When you realize that Mashiro's VA is only 16 years old, and she's doing really well for her age:
@balladmusicrules4 жыл бұрын
when you realize bang dream is one of the most played games and they got a *bad* singer for a band but you excuse it because she is 16
@April-fr2pf4 жыл бұрын
@@balladmusicrules hey don’t be like that, she’ll get better over time
@franciskusdevinsorenshalim45694 жыл бұрын
@@balladmusicrules really bashing at a 16 years old girl?
@eternal47804 жыл бұрын
@@balladmusicrules bro she sounds fine, i genuinely love her singing
@balladmusicrules4 жыл бұрын
@@franciskusdevinsorenshalim4569 im not bashing these are the truth i always turn my volume down when i play their songs it hurts my ears yall act like her voice is good when its not other vocal's voices were amazng in their first songs and morfonica's vocal sounded like a dying cat
Morfonica is the only band that has violinist in their band but no pianist.
@astridicegenesiss5914 жыл бұрын
Keyboardist not pianist
@djwoof7344 жыл бұрын
@@astridicegenesiss591 almost the same thing
@astridicegenesiss5914 жыл бұрын
@@djwoof734 Not only Morfonica, there is no band in Bandori that have pianist.
@djwoof7344 жыл бұрын
@@astridicegenesiss591 Ik but I'm just saying that Morfonica is different from the rest
@astridicegenesiss5914 жыл бұрын
@@djwoof734 I understand but I just want to point out the fact that using the word pianist is wrong.
@lovemagicfantastic4 жыл бұрын
I love the vocalist’s tone a lot even though she doesn’t yet have the star factor to mirror the instrumentals. She’s only 2 years older than me, but she’s definitely better than many adult pop stars I can list. Her vocal profile is definitely distinct from the other vocalists, which is very crucial to her identity in BanGDream. She has so much promise within the franchise even for her newcomer status. I can’t wait to hear her voice mature and convey emotion!
@warofdefeat-TH4 жыл бұрын
wait?? You're 13 years old?
@RaGiAn874 жыл бұрын
The vocals are weak. If you can list adult pop stars worse than her they aren't even singers in the first place because she is bad. I'm not hating on her, she has promise and I really want her to improve, but I'm just stating the truth.
@PinkySoda4 жыл бұрын
She's good but her vocals are week she would really benefit from learning to project her voice . I a really good example of a strong vocalist is Yukina's Voice actor she has a very strong voice
@PinkySoda4 жыл бұрын
@@RaGiAn87 I agree I'm a year younger and I can say that she has promise but she needs to learn to project her voice
Everyone here be talking about the vocals. I'm here like "damn i like the violin"
@esaualfaro34474 жыл бұрын
Violin is amazing. The vocals aren´t that bad honestly. In fact, I think her vocals are perfect for the type of music they´re making. They´re not Roselia, so I can´t expect a Yukina that steals the whole show with her voice.
@classikbat82144 жыл бұрын
Well that's Ayasa for you. Can't believe that one of my favorite KZbinrs joined a band for one of my favorite franchises.
@leahshirokane14254 жыл бұрын
ClassikBat yeah ikr!
@isatahir39714 жыл бұрын
Popipa use drum afterglow use drum roselia use drum too pasupare use keytar hello happy world us dj deck and morfonica use violin that nice thoo
Could you stop saying that the vocalist doesn't sing well? understand well that she is still a girl, for her it must be difficult to see that she is being criticized,obviously she's just getting started and she's not going to have a voice like the others vocalists in bandori
@sarinhaasa4 жыл бұрын
right? For me she is one of the best vocalist so far, Yukina is my favorite tho but i can't lie when it comes to Shiro. Her voice is powerful and calm what i think is beautiful
@randombangdreamplayer43754 жыл бұрын
@@sarinhaasa isn't ayas voice also calming
@sarinhaasa4 жыл бұрын
@@randombangdreamplayer4375 yeeeeees
@akekeke4 жыл бұрын
preach
@akekeke4 жыл бұрын
She's only sixteen and getting started. I personally love her voice tho, it's very unique and has a soft feeling
I come back here after a year to see how far Amane-chan've come. I remember how her voice was criticized by haters even on her Twitter but Bandori 8th live just prove them wrong and i'm so proud.
@taichik53684 жыл бұрын
フル出してくれるのか…! 運営神すぎ! 八潮さんに完全に一目惚れした…! これから推します‼️
@exfreedom3714 жыл бұрын
これからの成長が楽しみになるようなボーカルの歌声。何より… ましろちゃん可愛いスギィ!!
@izumi114 жыл бұрын
when i first heard mashiros voice, ngl i thought it was underwhelming, but then i found out her seiyuu is only 15!! honestly im looking forward to seeing her growth as a vocalist now ☺️
@alvinhow79964 жыл бұрын
I know right? She even voice in D4DJ with Oyu.
@bronymon084 жыл бұрын
I bet you haven't even heard good vocalists on that age like JUNNA who debuted at 14 years old at walkure so ehh...
@toyalovemail4 жыл бұрын
@Idolmaster08 junna has nothing to do with this, why are you bringing her up in every comment thread?
@alvinhow79964 жыл бұрын
@@toyalovemail they're probably jealous of Amanesu, that's why.
@tunaparfait92784 жыл бұрын
Her voice is actually not bad at all, she's just inexperienced. Just give her time. And I'm sure JUNNA has also done a lot of voice lessons and training to achieve that level.
I remember the time when lot of fans were hating on Popipa because of Kasumi's vocal. It seems like now they hate onMashiro. But look at Kasumi's voice now. I'm sure it'll be the same for Mashiro's VA, and shs's only 15! I'm happy that more people is(are? I don't know ._.) defending her now
@rizkyansyahaditya67264 жыл бұрын
Ikr, kasumi voice has grown so much, like from their first song like tokimeki, and their recent song like returns or initial, her voice became stronger, more high pitch, and blend with the mix really well. Im sure mashiro will get a lot better (especially bang dream have a strong connection with esp academy, which helps kasumi VA with learnig guitar and vocals)
@nekochan32314 жыл бұрын
It's not that bad, but it's pretty mediocre. For now. We'll see
@keyrienliana65614 жыл бұрын
She only 15? Wow
@dwiatmika95634 жыл бұрын
@@rizkyansyahaditya6726 it's not like aimi can't sing at the start of bandori it's more like she have to sing as kasumi which is hard, watch her imas performance then compare.. comparing it with kasumi when it is not the same case is just dumb lol
@xz-guvnor84114 жыл бұрын
@@dwiatmika9563 its the same for amane then it's not that she can't sing but she just new to this genre and need to sing in character for the character that shy
@亞爾密紐謨ヴァイス4 жыл бұрын
昨日発表だったのにもう発表かよw 早すぎwいや神運営かよw
@otaniemiri4 жыл бұрын
See a lot of people disliking the vocalist. It’s perfectly fine to not enjoy her voice, but please give her a chance to improve as the band develops its music. Don’t blame her for ruining the band after half a song.
@otaniemiri4 жыл бұрын
jin woo kim That’s the thing, though. She isn’t a pro. She started work around a year ago and has only professionally sung ~2 songs before, with one being a group song. As other people in the comments are saying this is probably to do with the whole butterfly motif symbolising growth
@mr.spooky61344 жыл бұрын
I mean, why? U think this is a game for ppl to train?
@philosophyz10864 жыл бұрын
I agree. Remember Rimi was playing guitar but she is the bassist in poppin party. Ayasa even just start learning keyboard after she joined poppin party. It’s definitely fine to be not professional.
@hunter_michelie44254 жыл бұрын
jin woo kim >she is a pro She is fucking fifteen!
@chilinhmainguyen164 жыл бұрын
True, Mashiro VA 16 year s old btw lol
@Zevven4 жыл бұрын
What's wrong with her vocals? She is seriously very good , maybe less confident and loud , but damn that voice is beautiful and fits the music very well.
@imposter_chan26363 жыл бұрын
personally, i believe her vocals fit the song the best.
@canyouguesswhoiam55393 жыл бұрын
Her vocals suit this song the best, I can't imagine Yukina, Ran, Rei, etc sing this maybe Kasumi since she sing it on Astral Harmony
@imposter_chan26363 жыл бұрын
@@canyouguesswhoiam5539 exactly, like else do these people want.
@jayceonbishop38613 жыл бұрын
I know I'm kinda randomly asking but do anybody know of a good site to watch new series online?
@tommygraham47273 жыл бұрын
@Jayceon Bishop lately I have been using Flixzone. Just search on google for it =)
@ななぎ-p3e4 жыл бұрын
待ってました!!バイオリンに魅了されたオタクの1人です
@CuriousNeon4 жыл бұрын
I think this song is really a good introduction. Her voice is like a butterfly, light and weak. But when they sing together, it feels like it creates an effect, a butterfly effect, which is powerful enough to change something like the harmony they have~
i dont really understand why everyone is so hard on mashiro's va for not having a good singing voice. her voice is supposed to be like that to fit her character's personality and im sure her singing will get better as she and her band progress. also as a teen, all this critisism shes getting isnt going to make her feel any better about herself because she already has the pressure of acting along with a cast made up of grown, experienced voice actors and musicians. what she needs at this point in time is a little critisism but also plenty of support and love; we dont want to push them down right as they debut. bushiroad pick great voice actors for their characters and i think as a voice actor shes already doing an awesome job. i personally think that even though her singing technique isnt there yet, she has a very sweet voice (unlike me lol) and has plenty of room to grow along with her character. i hope everyone will continue to support morfonica
@alvinhow79964 жыл бұрын
Agreed, almost everyone will hate them at first, but few years later. The interest will grow back on them again.
@HadeaRin4 жыл бұрын
When the extra band is opened with RAS and Argonavis.... well, it is like asking for impossible to not expect something out of Morfonica.
@seikaadhes15524 жыл бұрын
Bad or not , at least her voice make u say "ah thats morfonica" just like kasumi and aya So i think its a good thing imo
@miyu_kiriyaki4 жыл бұрын
I fully agree with you. People should stop comparing her to other seiyuu or wish her to be exactly like them. Like…she is her own person. Or well, she is acting a character which is different than others for a certain reason. We don't necessarily need more powerhouses that immediately catch our interest because of a strong or powerful sounding like voice like in Roselia or RAS. To be honest I also expected a bit deeper or powerful voice in the beginning when I first listened to it but I quickly started to like it actually. The violin gave off classical vibes and suiting to her character her voice is softer. It does fit very well in my opinion. I'm also pretty sure she will be able to go from a softer sound to more powerful one day although I do believe she is actually doing a good job. Singing isn't that easy and takes a lot of time to practise as well. I know that very well since I also sing in my freetime. (in singing groups too! I even own one) I might have never taken singing classes at all but I do take critic from friends, like my timing is sometimes off at self collabs. We do learn and will improve but just give us time. I don't if Mashiro's seiyuu needs to put some pressure on her voice to sound like that but if she has to I really respect her even more for keeping that up. I also do impressions and am used to do darker voices (like Yoshiko/Yohane from Love Live) but once I was chika from love live in a singing group. The problem is that her voice is very high and the person that asked me to be their chika believed I could pull that off, but whenever I sang as her I sang really quiet and I literally killed my throat. So I stopped being in it. I didn't want to damage my voice even further and my throat to hurt like hell. For real, people should at least respect her for her hard work and her current achievements. Not everyone is born as a natural talented singer. And it takes time to improve. You might say she isn't as talented as Yukina's seiyuu yet for example. But have you ever sung yourself seriously and experienced how hard it is? Those singers from groups I'm in, who have heard Mashiro's voice also support her. We also take our singing seriously and aim to be as good as such singers from bandori, love live, utaites, … Have a heart and learn to see things from a different angle. Oh and not to forget, Mashiro's Seiyuu isn't pulling the whole band down. The whole band is going to help Mashiro's Seiyuu up. They will help her grow.
I actually adore Mashiro’s voice, and I think it’s incredibly impressive for a 15 year old voice actor to sound this good! On top of that, there’s still a lot of time to improve! Show her some support~
@ichigosaionji84424 жыл бұрын
Shindou amane really seems like a raw diamond, rlly excited for her improvement
@Lxuminee4 жыл бұрын
The song still sounds gorgeous none the less. I could see myself liking this along with Roselia. Given the vocalist does need practice but she’s only 15. I don’t doubt she will have gorgeous vocals when she’s older if she didn’t already have them now.
The violin is different from what we had so far and that's actually a welcomed change this band sounds really good.
@motleycrow77714 жыл бұрын
I THINK HER VOICE FITS THE AESTHETIC OF THE BAND OKAY,, I LOVE IT SM AND JUST WAIT TIL SHE RECEIVES MORE VOCAL LESSONS IT AINT GNNA STOP HERE SHES GONNA BE HITTING SOME HIGH POWERFUL BELTY NOTES LIKE AIAI!!!
If you read Mashiro’s character profile, it is stated that she feels overwhelmed by other talented people around her, so it seems that she thinks that she’s not as good as the others, she knows that she’s lacking in talent and she feels down about it Someone made an analysis thread about Daylight MV and it seems to portray Mashiro feeling “behind” from her other bandmates and that she feels the need to catch up to them...she wants to grow, she wants to change quote tweet: heres another reason i like the video!!! we cut to the girls but it’s only ruirui, touko, futaba, and nanami. while they are shining mashiro isn’t. (this also might be a play on popipa and tokimeki experience!!) Morfonica’s motifs is butterflies, and butterfly usually represents change/growth/transformation, so I think this is likely to be the main theme in Morfonica storyline...”transforming” into a new, better version of yourself, just like a butterfly It especially seems to be what Mashiro’s character arc would be, as she feels “behind” from the others...but then she’ll eventually “transform” into a better version of herself, which also means that she’ll grow as a vocalist too I also wonder if the fact that Mashiro’s seiyuu is still at very young age is also intentional...since change/growth seems to be a major theme in Morfonica, I wonder if they want to reflect that both in-game and irl As Mashiro grows as the time goes on, so does her seiyuu It’s possible that they probably want to emphasize that theme of “growth”, thus they went with that decision for her seiyuu, after all Bandori has a bit of 2D/3D parallels sometimes Well this is just simply my personal thought, but I feel the need to write this so yeah
@salsabilaangelia19454 жыл бұрын
Wait this is from a thread on Twitter (anyway I was the person who wrote it), but anyway thanks for posting it here, I hope this will make people understand regarding the choice for Mashiro’s vocals
@xz-guvnor84114 жыл бұрын
@@salsabilaangelia1945 oh fuck i forgot to credit it sorry XD
@salsabilaangelia19454 жыл бұрын
X Z-guvnor lol it’s okay
@soulcraftyt49234 жыл бұрын
@@salsabilaangelia1945 Thx for the explanation and thx to the poster of this in yt as well
@holymcdillydawillyinthechi8734 жыл бұрын
Still can't believe I took the time to read this but I have no regrets what's so ever...
@naomichacha19994 жыл бұрын
She gave me chills and made me cry.. Her voice is so pure and innocent and she has so much room for improvement! Some of y'all are judging her voice but I believe that there shouldn't be a wrong or good in arts.. Here I could feel the emotion in her voice and the effort she has put in her work
@otto61854 жыл бұрын
Please, say it louder!
@dmeforever94963 жыл бұрын
I dont listen her vocals at all cos the violin is good
@takana_katana_kanata3 жыл бұрын
@@dmeforever9496 Did you think that you heard the music from fans' first live and fans cheers? If it is said, it is another good. But if you don't know their live, please watch them. They grew into a beautiful butterfly.
@dmeforever94963 жыл бұрын
@@takana_katana_kanata i heard first time from this video, the violin stand out more than the voice, but i never say her vocals are bad. It's good actually and i love it, it's just violin that stand out
@takana_katana_kanata3 жыл бұрын
@@dmeforever9496 Oh, I apologize for a little bit of interpretation. I thought that I wanted to dislike Amane.
@sidebook14 жыл бұрын
とりあえずモニカでバンドリーマーが手のひらドリラーばっかなのは把握した
@蜜もち4 жыл бұрын
ほんとそれだよ
@darthrevan87374 жыл бұрын
English community: *hating on the new vocals already* This is why we can't have nice things. I'm really liking them as a whole already, really excited with the new things they're gonna be bringing us.
@kavvw5594 жыл бұрын
Darth Revan Honestly, I wouldn’t say the comments are hating on the vocals, just saying she needs some improvement. But, i can understand why her vocals are like that since her VA is only 15 and doesn’t have fully developed voice.
@junjun15144 жыл бұрын
kaylie v but a 15 years old person can also sing professionally so
@miyu_kiriyaki4 жыл бұрын
@@junjun1514 you still would need to consider that singing also takes practise and with that a lot of time. remember school is also a thing. And not only that. not everyone is getting born as a professional or talented singer. Of course there are some that might be but that doesn't mean that every singer is like that. It's not a valid point to say "there are people around that age that are professionals, so?" You can't and shouldn't expect everyone to start on the same level or so.
@tori47704 жыл бұрын
@@miyu_kiriyaki you just changed my perspective. Thankyou.
@justinrafael2274 жыл бұрын
sound wise, i think bushimo just wanna have this band has some different things really, but it ended somehow flop. The violin is good tho, and imagine this band without violin and bit of chilidsh vocal? than more or less, this becomes second version of Roselia in the game
Everyone out here talking about the vocal is bad BRUH Her voice is fine not that terrible tho. And the violin is really doing a decent job!!!! I really love it.
@248.n_n4 жыл бұрын
meanwhile I am addicted with the bassist and can't stop thinking of LoZ while hearing to this
@248.n_n4 жыл бұрын
@Ye Nan yes, she can still improve but damn I hate there are people who continuously insulting her on social media like srsly I think she will really have harsh time. Hope she can handle it and finally one day she can bash those haters with superb vocal