Mutinying Russian conscripts surround general and shout 'Shame on you'

RUSSIAN marines have slammed Vladimir Putin for leading them into a "massacre" in a bombshell leaked letter.
It emerged as mutinies erupted across Russia's armed forces - with video footage showing 2,000 conscripts surrounding a general and angrily shouting: "Shame on you."
Read more:
‘PUTINY’ GROWS We’re Putin’s cannon fodder, say Russian marines in letter - as vid shows mutinying troops tell general ‘shame on you’
www.thesun.co.uk/news/2034531...
The Sun newspaper brings you the latest breaking news videos and explainers from the UK and around the world
Become a Sun Subscriber and hit the bell to be the first to know
Read The Sun: www.thesun.co.uk
Like The Sun on Facebook: / thesun
Follow The Sun on Twitter: / thesun
Subscribe to The Sun on Snapchat: / 1633225139
#russia #ukraine

[@timbow614]

This is a prime example of complete leadership failure in an Army.

[@ToreOnYouTube]

Well, none of them wants to be there. Not even the generals.

[@olaniyanmichael640]

No commitment at all.

[@olaniyanmichael640]

No commitment at all.

[@ohmygodpleasehalp3984]

More like complete failure of the entire government

[@khiem1939]

Looks like Putin is just getting what he deserves!

[@Robert66734]

What I learned as a young officer from a older officer is this; soldiers need to respect you if they want to fight and die for you. If they don't, you might as well go home because you have already lost the battle before it even starts.

[@bentup.]

This is an absolute truth statement.

[@edby263]

I read exactly this in an old manual from WW1. It compared weak officers to school teachers that could not get the respect of the kids.

[@ricardoromero3065]

Los soldados alemanes siempre tuvieron esa mística a pesar que el enemigo los superaba en número

[@simonecucchi3303]

for a better world you need a coup d'etat in Russia

[@simonecucchi3303]

In Italy I have many Russian friends who hate Putin

[@gregparrott]

The general was probably never so nervous facing enemies across the battlefield as he was surrounded by his own, conscripted troops.

[@andrewstackpool4911]

He has probably NEVER faced any enemy; he will be an apparatchik for the party.

[@gregparrott]

@@andrewstackpool4911 You could be right. Then again, he could have dropped barrel bombs on Syrian citizens

[@andrewstackpool4911]

@@gregparrott Or most likely stayed warm and cosy while others did. You know. General Melchett and all that.

[@GodWeenSatan]

Not troops citizens

[@elguapodoggy2215]

That was beautiful 👏👏👏👏👏

[@FayeLawnKrack3d]

I literally almost cried when they said "Let's go home guys". My heart 😭

[@lenitaa7938]

They would probably be arrested and serve prison time if they do go home! And likely will be abused and humiliated by the prison officials, guards and FSB there! There is strength in the crowd like this, but later you are alone! That's the reality!

[@javierrodriguezgonzalez3426]

Si así va a ser 😭😭😁🤣🤣🤣

[@andreinarangel6227]

I was an officer a long time ago. Best lesson: DO NOT LIE TO YOUR MEN.

[@user-cx2bk6pm2f]

Russian Army Handbook, rule#1: lie to your men

[@jamieeprato5809]

@@user-cx2bk6pm2f lmao

[@erikswanson5753]

It has been made clearly abundant during this war that Russian officers and the country's leadership have absolutely no respect for their enlisted men. Treating them like idiots and cannon fodder. When was the last time you saw Putin standing in a flak jacket being hugged by his troops? Surrounded by his soldiers? Right. Never.

[@indiasuperclean6969]

WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😠 I WILL NEVER GO TO RUSSIA!! 😠 😠THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗

[@jamesnash6101]

Especially, don't lie to a man with a gun in his hand.

[@Prototheria]

As a vet, I can't even begin to wrap my head around the magnitude of the collapse of their command structure. The vast majority of people in the world have never served, so I'm not sure many are grasping how astoundingly incomprehensible this is to see for someone that's served.

[@slapukaz]

I appreciate your grammar, too.

[@ReneDominique]

Yup . Military brat here .

[@Prototheria]

@@slapukaz Mighty fine of you to say, Friend. Thank you!

[@slapukaz]

Look, ya'll have Army, Navy, Marines, Feds-state-county-city et cetera and no one is being sent in as a newbie for war related stuff. What Putin did, he sent 300k men without training to satisfy his Trumpish egomaniacism.

[@gdutfulkbhh7537]

This is seismic. A 21st century analogue to the Russian battleship Potemkin mutiny.

[@vilo_h5541]

Probably one of the few times those guys will see any officer. I admire their guts.

[@MrDirkhead]

True soldiers go to war for their nation, not for the whims of one person especially when that person is lying to them and the rest of the world. From one ex-soldier in the UK, you have my respect and it is your right to ask why you are going to war and why you might die for the beliefs of one person. Think of your families and surrender this is not a just fight, choose to live and go home to your loved ones. Respect to you all.

[@DECIMATOR69]

Isnt that what americans do tho

[@logangx9319]

@@DECIMATOR69 Isnt it a miserable existence to know that your 15 minutes of fame will never amount beyond spreading Russian propaganda on social media for worthless rubles tho?

[@DECIMATOR69]

@@logangx9319 first of all i am not russian but i am from a country that has seen what americans do in war and how they do it and you cant deny that they arent any better in fact probably worse and second isnt what you are doing right now spreading westerns/nato propaganda?

[@boombyte8849]

Those rotten z-ombies don't care about the war--they just want supply and ammunition.

[@epsilonarcaneresearch1945]

@@DECIMATOR69 "I'm not from Russia" *proceeds to shill for russia* Hope they're not paying you in rubles boris.

[@oceans54321]

as a great man once said: "If not for the defence of the motherland, war is crime"

[@JohnSmith-cy9tt]

Sun Tsu

[@alpkaban1386]

Atatürk

[@Humanaut.]

That's why every nation always claims war to be for self defense, no matter the real reason. Russia does this, the USA does this. Ah wait, the USA calls it "protecting American interests abroad".

[@Zhoshyn]

Also "Don't wait for your potential ennemies to get the high ground."

[@General--Grievous]

He did say for the DEFENSE. Now is there any serious human being in here that things Ukraine would attack Russia>? Pretty much Greece will be the next victim against Turkey. Same scenario

[@doresearchstopwhining]

Finally some drunk Russians the world can be proud of.

[@aslanmonahov6238]

I would be proud of them if they, wouldn't let themselves be drafted. Nobody still was jailed for refusing to be mobilized. They protest only because they didn't get their money, not because they will kill Ukrainians

[@eliotcole663]

They are protesting because they are not well equipped and payed to kill Ukrainians in Ukraine. Not because they don’t want to fight in the senseless war.

[@davidsocha8642]

Russian General at a warm place, soldier suffering / Putin at warm place, population eating grotesque propaganda whit the conséquences 🤔 🤔

[@ironmaiden2772]

@@aslanmonahov6238 this is very sad, but true.

[@M4rk58]

@@aslanmonahov6238 Those who are jailed are still drafted, its a lose lose

[@TheSubpremeState]

This could be a significant moment in world history

[@boombyte8849]

No.

[@ethon3733]

@@boombyte8849 yes.

[@bateli9733]

We can only hope!

[@hitrapperandartistdababy]

This seems completely unprecedented… I have never served but I’m curious if any of you who have have ever experienced anything like this? A large group of conscripts cussing down a g e n e r a l making him seem so small and timid… never heard of such a thing in any modern army

[@wesleywilliams6753]

Hi, Marine for five magical years. To answer your question, at least from my experience in the American military, no definitely never even heard of a break down of command this intense. infact, I've never heard of a lower ranking guy saying any sort of expletive to a general. I am curious to ask the vietnam veterans though, but I've never heard of it in the modern military which is what makes this so insane.

[@erichoughton4128]

Respect to these conscripts their bravery can not be understated

[@indiasuperclean6969]

WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😠 I WILL NEVER GO TO RUSSIA!! 😠 😠THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗

[@Serg_Bro]

They are not protesting against the war, they are protesting against the fact that they have created uncomfortable conditions for the preparation of the murder of Ukrainians! Do you respect it?

[@sootikins]

@@HelloHello-ho8mh Bot or not, that channel has some pretty funny India videos that show the exact opposite of what INDIA SUPER CLEAN's post claims.

[@biglebowski5737]

@@indiasuperclean6969 Not even Columbus liked India. He stopped in the Americas!

[@greatsarmatae]

Iran people show bravery. These however just miserable slaves with chaotic complain, not minding to fight generally. Westerns have to stop believe in primitive illusions about Ruz.

[@Boccaccio-ii1fl]

This people are right, they have to endure the heavy of the fight in cold, with no weapons, no ammunitions, no clothes, no food or drink while their generals and commanders stay far from the fight in warm places and enjoy the life !

[@nicholaiginovaef4861]

in soviet russia, soldiers tell general what to do..- yakov smirnoff

[@SparrowwithaMachinegun]

"Let's go home" I never heard such a terrifying warcry.

[@tammyleung7578]

If every soldier decides to just go home, the world will be a much better place.

[@jacobp.2024]

@@tammyleung7578 "Let's go home" is indeed the scariest warcry a disconnected general or warhawk politician can hear. It means they didn't inject enough brain rot to get them ready to impale themselves against the enemy.

[@spacegerrit9499]

"Show me your warface!" *steps into Lada and drives home*

[@sadjaxx]

They all have family at home and can't trust that their pay is getting to them. Hell that one place thought it was a big deal that families would get fish and flour. Holy Crap! You gonna die for that?!

[@lenitaa7938]

@@tammyleung7578 Only in some Utopian country! Every country needs military defence!!

[@ezequielstepanenko3229]

That's how my country began to recover it's democracy after seven years of military dictatorship, when the conscripted stood up to the generals that were sending them to a useless war

[@mclark2330]

Breakdown in leadership pure and simple. This is worst case scenario for any military let alone a so called super power. Thanks to social media for allowing us to see this implosion happen.. 😳

[@apsmith1635]

I fully understand their protest. Finally they seem to understand what they are being sent to and that they are only bodies to the regime !

[@ClickClack_Bam]

It's ONLY 80,000 dead Russians later.

[@naronlost1048]

👍🏻

[@Drak_Thedp]

Well. Yes and no. They've realized how they are being treated, and that they are many. The general seems to had called them "dirty as pigs" before, while not giving them proper equipment, facilities to wash themselves and their clothes, outlets for anything in the encampment. The thing is, nothing is ready for this amount of troops. And I'm not trying to somehow whitewash all this war but the commanders should had seen this draft coming for several months, yet they didn't even bother to make simple accomodations for their troops. So they're basically trying to tell the draftees that they're expendable and not even worth humane treatment. It's all rotten.

[@PatriciaSantos-qt9lw]

Yeah.., but no. Rather some runaZZorcs only protesting because they didn't get their money(!), not because they will kiII Ukrainians! ruSSia is such a SSupper-power 😱

[@FlyingBodyParts]

Maybe some. Others mostly unhappy about the lack of promised payment.

[@JTMaster]

An absolute collapse of respect for the military command and the orders they are being given. I keep hearing too often of mass amounts of troops who are literally abandoned by their commanders on the frontlines to die. A recent large group of mobilized conscripts got largely wiped out, estimated 440 out of 570 died, and the survivors said their commanders completely abandoned them as soon as they started to die in large numbers. Absolutely deplorable. Any commander who abandons their men to die needlessly like that deserves to swing.

[@brahmburgers]

When the French fought their last battle in VN (just before the Yanks unwittingly took over), the French commanding officer was a long distance away. The VC had parked their big guns in the hillside brush surrounding the French position - which was down in a valley. You can guess which side got creamed.

[@stormywindmill]

@@brahmburgers ---Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't the same thing happen at Kah San, also directed by Vietnamese Genera Giap?

[@memorystyles5006]

@@stormywindmill What the hell does that have to do with the Ukraine war? Why even mention something that’s not relevant. Also do you think that this condones that sort of behaviour just because of what’s happened in the past? 2 wrongs don’t make a right. So wash your dirty mouth out before I do it for you

[@memorystyles5006]

@@brahmburgers What the hell does this have to do with the Ukraine war? You need to see a doctor asap

[@thegodfather_8455]

@@memorystyles5006 it highlights the same topic, command issues and incompetence

[@maireadmaccy4336]

When eyes are opened the mind awakes.🔥💪🔥💙💛

[@samiam9008]

having served can you imagine speaking to a General like that.

[@thefpvlife7785]

Don't die for Putin.

[@moniquenelson5142]

Die for NATO then choose

[@200130769]

Don't die for the terrorist USA either

[@wilo1463]

YER YOUR RIGHT KEEP AWAY FROM UKRAINE. DONT GO TO UKRAINE

[@trifulquita15]

But dying for NATO is okay

[@Perseus7567]

@@trifulquita15 Good thing no one is dying for NATO in this war then.

[@bollewillem1]

In Roman history the idea was raised to cloth slaves in uniforms, so it was clear for everybody in the streets who was a slave and who was not. But than the Roman rulers realised that the slaves also might realise how many slaves there are. That they are a big group who, if the joined forces, were a group to recon with. So the plan to dress the slaves in uniforms was cancelled. This video reminded me of this story.

[@nana-uj2yz]

This is probably the most intelligent comment there will ever be in the youtube comments on a Sun video

[@vashimy7158]

@@nana-uj2yz You guys should get married 😍

[@Silverfirefly1]

All three of you are correct.

[@MrElis420]

@@nana-uj2yz LMFAO I agree

[@TalibanAtrocities]

@@nana-uj2yz okay if that's the most intelligent comment... What's the most intelligent question... Could it be... Should the sun upload page 3 videos? 🤔

[@awkwardllama0509]

I wouldn't be shocked if that commander doesn't make it back home.

[@olzyolzmobile]

It's like at the front in the good old days in 1917!

[@johnnysilverhand6045]

Hahaha that general getting chewed out by grunts!? I love it.

[@axis1662]

I was surprised they didn't beat him

[@TalibanAtrocities]

Squeaky bum time

[@DaaronIrwing]

He isnt a general. He just a corruptor in the army.

[@ZetarFox]

@@axis1662 Well that's allot of man to talk back to,they will beat him to death.U can see it on his face,fear of his life.

[@indiasuperclean6969]

WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😠 I WILL NEVER GO TO RUSSIA!! 😠 😠THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗

[@arnaudekko]

Bravo👍

[@a.g.4843]

This is incredible….wow

[@kristiankajhoj]

It warms my heart to see these actions take place within the Russian army.

[@skankhunt420]

Well, they seem to have no problem to go and kill innocent people, if they're were properly equipped and paid at all.

[@kristiankajhoj]

@@skankhunt420 They are soldiers of a totalitarian regime. You cannot blame their naivety; many of them knew nothing else before coming to Ukraine facing their neighbours on the front line. These conscripts are there against their will most of the time. You need to turn your anger towards the leadership; the generals and Putin.

[@graphite282]

How long before these conscripts turn their guns on their commanding officers? In a field, no one will know who shot whom and for what.

[@kristiankajhoj]

@@graphite282 Let us hope it comes to this. That would be poetic justice and although they would face procecution from Russia, they would probably be regarded as heroes in the west.

[@TotSamiyyy]

​@@kristiankajhoj this is a very naive discussion, if you knew a little more about Russia, you would not write this, most of them there voluntarily came to, and they are not against the killing of Ukrainians, they only complain that they are poorly provided and used as meat, plugging holes in front.

[@dustinadkins5804]

A scene straight out of Dr. Zhivago 105 years later.

[@dmgeo]

That is some respectable attitude from the Russian soldiers. Only Russian people can put an end to this madness

[@angel77503]

You are a clown you live in your own fantasy

[@venciarsov4678]

PUTIN KAPUT 1000%%

[@user-hl2ok5vq1m]

This is Kazan, they are Tatars mostly. Russians are much more obedient.

[@rebellion-starwars]

Maybe it's a other way around? Do you ever question your own government? Or it's just easier to blame the other side, that's just easier to do. I'm following both sides, following journalists, especially independent from West. No one questioned why people at the Donbas was shelled for 8 years? Answer me why at the February 24th was so many foreign military in the Ukraine? Did you learned in school what happened in Cuba? Do you know that the NATO was formed as an answer to the Warsaw pact, Warsaw pact seized to exist '89 but NATO was expanding and expanding even though there was a deal not to expand. Do you know that the US have the law that no country in the North America cannot be part of any alliance except for the NATO? 2008 nato publicly said that the plan is to bring in Ukraine and Georgia? Did you know that 2014 legally elected president was illegally impeached with the help of the foreign agencies? Russia said you can join the EU, just give full autonomy to the DNR, LNR and don't join the NATO. This is classic proxy war. Find the list of the wars that US was involved after the WWII and do you know that people killed in those conflicts are higher than allied losses in the WWII? Soooo leave the propaganda at the side and try to know the real truth. Sure Putin is not good, but western leaders are way worse. And I'm not picking the sides here, my side is peace but for peace you need all sides to agree to. Don't forget that. Ukr is saying unreasonable things, they are asking for Russian to let go all the regions and then they will talk about the peace, that means - no talks. Did you know that Putin launched preemptive strike? 7 days was needed for Ukraine to attack DNR and LNR, the plan was to do ethnic cleansing and they stopped that, that's why there was so many troops during the beginning. Are you aware of everything that I said now? Just please be realistic and do proper research, please! We need normal voices on both sides if we want to see the peace talks. Peace is n1 priority! But military industrial complex is massively profiting from this, every army that sent old weapons will buy new, who's profiting? Turn on your brain please mate

[@msairshot7097]

@@rebellion-starwars Я как Русский соглашусь с вашими словами . нас всех толкают на эту войну ради политики и денег ! не кто не хочет умирать на этой войне, но и свою страну мы не дадим разбить на куски ... будем большая бойня .

[@Eza_yuta]

This is what people will do when you go to fight for someone you don't like againts someone you don't hate.

[@boombyte8849]

Those rotten z-ombies don't care about the war--they just want supply and ammunition.

[@ohidontknow25]

Stopping people revolting through fear, but then sending them to face something they fear more must make a revolution somewhat likely.

[@RachelHarris-jk1cm]

Now Russian comrades take that fight all the way to the Kremlin, Go and overthrow your insane leader. Only then will the world respect you!

[@lobsters12111]

I agree. Once they’ve been backed into a corner the only way out is through whoever has them trapped.

[@indiasuperclean6969]

WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😠 I WILL NEVER GO TO RUSSIA!! 😠 😠THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗

[@ohidontknow25]

@@indiasuperclean6969 Yeah. Just a shame India doesn't have lower case letters yet 🤣

[@TactfulWaggle]

@@ohidontknow25 LMFAO

[@samimurtomaki5534]

That's the spirit!

[@iraimacuencaromero7454]

Regresen a casa , salven sus vidas , jovenes soldados.

[@steeltalon2317]

33 years in the Army and 3 wars later, I've NEVER seen anything close to this behavior. The Russian Army is truly, and I don't mean just this brigade, on the verge of collapse in the Ukraine. As soon as these men are issued weapons, this general will be a walking dead man. In fact, as you can see, he is surrounded by body guards because the situation is so peerless for the officer corps of this unit.

[@aslysa2277]

Fragging is what I also had in mind

[@sjonnieplayfull5859]

I hope the Ukrainians have enough weapons to arm these troops: they are VERY likely to join the Ukrainians first chance they get

[@luxborealis]

Eh, doubt the general himself is going to be in much danger as long as they wait to issue the guns until these guys are on the front. From what we’ve been able to geolocate from pictures of Russian command positions they are all placed well outside missile range (so 35 clicks plus) from the front line. For example the disgraced General Lapin who was rumored to have pulled his gun on soldiers refusing to stop their retreat, had his command post for Kherson city located in the Olezhniy Sands nature reserve far away across the Dnieper river from the city and fighting.

[@steeltalon2317]

@@luxborealis Over 100 colonels and 13 generals have been killed from the Russian Army so far this war. And you think he has a good chance of survival?

[@busterbiloxi3833]

You mean "perilous".

[@zacharystotz2350]

If I were Putin and the people in charge of Russia right now, I would be nervous. Soldiers that are not happy turn out to be the same ones leading a revolution that overthrows a government. With military supplies dwindling, they are only getting weaker with a smaller inventory of arms to defend themselves with.

[@obey112el]

Dude as long as they are leader, they will tend to silence as much people as they can

[@ghsty301]

@@obey112el with what army

[@vitmast5262]

Russia is a Biblical Country this is why western transgenders are so afraid of ITS church and family values

[@fununlimited7791]

You’re not Putin , that man has balls to face the world and you are just sitting in your rented flat

[@cikiface13]

@@fununlimited7791 I still can kill any of these mfs without being noticed lol.

[@4jqxc]

Yeah that's not what they're saying. The Russian soldiers are calling the commander a word that rhymes with maggot but starts with a F lol

[@tommyjoemusic486]

BRAVO TO THESE MEN!!! STAND UP FOR WHAT IS RIGHT!!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@elguapodoggy2215]

Exactly, the general is comfortable sitting in a warm place, drinking vodka and eating delicious food, meanwhile poor soldiers are dying 😢

[@drc8i080i8]

Russian and Iranian people have had enough of the dictators. People rising up is the best chance for change 🤘

[@SamKucherov]

Say that to the American people that have had enough of the Biden regime and what it’s doing to the economy. Let’s all stand up and take the president out of his place to show Russia and Iran how it’s done.

[@PatriciaSantos-qt9lw]

same ruSSian & Iranian taIibans same

[@lentar]

@@SamKucherov stupid bot

[@Mr.Wonderfui]

@@PatriciaSantos-qt9lw Что? Что вы несёте?)

[@Eagle0watch7dv]

@@SamKucherov Stand up to what? We comfortable. We sitting here getting fat watching the Ukrainians kick Russia's ass all day everyday on youtube. Nobody killing us and forcing us to fight an illegal war. By the way if a little small country like Ukraine is kicking your ass what do think is going to happen if USA jump in. USA would destroy every Russian in Ukraine in 3 days. If NUKES didn't exist USA would take over all of Russia in less than a month.

[@mohamadsudani3689]

I feel sorry and sad for the russians unwilling to fight for an unjust cause, I applause their bravery and hope they can make out alive to a safe place away from combat

[@bafattvahetere]

This army is not safe as putler now gave order to shut own soldiers who don't fight. What a miserable country russia is today!

[@banana03]

Just surrender to the Ukraine and then will save their lives very sad for these young men they wanted to fight.

[@boombyte8849]

Those rotten z-ombies don't care about the war--they just want supply and ammunition.

[@bailey_the_choco3289]

Well said 👌

[@Unknown-bt5rd]

@@bafattvahetere Bro this is army, if you not willing to fight, you get punished, and this rule exists in every army I guess

[@BREEZE-ROADS]

That dude's gonna wake up in a body bag 😬

[@rebelliousfew]

A lot of people need to understand that they are not protesting about the war, they are protesting about the harsh conditions they are put In. If they were put In better conditions all around, they most likely would be willing to fight.

[@agatamisiun7180]

100% truth

[@MrJMHP]

But war is harsh everywere in this world physically and mentally. What could anyone expect better conditions from this stupid war?!. Winter is just around the corner...

[@isaiasabreu2339]

You Will them protesting soon for that too.

[@mg1984]

Not sure. Some of them would but not all, far from that. Why would they risk their life when their homeland's peace and security is unchallenged ? Didn't you hear that shout : down with putin's regime ? It was loud and clear. The situation in Ukraine can be summarised : a steely will to fight on one side, no will to fight on the other side.

[@stephenoneill245]

At the end of WWI, when defeat seemed inevitable and the country was in tatters, the German navy revolted against a senseless, suicide attack against the allied blockade that started a chain reaction on the streets and tired armed forces that eventually led to Kaiser Wilhelm fleeing the country to Holland and the armistice. This looks vaguely similar. Hope it snowballs.

[@detroxx56784]

@watch my videos Yeah well, WW1 was just a stupid d*ck measurement contest between cousins and not a war "of the people". WW2 was different since many people were angry (and emotionally manipulated) due to the treaty of Versailles. Hitler and his men knew very well how important the emotional side of things was and used propaganda very effectively. Since the war in Ukraine is also a war which most of the Russian people don't emotionally support, I'd say they will face a mass mutiny and or revolution eventually.

[@oeokosko]

Mutinies amongst the British, French and of course Russian soldiers in WWI, probably also amongst the other nations involved.

[@richardrose9943]

Lmao Putin will flee to Iran or North Korea

[@dekippiesip]

But what if it's a suicide attack that can actually make some significant progress. Like commanding your men to go in bomb boats and destroy an important choke point? It's not senseless from a strategic perspective, but you do order men on a mission where their death is 100% assured.

[@erikswanson5753]

It got a little confusing when it suddenly switched to something else. But, this is amazing. Incredible footage. Like something straight out of 1917. I can attest that what the conscripts were saying did indeed match the subtitles. Shouting "pozor" (shame) at the general.

[@sjonnieplayfull5859]

The tone and volume of their words was quite clear. Now all that is needed is ONE guy that can speak for all, earn their respect, and get them moving, and Putin can forget about his winter palace

[@nikiTricoteuse]

Thank you.

[@joancampbell1377]

Well done to all the conscripts it's time to take control and rid the world of Putin and his idiot generals wonderful thing to see hope they all make it home safely GOOD LUCK

[@JosannaMonik]

Now that is courage!

[@chaosXP3RT]

"It is only those who have neither fired a shot nor heard the shrieks and groans of the wounded who cry aloud for blood, more vengeance, more desolation. War is hell." -General William T. Sherman

[@0x777]

No. Hell is hell and war is war, but war is worse than hell. There are no innocents in hell. There are, though, mostly innocents in a war.

[@emwhaibee]

It is the only way. Violence is the only language these corrupt so-called leadersnthat have grown too big for their breeches.

[@Nedbryten]

"It's good that war is so terrible, otherwise we would grow too fond of it."

[@AmericanGirl6128]

American Girl Cries for Peace!!!

[@orchidorio]

Makes me think of the use of cannons shooting 12 lb. metal balls that tore through opposing troops. Pretty grizzly. 11722

[@kaneroblox211kane8]

Respect to the people of Ukraine. Stay strong Ukraine..👍 Greetings from Australia.

[@veronikapolischuk6363]

Thank you!💙💛

[@mozambique9113]

ukraine and russia are not real. theres only soviet union

[@gazpachopolice7211]

@@mozambique9113 there's no Mozambique. There's only the Portuguese Empire

[@roozdelasierra4515]

@@mozambique9113 oh man you are a time traveler...xd

[@tenidaska9984]

lol Australia? trash country anyway

[@alexbeer4705]

Our troops being shelled in the end. He said let’s go back let’s run away.

[@sugar2th173]

Well this is some hope in a very dark time 🙏🏼

[@user-cs5fq7kl1w]

明るい未来に、今改革、自分たちで。

[@frankb5603]

They only want their pay. Don't be fooled. Russians are Russians.

[@anchoranchor3495]

There is no hope, they were protesting for no being paid.

[@thedecafe1]

Same here too.

[@sugar2th173]

@@anchoranchor3495 good. Let them not be paid

[@marisabenson1222]

Well done to these men who have human spirit and show that they are not sheep and that when people communities act together much can be accomplished. The truth is in our humanity and our ability to see the humanity in others.

[@aw-resistance9968]

They were protesting not getting paid, that's all.

[@teaboy9614]

lol they do it just cause it's their skin that is in danger. If they had a good gear and stuff, they woudn't have any issues killing people

[@basedglennuk]

What drivel? 🙄

[@rogerpennel1798]

Putin's mobilization is his Kerensky Offensive and like the Kerensky Offensive in WWI, its results will be the same. The diseased, starved, untrained, under-equipped, demoralized, and poorly led men mutinied in the field, they turned around marched on St. Petersburg, and overthrew their government. Putin is laying the groundwork for Russia's 4th and final revolution.

[@anchoranchor3495]

Beautiful comment, but they didn’t protest against the war in Ukraine 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@acab3146]

Well, "shame on you" is the most polite that they shouted

[@IvanIvanov-us1fb]

i heard they shouted "fa...got"

[@michaelverone4911]

No bro, they shouted **дарас, this word even banned on twitch

[@grizzle273463]

Nothing better than change from within.

[@Korozzz]

The last one who shouted at a colonel, is accused now and is going for 12 years in jail.

[@MrRotaryrockets]

nice to see they have opened their eyes..and they know that if they don't leave Ukraine now ..they may never go home Alive.

[@saadsyed7531]

I bet if Putin saw this, he would say ‘it’s all going according to plan’ 😂

[@lenitaa7938]

The scary thing is if Putin saw this, he would send in his FSB and the riot control police, the 'leaders' would be identified, imprisoned, maybe even tortured! Putin is big on setting a punitive example! They would try to re-education, disinformation, propaganda, etc.. The Russian FSB is proficient in how to handle such! In this case, the General may not even care, because these soldiers are just the canon fodder! And the soldiers know this!

[@joancampbell1377]

He is such a lying evil person time hecwas gone one way or the other!!!!

[@PhatChin]

"I remain a master strategist." - Putin

[@priscillaroberts7945]

I don't think " shame on you" was an exact translation of what those students,shop assistants and assorted office workers were saying. Lol.

[@cristinarosello5971]

forced to fight in a war. oh my! my heart goes out to these mobilized Russians.

[@yeahdefinitely6607]

I love how they censor Russian swearing, knowing this won’t be going to a Russian audience

[@borivoj_navratil]

We in Russia watched it a million times

[@miroslavkowalski5783]

It hasn't been censored by the sun.

[@lowandslow3939]

@@borivoj_navratil And what do you, in Russia, think about all of this? This is a sincere question.

[@FiftyFabs]

@@borivoj_navratil How can you watch this? I thought the government censored everything?

[@ashscott6068]

@@miroslavkowalski5783 Obviously. The people who work for The Sun, can barely speak English!

[@eddy-fw7hv]

I think those guys are 2 seconds away from complete mutiny

[@waynelengyel8043]

This may be very significant. Sometimes wars end unexpectedly. Troops refuse to fight en masse. We shall see.

[@denniscompton5800]

I was discharged in 1973 and things in the US military weren't the best at that time but I can even imagine something like this happening even back then in the US services.

[@joeflippo520]

Thanks for Everything, Mr. Compton

[@Retrohertz]

"Can" or "Can't"?

[@mbrow]

Sir, we thank you so much for your service, especially back then. Welcome home soldier. May everyone honor your service now as we should have back then.

[@user-km7hl2hh1g]

There were multiple cases of mutiny in the Vietnam war on the US side, especially towards the end of the war.

[@jaimeerives8793]

Lol tell that to the officers who were fragged

[@deecantola1923]

I couldn’t be more proud of these conscripts ❤❤

[@boombyte8849]

Those rotten z-ombies don't care about the war--they just want supply and ammunition.

[@warhedd]

Strength in numbers. The powerful few may be powerful. But they are few indeed.

[@wesleymiller6674]

Dude imagine being in the USMC and talking to a general officer like this. These guys should just rebel and fight on Ukraine’s side.

[@reting1111]

This is a beautiful sight to behold 😊

[@KatharineOsborne]

There was a story my dad told me about his father in WWII, that with the allies, that if an officer was treating the men poorly they sometimes got fragged (a grenade thrown into their tent while they were indisposed). I think these men might be at that point.

[@frankwood7878]

They did that in Korea & Vietnam too

[@khuti007]

Yeah their not giving them any guns, let alone grenades. Now we know why !!

[@cesaru3619]

FRAGGED!

[@fromtheflightdeck252]

"I was fragged in Nam" Joe Biden 2022

[@indiasuperclean6969]

WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😠 I WILL NEVER GO TO RUSSIA!! 😠 😠THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗

[@TapeLV]

That took balls. I hope they stay alive after that...

[@Coastfog]

What could possibly we worse than being blown to bits or mutilated for a criminal syndicate's pointless war?

[@whiteprivilegedenier7459]

The General is the one that would be executed. For not having any control over his men.

[@SL3DApps]

I would take jail over dying for Putin any day of the week.

[@andrewbuckley1986]

@@Coastfog having your family pay the price, I'm sure their greatest fear is their families will pay for what they do or not do.

[@StillAliveAndKicking_]

What will they do, slaughter them all? Or send them to a cold jail in siberia which is the better option, no?

[@mmuscheid]

I spent 10 years in the military as officer and served in the Middle East during wartime. Not once did I ever experience disrespect or insubordination, because I always knew I was nothing without the men and women serving with me. We were a team. It is incomprehensible to me the level to which these soldiers do not support this war (sorry, special operation - jk) or any of the Russian leadership. Slava Ukraini!

[@Jagonath]

They may well support the war in principle. I'm guessing the frustration (rage?) is the realisation of how little Russia is supporting them in return, with any kind of proper training or equipment.

[@spirit9871]

Thank you for your service.

[@edie9158]

The actions undertaken by Russian and ethnic minority (e.g. Tajik, Tatar, Chechen, Armenian etc) enlistedmen and their upper echelons is mind boggling, to have lost so many of their command and combat staff and dealing with domestic revolts amongst their civilian and military population, this is almost reminiscent of the August Coup. While not to the exact extreme it won’t take much to get to that tipping point. I’m concerned for the future of Russia and hope someone deals with the Regime internally before they turn to more drastic measures.

[@yoffens1]

I hope that this will happen in all mobilized divisions. And then they will go to the winter palace, as it was in 1917.

[@user-gu2gb7po7x]

Да все знают как ты убивал и разрушил чужие страны. А теперь поддерживаешь нацистов и убиваешь коренное население на Украине

[@jasonanderson846]

Bravest men in the world right now.

[@johnschneider4160]

"YES!!!" to Peace!! We must stand up to the forces of evil!!

[@Trin978]

History of 1917 is repeating itself.

[@vipeton.8927]

My thoughts exactly. Also remember, what happened after. Long, bloody civil war. Nothing good in the future.

[@reidtanner5978]

🤞

[@TheCrazyCanuck420]

Hopefully 😀

[@firstname4865]

Crazy to think you're allowed to take your phone to war

[@ivanbasson982]

Youv'e gotta tel somebody about all the crap that is being stirred....

[@Travio247]

You're not allowed. But they aren't stopping them all

[@johnsmithe4656]

Yeah, that would never fly in the US corps. They take your phones from you when you first get to training, it's like the first thing that happens. The Russian training facilities probably cannot handle the huge influx of new recruits and just can't control them. It's absolutely crazy, unthinkable in the US.

[@DoktorSchmand]

@@johnsmithe4656 russian training facilities should do this aswell. But the soldiers keep hiding the phones pretty successfull

[@PumpkinHoard]

@@DoktorSchmand I guess they don't check up your ass.

[@alangcanosa8978]

RESPECT!!!

[@josef6180]

Eternal Shame on any man who turns away from military service

[@arkwill14]

I don't think most people understand how big this is. This is more important than AT missiles or drones dropping grenades. We are seeing the collapse of the command structure of one of the world's most (seemingly) powerful militaries. When the common soldiery can shout down a general like this, it speaks volumes.

[@boombyte8849]

Those rotten z-ombies don't care about the war--they just want supply and ammunition.

[@WatDoino]

To be fair the conscripts (if they are) probably didn’t have enough training refresher hammered into them about respecting command structure. They just didn’t have time. But yeah, imagine disrespecting a general if you’re a soldier…

[@geroutathat]

Or, it means the USA lies to us telling us that people who disagree with Russia are murdered on the spot. They seem like they have no fears at all. I mean they are probably just conscripts and the military is trying to treat them as well as they can giving them freedoms that allowed them to think such behaviour was OK.

[@arkwill14]

@@geroutathat So you think all the cruelty Soviets committed against their own soldiers is just Western propaganda? You think all the officer purges of the 1930's were just Western propaganda...despite literally thousands of accounts from Russian sources that this indeed was the case? And even if we accept that --- you think that what is displayed here is what, a _healthy_ sign of morale in the modern Russian army?

[@geroutathat]

@@arkwill14 Russia said they didn't fire on Poland and they didn't. They said they didn't shoot a civilian plane out of the sky, do you think they did?

[@kebo57]

We need a lot more protesting like this!!!! It seems as though an internal resistance to the upper command is taking shape, so there is hope.

[@thierryparte2506]

Dont get hopes up to early, winter will be brutal to the Ukrainian people who will seek refuge in Europe which could lead to political tensions in Europe and so will the winter be brutal to the Russian soldiers let hope they lose hope first

[@thierryparte2506]

@jim I know but we're talking about 10x the refugee we have now

[@richsackett3423]

@@thierryparte2506 The winter will be much harder for the Russians. They have no issued military gear or proper boots even. The Ukrainians have the home field advantage times ten. Putin thinks leading like Stalin will work. WWII goes to the Germans if it was left up to Russia. The Americans defeated Hitler with industrial might, not with Russian soldiers being bullet sponges.

[@DaaronIrwing]

Those civilian-soldiers will be sent to most difficult warzones and be sucrifice to show others that mutiny has penalty. They will be dead by winter.

[@MrGokamok]

These guys already protested more then the rest of Russia.... Respect

[@Tigerpanzer66]

You can feel the power of many angry people.

[@Lux-ue1md]

I love soldier when they show braveness to tell these things!

[@erikswanson5753]

When a dictatorship loses fear as a tool of coercion it's done.

[@indiasuperclean6969]

WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😠 I WILL NEVER GO TO RUSSIA!! 😠 😠THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗

[@user-xv1zv8fp3p]

Hah, they are protesting because they received poor equipment and bad conditions... not because they don`t want to kill Ukrainians

[@Heretowatchstuff]

This would have happened to most armies in WW1 if the men had smart phones.

[@johnaudwinconarco3785]

Peace on earth

[@mikesheldon1957]

As in Blackadder goes forth, General Melchett said to Baldrick, 'When you men go over the top to attack the enemy you can be assured I will be right behind you' and Blackadder replied to Baldrick, 'Yes, About 5 miles behind you to be precise', many a true word spoken in comedy.

[@Lillenism]

More of this is good😎Glory to Ukraine💙💛

[@eastern2western]

There is no matter way to find out the problems in a military than going through a war.

[@bozokluoglu_]

If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle.

[@Symon_Musician]

As more it goes on as more it reminds me the Russian army in 1915-1916: demotivated soldiers, who don't know what they are fighting and dying for, unable to command officers, fightings between different fractions of so called elite groups. Let's don't forget to mention failes with military equipment, rampant corruption, inability to deliver Russian grain to world markets, weak military undustry, constant searchs of spies to explain defeats on the front. However, nobody knows where modern Lenin is. This is how Russia looked like before 1917.

[@jlethal4929]

Yes I’ve been thinking the same thing since before the mobilization. They’re creating another 1917 situation.

[@Symon_Musician]

@@jlethal4929 There is an opinion that Putin started to like history since 2011-12 when he finally took a decision to return back in the Kremlin and it became evident before invasion in 2021 that he is keen on it. As it turned out he is a bad historian 🙂

[@rickprice6312]

It really looks like history is repeating . . . .

[@dzonikg]

@@jlethal4929 And they started civil war where 5 times more were killed then in actual WWI lol

[@jlethal4929]

@@dzonikg a lot of western support kept the whites in the fight for years. Nobody is going to help Putin, not even China.

[@peterarmstrong6928]

History is repeating itself 👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@anthonycantu8879]

The general rests in a warm place, while his troops rest in a cold grave.

[@wot_noobclown5621]

Respect

[@robertgranholm2055]

As an ex military officer, this kind of conduct would never stand in western militaries. Russia is a mess

[@CD-pk7xr]

It would never reach this point. Priorities of mission accomplishment and troop welfare.

[@mikehoncho7252]

Western militaries don't treat recruits as Cannon fodder

[@barryj388]

Hopefully the treatment the Russian troops are supposedly being subjected to would also never stand in western militaries.

[@Jacoob793]

What an odd comment to make

[@alexisXcore93]

@@barryj388 sending soldiers with tampons instead of actual medical kits? Yes. Never.

[@AffordBindEquipment]

that general can be thankful he's still alive. wouldn't take much to set those guys off.

[@GabrielMensajera]

If only 🙏🏼. One less General could be another step towards a possible end to this insane attrition ‼️

[@m1kcan1]

Poor people in a bad situation. Neither the soldiers nor general wants to be there.

[@VentiVonOsterreich]

"War is where old people trick young men to kill each other" -Niko Bellic, GTA IV

[@janethompson5153]

The awakening😊 Glory ,Victory and Peace to Ukraine 🇬🇧

[@liamwalters5029]

I think your running before you can walk here Jane but it’s promising , I dare not think what happens to these men

[@richsackett3423]

They either revolt or go to the front to die in a couple days. It is that simple of a choice. What’s with the “I dare not” nonsense?

[@jackattack2608]

A sad old soldier once told me a story. About a battlefield that he was on He said a man must never fight for glory He must know what is right and what is wrong. Flying Burrito Brothers

[@arleyrestrepo3713]

Es bueno ver cómo muchos soldados rusos saben que Ucrania está luchando por su patria y que ellos no tienen por qué estar saqueando tierra ajena. Gloria a Ucrania. 🇨🇴🇺🇦🇨🇴

[@kuroshin7685]

They even don't have the force to shut down the shouting so we know the situation now

[@arkwill14]

Can you imagine what this general is thinking? Back when he first entered the military even a fraction of the dissent shown here would probably get you sent to a penal colony or maybe even earn you a bullet to the back of the head.

[@gobblox38]

And now all of this dissention will earn him a bullet in the back of his head.

[@tedunguent156]

Putin, watching this, is probably thinking just that. Thinking, why isn't my general shooting them in the head one by one? If he did he wouldn't have anyone left to fight for him.