Muslims Explain Islam - Where's Your Evidence?

[@billyzahid5904]

Guys i just want to say - please keep your comments positive. The sister might be reading these comments someday and we are not painting a good picture of Islam - we are the Ambassadors of our Religion. Please share the love and thank her for asking direct questions and being honest with her thoughts/mind.

[@akagaminolip]

yup totally agree, many of us commenting using their emotion.

[@komujimaru]

I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah" (Muslim 1: 33) Permitted stealing from unbelievers. (Bukhari 44:668, Ibn Ishaq 764) Permitted lying. (Sahih Muslim 6303, Bukhari 49:857) Owned and traded slaves. (Sahih Muslim 3901) Beheaded 800 Jewish men and boys. (Abu Dawud 4390) Murdered those who insulted him (Bukhari 56:369, 4:241) "If then anyone transgresses the prohibition against you, Transgress ye likewise against him" (Quran 2:194) Jihad in the way of Allah elevates one's position in Paradise by a hundred fold. (Muslim 4645) Married 13 wives and kept sex slaves. (Bukhari 5:268, Quran 33:50) Slept with a 9-year-old child. (Sahih Muslim 3309, Bukhari 58:236)

[@samiirrrr]

absolutely.... people get into a defensive / argumentative mode because their knowledge of Islam has come from the media and random stuff picked up from here and there. inshaAllah, once she speaks to the brothers she will have a positive outlook....

[@salimali7093]

With positive comments she won't be able to learn anything, the good, the bad and the ugly side of herself, especially her arrogance. The truth helps to improve oneself rather then being cocooned like a frog in the well, not moving forward nor backward.

[@billyzahid5904]

@@salimali7093 It's called respect my brother. I had someone once laugh at my face for something I said about Islam but when I explained the beauty, science and logic of Islam their perception quickly changed. I think none of us have ever gone up to a sheikh/da'ee and asked direct questions like she did. So hats off to her. I'll leave you with a quote that I learned from a brother from Medina - "when you point one finger, there are three pointing back at you"

[@elafzal5866]

As a newly revert, the brother in the black, he has the best of intentions and is very excited but he should not interrupt the da'wah.

[@squidguard4743]

I was cringing

[@alexandriaDMR]

He just excited lot of new reverts are but they should learn first

[@thairinkhudr4259]

I think he is following the brother to learn to do dawah. In the previous video, his inputs were quite ok and doesn't disturb the dawah or detract from anything imo. But he should take a hint to give space for the main conversation to flow without interruption.

[@tdsdave]

Fashion victim , thinks being Muslim is cool, I doubt he'll go the distance.

[@Shadh777]

He’s very annoying, constantly interrupting

[@misterysnip4022]

We can all take a lesson from Dr Imran as to how to have a conversation. His manners and tone are great. May Allah preserve him.

[@baqi9]

Ameen

[@komujimaru]

I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah" (Muslim 1: 33)

[@baqi9]

@@komujimaru debate is fighting too

[@nassermohammed9329]

@@baqi9 fighting the shaitan inside.

[@baqi9]

@@nassermohammed9329 yep!…that’s another one

[@AyeshaKhan-mk3so]

This woman is a complete test of patience. Kudos to Dr imran

[@dr_ismail_wazir]

So true

[@zulharith1709]

"I can debate with 10 people who are knowledgeable but I will be defeated by the ignorant, because ignorant people will never understand the basic of knowledge" (Imam Shafi'i)

[@truth6564]

Nah mate not every one is gona think like u or like ur brothers 🙏🏼

[@Someguy1357]

@@truth6564 The quote is true though, regardless of what one might think of anyone in the video.

[@truth6564]

@@Someguy1357 Yh but don’t have to believe what I believe it don’t make me a smaller person to believe believe what I believe is the truth

[@hridrumaiya]

@@truth6564 a knowledgeable person will try to understand what the other person is saying, he may agree or disagree but will not repeat same thing like a parrot he heard from some hater.

[@truth6564]

@@hridrumaiya stop going in circles u boring me

[@Addakhel]

Subhana'Allah.. She's hearing but she's not listening. Not even letting brother Imran finish his points!

[@AM-dn1iq]

Bro how's she not understanding this 😳🤨🤔

[@goldenbrown3283]

She asked for proof but she was not given the truth !!! ..How long does it take to give proof ???.

[@otakugamer1438]

@@goldenbrown3283 thats a dumb question. What kind of evidence is she looking for? What kind of evidence would make you be a muslim on the spot? Nothing Thats why he said here request is unreasonable.

[@goldenbrown3283]

@@otakugamer1438 it's not a dumb question at all. If your answer does not sit right with her then it doesn't sit right. There is faith and there is blind faith. The two are very different. Blind faith does not allow you to think or question. It's her personal journey. People need to stop getting uptight and triggered!!.

[@otakugamer1438]

@@goldenbrown3283 “if your answer doesn’t sit right with her then it doesn’t sit right” Hitler walks in an asks what is wrong with killing them jews? You give whatever elaborate “not dumb” answer any human could ever think of Hitler says ohh but that answer doesn’t sit will with me Boom its okay to kill jew now According to you it is

[@asifulovi4673]

This is literally Islam vs Arrogance, Wisdom vs Ignorance 101 in front of you folks! May Allah increase brother Imran in knowledge & guidance! Such a gem mashaAllah!

[@dinaroadvecero70]

no hypocrisi against the girl

[@asifulovi4673]

@@dinaroadvecero70 what do you mean?

[@dinaroadvecero70]

@@asifulovi4673 watch the clip again and now with openminded and listend to that gir and then the answesr of that fake dude and listen to the 3

[@asifulovi4673]

@@dinaroadvecero70 what's your point!

[@snakejuce]

@@asifulovi4673 Why do you waste your time responding to ignorant troll 🤡's?? Just let the dogs bark, they're deeply jealous if the deen and have a deep hatred towards Islam. Let it destroy them.

[@paksallion]

I studied biomedical sciences. Dr Imran remains quiet and humbly educates the student of science.

[@ghiaspiracha302]

40gramsofProtein oxxxoviiioxxii It is quite common among atheists, agnostics and evolutionists to assume and believe that they know all there is to know and do NOT have the manners or the patience to LISTEN and understand then THINK and prove their 'assumption'. If we evolved from 'monkeys', why the dickens monkeys are still around talking about evolution....? This know-all 'hoity-toity' lady is no different.... Bro. Imran is a Doctor by profession, extremely polite, patient and knowledgeable.

[@usmaniqbal836]

He sure made her look like a student in this video May Allah guide her

[@tdsdave]

No , Imran is not educating anyone he's just misrepresenting the science and doing sophistry. For example he states "It's not about the size of the beak, it's the shape" , this is simply incorrect, obviously size and shape are interrelated. The types of finches beaks sizes varies between 6mm and 14mm. He talks of knowing that all the beaks changed over one or two generations on the birds arrival at the islands, but that is a bare assertion the birds arrived perhaps a million or more years ago ,there no one observed their adaption which he claimed they had. Even epigenetics does not work like that. What I think he is referring to is study relating to a drought . "A drought on the Galápagos island of Daphne Major in 1977 reduced the number of small seeds available to finches, causing many of the small-beaked finches to die. This caused an increase in the finches' average beak size between 1976 and 1978." Birds dying because they have no food , whilst others surviving because they have food is not the birds evolving its a selection pressure, just meaning big bills survived, and went onto reproduce big billed birds. He talks of epigenetics , but these bird types have variations in their genetics as well as their expression of those genetics, epigenetics does not show evolution is wrong. It's no surprise Imran harps on about epigentics , creationists have been jumping all over and misrepresenting that topic in an effort to save their fairy tales. She asks about homosexuality and Imran cannot even be honest about Islam position on it , he says go to sources, and what do the sources say , they support the spirit of her statement , yet Imran cannot even admit that. «مَنْ رَأَيْتُمُوهُ يَعْمَلُ عَمَلَ قَوْمِ لُوطٍ، فَاقْتُلُوا الْفَاعِلَ وَالْمَفْعُولَ بِه»

[@paksallion]

@@tdsdave nice. Now go tell him.

[@iifsyifa102]

@@tdsdave if we have wrong intention but we don't do it, we not sin. Live Is test. Homosexuality Is a test. A difficult test for someone who has it. But, as long as he doesn't practice it, is not sin. Event heterosexuality Is a test. You only alow to do it with your halal spouse, not with everyone you want.

[@DjTableManners]

The amount of patience you need to talk to these people is huge. Omg

[@dr_ismail_wazir]

😅

[@sofyanasha5706]

I feel you, she is lost with the way of her thinking

[@awakenedservant]

May Allah swt open this sister's heart and guide her to Islam . Ameen .. she has a good heart insyaAllah

[@mohammedcoker415]

Ameen

[@Agibator]

She doesn't have open heart, she has arrogant heart, she is mocking Allah by saying: Why can't you prove your God's existence, your God is amazing (she seems to be saying: Why can't He show Himself to the world) You don't feel that in her statements? Like Allah said in the surah Kahf: This is Haqq from your Rabb, whoever wills let them believe, and whoever wills let them disbelieve; She right now choose to disbelieve and I don't saw any signs that she's trying to find the truth.

[@awakenedservant]

@@Agibator Remaining positive is the Sunnah akhi InsyaAllah the reason she is there is because Allah wants her to find him . InsyaAllah.

[@jzilla1234]

Ok i take it back, she just wants to argue for the sake of arguing. She says "I did bio med" but doesn't understand the basics. I wish her all the best

[@samiirrrr]

i think she was arguing because she refused to believe in an unjust god. and society seems to have convinced her that Allah is unjust (auzubillah ! ) , i am 100% sure that once she has that conversation with Dr Imran and Br Javed, she will change her mind insha'Allah.

[@flipedude5404]

She’s a fool. Modern western women

[@jzilla1234]

@@flipedude5404 got nothing to do with being a woman

[@illmatic1official560]

@@flipedude5404 You are no better with speech like that

[@BrakaInu]

She should ask for a refund whatever she studied. It failed her miserably. IQ got stuck at room temperature

[@reptilespit4433]

People come to ask questions from all sorts of backgrounds, British upbringing often makes ppl think high of themselves without the substance or much thought. You need patience to understand that & kill it with kindness to let the truth come out. Masha Allah Imran has done that eloquently.

[@RedGorillaLFC]

“I did bio med” - the arrogance of the women who couldn’t answer her own example and not realising she is speaking to a medical doctor

[@welcometolife4237]

Calm down. Even all scientist combined and her can't create a single newn earth let alone a grass

[@AM-dn1iq]

Most qualified people don't learn amything

[@XiagraBalls]

A "medikul dakta" like Zakir Naik, you mean? 😄

[@principlemethods5281]

being a medical doctor doesn't mean much. I say this with full respect to Imran, what I'm saying is that I don't respect him because he's a medical doctor but because of the intelligence, collectiveness, and adab he displays. I'd respect him the same if he wasn't a doctor. to me it makes no differrence

[@mikaelN00]

Being a doctor doesn't mean you have logical thinking or Intellect.

[@SwampFox01]

22:48 Thank you so much for adding this to the conversation. Most atheists think we are close minded and have back dated mentality, most of us who STAYED to practice Islam because we had to CONSTANTLY QUESTION and criticize Islamic viewpoints about all the things. Alhamdulillah, we stayed because it made sense. ISLAM makes total sense.

[@abdoulaye7179]

She came with a whole set of pre conceived ideas trying to school the Muslim brother,but got blown away by the magnitude of his knowledge. Thanks Brother

[@ElKoubi1975]

I think that she is trying hard to convince herself that her sister has made the wrong decision, so she was trying hard M, not to get answers, but to do all she could to corner the brother. May Allah open her heart to Islam.

[@Someguy1357]

@@ElKoubi1975 Ameen!

[@Emron_Alefi]

No, I don’t really think she’s trying to school him I think she’s trying to understand the things that he has to say and how different they are from what she learned and of course if someone is teaching you things that are opposite from what you learned your gonna disagree with them and give them reasons why you believe they’re wrong. If someone was stating what they believe to be facts but you know there not facts you’d do what she’s doing in this video which is trying to disprove it.

[@Someguy1357]

@@Emron_Alefi There's a big difference between disagreement and arguing. Mainly, it's listening and considering what the other person says. Please, don't take the exchange here as an example of healthy disagreement (from her end anyway).

[@HPzFreelance]

May Allah SWT guide her and all those who are searching for the truth. It is great to see this lady ask these questions and trying to understand. Most people who accept Islam including born muslims have gone though these very same questions and have come out with a better understanding of Islam and stronger in their Islam. Keep going at it !

[@mikaelN00]

Allah wouldn't have guided her to ask these questions in the first place, if she didn't have some inclination. iA she will understand the truth.

[@Omarking101]

So many different subjects in a short discussion. This sister has put herself in a box of emotionalism, scientism and ducking and diving. This proves that being "educated" doesn't mean anything.

[@pessimistkai5569]

Many women are emotional. I think it is their general thinking way.

[@esxessax7710]

science and wisdom cannot grant El Bassira because the Truth is about faith, if you recognize the truth sincerely you can't deny it but you can cover it with excuses the choice is yours just know that God never left you and gave you all the tools that you need, made you conscious , gave you the freedom to make the right choice , that is what you'll realize in the Last day that your deed of rejecting or accepting the truth is the biggest one after it Heaven or Hell.

[@playingwithrami]

Honesty, she is one of the most arrogant, incoherent humans I've ever watched. After being asked clear questions, her mind is already in defence mode, as though she's worried her true answers may be falling for a trap.

[@ahmedd320]

Okay Sheikh

[@playingwithrami]

@@ahmedd320 sad response

[@mikaelN00]

The worst thing about it is, astaghfirullah. This could be someone's wife one day. 😬

[@Undisputed_King]

Even as an atheist, I think she had an odd attitude.

[@soothingsounds2650]

She had no intentions to listen to understand only to react and answer back! Poor lady. The brothers intellect was too much for her. Bless her

[@murattaskin2640]

Don’t understand the negativity towards this sister, she’s asking questions because she’s on a journey , may Allah guide her to the the straight path , wholeheartedly I pray that she accepts Islam for you can see the struggle in her eyes.

[@LO-dm6uf]

It's so astonishing for me seeing someone who strongly disagrees with your opinion, yet is still very interested in having a civil conversation with you! We barely see this nowadays, most people are too egoistic to even try and have a conversation like this. May Allah guide her to the truth and bless her!

[@greybear3]

Dr Imrans epigenetics explanation was very informative. I'm glad I heard what he said.

[@dinoaldosyah3592]

It is so beautiful to listen to Brother Muslims explained to that lady.

[@halsm7392]

I can honestly say she’s not here to learn she here to argue. Everytime she couldn’t defend her claims she jumped to another. Everytime dr was answering her question she interrupted. Everytime dr asked her a question she would purposely avoid the question

[@hs6585]

You cannot say you don’t know what’s in her heart

[@Unlocos.]

I genuinely looked forward to the rest of this conversation. It was so refreshing to hear a sincere person asking questions and sincere answers done with knowledge, kindness, and eloquence. Alhamdulillah for these brothers and Alhamdulillah for Islam.

[@Naz_91]

Sincere .. right ..

[@Unlocos.]

@@Naz_91 she genuinely does not know, and she genuinely thinks or believes the things she’s saying. Her questions and responses while pushing back are respectful atleast and you can see the fact she likes speaking/listening to them because it seemed like she really did want to come back.

[@Naz_91]

@@Unlocos. sincerity and arrogance won’t come together. This woman was a waste of time with such attitude. The way she was talking to Imran as if she’s the expert because she “did bio med” is laughable and pathetic. A person who “genuinely doesn’t know” will never jump to conclusions and rather hold herself before spewing nonsense.

[@Unlocos.]

@@Naz_91 I see where you’re coming from. But nonetheless you can see that she’s struggling to process some of the things being said even while fighting against it. That’s a sign of some sincerity to me. And she wants to hear them out more. May Allah guide her and all of us as well Ameen.

[@Naz_91]

@@Unlocos. I see facial expressions of someone acting puzzled as if someone provided an inferior argument to them .. The ironic part of it all is that she doesn't even understand the argument she's throwing at Imran and he's trying to educate her with the basics of her argument before refuting it and she's acting like he's evading xD .. LOL how pathetic .. may allah bless brother Imran and guide us to alhaq.

[@thairinkhudr4259]

Jazakumullah khairan for your wonderful dawah effort, may you be highly rewarded. ❤️

[@amsamsamamsamsam8022]

I am so happy to hear Dr Imran on the level of the sound, his voice now loud enough I can hear him alhamdulilah , it’s either he enhanced his voice or I started to hear better, it’s not any negative against brother imaran.

[@Adminuser29729]

Brother. Her first argument was regarding Darwin’s evolution theory. Which now in 2023 is still a theory. Even Darwin himself after releasing “On the origin of species” claimed that his publication contained errors and that it was impossible correlatie his evolution theory sufficiently. Darwin was taught to me in high school and it took me like 10 years to find out and realize it is a *theory*.

[@saidborito4710]

May Allah bless this Sheikh for his patience. And, May Allah guider her to the right path.

[@Rawdil]

The argument about giraffes growing taller as the trees grow being an evolutionary process is baseless, it's still a giraffe.

[@StrictlyGermans]

Im love how Dr Imran is and how he approaches these conversations. May Allah bless him.

[@zednero8398]

That guy in the glasses should just zip it ... Its so annoying when people like him just jump in and derail the conversation and all.... We get it you have knowledge and you understand but if you want to talk to her then do it after Imran is done talking ... or go get your conversations...

[@samiirrrr]

i really hope the sister comes back for that conversation. she was genuinely looking for answers...

[@hichamagb4165]

Great conversation, we missed some good ones like that, wish that she can understand what the brothers was explaining to her with a open heart and reason

[@stevemcroy2020]

Even millionaire Christians put their parents into old age homes. Also just pay attention to her answers. It is beyond disingenuous.

[@paksallion]

She's giving her personal subjective idea of morality. Sometimes people are grown and nurtured by different cultures and they completely detached from these ideas. Being around so many cultures I can honestly say I completely understand her way of thinking. This is why you can't impose your own personal idea of morality like she has on to others. This is also why the Quran and Sunnah is important for us to base our lives and behaviour after.

[@elite7329]

It's like you're talking to a wall. While you are answering her last question instead of listening she's thinking of what question she's going to ask next. Literally does not want to have a dialogue. Complete waste of time engaging with people like her.

[@flipedude5404]

Whoever marries her will have a hell of shitty life

[@sylhetipagol1]

May Allah preserve this brother. What a beautiful way of speaking. The lights are turning on in the minds of this sister. Little pondering will do it insha allah.

[@jawaadshahid]

This person has 0 capacity to reflect. Shes already asking the next question while one is being answered.

[@DePeaceHunter]

You don't know that brother. She might reflect later

[@cryptaxer]

Really hating these premiers 🥵, its reasonable to divide the video into parts but why delay it for days? Someone explain the reason behind it please.

[@itisyouthatiadore]

This lady just realised that she is trapped, Dr.Imran is concise and well manered, may Allah guide the brothers in the dawah

[@shabanali8591]

i wouldnt use the word trap, she lacks knowledge & may allah guide her & encourage her to read Quran

[@MansMan42069]

@Brother asked a very good question You just Zakir Naik'd yourself

[@flipedude5404]

@@shabanali8591 Lol you’re wrong

[@shabanali8591]

@@flipedude5404 based on what evidence you say I’m wrong

[@f.h.5840]

She's been institutionalised. Has been taught something for so long she refuses to accept any evidence brought to her contradicting what she's learned.

[@f.h.5840]

@Sir Christofer Braxton like I said not accepting evidence. We Muslims don't just believe we say we accept beliefs base on evidence. Everyone knows the flaws in evolution theory n reincarnation etc. yet millions believe in it.

[@f.h.5840]

@Sir Christofer Braxton Islam is not new. If you read the Quran prophet Muhammad is the seal of prophet hood from the time of Adam. We accept all the previous prophets n make no distinction between them. Islam is the only other religion to confirm Jesus to be the Messiah.

[@f.h.5840]

@Sir Christofer Braxton humanity didn't exist before Adam did it? So God sent messengers throughout the ages with 1 message,to worship God alone. N different laws for the time, like for the Children of Israel the mosaic laws to Muhammad the final testament n law.

[@f.h.5840]

@Sir Christofer Braxton It's called Abrahamic religion bcos of the lineage Ishmail n Isaac. But wasn't what Abraham followed the first? He was neither a Jew, nor a Christian. So as you well know the scripture followed by Jew n Christians have got many errors n contradictions as attested by these faith own scholars. Islam n the Quran confirms what is correct in these scriptures n rejects what hs been falsified. It's the criterion!

[@f.h.5840]

@Sir Christofer Braxton lol alrighty then. We in the information age. Research the scriptures, what they say. Make n informed decision. The only way to be a Jew n Christian at the same time, is to be a Muslim. May God guide you n I. Thanks for the chat.

[@pessimistkai5569]

"I am a good person. " "I don't know that person, maybe is good or bad" 🤔

[@Ismail-Yahya]

She needs to take a deep breath and let the conversations play out; think about the argument rather than get frustrated. The doctors arguments are not a personal attack on you; subconsciously you are coming from a place of arrogance, thinking you know it all; have all the answers and your world view is perfect; without flaws. When challenged on things you hold to be accurate or true, you get emotionally triggered, frustration kicks in and the ability to be rational goes south. You don't want to accept that there is a higher possibility you could be wrong. What would that mean, shaytaan let's the fear kick in... eternal punishment, I'm not that bad! Am I? Based on morality from where? From who? You are committing a crime by not acknowledging the One who gave you life, the Author of All Existence, Allah. If you had a child who grew up calling someone else Mummy would you be okay with that? Even though for arguments sake you make an allowance; is it right? Is it just and politically correct? Is it the Truth with a capital T! The answer is No, it's not. What then if you created the Existence itself, should it not be run in accordance with your rules? Your law's? If Steve Jobs created an iPhone that didn't do what he programmed it to, do you know what would happen to that phone? Or any consecutive phone after? It would be in the bin sister! You see human's subconciously understand the concept of submission, we have devices created by humankind all around us that are in 'submission' to 'us'; why then are the rules changed when it comes to our Creator? Double standards! We choose to not accept a simple principle. If you make something you own it; you have the right to do what you want. To find the truth you have to be objective; objective to everything you know, let's the facts and arguments in front of you speak for themselves; don't let it become a me vs you thing where you just say things for the fact of saying them, becoming defensive, without really giving much thought. Some words of advice. On the search for God you have to approach your research with complete sincerity and humbleness. You see Muslims (people who recognise there is a Creator, and are living life in 'submission', 'accordance' with His Law's and Guidance, we love this Creator of ours with all our hearts; the fact he brought us into existence; gave us a life with so many beautiful experiences, good or bad; gave us the ability to know Him through seeing His amazing creation, God told us to be patient and eventually we will return, reunite with Him in Jannah, where He is happy with us and us with Him this gives us so much peace in our hearts. We long for that day; the day we see Allah. May Allah SWT forgive us all our shortcomings and sins and make us from amongst those who get to see Him. Ameen. You will need to be patient along the way, to really see what your sister has found. May Allah swt guide her through her sister.

[@KnowledgeBoutique]

Ignorance is frustrating for them to cope with.

[@reptilespit4433]

When everything is about you, me me me me me and grow up with that, it's hard to shake that off in one conversation. Congnitive dissonance is the first thing that hits ya.

[@monkearmy2439]

@@reptilespit4433 id agree

[@nobodyisborngayislam]

@@KnowledgeBoutique yeah quiet hard to understand for some people that darwinian evolution is a religion

[@Edward-bm7vw]

If you want to look for the truth, you will not find it in religion.

[@londonsbr]

I hope she comes back to these videos and is able to really reflect more on what she and the brothers were saying because there was also so much going on. May Allah continue to guide her.

[@Xtl961]

That woman is utterly confused. She is also a deceptive liar. No transitional species has ever been found , big problem

[@placebo2682]

I would love for this sister to return to the park and have that conversation !

[@esrefcelebi]

I am amazed by the speed she proceeds a given information, and losing her patience to hear the rest of the talk as she gets the message and immediately jumps another point. It is a privilege to discuss with such people, as it is a quite rare talent. Wholeheartedly I wish for her, she finds the straight path.

[@Soyodi]

This level of scepticism is gonna lead to an endless rabbit hole.

[@NayimKay]

And potentially jahannam

[@DrAdamAckerman]

She couldn't care less about any of the answers. You can see it in her demeanour

[@hadiyatali193]

She's defiant to the end.May Allah grant her a sign which she cannot turn away from.

[@spiritzen]

Doesn't matter what you study or how intelligent you think you are, you can struggle with basic logic and reasoning, as demonstrated by this young lady. May Allah guide her.

[@victhegamer9918]

Says the person who believe in a invisible person in the sky and has a big book that say that our solar system is geocentric. That the sun sets in a pool of mud. Believes in unicorns.etc etc

[@spiritzen]

@@victhegamer9918 Says the person who hasn't even done the basic homework on their claims from Islamophobic clap-trap websites. Seriously, do some basic googling and you may just learn something. PS. We don't believe in an invisible 'person in the sky'. Back to school for you.

[@victhegamer9918]

@@spiritzen great you refuted my worse point that i wrote to match yours, what about what i claim to be in the quoran. I can give you verses if you want😘😘. And what about my comment was islamophobic? Btw just because you use words to make me quiet doesnt mean im wrong. Mr logic man please use the logic you claim to have

[@spiritzen]

@@victhegamer9918 I won't bother with someone who is intellectually lazy - as you've proven a couple times with your messages - as I said Google is your friend and you'll find tons of Muslim responses to your so-called claims. Should I waste my time educating someone who is already hell-bent (pun intended) on trying to debunk believers, when they clearly haven't even made the simplest effort to see if what they have read somewhere is factually true or not? Your very questions are clearly indicative of someone who is a troll and has little value in learning or being intellectually honest.

[@spiritzen]

@@victhegamer9918 I didn't say you were Islamophobic, read again.

[@adamS993]

It appears she has good intentions, but man is she painfully slow and counter-intuitive. May Allah guide her, and reward Dr. Imran for his patience and good manners

[@alyarrf]

This sister seems upset about why her sister coverted to Islam, that is why she is jumping to various points and not going with the flow of the discussion.

[@thairinkhudr4259]

Dear brothers, same as the previous video, the closing bit doesn't have any audio. Thank you.

[@TheRockeyAllen]

Hey sis, if you're reading this, I'd urge you to read the Qur'an with an open heart. As long as you are sincere with your heart, I promise it'll change your life.

[@adamtom9661]

📗📕📗Ur Quran is full of contradictions, discrepancies, discriminations, racism, lies, hatreds, curses, abrogations, suppressions, oppressions, fears, subjugations, cruelities, extortions(Jizya) jihad, terrorism, crimes against non-muslims n kaffirs. Muslim heaven is already fixed by Allah n his Angel's before the child is born. Thus stay from Islam for the Good n Peace in Humanity.

[@02logan]

This girl shoots another question even before her previous one is answered and when he goes off the new tangent she herself made, she says he hasn’t answered her earlier questions. She’s either doing it on purpose or is internally jumbled up in her mind.

[@StrictlyGermans]

Im live how Dr Imran is and how he approaches these conversations. May Allah bless him.

[@salonpas9006]

She always answer vaguely because she's afraid her answer will put her in a certain direction. Just answer honestly, sister, if you really are trying to learn.

[@mdforkan7312]

A good way to understand the “I believe in Christianity but I am a good person… why should ai go to hell”. Let’s say your in school and on your exams you added 1+1 and you got 3. The correct answer is 2 but you might say “I tried my best…” you still got it wrong. Ok let’s say the teacher lets that slide and this time she says to you “1+1=2” but you still decide to write 1+1=3. You will definitely get penalized for that as she has told you the answer. At the end of the day it’s not about what you believe is right or good. Everyone has different morals but there is one true morality. Yes you write 1+1 is 3 with good intentions but that doesn’t negate the fact that 1+1=2.

[@lordlatimer6672]

21:58 Her sister converted and was pushed away from the family. She wants her sister back, to re join the church and return to her family, cos she misses her which is why she asked 'can I be good and go to church instead?' Her flippant requests for evidence at the end was something she take back to her sister and say 'is this what you belive in?' 21:58 her face pulling showed that she's already made up her mind how she sees her own sisters mindset.

[@4i4ui4i4u4]

جزاكم الله خيرا

[@tengkuazlan8720]

Allahuakhbar...May Allah swt protect him and his family. Aamiin. With rgrd to d lady, she first seems genuine in asking abt Islam, but soon became insincere and arrogance when the good Dr Imran was explaining and giving examples for her to understand. Like any other insincere christians always ready to ask d next questions without letting Dr Imran finish his explanation to d previous questions.

[@freeman7983]

may ALLAH bless you brothers

[@nazhir4156]

She come and tried to talk about islam with muslims. Respect her for that, hope she come back.

[@javed2547]

I’ve met women like this before, exude arrogance, ignorance and above all when they speak it shows their lack of knowledge.

[@mustafapk1516]

10:00 "i didnt say that" she did say that originally, just watch the other video, ig she wasnt present at all in the convo.

[@jordanm169]

If anyone asks for evidence and are in a rush…hand them a Quran 📖 and say ‘here you go’ :-)

[@amirmxd]

Jordan you’re a legend

[@thedude0000]

but it's not evidence. it's simply a 7th century book. demonstrate a god exist first...

[@Toronado2]

​ @The Dude God is already evident. It's up to you to recognize and accept what your mind already sees.

[@thedude0000]

@@Toronado2 _God is already evident_ Again, this is an assertion by you without any evidence. In fact, Christians, Buddhist, Hinduist, etc... *all say the same thing* yet you don't believe them....

[@Toronado2]

​ @The Dude You are not thinking critically. It's not they I don't believe them. I Don't believe in their Version of God. Otherwise everyone BELIEVES in a God. You also do. It's just that YOU have not paid attention to what you actually believe, just like you didn't know the difference between Muslims who Believe in A God versus those who believe in other Gods.

[@danoganoxx]

Such arrogance in her face, I’m starting to know what Allah (swt) means he has closed some people hearts😢

[@lasreedlee1750]

Her stubbornness is unreal😮‍💨

[@commandinggood1017]

*Arrogance actually. ● (Arrogance) like what made the cursed satan Kafir. ● What are the humanity standards for right and wrong(morality) ? Answer: me! you! everyone!! Lets all do(worship) whatever we like, and lets agree together that we all MUST go to Paradise?!!🤦🏻‍♂️🤯🎭🎭 ● Arrogance is a disaster for body & soul...😷🤢🤮🤮 》That's why: ● No arrogant will enter Paradise. May Allah keep us far far away from such repulsive trait🤮🤮..🤲🏼

[@travelwalkstv]

Salaam bothers at EF Dawah. I really enjoyed this conversation. I was wondering, the sister you were talking to, did she get back to you after you gave her the email? Very interested to know what the outcome is? Did she contact you, is she convinced etc? Inshallah

[@alcarbone7305]

In this day and age people still talking about evolution. Darwin's theory of evolution is and remains a theory. People should do some research on the word "Theory". The da'ee is right mutation and evolution are not the same.

[@shoaibakramchaudhary]

This ain’t fair brothers, why do we have to wait so long for this video??

[@Saif_theFox]

Tells her you cant judge Islam based solely on Muslims. She proceeds to ask a random Muslim… I dont understand what she meant by logically understanding if her action was so illogical Im surprised she even did it

[@Rico-Suave_]

Many people who convert to Islam or revert back to Christianity is because religious organizations provide a sense of community, comradely, fellowship and a sense of belonging. These powerful emotional needs are fulfilled, even if religions are not historically and scientifically accurate or just myths. "ignorance is a bliss" Matrix-quote. originally from Karachi Pakistan and Teer Haripur Hazaara, now ex-Muslim Atheist .,,

[@shadowrealmgamer4147]

Oh dear me!

[@moonmounie2447]

She is trying to refute every example he put forward

[@lockedin6699]

Shaitan working overtime lol

[@Dr.NahBro]

It seemed like she really had a hard time understanding anything said by Dr. Imran. It was almost frustrating to watch…

[@KNZ95]

"Allah has set a seal upon their hearts and upon their hearing, and over their vision is a veil. And for them is a great punishment."

[@nadabida]

She is just playing a game... She know wrong and right but she just said "i don't know"🙄 she is arrogance.. She does not want to accept

[@umfatima2810]

So true SubhanaAllah and it makes me sad how innocent they play to be. May Allah guide us all Aameen 🤲🏾 💚

[@roccoroselli3957]

She wasn't comprehending most of what was being said.

[@mohammedirfan9507]

Be patient and answering its a beautiful things to see us

[@moorefyre9381]

Its sad that ppl really believe and would accept they evolved from some animal. They prefer that which is a theory over believing man was created as we are today.

[@hemisphere903]

What happened to last nights dawah clinic stream it seems to have disappeared

[@muslimspeakmy]

She said 'you gave in...', that's submission isn't it. They submitted, they yaslamuuna into Islam. 😂 Alhamdulillah. May allah guide the sincere seekers.

[@oncefenerbahcesonravatan4286]

I love you man…. Very knowledgeable, speak very clearly with good English../ live from NYC….

[@miruu28]

She's going in circles

[@IIAdnan93II]

If you are reading this sister please please please refer to the sources. Masha'Allah the brother consistently advised you to refer to the Quran and the Sunnah. May Allah swt guide you sister. What has happened in your past does not have to determine your future. Allah swt is the most merciful, the most giving, the most forgiving, the most loving.

[@HessaHotness]

I didn’t like how she was jumping to different questions before giving the man to finish his thought. However I think maybe this is just her one step to get closer to Islam. I could see how ready to attack the answers but hopefully one day she could listen clearly with an open mind and heart. Without any prejudice and prejudgments of Islam.

[@homtanks7259]

JazakAllahu khairan

[@clearthings9282]

May allah guide that girl 🤲🤲🤲🤲

[@ChaosAlpha]

Allah-u-akbar

[@damascusyt6426]

May Allah save us from the arrogance and insincerity of people like this lady.

[@AliBot-q6x]

Asalam o alikum I watched the video and listened to it. In fact, Imran's response to Islam's position on homosexuality was not successful. Rather, I felt that he detracted from this disobedience, which is a major sin and for which God did not punish a people more severely than the perpetrators of it, and they are the people of Lot. Even the woman was shocked by this response. And when you mentioned that a person sometimes is not able to control his actions or control himself, this is not a justification for him to continue to do the sin, but rather openly, for God Almighty forgives the sinners if they repent except the openly. I also mentioned that he must seek forgiveness only, and this is not true. The one who commits a major sin has to repent and its well-known conditions are that he regrets his act and hates this sin and resolves not to return to it at all and leaves it for God’s sake and for fear of Him and not to speak out. to its owners. Flattering the infidels in such matters in order to attract them to Islam is a grave mistake. It is necessary to be clear in these matters and to present the correct position of Islam. Just as we are not complimenting in the belief of Islam, we are not complimenting in its laws either, otherwise we present a wrong image of Islam. (ودوا لو تدهن فيدهنون) (They wish you would compromise so they would yield ˹to you˺.) We ask Allah for us and you guidance, help and payment. I hope the owner of the channel conveys my comment to the brothers Imran and Abbas..

[@OmgGamingFTWlolz]

I believe he was making the point that committing a sin other than shirk does not take you outside the fold of Islam unless you were to also state that the sin is ok for you to commit.

[@ElKoubi1975]

I think that she is trying hard to convince herself that her sister has made the wrong decision, so she was trying hard, not to get answers, but to do all she could to corner the brother. Allah is capable of opening her heart. All we can do is to make du3aas.. May Allah open her heart to Islam.

[@mas12]

Imran has the best approach and his tone of voice is stunning

[@serendipitous9584]

They want God to appear physically infront of them so they could believe, and then they say we believe in reasoning , Intellect and logic . If you need to see God in order to believe in Him, Then there was no need to have the human intellect ,rationale, moral sense, distiction between right and wrong, creativity , sense of beauty and Art etc etc. There was no need and reason for the human existence.Just Animals would suffice who dont have these higher functions.

[@zainquadri1206]

@7:30 Speaker : The Quran says you can't be gay... Br. Imran : Where does it say you can't be gay...? Speaker : In the Quran... Br. Imran : No, where in the Quran...? Speaker : I'm sure I can find it... Br. Imran : Nowhere in the Quran does it say that you can't be gay... I have a serious issue with Imran being a Da'ee... This is the second or third time in his videos that he has failed to outright condemn homosexuality... Islam categorically condemns homosexuality...

[@zakiruz]

I think you missed the point he is trying to make.

[@thinkdifferent4314]

Being Gay is having the feeling or being attracted to the same gender, Allah won't punish you for having feelings UNLESS you act up on it, so he was right. Allah was punishing the ACTIONS of the people of Lut (pbuh).

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

(56:57) We have created you,22 then why would you not confirm it? 23 22. The arguments from here to verse 74 provide the reasoning to prove both the doctrines of Tauhid and of Hereafter rationally. For it was there two basic doctrines of the Prophet’s (peace be upon him) teaching that the people of Makkah were debating and objecting to at that time. 23. That is, why don’t you confirm that We alone are your Lord and God and We have the power to create you once again. (56:58) Did you ever consider the sperm that you emit? (56:59) Do you create a child out of it, or are We its creators? 24 24. In this brief sentence a very important question has been put before man. Apart from all other things in the world, if man only considers as to how he himself has come into being, he can then neither have any doubts left about the doctrine of Tauhid presented by the Quran nor about its doctrine of the Hereafter. The process of man’s own creation starts when the male has conveyed his sperm to the womb of the female. But the question is: Has the sperm by itself become endowed with the capability of producing a child, and necessarily a human child? Or, has it been created by man himself, or by someone other than God? And, is it in the power of the man, or of the woman, or of another agency in the world, to cause conception by this sperm? Then, who is responsible for the gradual formation and development of the fetus in the mother’s womb, its shaping and molding into a unique child, the provision in a particular proportion of different mental and physical powers and qualities in each child so that it develops into a unique person, except One God? Does someone, other than God, have any role to play in this? Is it done by the parents themselves? Or, by a doctor? Or, by the prophets or saints, who were themselves created in this very way? Or, by the sun and the moon and the stars, which are themselves subject to a law? Or, by nature, which is devoid of any knowledge, wisdom, will and authority? Then, is it also in the power of someone other than God to decide whether the child is to be a boy or a girl? Whether it is to be beautiful or ugly, strong or weak, blind and deaf and a cripple or sound bodied, intelligent or stupid? Then, is it someone other than God who decides as to people of what caliber, good or bad, are to be created in a particular nation at a particular time, who would cause its rise or fall? If a person is not obdurate and stubborn, he will realize that no rational answer can be given to these questions on the basis of polytheism and atheism. Their rational answer is only one and it is this. Man is wholly and entirely the creation of God; and when the truth is this, what right has this man, the creation of God, to claim freedom and independence as against his Creator, or serve someone else beside Him. As it is for Tauhid, so it is with regard to the Hereafter too. Man is created from a germ which cannot be seen without a powerful microscope. This germ combines in the darkness of the mother’s body with the ovum (female germ) which is like itself an insignificant microscopic germ. Then by their combination a tiny living cell comes into being, which is the starting-point of human life. This cell also is too small to be seen without a microscope. Allah develops this insignificant cell in the mother’s womb for nine months or so into a living human, and when its development and formation becomes complete, the mother’s body itself pushes it out to be raised in the world. All human beings have been born into the world in this very way and are witnessing day and night this phenomenon of the birth of human beings like themselves. After this, only a foolish person could assert that the God Who is creating human beings in this way today would not be able to create the human beings created by Himself in some other way tomorrow.

[@tauseefakram90]

This sister has many questions and assumptions.. I hope she comes back and get her answers and clear her doubts.. I hope and pray that Allah guide her.. :)

[@AdelinaRego-o8e]

Honestly this sister seems very genuine in her pursuit of knowledge, I applaud her effort and curiosity and wish her all the best, may Allah guide her to the truth. I’m confident that with Allah’s will she will be guided to Islam and I pray for that as well. Amiin🤲🏼 Personal thoughts: Its just that she hasnt got a strong foundation of faith, meaning she doesn’t even believe in God yet, so obviously she would reject many islamic beliefs and teachings for now. I mean if she doesn’t believes in a Ruler why would she follow or embrace the rulings. She had multiple different questions which is good but a rather minor issue. Once the foundation and belief in a Creator is established in the first place all those questions and doubts will start falling into place. When faith in God is established you will understand why He did all this (ultimately for the best interests of mankind, afterall we are in constant need of Allah but Allah doesn’t needs us, He remains the highest and Almightiest with or without your worship, in fact if you were smart you would follow His guidance for your own sake in this world and in the hereafter).

[@greenhomestead6305]

What’s the point of this lady talking to Muslims if she already has the answers for everything and not interested in learning anything. Arrogance will definitely land people in jahanam.