Kolkata Rape & Murder I Angry Judge, A Polygraph for Sanjoy Roy & Global Protests I RG Kar I Barkha

[@mojostory]

Become A Mojo Story Member Now: kzbin.info/door/rdPiSPVW0rtRsI002BX8iwjoin

[@ASLAMANSARI-mw8yp]

I SALUTE MOJO BARKHA DUTTA JI FOR YOUR TRUE JOURNALISM GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR ENTIRE TEAM

[@DSRao-wu5vp]

Why not send to jail each and every one responsible for coverup and evidence tampering ?

[@devajyoti2753]

Including the police head and political parties for tempering the evidence

[@driltiza6931]

@AbhijitPakrashi-q3t You should always find an alternative than find fault with the existing system. You are talking about a leader who was not the only one who wrote this. Can you draft another Constitution which can please all and fits the solutions for all problems which exists? If yes, please go ahead. We all support you. If no, don't complain.

[@Huntress1111]

@AbhijitPakrashi-q3tyou’re like really dumb to think that!

[@driltiza6931]

@AbhijitPakrashi-q3t Why do we Indians need to confirm that everytime? Although we were colonised but Indians were never slaves like Abyssinians or Africans who were sold as slaves. There is also a group which believes India was not independent till 2014! (LOL!) Anyway, your answer is totally taking us away from the main point. Each and every culprit must be given capital punishment because they are not humans.

[@janetdcruz595]

Thnks Barkha,n all the doctors .Well said , the doctor in Kolkata deserves justice soon 🙏

[@subratachakraborty3125]

@Barkha...I congratulate you for consistently following this issue with due seriousness.

[@mojostory]

thank you sir- regards, Barkha

[@uncletom9321]

This is very sad how these media are targetting just west bengal. The issue is across the nation where the PM of indian is closely associated with many murderers and rpsts. They normalize rpe by not punishing their friends like prajwal revanna. does the most intelligent agency the cbi not know about this? it requires a mistaken leak of a usb? and then you have the supreme court going with a narrative about safety for medical workers not addressing the issue of women safety in india. safety of any worker is important. The whole govt system is evil.

[@sairabanu3996]

Dr. Kunal Sarkar , you have articulated so well

[@Piyushkumar-i9h3q]

The fact that a corrupt, mafia-mentality doctor like Sandeep Ghosh was at the helm of affairs at R.G. Kar Medical College emboldened a criminal like Sanjay Roy to commit the most heinous crime with such audacity. He believed he could literally get away with murder under Ghosh's patronage. Such was the toxic atmosphere in the college during his tenure. There are more questions than answers in this case, especially regarding the involvement of multiple individuals in this ghastly act. Sadly, even the anti-rape bill tabled by the West Bengal government does not focus on making workplaces safer for women. It seems more like a politically driven response and lacks detailed provisions for expediting trials or investigation.

[@tamangish]

Was Ghos involved in the Gang Rape ?

[@NidzShah-ps6kr]

Not just that, Mamta Banerjee tried to help him distance himself from the scandal by giving him a transfer so he could terrorise other students and continue to hold positions of power. She also sent 2 men to convince the mob of students to accept his transfer as there was much outrage abt it. And now she has the audacity to call for "harsher penalty" for grapists (she was secretly protecting), as if there already aren't enough severe punishments for these crimes. A Sandeep Ghosh can only exist in an extremely corrupt system, he and his master are exactly the same.

[@Vanillevirus]

The Bill is definitiely a politically driven response like you said. A Governement which fails to provide basic infrastructure like proper toilets in the Hostels hospitals, rooms for on-duty Doctors etc. is just pretending to care for the security of women.

[@sanjoyghose1952]

Workplace is not unsafe for women only but for men too, as as per news paper reports, there are multiple cases of false complaints of rape and sexual harassment by women to harass and to send to jail innocent men to take revenge. New proposed Act of WB, is totally silent on issue of false allegations by clever women. Hope, this proposal will never become Act.

[@isns2502]

Thnx to mamta govt

[@positivetruth]

Let's not shy away from implicating WB Govt and particularly the CM, who is in charge of both Health and Police Dept as the role of the Govt in the entire episode makes them responsible to create this unholy nexus for years, of criminals in charge of the medical education system in WB. Give all the audio, video recordings already available to any sane, independent person and it definitely won't take any time to find the complicity of the state govt in this crime. The people in-charge must not only resign, they must also face trial.

[@sushilkapoor1166]

Well said about the present govt and leaders of W Bengal

[@siddhartharoy7681]

Well said Dr Sarkar about the ray of hope from young generation❤

[@ritamohan8426]

I cannot believe that in today’s day and age, the CBI cannot find the criminals who did this gruesome murder.

[@mayaaniccha3290]

All evidence has been erased

[@md.sayeedverygoodreporting9350]

Who will stop such heinous crime in India where the convicts of rape and murder are garlanded in some states of India?

[@anuradharoy3522]

Who is going to watch the watchdog? When the government itself is corrupt, who is going to bring in change and enforce the change?

[@georgepattery4278]

We should bring this issue to the fore to make it accountable for the incident including the govt of WB.

[@itsabhi00]

Dear Supreme Court, there is serious concerns amongst common people about the seriousness with which you are taking this matter. This is an earnest request to you to bring this investigation and judgement to closure unearthing the nexus and direct/indirect involvement in committing and/or circumventing the truth. If CBI is reluctant then you should give them the free hand to go deeper in the investigation. Finally even if it means punishing some Chief Minister then you shouldn't hesitate. Then only people's confidence on you will be reinstated. Looking forward to you to bring the brighter days ahead.

[@xriamux342]

Yes, you are so right ! Enough is enough ! Someone, somewhere, knows what went on, that night. Everything, from the 3 phone calls, to the police not giving access to the parents, and urgency in cremating the body and so many loose ends. The whole world can smell a rat or rats that are involved in this murder & rape. But the highest institutions like the SC & the CBI cannot crack this case. Then they should be scrapped. If they have to torture Sandip Ghosh & get the truth out of him then so be it. As of now, I feel they've only jailed him, to protect him from the public. He will be safer in jail & he will probably enjoy a comfortable life , owing to his political connections. India, I cry for you.

[@nirmalkar69]

The CM of WB , WB Health Minister and WB Home Minister should stepdown immediately on moral grounds till the case is independently investigated and solved by CBI. All the culprits be brought to justice. Including officials of KP for tampering evidence and misleading cbi in investigation.

[@tilottamaguha1387]

Global Protest for RG KAR is a protest by the Indian Diaspora in 150 cities and 28 countries. It is happening on 8th September at 5pm at respective time zones. Coordinators across the globe have joined this movement and are organising protests in their respective locations. More than 300 people are volunteering and working tirelessly to organise this vigil. The demand is justice for the RG Kar victim. Indians outside of India are in solidarity with the cause 🙏

[@srihari772]

The display of national and international solidarity towards this burning issue and the cause is very positive, encouraging, hopeful, and is the needful that's focused upon amidst other burning issues worldwide!!

[@twotwo1bbs]

Tilo , Sayantan bolchi, ki korte hobe bolish

[@sumitabhattacharyya815]

Excellent discussion 👍

[@HinduMilitant]

Barkha ji We are very afraid and shaky about too much violence here in Kolkata. Pleass dont stop until the CM resigns or dismissed and President's Rule imposed.

[@Kur1934]

We North East can't pay much attention about Bengal demand, for their CM to resign, as we are busy thinking about our selves Especially Manipur

[@atreyee26]

​@@Kur1934 Please don't stop bringing the Manipur violence to light. We must all unite in exposing the political henchmen in every part of the country. The entire nation is being tormented by whoever is in power.

[@georgepattery4278]

You are right on spot....we need to be on the alert..

[@goodcitizen3775]

Dear Barkha we are thankful to God to have you as the most tenacious and honest journalist of our generation. Thanks.

[@narayanprasad4008]

The panel is spreading the blame thin ! They are not looking at it through the environment of political violence under Mumta B govt . Sandeshkali was overlooked ! The whole State has been run by Mafia gangsters and this Mobster CM has given herblessings to them . Decent Bengalis are fleeing the State . When the CM is involved in destruction of evidence , she should be held responsible and prosecuted for this crime and punished with jail term !

[@akadannuakkadannu6112]

Exactly.🙏

[@mubeenmubeen2854]

It is more than what you can take. A heinous crime committed in an unimaginable way at a hospital where we believe humanity serves . Unfortunately criminals know how to do crime with the safest way so that they could dodge law by dismantling crime scene and they did the same. Courts need evidence, I doubt if the real culprits would be punished when Government machinery protects them.

[@nasdoc1]

The question is how does a common man counter the mafia raj? Where does the common man go? All the institutions are compromised.

[@monud5833]

Worst mamatha worst police

[@neerajbali7]

Well done, Mojo Story and Barkha Dutt. This is what we need from good journalism in our country - a laser-sharp focus on issues that matter. If justice does happen in the end, you would have played your part in its pursuit.

[@mojostory]

thank you sir- lovely to you see here @neerajbali7 - regards, Barkha

[@victoriarego1426]

Justice to be served at the earliest.

[@ushamenon6975]

thank u Barkha and your team for trying your best to analyse this gruesome crime and letting the viewers know where we have been let down by the various authorities who are supposed to protect the citizenz who graciously chose them to powe.....a sad state of affairs... the international community should express their concerns and request the govt. to resolve the issue...thanks again

[@dineshpendharkar7210]

As a first step towards normalisation in WB, Mamata Bano needs to go. Country has zero expectations from this regressive lady

[@gtrinathpatra307]

Each time I listen this incident, teAr roll out from eyes

[@rubensg1982]

Great job. You are doing a very good coverage. Though at times I disagree with you about other issues ,. But your coverage on this issue , I must say , you are doing a perfectly fine job . Kudos. Keep going. With medias help we will get justice and as a society we will not stop till we get justice

[@SidVariar-o6m]

This is not a crime thriller- it's harsh reality in a STATE which REVERS and WORSHIPS WOMEN and WOMENHOOD

[@SourendraDas]

Thanks to the Indian diaspora in Great Britain, Australia and United States to support India even when they are not here. Shows how much they care of India even now. Thanks to all such NRIs. #JusticeforAbhaya #EqualRights #Justice

[@monojdas-gupta5918]

Young doctors protested too late thereby compounding the confusion. Nobody knows better than them the consequences of the hasty cremation of the victim of a suspicious death. They should have protested right at that stage. I think it was a momentous failure on the part of them. They had enough time to realize something fishy was going on. Even if they were unsure, they could have reacted on the side of caution. At this stage, their delay is proving fatal.

[@lakshmilucysaravanamuttu5400]

Education of men from a very young age is crucial and self defense classes and education on how women can enhance their safety.

[@Shukra9665]

Superb final point by you. Any social awakening is no match to stop a flourishing syndicate of crime.

[@ecomatters3416]

Thank you Barkha for keeping the topic alive. Hope the case will come to a closure with a fair verdict. Whole of India is watching keenly.

[@annettesom8209]

So proud of you Barkha.

[@mamtat7206]

See if we don’t stop this Corruption things from All involved. How can you go through Crowds and still Burn the Body without Parents Written Consent ? How ? And the thing is we think it is someone else’s Daughter. Guess what our Relatives could be next. Justice Now.

[@paulhigginssuting4618]

Barkha the great. Thanks for sharing the news.

[@aartithacker3249]

Excellent choice of panelists Barkha ... Dr. Sardar made some very important comments

[@yogainfo]

What about the lady that was molested on the way to the hospital? Why isn't anybody pursuing this aspect of the crime?

[@riyaansheikh7470]

Well she's a muslim plus she's not famous, so general population wont really give jacksh%t about her and other 900 cases that have happened since then

[@ushamenon6975]

definately we need to salute the young doctors...well said. We cant thank u enough BARKHA

[@srihari772]

Dr. Sarkar's closing remarks and positive views about the "unprecedented" young doctors and medical fraternity's relentless struggle and consistent efforts in keeping up with their protests, for their ✊ strong will for justice, were definitely of 👍good cheer, 🙏hope, and a goosebump moment for me too!!😌👏 A kind personal request please, regarding the choice of panelists. It really would be sensible on the part of your channel or for that matter any channel to bring in the "really concerned and relevant" people as panelists, similar to this one specifically, instead of the very often seen faces of 😖"shout overs, creating meaningless, irrelevant, and emotionally charged ruckus," some unfortunately happen to be the so-called "people's political representatives," and yet some have the dubious distinction to be the die-hard, foolhardy, disgustingly one-sided, and/or "plainly stupid" 🤡 party🥳loyalists and/or "psycho"phants??!!🙄

[@suneethahelen9756]

Well said Dr.sarkar👍👍👍👍👍

[@sabinaabraham7088]

The lesson is when similar incidents happened and got covered up the public kept quiet never came together to raise their voice . The criminals started pushing their boundaries . Hence now it happens in open public . Bottom line is corruption must be the deal breaker for any public official and politician. They must be punished and removed from their post immediately and forever. If the public and politicians can end a stand up comedians career in a jiffy with just one incident then why is corruption tolerated. Not one AAP politician has been proven corrupt why are they in jail for what. Public is least concerned again.

[@triggeringanalysis]

When people vote, they vote for corrupt, bad and incompetent politicians. When bad politicians deliver poor and corrupt administration then same people who suffer the consequence of poor administration, start hue and cry. They expect good administration from bad, corrupt and incompetent politicians. Unrealistic expectation! Start voting for honest politicians, start voting for AAP.

[@devajyoti2753]

Rightly said But are AAP honest? You seem to be an AAP man No political parties are ok

[@triggeringanalysis]

@@devajyoti2753 AAP is not an absolutely honest party but it is most honest party in comparison to other political parties and for now until other better option is available that is enough for me.

[@riyaansheikh7470]

​@@triggeringanalysis yeah agreed. At this point we just need to choose the lesser evil government

[@binuab1565]

Yeah we know where AAP is in Punjab and Delhi. They are equally corrupt. They also got into corruption at every level. To survive some level of corruption will always be there.. but this is not corruption here.. this is mafia run ministries of health and home ministry that has to come down.

[@sukamalchaudhury7201]

You are right but not to the end

[@drumanerle5926]

Barkha mam this news should reach to all women s even to villages

[@Saachi1114]

So eloquent dr. Sarcar

[@nipagandhi7251]

Dr. Kunal Sarkar, well said 🙏

[@crypton_8l87]

first time in years Barkhaji.. you're being true to yourself. but at what cost 😢

[@hummafarooq678]

Firstly what did CBI do, it was Kolkata Police who caught the culprit, what BJP is trying to doing is trying Political gains but when Manipur is burning they have nothing to say

[@alishaislam1858]

It's Sanjai Rai. Please dont confuse him with Roy!

[@Alina-h5l6e]

No where in the world this should happen to a women it’s very disturbing where we are heading to …..

[@Alina-h5l6e]

It’s a responsibility of the institution head Our profession is no more a profession it’s a business in Kolkata it’s a mafia

[@SourendraDas]

Drove parallels from the society they lived/live in UK, so true. #JusticeforAbhaya #Justice

[@manishamishra9552]

#JusticeforAbhaya

[@Shukra9665]

Barkha, Not sure why you said Alum. Alumnus - Alumni You are doing a great job of following up. Heart wrenching crime. Such a wonderful child was lost to unacceptable brutality. 😢

[@chandrimabhattacharjee3143]

Justice For R G Kar

[@mohammadhabibsiddiqui]

My salute to dr.sarkar for his eloquence.

[@binuab1565]

Highest Court of the country is a Joke. They could not find any reason to suspend the Police CHIEF and also make Mamta resign as allegations are not small and both ministries are under her and everyday they are making it worse for the truth to come out. CJI and Mamta is waiting for public anger to come down. And then push this away without anyone noticing

[@xriamux342]

It's a joke ! Corrupt politicians ate the highest court in India.

[@Subramanan-ys5wc]

Who give them authority to cremate the victim's body without let parents do their ritual rites beloved daughter,in other words No:1 physical evidence already had been destroyed.

[@prasanna6698]

Yeah, as Dr. Sarkar says every protocol was flouted...as happens in many institutions. All with huge impunity

[@RashiB-og7fc]

First time respect for Bartha dutt

[@Shukra9665]

Dr Sarkar, so well exposed. Such a helpless situation. Law enforcement is pathetic and their political masters.

[@positivetruth]

In this case rape, howsoever gruesome it might be, is secondary..primary issue is the nexus of miscreants and their racket which eliminated this young doctor and as it is customary to torture a woman by raping her, they did that too.

[@victor256in]

Mamata is the main culprit: Total dictatorship style control of a violent political party that is ruling in the state. CM. Health Minister. Police Minister. All roads in the Mob ruled state of West Bengal, lead to Mamata Banerjee

[@sukamalchaudhury7201]

There are corruption cases & administrative failure in RGKar management, so CBI may pl talk to the concerned mininsters too considering political involvement in the administrative matters.

[@drumanerle5926]

Dr KUNAL SARKAR respect to you please please we want justice

[@AmitMistry-dy7oh]

কুনাল বাবু আপনি কি সিজার লিস্ট দেখেছেন? ঐদিন আপনি কখন থেকে সংবাদ চ্যানেল গুলো ফলো করছিলেন?

[@annettemathews6423]

Protests Not to be organised on the street/road.Other citizens need to go about their work

[@amulyalabschandigarh1009]

Governance is the most important thing in society to make it safe which in our country is totally gets a free ride!

[@sentimonglaaoamazingvoice1647]

We want justice

[@amulyalabschandigarh1009]

Parents have already stopped sending their daughters to relatively unsafe states. I know of someone who got a fellowship in AIIMS Bhupeneshwar, her family says NO you don’t go due to safety reasons. AIMS is such a prestigious institution….

[@ingodwetrust8505]

KZbinrs are not allowed to post any video regarding the RG Kar hospital

[@vindhyacharan9195]

what? u mean rgkar words n videos both banned?

[@dorabee18]

I pray Justice prevails in this case. It's very sad the way the young Doctor lost her life and for her r family who lost a beloved daughter. The family was not fairly treated by the College and the Police. I pray things change in India and the medics can serve the sick in safety, ... from Malaysia.

[@radhikagaundar26]

Why isn"t CBI interrogating kolkata police officers

[@Shukra9665]

Barkha, I think they can announce big rewards for those who know the truth. Ultimately money talks.

[@suklachatterjee7258]

We should keep hope that 'AVAYA' will get justice, even facing mountaneous neglect of duties by WB administration and hashing up evidences

[@ushamenon6975]

thinking logically all of us know that a single individual cannot restrain even a ten yr old child...how could any single perpetrator restrain an adult female

[@meenakshinegi2079]

What do the forensics say? Why not report specifics?

[@SidVariar-o6m]

In one particularly gross CRIMINAL Case in Kottayam, Kerala, punctuated with political, public outcries and Church intervention, the same CBI, took 28 years(sic) to come anywhere near the TRUTH of the case- THE NUN Sister Abhaya case This case had relied on CIRCUMSTANTIAL evidence and not CORROBORATIVE evidence This Sister Nun Abhaya highlights the truth that crimes, in which politics, religion and public protests are intertwined, serving the cause of due process of law may not really be FORTHCOMING This Kerala Case bears parallels with the current Abhaya case, and asserts that even the BEST INVESTIGATIVE AGENCIES may sometimes, have to throw up their hands in despair.

[@samin096]

The international protest for RG Kar doctor started from Bangladesh. It started even before 14th of August. It started from Dhaka University,

[@ushamenon6975]

honestly comparing politically motivated violence that occurred in manipur to this gruesome murder cant be accepted. however all of us do offer our sympathies to the victims and their respective families in Manipur

[@vediclightlineage4661]

I have been watching this story for sometime from NZ.....but sadly despite all the exposures and questions....none of the media have asked the pertinent questions and issues: 1 ) why has not the law enforcement heads, Ministers etc called upon to answer the shoddy evidence preservation and crime investigative methods deployed by the police 2) why does the criminal ordinance allowing for quick disposal of the body not being questioned or flagged? why is there such a provision under law? Why aren't these questions of law not being flagged ? The law itself has not being questioned is an issue? Since many a time those who are targeted and killed are the poor and the weaker sections of society, where the victims are hurriedly buried always with the collusion and complicity of the police and the judiciary such as the magistrates providing a greenlight. Invariably allowing for key evidence to be destroyed and the crime being placed under the rug. India suffers from severe racism and castism and severe patriarchy etc and having authority under a law, or under color of law; which allows for a complicit law enforcement machinery, and other unduly interested parties and institutions the power to dispose of the body of a victim without due process of law or transparency should be the key questions here? Shouldn't there be a provision under the law preventing even the police from disposing of a body of a victim of crime for an allotted reasonable time; such as a few weeks or months as may be necessary in order to preserve the necessary evidence and to prevent the complicity of individuals and institutions tainted by corruption and malfeasance? Plainly shouldn't there be a mandatory law requiring and preventing the disposal of the bodies of victims of crime by the police and judiciary in a hurried and opaque manner which lends to the accusation of institutional collusion and corruption in covering up the crime of powerful interests.?

[@xriamux342]

You are spot on there. In India, sadly, the politicians rule the roost. Not the highest courts or the CBI. And whilst a lot of folks know, there's a political connection owing to this rape & murder, the highest court is still dragging its heels. Goodbye justice, Goodbye transparency. Sad state of affairs, really.

[@raveenayogasegaran7828]

This is not a joke.justice please

[@MrArup1965]

Frankly speaking all panel members including Barkha, failed or be more specific feared to point their finger to wards the head of the State affairs .

[@RamaDas-i1o]

Ms Barkha , please also talk about the growing influence of pornography in our society which might be a reason of such crimes against women.

[@holajeevan1021]

The hasty cover up and the audacity of the police and the lack of health ministry's intervention-calls for resignation of CM and punishment of the culprits and people in power for their inaction and cover up.

[@svpraveen5653]

Its a failure of the system meant for safety & security of women. SV Praveen Director LG. Review the system and its implementation.

[@TDRCSG]

Multiple, multiple investigations and court cases against TMC, Mamata Benerjee, her family are pending indefinitely. Her brother accumulated 400+ properties in last 10 years, the school teacher appointment scandal where one sitting judge accused another, and so many. All are getting lost in the quick sand of higher judiciary. Will this one be an exception?

[@AmitMistry-dy7oh]

কুনাল বাবু আপনি জানেন না যে ঐদিন হাসপাতাল চত্বরে কি ঘটেছে। আমি সকাল থেকে সংবাদ শুনছিলাম। আপনি ভুল বলছেন। তাড়াতাড়ি করে মৃতদেহ পড়ানো হয়নি । টিভি নাইন এর সাংবাদিক ওখানে উপস্থিত ছিলেন। কুনাল বাবু ভূল বলছেন।

[@niveditadey7347]

Lakhi bhander payment will increase by₹200 and the women will forget everything and vote the same govt to power

[@sujitmohanty1]

Barkha dutt in her element! The rise begins!

[@monojdas-gupta5918]

There is more than enough punitive law against a rapist.But precious little against cover up artists. So what hope for a victims to get justice?

[@MS-db2in]

Is Sanjoy Roy the only perpetrator? What about the system all round that enabled it? Why are we not including them in the crime? In fCt the system, ie, Sandip Ghosh is criminal number 1. And whis responsible for the mental health of this country?

[@annettemathews6423]

Soul A athma to be emphasised

[@AmitMistry-dy7oh]

বোরখা ম্যাডাম আপনার কংগ্রেস প্রীতি আছে আমি জানি. কুনাল বাবু আপনার বিজেপি সরকারের প্রতি প্রীতি আছে এটাও জানি

[@DanaLepinzan]

What future has a society where the most trusted professional( supposed to be ) Doctors and police , that are supposed to protect you and heal you , they are involved in a such a horrific crime !

[@pbaroi5747]

don't know how much change will take place in the system but at least people have come out of slumber in protest against the various systems within the system. It's sad to say but better late than never. Hope that things must change as well as regimes, if need be wherever when it's suffering from sepsis.

[@Scramblersj]

All nautanki happening ...culprit will be free soon.

[@RudraSarkar-n7q]

He is not Sanjoy Roy, he is Sanjay Rai.