Why Putin Didn’t Invade Ukraine During Trump’s Presidency

Chris Hayes: “When Republican politicians say that Putin would not have invaded Ukraine under Trump, they are probably right. But for the wrong reasons.”
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/Su...
About: MSNBC is the premier destination for in-depth analysis of daily headlines, insightful political commentary and informed perspectives. Reaching more than 95 million households worldwide, MSNBC offers a full schedule of live news coverage, political opinions and award-winning documentary programming -- 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Re...
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersKZbin
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Li...
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Fo...
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/In...
#MSNBC #Putin #Trump

[@billwalsh388]

"We don't need to rely on American banks, we get all the funding we need out of Russia" Eric Trump

[@orthopara8192]

How was your day?

[@LD86]

“Putin is a genius and very savvy” - Trump talking about Putin’s move into Ukraine. At Mar-A-Loco the same day he spoke about Ukraine like it was prime real estate and “why wouldn’t Putin want it?”

[@magzmoney]

Yeah, the state of Kentucky didn't have a good day today.

[@cookingwithgaz7787]

Yet the only one getting paid from Russia or Ukraine was the Biden's through Hunter 🤔

[@MrStallion777]

putin invaded Ukraine in 2014 and 2022. Who was in the White House?

[@The_Honcho]

Because when you have someone openly talking about nuking your capitol, you generally walk on eggshells.

[@tmac20031]

All you did was read the title and answer with your delusional theory instead of actually watching the video with an open mind.

[@woodstocknation1961]

There wasn't any money in it. The minute biden snuck into office he started sending 1 billion dollars a month for zalensky. Biden and his colleagues have worked this sham to a perfection and a trillion dollar rip off of U.S. taxpayers. Trump told putin no. Meanwhile hunter biden is sneaking around Europe cutting deals for the BIG guy.

[@scottprice8994]

Trump is friendly with Putin. Trump would allow Russia to take over Ukraine.

[@1bIgFaTsOnOfAbItCh]

Wow! Not only is that false, but quite stupid.

[@billyrubin2001]

What were Trump and Putin’s closed door conversations about? Why were they private? Americans have the right to know what they were discussing!

[@ast-og-losta]

Of course. I would like to know what was on the documents that Trump ripped up and took to his home in Florida.

[@beesmart4048]

We also have the right to know what was written in over 30 thousand emails that Clinton destroyed. We also have the right to fully understand how the Steele Dossier was written by a RUSSIAN and used to get a FISA warrant using false information. The entire mess tore our country in two. This news channel continues to divide this nation.

[@thewolfdoctor761]

And why did trump make his interpreter rip up his/her notes ? My guess the meeting in Helsinki was treasonous.

[@robertm3699]

@@beesmart4048 we also have a right to know about Hunters dealings in China, Russia and Ukraine while the “Big Guy” was in office.

[@integral]

@@beesmart4048 When you hit that Hillary's email cliche all you'll get is laughs. People will recognize you as just one more Trumpanzee troll and scroll on. Poor gullible little thing.

[@malickfan7461]

This is like asking why the school bully waited for the teacher to leave the room before he started picking on the nerdy kid he dislikes.

[@malickfan7461]

@@nanananananananaaish Considering that the Trump administration gave and sold weapons to the Ukrainians, I’m willing to bet that Putin would have still have had a headache when invading. Ultimately, the biggest factor in Russia having a hard time was Putin’s own overconfidence. It’s like Trump himself said, Putin thought the invasion would be a 48 hour deal. Now he’s paying the price.

[@Simmy_NG]

Putin isn't a bully though is he? America is far worse and done carnage like no other country

[@Pizza793]

So trump is the teacher who would punish putin for bullying? And biden isn’t?

[@Hairysteed]

More like fellow bully rather than teacher

[@malickfan7461]

@@Hairysteed Ironic statement given that Trump was the first US president in over 30 years to not start a war.

[@tonyv1695]

Like Colonel Vindman says, "Why would Putin buy the cow if he could get the milk free from Trump?"

[@13bustah]

Vindman has become a traitor and a paid liar.

[@patriciagazey4693]

1000%

[@LD86]

Mango Mussolini ensured Putin's dirty work was being done.

[@patriciagazey4693]

@@13bustah nope

[@disposablehero43]

LMAO way to excuse Biden's failures LET'S GO BRANDON!

[@kittychancool888]

Trump said he believed putin over our own intelligence 😂

[@EMendonca-mp2mf]

The guy said he liked soldiers who weren’t captured.. how could any American still side with him?

[@LD86]

@@EMendonca-mp2mf None can call themselves American and stand with Trump, when he proved time and time again he stands with Putin.

[@EMendonca-mp2mf]

@bob trump That’s what all anti Americans say.. proud?

[@stultusvenator3233]

Translation, I am working for Russian & My interests not America's. (we got plenty of Money from Russia -Don Junior).

[@Colonel__Ingus69]

It's about 50/50 between those 2 options

[@josevalencia5576]

Because 45 gave him Almost everything within reach.

[@wkahn1005]

Never forget when Kim of Nth Korea threaten America under Trump sending his missiles to Hawaii ..Trump did not take Kim's threats he told him if he wants a nuclear War he has a Bigger Nuclear Button and he stopped.. Putin threatened Biden and he rolled over and played dead... History will not be kind to Biden he lost Crimea ,Ukraine to Putin and Afghanistan to the Taliban

[@monkeytime8653]

if he did than why didnt he invade under trump if trump was under putin

[@whenyoupulloutyourdickands4023]

Its funny how putin then decided to invade as soon as 45 left the office 🤔

[@harrytopia282]

@@whenyoupulloutyourdickands4023 trump was voted out 2020, pootin invaded Ukraine 2022, that is 2 years 2 months after traitor trump was voted out of office, trump presents in office did nothing for Ukraine, trump tried using Ukraine to dig up dirt on Biden and failed.

[@stormking57]

And he'll leave Ukraine to the wolves. No country is scared of Lord Donnie of Damnliar!

[@Maurice-mi3gr]

Next video: Why did the mugger wait until there were no police around before he tried to rob someone.

[@robertdouglas8314]

Because the mugger knew that revealing that the orange haired cop was corrupt would not help his future plans. Putin thought his puppet cop might still be useful in the future and he didn't want to reveal Trump's willingness to be an accessory to his war crimes. The first remarks out of Trump's mouth a year ago was to praise Putin as "genius" and "savvy" in his invasion of Ukraine: " Trump is a traitor to America.

[@lisarochwarg4707]

The fact that Trump would hire Manafort, all by itself, says nothing good about him.

[@ast-og-losta]

You should research Trump's history. Roy Cohn mentored Trump.

[@danajohnson4480]

“if elected I'll surround myself only with the best and most serious people” - adding: “We want top-of-the-line professionals.” goofy trump.

[@NecessariusBalance]

Exactly.

[@mysterywriter888]

And for free! Putin understands trump very well!

[@vercoda9997]

Manafort made a fortune in blood money promoting a huge range of dictators and tyrants, as he grasped very well that he could coin it in if he served such people, when nobody else would.

[@benedicta7490]

If you have a safe and comfortable life outside Ukraine then enjoy it and be gratefull because you never know when that ends . Salute Ukrainian soldiers for their bravery . The president of Ukraine is a real life hero RESPECT.

[@hanafuji3434]

Same as 70 years Israel invasion of Palestine, and a lot of war in the middle east which US interfere

[@zanabanci1943]

Hana Fuji Middle East has Been interfered from Russia as well Afghanistan and Syria and Putin brought asad. Both is a territory control. Why Putin don’t interfere with Israel when attacks Palestine how many Jewish Russians are livin in Russia

[@themajesticmagnificent386]

Keeping focus on Ukraine..God Bless and watch over the brave people of Ukraine..They are fighting off a discussing invasion from Putin and a fooled and confused Russian people..The fight for freedom is happening now and the Ukrainian people are at the frontline of this fight..Trump was in Putins pocket and weakened America by fooling and confusing the American people.. The rest of the world can see clearly what’s happening..The American people seem to just see conspiracy theories..We need a strong America..But America is too busy fighting each other over politics..Division in America and Brexit in the U.K causing division in Europe..All this division stopping people being United..So who does this fooling,confusion and division really benefit.?.Still think the West won the Cold War.?❤️🇬🇧❤️🇺🇦❤️🇺🇸❤️✌️&❤️

[@zanabanci1943]

The majestic magnificent I’m 100% with you. Well said. Some ppl here in Michigan don’t believe that is war in Ukraine they are calling fake news that much their brains are bleach washed. I don’t get it what more they need to believe the reality for everything.

[@themajesticmagnificent386]

@@zanabanci1943 It’s sad to hear that..Some seem to be fighting common sense and against conspiracy thinking..While in Ukraine they are fighting for real freedom… They say fake news..I say those that believe in conspiracies are suffering with fake views..It’s time now to again look up the word and meaning of democracy and freedom..Because democracy and freedom is being too taken for granted by us in the west right now..Words and their definitions are true and powerful..Those that exploit,want us to forget or wish to twist their meaning do so with truth.We need to be reminded by true meaning of words like democracy and freedom to really see and know their value..A value that’s being fought for right now in an invaded country..While others have the freedom in their democracy to call an invasion ‘fake news’… Thank you for you kind reply..Take care❤️🇺🇸❤️🇺🇦❤️🇬🇧❤️..✌️&❤️

[@jamesirwin8917]

Chris is making perfect sense. During a Jan. 2019 meeting Trump was having with Putin, Trump jerked the translator's notes away and kept them. So he obviously didn't want the content of his meeting with Putin to leak out. Trump returned from this Meeting telling us his usual general comment "It was a great meeting." Trump hid so much from us for four years!

[@LD86]

Mango Mussolini idol worships Putin, Jong Un, and another autocrats… because DICtators stick together.

[@ziadassaad1371]

Are you a serious person? Do you ever go back and read your comments after posting them? In general, how do your comments leave you feeling?

[@LK-bz9sk]

Donnie came back from Helsinki ……..with a soccer ball.

[@blacknosugarnocream]

@@ziadassaad1371 - Like all trump supporters... you are projecting.

[@jhanes3791]

@@ziadassaad1371 putin tool...

[@zach3305]

This is textbook gaslighting.

[@grantchampaign]

Even sadder is that 99% of these comments believe it

[@CurtisThomas-l9p]

Nyet

[@davidmartin6266]

Did putin learn "fake news" from trump or was it the other way around.

[@LD86]

It was actually the Nazis who started that. Lying press (German: Lügenpresse - “press of lies”, “fake” or “false news”) is a pejorative political term used largely by German extremists in the early - mid 20th century for the printed press and the mass media at large, as a propaganda tactic to discredit the publications, networks and individuals that offered a message counter to their right-wing agenda.

[@Mrbfgray]

Ironic on the most childishly transparent fake news sight on Earth--MSNBS.

[@gazpachopolice7211]

Observing right wing across different countries I've learnt that they constantly imitate each other. Although, this one is something I'll give Trump full credit for. He was using similar terms when he was a realtor jumping into the casino business

[@LD86]

@@Mrbfgray If you want fake news… I refer you to Faux Snooze & Friends.

[@Thenineoh]

They both learned that from Hitler

[@gazpachopolice7211]

That at of shoving another president just to be the centre of attention was the most childish act I've seen any world leader do. So cringe worthy!

[@gj1234567899999]

Putin was scared of Trump. Putin isn’t scared of Biden. Looks like Ukraine will be taken over on Biden’s watch.

[@rjwood6314]

@@gj1234567899999 putin was absolutely not afraid of trump guy. He was waiting for trump to try to leave nato so we would be weak

[@matthewcraig3837]

Ever heard of the LBJ squeeze?

[@theworldsbroken]

@@gj1234567899999 did you watch this video on mute? 🙄

[@whyputaname]

@@gj1234567899999 ... 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Yeeeeeeeeeah...

[@gordonlynn8300]

Imagine Trump saying they didn't pay their bills, sounds familiar Donny , you are the master of not paying your bills .

[@babblo1389]

Trump knows you need to negotiate with Russia,not ignore Russia. All Russia wants is DEMILITARISED Ukraine that never joins NATO.

[@ronaldo19832]

He always projects on others the things he does

[@jdnb86]

@@babblo1389 Russia doesn’t get to dictate what other countries do. Ever.

[@tmyers84]

Or trying to flush the bills down the toilet. Hahahaha!!!!

[@tobiisiba1641]

Bruh how much do you think Donald trump is owing?.

[@spicerlovejoy8186]

Let’s be honest here, waiting for trump to leave office in favor of a weaker president was the only intelligent decision that Putin made in regard to his botched invasion of Ukraine.

[@andrewblanchard2398]

PUTIN OWNS TRUMP

[@TheArsenalgunner28]

So Russia waited for a weaker president who won’t do anything about the Ukraine war?…that plan worked really well

[@GKB.official]

He hasn’t brought out the big weapons yet.

[@whatwhat3432523]

The Trump election and Brexit was the centerpiece of putins decade long creation. After seeing the turmoil the populists created in their home countries he attacked. In the US they nearly managed to succeed with a coup d etat. The US is still not stable, and will probably pop off again. And the UK is reliving the 70s, with a lot of people starting to wake up from the worst hangover ever.

[@GuilhermeS123]

MSNBC exists to cover up the huge corruption of Biden and his family with dirty Ukraine. 2014 was a coup and the Kiev dictatorship has been committing massacres of eastern Ukrainians and Russians for 8 years. Tens of thousands of people killed by these nut jobs neocons and its media arm MSNBC. Trump is the guy who can stop these thieves making billions on killing Ukrainians. The Russia. Lie tying to Trump fools only simple people who are gullible easily. It is sad evil be presented and revered by many.

[@kryzzan7039]

"When the speech condemns a free press, you are hearing the words of a tyrant." - Thomas Jefferson

[@ast-og-losta]

Trump once called for a federal investigation into “Saturday Night Live” after watching a rerun of an episode parodying him.

[@galaxy-star-me]

Open your eyes , We have media censorship don’t have freedom of speech for years under the leftists ideologies!

[@billkris07]

I see less of a free press these days and more of a biased one. So be careful in touting a quote that was noble but now our media is not.

[@nflegal49]

@@billkris07There are many media outlets. Find one you prefer. That's what free press is all about

[@epants8507]

Lmao free press? You’re joking right? This is propaganda 🤪

[@donaldgenenavarro]

like we have been saying for years, we had a soviet operative traitor in our white house

[@jazldazl9193]

The problem is it appears most Republicans have lost their souls and their balls

[@swieseldorf]

You’re insane

[@cookingwithgaz7787]

Yes called Joe Biden 🤣😂

[@bautistopacheco8439]

@@jazldazl9193 Kinda like how every bill passed Democrats take more and more of tax payers money for themselves lol

[@yakivpopavich]

Lets look at reality, contrary to your Trump Derangement Syndrome and false narratives about Trump and Putin/Russias relations. Lets look at the FACTS and STATS of when Trump was President and how US & Russia Relations were. Under Trump we ... - Trump administration Renegged on nuclear agreement with Russia and Putin in place since the cold war - Trump administration put hardest and heaviest sanctiouns on Russia, Ever. Even more than Obama ever did. - Trump arms Ukrainian backed seperatists in Kiev and Ukraine to indirectly and directly fight Russia - Trump expelled all 18-19 Russian Diplomats after the 2016 election Meanwhile Liberals and democrats and far left NPC's like yourself still cry " TRUMP AND PUTIN " years later, despite the facts and information showing exactly the opposite. Loser.

[@catwilliamson3887]

I wish the press would take this opportunity to show the similarities between Trump's talking points (e.g. "Fake news", controlling the press, misinformation) with Putin's and other authoritarian leaders.

[@mrjackson2067]

Can you actually name any misinformation from Trump?

[@robbrewster2998]

@@mrjackson2067 everything he says.......wait a week and he'll flip .......

[@mowthpeece1]

They're similar because they have the same source.

[@kbengson9163]

I wish the people of Russia would rise up and un-seat Putin from power. Right now there are much bigger issues than what the Trump, Obama, Bush, Clinton, Bush, and so on, administrations did or did not do.

[@CGKA2020]

@@mrjackson2067 Did you just wake up from a coma?

[@halfa5048]

I got an ad begging for donations to the Biden administration on this video. That pretty much destroys any credibility this channel may have had 😂

[@idkwhatsgoingon4584]

I don't know how many times I've gotten that ad despite reporting it and saying don't send me anything else about this puppet

[@PANCHOVILLAMATO]

@@idkwhatsgoingon4584 You JUST finished watching a video proving Trump was/is Putin's puppet and YOU try to spin it over to Biden... You've got a pair like a bull.

[@PANCHOVILLAMATO]

You JUST finished watching a video proving Trump was/is Putin's puppet and YOU try to spin it over to Biden...

[@aaroncabello8221]

That's more really controlled by KZbin, not the channel.

[@GuilhermeS123]

MSNBC exists to cover up the huge corruption of Biden and his family with dirty Ukraine. 2014 was a coup and the Kiev dictatorship has been committing massacres of eastern Ukrainians and Russians for 8 years. Tens of thousands of people killed by these nut jobs neocons and its media arm MSNBC. Trump is the guy who can stop these thieves making billions on killing Ukrainians. The Russia. Lie tying to Trump fools only simple people who are gullible easily. It is sad evil be presented and revered by many.

[@davebartosh5]

I love that clip of Manafort stumbling on his tongue. Classic! He's so full of sh*t he's choking on it.

[@djbenje4019]

His reply was a resounding "YES".

[@randyfuentes4201]

@@torresc2310 Americans need to understand Donald trump is a traitor. Trump was advised years ahead of the invasion and all trump did was withold aid to Ukraine. Donald trump has blood on his hands

[@randyfuentes4201]

@@djbenje4019 RepublicanT's are treasonous and continue to attack American Democracy and the Nation as a whole. We the People need to call for these treasonous Republicans to be held accountable . Fox News and Rupert Murdoch are Donald trump co-conspirator. Follow the money. Reason why Joe Rogan and Dave Portnoy are spreading misinformation is because Fox pays the UFC and NFL.

[@williamdevlin5233]

@@torresc2310 As a CT resident lifelong, I had heard of the Manaforts and their corruption long before Trump's candidacy. As a matter of fact, when I learned that Paul Manafort was with Trump it sealed my suspicion that the whole Trump campaign was corrupt. The Manafort patriarch was mayor of New Britain while heading the family construction and demolition company and overlording the destruction of great swaths of that city using federal funds. Hmmmmm.......

[@williamdevlin5233]

@@torresc2310 Also, I guess you have less than zero understanding of how NATO is paid for. It's not like the UN.

[@Peace17292]

If Trump's behavior described here is not treason, then I am not sure what is.

[@sheliadantonio7088]

It is.

[@spaceforce0]

We used to turn these people into chickens. They’ve divided us so that we don’t do that anymore

[@uio890138]

Believing what you see here is insanity.

[@ajl22586]

@@uio890138 You sound just like the Russian's do right now "war what war just a peacekeeping operation"

[@tinaandro1178]

@@ajl22586 Or that a Jewish President is a Nazi

[@joeberta368]

That,s easy - trump most likely made a deal with Putin at the Helsinki “private” meeting.

[@CellarDoorCS]

Bingo!

[@luiscraze169]

Exactly 💯

[@chillingguy8386]

My God the Russia gate propaganda you msnbc viewers fell for over the years lol

[@dugsoif]

That's probably why Trump tore up interpreter notes at Hellsinki. Then he put it in his pocket. Remember that?

[@LD86]

Mango Mussolini has undoubtedly taken out stocks in chapstick and kneepads for his service of Papa Putin.

[@elijahsabo3846]

Yes, with Trump in power there was peace Ukraine. Thank you for understanding that Chris 😊

[@GuilhermeS123]

MSNBC exists to cover up the huge corruption of Biden and his family with dirty Ukraine. 2014 was a coup and the Kiev dictatorship has been committing massacres of eastern Ukrainians and Russians for 8 years. Tens of thousands of people killed by these nut jobs neocons and its media arm MSNBC. Trump is the guy who can stop these thieves making billions on killing Ukrainians. The Russia. Lie tying to Trump fools only simple people who are gullible easily. It is sad evil be presented and revered by many.

[@Not_a_lier]

@elijahsabo3846 Yeah, peace, but just 10k people died in the Donbass front during the trump administration. But as they say, a minor mistake.

[@malickfan7461]

@@Not_a_lier That Donbas conflict kicked off during the Obama admin. Putin didn’t dare to escalate it to a full scale invasion until Trump was out of office.

[@heartattackhomer609]

@@Not_a_lierDonbass war started in the Obama admin. Not Trump’s.

[@billyrubin2001]

“You scratch my back, Vlad and I’ll scratch yours.” - Traitor Trump

[@bidensbrain2383]

4 years of Trump- peace 1 year of BRANDON- WW3

[@TheEndingAbyss]

@@bidensbrain2383 since when are we in world war 3?

[@tomgeorge9025]

@@bidensbrain2383 We are cursed since 2015 because of Trump,,,7 bad years straight…

[@Asoka-great]

Just watch Trumps body language in Helsinki..

[@BILLEON2005]

You are a goofy Nerd…

[@Mystique_Raven]

I totally said this at start of war! We should also treat Trump as a freaking traitor!

[@shawnwilliam4653]

He needs to be behind bars soon or I w8sh the CIA could take him out...it can be made to look like a heart attack

[@markfreeland1027]

It seems pretty clear to my reading, that he and about 117 members of congress ALL qualify as Traitors against The Constitution of The United States!

[@cliffperkin63]

hee r m ing is Traitorous butt butt fool ,he WILL BE SEEN TOO I GUARANTEE.!!🌺🌻🥇🏵️🌾🌼😄💐🌹🥀🌷🌸💮🏆🪙

[@Mystique_Raven]

@@shawnwilliam4653 yes! He is a traitor of the country and should be paid a visit

[@shawnwilliam4653]

@@markfreeland1027 very true... The 117 and 2 Senators.. Plus it would be very interesting to find out the right wing donors who were donating to the convoy up in Ottawa...... Because they were Americans there who were clearly sovereign citizens which has been classified as a terrorist group by the FBI.... And the DHS so these right wing donors to the politicians are also in a way committing treason if they're supporting domestic terrorism... Not to mention Rand Paul.....I think I heard him call for a trucker type things shut down our cities here... GOP The scary part is is the whole trump thing and the whole Russia simple thing is is what the right one to do is bring us into a Putin style system... Right now it's democracy versus dictatorships and the republicans have clearly chosen dictators dictatorship because they cannot win an election fair and square..... That's why because of the gerrymandering you can have 65% of the state vote Democrat but still it's still the majority of the majority of house members coming from that state will be Republican....

[@pohanahawaii]

🙏 Let's be thankful for that because Trump would have sided with Putin against NATO, withold aids to Ukraine, and feel all smug and entitled about it. Oh wait a minute, he DID do all that! 😂

[@lylemorgan6107]

Ukraine is really the enemy you’ve been brainwashed congrats

[@Diamerald]

@@lylemorgan6107 😂😂😂

[@cinnabun715]

@@lylemorgan6107 bot

[@gatti7740]

Trump was the best thing that happened to this country for many years. Prices were down and business was up.

[@michaelschwartz8730]

@@lylemorgan6107 Yep, that's exactly the level of logical counter-argument we've come to expect from people who think an incontinent former game show host is Jesus 2.0 😆

[@suehowie152]

THIS needs to be replayed often!

[@cynthiaciotti2888]

Absolutely

[@blast2763]

It needs to be taken down as misinformation.

[@zach3305]

Sue Howie sounds like a fascist

[@suehowie152]

@@zach3305 Duh..

[@DS-lk3tx]

It's funny how you bots treat the word "THHHISSS." Bunch of sub-humans.

[@jeffeastwood1051]

Pretty telling how over time you can replay Trumps talking points and straight line them right to Russian Propaganda.

[@kkaybaltimore]

Trump should face the highest punishment 🙄

[@judiemeierfranz4329]

Putins Useful Fool

[@lottasunshine1325]

@@kkaybaltimore I hope so, but I won't hold my breath.

[@LD86]

The way both Putin and Trump attack the free press, vilify opposition and call for their imprisonment, election fraud and tampering to rig elections so they win, perpetrating disinformation, hate/fear/power/war mongering campaigns.... it's straight out of the fascism handbook.

[@stephendavidbailey2743]

@Johnny Mill Biden has unified the whole world against Russia. So incompetent.

[@jjmarz1001]

'We get all the money we need from Russia.' Eric Trump

[@pxrays547]

@Brass Dolphin Midnight Foot Feed Trump continued many of the policies toward Russia that had begun under his predecessor, President Barack Obama, particularly after Russia annexed the Crimea region of Ukraine in 2014.

[@yakivpopavich]

Lets look at reality, contrary to your Trump Derangement Syndrome and false narratives about Trump and Putin/Russias relations. Lets look at the FACTS and STATS of when Trump was President and how US & Russia Relations were. Under Trump we ... - Trump administration Renegged on nuclear agreement with Russia and Putin in place since the cold war - Trump administration put hardest and heaviest sanctiouns on Russia, Ever. Even more than Obama ever did. - Trump arms Ukrainian backed seperatists in Kiev and Ukraine to indirectly and directly fight Russia - Trump expelled all 18-19 Russian Diplomats after the 2016 election Meanwhile Liberals and democrats and far left NPC's like yourself still cry " TRUMP AND PUTIN " years later, despite the facts and information showing exactly the opposite. Loser.

[@serenesrn3827]

Yes by taxing them and not buying oil from them .

[@LD86]

@@yakivpopavich Putin not invading Ukraine during Trump is the same reason we don’t key our own cars. (Credit to another poster in this comment section)

[@jevo7747]

@Brass Dolphin Midnight Foot Feed there are easy to find easy to read minutes of what actually goes on in the halls of congress or a memory if you had one of those would be nice

[@justsayen2024]

The same reason China reportedly asked Russia not to invade until after the Olympics?

[@lmarvel4431]

😌

[@benjiebenjamin7810]

Yep!

[@elitespuppet1669]

Nwo

[@Titan-dg7uw]

Yea never ask them questions do they. They must dream about trump papa trump i just cannot stop thinking about you morning wood again lol

[@augustlion6645]

I would say that is obvious.

[@justsayin...2784]

Yes, as noted elsewhere in the comments, this piece from many months ago needs to be replayed often. Lots of people STILL don't get it.

[@danielsurman4669]

you got that right .. all of this is starting to make sense now

[@patriciaburke9308]

Bc they do NOT WANT TO GET IT! It is so evident even the densest of persons gets this! Where is this kind of anger coming from? Prolonged income equality? Lobbyists buying out best interests of this country through onslaught of dark money are just 2 of the many reasons among a myriad that are fact and history based. May God help us all for allowing this death of America!

[@blast2763]

It's laced with lies dummy. Go do actual research.

[@pokerone6489]

If you get your information from cable news or social media, you don't get it. Like, at all. The opposite, in fact.

[@zach3305]

Thats called fascism

[@seanpatrick1243]

The guy who never has paid his bills complaining about NATO nations not paying their bills. At least he is consistent in his projection.

[@tonyt8805]

I feel over when he stated that! 🙄😲🙄

[@goodone5590]

He prepaid his tax and pays his bills you clown.

[@seanpatrick1243]

Yeah, that was a Good ONE! Oh wait, you're serious. I'm sorry for you.

[@seanpatrick1243]

Torres You can copy and paste your comment an infinite number of times from your fake troll bot account, and it does seem that you will do so . . . But it doesn't make it any more true.

[@irockyourmama123]

😂 They should pay their part regardless.

[@PsiliPharm2012]

And you forgot to mention the fact that when Trump pulled the US out of Syria, Russia moved in the very next day, but “…we got the oil!” claimed Trump.

[@MKR5210]

And shafted the Kurds who the US used to fight ISIS by proxy. When considered surplus to requirements the Kurds were right royally shafted!!!!

[@mentak2593]

@@MKR5210 just like Bush Sr shafted the Shiites .

[@BoB10]

and when he moved the usa out of north iraq the turks and the russians moved in and what happened the kurds

[@PeterAcrat]

​@@mbusombuso9119 🤔IMO; I don't believe the US is _all_ about Narcissism regardless of who "they" are. Many people there actually have a heart that truly feels for others. Trump and poo💩tin couldn't care less.... they'll never _say_ that, but their actions speak volumes of their sense of unaccountability, lack of empathy and entitlement. They are unfit to lead humanity.

[@MamaKat27]

@@mbusombuso9119 Trump showed what HE is all about and THATS why we hate him. He didn’t speak for or represent the people.

[@kimberlysantos4085]

Thank you Chris Hayes for aligning this treacherous behavior , Slava Ukraine!!

[@tinaandro1178]

@@torresc2310 copy paste bot?or brainwashed or something?

[@susanmattinglyhatfield9036]

@@torresc2310 vTrump wanted to leave NATO. Stop defending the traitor. Trump did everything Putin wanted him to do and if Trump would've gotten a 2nd term, we'd be the United States of Russia minus Alaska.

[@leeadickes7235]

@Tina Andro it's the truth.

[@lintoppthomas]

@@susanmattinglyhatfield9036 you are a leftist Brandon voter this was expected from you..

[@irockyourmama123]

@@susanmattinglyhatfield9036 There’s video of Trump stating he wants to stay but the Europeans have got to do their part, smh. “We are in bad deals” - Trump. Facts are facts. Disclaimer: Not a Trump supporter.

[@philipwilkins3812]

Imagine what the USA could be if the people were to stop arguing about how great or bad their party or representatives have become and unite over the fact that both of the ruling parties they support have become corrupt. Instead of focusing on the disagreements merge that frustration and unit to create a new party that can manage both interests and conduct government more inline of how our forefathers set up!

[@cherylsmith4826]

If only...

[@philipwilkins3812]

People should by all means do exactly that but they won’t. Not every politician is corrupt but you can bet more than 50% are.

[@KimberlyBishh]

Stop bothing

[@philipwilkins3812]

@@KimberlyBishh Both deserve it

[@natashanonnattive4818]

A REPUBLIC NO MORE 2 PARTIES

[@rezadaneshi]

He started planning counting on Trumps second term

[@LD86]

@Brass Dolphin Midnight Foot Feed Trump is currently under investigation for election fraud. 🤣

[@Cryosxify]

Ukraine is guaranteed what they discussed in secret.

[@stephendavidbailey2743]

Brass and Johnny only see surface tension. Their criteria for women consists of how big their boobs are.

[@jeffwalsh6015]

Putin figured that a President that wears Depends like Biden cannot be that tough.

[@randominternetuser2888]

@Johnny Mill Russia attacked Ukraine boats in 2018 & 19. Tump did nothing while complaining that nato are the bad guys. You are advertising propaganda You're a liar and a troll

[@evanpenn1]

That Montenegro leader should have hauled off and knocked Trump out when Trump grabbed him and shoved him. That would have been one of the all-time great moments in history. But the guy missed his chance.

[@tonyv1695]

Howard Cossell: DOWN goes Trump! DOWN goes Trump!

[@jakel8627]

It would be internationally condemned, like Putin's invasion.

[@LD86]

I would have paid to see that! 🤣💪

[@marshwetland3808]

@@LD86 Or at least goose him really hard from behind a pen or something.

[@yakivpopavich]

Lets look at reality, contrary to your Trump Derangement Syndrome and false narratives about Trump and Putin/Russias relations. Lets look at the FACTS and STATS of when Trump was President and how US & Russia Relations were. Under Trump we ... - Trump administration Renegged on nuclear agreement with Russia and Putin in place since the cold war - Trump administration put hardest and heaviest sanctiouns on Russia, Ever. Even more than Obama ever did. - Trump arms Ukrainian backed seperatists in Kiev and Ukraine to indirectly and directly fight Russia - Trump expelled all 18-19 Russian Diplomats after the 2016 election Meanwhile Liberals and democrats and far left NPC's like yourself still cry " TRUMP AND PUTIN " years later, despite the facts and information showing exactly the opposite. Loser.

[@RWald8888]

Putin didn't invade Ukraine during 45 because he wasn't expecting 45 to lose re-election. He would have done it during his 2nd term in office. I'm almost positive that's what they discussed in their " secret meeting " in Helsinki. That's why I want 1/6 committee ( on a side note) to interview interpreters in the secret meeting with 45 and Putin.

[@stormmedicaa]

you are delusional dude go take you're meds

[@andrewsomebody844]

@@stormmedicaa gaslighting troll

[@balls433]

Almost positive huh? Doesn’t count

[@vietnamd0820]

Putin wouldn’t have even wanted to invade Ukraine if Trump won or stole the 2020 election…Putin has compromising video on Trump with prostitutes, and Trump wants to build a Trump Tower in Russia…so for both reasons, Trump would do everything he could to keep Ukraine out of NATO

[@sheiladavidson7475]

I said the same thing before I read your comment.He just knew Trump was going to win.Scary

[@remon2541]

I remember that mr Putin and mr Trump had a private meeting a couple of years ago, and no information at all came out of this, I wonder why, even more than at that time.

[@whyYoutubeSpyingOnYou]

Most likely President Trump threatened Putin that his days would be numbered if he invaded Ukraine. Go read how Russia tried to bypass Ukraine sending oil and natural gas through under sea pipelines. President Trump told Russia to make sure Ukraine gets the royalty and Russia promised to pay up to $10B a year even though pipe lines were not on Ukraine territory. President Trump sent Javelin anti tank missiles to Ukraine to deter Putin from invading Ukraine when Obama sent blankets and Biden sent helmets until months after the war began he started to send CASH (why cash? so he can get his 10%?) and some weapons to keep the war going and more people dying. Notice how Biden does not even mention a peace treaty when it is clear that many more people will die in Ukraine? More money for the Big Guy!!!

[@jar407]

did you forget Obama telling Russia in whisper that open mic picked up he can do more when reelected. so what did Obama do behind closed doors with Russia. we know sec of state Clinton sold the rights to Canada and USA uranium

[@bert7216]

Wonder no more,It's because Putin helped Trump win the election so Putin has Trump in his pocket,And If you find that hard to believe then maybe you should move to Russia and trust Putin like Russian people do

[@GuilhermeS123]

MSNBC exists to cover up the huge corruption of Biden and his family with dirty Ukraine. 2014 was a coup and the Kiev dictatorship has been committing massacres of eastern Ukrainians and Russians for 8 years. Tens of thousands of people killed by these nut jobs neocons and its media arm MSNBC. Trump is the guy who can stop these thieves making billions on killing Ukrainians. The Russia. Lie tying to Trump fools only simple people who are gullible easily. It is sad evil be presented and revered by many.

[@garymathews4042]

too many people were calling trump a Putin puppet from day 1

[@jeremybackup5758]

And Trump went out of his way to prove this fact again, and again, and again, and again, and again, and again.......

[@aliciachristopher6506]

And they arre right.

[@idahocorrupt2082]

I have the another version WHY the war did not happen Under Mr. Trump Administration and why it happen under Mr. Biden administration. Yugoslavia was bombed By NATO in 1999, and 150,000 Civilians were killed by NATO in Europe, . Mr. Trump wife is from Yugoslavia and she did not want any wars in Europe. On other hand: - 2014: President Obama/ Vice Mr. Biden: the coup in Ukraine, to get a part of Private land in Donbass (oil company Burisma?) and cleaning the Donbass territories from Russian speaking Ukrainians (in DNR, LNR) killing 15,000 Civilians. - 2016-2020: President Mr. Trump- no war in Ukraine - 2022- war in Ukraine - the first major event of Mr. Biden Presidency..... or maybe WW3!!! Ukraine is just the collateral meat for the U.S. This is NOT a "Russian aggression" in 2022, but this is the continuation of Russian defense since 2014 from NATO. . ...... The U.S. is fighting against Russia on Ukranian Territory by Ukranian hands since 2014.

[@pattydonohue5452]

@@idahocorrupt2082 wait, are you on Putin's payroll too? Sounds like it.

[@Mark-kq6ch]

@@jeremybackup5758 In your mind.

[@danrion8839]

Joke of the century 'Trump was tough on Putin' by taking Putin side in Helsinki, by calling him genius and savvy for invading Ukraine for two dollar sanctions.

[@brandonfriesen5389]

Trump helped Arm Ukraine a couple years before the 2020 election, the articles are all out there, he saw the writing on the wall

[@tonyv1695]

How could anyone understand what Trump was saying with Putin's caulk in his mouth all the time?

[@jeremybackup5758]

@Brass Dolphin Midnight Foot Feed Right, Trump was clearly Putin's puppet. To your point, had Trump been successful with his insurrection or coup attempt, he'd have betrayed our allies and sided with Putin.

[@jeremybackup5758]

@Brass Dolphin Midnight Foot Feed Right, Democrats have always stood against it, while Republicans have defended it. I'll never understand why Republicans always side with Dictators over Democracies.

[@AnitaWetwunDrag]

@Brass Dolphin Midnight Foot Feed "... calls for peaceful protest..." Ok I have to ask... what videos are you people watching that makes you all believe this was a peaceful protest?! I've heard this multiple times, yet so many clips of violence come to mind that they have almost pushed any even remotely peaceful ones out of my memory... I'm honestly curious, because my dad has even claimed this and I still don't understand how...

[@deniseandrews113]

If Impeached² had not been defeated, Ukraine would have been handed over to Putin as a thank you gift, no invasion necessary..

[@Dev_1945]

You’re mentally ill if you think that’s true. Obama/Biden watched Russia take crimea with no repercussion, and now as Russia is about to take Ukraine.. we only recently have sanctions.. and are still buying Russian oil.

[@mikemaryniuk571]

Or Putin would have got a pipeline through Ukraine. I've Said from beginning that 5 Russian gas lines go through Ukraine. No deal then he will steal Ukraine before the west and democrats get in there. Gas and oil is all Russia has and one pipeline though Ukraine and Belarus would have them pumping it cheaper and quicker then anyone.

[@gailflanagan1214]

@@Dev_1945 Go back to FOX Fantasy Show. Why are you here? Did you watch this news video?

[@uio890138]

Doesn't hold water man, Putin got nothing but sanctions from Trump. Biden lifts all sanctions as soon as he took office in 2021 and Putin immediately started making preparations to take Ukraine (it takes a year to get everything in place to invade a country on this scale).

[@loubryant1648]

Impeached? Those two impeachments were laughed out of the hearings. The dumborats had doctored evidence for the last hearing , the Demonrats were humiliated . Puton waited until the week man Biden was in office and then he made his move. Has Biden stopped buying oil of Russia yet or is he still funding Putins war

[@glenndarling738]

I'm glad someone put these two incidents together finally!

[@aaronchieu1435]

Educational!

[@alexhp1282]

Congratulations, now people are dying

[@WiredCountDuckula]

Time machine go back get trump as baby

[@kellishafron5920]

Thank you for reporting this! So many people don't know this and everyone, especially Trump supporters, need to understand this.

[@jeremybackup5758]

Trump supporters want the US President to be a dictator, telling us how to think, what to do, what to say, etc.

[@goldilocks3593]

And yet either the denial and/or the lack of awareness is astounding

[@veganpotterthevegan]

Trump supporters won't believe any of this. They'll just blame Biden for escalating it because they're idiots.

[@deamonomic]

Trump supporters won't listen. They have chosen WILFUL IGNORANCE... just like Putin has.

[@LD86]

Republicans don’t want to govern and legislate, because they want to rule and dictate. Reich-wingers don’t want America to be a constitutional republic anymore, because they want it to be theirs.

[@penny2093]

Well, this is what happens when people underestimate the evil in certain individuals and put them in office. There are consequences!

[@denisemand4391]

I would think that the majority of all people just want to live in peace. But, sadly, the world is controlled by the evil.

[@the_empath_etc]

@@denisemand4391 You do know the quote, don't you? "SOME PEOPLE JUST WANT TO WATCH THE WORLD BURN"... "while eating popcorn".

[@Rnankn]

Trump is a really messed up TV man, with charisma and deep insecurities. Total speculation, but Russian intelligence could have scrubbed his mind and turned him into a puppet, a Manchurian candidate. Of course, without proof, the internet is the only place it can be mentioned. And since no proof would exist, it could never be investigated. This must be how conspiracy theorists feel…very disorienting…

[@davidwilliamson9333]

YOU MEAN LIKE JOE BIDEN 😏 YOU NOTICE PUTIN DIDN'T INVADE WHEN TRUMP WAS PRESIDENT

[@denisemand4391]

@@davidwilliamson9333 Did you even watch the video?

[@yvonnetomenga5726]

Trump repeatedly said said the G-7 should invite Russia back in after it had been kicked out of the G-8 for its annexation of Crimea.

[@JR-playlists]

Ukrainian Lives Matter GQP & pootin's lies don't

[@JR-playlists]

If you want to know, watch Beau of the Fifth Column on you tube

[@imrael496]

It's called diplomacy the opposite of war.

[@Human_Earthling]

@i'm the king You are beyond deluded.

[@merlekallis2618]

@i'm the king totally 💯 but the other side can’t deal with it!

[@cfox8514]

Solid reporting. Keep it up.

[@thcollect3544]

Putin would never hurt his princess Trump. 🤣

[@LD86]

More like Trump would never want to insult his idol Putin.

[@wkahn1005]

Never forget when Kim of Nth Korea threaten America under Trump sending his missiles to Hawaii ..Trump did not take Kim's threats he told him if he wants a nuclear War he has a Bigger Nuclear Button and he stopped.. Putin threatened Biden and he rolled over and played dead... History will not be kind to Biden he lost Crimea ,Ukraine to Putin and Afghanistan to the Taliban

[@jeremybackup5758]

@Jamestib kirk Is that why you are attracted to her, you think she's a man?

[@jasonallen3678]

Yep,Trumps is Putin's bae..

[@jeremybackup5758]

@Jamestib kirk I hate to break your heart Jimmy, but she's not a man. You will have to look elsewhere my friend. No judgement, love who you want to love, it doesn't matter to others.

[@jjamnason2066]

Trump saying the other countries don't pay their bills! Look who is talking about not paying his bills! That is hilarious!!

[@deniseandrews113]

Everything he accuses others of doing...is exactly what he's doing. The king of projection..

[@dglorious1269]

Hahaha! 😄 I witnessed all of his casinos and hotels in Atlantic City getting shut down for FAILURE TO PAY! 🙄

[@xeebtxob6641]

Everything Trump says of others is mirroring of himself (projections).

[@haparcheledupwar]

AHAHAHAHAHAH nobody is watching to your propaganda NEWS, hahahhaha Trump? really? hahahahahahahahaha Bittter people

[@Grant80]

@@deniseandrews113 umm everything Democrat accuses trump of there doing themselves

[@dianebannister4591]

This was an excellent presentation by Chris Hayes. He explained so well the series of Putin maneuvers. And I hadn't more fully understood Manafort's situation until Chris explained it all.

[@renataloren2384]

I agree excellent presentation!!

[@AlexLee360]

My god are you that deluded? This is straight up propaganda.

[@karenneill9109]

@@AlexLee360 Have you ever noticed that propaganda machines allow for people to disagree on their platform?

[@wiljanhopeable]

@AlexLee360 how is it propaganda when it's all true? Oh, never mind... you're just repeating stuff from Fox news

[@AlexLee360]

@@karenneill9109 I’m not saying msnbc as a channel is propaganda, I’m saying that this particular segment is.

[@midiknightccgs6758]

I miss having someone without dementia in office

[@marcelwiszowaty1751]

So what was Trump's excuse... sheer stupidity?

[@aidanbiton4105]

trump and putin have a lot in common. im sure trump would love to control the us like putin does in russia

[@JsGarage]

Biden is sure taking care of us! Lmao 🤣

[@rinaperez4124]

Then how? Look what happened to the 2020 Nov. election, was Trump able to control this? It is the Democrats who wants to control America, Democrats are untouchable.

[@Redridge07]

@@rinaperez4124 Build that wall

[@Chatterbox-94]

That’s always been Trumps goal.

[@jeanmarcu1446]

areyou a mind reader?

[@torycook1215]

Bingo. You nailed it. Well said, Chris.

[@delefo]

Everyone always asks what Putin has on Trump. Here you go.

[@robertm3699]

Everyone always asks what China has on Biden.

[@mrjackson2067]

Conjecture? Big story there.

[@Dennyh025]

@@robertm3699 I didn't see Biden in the title of the video.

[@kathyweis7451]

@@robertm3699 rubles fell below a penny, good luck getting paid troll

[@DrHughMonguscoque]

@@robertm3699 do tell... please tell us or link some info. We'll wait.

[@willie9537]

Spot on! Thanks for everything you said, Cheers 🍻

[@saintpeterspeters1053]

Obama/Biden were in power when Crimea and Donbas were seized by Russia, what did they do? NOTHING! Why blame Trump who rather sent Arms to Ukraine when he came into power!

[@noitalfed]

Nice job of putting the facts together.

[@tinaandro1178]

@@fluffy_kitten They are facts: I read what most of pro Trump people were saying and was curious so looked at Fact-check - they are mostly false and what appears in this video cannot really be debunked

[@tinaandro1178]

@@fluffy_kitten ummm you do know that there are sites like Politifact that makes it easier right?

[@AD-bb9np]

Fact is NATO keeps invading and has scared Russia and China into WW3.

[@steve-o_8840]

@Pp Pppp slow day at the Q page? Russian disinformation is killing the very few brain cells you have left!

[@BLaCkKsHeEp]

"facts"

[@twulff7060]

I have asked the question so many times when is the level of treason so high, that actions are being taken and we no longer look away?

[@johnrace5979]

Look at joe biden and you will find your traitor. He is selling us out to the ccp. Wake up you fool.

[@steveparker2704]

I also ask myself this question, It seems so easy to see even a child co recognize

[@teru797]

@@steveparker2704 why do you actually believe this? You really think the media is not biased? Why were US politicians not tried with treason when they supplied weapons to islamic terrorists in Syria?

[@steveparker2704]

@@teru797 Sadly you are right it is hard to get unbiased news unless you look for it. Yes the US politicians are becoming almost as corrupt as any in the World. That being said we must do our best to keep them accountable

[@melaniecotterell8263]

Treason? You mean Joe Biden? Taking money from all of our enemies, Ruining the United States in every possible way. Destroying the country.

[@michaelschwartz8730]

Why? Because 45 was such a strong and intelligent leade---😆😂🤣 Sorry, I couldn't keep a straight face for that entire sentence

[@SassyShay7]

The chosen one. Chosen by Putin. 😂😂

[@bartjargengarblbargeler1980]

Really? I didn't even grin.

[@LD86]

Aisle 45 needs a major clean up of toxic and hazardous waste! 🤣🤣🤣

[@michaelschwartz8730]

@@bartjargengarblbargeler1980 Hard to laugh when the joke's on you 🤷‍♂️

[@jeffwalsh6015]

Dementia 46 is off to Delaware again. What a strong and intelli...... LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@davidbaise5137]

I believe the folks who need to hear this step by step explanation will never hear it, will never accept it. Very good segment, tho.

[@HalfCrazy520]

I fear you are 100% correct. It would be dismissed as a witch hunt and hoax.

[@frankwood7878]

YEP,.... THE MAGATS NEED TO HEAR THIS DETAILED & SOLID ANALYSIS

[@zach3305]

I believe the people who accept this. Will never hear anything else. Very good gaslighting though.

[@HalfCrazy520]

@@zach3305 Please point out the actual facts here, since you claim the piece is gaslighting.

[@Mark-kq6ch]

I'm open to it but it has more holes than Swiss cheese. It is an improvement over the pee tape theory though, I will give him that.

[@deimondrawsproductions]

Putin was pretty much Trumps sugar dad, if Putin said sit, Trump would sit. If Putin said jump, Trump would Jump. He got money from Putin

[@Rick-of6gx]

I love paying more for everything now!🙃🙃🙃

[@hedgehogshadow982]

OPEN YOUR EYES YALL. FIGHT WAR NOT WARS

[@LD86]

@@Rick-of6gx inflation is because of the pandemic. Not Biden.

[@geegaw1535]

@@Rick-of6gx it may have been different if he'd been impeached either time

[@thewolfdoctor761]

@@LD86 Yep, oil/gas prices started rising in 2020 under trump.

[@aaronz.]

Sadly, this story is becoming more clear everyday.

[@babblo1389]

So sad to see ordinary Ukrainians suffer. In Kherson Russian army took over as locals did not have weapons. And no violence at all. At other towns where Ukrainians are armed, killing starts . Thanks 😭😭😰

[@kelperdude]

Biden thinks he's a leader. That's sad.

[@dandansen571]

Come midterms; a vote for ANY republican is a vote for a Putin puppet - and seriously, The 2016-2020 Puppet in Chief was more than enough misery, don't ya think?

[@uio890138]

Putin got the Crimea, most valuable part of Ukraine, while Obama was president, how does that figure into your insane lib logic? All indications are that Putin was given the green light to move on the rest of Ukraine "when" Hillary won in 2016, but that plan was monkey wrenched. There was good reason so much money from Russian oligarchs had been 'donated' to the Clinton Foundation is 2015 and 2016.

[@rumpvirus7393]

...and pulling out of Syria and handing it to Putin. GQP had a small moment of WTF on that move then back to worshiping theIr golden hair plug cow. I guess its like waking up and you are driving Off the road through a corn field so you go back to sleep to make sure you don't hit a fence post or a tractor.

[@nick66rc2x]

Trump was and will always be remembered as Daddy Putin's little toy!

[@jokerss9786]

I literally looked up “what the media doesn’t tell you about other countries” thinking I was going to see some futuristic hidden city in the middle of nowhere.

[@sparkyfister]

If you didn't, you stopped your search too soon.

[@jokerss9786]

@@sparkyfister no I’ve found those videos too

[@michaeleasler5249]

An excellent summation of the rather damning facts. The Trump-Russia connection is most certainly there! This explains quite a lot to anyone willing to look at this objectively.

[@AD-bb9np]

Look into the history of NATO's eastward expansion. This was always part of the plan for both NATO and Russia. Neither side will ever stop trying to control Eastern Europe.

[@shedactivist]

@@AD-bb9np NATO does not seek to control other countries. It allows them complete autonomy and offers a defensive shield. To equate that with Russian expansionism where control is everything is just wrong and misguided.

[@wahyuindrasto]

*Because of this back and forth between NATO and Russia over Eastern Europe the US will forget its pledge to pivot to Asia or Indo-Pacific, much to China's (Russia's ally) delight.*

[@Dang3rMouSe]

Lol, cause Trump surely conspired with Russia during which he undermined their largest form of GDP by sanctions so hard it stopped the building of Nordstream 2 (which Biden completely lifted) while countering the same by selling US oil & gas to Europe to lessen their need on Russian oil & gas (which Biden also ended.) He also publicly stated to NATO & particularly Germany to increase their defense spending to be ready to counter Russia. He even told Merkle live on camera that if she allows Nordstream 2 Germany would become compromised by Russia which we have now seen. Still he must have ties to Russia even though he fired Manaford when he found out he was a slimeball & after 2 yrs of investigations charges were dropped when it was found that the debunked Russian tie was due to an automated Trump hotel mass email. This has now led to 3 seperate ppl, 2 of which are within the Clinton & Biden campaign who colluded w/ a known Russian agent to falsify evidence & are now facing federal criminal charges for falsifying evidence & lying to a federal agent w/ more ppl soon to be charged from both campaigns. It's easy to be told things w/ zero evidence or watch clips out of context & think it's true when you have confirmation bias & you don't due your due diligence of looking into it yourselves. This is the danger of today's news media on both sides of the political aisle. Don't be an NPC.

[@AD-bb9np]

@@shedactivist, I don't understand what you mean. Both want military control over eastern Europe. Obviously each has a different culture and government.

[@Pokarot]

"Why didn't Putin invade Ukraine during Trump's presidency?" Same reason I don't key my own car?

[@LD86]

lol accurate! 🤣💯

[@regionalhealthcareassociat4847]

Putin was busy planning to hack into US government computer systems. Putin's dream is to restore former communist block by force, with genocide.

[@MM-pk4xw]

I already know why but its sad some people can't see how far back this man set us just to try and get himself out of trouble he knew was coming his way.

[@7thpilot]

WASHINGTON - The Trump administration took one of its most aggressive actions against Russia on Friday, announcing sweeping sanctions against members of Russian President Vladimir Putin's inner circle, along with top officials and several businesses. Biden approved North stream 2 after Trump shut it down wake up FOOL

[@DarqJestor]

@@7thpilot Trump opposed the sanctions but both houses of Congress overwhelmingly passed them and Trumputin didn't want to risk an override if he vetoed them.

[@7thpilot]

@@DarqJestor Nice try you lie without guilt CNN is looking for your kind, dont worry your pedophile charges wont hinder your employment at CNN

[@davidsalo8397]

@7thpilot Get back to work. Putin wants you to finish digging his bunker ASAP!

[@7thpilot]

@@davidsalo8397 I dont have to Biden has sent him billions from the oil he purchased. Biden and the Democrats have Ukraine blood on their hands, guess that includes you. Traitor!!!!!!!

[@some_guy441]

We all know Trump would have smashed Russia back to the stone age....

[@CurtisThomas-l9p]

Like Roy Cohn smashed Trump's sphincter 😅

[@armandob.castenelli3525]

And now all of the sudden the GQP don't know who Putin is?😂🤣😂🤣😂

[@annerigby4400]

I think it would have been interesting and relevant to include Russia's interference in the Brexit referendum. As a result of Brexit, Boris Johnson is the Prime Minister of the UK and he is stalling on freezing Russian assets in the UK. The City of London is the major source of financing for Putin via his oligarchs. Johnson has said he would take necessary steps in eighteen months which is the same as saying he is going to do nothing. The fact that they are Russian oligarchs is sufficient reason to freeze their assets. So, this is relevant to the topic of what is discussed in this video because it is part of the same strategy and it is still working.

[@cliffperkin63]

Yes I'm aware of Bor is Borat Russian connection ,the finance for BREXIT splash campaign an lies of all Rich's that would flow (hint they didn't) how easy to just step outside all long term agreements would be(took 2 years cost Teresa May her job )So yea I would definitely like to see tangible overt action by Boris(sorry that's usually Russian name) Johnson which is very English ,maybe it's meant to have a foot in both camps.🌻🏵️🌾🌼🪙🏆💮🌸🌷🥀🌹💐😄

[@pdoylemi]

There is also recent reporting that these oligarchs have made massive donations to the Tory party in recent years.

[@annerigby4400]

​@@pdoylemi No surprise there, right?

[@annerigby4400]

@@cliffperkin63 Boris puts his feet wherever there is a chance at power and plenty of money.

[@pdoylemi]

@@annerigby4400 Sadly, not really any surprise there.

[@brenthood2337]

I'm hearing Roger Stone's name a lot today.

[@Mdebacle]

A younger Roger Stone showed up in the documentary 'Where's my Roy Cohn ?'

[@mikeg9341]

That explains everything! Birds of the same feathers, Flocks together. Tell me who your close friends are, and i will tell you who you are!

[@stephenyurica9834]

Excellent analysis. Bravo. We connected the dots for the rest to see what they haven´t seen until now.

[@kellythomas5596]

Hello Stephen how are you doing today.

[@allan5996]

i like how he lined everything iv seen up over the years, in just under 9min.

[@Rilianawakened321]

It was well presented, very clearly and succinctly by Chris . . . this should be mandatory viewing.

[@coreyham3753]

Yes, Chris did a great overview of tying everything together.

[@tonyt8805]

🎯 💯 🎯

[@heyaisdabomb]

@@torresc2310 You can't deny Trumps connections to Russia. From Mannaford to repeating claiming Montenegro would start WW3 because they joined NATO, Trump play every card Putin wanted, and Putin is the reason Trump won.

[@kingbud4966]

@@heyaisdabomb then why didn't putin invade when Trump was in office? Wouldnt it have been easier while his puppet is in office seeing as the biggest threat to Russia during this whole thing is America?

[@hansvandijk1487]

Excellent reporting, Chris. Greetings from the Netherlands 🇳🇱.

[@JohnBowl14690]

Chris is the best. Good to know that with Biden in office, Putin and Ukraine are going to be at peace forever. There is no war. It's fake news. Biden is the best.

[@noslack68671]

This spot needs to be made a part of all US history classes in schools!!!

[@zach3305]

Thats called fascism. Congratulations on the (not so) bright idea.

[@noslack68671]

@@zach3305 Given you write this off in one word, demonstrates that you are obviously a simpleton! Trump loves people like you.

[@zach3305]

@@noslack68671 Yes, fascism is a word. And its what you described in original post.

[@jessicajaramillo911]

Fresh of trump to say we were getting ripped off, that’s coming from a guy who doesn’t pay taxes 🤦‍♀️

[@rootpt]

Unbelievable lolol, how can someone still believes that puppet, Unbelievable

[@ec3499]

You clearly don’t understand real estate lol

[@kellythomas5596]

Hello Jessica how are you doing today.

[@kenkripto3515]

The reason most if not ALL Billionaires don't pay Taxes, is because of Laws that were implemented BY DEMOCRATS!!!!!! Amazon Founder - Jeff Bezos has NEVER paid Taxes who has been the Richest Man alive for the past Decade until this year when Elon Musk became Richest Man alive - who BTW , also doesn't have to pay Taxes.

[@sueburn150]

Jessica j proof he don't pay taxes put up or shut up

[@LD-jv9vq]

Did I just hear Chris Hayes say "Without him in the White House, Putin took matters into his own hands invading Ukraine"?!

[@brmbkl]

yes, yes you did. that's how politics work when you're a dictator. you have to make moves to stay in power.

[@valoredramack9117]

You didn't pay attention to the full explanation. Chris Hayes said that Putin wouldn't have invaded Ukraine in the first place if Donald Trump didn't become Putin's ally; if Trump didn't legitimize Putin on the world stage while delegitimizing Ukraine, and if trump didn't weaken Ukraine by scaling back military support for Ukraine during his administration. Trump positioned Putin to be able to invade Ukraine in the event that Putin couldn't control Ukraine by using his puppet in the White House. In other words, Donald Trump has benefited Putin no matter what the outcome is.

[@blqest125]

@@valoredramack9117 ,lol you're the one that didnt pay attention. along with chris hayes. you and chris hayes absurd logic make no sense whatsoever. putin's been president and the leader of russia since the late 90s. well before trump became president so this whole trump "legitimized putin in the world stage" and wouldnt have invaded urkaine if trump didnt become putin's ally is just an utterly dishonest, and incorrect analysis of the situation and basic history. putin was already legitimized in the world stage after he took over from yeltsin. if anybody weakened ukraine and put putin in position to invade, its obama. who was defeated by putin by proxy in syria when assad won, in iran when the green revolution failed, in turkey where the failed erdogan coup failed and when obama refused to sell urkaine offensive/defensive weapons which would have prevented the first ukrainian invasion attempt and the takeover of crimea which is now being used as a staging military point. this all happened under obama. putin saw weakness in obama (didnt do nothing when assad crossed his red line, got caught on hot mic promising flexibility to putin after his re election, failed proxy wars vs putin all over middle east, capture and humiliation of american navy by iranian navy the list is endless) and now with an even weaker president not just mentally but physically in joe biden whose afraid to even take questions from handpicked media and who should be hospice care instead of in the white house. your regurgitated msnc, cnn talking points cannot rewrite history. putin did this under obama and biden but not trump who was sandwiched between two democrat presidents. you need to try that dubious geopolitical read again.

[@jaggerjards7236]

@@blqest125 Russian troll at work

[@mikegrzincic6235]

@@blqest125 nice tell them! and you're not a troll

[@EM2theBee]

Thank you! This logically connects the dots. Incredible.

[@brettkenschaft4239]

Agreed 💯. Unfortunately a lot/most/all Trump supporters have blinders on and are impervious to logic 🥴

[@a55tech]

except it's the opposite of what a lot of other sources say. based on MSNBC's general bias, you can safely discard this depiction as BS. Other vids say the US rigged Yuschenko's elections. We don't know but without disrupting your life to dig into it, it's usually safe to take the opposing view as MSNBC.

[@kittyday1402]

@@a55tech And keep sending your money to the trumpers! They need it for LAWYERS & new accounting firms.

[@jowen001]

@@a55tech you'll disregard MSNBC but believe who? Fox? Trump? I can't wait to hear it. Maybe it's RT. This should be good. Lemme get some popcorn, dude.

[@a55tech]

@@jowen001 keep swallowing msnbc. don't worry about irrelevant questions. just know that u believe whatever msnbc says. that's a you problem.

[@Zenoithegreek]

Why is he sounding so sanctimonious when America is intervening everywhere in the world?

[@nycatlady2314]

This explanation and complete timeline was masterfully done. Eight min and 51 seconds that I wish the whole country could be made to watch. Even the trumpublicans might understand it. Well done

[@shirolee]

Exactly!

[@alexanderlipowsky6055]

30 secs is all you get from these peeps and thats extensive

[@sds5502]

Nah...to much credit you give them

[@lesliecurran1704]

One more resource, I just read article written 3/2/22 which goes back even further, to the 80s, with chronological events between Russia and the trump organization, undeniable, and after reading, not only did it shake me to the core but everything makes sense, falls into place. The information in this video and in that article need to be blasted everywhere, the title is "Donald Trump Was Everything Vladimir Putin Could Have Wished For". Google it, I fear that the short attention span of most Americans will not get them to even read this and with a population who do not understand what is below the tip of the iceberg, we are in serious trouble.

[@deborahemielita5949]

@@lesliecurran1704 thanks.

[@julesl7679]

They don't pay their bills? Lmao like trump should say they don't pay their bills...he's the king of not paying his bills. Lmao

[@epants8507]

Biden paid a bill of 1 billion dollars to Ukraine if they fired the prosecutor that was investigating his son.

[@sounddeej3157]

@@epants8507 defo real bro

[@julesl7679]

@@epants8507 omg ur a real nut case.

[@billyrubin2001]

In other words, Trump would have gifted Ukraine to Putin had he been elected a second term.

[@ast-og-losta]

There more to it than that. Putin would have invaded in Trump's second term. Russia needs Ukraine's natural resources particularly in Crimea.

[@geraldjosserand4476]

Did Trump tell you that? Or you thinking that? It's nice you put words in trumps mouth. There was no Wars, when Trump was in office. How about Biden? Don't kid yourself, Trump has false to. But so do all of us! And how would you handle the situation, if you were president?

[@jasonruff1270]

putin was probably expecting trump to win in 2020 but go frustrated and invaded ukraine anyway

[@missourimanful]

@@geraldjosserand4476 - Well said. I totally agree with you.

[@annamallen90]

It is almost like you think MSNBC is hardcore right and that you are hardcoere right about your theories here despite the reality that this DID happened under your beloved Joe Biden. You don't get to take the blame off of Joe Biden and put it on now regular American citizen Donald Trump. Last time I checked no one has the power to predict multiple alternate realities or read minds. This is pure madness. I just have to have hope that people like you are in the minority and that the majority knows how disgusting the democratic party has become with these lies, cover-ups and total chaos. This is ridiculous.

[@larzybernard9617]

Trump is one of the worst things that ever happened to America.

[@trinidadscorpion3835]

And trump aspires to be just like Putin.

[@yououtuber4176]

yawn

[@JoaoSoares-rs6ec]

Yes he does, he may still do it

[@ampamp999]

Thanks to Biden, there is so much piece in Ukraine!!

[@chrishughes9399]

Trump aspires to be like Putin, but like Putin and Kim that played Trump, it showed the world Trump is to stupid to do it!

[@trinidadscorpion3835]

@@ampamp999 Please educate yourself. Stay away from fox Russian propaganda. You sound like a trump cult member.

[@garybarrett4881]

Make it illegal for anyone with any Russian funding links to run for any government office.

[@deborahemielita5949]

Excellent point.

[@matthewhumphrey496]

More than half of the politicians would be fired.

[@garybarrett4881]

@@matthewhumphrey496 And then people wonder why there is so much division and hatred going on in western democracies. Putin funded the most divisive politicians to be found in western countries to weaken them and it has been very successful. The UK brexit politicians were/are massively funded with russian money. And Trump in the USA is same.

[@NJ-dy4zl]

@Matthew Humphrey And? Clean house then.

[@Mark-kq6ch]

That would make Biden ineligible...................

[@jerrymarski5922]

Get the transcript of the "closed door debacle" unredacted and unaltered, the answer will lie therein.

[@Seriouslydave]

Biden would have looked at that day 1, and interviewed the translator. and biden probably knows what will be happening to trump either way, if hes an agent, the current admin will know it, the timeline of events will already be written to avoid riots and world war if putin is involved, we may not even find out about most of it.

[@reynardfoxx6753]

Putin insisted on a Russian interpreter only. No American interpreters were allowed in that room. No notes taken.

[@Seriouslydave]

@@reynardfoxx6753 oh your right, he had an american translator in helsinki but didnt have a translator in osaka, at an UNPLANNED meeting.

[@Mark-kq6ch]

Oh yeah? Is that gonna be the thing that finally gets Trump? haha...

[@cherylsmith4826]

Thank you for clearing that up for me- I often wondered about those moves

[@saintpeterspeters1053]

MSNBC are part of the Anti-Trump Media! For once ask yourself, were NATO members contributing and serious about their own security? It is now evident that the greater share of Military aid to Ukraine is from US! NATO members has NOTHING and this was what Trump adamant on!

[@velder22]

Trump talking about somebody else not paying their bills is Rich LOL

[@Stuart68505]

Good point. I believe however that Trump was covering up his real motivation: Putin’s orders to get the US out of NATO. Trump has made a career of not paying his bills to contractors or to cities and utilizing our legal system to intimidate those who want to be paid. He has developed a way of entertaining crowds while undermining our democracy behind the scenes and creating incredible strife in our country.

[@meganfedor]

@@Stuart68505 It's all projection with Trump. He's the world's worst poker player.

[@mervyngreene6687]

I am amazed (and a little impressed) at how Republican leaders can keep a straight face. The only exception that I can think of is McConnell. Someone reminded him of the reason he gave for refusing to confirm Garland. He actually chuckled.

[@MargauxStewart]

Jonathon: The "Mussolini of Mar a Lago" (MML) really believes that he is going to win a Prize for being "The Biggest Most Disgusting 'HYPOCRITE' to have ever walked the face of this, fed up with him, EARTH ! I.e: (MML). Screams and fumes about immigrants using OUR U.S. LAW of "Chain Migration" to bring their Relatives to US ! But, then he, without explanation, brings Malaria's parents into U.S. WITH "Chain Migration" ! Here is the BEST part of (MML's) stomach gagging HYPOCRISY; who is an ill-legal immigrant herself and has a father, who was the Head oF the COMMUNIST Party in their Home Country of Slovenia ! Do WE have to wonder how KILLER, Putin so enjoyed that connection ! 🙏🇺🇸🇺🇦😜‼️

[@worldview730]

By now we should all know his brain is empty therefore the mouth follows

[@secondone6833]

This was so informative thank you for TRUE journalism

[@someguy2135]

Chilling! Manafort was able to get Yanukovich elected, and then tRump. Putin wanted both of them to be elected. Coincidence?

[@Chicago48]

"Manchurian Candidate"

[@jeanmarcu1446]

Can you please describe how did the Trump presidency benefit Putin's regime?

[@FM-kl3iu]

@@jeanmarcu1446 do you really not get it?

[@jeanmarcu1446]

@@FM-kl3iu I want you to describe how did the Trump presidency benefit Putin's regime.

[@pattydonohue5452]

@@FM-kl3iu they either dont get it, cant understand the language, or is a TROLL paid to spew division and discord.

[@sitalaird3986]

Why don't you ask Putin Why instead of asking why?

[@robertsimpson7113]

It's too bad that the politicians didn't listen to George S. Patton in 1945. He wanted to march all the way to Moscow after the defeat of Germany. Would have saved a lot of suffering within the USSR.

[@CharliMorganMusic]

Yeah, you're not wrong.

[@robertnussberger6449]

In 1945 America's were pretty war wary . We lost a couple thousand Americans many more injured. Enough was enough. He did the right thing . We bet Russia over the years by being better. It's just everytime we let a weak president in office Russia gets strong again. People that don't fight in wars and don't send their families are the ones that usually say that

[@user-r8or-pko3dfg]

"It matters not what form of government Russia has. It's North Star --- world domination --- is a fixed one." Karl Marx. I first saw this quote in the mid-1980s, around the time Gorby came to power.

[@davehartx]

@@user-r8or-pko3dfg "world domination" .. and of course not what the US wants 😂

[@robertnussberger6449]

@@Paonporteur Trump was the best president this country had in over 35 years . Biden is a weak old man . No strength

[@cindywong9668]

Very Well Said. Great Insight. Too bad that many in this country don't see it.

[@jeffg1524]

The reason why is tens of millions are still mesmerized by Fox and conservative media's disinformation and lies. They've been indoctrinated by years of propaganda that's painted MSNBC and CNN as "lib"-centric and untrustworthy shills for corporate interests without actually absorbing the facts presenters like Chris Hayes and Rachel Maddow give and coming to the logical conclusions the rest of us do.

[@moonpie2637]

@@jeffg1524 45% of democrats watch foxnews not cnn and msnbc.

[@sarahf4.258]

@@moonpie2637 we watch it ironically, Einstein

[@MsRoge25]

Biden and his family make money from every arms deal with Ukraine. You can not understand why he has no interest in peace.

[@moonpie2637]

@@sarahf4.258No it started after Russia gate. The lies coming from the left caused their own supporters to stop believing what they say. 90% loss for cnn in just a yr. I wonder why.

[@joeb134]

What's scary is he has been doing this here at home simply using propaganda on social media.

[@karenneill9109]

Is it not factual? Does it ignore major facts or context that make it meaningless? Is it government mandated?

[@plukowski]

Let's not forget a pandemic, was happening the last few years and when it waned Putin invaded.

[@therock8288]

And Putin was watching the Olympics in China on TV all week.

[@Sonicman415]

This is SO obvious to me, having lived through it in real time. Glad you’re spelling it out for those who don’t quite understand the trajectory of the previous administration’s ‘dealings’.

[@user-fn5xg7qt7u]

Low IQ

[@scottpultz5353]

Hahahahahahaha your brainwashed . Our country was so much better off with trump in office . We now look weak which is the reason no one respects us now . I’m not a trump supporter , but I can be honest and tell you our country was in a lot better place with him in office . Now excuse me while I go fill up my truck with an entire paycheck so I can get to work.

[@arturvirgilioalvesdosreis6796]

I bet you wear 3 masks

[@B7NZ]

FOLLOW THE MONEY Russia main pipe line went though Ukraine, so Putin couldn't invade. Bidun & DEMs shut down USA energy started buying from Russia & Iran, approved & helped Putin put in new pipe line, so he didn't need Ukraine pipe making him about a billion a day & now gas went up so we can pay Russia even more that we still pay. Now who is making Russia money WAKE UP enjoy 5 bucks a gal DEMs it gos to Putin

[@Melbourne-s4x]

@@user-fn5xg7qt7u correct, yes you are.

[@jimrich4192]

And the hidden rich elite just get richer & even more POWERFUL...what a show!

[@billyrubin2001]

Connect all the dots and this assessment makes absolute sense.

[@msoperator510]

Yes, just posted, Chris' summarization of timelines & events is spot on.

[@lgroots8691]

Lmao ur so ignorant....Trump was a strong leader that's why. Biden is weak obviously. Msnbc is so ridiculous

[@jackpayton5065]

@@lgroots8691 Trump was just Putin Trojan horse, that's why, bowing to Putin like a little P*****y.

[@jackpayton5065]

@@torresc2310 You and I know Trump is an American traitor.

[@annamallen90]

Doesn't make it true though. Not unless you are all some sort of gods or whatever.

[@Алекс-о2р7ъ]

The Russian Establishment still hope to see Donald Trump back in the Oval Office but I think their hopes are in vain in view of the court proceedings he faces.

[@malickfan7461]

That didn’t age well….