Motion Extraction tutorial (attempt...)

[@moebest]

I believe the issue in Premiere is the order in which the effects are applied. Instead of using the invert effect and changing the opacity to 50%, here's how you would do it: - Duplicate layer and shift by the desired frames - Apply Calculations Effect - Check "invert input", set second layer to the reference layer, second layer Opacity 50% this works at least on my end and also allows you to target individual channels, not just RGB In after effects this works natively, probably because the order of how the opacity and inversion is applied is different compared to Premiere

[@2DVincent]

adobe always finds a way to overcomplicate and slow down your projects...

[@SimonVasquez]

That Worked on Pr24! Took me a bit to find the calculations effect since its translated and the search also looks for accent markings (its on the obsolete FX).

[@mistersircode]

How do you "apply calculations effect"?... Im confused lol

[@moebest]

@@mistersircode the calculations effect is just another effect like any other. drag and drop it onto the layer and select the layers you wish to blend

[@evaneatsbacon]

amazing comment - thanks a million!

[@elliotmarks06]

Worth noting that the whole effect can be done in the free version of resolve!

[@chris616]

this is singlehandedly the best davinci resolve ad i've ever seen

[@jbarber7127]

Never even heard of it until I saw this video but now I have it (the free version).

[@jeffpv7468]

FOR ADOBE: you need to go to sequence > sequence settings > and turn off "Composite in Linear Color" this will make all colors work as you want them to and they will invert and blend correctly :)

[@TimBurbank237]

THIS! Why isn't this comment at the top?

[@Imagiinae]

Gimp has the same problem where "invert" doesnt actually invert the colors properly, but instead "linear invert" does.

[@Flakester]

I just want to thank you for this... I've been trying to get this working in OBS by applying a LUT, and could not get it working properly using the built in invert.png. After creating a new inverted image file using the linear invert, its working perfectly.

[@zeskfx]

not going to lie, these are the kind of tutorials that I needed (to learn new stuff). Your videos are very well made, very relaxed and very entertaining, thanks for making them! Ps. greetings from Germany :D

[@tverdyznaqs]

lmao, homeboy doesn't even go into the fusion page once. respect!

[@dpo2078]

posy, the examples you created in the motion extraction video that directed me here are mindblowingly creative. I especially liked the clip at the 2 minute mark, and would love to figure out how to use this technique to create something similar... specifically with how you managed to separate the trees from the sky. that and the clip with the grass blades are just so damn cool. I appreciate you putting this out there!

[@majordabalert]

I think part of it had to do with it being a clear sky with no (visibly) moving clouds

[@EggBastion]

I love how softwares just agressively _DOESN'T give a good go-ddamn_ about which folders you _'default'_ or _'most recently used'_ - even when they 'do' - the harder they try... the worse job they do

[@JimGriffOne]

Premiere... Adobe ruins every piece of software they buy out, just like how Microsoft do with software they buy out. And don't get me started on subscription schemes just to be able to open your old projects... I hate the _"You will own nothing, have no privacy, but be happy. :)"_ world. I'm not happy.

[@Splarkszter]

Yup, glad DaVinchi has perpetual license and also works on linux

[@JimGriffOne]

@@Splarkszter Oh yeah! And a free version, too, for those who don't need all the features. Can't stand companies who put profit before their products (like Adobe).

[@Raoul1808.]

Focusing so much on profit, the software suite is a buggy mess, but it still sells because it has the Adobe name.

[@S0L4RE]

lol I crack Adobe software in my disassembler

[@parthl]

im dreading the day that final cut moves to a subscription model

[@cest7343]

Thank You so very much Posy for teaching us swearing in Premiere 🙏

[@pontifier]

This needs to be standard in security camera software.

[@xing3240]

While I'm sure this could be useful in some cases, it is a bit overkill for most. Afaik, most cameras/motion detectors have a Passive Infra-Red (PIR) Sensor to pick up on thermal changes such as body heat in order to detect motion.

[@72nodes85]

This man is clinically insane, I love him.

[@michel_demello]

Never have i seen such a direct tutorial in my life

[@setharnold9764]

Oh wow! Those shelves are in focus!

[@StillthatguyJake]

Your videos are fantastic! Thanks for making me laugh 10 seconds into this one...and then keeping me watching until the end!

[@joedirtpig814]

Glad I chose resolve on a whim and stuck with it. (Also helped that the free tier works for everything I need it for)

[@knightfury7120]

I used this method on vsdc free editor amd it worked smoothly, I was super interested in watching foots steps on gravel

[@CYXXYC]

i think you needed 50% opacity with some other mode, as it looks like their normal mode is not averaging colors but doing something else

[@FlyRetroGamer]

This is what I wanted.

[@SyntheticFuture]

14 second tutorial. Well done 👍🏻

[@roborogue_]

loved the outro

[@karasekjh]

Wow. Thank you very much... I hope you'll show us how to do other more advanced edits with colors etc. I would definitely pay for it.

[@smirkingaki6837]

I mean. I have an idea of how to do that outside of Premier. I actually have it on my "interesting programming challenges"-list.

[@FTLOI]

This the funniest thing Iv' watched in ages, might even give it a go some time on vsdc lol

[@smirkingaki6837]

I saw the previous video and I just remembered that I thought: man, I should write a program to quickly do this automatically. Now I see it again so I'm writing it on my free time list haha

[@mtbewan5632]

This has to be the most mind blowing thing I have ever seen. Thank you so much for making this tutorial. Also I had the same reaction when using new premiere pro when updating it. HILARIOUS

[@robni7]

Great, now I want your underscore/extended(?) mix of Microgalaxies too, I love the string plucks! Also, will you be releasing the “Zalwal”-track you featured in the main motion extraction video? Cheers ;)

[@E4S65]

Same, I want this extended version of it too!

[@ricande]

I was laughing so hard the first minutes of this video,... :D

[@quiteadept]

thank you for this, i am an idiot and

[@treakzy_9594]

i came for the tutorial and stayed for the Pr rant :D

[@КириллНовострелов]

In "adobe primer 2019" invert+opacity 50% correctly working.

[@TechnicalGamingChannel]

I think the reason it doesn't work in adobe is that the opacity is applied to the footage before it's inverted. I think if you add an opacity effect and place it below the invert, it should work. Or you could just not use Premiere because Resolve is better and works I guess lol

[@naiknaik8812]

oh my god more posy content

[@macktheinterloper]

Thank you, this is exactly what I'd expect from a lazy tutorial haphazardly slapped together. But seriously, thank you, that was informative and helpful. Also, I pity anyone forced to use Adobe.

[@michaelspahn3675]

Thx Posy, I tried it with PS, and it worked, but not very well to handle. But your little funny tutorial is very usefull und your motion extraction technique brought a lot of new ideas into my personal timeline.

[@RafaelPlayer]

where are my FOLDERS??! DAMN YOU, PREMIERE

[@fishchikin]

thank you for this, i was confused as to why my effect came out different

[@unknown_E]

Yoo I found a solution (for premiere pro): After inverting, change the opacity to 50%, then apply blend mode linear light. I think it gives a similar effect

[@JacobClarke]

Yeah seems like this kind of discovery is partly a product of using Resolve -- having personally only used Premiere before, the node-based vfx workflow and even just the color grading ui all seem really intuitive. Is audio also done in a node based way?Are there any other night-and-day things converted resolve users would like to comment on? Am tempted to give it a try..

[@ColourRedCalls]

Thank you so much

[@fazergazer]

Perhaps one can do a similar thing in sound scape. Then the bike horn would naturally play its resonance frequency negative complement!😂 actually thanks very much for the great video❤

[@MrFunkinPure]

Thanks for covering Premiere. I’d tried a few things but was still coming up shorter than Rishi Sunak.

[@Andee...]

50% opacity and invert works in after effects as well

[@2DVincent]

resolve is definitely the way to go

[@EricLefebvrePhotography]

I did it in Fusion instead. image into a color ivert node to a time remaper into a merge on top of the original footage and then a color correction nide to confvert to balck and white. Save this as a preset ofr quick motion extraction.

[@zight123]

Hey Posy, Question for ya brother, Watching your original video on motion extraction, i was wondering what you meant by to see fast movement you move it 1 frame, and for slower movement move the time by 1 second?

[@barbee3602]

I did it, it was awesome! thank you for the inspration!

[@broadcastbytes]

This is 'time difference' yes. That's an in-built After effects effect. Pre-Comp. Add in a curves and even glow for a bit of spice. and voila! I may be missing something but this feels very much like time difference

[@henkenn]

i have davinci so i may as well give this a try :)

[@khalifaadam1653]

sequence > sequence settings > turn off "Composite in Linear Color"

[@fynnroovers4267]

For all the people having trouble achieving this effect in Premiere, the only thing you have to do extra is this: Sequence - Sequence Settings - Disable 'Composite in linear color'

[@YasinHasan]

that somewhat works

[@rooditooti4388]

doing this in capcut is crazy, truing to make sometjign that looks, like, GOOD...well im struggling to gwt there still but im keepin at it

[@bibliusz777]

How to blend colors so that in places with no changes, the image is black, not grey? I use my implementation, not some established software. So far my blending is computed like so: a2_scaled = a2 * (1 - a1) a = a1 + a2_scaled r = (r1 * a1 + r2 * a2_scaled) / a g = (g1 * a1 + g2 * a2_scaled) / a b = (b1 * a1 + b2 * a2_scaled) / a

[@LemoniumOre]

you need to be in the edit mode in davinci to see the little chain thing here 1:34

[@serhiirudenko6183]

Haha not surprised Adobe's software works like that)

[@SlavaBohu]

Nice, thank you man.

[@thirstyCactus]

@4:48 1st time i hear distortion on a Posy video. forgot the limiter? :D

[@clayday5299]

Cool beans

[@mattiabucciol]

i missed the part where he freeze frame the clip inside premiere or something?

[@delusionnnnn]

I think Vegas might be doing something a bit odd. After all, if you invert a channel and set it to 50% opacity, you shouldn't get a 100% knock out, but rather a half-inverted image which pushes the colours around. Right? I could be misunderstanding. But yeah, it's frustrating that these don't use the same design language. Honestly, Adobe apps don't even use the same UI affordances as other Adobe apps. Font support for OpenType and Style Sets between Illustrator, Photoshop, and InDesign is madness.

[@TaritSenaAlt]

The Old Chair broke after 8 (or so) years, R.I.P. Old Chair

[@Nadiaidan]

How do i do the color shifting thing? (Da Vinci Pro)

[@legoworks-cg5hk]

How do you shift the red green and blue channels in time?

[@lazyposy]

I make a separate layer for each color :) and I forgot which blending mode I used to combine them ;-)

[@Mark_Rober]

Its so weird, I speak Afrikaans but i can read all the German folder names perfectly

[@rzdnx]

Posy or posay

[@JulsGeekPI]

Tried this with Shotcut or other open source video. Editors?

[@MacAstorYT]

I tried it and yes, you can do this motion extraction effect in Shotcut.

[@wigwagstudios2474]

Sapphire can do this with S_MotionDetect (or a similar name), but does not have as much creative capability (though I’m sure you could do stuff to it somehow)

[@Ard1023]

I want to make this effect for website . But ı dont know what is changeing in video data. If ı was know and good add programming, I will make one website and you can enter url of video and it will process and makes new video with that effect. Maybe yoıu can choose which effect going to add.(glow,rainbow....) I wish.

[@Oaisus]

What does it look like if you invert the video instead of the freeze frame? I think it will probably fix the colors of things when you walk in front of them

[@colehewitt9827]

i think it would just be the same final video but inverted

[@logandragneil366]

Hi, I attempted this in resolve but I have a strange issue. The first frame leaves darks that linger through the rest of my videos that I don't see on other peoples. It might be because I'm new to resolve or my video is not optimal. Any tips or better sites for stock videos appreciated!

[@masonsmith858]

I wonder if this is possible in iMovie? Feel like doing it to a 3minute film clip I have??🙏🏻

[@gabworm]

for a instance I thought that I was having a stroke when he 01:03

[@reddcube]

I came to watch a tutorial, but I stayed to watch more shitting on Adobe.

[@aldiergreen]

I'll try on vegas video

[@aldiergreen]

Update: Here's how to do it in Vegas. You drag the video file to the timeline; with the file selected you press 'U' to unlink the sound from the video, then you duplicate the bajdaio by njahg jbahgaaahanm maamahm balalagah

[@hehe42069-k]

@@aldiergreen I see.

[@nikolajoskarlindblad9591]

I share your unease with Premiere... If you'd have included a segment with Avid though, I might have had to Ron Swanson my computer

[@lordtyroxx]

The way to do it in Avid is to send it to a VFX house so they can do it for you in After Effects or Nuke lol

[@weesledun]

I am a noob, how did you duplicate the effect node to add the glow?

[@weesledun]

found the answer! it was Alt-S

[@fletzyproductions1190]

It work in capcut!

[@Gekko-t4i]

voice is similar to zfrank

[@reuelchinthala]

you're doing something wrong and then getting upset that it's not working..

[@acidswim1461]

No, he is following basic knowledge when it comes to graphic design and video editing. Features in premiere are not working as advertised.

[@D-K-C]

Ъ.ъ

[@ADDAxyz710]

Wait.. did you take drugs.. off the shelf? Bcuz your KZbin plaque is sideways.

[@JohnDoe-rx3vn]

i liked your first video so much that i used ChatGPT to write some python boilerplate, and with some minor error fixing, i have a python script that takes an mp4 video, and then spits out an mp4 video with the differences highlighted in bright green. It does not look nearly as cool or as wonderful as in your video, but i was so enamoured with seeing footprints in gravel (that normally would be invisible to the average person), that i had to try kzbin.info/aero/PLXiys6ucP9heLqHh4IQib85ZmnPMuxwX2

[@FelanLP]

"Motion extraction" it is callesd motion amplification in the industry. It's used to spot unwanted vibrations on heavy machinery for example. But I have not seen this used in photography or videography before. (besides the other video about motion extraction, tbh.) And since "motion extraction" is just the generalisation of what is done, but that's also whats done with motion amplification, I think it can remain named like this. And since here the time gets shifted to make motion visible in an artisik way, I would like to propose naming this effect the "Posy Shift".

[@ColourRedCalls]

The paper from years ago had amazing motion amplification of a baby breathing and other stuff you could not see by watching the original video

[@ADDAxyz710]

Stamp of approval from random citizen on the interwebs. Way too goooooo👍

[@JBroadway]

Really cool stuff you could do a lot of really cool creative effects with this! Somebody with 200IQ quick write a shader for this so playback the effect live in real-time 👀 The Linear Burn composite mode at 100% opacity in Davinci resolve also works great. Hard mix gives a really cool glitchy distorted look and hopefully wont give you a seizure Linear burn/doge also works. Vivid light works great as well for some cool colors.

[@ksenolog]

Yea, that's premiere

[@lincolngolladay]

All video editors know how stinky premiere is

[@scellyyt]

I tried it out literally the moment you showed it in your first video, it's a really trippy effect

[@Lumegrin]

oh my god wait youre using the same editing software lol i was worried this would be hard to do on it but... ok then i guess

[@UgurOnderBozkurt]

Microgalaxies!

[@fritsdehuisspin]

Hier was ik benieuwd naar, dank voor je uitleg! Zou denk ik wel heel mooi zijn als dit live toegepast zou kunnen worden in het veld om wilde dieren te observeren/waarnemen.

[@mrkitty777]

Ook leuk voor huisdieren

[@martinrages]

Zou wel kunnen, moet de video alleen een paar secondes achterlopen

[@JacobKinsley]

This will revolutionise family guy zoomer memes

[@thinkamake2948]

How would one also timeshift the rgb values? I've tried making 3 seperate inverted channels with each one being red green or blue but the end result is a weird mush that doesn't look like 3 seperate offset channels. Did you use nodes or something else?

[@TheTomJon]

If you freeze frame your clean plate then difference mode works perfectly. been doing this for years and years in Ps, Ae, and Pr as a quick rotor-scoping hack.

[@mrrodent8933]

how did you do the colours in your original video i cant seem to figure it out at all

[@jimqin1173]

what happens when you modify the opacity is that it scales the magnitude (color of the pixels) of the picture, by let the phase (location of the magnitude, or a map for the pixel magnitude) remain the same. then by substracting different frame's phase, you can extract the difference between the two frame, which is the thing that is been taken. if you just isolate the phase directly (use fourier tranform, or set the opacity to 100% or any other value really), you can essentially do the same thing, keeping part of the magnitude in the frame just makes it visible. for small motion, by amplifying this phase difference by simple math, you can amplify the motion. anyways great video

[@YasinHasan]

if only Resolve didnt have shitty UX

[@zakaroonetwork777]

Please. More in-depth about motion; if you Freeze Frame how is there motion? And what about Time Shifting?

[@Superwazop]

Noooo mirra 1 (2?) rip

[@TeraByte38]

how do you do color motion extraction (in davinci)? in the main video its at 5:17

[@Aveisinpain]

Would also like to know this. The effect was really cool!

[@Planetkid32]

The rage at 4:47, 4:59, & 5:26 make me laugh. 😂

[@TroyRubert]

Absolutely love your personality. Love seeing this side of things.

[@nika_vodvud]

I second this!!