Warrior Cats Canon Hierarchy

[@pigeoncolada2142]

plot twist Brokenstar is the fox that killed the kits

[@spiritwolf8596]

wow...yessss thats ...just...crazyy..never though of it that way...mind blown!!!

[@sentientshoelace111]

*x files theme plays*

[@somedragonbastard]

Dripping Honeycomb (Conspiracy music intesifies)

[@p1nkpawz571]

Dripping Honeycomb are u sure that he was close to foxheart cause it didn't look like it

[@p1nkpawz571]

Dripping Honeycomb the reason cats thought his mother was foxheart it because she spent a lot of time around him and then made her dep. so cat theorized that they were mates

[@QuietRage]

I was browsing the Warriors wiki once and I saw this glitch on Patchpelt's page where it moved all the names in the family tree box one step down. According to the Wiki, Adderfang, Patchpelt's father, is now Patchpelt's son. Swiftbreeze, Patchpelt's mother, is now his father, and Redtail is his mother. Spottedleaf, Willowpelt, and Leopardfoot are his brothers. His BROTHERS. And you thought the website family trees were messed up.

[@rosebudrosesnotificationsq5659]

Quiet Rage O.O

[@neonskylite2242]

They revamped the code so it looked better and didn't glitch.

[@arionarts9756]

Another error with a warriors info source: The "official app" of warriors that moonkitti mentioned, that says firestar' she parents are unknown, but then says who his mother is, I own that app, and it has a trivia game and like 75% of the answers are wrong. For example: Barley murdered Spottedleaf and Brightheart's first warrior name was Sadheart instead of Lostface. Greystripe gets to mentor BraNkenpaw instead of Brackenpaw and Cloudtail's mother was Sandstorm

[@psychticambitin7987]

Quiet Rage that happened in the tigerstar page too

[@eridenthe]

oml ur prof pic says it all XD

[@SelinaLee]

Petition for Moon to write her own Warriors Wiki

[@sleepylark]

butterflyidentity *signs petition*

[@eiixiirs4155]

yes

[@wizardwolf5242]

butterflyidentity I'm in !

[@ayengelic]

butterflyidentity *signs*

[@Moonkitti]

I have a full time job, pls don't sign this petition

[@amberpaintedglitch6891]

I vote Moonkitti make a Moonwiki XD

[@rosebudrosesnotificationsq5659]

Amberflame Animations YASSS

[@mariehayes29]

I 345th that vote!

[@Kosky555]

THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY THIRD VOTE

[@OliAtypical]

364th

[@karensturm7316]

*sighs paper* YAS

[@Lilacuity]

Yo where can i get one of hollyleaf's chainsaws, they would sell amazingly well among the dark forest cats

[@omithedank1262]

Lilacuity a

[@Bitchypoetsblog]

Lol!

[@lovealways6456]

Lmao ya

[@Tobynotfox]

My OC, Spottedsky walked up to you. "I can give you one for five mice! Just come down to twoleg place..." Spottedsky stared at you mischievously.

[@copicc]

*Leaf creek walks up* what? I heard mice. Wheres the mice?

[@seago4t]

0:47 Maybe Brokenstar made them fight the fox? it could make sense..?

[@Gxylord]

MissSeaGoat That's what I thought, maybe Brokenstar then used Yellowfang as a way to pin the death of the kits on to another cat rather than a fox (I'm guessing he just didn't like her for some reason)

[@lre834]

Bleach Martini Yellowfang threatend him that she will make Star Clan punish him, so he got rid of his mother (he also killed his father so yeah great cat)

[@lre834]

Bleach Martini i just looked up to see if its, like mentioned in the video, a fact that the fox killed them which is not. And there i also read the part were she threatend him. Poor Yellowfang her only son choose the wrong road despite having the choice

[@Weirdanimalboy]

+Tom Don't forget about what he did to Mufasa

[@lre834]

Weirdanimalboy who? xD

[@stopitn0w]

Erin Hunters: Lets make an official website! But we won't update it any time after 2010 though trolololl

[@hawkthespork765]

this is so true it hurts

[@iwakeupandboomimarat]

this hurts

[@Weirdanimalboy]

And let's remove the only actual fun game from it as well :D

[@quetzaal5414]

oof, too soon

[@nightiingale_]

Except, now they did.

[@eliza_da_hamilfan2636]

Holy crap! I didn't know Brokentail was also a shapeshitter!!

[@asshatdotorg]

Xx_The1stPalmsway_xX Omg XD

[@Weirdanimalboy]

Xx_The1stPalmsway_xX "a shapeshitter"

[@iwakeupandboomimarat]

sTARKIT!??!!?

[@riddledaj3055]

Eliza_Da_Hamilfan All I can think of is a cat's poop being little shapes.

[@subspace2913]

Oh yeah, a shitter of shapes.

[@binary6254]

Fun fact: Yellowfang ran into crookedjaw at a gathering once I think he was with Willowbreeze or Bluefur were there as well

[@OliAtypical]

ok

[@sweeyangchen3710]

Noice

[@hattercat_23]

DANG IT I wanted smudge to be Cloudtail's dad

[@glass_2526]

HatterCat ! Ikr! Same!

[@hattercat_23]

Actually they never said he was tho

[@peasinapodproductions1996]

HatterCat ! Yeah

[@Weirdanimalboy]

HatterCat ! Didn't Firepaw say he smelled different when he met him again as an apprentice? I thought they had a conversation about him going to the cutter?

[@parrotenthusiast1181]

No. Jake should be his father . Jake is everyones father. Jake is YOUr father.

[@Flameswipe]

To be honest I always took the 'Whitestorm having kits with multiple queens' things as just providing future warriors for the Clan. No romance, no cheating.

[@jiexin1886]

I believe that Yellowfang's mother has some trust issues. The so called Marigoldkit and Mintkit were Yellowfang's siblings, and for her mother to believe she killed them is really messed up. Also apparently on the wiki it says she's in the Dark Forest? Uhhhh

[@Moonkitti]

Her being in the dark forest is another one of Su Susann's claims that doesn't add up.

[@gracekim1998]

Moonkitti that’s even more confusing

[@katestarnes1709]

TheStylishWolf She was actually one of the best Warriors mothers up until right then

[@missldoherty7271]

Moonkitti• do u mean theyre saying yellow fangs in le dark forest?

[@huggawuggafamily]

I think they mean that because in Fading Echoes, (spoilers for oots) Yellowfang and Jayfeather visit the Dark Forest because they want to know what's going on there. Yes, I know this was 3 years ago.

[@cadenwiener9686]

For the entire Cats of the Clans book Mosskit was a tom. Does this bother no one else.

[@mocha3730]

IT BOTHERS MEEEE

[@BlackHeartKitti2]

The first time Mosskit was mentioned s/he was a tom. I wonder if the gender of cats changes based on which author wrote the book.

[@ratajamieson5828]

Caden Wiener Apparently according too Bluestar's prophecy, Crookedstar has two mothers. Isn't he lucky! (His moms are called Lilystem and Rainflower

[@arionarts9756]

Another error with a warriors info source: The "official app" of warriors that moonkitti mentioned, that says firestar' she parents are unknown, but then says who his mother is, I own that app, and it has a trivia game and like 75% of the answers are wrong. For example: Barley murdered Spottedleaf and Brightheart's first warrior name was Sadheart instead of Lostface. Greystripe gets to mentor BraNkenpaw instead of Brackenpaw and Cloudtail's mother was Sandstorm

[@featherthethirdwheel3738]

Not as much as Dovewing's second power. Her eyes can't decide on their colour! (Also, Patchpelt had kits with a sibling **Pukes**)

[@shulbur]

it's 5 AM and im awake watching THIS i love it.

[@kitti6273]

oh its 10 pm here

[@koinokakeras]

NeonGreenFox :3 Here were I live, it's 5:44 a.m

[@shulbur]

+Pelo de Folhas now its 1 pm

[@shulbur]

+NeonGreenFox :3 aka in norway

[@shulbur]

i seriously wasn't hoping this comment get 51 likes XD

[@Kittennedy]

That's a lot of what I have wondered I do and don't trust the Warriors WIKI for those reasons It would be funny if you animated the Warrior Cats movie

[@rosebudrosesnotificationsq5659]

Stormwhisker Productions Yes please X3

[@Weirdanimalboy]

Stormwhisker Productions With the running cycle Bluestar had in the spoiler video of Rising Storm? It would be amazing.

[@sammyhewens5893]

lmao i'd watch it if she animated it in the way she animates the I Spoil videos.

[@lre834]

all fine but you made one mistake: in Yellowfangs secret it is *suggested* that it was a fox an then (Spoiler) Yellowfang got blamed for it. And she believes it was a fox but when Thunderclan trys to get their kits back she probably realizes that he killed the Kits. it was never proven to be an Fox (Note there was also no fox scent)

[@meowtube89]

I noticed that too, it wasn’t a fox, yellowfang thought it was.

[@spira543]

I'm extremely scared for the movie

[@thefailinghawk5785]

Spira - literally me

[@akinarii1]

me too

[@maddiek8474]

I live under a rock. I HAD NO IDEA THERE WAS A MOVIE

[@stumpy1012]

Agreed, but I'm gonna try and drag my warriors fan friends to it anyways.

[@Chimera_VA]

Spira HELLBENT!!!!!!!

[@wacky9888]

7:45 Pffttt Thorrkit? Where's Lokikit?

[@subspace2913]

Lmaoo

[@revui5582]

lokitty

[@scootermcpeanuts6699]

Ah yes. My favorite character: BRACKERKIT

[@kit_nine]

lollllllllll

[@lpsgirlanimations3974]

LMAOOO

[@ellacatman]

Moonkitti, the queen of consistency.

[@ratajamieson5828]

Also, I have an incest theory- Everyone that trained in the dark forest in Thunderclan is related to Tigerstar. Ivypool is anyway...

[@yourfriendlylocalhitman667]

Chicory sugar and tigerheart r realatd

[@ashanimates1716]

How is Ivypool related? I’m only on Omen of the stars book 4

[@quantumflare]

Ivypool isn’t related to Tigerstar

[@ashanimates1716]

O O F I finished omen of the stars now

[@nix.i]

@@quantumflare Not blood - related, but mate related.Tigerstar was Bramblestar's farther, who mated with Squirrelflight who is related to Ivypool through Cloudtail.

[@onionisking7021]

Oh yes PLEASE don't let the wiki change the descriptions for the cats to the ones from the movie when it comes. I'm scared the movie'll will use ''Realistic" cat models, and not have 'some fun' with the cats, and make them look unique. Even the official book art can't decide what cats look like, and neither can us as a fandom. But the unique designs are the point. I almost wish we WEREN'T getting a movie, because I feel it'll bring 'official designs' and the wiki may feel the need to use them, but I really hope not. Thanks for the great video, Moon, Love it :3!

[@leobull4533]

OnionIsKing they'll be using the main book cover cat designs probably as they are the realistic illustrative designs of the character

[@pearlytheegg3838]

I'd like realistic cats in the movie, especially if they're well animated like Legend Of The Guardians: The Owls Of Gahoole. That movie was gorgeous.

[@aislynlastname6975]

OnionIsKing And I rlly hope that it's Handdrawn

[@samanthot_]

@Pearly The Fried Egg I remember seeing that movie when I was five or something, it was gorgeous... Too bad I can't remember much of it tho

[@sparkishay1499]

That actually makes me sick. Like the over-dominance of CGI created animated movies is pathetic. There haven't been any 2D style animated movies in the US in like... over 10 years. This would've been perfect, but no, let's jump on the CGI bandwagon like everyone else.

[@orangeyellow7066]

The Warriors Website Family Tree is probably where BrindlefaceXWhitestorm was born.

[@yeetmastercatto]

HA

[@BagelBoyboss]

We do NOT acknowledge that here!

[@mariacastellano6760]

Moonkitti becomes lzrdwzrd.

[@rosebudrosesnotificationsq5659]

MalachaiLikesMangos Funny Blzrd wzrd

[@jillianfry4520]

petition for moon to do an asmr or a video where she is just laughing. all her fans just love that laugh omg

[@valiendovrgasenores6943]

*How do you delete someone else's comment?*

[@hokmabattle3]

@@valiendovrgasenores6943 I don't know but I need to know

[@hokmabattle3]

This comment is interesting

[@morbius]

I have a bad fact. They were all in the matrix all along, and scourge was the boss of it all.

[@maddiek8474]

Definitely not a person NOOOOOOO

[@missldoherty7271]

Lmao

[@yeetmastercatto]

OHhhhhh YES

[@hornet2568]

More like a miniboss lmao

[@somepersonoutthere1068]

Legend says that if your on time moon will reply

[@giselleb5499]

Puppy Bananna I guess that legend wasn't true

[@somepersonoutthere1068]

yep XD

[@MythimnaImpura]

I think a lot of the first series stuff should be canon, yeah, except for some of the dumb early things.... like shadowclan being angry 5 times

[@Weirdanimalboy]

Mythimna Don't you mean EdgyClan?

[@MythimnaImpura]

Weirdanimalboy theyre not edgy, they're misunderstood(sarcasm sarcasm)

[@arionarts9756]

The "official app" of warriors has a trivia game and like 75% of the answers are wrong. For example: Barley murdered Spottedleaf and Brightheart's first warrior name was Sadheart instead of Lostface. Greystripe gets to mentor BraNkenpaw instead of Brackenpaw and Cloudtail's mother was Sandstorm.

[@motorcitymangababe]

Who had a better story than brankenpaw the broken? Sadface.

[@true_lovers_knot]

I REMEMBER THAT and my friend ATE IT UPPP

[@ZirconiaGacha]

I know this comment is old, but... Give that trivia to someone who just started reading and has finished arc 1, but only the arc 1 questions. And then give them the "right answers".

[@sherriannarnold3778]

Moon is not allowed as a prefix, but is fine for a suffix, at least that's what I've always believed.

[@Moonkitti]

Sydney Arnold but based on what evidence

[@sherriannarnold3778]

WTF you replied :P. None, it's just what I've always thought, since they use is as a suffix quite commonly.

[@Moonkitti]

Sydney Arnold ahh, I see. I was just wondering if you knew something I didn't

[@sherriannarnold3778]

No, I'm just saying what I've always believed, though I never use 'Moon' for anything anyways.

[@iman.schmol]

Moonflower is triggered

[@sunk1sed]

im deceASED thornclaw is over twice blossomfalls age why cant they just leave him be

[@Moonkitti]

At the very least it's Blossomfall and not some new warrior like Hollytuft or Sorrelstripe

[@jindedspeakevolution8461]

yes

[@jindedspeakevolution8461]

i think he's always been putting his head together with blossomfall, sort of makes sense but it is better than like sparkpelt. probably related somehow though

[@shadedrse569]

That's true. Tbh I honestly never thought he would get a mate

[@ThunderclanOakfang]

Eh, they're both consenting adults so I don't really care. I think the only relationship in Warriors where I cringed at the age difference was Pinestar and Leopardfoot. That was just...unnecessary and uncomfy.

[@mysryuza]

That moment Violetpaw reminds you of Starkit because of the name. XD

[@hallgeir9306]

You can actually trust more on the website than the app

[@Savannahmrowl]

idk if i like this su susann '^' were all ultra warriors fans

[@spiritwolf8596]

yes..thank you...just what I was saying!!

[@fickyfince4332]

What about that one friend I have..... ya Know..... that only read power of three Up To book 4 And the ultimate guide. And then stopped.

[@Goldy12378]

Savannahmrowl Yeah I don't think there is a such thing as a casual Warrior Cats fan.

[@mimi-wh8jw]

yup!

[@nix.i]

Haha, I spend my hard earned money on Warriors books.Try me

[@waffleweirdo1252]

Dovewing having blue eyes, then switching to green, WHY!?

[@toastedlite3034]

I was wondering why all those kits suddenly had names in the wiki

[@somepersonoutthere1068]

I love how they make these wonderful mistakes

[@ratajamieson5828]

I think Warrior cats app should be lower on the list...

[@mebanks-smith9079]

It is very outdated and doesn't have many facts

[@theorisingmatrix_mouse8991]

I tried the quiz on the warriors app, and because i smelt something was apaw (get it?) i checked each question in the books and on the wiki. It gave me 0, even when i knew i answered correctly. One question I got was "In Fire and Ice, which cat fell into the gorge and died?" My options were Leopardfur, Sandpaw, Whiteclaw, and Graystripe. Obviously I chose Whiteclaw, as i had recently read his death scene. The app said "NO DUMBARSE, IT WAS SANDPAW!!!" Obviously not like that, but it said Sandpaw fell off the edge and died. I deleted the app whilst flipping it off the entire time

[@maple_wing--]

I personally agree but. I'm confused how Thistleclaw changed through the books Xd

[@TobyandMavisforever]

I have a theory. By OotS, Thistleclaw had spent so much time in the DF that the place corrupted his mind.

[@celestialdetective]

@@TobyandMavisforever i read OotS as oooots

[@nathanhuerta4445]

I really dont like the new covers for the books.Seeing a image of one gets me really annoyed.The new ones are all "Epic" and "Gritty" looking when I think they look far worse than the old covers.Have you seen the new covers for "The Darkest Hour" and "The Last Hope"?They look terrible and I hope they dont change the cover for the first one again when the film comes out.That was my rant about the covers.Also I gave up on "Continuity" for the series and just said "whatever book i'm reading is the continuity i'm going with" because its much simpler that way.

[@rosebudrosesnotificationsq5659]

Nathan Huerta Actually, Dawn Of The Clans and Omen Of The Stars have the new covers (I believe) and they have some of the prettiest covers I have ever seen!

[@kukuandkookie]

Nathan Huerta I love the new covers! It's aesthetically pleasing and the old ones could be pretty in their own right, but they don't fit into the modern aesthetic and were often pretty inconsistent/contradictory in terms of art. The new ones are just really pleasing to look at, but that's me speaking from an artist's standpoint. To each their own!

[@nathanhuerta4445]

kuku88 I'm just a crotchety old man who thinks things were better "in the old days" and have a hard time accepting change.

[@kitti6273]

Im like that too haha

[@lre834]

Nathan Huerta well in the German Version its a Giant head of either Firestar or Sandstorm with 2 cats fighting (probably Firestar and Tigerstar or Bramblepaw) and a black cat beside them

[@strawberryqueen0382]

I like the wiki for when they have the summaries for books but the info on characters they have is so wrong like I believed Redtail was a dark-ginger for months until I reread the series.

[@oatmeal950]

So I spent 29 dollars on the warrior ultimate guide to read fake information?

[@crownedhyacinth]

my hearts hurts for Rosetail (look at what they did to her design in the wiki, it's just... uh yeah)

[@tiptaphooves]

Leafpool isn't on the app info because she's a disappointment.

[@thefailinghawk5785]

Fallout Kat - ikr

[@colorfulchameleon9891]

Okay, I watched this video when it came out, and I hadn't read Yellowfang's Secret. I assumed Brokenstar killed the kits by sending them to a fox, but after reading Yellowfang's Secret, something hit me. The book never says a fox killed the kits, only that Yellowfang detected the scent of a fox. She didn't even guess Brokenstar killed the kits. That's why it makes sense he had his "I killed Mufasa" moment in Into The Wild when he reveals he killed Mintkit and Marigoldkit. Yellowfang had no clue. Maybe Brokenstar spread fox-dung around the area, or just killed the kits somewhere there was fox-scent? Sidenote - Brokenstar in Into The Wild seemed like a boring, generic, "I am evil and am going to kill you!" villain, but when reading Yellowfang's Secret, he was sometimes kinda sweet as a kit (especially around Yellowfang), but as he descended into evil, he became really convincingly manipulative.

[@djayrainstorm7834]

You are the best in the youtube world *how much do I get paid to say this?*

[@spiritwolf8596]

right...lol!!

[@canigetahoyah6028]

D Jay Rainstorm 19 cents

[@charadreemurr1818]

When someone says Moon, and other clan names are forbiden: Ahem...MOONFLOWER, RUNNINGWIND MOONSHADOW, AND AMBERMOON (I'm sure there are more)

[@streamtheshapeshiftingfox3659]

I assume Moon- and Clan names are forbidden as prefixes but not suffixes, and I think I heard that Moonflower was a mistake. But there's no excuse for the cat Windflight at all. Especially since he's PART WindClan.

[@Tsukiakari-qb3tk]

@@streamtheshapeshiftingfox3659 Skywatcher, Shadowsight, Windflight, and others

[@streamtheshapeshiftingfox3659]

Elizabeth Moore I commented 3 years ago before Shadowsight was even a kit. So my point is moot.

[@Tsukiakari-qb3tk]

@@streamtheshapeshiftingfox3659 okay! Have a nice day!

[@Tsukiakari-qb3tk]

@@streamtheshapeshiftingfox3659 okay! Have a nice day!

[@noxixx]

0:25 Brokenstar turned into a fox and killed them

[@mayoi_nui]

In the 2nd book in the new seires, I think page 45, Twigkit is mistaken for twigpaw..

[@imitationinfinity7962]

So...does this make Mosskit a tom or a she-cat?? Because NO ONE SEEMS TO KNOW.

[@parrotenthusiast1181]

Mosskit does not obey your puny human genders

[@kroduss4802]

Mosskit is *_A L L ._*

[@numberjacksoctonauts7138]

I think she's a girl since Bluestar's Prophecy is her biggest appearance.

[@cosmicleonids]

When explained in Forest of Secrets, Mosskit is male. But all throughout Bluestar’s Prophecy Mosskit is female.

[@UUEBWISJSVUSSNIFFUEUE]

SHE-CAT!!!!! (uhhh....yeah, I read the books in two languages, and counted how often the, were named a she-cat, and how often a Tom, and the she-cat "won", so she is a she-cat for me)

[@TStewart1973]

Moonkitti: Mangas aren’t usually contradicting Me: *C O U G H* millies pelt color in the full color graystripe’s adventure vs main series

[@McMerlin11]

In Bramblestar's Storm, Graystripe stated Mistystar and Stonefur were his kits. They were born before he was! Get your crap together Erins

[@MsCreeperCrafter]

Well, did anyone notice that in Crookedstar's Promise, Shellheart is a boy... On the other paw, in Bluestar's Prophecy, Shellheart is a girl... FIRST EVER TRANSGENDER CAT!

[@youinanalternateuniverse]

Foxheart from Yellowfang's Secret also had a gender change from then to Crookedstar's Promise

[@sherriannarnold3778]

Don't forget Rowanstar...

[@noniekangas3142]

On the alligences in Bluestar's Prophecy Rainflower is called Lilystem.

[@peasinapodproductions1996]

There's plenty

[@annamurphy709]

Transcats are best cats

[@nightridges7344]

I'm so scared for the movie 😰

[@ryu6699]

The reason viki is not writing warriors anymore is bc she is recovering from cancer and she has had no time to wright warriors bc she is recovering is says so on her face book somewhere and that is why they didn't tell us the name of the new author bc it wont last for long from my understanding

[@ryu6699]

I could be wrong

[@tmaxim2651]

Wait but is the Brokenstar thing an actual contradiction? The way I always saw it was that the kits should not have been outside the camp, it was Brokenstar who pushed for them to be outside the camp, training too hard, too soon. In their training they were killed by a fox. It's still almost entirely Brokenstar's fault as he disobeyed the code(?), common sense and ignored or didn't care about the heightened danger he put the kits in. I mean original I did assume Brokenstar was the one who actual fought them to death... I don't know, I don't remember the details...

[@TehWhiteTiger]

Ahh where would wsrroors be without contradictions.. pretty sure the facts page on my site is somehow all not fact anymore.. like how Thunder has three different reasons for his name in......

[@clawcakes]

W S R R O O R S

[@ki4099]

Btw Su Susan isn't canon anymore... let's party.

[@maemarbles3786]

I thought LionFart was AssFur and FernCloudHasTooManyKits' father?

[@loupie]

No, Lionheart is CinderPelt, Brackenfur, Brightheart and Thornclaw's dad :3

[@rickbeter9898]

I always thought of runningwind being the father

[@minccinoluna805]

I always thought it was Redtail

[@fangleanimation244]

iM sO cOnFuSeD

[@honkerenthusiast]

your voice is so cute i'm jealous

[@honkerenthusiast]

but good heirarchy i agree. and great video!

[@emberaj3330]

Another thing: Dovewing is considered Bumblestripes (formal) mate in the wiki, which is DEFINITELY not true considering she just wanted to be friends with him, and not agreeing to be mates with him.

[@clairemyers1443]

Maybe Brokenstar did kill the kits and Yellowfang thought it was a fox?

[@peachtea7269]

Actually, I have a theory: Brokenstar scared a fox after murdering the kits. Problem solved.

[@jonas8481]

What about incosistencies in the main series?

[@venenososerpentine9865]

Maybe they were killed by a fox during a train lesson to kill foxes

[@venenososerpentine9865]

Or learning to defend themselves against foxes by brokenstar getting a fox for them to fight

[@georgecat2291]

I don't think apprentinces are forced to fight foxes, but hey maybe i'm wrong

[@Donnegail]

They're not but BrokenStar was insane, let's face that.

[@duasii1335]

Help I'm lost in all these comments

[@duasii1335]

***** thank

[@koinokakeras]

Arcticmoon Jamaa I've found you in this sea of comments

[@abandonedchannel24]

make the warrior cats movie

[@gracek3846]

YOU TOLD ME YOU NEVER READ YELLOWFANG'S SECRET, GIRL.

[@Moonkitti]

Grace things change

[@gracek3846]

Haha, good to know.

[@dragonflower5193]

I made 666 likes turn into 667

[@WowieItsMeowie]

Blossoming Story Good job. You're our hero.

[@gaunjee4182]

I don't know why su susann is even a thing.

[@rayjensen4799]

I don't mean to be rude but, I was wondering about your voice.. were you born like that or did you just not go through puberty?

[@Moonkitti]

i mean, born like that and not going through puberty would be around the same thing

[@rayjensen4799]

Ya i guess so! but you still have not answered my question. Again i dont mean to be rude.. cause... asking that might be a little offensive.

[@Moonkitti]

yeah sorry it's kinda personal

[@rayjensen4799]

ok then, thats fine. i wont ask anymore

[@lostsouls1573]

+Moonkitti I like your voice! :3

[@pixelapocrypha]

This video helped me figure out why I've had a harder and harder time getting into the books as the series goes on. It's the author's version of "too many cooks in the kitchen".

[@asri3l671]

This makes a lot of sense and I will honestly be using it to organize canon in my head 👍🏻 while also shamelessly inserting a few headcanons as well. Also, your voice is adorable and very enjoyable to listen to.

[@LooneyLei]

I just started the series, haven’t finished into the wild yet. But I love seeing this types of videos :)

[@Epiccatqueen-un1ew]

Omg I’ve never seen the actual cover of Crookedstar’s Promise, like without the jacket and wthhh he literally looks like something from the exorcist

[@LZRDWZRD]

Thank you so much for making this and I 100% agree with your order, especially the decision to separate the main series from the super editions. Like you said they're contradictory at points and don't always fit neatly into the events described in the first series. I think they should be seen more as "legends" or "stories" passing on rather than the usual omniscient third person storytelling. Guardians of Ga'Hoole had "prequels" and hell even classics like The Hobbit told stories with an admittedly limited or erroneous writer iirc. Heck they could have run with that premise and given these books an all new style to them. Anyways, great job!

[@pixelatedcorpse]

I haven't even watched the video yet but It's a rant video so it's already amazing

[@jeretoon8350]

Authors: moon can’t be used in a name Moonkitti: *sweats nervously*

[@-lightshadow-616]

When I looked in the wiki not to long ago and Dovewing was .5 years older than Tigerheart

[@neonkitty3574]

"Su Sussan's Suspicious Van" I Get It Now.

[@old4586]

Fireheart gets to keep the kit he found...su susans suspicious van...it all makes sense now. My mind has been blown

[@sophie2858]

I love this channel, it's like being in a book club and getting split sides with a friend that is funny as hell.

[@AmyMist]

I don't always agree with your Warriors opinions... But this time I do completely. Especially when it comes to the field guide stuff, since there's so much information there that just plain doesn't add up.

[@lincolnlogsforleeches1422]

The messages I was getting before Bluestar died was that Whitestorm had had a romantic relationship with her or before she went insane, had a crush on her and that was what we continuosly observed from Fireheart's point of view, Whitestorm caring for Bluestar, I still ship it

[@shadowy_o.o]

I know this was from 11 months ago but Whitestorm is Bluestar's nephew.

[@Hazelstiltskin]

I love your videos :0 this one was a turn from comedy but still great content, I totally agree with your opinions and presentation of which fact gets priority and even if I didn't, which would be weird because you are completely logical here and you backed every single thing you said, I would still appreciate the time and effort you put into sourcing your words and explaining why you think the ranks you placed are correct. I also totally agree with you on the movie adaption. if it even makes it out of production, it better stay in its own little quarantined corner and not taint our canon world™ with its budget-cut edited abridged one

[@kendollguy97]

You know, I know everything about Warriors because I keep up with chats, read all the books, proofread, and still people don't know anything. Wiki doesnt know anything, they got the story for Yellowfang's Secret wrong, her kits were killed by young age. I do agree with the things you say Moonkitti, I feel all the pain.

[@succulentstan3912]

The art in this is actually really nice :D

[@pokeslash1416]

This is actually really helpful. I'd be interested in seeing you write up a collection of your own Warriors timeline, but of course that wouldn't be a TON of work. Thanks for the info on Su Suzann, I had no idea Vicky was even no longer answering stuff because I've been totally out of the loop on Warriors. I'm getting hardcore into it again (never really left the fandom) and still very passionate about the lore, so it's nice to see a vid about it. Totally agree on both the movie and the website. The website has always been frankly terrible for getting info on the cats, and a movie will likely have serious changes from the actual series purely because they're crunching it down for a movie (see Legend of the Guardians: The Owls of Ga'Hoole) and shouldn't be treated the same as book-canon. I'm curious on your opinion of Dawn of the Clans vs the Warriors Guidebooks. The Guidebooks are rather inconsistent sometimes but they did give us our first look at the lore of how the clans started, and it's been a subject of debate between my friends and I on whether it's what actually happened, has been warped by time and forgetful generations, or it's just an error. I gave up reading Dawn of the Clans because even though the lore fascinated me, I found the first book to be incredibly inconsistent and the I didn't like the jumpy writing or the weirdness characterization much. I might give it another try because I was younger then, but I distinctly remember completely losing track of which character was who because they couldn't stay consistent. Anyway, I'm sticking to the special editions for now. I really enjoy that people like you are still having fun in the fandom and just paying attention to your own canon, it's always good to know we can discuss our fanstuffs in a calm environment. I hope the movie isn't to detrimental to the fandom at large.

[@Moonkitti]

I consider dawn of the clans main series books, so at the top of my list, over the field guides. The dawn of the clans gets better as it goes, honestly.

[@pokeslash1416]

It just occurred to me... Could we solve the Brokenstar issue by saying that a fox attacked, and he forced the kits to fight it instead of defending them? Allowing a couple of kits not even at apprentice age fight a fox alone is close enough to a murder by his own paws.

[@rowanheart8122]

I read Ravenpaw's Path and I was super confused and bothered when Brambleclaw was referred to as an apprentice, but Squirrelkit and Leafkit were there

[@codorlune6672]

For some reason I’m rewatching so many of your videos during quarantine, But my thoughts on the thistleclaw thing, the only thing I can think would make sense is that Bluestar’s view on Thistle was tempered with age, obviously this only kind of works if you take it in a bubble, but this is a halfassed possible explanation for Bluestar’s feelings about Thistle. Bluefur in the SE is incredibly dramatic and emotional, the whole book is about her dealing with grief and how that made her a not so great person, so her taking thistle WAY too seriously and being HELLA dramatic about how he’s gonna cause the end of the world could work. So her being older and having hindsight in forest of secrets she could be like..huh 20/20 I was pretty paranoid.

[@GiaBird-The-Jumin-Han-Lover]

4:53 oh thank goodness the "moon" name is safe, i have a warriord oc "MoonDust" and i wanted to use her in my own comics/mangas im making. (lol they probably wont really be published but just for me and my vids) and i really don't want to break any warriors "rules" because then i'd sound immature, and that i dont respwct true warriors, which i DO love the warriors books with all my heart. So now i have an almighty Moonkitti that says its ok, so now its fine! Thx for clearing this up for me Moonkitti!

[@seapinecone2869]

0:24 actually Yellowfang thought a fox killed them, but it is later revealed in that book that broken star killed them

[@finnium2814]

I do really hope they don't put the movie pictures into the wiki, everything would be scrambled up XD

[@pokemoon7367]

Here’s my personal head canon for the ash paw and from fern paw stuff: it was dark’stripe who was the father and they weren’t close by the time we saw them in a book and when brindle’face took in cloud’kit that’s when they broke up offscreen and after cloud kit,ash kit and fern kit were Apprenticed, white storm finally took his move and had kids with her. This is my personal head cannon and I think it makes the most sense due to the fact the dark stripe looks like both of them, and could reasonably be their father due to the fact he’s a young Tom that had no mate in his life that we know of.

[@ibeamemeyboi9098]

Congratulations for another thousand subscribers

[@Stounyx]

Moonkitti, I love your animation style ^^ and there too many things that happen that contradict the main series to count

[@g.snapdragon9817]

For The yellow fang and kits problem I think broken Star DID kill them but he blamed it on a Fox in yellow fangs perspective, making it look like she couldn't heal a fix bite and in turn as a bad medicine cat or something like that idk

[@g.snapdragon9817]

*Fox bite not fix

[@fantasiesbyjuls]

If I remember correctly, in yellowfangs secret, the kits that she was blamed for killing were her mother’s newest litter...

[@midnight4914]

I think brokenstar killed the kits and blamed it on a fox and then realized he could blame it on yellowfang after

[@venusserina]

My Canon list: 1. What I like the most 2. Everything else