Victoria Crown Pigeon Egg Didn't Hatch, I Need To Investigate

[@jorgehurford1742]

Please don't take any notice of criticism from ignorant people; it is very obvious you are doing the best you can ;the amount of time and trouble you go to is amazing.

[@lorisullivan327]

Agreed, Lord, didn’t anyone ever tell them if you can’t say anything nice don’t say it? I’m sure Brooke is devastated 🙏🏻🩵

[@lori1508]

Very well said. Amen.

[@peggysmith5202]

Agreed

[@csnanny1882]

I don’t think there will be a problem if it’s not the last one. It doesn’t matter Brooke, your birds, your farm. God bless.

[@cheryldavidson-Godandguitars1]

I’ve actually never seen any criticism on this channel- not in any of the comments here today . It’s one of the most positive channels with positive followers on KZbin!

[@CoyoteWindRanch]

Don’t hesitate to report an egg. This is real life on a farm, good for educating people on that.

[@angiebrewer9960]

At least the egg was fertile, they will continue to try.😊

[@cherylcollette3495]

Hello Brooke, the baby didn't die from the fall. The baby died naturally, they know it and they kicked the egg out of the nest.

[@merisehetherington9785]

That totally makes sense.

[@janellewatson1191]

Was thinking the same

[@catherineabramson5460]

❤❤Very encouraging that the egg was fertile! It will happen.

[@lucyblair9408]

Never quit Brooke making changes and discovering improvements always helps .

[@KWeston1123]

Don’t give up, Brooke! I’m sure those two pigeons won’t give up.

[@snakey319]

3rd time is the charm, put a new dead tree in there.

[@elizabethgibbens]

I agree. Never give up, even if you’re birds in love.💖

[@bettyhutcheson9318]

They may have pushed the egg out other day cause they already knew baby was gone

[@nannykat1057]

That's my thoughts....

[@patevans3709]

Brooke - Mary Carl may be the bird expert, but you are the bird nanny! Thank you for all you do for your animals, AND for sharing with us!

[@peggysmith5202]

lol. Love it!! Bird Nanny. U got that right!!

[@jeanwetzel1366]

​@@peggysmith5202❤yes yes yes! We do get to witness the absolute best Nanny in the whole wide world ❤😊

[@janetwithers7427]

So sad the egg didn't make it. I am so rooting for the Victorian crown birds to succeed. Thanks for helping them so much, Brooke ❇️💞❇️

[@cherylsmith-bell6509]

At least you know the egg was furtile. So sorry it didn't mature. When is their normal time nesting in the wild. Early spring or later? They may not want to try again this late. would shade cloth over it help?

[@randycharest4507]

​❤😊

[@randycharest4507]

❤😊

[@reneedickerson4489]

That's sad, but it is their second egg. Maybe 3rd time is the charm.

[@snakey319]

Morgan at Gold Shaw farm is having trouble hatching his goslings too, almost at the same time frame as your Pigeon looks to have got to. You sure are helping them propagate, doing everything.

[@paulasweeney7358]

So very sorry, Brooke. The birds are lucky to have you as their advocate.

[@dreamweaver8913]

I'm so sorry, Brooke. They're eventually going to have a little one successfully. I remember in the past, MaryCarl said their first one might not make it. I think they'll have one soon. Hang in there

[@valrummel7215]

Hey don't give up....keep showing the Crown Pigeons

[@karenarrowooddaniels8727]

Brooke I enjoy the stories about the VCP it is the opportunity to learn new things that I would not have known about otherwise. Thanks❤❤

[@cherylchristopher4315]

So sorry Brooke hopefully next time we will succeed.❤

[@bethandcompany4251]

I gather that they like to be hidden while nesting. Maybe enclose the shaded area or move them closer to the corner and plant taller bushes outside. Hope this is helpful. This is from the Louisville Zoo website. Nests are solid, compact, and built of dead stems, sticks, and leaves. They are low to the ground, usually about 12-50 feet from ground level. They prefer areas with tall hedges and thickets to woodlands.

[@smokeyangelav]

If you go back and watch the videos in their history, you'll find out why that location was chosen. They actually spoke to a keeper after they weren't laying in the sheltered location and this is what was decided. It worked and they started laying.

[@indica113]

so sorry about the baby... BUT now you know they can have a baby... I think 3rd times a charm!! next one will be a success!!

[@ginny5937]

Good job, Brooke!👏💐💗🙋

[@DoreenLovesHerDog]

Of course you should show us when another egg comes! I loved watching both times. We’re in this with you guys!

[@deniseharris9363]

I’m so sorry about the egg!!!! But there was a baby in there so we know they are capable!! And yay on the new nesting box!!! 3rd times the charm ❤❤❤

[@dandymom1709]

From all I've heard and read, VC pigeons often have a hard time figuring out parenting. Sometimes it takes several years for them to successfully hatch an egg and then a couple of years after that to actually raise a chick to maturity. I'm kind of surprised the egg developed as far as it did. I guess what I'm trying to say is ya'll are doing just fine. Don't get discouraged. They will figure it out.

[@sandrah2758]

Look at you go girl. Cuttin’ it up. Bummer about the egg. Maybe they are still learning about being parents. Maybe they kicked the egg out knowing it wasn’t gonna make it? Have a blessed day. Glad you are feeling better!❤️🤍💙❣️🤍💙

[@annkastura1849]

Your viewers, including me, are already involved in the life-story about these Victorian Crown Pigeons. Please continue to report on these birds. If you don’t, it would be like tearing out the last few chapters of a good novel that you already have begun to read. I’d like you to reconsider your decision.

[@jeanwetzel1366]

❤yes, please let us be a part of the next chapter ❤😊❤ of the Victorian Crown Pigeons. Unless it was too exhausting for you to share. Then we want you to take care of our Brooke. ❤

[@Psalms121KJV]

You tried your best Brooke and thank you taking us along. Thank you for giving us a glimpse into the egg - it was great seeing the inside of this egg. We are here to share in your joys and in your sadness because we are here for you Jason and MC. God bless you as you continue to take care of His creation. His Peace

[@wakuaroberts2992]

Hi Brooke. The VC pigeons are learning. I’m sure that they will be proud pigeon parents soon. Keep up the good work and good care.

[@dianepicard6198]

Good morning all. Sorry for the Victorian pigeons. I would put a shade cloth over the next to protect them from the sun. Hope next time will be the one and have a baby Victorian pigeon.

[@donnawhipple4079]

you have all ready figured it out. Lord willing and birds too the third times the charm you go girls.

[@annietaylor6023]

Sad that the little egg didn't make it to hatching but there's still hope now with the new box. Good luck.

[@galady8632]

I know Brooke and Jason are more disappointed than we are. The sturdy platform was a brilliant idea! Kudos to Bonus Mom Brooke! Since the 2 VCPs observed Brooke and Jason installing their new 'birthing room platform' hopefully they will learn the Smith's version of Teamwork and the next egg will be viable.

[@milkweed697]

Oh, so sad😢 But please keep showing everything that happens in the future… it’s very educational.

[@AlisonEngel]

This is really heartbreaking. It is so confusing too as it was developing so well for some time. I guess even the parents have a hard time getting the egg to successfully hatch. Maybe they need to be a bit more mature. Who knows. Maybe next time. xxxx

[@fayebailey9358]

Brooke, sorry about the Victorian Crown pigeon egg. Hopefully they will consider the new nesting box you built as a 'five star resort' for their next baby! ❤😊

[@lauraquigley6403]

Maybe the Victoria Crowne pigeons are just practicing? So sorry Brooke😔 Please always let us know when they sit Brooke 🙏🙏🙏Blessing’s

[@caroldibben2473]

Good morning Brooke, sorry about the Victorian crown pigeons. Blessings to Cog Hill and all the fur/feather babies.

[@nikkiflower486]

Brooke Jason and Mary Carl, we all know you always do your best for the animals in your care, sad but I am sure they will try again hun, just like nugget and goldie will! And we will be there with you when it happens! Best to you all xxx

[@marvettajones8515]

The third time is the charm Brooke! Keep trying, we believe in you.

[@sherreywurz731]

Great job brooke on the new victorian nest platform......now lets just let nature take its course girl.❤❤❤❤❤

[@evaflannagan4918]

So sad and so close! that nest is HUGE. It did not look that big until Jason had it in his arms

[@lomagibson664]

So sorry the baby didn't hatch... love you all so much! Continued prayers! God bless ❤

[@juliepippin8710]

I'm so sorry, Brooke. We were all praying for the VCP to hatch their baby.

[@ginacurtis1702]

That's so sad. But I know you won't give up. They'll build another nest, maybe some where else . I know this broke your heart but I think you're on the right track.

[@sandeepettit696]

I feel it will happen third time's a charm❤❤❤ God bless you all. God bless those Victoria Crown pigeons with a baby❤

[@robinsiciliano8923]

Oh no. So sad and sorry to hear this. Not the outcome we wanted. I do appreciate the documentation of real life. Sometimes life throws us several curve balls and strikes until we hit that home run. Helps to know I’m not the only one experiencing this day to day stuff. Sending y’all and those sweet birds hugs.

[@sylviawislocki5161]

I know you’re so disappointed. We are, too. But, please keep showing us. I so enjoy it! And, YES, the third time is the charm! 🙏🏻

[@margueritepeaden3445]

Each time there’s progress. First time the entire egg disappeared. This time it didn’t thrive, but you know it was fertilized and developing before it failed to thrive. With the new nesting box and shade cloth hopefully the next egg they lay will go full term and produce a living baby.

[@LindaSpringer-rh9xx]

So sad, but nature happens. You are doing everything you can. Thanks for keeping us updated, I hope you all have a great rest of the week.

[@ja_Iam]

Well darn. Sorry about the egg. At least you know they are capable of breeding. Hopefully you’ll get a successful hatching soon. God Bless them for trying so hard.

[@alysiachristensen5475]

Great plan Brooke!!! The nest looks great!

[@angelraburn4401]

Thank you for always being positive and sharing with us. Nature will let them have the baby when it’s time and we will all be here for it. Love y’all. Be good ❤

[@oldmanjohnsonsfarm9715]

lol...yeah...please surprise us...lol I am wayyy too emotionally invested in this! But it's only because I love your animals and am fascinated by these birds!!

[@rongray4847]

Good morning Brooke. That’s a mystery with the pigeons, maybe next time? 👍👍❤️❤️🇨🇦

[@bettymcbryar208]

Hey again! ❤ Sad news 😢 Good job on the new nesting box. Third time's the charm!!! 🐣

[@robintucci1087]

Brooke I think the 3rd tome will be a charm. Love the new nesting box.

[@anatsc69]

Sorry to hear about no baby Victorian crown pigeon

[@lizregan1949]

Hi Brooke, too bad about the baby bird. One day, Cog Hill will get a baby crown Victorian baby. Hopefully, next time. Those little baby goats grew up fast.

[@gregmacdonald3559]

Thank you both so much, inviting us into your beautiful home and family. 😊

[@moda78z]

Aww I’m sorry, Brooke. ❤️

[@kathleennicholson7620]

Brooke I'm absolutely committed at this point. I'm with you girl. I think this time is the charm ❣️

[@nan25girls]

I am so sorry their baby didn't survive but I'm glad you have designed a new nest for them! I'm praying this new baby will survive! The Cog Squad has definitely had a lot of HOPE for this to become a reality!!❤

[@ghoo283]

Brooke, so sorry that the egg failed, but your new platform is great. Third time lucky, we will soon have a chick 😊

[@Froger26]

Keep on sharing. We’ve come this far with you We don’t want to be left out on the next trial. Please. I consider the baby bird a positive thing. They will get it right eventually

[@missharley964]

Ooooh noooo! So sad to see the title of your video. Maybe next year. 😢❤

[@jeanwetzel1366]

I shared my pigeon enthusiasm with a stranger in a doctor's waiting room when I noticed her work boots and I asked her if she had a farm .😮😊 . Hopefully she checked out my wonderful farm family. At age 80, there isn't much joy in my life now except wonderful memories and my farm families. ❤

[@b.abernathy7980]

That is life, Brooke. Things happen. No matter what, we learn from life. So we will just learn what we can, and keep on going! You are doing a fantastic job!

[@jeannepotter3051]

Those crown pigeons have gone from Motel 6 to the Ritz!

[@peggysmith5202]

🤣

[@freddiehansen7324]

Aww that sucks! You take so good care of them, and accidents do happen. As sad as it is, you know now that they CAN produce offspring, they just need to not roll their egg out of the nest no more!

[@Hennessey5150]

So sorry about the baby pigeon. I was so waiting to see it well the third times a charm. I enjoy you and Jason‘s video so much and I miss Mary Carl ❤❤❤❤❤

[@kathycrook1913]

Good morning Brooke! It is hot in montgomery!

[@rlight7666]

Aww...we're getting closer to a baby. Maybe the 3rd time is the charm❤

[@AnEarthhelper]

Providing fresh cuttings and downy feathers will help. I watched birds take dog fur (post brushing) and spider webs for nesting materials. Master builders.

[@kristilucia3491]

Oh I'm sad that the little pigeon didn't make it to full development and hatching, but this whole "saga" has been such a learning experience for your family AND your viewers! Please don't give up on filming more footage and "seasons" ... it's reality TV at its best ❤

[@poorthing]

Thanks for the updates on all the birds, grateful for the female peacock choosing a safe, cool spot for her eggs. VCs now have - 3- options to nest safely? I wonder if they will reconstruct a nest- the twigs etc- instead of using the old one?

[@meeofcourse4152]

You are so inspiring, Brooke.... Never giving up. Thank you to Mr Smith for assisting you. LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE hearing Scott 🦚

[@VickieHarbaugh]

The pidgens will get it sooner or later, maybe they are young and trying.

[@GingerSnapVizsla]

Nice job. Educational. Third time's the charge for sure.

[@LoriM222]

I truly hope that this 3rd time IS the charm! Brooke, you did a wonderful job creating the new nest area and Jason for helping to make it sturdier! Hoping for excellent results!!!

[@hazellove2144]

Keep sharing the Sagas.😊

[@marjoriegriggs3503]

I am so sorry that the egg didn't hatch. But please keep showing us of the sagas because I (we ) would like too keep up with it too. We are all in this together you are not alone.

[@stonehillfarm866]

The shade cloth or even a partial tarp is a great idea.

[@katieallen3927]

Too bad about the egg; however now you have an opportunity to modify the nesting area as you've mentioned before.

[@victoriabaker4400]

SHADE CLOTH: so glad you're already on this, was going to suggest. In the wild, they'd have tree foliage overhead. So I'm excited and I think you're really getting this dialed in. If it were me, I think I'd consider removing that other hardware cloth sling, since it's clear that isn't safe. That would leave them 2 choices of solid nest spots. Anyway, great job on this, great video. I agree with you that it appears the chick stopped developing before the egg rolled out. It would have been much farther along if that was when it failed. You got this! Thank you for bringing us along.

[@jgg7377]

I agree! I would also get rid of any crossing branches so they don’t have any other areas to try and build on. My thoughts are they knew that the egg wasn’t viable and kicked it out of the nest. But why did they continue to sit after you picked it up and put it back in? Hummm. I also think I would not have built the new nest box out in the open. They used the first platform before so I’m sure they would use it again ( which is the perfect spot. Just remove all the other area’s so they have to!

[@victoriabaker4400]

@jgg7377 I don't think they should remove the new box, because they exhibited a clear preference to be out in the weather like they would in the wild. Giving them that choice is reasonable, because they chose not to lay an egg in the other box, at all.

[@JeanBrewer]

​@@victoriabaker4400 That's right! They have made a choice.

[@KAStodgell]

I love you called him word smith. Good job Jason and Brook. Shade cloth is a great idea

[@jotaybaybay]

Don't give up Brook, third time will be charm! And please don't keep it from us..we can handle it. ❤

[@tthomestead2763]

We had storms yesterday that dumped 3 inches of rain in just a few hours. It was a lot. But we were still happy because it hadn't rained here in 3 weeks.

[@pupcamper58]

Thanks for showing us the Victoria Crown Pigeon egg situation Brooke so sorry that things didn’t work out and you didn’t get a baby hatched. Maybe next time.❤

[@susanorr7535]

Brilliant idea!

[@heidiDonato]

Aw so sorry it didn’t hatch

[@janiceaucoin1435]

Poor Victorian Crown couple, they tried.

[@karenwest2670]

Thank you for sharing the egg and the story of the VCPs. I want to know when they lay again.

[@DonnaLightfoot]

Well, maybe next time , sorry, we won't be able to see them anymore, but whatever you think best, Brooke, I love the new box, much love from Ks ❤

[@juliettefields7202]

So sorry! 😢

[@martinevancamp3961]

So sorry for the litlle baby 😢💔

[@margesteinmetz863]

Sorry about the CVP egg. We'll see if MaryCarl can research on undeveloped egg. They will try again. Thanks for sharing. Blessings 🙏🫶🙏🫶

[@SonnyLee259]

Oh no ,Brooke ,just keep trying ❤❤

[@kthemi10]

That's such a shame😢. But as you said Brooke, "it's nature". Fingers crossed for next time 🤞🏼😗💖

[@KJABurch]

At least you know now that the capability is there now. So let’s go! 3rd times a charm. ❤

[@tfisher67]

Please continue to vlog the pigeons. We're all rooting for them and they are so fascinating. So sad that this egg didn't make it but we know things just happen, especially with wildlife. Birth is always a miracle. Thanks for all you guys do.

[@lyndaharwood2575]

You did everything you could.

[@djpmdelsig]

I can feel your disappointment! You are so amazing and nurturing! Big hearts break easily.

[@dyannejohnson6184]

I had that problem with my few regular chickens years ago….i had to feed extra calcium to harden shell…but I think your right-the egg falling out of nest may have been their choice too…you are so careful…I know what happened -happened