Multiple uplinks using PCC, Load balancing

[@tmcarter3]

Fantstic video... These videos are SO valiable and I wish these were done 15 years ago! Martins, you have explained this is terms that are easily understood; and easily repeatable. I know there were examples on website; but this gives the "picture is worth a 1000 words" a brand new meaning. Thank you!! I look forward to future config overviews.

[@domhamai]

And a video is a thousand pictures!

[@dvreshta]

Mikrotik just discovered a new talent on content creation. Great job Martins!

[@ksenyxths]

The way this guy explained such an advanced topic with such simplicity is mind-blowing. It's like he's telling a captivating story that even a 10-year-old kid could understand. I'm amazed at his ability to break down complex concepts and make them accessible to a wide audience. This is the kind of teaching we need more of - making knowledge accessible to everyone. Kudos to him for his exceptional communication skills!

[@easypr]

It took 10 minutes to setup , with 2 isp working perfectly , great description . Thank You

[@Kredo800]

Thanks. There are plenty suspicious & unverified DIY instructions, having the "official" one is very valuable.

[@sudanking99]

Great video, will done. I think you forget mentioned NAT.

[@harrysugiarto]

Nice video...one of the best tutorials for load balancing PCC...👍👏👏👏

[@florentinbarbura7808]

Thank you, concise, concrete, very helpful explanation, very useful in OS7 versions.

[@glrfi4eva]

the best mangle tutorial - I have been looking for days for something like this that will actually work in v7+

[@keletk]

fantastic video martins have explained clearly and simply....please add a video with configuration of failover recursive routes based on config of this video

[@19HOKAGE68]

Nice! Part 2 please 🙏 thank you.

[@yeo1397]

Nice video.. Clear and concise. Can you make a video on how to integrate QoS with Load Balancing (PCC) with a theory explaining how it works?

[@RuouniKenshin]

Awesome video! I hope you keep making educational videos like these because your OS and products are amazing and teaching people how to use them is just another way to show them to a wider audience.

[@mauriciohenriques3820]

Excellent video. I could be complemented by adding how to incorporate recursive routing and ISPs with DHCP address attribution on this scenario, as the "default gateway" for each ISP changes over time.

[@SuperSiyko]

Thank you for such a clear and qualitative explanation. I would like more videos like best practice options, especially about load balance, wan or vpn failover etc. Thank

[@jermainebrown8615]

Great video! Just a small twist: if your connection is not local, use the unicast option in the classifiers.

[@philosophermind2589]

THIS GUY make me config 3isp in a easiest way...amazing guy..mikrotik expert

[@arttrout8236]

Great JOB! I have been having trouble with my 2 wan system using another multi wan scenario. This one sounds like the best thought plan for my application.

[@Joshv918]

Love these videos!! Helped me get into mikrotik faster and made it easy.. maybe adding to this design would of been nice to see recursive routes .. Thank you!!

[@troelse.nrmlle4625]

Time well spent 👍, we like them.

[@ifscale3]

Thank you for this video. You have explained a lot of information very clearly. In the MikroTik wiki on PCC, there are *accept* rules in the prerouting chain for traffic from the LAN destined to connected WAN subnets. These rules are placed before the PCC rules and are meant to prevent a routing loop. Can someone help me understand how these accept rules prevent a routing loop? Which traffic from the LAN to the WAN interface subnets will match these rules?

[@alekseykharchenko2769]

Thank you from yours video settings router demonstration. I will try this settings in my router.

[@flisskennigen4675]

Nice video. Very informative. Thank you for the video Mārtiņš & team.

[@黑沙漠-v5n]

视频说的很详细，👍

[@Mensan1960]

The issues I have with these setups are: 1) most ISP's I deal with are issuing dynamic IP addresses, so you can't use static routes in the routing tables. 2) Since the ISP device is almost always local, just pinging the local address does no good for a connection outage. You need to ping a REMOTE device to check connectivity. I haven't seen any of these videos address these issues.

[@pooshrulez]

1) You can assign a script to DHCP Client, which RouterOS executes after obtaining IP information. It is tricky but possible to identify the new gateway and update your static routes from the script. 2) You can schedule a script to periodically do some checks (e.g., pinging an external IP from a specific interface), and enable/disable routes based on that.

[@rachidrac1759]

درس جد رائع و واضح ... كيف يمكن معالجة الأمر مع الموجه من نوع أجهزة التأرجح في التحميل و او دمج ثلاث خطوط مختلفة tenda ax 3000 w30e له واجهة جد مختصرة و لا تتيح فسحت الاستفادة من مؤهلاته رغم كونه يتضمن ثلاث منافذ من فئة wan/lan و واحدة من فىة lan mtu بين 1400 إلى 1500 أنوه بجهودكم العلميو على جهودكم الفاضلة

[@unumpolum]

Thank you. This is what I needed.

[@thulfeqarAli]

Hello, thank you for the clear and comprehensive explanation, but what about the NAT settings?

[@Rouly88]

😊 un pur bonheur. Very cool. Enjoy myself

[@evgeniyloginov]

nice manual, thanks!

[@GlenKowalchuk]

Thanks again Martins 👍😎

[@suadiadnya]

nice tutor i'm mikrotik user from indonesia , gbu

[@truongsi1]

Thanks about this videos. If i want to setup 8 isp loadbalacing on CCR2004. What can i do ?

[@leratoradebe6438]

Awesome!!!

[@bonamin]

I will look at this later with a clear mind. I am using an LHG-LTE18 as my internet Modem/Router, but I've also bought an RB5009 for this exact purpose. I wanted to buy a second LHG, and have them both feed the connetion to the RB and the RB serve as my main Router. I wanted to do that because when using 4G in my country and with my ISP you have to options. Either use "vpn" APN or the normal one. VPN gives you a public IP (like ADSL for example) but limits bandwidth to 150Mbps. Normal APN puts you behind a NAT (CG-NAT) effectively removing your ability to port forward anything inside, but gives you Full Speed. I wanted to combine two lines, with two seperate 4G SIMS, on two LHG-LTEs. But it's SO HARD setting up these things since RouterOS is so complicated (in order to be detailed and powerful), and the community on Mikrotik Forums didn't really help me much, as from what I've seen, they don't really like noobs. :) Currently my RB5009 is just a brick sitting in my closet :( Anyway, will check the video later and maybe I can find more info on how to set my net up.

[@mikrotik]

Did you manage to find a solution?

[@bonamin]

​@@mikrotik No. I had no time to look further into it. I need to gather information that is scattered around because I'm not an expert on the subject. The problems I face mainly are: 1) I was told by Mikrotik specialists that if I put the LTE18 on "Passthrough" mode, I should have setup a VLAN for management. 2) I then need to figure out the rest of the setup so the RB works as a Router and the LTE18 machines work as Internet supliers only. Anyway, the problem as I said, is that I didn't have the time to look THAT DEEP into the matter. My LHG-LTE18 is super fast as it is. I just wanted to make my VoIP phone work as well. :(

[@WanFiITSoLuTioNs]

very informative. next discussion about policy based routing. please

[@alciomar]

Excellent video!

[@mikkio5371]

Weldone and nice . Lengthy but worth it

[@compratecno]

excelent explanation.

[@kirksteinklauber260]

Thanks but I have an scenario and a question: How can use PPC if I want Primary and Standby scenario? For example broadband of 200 Mbps as primary and LTE as backup only? Also as my uplink is directly to a local cable modem and 3rd party LTE router the WAN port of my Mikrotik can be up but the Internet can be down. Don’t do require here to do recursive routing? And if so how can I do it when my ISP gives my WAN IPs only via DHCP in my router instead of static routes? Thanks and great video!

[@k0nctant1n.pererva]

I set it up a long time ago. Everything would be fine, but I discovered that the connection to the router is ISP2 (the router page does not open). The connection is marked ISP1. Help

[@hexatested]

Mark connection rules also mark the ospf connection which use multicast address. I would suggest to accepting routing related connection before marking for load balance or incoming connection into router.

[@kubik256]

Nice video! Is there any chance to export finished config (RSC or plaintext) and place it somewhere, that anyone can review it? I have done this setup few years ago, but it was quite buggy... probably I had bad PCC values.

[@UlrichWessendorf]

Very nice video, but what if I get on all connections IP´s and Gateways dynamically via DHCP, how can I prepaire the needed Routing tables? That´s unfortunaltly the critical point in using more than one ISP here in Germany.

[@UlrichWessendorf]

@@geogmz8277 Could you give me the headline of the forum title? The forum itself is well known, but it's hard to find something without knowing details🙂

[@davidcraddock6474]

@@geogmz8277 Would be very interested in this as well..

[@mikrotik]

As mentioned in the video, this video was about PCC method and we did not configure things like DHCP server, NAT, firewall, users, etc. You can not dynamically adjust routes in differnet routing tables automatically based on the DHCP client. But it is very easy to write a script on the DHCP client which simply updates the route when gateway changes (help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/ROS/DHCP#DHCP-LeaseScriptExampleLeasescriptexample). However, thank you for the inspiration. We will see if we can convince our developers to allow doing this dynamically in the upcoming RouterOS releases. :)

[@alimibrahem8120]

So elegant..!

[@sabujplays1611]

Best helpful video for me... Thanks 🫡👍

[@R_Al-Najar]

I use the same rules as mentioned in this video for load balancing to increase Internet speeds in a hotspot, but unfortunately, it's not working. Can anyone here tell me if this is working for a hotspot?

[@Anavllama]

Why is NEW required on the connection marks for incoming eth1,eth2,eth3 when you have no-mark selected. Saying its not required in your scenario. Same with the LAN connections!!

[@takeiteasyeh]

thank you for the video. the eyes not looking at the camera, but to the side is super noticable and really throws me off,, maybe its just me that finds it distracting

[@SoranEngineer]

good explanation thank you so much

[@TerryPullen]

I just received my new router today, I am brand new to MikroTik and there is no way I can keep up with what he is doing. The mouse moves so fast that I had to slow the video way down and pause it in order to see what he was clicking on. Please make these videos clearer and easier to follow.

[@mikkio5371]

i got it from your mikotik help page : " PCC is not a valid method, in case of Hotspot(captive portal) - due to the fact that Hotspot uses web-proxy and it uses only the default routing table, at the moment. " is this statement still valid as of today ? and if yes what other method best suit load balancing for hotspot . ECMP or policy base routing . which ?

[@asiimweonesmas4212]

Thanks for the video Hotspot doesn't work well. Captive portal doesn't open automatically 😢😢😢😢. Any solution

[@radenrohmatulloh]

Me too

[@OperKH]

What about FastPath\FastTrack should it be disabled?

[@samaelfront2848]

thank you👻

[@Problembaer4]

To me, as a non native-english speaker, "remainder" was a bit misleading. 26/3 = 8,667... ",667" was the "remainder" to me. But what you mean with "remainder" is a MODULO operation! 26 mod 3 = 2.

[@KP_187]

Martins this is a really helpful video, thank you! I have just configured my RB4011iGS+ with to ISP connection following your tutorial and all is working perfectly! I just wanted to ask you something?! I have already setup 5 VLAN-s under the Bridge Port to this RB4011iGS+ router! I also added ether1-ISP1 and ether10-ISP2 at the WAN Interface List and at the NAT side > Chain: srcnat > Out Interface List: WAN > Action: masquerade! Hope this is a good configuration! My question is: At @10:21, the mark new connection from LAN... Am I supposed to choose All VLAN as In Interface? Thanks in Advance!

[@Лёха-р7д1г]

Setting up a multivan for the Internet is not a problem. But if the task is to create a VPN tunnel through each provider where the static IP is only on one side, then there is a problem. Can Mikrotik balance VPN? I tried to set it up for a long time, but the multivan and 1 tunnel did not move. Is there information on how to implement balancing of VPN tunnels between the main office and the branch? I'm trying to configure everything on wireguard.

[@jackypeng7952]

Great video got PCC working could a video be made for port forwarding with PCC setup

[@burimbajraktari]

Great video thanks. A question why you didnt used the Pasthrough option?

[@davidcampos8795]

Would this still dynamically route traffic if an ISP loses Internet but the ISP gateway is still ping able? Ping seems like an unreliable way to determine if a route is down because here in the states the gateway is usually an ISP modem device and that never goes down but you'll lose Internet

[@nick9323]

Yep, it will. Google pdf "Monitoring the Internet Connections of WAN Links with Only Routing Configuration", it's has and example of your needs

[@peterkovacs233]

you can check a gateway internet connection with recursive routes. This is what you looking for.

[@CaMapTrang]

you are right (Y) , on the os7 router you can check fail the port connected to the BFD instead of using the very inaccurate Ping ! my video at 28:11

[@mikrotik]

Yes, then the route would be still active. However, this video was not about that. It seems that this is the solution that you are looking for - help.mikrotik.com/docs/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=26476608

[@wernerjalinski392]

its missing to add the NAT Rule for both ISP'^s .... masq srcnat --> wan1 and second rule is masq srvnat --> wan2 .... after creating both nat rules the connection over vdsl + skylink was dynamically able to switch =D

[@donakpabio]

Great video! I have a question, what happens when we have a BGP connection with the 3 ISPs?

[@robertkirwan29]

Great video, is there a simple way using Mangle to force traffic from a specific local ip to use ISP1 as a priority?

[@hectorj.romanp.]

Do a failover configuration, please. One of my clients has three ISPs, all of them use DHCP and one of them uses PPPoE.

[@Kredo800]

You can do failover just simply pluging all three, making them wan, and making different distances.

[@anthonya.1958]

Technically yes, but doesn’t work for failover. I’ve tried this but RouterOS doesn’t failover route. We need better way to do recursive routes in RouterOS 7

[@mikrotik]

As mentioned in the video, this video was about PCC method and we did not configure things like DHCP server, NAT, firewall, users, etc. You can not dynamically adjust routes in differnet routing tables automatically based on the DHCP client. But it is very easy to write a script on the DHCP client which simply updates the route when gateway changes (help.mikrotik.com/docs/display/ROS/DHCP#DHCP-LeaseScriptExampleLeasescriptexample). However, thank you for the inspiration. We will see if we can convince our developers to allow doing this dynamically in the upcoming RouterOS releases. :)

[@ebenolivier]

At about 5:30 you add the route tables to the route list. What I do not understand is that you give each one an immediate Gateway address, but seeing that one of the ISP's is dynamic how can you know the gateway address?

[@momensobhy2929]

Thank you for the awesome tutorial. However, I really need guidance on how to implement NTH load balancing in RouterOS v7. I've tried numerous times but something always goes wrong. Could you please provide any information or resources on how it works? Thank you.

[@erwinbolasa1524]

Can you provide video on load balancing with Hotspot?

[@pablorepolles]

Thanks Martins - it has helped me a lot to understand how mikrotik works to balance connections. I have a question - If the ISP2 router is turned off for example. Will the connection marking rules continue to mark new connections that are assigned to "ISP2.conn" by counter and therefore would be lost? Thank you

[@mikrotik]

Like the video says, when ISP2 goes down, main routing table will be used, meaning - the route with the lowest distance will be used which in our case was ISP1. Nothing will be lost, that is the whole point of this setup. So that it always works.

[@GixD_]

best tutorial 😁

[@fayron_global]

❤👍💪

[@MrHatchic]

Good afternoon The video is excellent, very useful information about your equipment, well, why is it not so easy to do, why make it so difficult to access available packages. Then, after the full setup, a lot of lines are built in the backup. I think for beginners it is very difficult to understand!

[@beelzebub8626]

What is the difference between using pcc "scr address and port" and "both address and port"? Thanks

[@toolsanddrymaller]

thank you 😊

[@Anavllama]

Why do you add the check-gateway ping to the Routes attached to the specific tables. Why not attach the check gateway ping to the default routes (main table)? Second question, why are you attaching distance to the three networks? PCC is load sharing they should all have the same distance???

[@JPMeijers]

This is nice, but how do one do this if the WAN interfaces use DHCP?

[@sashalexander7750]

Just did not get one thing: you are one of the gods or one of the guys from Mikrotik support?)

[@jozsefmolnar6179]

It's looks like good, but what about IP/Firewall/NAT/masquerade action? I think, it's missing from the steps!

[@اممحمدانسانس]

Welcome I have 3 starlink internet providers I have two RB1100Dx4's The first is load balancing The second is distribution to subscribers What is the correct way to program the load balancer in the first router?

[@hahay16]

hmm, using the same configuration, I can't seem to access my ISP Router/Gateway.

[@voltswagner]

Misleading. How can you add a static IP address in all three routes, when you say one ISP will get its IP address dynamically?

[@olpchk1115]

Still can't manage to make it working without that main route. It looks like those ISP table and route mark are just ignored

[@glrfi4eva]

1. How do you ensure interconnects maintain the correct gateway (say the router has 2 WANs and 2 other private networks (for interconnecting to the LAN of another router (B)), it sends and receives traffic for, i.e. a PC network isolated that needs a server under in the A routers LAN, so pass between LAN ports (router B has a DHCP lease in RouterA's LAN) ), I assume as they are not in the LAN bridge they will default to the "main" route table? 2. How do route table routes work if the correct gateway in not in the table, can they jump to the "main" table if no entry? Or just fail?

[@Lucas-av7]

following this tutorial my internet gets unstable, it only works good if I create two rules to mark the connection in the output chain? does anybody know why?

[@frank89095]

am trying to load balance on ros7 pcc with hotspot but hotspot keeps on indicating no internet

[@Ai__X]

I have a Mikrotik Hex S router which has SFP port and an RJ45 WAN port, Currently I'm using RJ45 port as main WAN interface and planning to get a second ISP connection can I do multiple ISP with Hex S router with an RJ45 SFP device?

[@Q4best]

Nice job. But local ruting table will not work?

[@collinsonyegbado309]

Thanks for the video How can I use mangle rule to route http,SSL,smtp and pop 3 traffic's to isp1 while the other traffice will go to isp2

[@albertas978]

but lets say i have 2 modems connected via usb to the same mikrotik device how would i go about load balancing those connections if they are dynamic routes

[@AndriiAntoniak]

Thank you for the video, it`s very helpful! Please can you make the video for Queues with Multiple uplinks?

[@hlbindonesia3547]

veryyyyyyy simple only use table mode to result loadbalance 3 isp thanks broohhhhhh

[@XtrAMassivE]

This is a great video, thank you. But I have one ISP with 1GB uplink and other with 50MB uplink. There are certain services (VOIP) that have to operate over the ISP2. What's the best way of load balancing this? Do I need to make hundred mange rules? Should I just create a separate routing rule for the VOIP subnet to only use ISP2? I would appreciate any advice, I'm still kinda new to this.

[@mikrotik]

Instead of using PCC, look into other methods of filtering out VOIP traffic.

[@Garen15]

Great video, got it working with two WAN connections. my only problem now is the router itself does not have internet, ping outside shows "No route to host". anyone has any ideas?

[@fervendelosreyes3278]

nice video, but try not disconnect the physical cable from your router, disconnect the cable or fiber from the isp, then will see if it still works..

[@anthonya.1958]

Yes. They need to validate this way…. As I believe it will fail. I’ve had this happen - as we need to instead use recursive route to validate GW

[@mikrotik]

We already did - kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJ3FaIt3q5pqqtk

[@dpgdigit]

The video state that there is 3 differents connections. static, dhcp, pppoe but then later @ 5:30 route to static GW are added. Usualy with dynamic IP ISP (dhcp or pppoe) you also have dynamic GW. I'd like to see the workaround there. Recursive route ? scheduled script ? dhcp client script ?

[@dpgdigit]

Because we don't know the GW IP, we can not create route @ 5:30. This script will do that dynamicaly { :local rtable "ISP1" :local count [/ip route print count-only where comment=$rtable] :if ($bound=1) do={ :if ($count = 0) do={ /ip route add check-gateway=ping gateway=$"gateway-address" routing-table=$rtable comment=$rtable } else={ :if ($count = 1) do={ :local test [/ip route find where comment=$rtable] :if ([/ip route get $test gateway] != $"gateway-address") do={ /ip route set $test gateway=$"gateway-address" } } else={ :error "Multiple routes found" } } } else={ /ip route remove [find comment=$rtable] } }

[@actomobile]

If I use this configuration I can't access other subnet in my router. It routed directly to WAN gateway. am I missing something?

[@jeytis72]

Can it also be considered as a failover setup? Thanks

[@aeronstone100]

Great Video, I tried with my dual ISPs and while speed wise it seems to be working. I am getting 50% packet loss. Any help?

[@user-comet7664]

Can PCC load balancing be achieved without NAT,DHCP? I have an existing router that handles NAT and DHCP. I am considering introducing PCC load balancing in front of this router to increase bandwidth

[@مجدخالداليوسفي-ح6ص]

Hello engineer I have 2 Mikrotik 1100x4 and I have 5 ADSL internet service providers. I use Mikrotik 1100x4 for internet sources and I use Mikrotik 1100x4 to distribute internet to users. But I am facing a problem with the load balance of internet sources Currently using pcc v6 Please ask for help to solve the problem The best load balance for Internet sources You have my sincere affection and appreciation ❤️