MTG Best Deck Boxes 32 - Imperium, BCW Deck Vault LX, DS Nest 300+, GameGenic Squire and Sidekick

[@PoetRonin]

As a retailer your reviews are essential to understand in which brand of supplies I should invest. In order to best serve my customers it's vital to have some kind 9f advance look at the pros and cons of these kinds of products because of the HUGE variety of them available. Thanks for all your hard work.

[@Bekayvd]

Never in my life would I have thought seeing a grown man review deckboxes could be so soothing and entertaining

[@idlowii7670]

I watch like 2 hours of him revieweing deck boxes every night to sleep well. Its really therapeutic.

[@Keirebu1]

Hugely cathartic to see you put the cards back in the box... **prof starts shaking box vigorously again,** **anxiety escalates**

[@dasnack]

Gamegenic is certainly doing amazing boxes, can we get a review of their sleeves?

[@BuckShotTherapy]

They have sleeves too 😲 why have I never heard of them or at least seen them when I've searched deck boxes on Google or Amazon? I think i would have bought some by now if I knew

[@MrDaxrowden]

@@BuckShotTherapy They are just releasing there products now. wait till you see there prime binders!

[@Wulfsmasher]

I just took a gander at their website, that keyforge deck book alone makes me want to start playing keyforge

[@kst8er]

I just looked them up, 6.99 for a 100, I am gonna give it a shot

[@turnermurray7407]

Jon Kirk You won’t be disappointed. Best budget sleeves I’ve used in a long time. They’re almost impossible to split with the rip test, they have a good shuffle feel, and they double sleeve pretty well 👌🏻

[@InsertCleverNameHere0]

I feel like Dragon Shield is really overthinking the design of their nest deck boxes

[@rayanthonylao4648]

I was about to comment that, but i'll just second yours. I mean the Ultimate Guard Arkhive just works way better.

[@NickNames-x1m]

Great to see him remind everyone to show their local game store love in this time of hardship. Keep up the great work prof I always enjoy your vids and the product reviews are always so helpful for me and the community as well.

[@capt.cheesecake6875]

RIP to all the poor non-flying creatures in his decks that die during him casting Earthquake on every box :(

[@schrottinator]

15:33 It's very easy professor: Reading the magnets explains the magnets. This is a lesson I learned from you.

[@harker-san6903]

15:57 That “oh snap!” Really got to me. 😂

[@ShadowTaiga]

If I ran a game store I'd put profs grades on all my products.

[@COOPALOOPTROOPA]

ONLY BUY B AND UP

[@galiojusticejustice3191]

@championchap Well ideally he'd only carry the B grade and up, so that wouldn't be a concern

[@ShadowTaiga]

@@galiojusticejustice3191 exactly

[@Tannhauser42]

When I was in my LGS a couple weeks ago, I noticed they suddenly had a shelf full of Gamegenic products. I didn't ask them why, but I strongly suspect the good grades from the Professor were a motivating force. And, yes, I bought one from my LGS.

[@Scopesightzx]

My lgs owner says that anything prof raves about he has to buy, and it always sells well

[@jonnysoccer20]

I found these deck box videos 4 years ago. They are the root reason that I still play the game today. And this game has helped me cope through some very difficult things in my personal life. Thank you, Prof. Glad I'm still here :)

[@pinballwitch5256]

You've really sold me on the BCW Deck Vault. As someone who makes my own custom tokens as a big part of expressing myself with my decks, I often lament how few can go in a deck box, especially with my double sleeved commander decks. I will be looking into those, so thanks!. Also I love how big you smile when you find a product that really does exactly what you want. It's so nice to see you be happy.

[@andesmountain9178]

When I saw gamegenic boxes with an entirely removable magnetic top I went “whoa”. It was VERY cool. As I saw it snap on the bottom, I loved it. I also noticed that you put a lot more care in the presentation of the box material and let it speak for itself. If you wanted a purely objective review, I’ll say you telegraphed that you saved the best for last, or that you liked those boxes the most. However as you continued to review the product, I had to agree that this was certainly the best product reviewed. I love the washed out colors and that they ARE mix and matchable. The box made me think of 2 cons however: the top could be easily lost. I know losing things is a given and infrequent, but that never has been a criterion for your reviews. At least with the tray cases, losing a tray allows the shell to be used as an oversized container that could be separated via toploaders or dividers. But with this product, you lose the bottom, you’re sh!t outta luck. I would have considered that a con on the otherwise beautiful product. Additionally, I love the shake test. But what about a drop test? Some of those boxes of dropped on a corner, I presume could pop open and out scatter your cards. And if you’re on the move, that could prove disastrous. It would be nice to see a drop test, or even forcefully throwing the box on the ground to see if it can be busted open. After a number of drops, does the case start to degrade? Just wondering. At the end of the day, fantastic video, quality presentation, I enjoyed it immensely and will hope to see more. It’d be great if you react or reply to my message if you read and cared about it, would make my week no doubt. This video makes me wish I bought gamegenic in lieu of DEXprotection.

[@phoenix0282]

I have one of these and i can assure you these magnet are no joke. Its not easy to open them. I have no doubt they would stay in place if you drop them . Also if you take 2 seconds to put the top attach to the bottom after you open it you cant lost it !

[@ADHDnD13]

Me: So nice to see him putting the cards away *18:31* Me: HE'S STUCK IN AN INFINITE LOOP!

[@Yao-fz6ie]

15:52 OH SNAP

[@stormd]

The super-obvious musical cue when it's the product Prof really likes.

[@ericaenglish2157]

Prof: "Magnets are like magic. No one knows how they work." Me (a middle school science teacher) "Ummm..." Great vid, Prof! I am definitely picking up some of those Gamegenic boxes.

[@vincentmccue7481]

The Dragon Shield one probably has a vacuum in it while empty which makes it difficult to open, but when you fill that space with cards, it doesn't have that catch.

[@bluesight_]

You shaking these boxes so hard is my absolute favorite thing about these videos thank u for giving it your all

[@Vabryn]

When the music at 12:08 kicks in I know I'm about to see a banger of a deck box.

[@hamonscorner8347]

Me: *only use small plastic containers for all my cards* Also me: *still watching this video eventhough i knew that i couldn't afford any of them*

[@markdunlap9960]

i really like ultra pros thin plastic deck boxes

[@skelten454]

Cardboard and Duct tape works great! (Or just Duct tape) Just make sure there are no sticky parts left uncovered. And you can customize it to patterns and designs you want.

[@Renegadetothe64th]

Oof. Save up 10 dollars and buy yourself a nice boulder.

[@keegs5632]

@@Renegadetothe64th Exactly, if you can afford to play magic, you can put that 10 bucks that was gonna buy cards towards a box to protect them. I never understood this logic.

[@aztraeuz5560]

I watch them as well, but the Boulder is the best AND they fit in my case really well.

[@anahata8870]

I love it when he does this box shaking until stuff flys off, there is so much effort in it ! Thumbs up its great !

[@Rafikichu]

With this plus the Dungeon in the last video, Gamegenic is my new favorite. I really appreciate your videos, prof. I watched about 15 of these box and case videos until I eventually found exactly what I wanted. Had fun the whole way.

[@ignaciopinedaetcheber7388]

Thanks a lot for your reviews! I followed ur advice and recently bought some Dragon Shield Art Matte Sleeves and GameGenic Squires and i can not be more satisfied! For many years i didn´t put too much attention/care on the quality of the sleeves/boxes i was using (ultra pro), and i have to say that the difference is huge!

[@stephenwittman5679]

After one of his last reviews I got ahold of my LGS owner and asked him to order me some of the gamegenics and I love them plus he said they have became a big hit for both his gamers and sports guys in his shop

[@dustinsollars2355]

I'm still using the stanley tool box that he recommended.

[@nosrin1988]

I can't find the specific one he showed in the video. All the ones I've seen on amazon don't match. :(

[@Polmax2312]

Nos Rin stayer company makes china copies of stanley’s boxes. For storing cards it’s same sturdiness and quality, but cheaper and more available (stanley variant is out of production, so it seems).

[@WTFA54]

*sees deck box review* *Haven't touched paper cards since January* *Instant speed click*

[@isaacfife]

Check out spelltable.com to play paper with your friends online! I'm not affiliated with it in any way, but it's what my playgroup is using

[@DRAGHNALL]

Hey Prof, thanks for always making great content that is such an enjoyable experience. The last 15 or so seconds put a huge smile on my face cause it felt so relatable and felt the happiness. Thanks you

[@marcelozapata93]

These reviews continue to get better produced as time has gone on. Congrats to you prof!

[@tylerashcroft847]

I really enjoy these review videos. I also really appreciate your willingness to put your decks in the boxes and do the shake test. I wince everytime the cards pop out and go flying everywhere - thanks for taking one for the team!

[@Vok250]

"No you can't buy one with my logo on it. I don't do that OK?" Oh how the tables have tapped!

[@jamesbuchen6256]

Your previous review of Gamegenic made me a convert, I was super impressed with the stronghold box, gotta buy me another one.

[@mikeym5483]

Thank you for everything you do Professor. I was wondering if I should get the Gamegenic sidekick and I knew I could find your review. You’re truly the player bases greatest advocate. Magic is so much greater for having you apart of it.

[@ricecakes7822]

prof, your shake tests are pure comedy and brighten up my day :) thanks!!

[@docmatt1]

After you showed off the Stanley parts box case, I haven't bought another regular deck box. Being able to hold almost all my decks safely in one place with enough dice and tokens for the whole table in an easy to transport case makes a world of difference. Thanks again for your reviews professor!

[@Kgfao]

14:59 That "hm-hm-hmm" might be the best thing I've heard all day.

[@Kwickstryke]

I got my BCW deck vault 200 today in purple. Couldn’t be more pleased with it!! I put my two favorite decks in there and the tray was able to hold all the tokens. I was even able to throw a few small dice and counters on top of the tokens. Thanks for the review prof!

[@leehunt6031]

Thanks for the suggestions. I have bought multiple boxes from your suggestions in the past and have not been disappointed once!

[@Sir_Francis]

Is it just me or does anyone else want a video of just the Prof scanning the camera over his bookshelf & giving his brief thoughts on his books??

[@GamingBear_Q_E_D]

Thanks Prof, I agree about the Gamegenic boxes, I got some in to test just before you did your last review .. Incredible quality, talking to the team that Makes them, they are all Magic Players and made the boxes they wanted to use .. then began selling them .. A great way of doing it .. So players supporting players!

[@gamingaddicted8535]

wow, i am impressed how far we got over the years in regards of quality. back then, when i got introduced to magic, you were this rich kid if you had normal size colorless thin sleeves and a plastic deck box^^

[@thatepicwizardguy]

If I ever came back to MTG after all these years I’d 100% use your videos as a guideline of what I should buy for accessories and what cards I should consider for commander decks and such.

[@TraumaTrae]

The primary store I go to doesn't carry the Squire boxes, but I was able to find a relatively new lgs near my house and just about cleaned them out, but I am beyond thrilled! I had 3 Ultra Pro satin towers and 3 Monoliths and the 6 Squires I have now take up so much less space! I am incredibly impressed and glad I watched this video. Definitely an A+ from me on the quality of these boxes.

[@keepthebeatfresh8165]

Thank you for sacrificing your decks to provide insight into quality of deck boxes! I always look forward to your reviews!

[@harker-san6903]

He always looks so intense when he shakes a box. 😂

[@SilverNoMakeVideos]

the dedication is real

[@QMTG]

100% agree with your cons for the Gamegenic boxes! I've completely switched over to Gamegenic deckboxes; using 5 Sidekicks in the Dungeon 1100 and 2 200+ Strongholds for bringing out

[@LTJ]

Thanks for the vid Prof! Astonishingly (as I love your review vids more than anything else you do), my favourite part was at the end when you were collecting the cards up and sorting them. It felt remarkably calming, intimate and personal. I found myself thinking that I could just watch a vid of you doing that and musing on MTG and life...I appreciate that clearly COVID is affecting me in odd ways...but I loved it 😁

[@dmcdante8845]

Love your videos on how you keep doing these deck box tests and card sleeve tests. I know it's been so long since I've commented on your videos. Hope you're doing well and hope to purchase some of these. Love your research and passion you put in to card games. Thank you.

[@TimelordPete]

how did you know? i saw the gamegenic in my LGS recently, and searched your channel for a review earlier this morning. this is exactly what i needed. and i'm glad they rate highly on your list, Prof.

[@foghorn51rater]

Incredible video as always. Both that BCW tower and that last product are definitely going to be on my shopping list as my commander deck collection grows.

[@torondin]

I feel like the Gamegenic went above and beyond, and for what they managed to do with the sideloader, I kinda feel like they deserve an A+ tbh.

[@rustybryant1363]

I think the only reason it didn't get a+ was the price if it was under 15$ it probably would get an a+

[@CarronBarboza]

“You can put in your standard or modern deck there” OK but what about my pauper deck? 🧐

[@Korg42]

For Pauper you need a custom made diamond encrusted deck box to hold your 75 triple sleeved pauper playable perfection.

[@JonnDuune]

@@Korg42 Quadsleeved. You need them in hard plastic cases too. Peasant.

[@sidneyyoungiv3712]

Pauper? A game for paupers.

[@Korg42]

@@JonnDuune what's the third sleeve then? Inner, outer, hard plastic.

[@emiliepelletier9850]

Use a rubber band on unsleeved card, like any PROPER pauper decks. Noob...

[@Zero_Chaos]

My LGS picked up some of the Game Genic boxes after your first video from them. So far we love the boxes!

[@TheAzulon]

I only play Arena, so deck boxes are not a problem, yet I love watching your reviews. They are on point, you ask questions players really care and point problems that make a difference. Keep them coming.

[@nade7451]

I've been looking forward for a review on the BCW deck boxes for a while. Awesome work Prof!

[@immersion726]

Yes! Deck box time ^-^

[@sammckay1307]

Every frame from 16:10 to 16:14 is a treasure. You can press period while paused to advance a frame and press comma to regress a frame.

[@InsaneGir99]

I'm a student in industrial design and these videos are always super fun through the ID lense, you are literally doing all the rnd for me haha thanks for the great analysis

[@leonardotassodossantos7077]

Professor, I'm not much of a person who comments everywhere, but this time you made me do it. The last words you've said in this video are truly amazing, LGS need our support more than ever. Thanks for spreading the word.

[@FeetjeMagneetje]

I use a telecopic brush holder (meant for paint brushes) to hold my playmat. It's amazing. fits perfectly, doesn't roll of the table, protects it well and is dirt cheap. Just a tip for people who want to carry their playmat safely.

[@brick5533]

I already have all the deck boxes that I need and I'm not sure why I still watch these videos, but I love your work professor

[@tamriilin]

I was in my LGS not that long ago and saw that the Gamegenic boxes had your logo and "A" grade on them. Immediately bought several. Love them. I agree, they are the future.

[@Pfromm007]

When I see the professor's smiling face on the thumbnail I know we're in for a good time!

[@Anthony-qy9vc]

Hey Prof, just stopping by to say I picked up a Gamegenic box after seeing this review and it's amazing. They look great, are affordable, and amazingly functional. Thanks for your reviews!

[@ImperialVersian]

Even though I pretty much stopped playing paper Magic completely, and am gradually just playing less and less magic altogether due to Mtg Arena being mostly standard, and standard right now is *awful*, I still enjoy these deck box review videos. Thanks, prof!

[@VladTepes44]

Now you will have to review gamegenic sleeves, mats and binders :)

[@ArteausArtane]

watching this makes me feel really good about purchasing a gamegenic deck box, i really like the design and feel! Knowing though that they got the Prof seal of approval makes it feel like a more worthwhile purchase!

[@4rc4vu5]

This is my favorite series. Thank you Prof. I review your videos before I buy any accessories! Keep up the great work!

[@sadino123]

That beaming face when the box holds on, blessed

[@autobotjazz1972]

I love these videos though i have yet to spend more than $15 on a deck box, the prof has helped me find some good bargain deck boxes though and avoid expensive clunkers like the one in this video.

[@bronsonkim6652]

I've been going back and rewatching all these deckbox videos and seeing how my favorite deck boxes are stacking up. Right now my favorites are my Satin Tower, Dragonshield Nest, Ultimate Guard Sidewinder, and I recently bought my friend a Gamegenic Sidekick because it had a review from this channel written on the box. He loves the Sidekick but I think the Sidewinder is still my favorite. Something about it just feels so right and I've come to really prefer sideloading deckboxes

[@LAmanafull6246]

Thk to you i bought the gamegenic 1100+, and it's a wonder, it's perfect for my beloved cube, and gamegenic is indeed now my favorite brand :D

[@diegoblin9090]

Thanks a lot prof. You take bullets for us. One see a deckbox with the name Dragonshield in it and could assume "it will be great" but thanks to you we don't have to have that bad experience. By the other hand who could tough that a new brand could be so good! You are our lighthouse in this sea of products. Pd. Laughed a lot with your face at the end giving the deck box a final shake test hahahaha.

[@ThatOneHeartless]

these videos have been helpful for over half a decade. thanks prof.!

[@Caijima]

I like the GameGenic Squire a lot, but i realised that my double sleeved deck wouldn't fit. I used the Dragon Shield inner sleeves Perfect Fit clear sealable.

[@hiddenleaf414]

Damn glad I saw this then. I use Dragonshield Mattes with Dragonshield inner sealable sleeves as well. What deckboxes do you use to fit your entire deck in comfortably? I’ve found even the Ultra Pro Satin Tower’s sort of bend the cards on the outside because of how much pressure there is.

[@michaell3461]

I wish I had seen these, I went out and bought 2 and can't get my dragon shield sealable+katana double sleeved deck to fit. Really disappointed because the deckboxes look good.

[@Caijima]

@@hiddenleaf414 Have not found a good solution for the Problem. Still looking for a Deckkox that will fit nicely.

[@hiddenleaf414]

Meijiuma Same. Seems like currently custom ones or 3d printed ones are the only option. ://

[@xPronTronx]

I just picked up three Squires to upgrade some of my accessories. Unfortunately my lgs was selling them for $20, but my god are they worth it! I absolutely love these things! Another cool feature I thoroughly enjoy is putting the lid on the bottom at an angle so the box tilts towards you, which is something they suggested on the packaging

[@Jrizzle7426]

gamegenix is coming in and taking over the magic card storage world. they make great stuff.

[@TheOCDmarkEtingClub]

thank you for this!!! I've been brewing a buncha commander decks and have been on the hunt for good boxes for them!!

[@raydelmartinez2905]

Always a good review. Once I am ready to change my deck boxes I know where to come for an assessment.

[@yairgomez9090]

Why in the earth is this so satisfiying to watch?!

[@orsettomorbido]

16:50 Cons "nah" Well, wow.

[@skamensch4306]

4:59 well...

[@UberNoober147]

Thank you for always being honest and transparent. Your work does not go unnoticed.

[@MrBagelz]

Bought some of the GameGenic cases after watching this video, absolutely love them. The snap feels so good and the fit is wonderful. Was thrilled to see these cases show up at my LGS, have already got 3. Price is Great as well, been talking them up. Thanks again for the review prof!

[@DarkX64]

I feel your love for the gamegenic boxes Prof. As someone who has just made his 8th commander deck and is looking to finalize 9 with 10 right behind, I love the Ultra Pro Satin towers but I am running out of colors to differentiate! I asked myself what the next step might be and while I am not 100% certain I am ready to move away from the towers especially for the dice compartments, the Game Genic's look like the answer. Loved the review

[@IronGlorfindel]

I gotta say, these product reviews are some of my favorite content on your channel Prof. I just wish you'd use 100 sleeved islands or healing salves during the oft-failed shake tests

[@Sabis2365]

"Cons? Nah."

[@Shifty69569]

This is my favorite review series, deck boxes and dice towers

[@ytsejam58]

My girlfriend has had the deck vault 100 since we got into magic a year ago and I was really impressed with how good that box is. Personally, I like my Sidewinder. It holds a commander deck really well or a 75 card deck with just enough room for a spindown and some dice. My favorite for when im taking one deck to a standard night out and want to keep it as simple as possible

[@SteamSteamers]

Looks awesome! I'm all in on UG Boulders but these look more compact at the table in exchange for some additional moving parts

[@joshlindblad9893]

I rewatch these like a damn TV show lol

[@fbfowler]

Love my gamegenic strongholds deck boxes! Great product that the prof introduced me to in a previous video.

[@spencersonnier1]

Hey Professor I don’t know if this is something you’ve noticed, but something I noticed with the new Dragon Shield sealable sleeves that you demoed a while back, they add just a little bit of thickness to your cards and makes your deck not fit into certain deck boxes. I have a commander deck in dragon shield mattes and dragon shield sealable inner sleeves and it can’t fit into Boulders anymore. The only deck box that it fits in is a satin tower. Which isn’t a problem for me but it could be for other people.

[@haingis]

I bought the gamegenic stronghold after watching your previous review. It is amazing how much satisfaction you can get from something like a proper box. I feel old.

[@apony6263]

My favorite part of these videos is putting the shake test in slow motion and really just taking it all in

[@redghost5705]

Gamegenics boxes are amazing I got the stronghold and have zero complaints. I would recommend it to anyone. Thanks for these videos prof

[@ZaNiiPhantom]

Such a wholesome dude, also now we might have to redo the “Professors top picks” video 😱

[@buenchiko007]

so what stopped the GameGenic from being a solid A+? seemed absolute perfect from every angle (price, design, reliability, card security, it can handle 100 double sleeved cards)

[@Brawler_1337]

Late reply, but I think the professor reserves A+ ratings for products that go above and beyond. A+s are for products that are innovative and potentially even revolutionary, on top of being just high quality. They’re for products that have no real equal and are just the best at what they do, be that in terms of functionality, durability, size, weight, or value for your dollar. If an A is amazing, an A+ is mind-blowing.

[@mtw31993]

If you put single sleeved commander decks in the deck vaults, the trays can hold a decent amount of tokens in addition to the deck. It's the box I currently use and love it.

[@actorz2005]

Bought the gamegenic stronghold after your review of that box and can safely say it’s my favourite accessory so far. I might look into the squire over the watchtower for some of my other decks (although, can one go wrong with buying extra strongholds). Thanks a lot for your videos prof

[@kingcaz5655]

Gamegenic is now my favorite deck box the first ones you reviewed I bought some that day and have been satisfied since