Most Unpopular And Honest Opinions On Pop Vocals and Music!

[@isitbees]

My brutally honest opinion: KPop Stan’s need to learn what a whistle note is because they’re throwing that term around way too freely

[@aintnootherfan]

YES

[@jxstadri]

Most of them need to learn a lot of those terms lmao and to except that sometimes their favs aren't the strongest vocalists they're making them out to be

[@Sylvaincks]

Most of them can't tell the difference between Head Voice, Falsetto and Whistle Register and it's just so annoying lol

[@yonce2143]

Agree

[@iTeacupPanda]

I mean K-pop stans honestly want to get mad when you tell them their faves aren't vocally all that. Like it's fine? They're not trying to be anyway? The package of a K-pop star isn't trying to be Sohyang to begin with because 1. you're not marketing to the Hallmark channel. 2. You're marketing to young pop listening teens and young adults. 3. You're PERFORMERS who sing, not SINGERS who perform. Plenty of them are more dancers anyway. So like don't take it personally k-pop fans, but also don't get so huge headed. Like if your fave sounds great? cool. But before you diss some other artist to pump up your fave, remember your favorite has like 4 other people to relieve them so they can get away with dodgy breath control and so on. But that said being vocally superior in terms of technique doesn't always mean everything. I mean there were more vocally technical singers than Utada Hikaru, but she is the queen of J-pop for a reason. NO ONE's voice is as warm and nurturing and just cozy and light as hers. Sometimes a SPECIAL voice isn't just high notes and range. SOMETIMES people with high notes and range have nothing special to their voices at all.

[@thalesviana6177]

actually, true lambs really praise the 2015 Jamaica show!! she was really "excited" that day, and her creativity goes through the roof. so many note changes, almost impeccable musicality, and she SANG that day. waiting impatiently for the video about it.

[@Heroliesinyou]

She was drunk as hell but her confidence was way up there. The vocals were fire.🔥🔥🤣🤣🤣

[@BB8425]

Same

[@noahflare6825]

It is amazing what a bit of confidence boost does to her live performance. Makes me sometimes wish she would "go higher than the heavens above" more often 😜

[@Solo-vh9fm]

She sounded great but she was definitely all over the place during that show.

[@THEE.apples]

Exactly I love Jamaica 2015

[@leedalite]

couldn't agree with you more about the jisoo jennie debate. i am so sick of people still saying that jennie is a better vocalist than jisoo when jisoo has proven on multiple occasions during the born pink tour that she really is the superior vocalist. i am in no way saying that jennie is a bad singer, but she is so inconsistent. my girl's highs on the tour have been so high but her lows are so god damn low it just makes me sad.

[@teumedeobi]

jisoo still can’t support which is the confusing part. otherwise i’d agree she’s better

[@chaeinneoneandonly9170]

Jennie better than her stay mad and also Jennie is consistent not jisoo in the beginning of the tour she cracks so much then in the middle of the tour she started to be relaxed on her lower notes then she came worse especially in their last France show

[@moreandmore395]

Face what tocic Jennie will say

[@moreandmore395]

​@@chaeinneoneandonly9170 not because Jennie tickled her? No because jisoo is a bad vocalist stay mad! Also she isnt only relaxed on her lows. She supportes them lol

[@chaeinneoneandonly9170]

@@moreandmore395 she is just relax 😌 because here solo is coming maybe she got some vocal lessons and her last show was horrible now cry about that you all love to shade jennie to make your bias better but believe me the truth can't be change Ps: jennie support A4 many times she improves alot

[@richmaxmchalliwchester1984]

I'm a very big Swiftie and i absolutely agree, Taylor is pretty inconsistent and unpredictable. She has days when i'm like: ''Did Whitney's spirit possessed her that day?'' and she has days when i'm like: ''Girl, WTF was that?'' I absolutely agree with you that with Folklore, Evermore and Midnights she found a style that fits her perfectly and uses more her strengths like her amazing lower register, vocal transitions, and playing with dynamics and emotions. She's a decent belter and sometimes she can really surprise but it never was her biggest strength, so i'm happy now she belts less but focuses more on overall control and stablity. Taylor's going on tour in a month, she's touring for the first time since 2018 and she didn't perform a full set since end of 2019, so i'm very interested how she will sound like. I expect slightly shaky start but more she will perform the better she will sound. I don't know how much you watch of her performances but i can tell that during start of an era and promotional performances she's very unpredictable but when she's on tour she sounds much better and shows much more control and better technique. I remember you said in one video something like: there are 2 types of singers: 1) singers who needs proper rest after performances and 2) singers that needs to perform consistently to be in a good vocal shape. And Taylor is in the 2nd category, she needs to perform consistently or she will become very unpredictable. I really think Taylor should visiting vocal coach again because the potential she has in unbelievable. The problem is that Taylor never had any intentions to become a powerful vocalist, she always wanted to be a storyteller and songwriter and artist in general. She worked on her voice to be able to give a good show and when she achieved this she stopped working, which is such a shame. So i really think she should working with vocal coach again, it's not just her, EVERY SINGLE ARTIST SHOULD HAVE A VOCAL COACH!

[@Heroliesinyou]

Did you really compare Whitney Houston with Taylor Swift in a "good" day?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@AM-dd6dx]

I like Taylor too, but Whitney who??

[@whoevr]

i’ve rarely seen a moment where whitney « possessed » her, actually never but slay

[@whoevr]

yup she definitely should visit a vocal coach

[@samueleemiliani9036]

No need to disrespect whitney like that gurl

[@mike_cbrr]

THANK YOU FOR MENTIONING LITTLE MIX ESPECIALLY JADE 🤧

[@liamseravali2291]

Jisoo and Jennie both are underdeveloped so thats not a big gap to ppl worry abt who is better.

[@silverplim]

exactly

[@AM-dd6dx]

Ariana’s vibrato and the way she can manipulate it is so gorgeous

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

I agree she always tends to switch It up depending on what she’s doing w it

[@cristi4n.anderson]

headvoice too

[@artistaroundtheblock2047]

Yeah the speed is perfect. 6 oscillations per sec

[@AM-dd6dx]

I agree that some voices are just better than others. Was watching Burlesque with Christina Aguilera when this really hit me. Like how on earth does she sound like that

[@Heroliesinyou]

Burlesque is iconic. 😍😍😍 Christina's voice is everything.

[@Hannah-ux2ni]

Burlesque lives rent free in my mind. Christinas voice is just WOW

[@AM-dd6dx]

@@Hannah-ux2ni It really isn't fair.

[@Hannah-ux2ni]

@@AM-dd6dx Definitely 😭

[@ernesfonse]

She is a vocal savage

[@pedrohenriquecarneiro4331]

I think Jennie has a better technique, but Jisoo is more consistent as someone mention here. I think Jisoo singing comes more naturally, while Jennie is more hit or miss.

[@plipplop5747]

I think it's the contrary, Jennie is very inconsistent because she has a very bad (or nonexistent) technique. However she has a lot of potential and it's unfortunate that she doesnt know how to use her voice better. She could be as good as Rosé in my opinion if she had proper training and understanding of her voice For Jisoo i don't really know, i think she could work on her tension, she's very tense when belting and she should probably open her mouth more to have better resonnance

[@helloworld-sl2lw]

I think the opposite, Jennie's voice comes more naturally but she's just not properly trained at all, while Jisoo seems like she focused more on training her voice because it doesn't come naturally to her.

[@PdPiper-wn2nb]

1 - Some people really don't know the difference between "not singing live" and "not singing well". 2 - I love Rihanna discography and she can be a very capable vocalist when she wants to, but the performance was weak 3 - There are voices that I prefer listening to rather than some technically developed ones 4 - I just hope the marketing for the solos are great to create some hype after the break 5/6 - I think musicality is an important part of it, there are vocalists that don't use a lot of vibrato but are still great to listen to 8 - Inconsistency always bugs me 9 - Gugudan's Nayoung and WJSN's Yeonjung also sound like Taeyeon 10 - I don't like none of the songs, but Nxde is slightly better. I still think the aesthetics (outfits and MV) and "Reset" are the best part of the comeback 11 - Like I said before, Jennie bugs me. There are performances that make me believe her technique is more well rounded than Jisoo's, but Jisoo is far more consistent 12 - Vision is nearly perfect, Fairytale is one of their best songs and their intro and outro are top tier as always. I prefer their other special releases, but I enjoy Reason

[@Bumblebey2.0]

As a Beyoncé fan i know how hard can be to explain to other fans that she uses lip-sync. What these fans need to understand is that this doesn't mean she's not a good singer, actually she's a great singer one of the best out there, BUT HIVE BROTHERS AND SISTERS SHE USES LIP-SYNC. Let's be polite.

[@AGEE_95]

It's not wrong to say she uses it. But people act like she has never sung live, and been able to dance at the same time, before. Of course she's can't do it all the time, and not even for a whole concert, I doubt. No one can. But she is capable of doing it for a certain amount of time, which isn't something too many other vocalists can also say.

[@sandhyanagarajan]

Ariana's vibrato is so gorgeous!! Also to the first point, it's absolutely true that lip sync is necessary in many situations even though it's good to be able to tell when they are singing live vs when they are lip syncing-many times it's quite obvious actually. Yeah, Beyonce's an AMAZING and underrated vocalist but still she lip syncs sometimes when she wants to perform and dance like crazy-it's very hard to sing and dance. Or sometimes they lip sync to protect their voice on tours and things like that which is also completely fine. As long as they are able to sing live that's all that matters.

[@ernesfonse]

When you think of singers, you have Christina Aguilera who’s voice will always be recognized. The emotive and power of her voice are unmatched. She may not be technically trained but the rawness makes her voice unique and something out of world.

[@yureino]

Unmatched power? Lol you’re just another delusional fans like what this video is for. She has unique tone & style, powerful chesty belt, but far from unmatched.

[@Oatsyummy]

I disagree about the Beyoncé Dubai clip. At the start of her singing that iconic part she puts her hand on the mic which muffles her voice for a second,which i don’t think would happen if it was a track playing. Also there was no noticeable volume change or tone change from the clear live vocals just before that part,to the alleged track that played at that part. I feel like it’s more likely live than not

[@AM-dd6dx]

I just commented something similar 😭. Some of her runs leading up to that were not as precise which i don’t think would happen if it was entirely pre-recorded.

[@rydercdaniels4475]

I’m the Biggest Beyoncé fan but the drunk in love vocal run she did at the end of that performance was in fact pre-recorded. Now she did sing 95% of the song live and her ad libs while she was walking down the stage was live but as the stage person was hooking her up to the stand that lifted her in the air, there was a Quick adjustment in her demeanor and after she sang the last ad-lib of “we be all night” and the way her head was moving left to right as the water started flying everywhere and she was elevated into air. The quality of the vocals was TOO clean and no waver in pitch was happening the way it would have had she been singing live. When you’ve watched 100s of Beyoncé tour concerts, love award shows, festivals performance, tv performances and even fan recorded shows, he begin to notice Beyoncé’s pattern and strategies of how she sings live and certain songs or parts of songs she chooses to lip sync to.

[@GarageStudio7]

@@AM-dd6dx The whole performance wasn't lip-synced. That particular part was.

[@GarageStudio7]

The dramatic head movements with no discernible alteration in sound and being slightly late/almost missing her cue, gave it away.

[@kurischan7303]

Not the entire song was pre-rec. Just that part. Also observe when she looked down, her voice did not change at all. She even missed the cue before her pre-rec played on.

[@Heyguhh]

3:45 i mean Leigh kinda hinted at maybe an album this year😅 ion kno if that’ll happen tho, but i hope so😭

[@goldyd144]

Miyeon trained in YG and was originally supposed to be a part of a 9 member lineup (with the Blackpink members) called PinkPunk, which would be YG's SNSD (Girls Generation). It wouldn't surprise me if she was trained in a similar vein while at YG, and later, Cube.

[@ArielthelittleFISH]

just jisoo existing make my heart flatter

[@leonardomapurunga753]

When I first heard Miyeon's Drive I instantly imagined Taeyeon singing that song and in that way.

[@Gush12]

That MC concert in Jamaica was so good! I miss her singing like that

[@nopestopitplz6079]

I disagree about Beyonce's Drunk In Love performance in Dubai being lipped. In the beginning of the riff, she accidentally covers the mic with her hand, and you can hear the muffled sound. Not to mention, she wasn't doing a lot of choreo like she was in the Deja Vu and Baby Boy performances. Plus, a few of the background dancers said that she did it all live.

[@janmodjadji5572]

Why would her dancers say it wasn't live? Lol she lipped that note.

[@nopestopitplz6079]

@@janmodjadji5572 they could have just not said anything at all. but in fact, the dancer said Bey did live rehearsals and the performance as a whole. also, like I said, you can hear when she covers the mic. 😘

[@janmodjadji5572]

@@nopestopitplz6079 I'm not delusional.

[@nopestopitplz6079]

@@janmodjadji5572 you’re not very bright either

[@IamRocque]

Right you can tell it’s live. There’s no reason to lip sync such easy notes for Beyoncè.

[@maincoasters]

Neither of my parents can sing, but ariana is mother so I really learn a lot

[@varunravi27]

Yes I really needed this 🤍 I do agree that people presume most lipped vocals to be live. Excuses like "You can hear breathing" or "The mic is on", like you said, do not work. Breathing can be pre-recorded to make it sound live. That first Beyoncé performance was very obviously lipsynced... it isn't humanely possible, even for Beyoncé, to sing with that much control while flapping her legs around and doing that much movement and dancing. It was kind of hard to tell with the second Beyoncé performance though. Edit: The second performance (Drunk In Love) is DEFINITELY lipped, now that I think about it. The water was spraying all over the place; the fact that the mic didn't pick up any additional sound whatsoever proves that it was off the whole time.

[@arditd7724]

Now this entire line of argumentation is flawed. Dead on arrival. Shame

[@varunravi27]

@@arditd7724 Just because you and a lot of other ignorant people can't accept facts doesn't mean that what I'm saying is "flawed". Unless you want to look more ignorant, I'll leave it at this.

[@michellegarcia5364]

Morissette dazzles! She is the consummate vibrato Queen.

[@JoCurKRAZE]

Love ❤️ this topic ….. always cool but interesting opinions 💯 Great video as always ‼️

[@ishathakor]

i don't really get the jisoo vs jennie debate because they're both so underdeveloped it can be argued either way. i think we can all agree that vocal lessons would do them both some good

[@poosea6979]

Taylor's voice really is inconsistent,but it's gotten much more stable and better since 1989 (maybe,or is it Rep?) era. Not shaky,sometimes still pitchy,can hit high notes with ease now,still killing it with them low notes everytime,and still a queen at belting. For me,the only eras where she performed bad vocally are Debut,Fearless,and Red era. I don't think she still has the same vocal coach,but her voice has gotten a lot better,all she needs to do now is to have confidence (Maybe it's just me but if u pay attention to videos where she performs at a show where there's only a couple of people and those videos where she performs something at a concert,whether it's a surprise song,an acoustic version of it,or something,u can see that she looks more comfortable singing to places with fewer people [Not that she performs badly on her concerts.] (Im not rlly good at English but if u get what im saying,then there's no need to comment about my grammar.😽)

[@poosea6979]

Examples of vids with fewer ppl are the Secret Sessions,her Begin Again performance at that one show,and some of her Speak Now songs on that same show.

[@teddies6549]

It is a fact that jisoo is the second best vocalist in bp after rosè jennie got her position as a lead vocalist only years after her debut

[@ihatecoffee7185]

bro i been sayin that clip of beyonce in dubai isn't live. u can see she was abt to say smthn on the mic to the dude strapping her on when the track started singing for her😭

[@RenaG]

“the track started singing for her” its still her singing lol

[@ihatecoffee7185]

@@RenaG i know... if you read, you'd know that the point is it wasn't live. she wasn't singing in that specific moment. so. the tracked vocals she recorded previously, sang for her. DUH

[@danielsick4927]

As a jensetter I agree jisoo is a better vocalist than Jennie ,like let's not be delusional now,and what buggin me is that Jennie doesn't have enough vocal material that really showcase her skills even though she is the second in line distribution....her legato is nice and I'm waiting for teddy to start giving her more melisma line....oh and you did jisoo wrong there ,find a better clip and reasoning to prove jisoo is better than Jennie cuz those tight belt is not it ....overall love the video ..

[@alikarol3]

Taylors live performances improved when she gained some healthy weight and got in amazing shape. She wasn't so out of breath all the time and learned better control. She's still shakey here and there but a 100% improvement.

[@melaniaarce8226]

I would love if you do a video about the underestimation of kpop vocalists

[@aintnootherfan]

I’ve been thinking about it for quite some time!

[@masteroffear5762]

@@aintnootherfan Nah now go and make it, i'd love to see that because people underestimating K-Pop vocalists for a long time

[@melaniaarce8226]

@@masteroffear5762 Yup. I'm tired of American fans saying that western vocalist s are always better, it's tiring.

[@masteroffear5762]

@@melaniaarce8226 And you know what? It's not just vocalists, but also rappers. Like dude, even K-pop idol rappers are far better than western mumbling rappers, although of course they still need to be a contender against likes Eminem, Nas, Kanye West, Missy Elliot, Tupac, Ice Cube, J.Cole or Kendrick Lamar. K rappers are good too. They should not be underestimated. Maybe there's should be a mixed vocal ranking between western and K-Pop artists.

[@AM-dd6dx]

Taylor’s long pond sessions surprised the hell out of me. I wish she’d done it for evermore.

[@AM-dd6dx]

I think Demi’s vibrato improved a lot in her Tiny Desk.

[@BB8425]

Thanks for the video~~~ This was fun for real ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@aintnootherfan]

Thank you for watching!😎

[@dodosh9444]

My ears spotted a Purple Kiss outro and I hope there is more to come on that!

[@littlemixwillsurvivelittle976]

Let's not rush little mix it's only been like under a year since their last tour. Leigh Anne seems to be obviously ready to release music. She's been treated well by her team (so far) by being booked and invited to big events in America and the UK. You'll have to be patient with them as this is new to them and you'll have to wait if you're a perrie and jade Stan because they expressed that they won't release anything at the same time to avoid the messy media putting them against each other on the charts etc (although they still will put them against each other no matter what) I think it's lovely of them to wanna support each other and let each other shine on their own, true friendship 💜 I can't wait to see what Leigh Anne releases.

[@mioann02]

Couldn't have said it better 👏

[@littlemixwillsurvivelittle976]

@@mioann02 🤗

[@dadg98ddg]

I'm so excited for Leigh's solo music

[@littlemixwillsurvivelittle976]

@@dadg98ddg I can't wait to hear how she sounds by herself in her own type of music.

[@dadg98ddg]

@@littlemixwillsurvivelittle976 I can tell you I heard a song that leaked a few months ago and I LOVED IT, she sounds amazing

[@jorgekeirey4550]

I want to know why you and that Garagestudio hater seem to think the Drunk in Love clip is not live? Like on what basis do y'all make these claims?

[@Lilla223344]

I can't believe that it still has to be said that Jisoo is a better vocalist than Jennie, for real I thought there are no debates about it cause it's obvious 😅

[@Goddessbat18]

Thank you so much for talking about how Beyoncé uses prerecorded vocals sometimes. I talk about this all the time and get torn to pieces for it. But it’s fine, she puts on a great show she doesn’t have to sing live all the time. But let’s just be real about it. She’s not super human 😭

[@drusilla2943]

exactly, beyhive be like her breath support this and that😂. Shes one of the best vocalist and entertainer, doesnt mean her vocals wont be shaky with all those movement.

[@arditd7724]

​@@drusilla2943 her breath support really is all that

[@beynotes868]

5:36 still better than today's pop gurls

[@earth2kira]

i think miyeon sounds more like jessica out of any snsd member tbh

[@drewdidenot7722]

Yeah, but Taeyeon and Jessica have very similar voices so it makes no difference.

[@polskityton6062]

OMG Celine :)

[@tkn7390]

I disagree, Beyonce dubai was live . The other 2 Beyonce ones were pre recorded

[@laramiaizz]

Can you do Siyeon vs Yoohyeon vocal battle or something?

[@yully5082]

5:55 finally somebody talks about this. 🙌

[@slimjam2467]

Why specifically target Bey and use THREE instances where she lip synced…and even one from a decade ago like what was ur point there?? What unpopular opinion was it tht needed three clips of her lfmaoao jus being shady for no reason

[@aintnootherfan]

Because I do often see Beyoncé be praised for singing live and I comment on how a lot of people have problems with telling lipsync and live vocals apart All these 3 clips have been labelled as “live” by many commentators So that’s why; Beyoncé is generally getting nothing but praise on my channel and that’s a fact

[@Heroliesinyou]

​@@aintnootherfan You know Beyonce's fans will come for you, unless you say she's inhuman sings and dancers on pitch all the time. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@rydercdaniels4475]

I wouldn’t call Taylor swift a “vocalist” 😂

[@HumminGBird168]

I'm not a swiftie at all, but her low notes are something else

[@filipmarinkovic6281]

after Reputation, she sure can be called one, not neccecararly a GREAT one, but a nice one, her lows carry the word "vocalist" for her

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

@@HumminGBird168 I agree

[@helloyou2253]

Sometimes she can't even belt an A4 , it should be easy for a soprano 💀

[@grandeflamesbutera3949]

@@helloyou2253 She literally has consistent E5 & Eb5 belts on her reputation tour. Did u even bother to research before typing? 🤣

[@kanzrifrosie]

I think Jisoo better than Jennie is debatable. Jennie is so lack of singing material. Btw i don't hate anyone

[@isaiahfralix4423]

Can you make a video on who you think is the best vocalist in Cimorelli? Or can you grade their harmonies?

[@rodrigoalves3408]

I actually really love Demi's voice. For me, their voice is so unique, powerful and full out feelings

[@yureino]

Her*. Demi is feeling her again lol. You need to be updated with her pronouns.

[@fusfuru1]

About 7:48 i feel like Chaewon from Class:y sounds exactly like a young version of Taeyeon, way more than Miyeon, but they have similar tone too!

[@CatheLesp]

I’ve lost faith in Beyoncé’s live performance as a whole the day I saw her in Montreal, her hair got caught in a fan and she « continued singing » Halo like nothing was happening while staff people were pulling and pushing her around to get her free from the damn fan. She hit the note.

[@itsmeJ89]

How do you always come up with the most interesting videos

[@aintnootherfan]

☺️🥹😇

[@henryfischer5365]

What is your opinion on Taylor Swift's vocals during the Fearless Tour?

[@richmaxmchalliwchester1984]

First of all I'm a big Swiftie! Fearless Tour was 2009 - 2010 - there was definitely a lot improvement from previous years (2006 - 2008), she had few lucky supported A4s and Bb4s, but still pretty inconsistent. We should be thankful that she didn't has any vocally challenging songs in her catalog at the time because she simply wouldn't be able to handle it, but it was a really good start for her vocal journey. I was just going down KZbin watching random videos of Fearless Tour one day because i was bored and that was the first time i heard a vibrato from Taylor, again it was only very few lucky moments, but still that vibrato sounded great, she should use it more. Vibrato is very rare from Taylor so i was pleasently surprised.

[@GarageStudio7]

1:37 I bet this is going to be controversial. Thanks for sharing your take on this particular clip. The dramatic head movements and being slightly late/almost missing the cue, gave it away. Not surprised that the general public (and many fans) think the Dubai clip is live; to this day, many claim that 1:26 is live. For some reason, the masses think "The mic is always on" when it comes to Beyonce. Even though it wasn't live, her tone has improved (her voice has matured better than many). 2:48 Gotta love Aretha; she kept it real 😅 You are spot on! With the participation trophy mentality that is running rampant these days, people don't like to hear it however some voices are naturally more gifted/pleasant than others. Technique can certainly help one to improve what they have but some will naturally have voices that appeal to the majority over others. Just like "Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder" some have more beholders than others. Side note: I don't know if you have watched "Got2BeReal" but it's fantastic 😄. It's a voice-over of the vocal divas & singers. I think it's stil on KZbin.

[@lizatsurkan4323]

“Just like "Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder" some have more beholders than others.” I feel like some naturally gifted singers kind of take advantage of this and only train their voices up to a certain point

[@kurischan7303]

They were fooled by that Dubai performance. Lol

[@AM-dd6dx]

Have you seen Legends Panel or Paro Deez channel?

[@GarageStudio7]

@@lizatsurkan4323 You are completely spot on about that!

[@GarageStudio7]

@@kurischan7303 😅

[@filipmarinkovic6281]

00:52 for example, Katy Perry and Lady Gaga. I hate how instead of praising the fact that Katy never lip-synced even tho she ofc planned to jump, move and dance and sound shaky or off key at times, before performing, people use that to make her seem like she can't sing, and she always could, but she chose to have fun in One Of The Boys and Teenage Dream era. MTV Unplugged or any acoustic/stripped down performance from those eras prove my point. And plus ofc, she improved, after 2015 i don't think there is a bad performance, and after 2020, nothing below good. Her musicality and creativity in adding high notes and any vocals are underrated, she never performs the song the same way (same for Ariana) And Gaga will always be underrated as a vocalist no matter how much praise she gets, i'm glad her art is getting recognition bc she is a genius, but to use those artistic, "crazy", over the top performances to say she is not as good or even worse that she can't sing is pure ignorance at best

[@aintnootherfan]

I agree! It’s so unfair for people to make fun of them sometimes but that’s what being used to lip sync does🫠

[@Justdance272727]

Answer me this pls: in ur honest opinion can Ningning sing live? Because her voice sound so weak whenever she has to do her high notes.

[@peupeukoo]

great video as always 💗

[@HumminGBird168]

5:45 Arianators get it 👇

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

I got it 😍

[@Reo805]

Oh lord this video is so fan made with you salivating over kpop 😅

[@Beytheevocalist.]

Drunk in love is live no matter what you say white man

[@cristi4n.anderson]

1:39 someone on tiktok made a video about this being lipped and it drove the beyhive crazy. that was an intense show so can't throw stones because if she messed up, would mess up the whole thing but i'm pretty sure that was the only pre recorded part

[@squarcircle2254]

There was so much money paid to her and privately. They wouldn’t have done all of that so she’d lip the performance. It doesn’t make sense. There wasn’t a lot of dancing and movements either. It’s not like she’s an amateur. She’s an incredible vocalist. And someone on TikTok pointing out that it was lipped doesn’t mean it was lipped.

[@mismiserables]

Lol when I heard the first point I immediately thought about the beyonce video...like she would have to be superhuman to sing that while rolling around and still sounding so good. Also rihanna always had a very lazy dance style. Just like in the SuperBowl performance. If people want to see spectacular dancing they'll have to look at her backup dancers otherwise just just know what to expect with her.

[@arditd7724]

Beyonce is an athlete's as well as a vocalist. She jumps kicks on heels while singing live She makes it look easy so ppl don't even acknowledge it

[@Anjan_-]

What are your thoughts on nmixx s living singing ( lily performing o.o with hand mic) they are really using mic and putting cds in their blood

[@AM-dd6dx]

Idk about the Dubai one just cause as she was adjusting herself on the lift, her hand passed over the microphone and her voice got muffled for a quick second, which means it was on. I definitely think she was singing, at least for parts of it.

[@aintnootherfan]

Her mic might have stayed on, but the track was playing nonetheless

[@rafitos6690]

my honest opinion: beyoncé is terrible at lip syncing lol that deja vu performance was so clearly not live i’m so glad someone finally said it

[@missz1833]

FINALLY. someone who agrees that jisoo's vocals are better, IM HONESTLY SO TIRED OF JENSTTERS CLAIMING THAT JENNIES VOCALS ARE WAY BETTER AND JISOO IS "just a visual" HER VOCALS ARE NO JOKE NITHER ARE HER VISUALS

[@luckyrathore192]

Beyonce dang that drunk in love note totally live at her tour ...go watch it

[@yoncedelrey]

the dubai drunk in love is literally live! you can hear her hand on the mic messing her up from starting on time! like huh?

[@swacman04]

No it’s not. It’s lipped.

[@NoName-pu1er]

Dont start. Go back to your hive honey we dont have time for beyhive drama here

[@squarcircle2254]

@@swacman04 prove it was lipped.

[@swacman04]

@@squarcircle2254 you prove it wasn’t

[@squarcircle2254]

@@swacman04 it wasn’t lipped (because there’s no reason for it to be) until someone can prove it was.

[@tkn7390]

The Dubai concert is live my friend... She does on renaissance tour every show. And it's obvious it's live because it changes every time... I'm really wondering about your credibility and capability of singing. Lost me as a subscriber haha

[@whitelilies3799]

About Taylor swift, she confuses me as much and idk enough about the topic but i *think* her vocals declined around 1989 (2014-2016) when she had an eating d*sorder. I know that weakens the muscles and affects the vocal cords, weight gain also has an effect so ig she was adjusting when she was recovering post 2017. On top of that she seems to lack confidence because there's a video recorded outside her house of her singing i will always love you and you'll never hear her attempt those notes live.

[@jessicasales9028]

I think miyeon sounds more like Jessica than Taeyeon

[@ifyouseekme6694]

Oh wow you're right. I do hear Jessica.

[@drewdidenot7722]

True. But Jessica sounds like Taeyeon so Miyeon sounds like both.

[@connor8099]

I personally never found Taylor Swift unpredictable. In the beginning of her career she was either going to sound average or good with maybe a few bad notes here or there and in more recent years she usually sounds good with maybe a few average moments here or there. But you can definitely tell she has been practicing over the years and she has went from being literally the definition of average to literally the definition of good but not amazing either and I think that's because yes she has been practicing over the years but she hasn't been practicing enough and that's why she has only made the transition to good but not amazing yet. Literally all she has to do is practice and work on her technique more and she could easily become a vocal Powerhouse and she's already pretty damn good so it wouldn't even take her all that long to get there there is so much unutilized potential. Someone like Lady Gaga is the perfect example of what she could be like a Powerhouse mezzo-soprano with Powerhouse belts and great low notes. Like if you were to take Lady Gaga and water down all her abilities you would get Taylor Swift lol

[@peupeukoo]

YASSSS REASON APPRECIATION 🔥🔥🔥

[@RaffaelWindgassen]

My 'brutally honest opinion' Most of commenters are not musicians/singers or people that really know a thing about music and voice. They just like to talk about this stuff. They remind me very much of those foodies that use the word mouthfeel and texture everyday, but couldn't make a decent plate of pasta to save their life 😂 In short: they just have bad ears, so they think their faves sing live all the time

[@mostcreative3680]

I feel like the Jamaica performance was proof that Mariah's inconsistencies are like 99% how nervous she is. I mean Im not gonna sit here and say she can sing the way she did when she was 19 but when she relaxes her vocal chords and stops the nasally whisper singing she sounds great.

[@Anjan_-]

Nmixx , itzy ,iu , beyonce ,celine dion really said eat cds and it has become a trend

[@Anjan_-]

I would like that to exclude beyonce I was just thinking bout her By mistake road

[@Anjan_-]

Wrote her

[@BP-tm6ye]

what is those songs 1:26 1:38

[@corpedatlanta]

Deja Vu by Beyoncé and Drunk in Love by Beyoncé (Dubai Version)

[@RenaG]

This Jennie vs Jisoo discourse is crazy considering they’re both terrible singers

[@kiranlimbu491]

Rude much

[@devanjihoon1270]

I'd like to hear your thoughts on the new group Fifty Fifty

[@littlealdo222]

What is the song called at 6:04?

[@r.uwamhenye8282]

Sometimes by Ariana from dangerous woman

[@averyatwell95]

Jisoo vs. Jennie debate is so funny. Cause both of them are not even vocalists. 😂

[@nyerhovwoakpome2151]

What do you mean they aren't vocalists?? Are you saying they aren't good vocalists or that they do not hold a vocalist position in the group, which they do, they are both lead vocalists

[@Sylvaincks]

yeah, even if one of them is better than the other they are still extremely close and both underdeveloped as vocalists

[@averyatwell95]

@@nyerhovwoakpome2151 I don't mean positions lol. I mean they are both underdeveloped/non vocalists as in they don't support. But Jennie has shown some kind of shallow support on some notes in the mid range I guess but Jisoo has never. I think that's why people say Jennie better but it doesn't matter much.

[@nyerhovwoakpome2151]

@@averyatwell95 Oh, I get what you're saying, they are both vocally underdeveloped but I have noticed that Jisoo is more consistent than Jennie especially recently in their tour, it's still hard to listen to them both tho, like I want to run to them to stop them from ruining their throats even more

[@averyatwell95]

@@nyerhovwoakpome2151 yeah you get it.

[@yag___7]

Dahhhhh beyonce always live

[@nickardomccrae1519]

😭😭😭 leave me alone Beyonce's singing will always be live to me . Call me delusional but I'm choosing to believe a lie 🤥🤡

[@GarageStudio7]

Even the lip-synced national anthem that she had a conference about?

[@nickardomccrae1519]

@@GarageStudio7 😂 yes , even if she did say it out of her own mouth . Ignorance is bliss .

[@aintnootherfan]

@@GarageStudio7 😂😂

[@aintnootherfan]

@@nickardomccrae1519 at least you’re self-aware!

[@arditd7724]

She got some lip syncs when she was young and they're trash. She's way more nervous when she lip syncs than when she's not

[@diamond82737]

Yujin from Ive sounds like Taeyeon

[@Sky-ys6jw]

Not even close

[@Naomimvl]

Ok but on baby boy B doesn’t even have her mic so I don’t think she was trying to make it look like it was live lol 1:57 It’s weird tho how many og fans are delusional about some of bey’s lip syncing. I’ve a fan since forever, I know when she’s singing live now lol and it’s not much of a big deal when she does cause we all know she can deliver And I feel like with Taylor, she gets too nervous when she’s singing in award shows and it takes a toll on her vocals. Today she’s gotten better at it but she still sounds off. And from the beginning of her career to 2012 her live vocals were not it. There’s a few exceptions, like her red live performance on a boat in Paris in 2012. She sounded great there. But yeah she’s pretty inconsistent but as fans we eat it up everytime lol I’d be so happy if she got in touch with a GOOD vocal coach 😅

[@squarcircle2254]

I don’t think the Dubai show was lipped though. There weren’t rigorous movements, she’s an incredible live vocalist, and she was paid an insane amount of money. Why lip it?

[@Naomimvl]

@@squarcircle2254 cause why not? It’s very normal for her to lip little parts of a song in shows and performances, I don’t think it’s a big deal if she did it in Dubai. After watching so many videos of her lip syncing moments, you can kind of tell by her face and the way it moves when it’s not live

[@ronnydraper]

Beyoncé needs a good vocal coach???? The one who vocal pedagogues literally worship on this app? They know a lot more than you. We can talk about Resentment at the formation world tour, Listen at Xfactor, If I Were A Boy at the Grammys, etc. PLENTY of tea. She actually sings live more than she doesn't and if she doesn't it's vocal preservation which is why she is 40+ and still able to sing. Idiots everywhere.

[@arditd7724]

Only the clip from 2003 of Beyonce isn't live. Deja vu is absolutely live. Are you desperate for engagement or what?

[@Miraclemac]

The Dubai one is certainly live too idk how he came to that conclusion

[@arditd7724]

@@Miraclemac right, she got paid 35 mil for that. You think she would risk embarrassing herself with a potential technical malfunction at such an event🤣 Beyonce has nothing to gain from lip syncing, unlike the rest, who NEED it

[@TheHonored01]

​@ardit D she fell to the floor with the audio movement whatsoever. That is not live laughing my ass off. Also, the dubai 1 is iffy.

[@arditd7724]

@@TheHonored01 elaborate on fell to the floor? She sucks at lip syncing and she stopped doing it 10 years ago

[@TheHonored01]

@ardit D No, she hasn't ur delusional. And you can clearly see her get down on the ground. There was no soudn change whatsoever

[@aliciastarsaturn2841]

Taylor never lip sings and I don’t know if Ari does all the time with the range she has

[@oceanamelodies8062]

she does sometimes, more often in the past, but in recent times occasionally as well

[@Zay-yv9co]

Demi’s vibrato was good there tho?

[@ernesfonse]

Beyoncé is the queen of prerecorded and lip syncing vocals.

[@lvlimua]

At last somebody talk about rih superbowl performance, it’s overatted

[@marineserre6858]

i always thought beyoncé’s deja vu performance was live …. like i would ALWAYS reference that when talking sbout crazy live performances …. feeling so stupid rn 😢😢

[@roger9283]

Don’t feel like that she has done performances where she sing and dance at the same time that he even can confirm for example her super bowl performance in 2013 cause she had something to prove that time Lip singing is very common in shows just for good entertainment or sometimes you may not feel your voice in some days cause of course no matter how of an amazing vocalist you are there some days you feel insecure about your vocals just like a batterie of a phone and so you don’t want to mess up

[@arditd7724]

​@@roger9283 she's been training since 5. Have you seen the Insane live acrobatics she does? Deja vu is live . There's a backing track for 20 secs

[@roger9283]

@@arditd7724 I know her story and aware of all that or even more than you thought but My was not for this performance it’s about how lip singing isn’t a bad thing for some reason

[@tonshaad1230]

Lets be bonest even when shes not lipsyncong, Beyonce is just weird vocally and has to perform because if she didn't, her hits wouldn't suffice as her discograpghy is BORING.

[@eecolme]

Do you think P!nk sings live when she is up in the air?

[@aintnootherfan]

Pink does sing live and she never sounds unrealistically clear and polished

[@arditd7724]

​@@aintnootherfan beyonce too perfect? It's what it is just accept it

[@bodhisattva2348]

I felt the beyonce vocals were definitely live & I felt the rihanna superbowl could've been better. TS has terrible vocals but great songs & good performances.

[@elijahlora224]

Nothing but facts

[@squarcircle2254]

I can see why the MTV performance was lipped (loads of over the top dancing and movement) BUT the Dubai gig wasn’t lipped, especially the part you highlighted. 1) The reasons you gave aren’t proof that something was lipped. Beyonce has had such headaches movements while singing live. 2) There wasn’t a lot of dancing (legit reasons to lip) and she wasn’t sick (to the best of my knowledge). So why lip, when she’s sang live while sick many a time? 3) Nobody privately pays someone 25 (or 35) million dollars, for about 2 hours, for that person to lip their live vocals. That’s not how things work when you’re paid for a private performance.

[@soemoeaung4857]

You should adele

[@idc8063]

It's the way you simply just say "this just cannot be live" without given a single reason why....(at least for Beyoncé's one since I just stopped watching after that)

[@chespinsdounuts3499]

1.I don’t know what would suggest Beyoncé wasn’t singing live in Dubai but you can have opinions I guess 2.Jisoo is NOT a better vocalist than Jennie nowadays I’d say they’re equal or jennie slightly edges but Jennie has always had way better moments in the 4 octave in below than jisoo,Jusoo and Jennie both aren’t good vocalist to say jisoo is better than Jennie when she’s either straining or extremely nasal Jennie has better and more consistent placement than jisoo does🤷🏾‍♂️(still haven’t forgotten her being over Kariselle)