatemethod which subject precisely?

[@mohammedahmed1109]

Hijab literally don't have enough knowledge to answer this guy's question, so he started hovering around mentioning names of books and scholars, and it's one of few times you hear hijab the " lion " stammering .

[@Joker-fz5bt]

​@@mohammedahmed1109 looool you clearly just hate Hijab because he answered the Question well and he actually read those books which you most likely haven't

[@kadsaidi1665]

This kid asks the same question to everyone, gets the same answers, but keeps coming back

[@aliciacantu1106]

Always talking bout mana

[@Daradajee]

Then this guy Yusuf Zaydi became Moe Deen's sidekick!

[@avec-zam7301]

I never went to Hyde Park, but incha Allah one day. At the same time i have seen i think every video in hide park for the last 5 6 7 years. And not alot of time people debating muslims have made me curious about them. Beside hatoun of cours but not for the same reson. But this brother seems to gater information to pull someting out in the future. His way of acting is very interesting, he knows what he is asking and do not deviat from that. I'm curious to know what his thing is.

[@avec-zam7301]

@R Galaxy Salem, Brother in the Quran there is only one kind of Muslim! And that is who the one who Believe in one God and that Mohamed is the final and last messenger. The reste will all end there speach with "Allah o arlem". No one knows who is or not is a Muslim beside Allah. May Allah accept us, and forgive us. Amine.

[@thereisnodemocracy5070]

TURNED OUT THIS GUY WAS LYING,HE IS NOT ASHA'ARI AFTER ALL, HE IS YAZIDI

[@anonymoose9322]

Hyena in the middle doesn't even have a clue what they're talking about.

[@mase123456]

Hatun sounds like my broken hoover

[@CR7Update]

Mashallah imagine if hatun always listened diligently and focused on what the other person was saying like she is here she would become Muslim

[@bromalik8484]

'i'm gonna sound a bit like shamsi' 10:45 You mean you sound like a muslim because you finally quote salaf instead of philosophy? Don't use your brothers name like this it doesn't look good on you.

[@umargq80]

Exactly. And he said straight after "when i say salaf i dont mean Rabi al madkhali (حفظه الله)" sorry what??? When we say Salaf, we are not talking about Shaykh Rabi al madkhali either and neither is Shamsi. This guy is a fool

[@daniyalahmed687]

@@umargq80 what's salaf?is philosophy bad or haram?

[@umargq80]

@@daniyalahmed687 The salaf are the first 3 generations of this ummah that the prophet (saw) said about "The best of people are my generation, then thise who come after them then those who come after them" hadith in bukhari. And if you want to understand why philosophy is incorrect as a way of understanding Islam, the i reccommend you listen to Abu hakeems lectures 18, 19, 20 in the series "doubts around the dawah"

[@umargq80]

@@أمالياأفندي lol are you stupid or what. I have literally told you that when we say that, we are not referring to Shaykh Rabi. But you are telling me I am, either I am lying or you seem to think you know what I intend even though I have already told you truth and you can ask any one else who follows Spubs or is a part of spubs like Abu khadeejah and Abu hakeem etc. You are a fitnah maker, and you want us to be referring to Shaykh Rabi so that you can slander those people who revive the sunnah and teach it and destroy this Ummah

[@أمالياأفندي]

@@umargq80 oh right ,reviving the sunnah by calling others names!wow , why is it you who call yourselves salafis are the most ill mannered,who can't hold a decent discussion,and have nothing to say in your comments other than labeling other muslims as innovators and kafir,? is that the sunnah you know or the salaf doings? and while you r separating the ummah you have the audacity to whine about others destroying the ummah ?? you r doing a good job doing that without the help of others. you telling me anything is worth nothing;i ve seen enough delusional people in the Park to convince me that people tell themselves all sort of things which is unnecessary true. if that is your argument then Ali dawah said he is not ikhwan _not that there is anything wrong with alikhwan _ yet you salafis "rabi almudkali version" is still going around in every comment section calling him ikhwan ,this is hypocrisy to say the least.if u r honest then admit your double standards and denounce what is said about Ali ,then we can have a decent discussion about whether you r mudkhali or not ,and i am ready to retract what i said should you prove me wrong.

[@sleepingforest636]

Alhamdulilah, great discussion, excellent mannerism and articulation😁

[@al_worshiper6086]

Yeh excellent discussion. Now I understand why the ashaari position on this subject is the correct one!

[@mohammedsuleiman5066]

Mashaa Allah mohammed hijab presenting true akida ahlu sunna waljamaaa

[@lavishlyenigmatic]

Hatun stands bwildered and in awe of how knowledgeable Hijab is .

[@habibsvlog9609]

Shaytoon is getting feqh lessons now !!!

[@EsotericMedic]

@pseudoswitch H*tun, the w*man at the back, lol.

[@jessejames9441]

Lol they were discussing Aqeeda

[@rabborabbi1276]

Hatun just want to stay relevant like just stay in the middle of the camera😂

[@hashimnasser9967]

May allah guide Hatun, instead of hoping her to react against a Muslim rather hope for her to be inclined to the guidance of Allah. May Allah guide you Hatun. Allah guided Umar Ibn Al-Khattab at a time when the Muslims thought him being guided would be impossible.

[@vincec_1]

Did he not ask Shamsi the same thing last week

[@sharkyh7327]

Yes, which makes me wonder why he’s here again, asking the same question again and then also talking about how he didn’t want to be on camera yet last week and this week, he did, seems a bit off

[@vincec_1]

sharky H exactly

[@johnogroats3318]

Is he not allowed to ask the same question again? Is shamsi the end of the line in official Islamic reasoning?

[@vincec_1]

John O’groats no obviously not

[@Monothiest247]

Hijab is athari, both ashari and athari are ahul sunnah ❤

[@The-servant-of-ALLAH1]

Sorry, but they arent

[@TazKidNoah]

Hatun isn't trying to listen because she knows nothing & is just trying hope to catch conflict where there is none.🤣 She keeps tuning out of the distance behind the crowd😂 than says Salah can wait 2mins. When he says he needs to do Magreb. How shameless can she not read the room she's been listening? new update: the Blonde guy is not Sunni or Ashaari. He's Zaydi Shia now I am not sure if he's Zaydi who adopted Iran version of Shia understanding(Houthis) or traditional Zaydis which share a lot with Hanafi fiqh but are Mu'tazili in relation to Aqidah. All i know is that this visitor isn't openly telling the truth about himself.

[@GilesHartop]

hijab is a ashari without a shadow of doubt

[@goldenbananacaveman9899]

That "Hatun lady" with spectacles thinking how to disturb.However a good discussion underway..its deep discussion with young Yusuf...who likes to engage.

[@abouandalouss]

He do not know what Tafwidh means ...

[@mushtafaawilson376]

All this talk and Hijab still hasn't answered the question. Bro Shamsi is the most straightforward and always has proof from quraan,sunnah and statements of the salaf to back up what his saying.

[@testplay9628]

They both have their ways ! But shamsi gets to the point !

[@EM-tx3ly]

My point exactly

[@Abu_Sumayyah1406]

What a great conversation

[@latusalihyasalim4872]

Allah’s attributes are intransitive and can’t be interpreted and should be understood according to its apparent arabic description. however, no similarity no conditioning, no denying. and has to be mentioned in the Quran and Sunnah. when we say Allah has hand. it’s mentioned in both Auran and Sunnah. however, we can’t obnoxiously assume that it’s like our hands. also, we can’t give it a made up and different definition other than what it really means. just say hand and leave it that way. also, we can’t prove the attribute and delegate its meaning to Allah. we prove the name and the meaning without those exceptions i mentioned before. this why hijab refused the word physical because it’s irrelevant. it has the meaning of Aljismiya. which is wrong because no hadith or verse uses the word aljism or aljismiya.