Most OVERRATED Player From Every PL Club

Adam McKola, Rory Jennings & Buvey debate who they think is the most overrated player from each club in the Premier League.
Join The Club’s official Super 6 mini-league now using the code CLUB23: super6.skysports.com/league/c...
Full season competition T&CS:
Listen to the FULL PODCAST here: open.spotify.com/show/2tLV2wP...
Join The Club
Linktree - linktr.ee/theclublive
TikTok - / theclublivetiktok
Twitter - / theclublivetw
Instagram - / theclubliveinsta
Follow the lads on social 📱
Adam McKola
KZbin: / @adammckola
Twitter - / adammckola
Instagram - / adammckola
TikTok - / adammckola_
Rory Jennings
KZbin: / @roryjenningsfootball
Twitter - / chelsearory
Instagram - / chelsearory
TikTok - / chelsearory
Buvey
KZbin: / @buvey
Twitter - / lawrence_bury
Instagram - / buvey_
TikTok - / buvey_

[@jaforgah]

how rory has made talking about football is full time job is bonkers to me

[@overcorpse]

He knows where the bodies are buried.

[@dunno23]

Ditto.

[@JamieB63]

He hasn't. He's made a living from purposely saying the opposite of the masses, in the hope some of it will pay off, so he can look more knowledgeable than people and look smug.

[@donegal7]

its not what you know its who you know. so many ppl around the world are clueless or shit at their job but nepotism or influence is what get you the job.

[@celtic69]

his full time job is winding people up and he’s very good at it

[@victorlopez-ks8og]

Since when is “overrated” and “bad” the same thing?

[@filltheglass2618]

They didn’t say it was… they clearly addressed players that are overrated

[@robbieavill7805]

Totally agree most of these players are just bad players

[@darrenfearon4288]

I think Romero's passing is underrated but I hate when they scapegoat players who do one mistake in a game but defend Romero when his mistakes cost the game.

[@wespicedmemes]

@@filltheglass2618nah adama Traore who barely gets a kick anymore these days, they called him overrated.

[@kurtsudheim825]

It's basically just bad but people don't realise

[@nadimparsa4329]

0:06 Spurs 3:03 Bournemouth 4:00 Wolves 4:35 Newcastle 6:07 Brighton 7:15 Chelsea 11:08 West Ham 13:32 Fulham 13:45 Crystal Palace 14:20 Liverpool 16:28 Luton 17:07 Sheffield 17:54 Aston Villa 19:20 Man City 20:38 Burnley 21:38 Arsenal 22:21 Nottingham 23:47 Everton 25:35 Brentford 26:39 Man United

[@imharbinger]

TY

[@Guestownedu]

hero

[@akshayhighbury]

Champ.

[@mrhussain9008]

Cheers mate. Theres literally no order these idiots do their lists in .

[@brandond3159]

Elite comment

[@SephirothUTV]

Saying Emi Martinez cant play with his feet is one of, if not the wildest take i have ever heard. Absolutely clueless

[@Samgee99]

Which spurs fans are overrating Werner 😂 what a load of waffle, Rory must go to bed thinking about Spurs 🤣

[@ultrademigod]

Certainly talks about them a lot

[@ant4613]

He has a vendetta against Werner for his time at Chelsea.

[@JoeSmith-br4qx]

He’s talking about every team in the prem so yes obviously he spoke about Tottenham u donuts

[@Ben-gd4db]

I've seen plenty of spurs fans hyping up Werner when he joined in January

[@ant4613]

@@Ben-gd4db That's because it was a good signing for them given their injury situation. He's not overrated at all lol (who even rates him that highly?), again, only reason he's mentioned in this video is because Rory still has it out for him because of his time at Chelsea.

[@Shirt-Pants]

I used to defend Rory.... I can't do it anymore

[@TwizzMattaddorJr]

Same 100%! He is what everyone says happened to Klopp while vsing Pep, all he does is chat shit about Chelsea and our players its so annoying

[@michaelmellish291]

Hes the most flip flop utuber out there..cant stand the twat

[@thexboxmaniac100]

I unsubscribed from his channel coz he's just a flip flop fan and just always toxic

[@TwizzMattaddorJr]

@@thexboxmaniac100 i might have to soon sadly as well its too much i dont care for that level of toxicity its genuinely draining especially with the reactionary content its truly terrible it makes him seem so disingenuous

[@Me-gs3uu]

He is jarring. He just changes his opinions constantly and sound too much like a modern football fan. Only cares about G/A and these hipster tactico ballers. But also contradicts himself and rates these Brexit midfielders like Gallagher. He's all over the place.

[@bwfcok5789]

Fair play to these lads for making a career out of this! The lack of knowledge about clubs outside the top 6 is mental

[@mrhussain9008]

Good video, but Rory had a mare with his spurs picks.. thankfully Miles was there to prove him wrong, an Arsenal fan. 😂😂😂. One day I hope Buvey starts arguing with Rory on his outrageous takes, but he's an idiot too so I doubt he ever will

[@jamnewt7338]

Any take from Rory that is Spurs related is completely biased with zero logic involved in his decisions, it’s actually pathetic at times. As a football fan in general, you have to be able to set aside tribalism to properly analyse players, clubs and their managers.

[@Jimbobiscuit]

​@@JackSpurs I'll never understand people who expect their rival fans to be anything other than this. Buvey spends a lot of time slagging United off... but he's a City fan so I expect it. What do you want from Rory seriously?

[@hishaamamin8072]

@@jamnewt7338nah what’s pathetic is you whining about it in the comment section

[@jamnewt7338]

@@hishaamamin8072 no your whining about my comment when I only made an observation… fool

[@hy3r691]

@@hishaamamin8072 you're the one going to multiple replies on this video and telling people to "stop crying" because they're sharing opinions. Grow up please.

[@Dennis_Rodman_GOAT_1091]

Newcastle have gone from best defense to worst defense in the league once Pope got hurt…. Rory: “Pope? Overrated.” Lololololololololololol

[@gazf09]

This guy said kai havertz has made the midfield worse...leading goalscorers in the prem, many assists and goals from havertz, these guys are fucking memes. 3 clowns talking pure bollocks

[@samt4053]

They have 1 brain cell combined, but when it comes to talking about teams outside the top 6 that goes down to 0

[@YellowMouse998]

But yet you watch the videos and comment on 7 of them. All 7 moaning about them.

[@ACE360x]

Miles was alright

[@KetwigKeith]

Buvey genius when talking about Pickford

[@Ian-zf5ss]

Its official: The Club is the worst football podcast ever. There is no way that they actually believe these awful takes, it has to be an attempt to just generate as many views as possible.

[@dunno23]

This is the most overrated football related channel out there.

[@YellowMouse998]

If true then you're the fool being played. You watch and comment on multiple videos.

[@YellowMouse998]

Also Ian - have you reread your old comments on this channel? 😂 Just a month ago you said there's no way Man United will overtake Newcastle and West Ham. What's their current standing?

[@Ian-zf5ss]

@@YellowMouse998 That commen about West ham and Newcastle(which is dont remember the full extent of) came from 2022 a different season and it was from the Kick off not the club back when they were with TG. Also its pretty unsettling that you recall my exact username so easily from years ago in a sea of various videos and comments but hey maybe you have a photographic memory. Thirdly to address your main point about me being the fool, Why would I cast judgement upon them so early on when there takes were not nearly as bad years ago. I am saying that now at this current point in time that they now simply say things that they dont believe in order to garner views. Not that I would say that years ago. But yea once again, a bit unsettling how you can just recall my exact name and comment but alright.

[@YellowMouse998]

@Ian-zf5ss Wrong. Your comment was from January 2024 on a video called "Should Man United sack Ten Hag." Your comment was basically calling Adam an idiot for thinking Manchester united can catch up to Spurs and could overtake on the table. You also mentioned that you think Manchester United will not overtake Newcastle or West Ham. Glass houses my friend. You can't criticise hot takes when your own takes has the expiry date of milk.

[@GuitarJammerJohn]

These guys clearly haven’t been watching Villa enough Martinez always plays with his feet and he’s pretty good at it, it’s actually a major part of how we play. He is perhaps a little overrated but he’s good with his feet.

[@KTK44]

Wasn't it also Martinez that wanted to leave Arsenal and not Arteta that wanted him gone?

[@Fmfcg]

We need to talk about Doku's 0 goal involvements since that statpadding session against Bournemouth

[@NUFCOfficial]

Doku is saint maximin, lot of talent in terms of dribbling and such but all of the crosses and passes are hopeful. It's like they're constantly free styling so you never get a consistent performance out of them.

[@abdikani2756]

he got injured

[@em_si]

@@abdikani2756 He's still made 12 appearances since that Bournemouth game. Got 1 goal and 0 assists

[@mrhussain9008]

​@@em_siCitys 2 LW are shocking tbh. Grealish and Doku don't do shit tbh

[@mrsparkymajor5284]

@@mrhussain9008not like grealish helped city win a treble or anything….

[@alexmatthews7279]

“Martinez can’t play with his feet” 😂😂

[@jaspionccv9426]

He won a World Cup with his foot!

[@nkosanamakhubela2586]

​@@jaspionccv9426 but he's overrated

[@llum0121]

4 mins in and they've not suggested one overrated player

[@yeonlee5]

This is just a let's trash talk Spurs video in just 5 seconds lmao

[@hishaamamin8072]

You gonna cry?

[@yeonlee5]

@hishaamamin8072 not rlly. Wbu?

[@jackjohnson156]

Every single take rory made in this vid was horrendous.

[@Dan-kb9vr]

Apart from Bernardo silva

[@joelthomas433]

Rory's take on Enzo sums up the quality of his football opinions.

[@philsblogs8527]

How is Maupay overrated 🤣 everyone thinks he's terrible & yet he has 6 G/A in his last 8 games.. if anything he's underrated

[@zulpro9231]

Lol exactly...he became a meme at everton

[@LiamJM10]

Someone needs to stick a gag order on Rory when it comes to Spurs. Romero needs a competent partner alongside him? Is that why he helped Spurs into the CL with Dier and Sanchez either side of him? Or why he won the world cup with a 47 year old Otamendi? Im begging people to actually watch him and not just roll out red card statistics that somehow get more superfluous every time. Blokes been booked 4 times all season and we act likes he committing murder weekly because nobody bothers to actually pay attention. Nobody is overrating Emerson or Werner either. They're squad players. The Richarlison narrative is just ridiculous. We rate as Richarlison is. A competent goalscorer who will get 10-15 goals in a good season, just like he did at Everton. And that's fine, try not to grade him against Harry Kane.

[@AlexStevens10]

Always hear weird takes with Richy and I think that’s because they don’t watch him every week. He didn’t just stumble his way into becoming Brazil’s #9. Always gives 110% & is a difference maker. Agreed that he’ll probably just always be a 10-15 goal season striker but to do that consistently is great for any team. We miss him here at Everton!

[@adambassuni6084]

romeros been booked 5 times this season and has escaped about 4 clear red cards over the last 2.5 seasons lmao. look how bad he is when he has dier next to him compared to van de ven.

[@shams3831]

@@adambassuni6084 Defender looks worse when partner is bad? Wow. Great brain.

[@JPayne95]

​@@shams3831why you mad that he made a good point?

[@LiamJM10]

@@adambassuni6084 odd how he managed to win the world cup without van de ven. Being booked 4 times, not 5, stop making shit up, is fine for a guy who's job is to make tackles.

[@user-ei1kf7jo5o]

mad how the gooner on set is more charitable to spurs players than rory, who incidentally seems to allow timo werner to live inside his head rent free

[@Cozzman666]

Chelsea's most overrated player is Reece James

[@theorangeman302]

Its not trust me as a chelsea fan he makes our team way better i would say sterling chilwell mudryk madueke sanchez and even Thiago silva are more overrated than him

[@josesesade5732]

​@@theorangeman302 no one rates those players

[@Fmfcg]

Icl I've only seen praise for on these podcasts, everywhere else people have given up on him

[@Cozzman666]

@@theorangeman302 Mudryk is mad. Everyone agrees he's shite

[@Josh-wn7fl]

He's fairly rated imo, he is an incredible RB but isn't available enough which at this point has to be taken into account

[@Ben-gd4db]

Saying Emi Martinez can't play with his feet and was the reason Arsenal got rid of him was an awful take. He's one of the best in the league with his feet and very composed, a large part of Villa's success come from them playing out from the back

[@Arun-dx1hr]

Why the hell this discussion start with Tottenham… especially when team has been performing to limit

[@DonWan47]

Big Ange is getting the best out of his players. The disrespect is real.

[@jahno7154]

At the moment we are poor our attack is shit and Big Ange is overrated

[@DonWan47]

@@jahno7154 Gotta disagree with you there, mate.

[@E23789]

How can Mendy be a terrible keeper but also have been the best keeper in the world according to rory

[@Ethan-pz7zp]

nick pope 2nd best save percentage in prem this season and 3rd best in the champions league but yeah a goalkeeper that wasn’t deemed good enough for a champions league team is better

[@djDannyOcean]

Can’t believe nobody mentioned Grealish

[@mrhussain9008]

Potentially the Most overrated player ever. He is literally the reason SOME people aka idiots say City are boring. Every attacker in that team is a great dribbler (Bernardo, KDB, Doku, Foden) but those attackers actually get goals and assists, I genuinely can't remember Grealish scoring a good goal in the last 2 years. He's shooting and final pass is abysmal. I'm a City fan btw. I've been in stadiums and some fans at Wembley said Grealish was better than Prime Neymar 😂😂😂

[@thatonebirtyd5058]

@@mrhussain9008ye Grealish is honestly awful and nothing more than a free kick winning merchant and even then he’s barely done that too for the last half a year :/ sure at Villa he had more free reign to do what he wanted due to him being better than anyone else at the club at the time and he scored great goals but at City he’s been horrendous let alone the 100m price on his head

[@-_-DatDude]

Overpriced yes. Overrated no. Last time I heard people throw his name in top winger convos or were clamouring for Southgate to play him, he was at Villa. If anything Grealish is underrated. In 2024 people speak on Grealish as a flop. You can't be widely seen as a flop and overrated at the same time. The maths don't work.

[@rohansunny3426]

@@mrhussain9008Most overated one is Ederson. And potentially Gvardiol. Rest are good Im a city fan.

[@mark5338]

@@rohansunny3426 Gvardiol? What lol, nobody even says anything about him was the price tag big yes is a defender ever going to live up to that probably no. He's a great player especially under pressure with the ball he's will even get better with more games. Ederson however is really shocking when it comes to shot stopping. The thing is nobody even rates him that high but he's actually awful and the only reason why he's at City is because he can probably play in the midfield in the prem with his passing. I would really love to see the statistics on how many times he played well in passing from the back and it resulted in anything useful vs how many times he doesn't stop shots a premier league keeper should save in his sleep.

[@NathanSweeney]

That thumbnail is CRIMINAL.

[@J_Sk15]

You still clicked

[@TheGeneral_LUFC]

😂😂

[@TheGeneral_LUFC]

It's rorys hair. Also they look very true geordish

[@jimmerisking]

Ku-li-ku-be-tu 😩... These man are bums with these takes 😂😂😂 wow... Buvey might be the most toxic and salty city fan out there... Makes LB look like Jesus Christ

[@ssrmy1782]

Richarlison was carrying an groin injury. He had surgery and literally started scoring as soon as he returned.

[@jakeshore1071]

Rory, you obviously don’t watch Chelsea enough for being a lifelong fan. I literally had to stop watching the video when you said Enzo shouldn’t be starting. I get the price tag on him, but he’s our best midfielder (skill wise) and other than Gallagher, always capable of putting in a world class performance like he has the past two games. Cmon man. I’m in the states and you’re supposedly a “lifelong Chelsea fan” stop hating bruv…..

[@joelthomas433]

Where did this Mudryk 100m price tag come from?

[@mrhussain9008]

Honestly trying to figure out who's overrated at Luton or Sheffield United will be difficult 😂😂. I honestly think this should be a top 10 teams discussion..and Chelsea

[@ghjklkop7868]

world class joke

[@menosscott]

Rashford is a decent shout but Shaw for me. We always talk about "When Shaw comes back" or "If we had Shaw" but the problem is he's injured way too often to ever be reliably rated and he doesn't consistently put 7s or 8s out 10 when he's available. Dalot has been the most consistent at least 7 out 10 player this season and he's consistently available. To me, Shaw is a bit overated.

[@jamiegaffney3474]

As a Chelsea fellow Chelsea fan, Rory is so negative about everything and everyone at Chelsea. Starting to do my head in

[@rapden18]

Brother makes more videos abt how arsenal will win the league than Chelsea vids

[@calm123]

Cuz Chelsea are shit and stuck in midtable, no Chelsea fan can praise anything now if they are serious

[@kierstanfaulks]

bro calling any chelsea player overrated is madness, everyone talks about the lot of them like they've never kicked a football before, that's rubbish that mudryk is overrated, everyone online is talking 24/7 about how shit he is

[@charlesingram9471]

Thing with Burnley is that they did so well to get promoted because they spent a lot of money loaning players from prem clubs which he lost when getting promoted. The squad now isn't as good as it was.

[@jepperiis6134]

Kai Havertz has not made the Arsenal midfield "worse". For the first ten games maybe, but since the intl' break he's been quietly brilliant.

[@ripxdoc]

solanke is in a purple patch like richarlison but they argue completely differently lol

[@TheGeneral_LUFC]

Did rory cut his own hair. Ffs.

[@christopherrandell6175]

De Zerbi is the over rated choice for Brighton. David Moyes is on the verge of being sacked for being 8th and having won a European Trophy last season. Brighton are below West Ham in the league and De Zerbi is being touted as a replacement for Klopp.

[@J_Sk15]

Cause he acc has a style of play and less money to work with

[@User-ei7eo]

you might aswell go and watch rugby if you think what de zerbi has done/ is doing is overrated.

[@TheGeneral_LUFC]

​@@User-ei7eohe is overrated

[@vendexa5840]

Just stop watching ball.... how many injuries have brighton got this season?... De Zerbi came in, immediately established an entertaining style of football and got europa + theyre doing well in europa rn.... modern football fans so reactionary wtf

[@SN64736]

​@@vendexa5840He didnt establish anything. Brighton already played attractive football under Potter. Their problem under Potter was their strikers couldn't hit a barn door. They massively underperformed their xG every season.

[@TheLizardKingC]

People always call out Rory for his bad takes and let Buvey get away his own biases every video. Saying Bowen is a better "footballer" than Saka is horrible. Also, Zinchenko is was better than Chilwell for Arsenal's system. I hate this sort of lazy youtube analysis comparing players like it's FIFA. You can't just say one player is better than the other without considering the system they're asked to play in.

[@AvergeJoehere]

B.Silva whenever Rory talks about him. Don't get me right he's world class, but Rory thinks off him when making love to his misses

[@TheFPLScope]

For West Ham it's the centre backs. Both Zouma and Aguerd have been pretty bad this season. Before the season I saw several people select Aguerd as a CB in their "non big 6" best team in the league. Aguerd makes far too many mistakes to be ahead of the likes of Joachim Andersen and Lewis Dunk.

[@chickensoup4347]

Rory isn’t a Chelsea fan you cannot convince me he is

[@thexboxmaniac100]

Don't get where people get 100 million for mudryk 😂 the guy was 60 million

[@rosscleary9110]

No he wasn't. Stop lying.

[@christhomas9769]

If you think Emi Martinez is over rated you're honestly clueless. Over rated for villa is Diaby or Carlos.

[@thomasreid404]

Enzo is class he's far from overrated He always looks to play a forward pass and is now scoring goals like what else do you want. 😂

[@micksr8680]

Rory, show by show you are becoming less credible and less likable

[@patcoughlin1987]

I watch every Liverpool game and when rory said Curtis jones and Harvey Elliott were overrated, I lost it. These two will be in the England squad very soon.

[@adamroberts626]

Buvey is such a smarmy city fan, lives in Bristol, and just supported the big club and then laughs at other fans and clubs misfortune…. We could all just pick the best team and then laugh at the other side

[@Eufamis]

I’d love to see a most underrated at each club as well

[@Jawlorr]

Jack Grealish is by far and away the most overrated player.. of all time. Does fuck all.

[@user-qy6fi6gz5q]

"I wouldn't trust him in a title winning side." Romero won the World Cup a year ago mate. With Otamendi as a CB partner...

[@Slesaint17]

Think he more so means a league title which is very different to a knock out competition. 38 games of absolute top notch quality is needed. I don't think Romero is good enough. Mayyyybe as the partner to a world class CB, but not as the main man in defence.

[@JoshuaOwen-pn1nx]

Why did you pronounced Jarrad Branthwaite's name like Martin Braithwaite who was a Danish striker who played for Barcelona

[@PaddyMcMe]

Nunez? Overrated? Jesus Christ the amount of slagging Nunez gets is insane. Even at Liverpool it's only a handful of guys who rate him.

[@somdutta7322]

Gakpo is not overrated, Gakpo already has 10 goals and 3 assists across all competitions. He is only 24, and is training to be the next big thing.

[@adambassuni6084]

how the entire west ham defence didnt get called overrated lol

[@AdewaleSmile-fw8wj]

Enzo has been our best midfield these season, he our highest goal scorers from Midfield and if you watch Chelsea you know he make the ball look easy

[@lukeflynn7182]

Nunez starts for both Arsenal and Chelsea... pure Dribble from the two lads

[@sj2672]

Mendy has never been the best goalkeeper in the world at any point so yet another pointless comment from Rory. He has really nicked a living talking about football🤔

[@coleslaaw]

They're not overrating Werner Rory, they're just trolling you

[@darrenfearon4288]

Rory dont judge Flav to every other Tottenham fan lol

[@CaelanDafydd]

The real list; Liverpool - Diaz City - Grealish Arsenal - Jesus Spurs - Romero Villa - Martinez United - Casemiro Newcastle - None West Ham - None Brighton - None Chelsea - Fernandez Wolves - Semedo Fulham - Leno Bournemouth - None Brentford - None Palace - Henderson Forest - Hudson-Odoi Luton - None Everton - DCL Burnley - None Sheff Utd - None

[@VivoEnChicago]

Arsenal - Gabriel Jesus Man City - Ederson Liverpool - Luis Diaz Tottenham - Kulesevski Chelsea - Reece James/Sterling/Cucerella Brighton - Fati Man U - Rashford Newcastle - Trippier

[@Kate-ms2mn]

who rates Cucurella in 2024?

[@taeloobusitse3686]

RASHFORDDDDD!!!!😂🔥🔥

[@saffiejallow8858]

You're wrong😏 diaz isn't overrated

[@billymanley2298]

As a west ham fan. Thank you for saying soucek. He is an abysmal player and needs to go

[@lucasrobinson1102]

I don’t think Rory knows someone has to be somewhat rated to be overrated

[@ljsmith8263]

What bidding war was there for gakpo ? we just said here's the money and it was done in less than 12 hours ?

[@crookieee]

Honestly they make so much shit up think they do it on purpose for clicks

[@em_si]

Yeah, that was a load of codswallop. United toyed with the idea in the previous January transfer window after Ronaldo left but didn't go through with it, and Liverpool snapped him up the following summer. There was literally never a "bidding war" between United and Liverpool, weird narrative from them.

[@user-wy3vb4vl8c]

Is Rory mad about pope? He’s better than Pickford and ramsdale in every department other than passing

[@teaonyj]

100% His tats don't lie

[@AlexStevens10]

Pickford will always be England’s #1 and that’s because he’s the best of the 3.

[@zainabsabera5850]

Pickford clear (I'm not a girl I'm a guy)

[@Josh-wn7fl]

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@jemi3869]

I’m not fond of any Arsenal players especially not Ramsdale, however saying Pope is the better keeper is just untrue.

[@-_-DatDude]

To be overrated, you need to be rated in the first place. Players like Mudryk and Rashford divide fanbases, so-called Man Utd have been calling him Trashford for 3 years now. Most of our fanbase wouldnt care if Rashford sold. Palmer and Garnacho are better examples of overrated. Foden, Alisson, Martinelli and Bissouma for the rest of the big 6 imo.

[@ashwinsinghsaul]

brother you do not know ball, this is the most awful take i've ever heard

[@taeloobusitse3686]

Foden?? Alisson?? Bissouma??😮😮😮 wow bro

[@ashwinsinghsaul]

@@taeloobusitse3686 he even put Garnacho in there, he's literally 19 years old

[@-_-DatDude]

@@ashwinsinghsaul In my 30's. Going by your name I'm not sure if English is your native language but overrated simply means they get too much praise/credit. Overrated doesn't mean bad.

[@-_-DatDude]

@@taeloobusitse3686 Overrated doesn't mean you're a bad player. It means a player gets too much praise or credit. A lot of non English people don't understand what overrated means. Foden is a very good player but I've seen people say he's better than Bellingham. Out of all Fodens trophies he's won at Man City, how much was he really needed? Hardly none. Man City could win without Foden. Again Alisson is a brilliant goalkeeper but people say that he's surpassed the likes of Schmeichel and compare his career to Neuer. Also everytime he makes a horrendous mistake like agaisnt Arsenal nobody mentions it. If that was De Gea people would be laughing and talking about it for weeks. Bissouma started off well this season and Spurs fans threw Bissoumas name into Rice and Rodri conversations and said he's better than Casemiro. Do we pretend that Bissouma was useless at Spurs last season? Or does it not suit the narrative?

[@TheMightofDab]

If you ever want proof that the podcast market is saturated to fuck, here it is. What a waste of 5 minutes i spent on this

[@alexmaggs3461]

No one rates mudryk so dont see how he can be over rated

[@thomaswiedner2524]

Rorys anti spurs bias is hilarious

[@rohandhesi]

This is obviously bias because I’m a Liverpool fan, but Rory can not even mention Curtis jones or Harvey Elliot in this conversation at all. The disrespect and lack of acknowledgment especially against Curtis jones is mad. He should be considered for England for the euros. If you just simply watch him for 90 mins you’d see what every Liverpool fan sees. Hard to get the ball off, barely gives it away, drives with the ball, brilliant decision making, and full of energy. Plus the fact klopp always starts him even when everyone’s fit just shows the level of trust klopp has in him in a title challenging side

[@superstarlevlyn5355]

How funny this arsenal feller downgrade Romero, a world class defender who defended well to Argentina to win the World Cup, very good on the ball , aggressive and tenacious! Saliba and konate are not better defenders than Romero

[@bradley4706]

Rory’s opinion on Edouard Mendy is, I’m sorry, stupid. Has one good season and wins CL. Has one bad season when everyone had a bad season. Rory’s opinion: He just had a good season the first season but actually the 2nd season is his actual standard. WHAT?! That’s so stupid. You need a third season to make that judgment. There isn’t enough data to make that conclusion.

[@MrSeananners12345]

Thanks for these podcats. Helps get me through the working week!

[@JB-bk6yp]

Rory’s the hot chocolate and shoot magazine type football fan. Still got posters stuck up in the wall and hilariously is so out of touch.

[@tomweeks6130]

Havertz gets so much slander, he was signed for not much more than nunes and kovacic at city and has been a far far better signing than both

[@TVFlix]

Are you mad? Havertz has 6 goals and 1 assists this season, Nunez has 13 goals and 11 assists. With less minutes played as well.

[@tomweeks6130]

@@TVFlix matheus nunes mate read the comment

[@TVFlix]

@@tomweeks6130Thought u meant Nunez at Liverpool or kovicic at city. Not sure why you’d compare Matheus Nunez, he’s a different position and cost half as much.

[@tomweeks6130]

@@TVFlix he cost £10m less and is also a midfielder

[@jackjohnson156]

Rory never fails to be delusional

[@Lonnakkoful]

Big 6 City: Gvardiol United: Rashford Liverpool: Gomez Arsenal: Martinelli Chelsea: Sterling Spurs: Romero Remember: Overrated isn't the same as bad, except for in Gomez case, he's rubbish

[@user-ts3ko6yg3m]

Everyone knows Rashford is shit, Gvardiol has been here few months and Gomez has been one of Liverpool’s best players this season you’re clueless

[@supervillan326]

That’s the Sky 6.

[@oscarwhitehouse9894]

No one’s rating Werner like that at all 🤣🤣 love to waffle about spurs don’t ya

[@adamdowling1700]

I think you guys missed the point of ‘overrated’. It’s not about being crap, it’s about good players that are hailed as a ‘generational talent’ ie Trent, Thiago silva, Phil foden, saka. In my opinion anyway!

[@karlcs901]

Trent: most assists as a defender in the league at 25 Foden: 5PL, UCL, 20 G/A this season, Young POTY Saka: carried Arsenal for 3 seasons, 3 20 G/A seasons in a row, 2 England POTY These players are more than just good

[@adamdowling1700]

@@karlcs901 Trent is a defender that can’t defend and they’ve already started work on his statue. Foden has been hailed as the greatest young player and yet 6 years on he’s still not an automatic first choice at city or England. Saka is great but Arsenal fans act like he’s messi.

[@karlcs901]

@@adamdowling1700 Trent can’t defend, sure but his attacking output is literally higher than 99.9% of midfielders, allowing Liverpool to have 5 in attack. VVD and Konate pick up his slack so he works in their system perfectly. Foden is in the best squad the planet has ever seen, where Pep doesn’t start any midfielder or defender for more than 30 games per season. He is 23 and has had to compete with some of the best attackers on earth for a spot. He’s basically as good as one can get in that squad. Guess who starts ahead of Foden for England? Saka, the guy with 100 G/A in 200 games with 1.5 seasons as a LB for the worst Arsenal team in decades. All of these players are world class or close to it. You don’t know ball.

[@adamdowling1700]

@@karlcs901 you’re just proving my point, all overrated.

[@TheFullPackage]

@@adamdowling1700 "Trent can't defend" is the laziest and most overplayed criticism of TAA from rival fans who can't cope with the fact that he's a generational right back.

[@mcnetchaiev]

These debates on overrated players are always useless because, for starters, no one ever really agrees on what overrated means.

[@rosscleary9110]

It just usually devolves into people crying that overrated = bad, when thats not what it means.

[@fault.]

Time stamps pls

[@dannymason5873]

Fulham overlooked as always

[@robhuanout5443]

cheers for that not gonna watch now

[@Antonio-hb8rd]

This is basically the slightly more adult version of Saturday Social

[@jamesgrannum3736]

glad they struggled with liverpool :)

[@CB-lw7ty]

I think Mudryk gets defended alot but isn't rated, its backing someone because he's your player than actually rating them. Enzo feels like the one that nomatter how many weeks on end he can be average the response is "He won the World Cup already mate" as if that means he's going to be a 10 year top 10 in the world talent nomatter what. The alternative unpopular one I'll give, Cole Palmer, he's being presented as this next golden English boy but I don't think he's any better or worse talent wise than alot of the players in the squad, I just think he's performing weekly and the others aren't so it makes him look like a wonderkid but when the team comes together more I think he'll just blend into being good but nothing crazy like he seems now.

[@NorthStand405]

19:20 wtf is he talking about "Rory vs the Ramsdales"... they were clearly talking about Buvey and Ramsdale😭

[@Zediaphh]

They couldn't wait to chat shit about Spurs and Romero lmfaooo

[@oliverboughey6328]

Emi Martinez has been playing out from the back with his feet for over a season now and it’s worked incredibly well for Villa. It’s actually incredible how confidently these lot will make statements that are just plain incorrect so frequently.

[@tommychesonis4610]

I can’t stand how Rory speak like he’s the ultimate overarching opinion in the room. He never says it, but just acts like their opinion is wrong and his is right. Wayyyyy more than buvey/adam/others.

[@kingluis6360]

How do you go through Liverpool and Konate isn’t mentioned at all? He has had a very good season, but people are all of a sudden putting him up there with Van Dijk and Saliba as the best in the league.

[@rorymclean1931]

Idk hes always been very good not just this season, just has had some injuries. But yea he shouldn’t be in the debate with those two yet

[@leemurovec24]

Probably because he's already better than saliba

[@onetwo8847]

Konate literally plays two positions at once at times... He partners VVD and also has to cover at RB when Trent inverts into midfield. He is dominant physically and also the fastest player in the LFC squad and solid technically. Definitely not most overrated

[@brianbates212]

I would agree that Konate isn't as good as some would have you believe but he's nowhere near as over-rated as Trent...

[@onetwo8847]

@@brianbates212 Trent is literally the best passer in Europe right now, behind KDB

[@sipho4265]

Visuals when talking about a team would be great

[@lukrcrittenden3817]

This video went from ‘overrated’ to ‘players that are crap’ really quick.

[@__dane__]

This can’t help but remind me of when Saturday social did “overrated players” with Rory and Rory was the only one who understood what overrated meant

[@ssrmy1782]

Cole "penalty" Palmer. Played all season in midfield and the forward line for a £ billion team that are 10th and have a goal difference of +1 after 24 games.

[@Metis1337]

As a Liverpool fan, Diaz is the most overrated, hes the only forward on these shows that never gets stuck in to, he's pretty bad and has been for a while.

[@saffiejallow8858]

You're nuts if you think diaz is overrated 😏

[@NorthStand405]

Not a player but the most overrated person at Brighton is De Zerbi. Wildly overrated manager.

[@conorbradley326]

How are none of them saying jack grealish isn't overrated literally does nothing for city cost 100m and they all thought he was the best last season yet he doesn't barely get a look in now