My All-Time Favorite Duty Pistol?

[@rudolfyakich6653]

A true tear jerker. Almost as good as The Godfather.

[@scottperson9487]

Thank you for your service both in the Marines and as a law enforcement officer.

[@hrfunk]

The honor is all mine Scott.

[@stevendedeian7774]

@@hrfunk you have a stellar history of service sir..not only military, but las enforcement..semper fi HRFunk...steve

[@hrfunk]

Semper Fi Steven. Thanks for the kind words.

[@Jleitte]

Outstanding Marine! We still need good men and women in law enforcement. I understand without the backing of a government or the public support for officers to take a second look as a career. I was in the Corps in 1967 and now have two retirements from the state and city positions. I know you have my back and of course, I got yours. Be safe, Jim Colorado.

[@hrfunk]

@@Jleitte Thanks James. Semper Fi!

[@davidnicholas7516]

I have to say, HR, that when you started this and ran through the guns, I said to myself that you were going to pick the gun you're carrying now. It's human nature, isn't it? You've been through a bunch of guns, and of course you're drawn to the gun that you currently carry, because it's the one best suited to your needs at the moment.

[@themidnightrambler4865]

I'm a retired law enforcement firearms instructor. And, unlike you, a mildly old guy, I'm a bonafide real old guy. Because of that, my first duty firearms were revolvers. The first was a Ruger Security Six and after that a number of S&Ws. A Model 19, M 65, M 66, M 581, M 681, and a Model 681. All were great quality handguns. Because of thousands of hours of training and practice, I could shoot all of them very well. I was a Distinguished Expert for many years. Also, with speed loaders, I could reload as fast as I can with a magazine fed semi auto and never felt under gunned or at a disadvantage, with a revolver. As things changed though, we eventually changed over to semi autos. Where I was employed, we had a choice of a few different pistols. I went with the Glock. First a model 22, as .40 S&W was the mandated cartridge. Then later, a model 23 as I preferred the smaller size and it still had a capacity of 13 + 1. When I retired, I was able to buy my issue Glock 23 and I've carried and shot it over the years. Some people love Glocks and some people hate 'em. I've always liked them and have never had a bad experience with them. And again, with many hours of training and practice with my Glock, I shoot it very well. The one change I've made, since retiring, and since I no longer have a mandated caliber, about two years ago I put a .357 SIG barrel in my Glock 23. I just like that round. I live in the South-West and do a lot of exploring, in my Jeep and the Glock, in .357 SIG is always with me out on the desert and mountain trails. I enjoyed your video and hope you don't mind my long winded comment. Stay safe, out there my friend.

[@hrfunk]

Thanks for a great comment! You went through an impressive list of wheelguns. I'm glad that Glock is still working well for you. I hope it continues to do so. Take care!

[@hrfunk]

jeff lockaby I just attended an officer’s funeral 2 weeks ago. I hope that’s the last one. Too many over the years.

[@happyhaunter_5546]

Thanks Chief for all your service and positivity! -With love, the Navy

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome Matt. Thanks for watching!

[@martyc1533]

I am glad that you settled on the .40 caliber. Far too many 9mm fans knock the .40 due to recoil (slightly more) and less round capacity (2-3 rounds). Having started my career with a 4 inch S&W .357 revolver and finished it with a Glock Model 22 in .40 Caliber (with a several 9mm's in between) , I learned to appreciate the effectiveness of the .40 and have no problem shooting it.

[@topg9555]

Ha, I did the same! Started in 1986 with a S&W Model 27 .357 Magnum, and finished in 2019 with the Glock 22/23 in .40 calibre. The .40 is effective. The recoil bothered less accomplished shooters, and so they were happy not to have to like it when the 9mm cam back into vogue.

[@martyc1533]

@@topg9555 I have found that there are 2 types of shooters when it comes to the .40. Those that think the "recoil" is too snappy for them and those that are delusional enough to still think the 9mm is just as powerful. My humble opinion (I am the humblest guy I know) shoot / train MORE OFTEN and you too can appreciate the .40!

[@almaadams3631]

@@martyc1533 Got so used to 40sw.; 9mm. just seemed wimpy ( in a full or compact pistol) I mean I like my Sig 365 and my Grandpower Q1S. But I just think anything bigger should pack more energy. After years(I am 55yrs. now) of shooting and reloading ( mostly pistol rounds) , I am sold on the lighter faster 135, 150 or 155grn. .40 bullets. Longshot is cheap and so are Nosler Sport HPs.

[@SierraBravo347]

That's a Nice lineup, and a Very hard elimination. They're All great firearms in their own rights. Any of these would make a great duty carry. Great presentation again, Thank You sir.

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome. Thanks for watching!

[@sgtmajtrapp3391]

Interesting video. Our first issue was a S&W Model 67 Combat Masterpiece (1972 fall) the first time we issued handguns allegedly would purchase what the majority wanted. . Most of the guys (we had about 100 full time and 10 reserves the (now 2000 sworn troops or more and 250 or more Reserves) wanted .357 Magnum Model 66 revolvers but these cost $10. more per gun so we went with the Model 67. The Detectives ( I became a young detective in 1975) were issued a S&W Model 10 round butt nickel .38 Special, but you could carry your own weapon, I purchased a Colt Diamondback 2.5" .38 Special (.38 Special only allowed then). We got around to magnums finally (years later) and these were the Model 686 S&W, but you could carry your own and I used a 6" COLT PYTHON. Our first self loading issue was a Beretta 92FS 9MM, and I carried my own gun (still allowed). The S&W 645 and later the S&W 4506. I was one of about six (including the Sheriff) that was allowed to carry (probably 1200 troops then) a COLT 1911 .45, I used the Combat Elite 2-tone .45. New Sheriff NO 1911's. I ended up with a 10MM GLOCK 20 in CID (return trip ordered there by my major, a reward?) and, personal purchase used a variety of handguns when an Investigator. including big bore revolvers (5" N frame .44 Magnum with good .44 Special, P7M8 9MM, and others). Regulations again changed (like you change socks) and we had to carry the Beretta 92FS 9MM no matter our assignement. We ended up with issuing the GLOCK 21 .45 in around 2000 and it is still our duty handgun. (I am not a fan of the GLOCK, sorry, gave mine to my younger brother as I seldom carried it); I must say that every gun fight we have been in, we have won since going from the 9MM to the .45. One fight Epic, took place on Police Memorial Day May 5th back in 2005 I think it was. Female deputy put three killers out of commission after rescuing a lady's children. If I had to pick ONE gun as a duty pistol, without any regulations, it would be my much loved 1911 Pistol in something like the 10MM with full power ammo, or the .45ACP, but I am a fan of the .38 SUPER and .357 SIG in that platform as well. One thing about being retired, you can carry what ever you want, no regulations to follow in that regard. Really enjoyed this presentation, made me look back too, adn I am sure others did the same. Really enjoy your channel and presentations, look forward to them on the weekend. Stay safe CHIEF.

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Sergeant Major! I'm glad you liked it.

[@sgtmajtrapp3391]

@@hrfunk Really enjoy your submissions. Find them all interesting and this was no exception. It is interesting what folks use for personal defense in general, and for hunting as well, course law enforcement is often limited to selections by issue firearms or by caliber. I use to make note when hunting various places what people selected for big game applications, depending of course on species of game. State forests were a bit different than guided hunting trips. But still find the topic interesting. I would venture to guess from my own survey/observations that the .380 and 2" .38 Special (probably a five shot) are the most used weapons by those with permits to carry, at least here in the HOT humid days of Florida, which is way too often. Maybe a review of your favorite off duty carry guns or those of friends may make an interesting study/video. Really enjoy your stuff, look forward to these each week. Hope you and the family are doing well. Thanks CHIEF.

[@prigs750]

I enjoyed the video. My career was 1975-2001. When I started, I also had to provide my own weapon, a S&W Model 15, 4 inch. I later transitioned to a S&W Mod 28 for the .357 power. I changed departments in 78. The new department allowed me to keep the 28. When I moved to investigations in 83 I picked up a Ruger Safety 6, 2.75 inch stainless. Much lighter than the 28 and easier to conceal. We transitioned to semi autos in 87 and I was issued a sig P226. I carried this until my 2001 retirement. I loved every 1 of these guns but my favorite would be the P226. I was given the weapon when I retired and still have. It is a W. German manufacture.

[@hrfunk]

Nice pistol. I know a lot of people who love those older Sig pistols. Those were also some great wheelguns that you carried.

[@jeffjennings794]

I wouldn't complain about any of those choices. As a young Marine I carried the 1911, I was first introduced to it at Parris Island and it's the first firearm my wife ever fired (she still oves it). I have carried the S&W 686, 1911, S&W 4006, Sig P225 and Sig P226. I also own a S&W 99. All are fine pistols. The only one I disagree with it the DAO, only because it is slightly slower on follow up shots. As always, it was a great video. Semper Fi!

[@hrfunk]

Semper Fi Jeff! I’ve got a qualification course video coming up with that DAO pistol. I don’t think the system is all that slow. See what you think when the video premiers.

[@scott78731]

Mr. Funk, thanks for doing this video. You responded to my comment about the 4006, one of my favorites because it is so safe. I replaced the grips and sights (Meprolight night 3 dot) on the 4006 making it even better. The 4006 was also the pistol S&W developed for their new 40 cal cartridge, but Glock introduced the 22 before the 4006 was released. The 4006 is owning a piece of history, and 40 cal is a damn good cartridge. 10mm is my next goal. The 1006 is tempting, but I am pursuing the Colt Delta Elite. Again, similar history, this was the pistol developed for Col Jeff Cooper's 10mm cartridge. Your service to our country throughout your career is greatly appreciated, and as FDR said on 6-6-1944, you are the Pride of Our Nation.

[@hrfunk]

Than you Scott. I’m glad you like the 4006, and I hope you find a 10mm you like. Best of luck, and take care.

[@obsoletevalues6209]

Thank you for your many years of service, Mr. Funk. You have my profound respect!

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@rexgigout1472]

I worked for a PD that required us to buy our own duty firearms. I started with a mandated S&W 4” L-Frame, for the academy training, ordering an S&W Model 686 for the duty rig and a 2.5” S&W Model 66 for personal time carry. When I was sworn-in, in March 1984, I then carried a 4” S&W Model 629. Yes, .44 Magnum. I trained mostly with mid-range Magnum ammo, not .44 Special. After my first year of street duty, I was then allowed to use an autoloader, so, switched to a 9mm HK P7, in a custom-made flap holster that met PD specs. When an open-top break-front rig became the standard revolver duty rig, I switched back to a revolver, in order to get away from the antiquated flap holster. This time, it was an S&W Model 58, .41 Magnum, which I carried from late 1985 to early 1990. By early 1990, I had finally managed to find a reliable Colt Commander, and the Safariland SS III, a.k.a. 070, was the standard duty holster. So, I used the Colt Stainless Commander for about a year, when it suddenly started choking, at which point I transitioned to a SIG P220, and carried it for two years. In 1993, I wanted to switch to a newer-version SIG P220, with the push-button mag release. My interim duty handgun became a 4” Ruger GP100, and then a 4” S&W Model 66. (By the Nineties, I had realized that I had K/L/GP100-sized hands. I had seriously damaged my hands, with those earlier N-Frames.) That “interim” actually lasted until 1997, at which time I returned to autoloading duty pistols, though full-Government-sized 1911 pistols, this time. I had thought I that would finish my career with 1911 duty pistols, but in 2002 I finally reached peak annoyance with the 070 not being an optimal duty holster, for my hands, at least, to carry a 1911. By this time, however, duty pistol policy had changed, so, if I let my “grandfathered” 1911s lapse, my options were limited to four specified .40 duty pistols. I transitioned to the Glock G22, which began two years of mediocre marksmanship, which I resolved by transitioning again, in 2004, to the SIG P229, which became my longest-serving duty pistol. While I was carrying the P229, the Safariland 6360 became the standard duty holster. As arthritis became my enemy, I wanted to get away from .40 S&W. In October 2015, shortly after my chief OK’ed 9mm to again be a duty cartridge, I returned to Glock, but this time Gen4, which fit my hands much better than had the Gen3 I had previously used. I thought that I would finish the twilight of my LE career with the Glock 17 being my duty pistol, but then, in early 2016, I was able to attend a transition class that enabled me to return to using 1911 duty pistols. The Safariland 6360 duty holster worked well with the 1911, so, my one remaining 1911, a Les Baer Thunder Ranch Special, became a duty pistol. When I retired in 2018, I was “qual’ed” with 1911 and Glock 17 & 19 duty pistols. Favorite? Well, this is difficult to answer. I reckon that my GP100 would have to be the favorite specific, individual duty pistol, due to its custom-level fit, and its performance during a significant incident. A problem with the GP100 was its weight, which had prompted me to switch to the lighter S&W Model 66, after a couple of years, to relieve the painful purple spot on the point of my right hip. Even so, my confidence in my accuracy with the GP100 meant that I continued to bring it to work with me, as a “bag gun,” for special situations, long after I had returned to using duty autos. Notably, arthritis in my aging trigger fingers has caused me to suspend double-action trigger-pulling training, live or dry-fire, with my GP100 and K-Frame revolvers, as of early 2024. My favorite GP100 is now relegated to being a family heirloom. My duty pistols that I actually carried on duty, that still remain active private-citizen carry guns, are my Les Baer TRS and a pair of Gen4 Glock 17 pistols. Of these three, the Les Baer is the easy favorite.

[@lavida57]

I can't tell you how much I appreciate your classes. Thank you

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome. Thanks for watching!

[@lifebiker105]

Mister Funk I've watched you quite a bit and I just wanted to say thank you sir for your service and your protection of the people in your District this time of trouble that we're having is unfortunate thank you thank you sir

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Joe. The honor has been all mine.

[@paulscountry456]

Wealth of experience you have, great show.My friend is retired Wash State Patrol and he carried a 28, a 92 in 9, and a M&P in 40, he still carries the M&P.With the 28 at first they used a cross draw break away holster.

[@hrfunk]

Now there’s a progression of Law Enforcement handguns through the eras! Those are all great duty guns for their day.

[@samhicks7568]

Great video. Thank you for your service, Military, and as a Police Officer.

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome Sam. Thanks for watching.

[@j.p.4541]

Great video, well articulated and very informative. Thank you sir!

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome. Thanks for watching!

[@KalashmanNC]

Funny where you find yourself. Marine Corps vet, Army vet, and very soon will be embarking on a new journey as a law enforcement officer. Love the channel, keep up the good work!

[@hrfunk]

Will do Jordan. Thanks for watching!

[@martyneff4008]

Thank You for your service. I got back into firearms last year and now addicted to going to the range every weekend. I have learned a lot from your videos and live stream things you do. My wife Susan carries a high capacity 9mm Smith and Wesson, I have a Smith and Wesson model 64. I wanted an Adam 12 Revolver, found a stainless one instead and now hooked.

[@hrfunk]

The Model 64/Model 10 is a great revolver. They have everything you need and nothing you don’t. That basic wheelgun has been keeping people safe since 1899!

[@martyneff4008]

@@hrfunk I was told they were hard to find. Our 3rd gun shop stop had my 64. I got injured last year and my wrists can't take high caliber or light weight handguns with heavy recoil. That 64 was meant to be mine. Very lucky to get it

[@druewzer]

Option to carry a firearm you purchase yourself "with the approval of the Chief of Police". That grin! Made me laugh. Only 3 minutes into the video and I am enjoying your presentation. But then, I typically hit that like button before the video starts anyway. Great video! :) I have been watching that subscriber number for last several days. Looks like it keeps increasing by .1 K subscribers each day. Nice!

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@007Chancellor]

Quite a few LEOs down here on the AZ/Mexico border still carry 1911s. Seeing them always makes me smile.

[@alantoon5708]

Another great presentation. People ask me what my favorite gun is. My reply always is: "The one that I have on."

[@2fast2block]

For just shooting for accuracy groups at 25 and 50 yards, wearing progressive lenses, the red dot sure makes it nicer since it allows me to slightly tilt my head forward rather than backward when I'm shooting iron sights to get my close range part of my glasses in view. If my eyes were good, I still like the iron sights. Even still, since I shoot at a local indoor range now, the low lighting and black bullet stop don't exactly make it iron sight friendly. On a side note, with a red dot when shooting for precise accuracy, the wiggle of it is distracting but with iron sights I feel more relaxed just looking at the top of the front sight and aligning it all. Seems to be more of a 'Zen' with iron sights.

[@hrfunk]

I know what you mean. If I still had my 25 year old eyes, I would shoot irons and not give it a second thought. But I don't, and the red dot's do help.

[@2fast2block]

@@hrfunk hey man, you did one heck of a job getting back in shape. I know I'm getting (ok, am) old but I don't want to go above 15% body fat. When I was excising a lot I stayed about 4% and with my joints and all I can't go as hard at it so been staying around 11%. There's a guideline I follow that goes by height and waistline to show me if I am getting too lazy. www.mdapp.co/waist-to-height-ratio-whtr-calculator-433/ Thanks for your service and your vids. You rock!

[@af22raptor23503]

That is a VERY Fair Assessment of the capabilities of the weapons! The SW4006 is an OUTSTANDING Pistol and I was LUCKY enough to pickup ONE of the California Highway Patrol Tactical SW4006 with the Rail Milled onto the Frame instead of being added onto it 3 years ago next month and I the one that I received was 95% on the outside and 100% on the inside! I replaced all the springs and put a set of Trijicon Night Sights and also replaced the bobbed hammer since I am not a fan of them. I am a BIG Fan of 40SW and I currently own almost every Major manufacturers Duty model 40sw and the TSW4006 is one of my favorite ones because of the weight of the pistol makes shooting 40sw even Underwood Hotter Loads Felt Recoil like a Weak 9mm or 38Spl Wadcutters thru a 4 inch 357 mag revolvers. The Best thing about the whole thing was that I got it when they were selling for under 400 with 5 mags!

[@hrfunk]

Wow! You got a deal on that 4006. Sooner or later I'll add another one to my collection. As you mentioned, it makes a great launch pad for hot .40's. Thanks for watching!

[@hoffpbass]

Good to know that incremental Quality improvements are defining the industry.

[@totizabayle377]

Good presentation. I am a senior and have a 5904 backed up by a 686 plus .357 magnum as my home defense guns till iget to my SKS paratrooper and Winchester defender 12 gauge shotgun.

[@hrfunk]

I think you’re pretty well armed.

[@BirdDogey1]

I became a cop in SoCal in 1989. My favs were the Smith 66 and the Beretta 92F.

[@sisleymichael]

I appreciate how you set and explained your eval criteria. That sets the stage for everything that comes next. Also, I liked how you stated your love of the 1911 and separated emotion from practical considerations. Smart video. I love my 1911 guns. I carry one sometimes, but only at my ranch and only for nostalgia. These days I carry a G19. For me, it shoots best, is super reliable, and my hand loves it. But that is me. Everyone should pick what is best for them. Very good video.

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@99Racker]

Interesting selections. In the MC, issued the 1911A1 for MP and other duties. At the SO, I started with a wheel gun (my S&W 6" Model 19) in a highride holster. Then a Model 19 (2.5") in dets that I changed to 4". For SWAT, issued a slicked 1911. Later, as you mentioned since the magazine was limited, a buddy and I went in on custom P14s Para Ord. with Colt slides (still a favorite but now wish it had a rail). Agency progressed to Model 66 (4") and later the Model 686 (4") for uniform. We later went to the Glock 22. I am big enough I can carry a 1911 or full size pistol in plain clothes/OD so I didn't bother with the smaller versions (even in upper positions), I wanted the full size pistol and mags. (At some staff meetings others carried the smallest pistols and looked at me like I had a big club on my belt.) Like you, I still have some old issued pistols I purchased or was given to me at retiremen; my Model 66 (IMHO. the perfect carry size .357 revolver) and my second wave 3rd Gen. Glock 22. For my Title 18, section 926C USC Qual, I have three pistols I maintain for EDC, a Glock 23 ( w/ a 9mm barrel and mags), a slick Sig 1911 with two extra 10 rd mags, and a Makarov PM with two extra mags. I didn't feel underguned with the revolvers as I wore three speedloaders and two strip loaders (for trips, I sometimes still travel wearing a Smith Model 25/JM in a cross draw holster), as I had a pocket pistol as backup and I had my carry 1911 with plenty of mags in my Warbag -- with a box of 50 rds for the duty revolver. In Narcs, on raids, I would carry my issue 4" in my back and my 1911 in hand (you might say, from experiences, I respect the .45 over other common calibers).When on a Federal fugitive assignment, I carried two 1911s with four extra mages. Besides the 870, we could check out a Winchester Model 94 or carry a SWAT assigned rifle (this could be a M16, Ingram or Thompson SMG, for me -- I didn't care for the Ingram) . I remember when the S&W Model 39 came out. My trainer (before FTOs) had one. I didn't like the angle of the grip and the same when the model 59 came out. The modern Smiths feel better in the hand. I am currently looking for a Glock specialist to mill a slide for a red dot sight. Good episode. Semper Fi.

[@hrfunk]

Thanks! That’s a great selection of duty pistols you were able to use!

[@walterminer4990]

Well HR, seems eyesight has been the topic of my week! I was with the wife at her Dr. yesterday and he always sends an assistant to the waiting room to call me in. He a great guy, loves guns. So, after the wife is good to go whe and I chat for a half an hour or so about shooting. I'm 68 years young, and have a few years on him. But, we have the same thing in common as you have joined the club! Age and "old" eyes! Yep, gets everyone! If I had my 20 year old eyes I would carry a 1911. I just felt the most comfortable with a 1911. Now, today with the improvements over the decades with them regarding upswept beaver tails, sights, tuned triggers, etc. they are a great choice for carry. However, the years go by and my parts wore out. Now, Sciatic Nerve issues and weight of the pistol don't work well for me! Regarding an optic on a handgun, hmm? I tried it and it is like learning to shoot again for me! I have difficulty locating that darn dot! Now, if I went to the range everyday and got got the weapon presentation in perfect alignment with my eye, I could probably adapt to it? But, at 68, not in a position where my job requires me to respond to situations that could require me use my sidearm I'm just not sure if it is really worth learning the system? Today I just work the old 3+3+3 method. 3 shots center mass, at 3 yards in 3 seconds from concealment. Age has even impacted that! Now, I see a lot of You-Tube "Professionals", or not, so they show the 3+3+3 EXCEPT from concealment! They stand poised, waiting for the timer and NOT drawing from concealment! I've only seen two fellows showing this. Ken Hachathorn and one former detective whose name escapes me. Both, are 1911 guys. Why? The 1911 with the no nonsense trigger makes most shooters better if they have their shooting fundamentals in check! Great presentation, Thank-you! Best to ya',,,,!

[@hrfunk]

You're welcome Walter. For me, the red-dots do help. Also, I'm going to be testing one in the near future that I think will make that alignment of the dot faster and easier. Stay tuned!

[@walterminer4990]

@jeff lockaby Yep Jeff I just can't get away from a 1911 either. After decades of shooting my wrists just like 9mm 1911 alot better! Plus, I do wish I used ear protection 40+ years ago! But, alot of serious 1911 old timers now carry one in 9mm. Bill Wilson of Wilson Combat and Ken Hackathorn. I cringe thinking about shooting a .357 today and forget .44 mags! Eyes, joints, getting older sometimes carrys a burden! But, I still like the old S&W Chief's Special .38 snub nose. Great for a quick trip to my local market! Best to ya',,,,!

[@walterminer4990]

@jeff lockaby Yep, I got one that our Chief was selling in 70's. He went to a Colt Detective Special. Funny, one additional round and the Detective Special got alot bigger. I noticed before current crazyness shops that had older firearms most the time they didn't realize what they had? Oddly, they were goofy over old Colt revolvers and knew nothing about S&W? Best to ya',,,,!

[@walterminer4990]

@jeff lockaby That does make sense Jeff. Personally, I like the feel of a Colt better but for me the trigger on my S&W's just was better for me. However, like most old guys I traded in or sold off guns that would be a small fortune today to the right person! The ONE thing that will never be duplicated, in my opinion, is "Blue Finish" guns from when I was young! Selling off guns from decades ago during those years, who knew! Like when I was a kid and the local hardware stores all sold guns. A wooded barrel with M-1 Garrands and the older guys laughing that they carried that for years and didn't want one! Heck, I remember them laughing about a $50 - $60 price tag on them 50+ years ago! Well, Jeff hindsight is 20/20 lol! Best to ya',,,,!

[@walterminer4990]

@jeff lockaby Jeff, I always tell people the our parents "The Greatest Generation" were made of harder clay! They were not affraid of work like most of todays young people. What people today call going through hard times was nothing for them! My Dad and Uncle were farm boys as well. Depression Era folks. They lived a much better life! No computers, no cell phones, outdoors all the time, etc. Yep, carrying an M-1 or B.A.R. today? Lol, for the most part ain't happening! They could keep a car running with no diagnostics, if they had one. They didn't live in a "disposible" society! Today, plastic guns? When I talk with younger pals they say "you always say you wish you could go back to the 60's & 70's"? Yep, even at my current age. People, food, guns, etc. all were better and life was good! I try to explain to kids at the range learn to shoot to new pistol stock. Don't run out and replace triggers, sights or whatever. If you learn to shoot well with a stock gun and then change whatever you want you may become a better shooter? You could be in a situation where you have to pick-up someone else's gun and defend yourself? Learn about other platforms. Shoot a revolver, 1911, Beretta 92, not just a Glock! I don't even own any Glocks! I don't care for the 22 degree grip angle, but in a pinch, I can shoot the no problem! Like our parents, "Make do with what you have"! Happy Sunday Jeff! Best to ya',,,,!

[@thomthompson9217]

All too often those of us who teach civilian self defense tactics to the non-law enforcement community either forget or ignore the parameters of what makes an effective self defense firearm. Thank you for a cogent explanation of what determinants law enforcement officers must contend with while selecting their tools of the trade.

[@hrfunk]

You’re most welcome. Thanks for watching!

[@5fifty794]

Love the old full size smiths! My EDC is subcompact Springfield XD 40 but prefer my HK USP 45 when going to the range. I hope to add a 1006 to my collection some day... Miami Vice style.😎

[@hrfunk]

I hope you find that 1006. I can hear Phil Collins singing already!

[@destroyingdadxx2274]

Awesome video. I love you S&W collection. I have a 4566 and love those old Smiths.

[@hrfunk]

There’s a lot to love about them. Thanks for watching!

[@ms.annthrope415]

I served in the army in the early 1980s and I first shot my first handgun with the 1911 .45. Been shooting the 1911 since then. I have 9mm, Browning High Power, HK VP9, and Soringfield SA35, and thr FN FNX .45. But my go to pistol is more often than not is one of my 5 1911.

[@Cameraman148]

Semper Fi and Great Video! I warmed to the 1911 In 1966 while in the Marines always Liked Them.Fast Forward to the 90's I Started work in Security..Always carried S& W Wheel Guns 38 spl and 357 Mag..When In Executive Protection we switched to Hi Cap Nines I opted for a 92 Clone and Then went Back to a Performance Level Colt Series 70...1911.. Now Retired and 71 yrs young I Have a 1911 I use for Carry and A 5906 S&W Nine.. Both Heavy but solid and good Shooters.. I just cannot use Tactical Tupperware...Smith makes some of the Finest Arms In the World!!! Semper Fi !!

[@hrfunk]

Semper Fi! I wish they were still making those pistols.

[@patrickmessinger7040]

Thanks for the awesome info in this video. My Naval career from 1987 to 1995, included DS/DS, the 1911 .45acp was also our issued sidearm and much loved by me & my shipmates. (:

[@hrfunk]

You just had to love those old pistols. They had been around for so long and done so much!

[@3Pillers]

Great video great evaluation and very nice collection and history.

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@paulasturi4199]

Since I have to wear Rx shooting glasses at the range, the M&P 9 2.0 is my pick! 👓

[@markyoung2981]

21 years with a badge for me and only 2 different issued sidearms. First was a Sig 226 in .40 S&W and the second was Glock 21 in .45 ACP. Both were fine duty weapons.

[@bwall615]

When I first went into Law Enforcement (30 years ago) I was issued the Beretta 92F. Which most all the departments in California at that time were carrying. We then switched to Sig 9mm then to Sig 40. I understand now they are carrying M&P’s. After leaving the department due to health issues after 10 years, I’m now a musician in Nashville. I still have that 92F and love it. But, my everyday carry pistol is the S&W M&P Shield 9mm. I think Smith and Wesson got it right with the M&P’s. Great collection and video. You have a new subscriber.

[@hrfunk]

Thanks for the sub Brett. By the way, I love Nashville. Great town!

[@TheGunfighter45acp]

Thank you for your faithful and continued service. I hope you find that 4006! I have a "shorty 40" on my list, but I sense alot of them are at the bottom of Loch Ness...

[@hrfunk]

Thank you. Hopefully I'll find a good 4006 one of these days (and you'll wrestle that Shorty 40 away from Nessie)

[@paulhaines2209]

Enjoyed...Thank You.

[@PPISAFETY]

Popularity of Glocks notwithstanding, if I were called upon to specify a duty pistol for a police department, something I have had to do in the past, it would unquestionably be a Smith and Wesson M&P. I base this on two factors that are important I think for patrol use. The first is that the M&P has a slightly longer trigger pull to fire than a Glock, and in patrol work we point pistols a lot more frequently than we fire them, under conditions of stress. So a bit longer trigger travel seems more stress resistant. I like a bit longer trigger travel for the first shot when the user may not be at their best, which is why my home defense pistol, likely to be used when I am awakened from sleep, has a traditional DA/SA trigger system and is in .40 S&W.. The second factor is that the S&W does not require the trigger to be pulled to field strip the weapon. I know that if one is handling the firearm safely, it should be cleared prior to field stripping, but a hole in the wall of the training room of a department I worked with tells me that not everyone always remembers this. As to caliber, I personally slightly prefer the .40 S&W for patrol work (I loved my 4006), but I realize that this is based on using the 9mm and researching disappointing police shooting events from the days before that cartridge received all the attention it got from the mid-2000's onward. Clearly for issue to the average recruit of today, a modern 9mm handgun and round is going to be the best choice from a number of perspectives, not the least of which is training time. So on that issue, I'd have to specify a 9mm handgun. I have to chuckle a bit when I see videos from hobbyists that downgrade the M&P pistols in comparison to other similar handguns. The M&P was clearly designed with cops in mind, and for that purpose I think it serves admirably. I tried the red dot optic but found that after decades of shooting open sights, the dot sight simply slowed me down too much. But I would certainly allow an optic on the duty sidearm for any officer who thinks they need it and qualifies with it.

[@logicaredux5205]

Love that belt! It looks like a rifle sling. I thought this was a very good and well reasoned presentation. Also a treat to watch because I share an admiration for Smith pistols. Since it will never be my “duty” to carry a sidearm, I would add for myself size as a factor in order to easily conceal them. Shield or M&P Compact make more sense for someone like me. If I were to choose two of your pistols that I would like to own, it would be for the “cool” factor rather than duty. I would love to have a 1911 and an S&W 99. One is a timeless classic and the other was a unique collaboration with Walther.

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Logica! If you ever make it to these parts, you're welcome to shoot either one of them!

[@logicaredux5205]

hrfunk Thank you sir! A most gracious offer!

[@thekimmonia]

Thanks for interesting video!

[@woodrow1037]

I have 2 favorite duty guns. I carried both during different periods in my career before retirement. First, SW MOD 66 .357 magnum. Second, Beretta 92f 9mm. I still have both and I still enjoy shooting both of them. Thanks, blessings brother

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Woodrow. Those are two great handguns in their own right.

[@danbyers8462]

Very interesting review! I can fully understand your reason for the final decision. I carry a M&P 2.0 compact 9mm with Crimson Trace integrated laser for EDC IWB. I am not LEO but had trained in the Navy (Seabees) and later fleet Self Defence Force by Marines/Navy and have a passion for 1911A1 also!

[@hrfunk]

Thanks for watching! As I said, emotionally I would have chosen the 1911, but rationally I went with the N&P.

[@rickm4295]

I love seeing an American with a table full of S&W's especially the M&P's. I have the M&P 2.0 compact for CCW. I love it .....I enjoyed your video to the nth degree , lol. Thank you for all of your service sir.

[@hrfunk]

You are most welcome. Thanks for watching Rick!

[@jarinwilson9539]

Excellent choice sir!

[@hrfunk]

Thank you. It was a difficult choice.

[@albee8280]

Thank you for your service Sir

[@paulrenner6387]

Watching this video was like watching you pick your favorite child. It’s cool you have most of your guns. I can’t ever sell any of my guns, just hurts thinking about it. Another good video you put out there. Hurt me to see the 1911 go down first but I never had to consider choosing a duty pistol, I would guess that’s a whole other game. I pick up my new fall weather pistol , a CZ75 B omega tomorrow, can’t wait. Warmer weather I carry my Sig p365.

[@mikekroesch818]

in my 25 years of law enforcement with one agency I only transitioned to 3 handguns. Starting in 1984 with SW model 20 revolver.Then in 1986 I went to a SW 4" barrel revolver I don't remember the model. In 1987 my final and only gun I carried for the rest of my career was a Sig P226 until I retired in 2009.

[@pjoseph4384]

Fun video. I have had the exact opposite experience in my LEO background. Came onto the job in my "major metropolitan law enforcement department" back in the 90s. In the academy we had a five minute opportunity to decide: S&W 5946 or Glock 19. No shooting practice. "Take your pick. Now." "Yes sergeant", said the recruits. So, strictly based on hand size and comfortable grip, never having fired either, I chose the Glock 19. Carried and eventually owned the original I was issued for well over two decades. Never once regretted it. Reliable, except for very rare ammunition driven stoppages. Worked with a few old timers that would not give up their wheel-guns, with beaten up and faded leather holsters and gun belts that would have fit any Western movie set. We used to say that their guns were probably so rusted in that they couldn't get them out of the holster. Interesting insight about using reading glasses to see the front sight. Never would have thought of it. Adapt, improvise and overcome. As per your question last week regarding Masada use where I am right now, as far as I know the only weapons generally issued to units that require hand guns are Glock 17s and 19s. Old timer cops sometimes carry Jericho 941s, due to familiarity and comfort level as much as anything else. The Jericho is a sweet shooter, as you know. Thanks for the stroll down your memory lane. I'm sure many viewers will have enjoyed it. Too bad about the 1911.

[@hrfunk]

Thank you! And thanks for the info about the Masada. It may soon become my NEXT duty pistol,

[@tacman2893]

Thanks for the video. I have carried 5 different service sidearms in law enforcement. They were model 10 S&W, 5946, 3953, Sig 226, Glock 22 (current). I also had a Browning HP in the military. Good stable of pistols there!

[@hrfunk]

Thanks! I like the ones you carried too!

[@swkohnle08]

Thank you for this all-time favorite duty pistol video. Although I'm not in LE, I found your criteria for selection to be well thought out and reasoned. For me, as non-LE, my criteria is slightly different but there are some similarities. Conceal-ability is an important distinction for EDC but even more important is how well I can draw from concealment and shoot accurately every single time. I have owned a Shield in 9mm and other similar sized micro compacts and I just don't shoot them as well. For me, the Glock 19 is the perfect size that I can shoot well and conceal. All my training was done with the Glock 19. Like you, my eyes are not what they were in my twenties, so switching to AmeriGlo with a bright orange front sight really helped out a lot. Living in a state with a 10 round limit, I also have to consider carrying an extra magazine although the odds of my involvement in a gun fight are far less than they would be for a LEO, concealment with a spare magazine sort of limits my options for including a red dot optic as well. Thank you again for your video Sir.

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome. Thanks for watching.

[@bh9229]

I find the G19 to be the perfect size for my hands... And if buying your own mags aftermarket choices and comparability with other 2x stack 9mm mags helps. I wouldnt call it 10/10 100% perfect... But 9/10 95% perfect, and not sorely lacking in any one particular area (size, capacity, reliability, trigger, etc).

[@Handgunslinger]

I have served as an SC State Constable, and then as reserve deputy. Duty weapon as a reserve deputy was an S&W 64 in .38 Spl. After my service, the sheriffs office switched to 9mm, then to 40S&W. Later, I heard that some significant numbers of deputies were dissatisfied with the performance against malefactors, and the department switched to Glocks in .45ACP. My thinking at the time was that it would have been less expensive if the department had searched for a more effective loading in the .40.

[@hrfunk]

It would probably been better to invest that money in training so as to improve the officers’ ability to place their shots more accurately.

[@albitcapinigro1107]

Another great video. I'm a big fan of the Smith and Wesson M&P line. Have a .40 & .45, 1.0 version.

[@paulwilliamson2067]

I already know you're going pick the M&P 9. But I'll watch anyway.

[@paulwilliamson2067]

@deucedeuce22oz One might think so, but I've been watching this channel too long not to know that Funk is a S&W guy.

[@kbm-zw5jd]

He had a video a few years ago explaining why he doesn’t like Glocks.

[@timclaus8313]

@deucedeuce22oz HR did a video awhile ago explaining why he does not like Glocks. Nothing structurally wrong with the guns, but he said S&Ws work better for him ergonomically than Glocks do. Also stated would be the opposite for other shooters.

[@BLACKRIFLEREVIEWS]

Outstanding Brother my favorite is the 659 9MM .

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Rick!

[@infidel24]

Thank you for your many years of service.

[@hrfunk]

The honor has been all mine Don. Thanks for watching!

[@johnsnyder5470]

I too wore a badge for nearly 40 years, I am most amazed you have been able to keep track of how long you carried each and what years, amazing.

[@hrfunk]

It's just one of thoise things that sticks in my head. Now, dont aske me what I had for breakfast. I won't remember that.

[@theparalexview785]

Very interesting observations, and despite my fondness for the 1911-A1 (the first semi auto pistol I ever shot, at age 18 in the service), I can't say I'd disagree with your rationale for excluding it. Nowadays, in my mid-'60s, eyesight has become an issue. I'm far sighted with presbyopia and can't see open sights without my reading glasses. But I don't wear glasses routinely indoors or outside while exercising. So I'm planning to install the XS Big Dot express sights on my Shield Plus. I did use the early generation electronic red dots about 30 years ago in competition, mostly the Aimpoint. It required a solid aluminum grip panel replacement with mounting rail for my .45 ACP. Worked great. Heavy and bulky, completely impractical for anything but range games. But I'm not quite ready to commit to a micro red dot for EDC. I've tried only one, on a rental FN 509 at the range. The triangle pointer was sharp and clear without needing glasses. But it took longer to pick up the sight and the FN 509 grip angle didn't point naturally for me. It was easy to group well out to 18 yards, but took longer to find the target. I'll need to practice with a pistol that suits me better.

[@hrfunk]

You might be interested in my video that’s going live today. In it, I’m going to be talking quite a bit about red dot sights.

[@virginia7370]

Interesting vid ... thank you. I started out with a Colt Trooper 6", then got a Colt 1911 Series 70, and carried a little Star PD off duty ... Next dept. issued S&W 19 4", but we could purchase/carry our own so long as we could qualify with it. Over the next few years I carried another Trooper but 4", Pythons, then Ruger Security Six, S&W 5904, S&W mod.57, mod. 25-5, and off duty a Ruger Sec.Six and then a Speed Six, and a S&W 469. Finally settled on a Ruger Service Six 4" stainless 357 (carried Rem. 158gr. 38spec. +P LSWCHP) ... Today, I still keep a Ruger Security Six 4" stainless 357mag. , though of course, I do have other handguns. Being a gun "nut" can be fun. But, if I had to have only one, it would be my Security Six 4" .

[@hrfunk]

That’s a good one to choose (you had a lot of other great handguns in that list!). A friend of mine has a security six that he swears by. Thanks for watching!

[@kikupub71]

Informational video, sir.

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@LionidasL10]

I put a Holosun 407C on my M&P40 1.0. Outer Impact adapter plate slides right into/replaces the rear sight dovetail. You could probably run that M&P2.0 9mm with an the same adapter plate and the Leupold if you wanted.

[@flyoverkid55]

Loved the M&P when it first came out, and were it not for owning my P 229 I would have bought one. Couldn't justify the expense. Now in my 60's, and eyesight is becoming an issue. Recently bought a P 365 with high visibility tritium sights. On the smaller gun they are worth the expense. You can be proud of your career in law enforcement and military service, I enjoy watching no B/S guys in an age of clickbait channel owners. Thanks for the review and thank you for your service. HM3, USN 75-79.

[@hrfunk]

You are most welcome Kevin. Thanks for YOUR service and thanks for watching.

[@roykent5864]

Another great video. Even with my 64 year old eyes I would have gone with the 9mm SW 2.0 My favourite sidearm right now is a SW 45 2.0 Thanks again.

[@hrfunk]

You’re welcome Kent. Thanks for watching!

[@lowspeedhighdrag]

This video inspired me to list all my duty pistol selections. I start my 34th year in September, and I was amazed at how often I switched in my early days, and some of the stupid reasons that I switched. I’ve always had to provide my service handgun, which has been a Beretta 96 .40 since about 2006. I’ll likely carry it until retirement. For me, it’s perfect. It came with night sights and I added rubber grips. Last year, I started carrying 3 extra mags instead of 2. But it’s still my favorite.

[@hrfunk]

And that's a great one to use Greg! Thanks for watching!

[@lowspeedhighdrag]

13 different service weapons in my career. I started differently than you, I was in the revolver half of my academy class. The first 3 duty guns of mine were round.

[@lowspeedhighdrag]

You should do a favorite off duty/backup video. That’d be fun. I’m already listing mine.

[@hrfunk]

So many of them have come and gone over the years that I don’t think I could pull that one off.

[@lowspeedhighdrag]

Point taken.

[@2vintage68]

Excellent video.

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@mickjagger5469]

Very well done sir !!

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Mitch!

[@willy4869]

All those duty pistols and not a single glock. What a breath of fresh air. The M&P's are great shooters. I don't own one. Not sure why. But every one I've shot has been a really nice pistol.

[@Elvis68spec]

Very nice choice!

[@hrfunk]

Thanks!

[@mikehagan4320]

I would like to hear about your recall to the Marines. How do they treat guys who have been out for a while? What do they have you do? And what duties did you perform while in during that 4 month stretch? My Son is a 5811.

[@hrfunk]

That was a very interesting time in my life. At the time I received my reactivation orders, I had been discharged from active duty for nearly two years (although, obviously I was still in the "Individual Ready Reserve"). During those years, I had been hired by my first police department; attended the Ohio State Highway Patrol's Basic Police Academy; gotten married, and had a son. So my life had changed considerably since the last time I had worn a USMC uniform. My orders required me to report to a Marine Corps reserve facility in Cleveland on February 14, 1991 (Happy Valentines Day!). As I recall, I had about two weeks from the time I received the orders in the mail until I had to report. As you might expect, that was a very busy two weeks! When I arrived at the Reserve facility, there was a perfunctory re-induction process that basically consisted of checking my name off of a list and handing me another set of orders that required me to report to MCB Camp Lejune NC. I was also given a plane ticket, but a snow storm that night grounded all flights. As a result, I got to spend the evening at the Cleveland Airport Marriott courtesy of Uncle Sam. Interestingly, there was a VFW post within walking distance of the hotel. I knew a fellow who worked there, and I thought it might be a good place to kill some time while I waited for the snow to stop. Upon hearing that I was shipping out for Desert Storm, the assembled veterans there provided me with far too much free booze that night! By noon the next day, the snow had stopped and the airport was back in service. I don't recall precisely what time my flight left, but I do remember being told while we were in-flight that our plane was being diverted from Jacksonville NC to another small small airport roughly 40 miles away. If I ever knew the reason for the diversion or the location where we landed that information has been claimed by the passage of time. When we did land it was around mid-afternoon, and one of the big 900 series trucks (that looked like a Duece 1/2 on steroids) was waiting. Those of us who were bound for Camp Lejune scrambled aboard and found a spot on the bench seats under the covering canopy. We subsequently spent the better part of the next hour bumping and bouncing our way across the North Carolina countryside as we made our way to Jacksonville. Upon our arrival, we were unceremoniously dumped out in front of the base gym. Said facility had been transformed into an improvised reactivation center. Inside, there was a long line of tables that had been fashioned into roughly a horseshoe shape around 3 of the gym's 4 walls. Each table represented an individual step in the reactivation process, and each step in the process built upon the last. So, by the time an individual had completed the circuit, he/she had been transformed from IRR to active Marine. Looking back on it, it was a very efficient process. Marines, such as myself would check in at the first table inside the door (once again, more or less, just to check our name off a list), and then we would progress from table to table. The process went something like this. Table 1-name and personal information; Table 2-sign your will; Table 3-medical screening; table 4-issue new utility uniforms; Table 5-new ID card and dog tags; etc, etc. This process was basically an administrative assembly line for processing reactivated personnel. I don't remember how many tables there were, but the process took several hours to complete. The last table in the gymnasium was where Marines were issued orders to their new unit. I was watching the Marines in line ahead of me, and one by one they were assigned to units that were already in the Middle East, or were training to go there. I fully expected to receive similar orders. Imagine my surprise when the orders I received attached me to the MP unit at Marine Corps Air Station New River (if you don't already know, the New River Air Station is also located in Jacksonville NC. Basically, I was just heading across town). I found out later that New River's MPs had been depleted when many of their Marines were previously shipped to the Gulf. As a result, headquarters had put in a request for replacements. Hence, my reactivation. At the time, however, I wasn't sure if I should feel relieved, cheated, ashamed, or ecstatic. In the end, I suppose I felt some combination of all 4. One rather comical component to this turn of events (or, at least it's comical now), was the fact that since I wasn't officially attached to one of the deploying units, and I was not yet attached to New River PMO, I had no place to sleep that night! As I recall, I found an empty rack in a dusty quonset hut and got a few hours of sleep there. The next day I hitched a ride from one of the Camp Lejune MP's who was kind enough to drive me to the Air Station. When I got there, I went through the Chinese fire drill that composes the check-in process for Marines reporting to a new command. That process actually takes a couple of days (or, at least it did back then). When I finished checking in, I was assigned to one of the New River MP platoons. Since I was a corporal, and I had prior experience as both an active duty MP, and a civilian police officer, I was assigned as the Desk Sergeant for my platoon. As such, I handled incoming calls (both telephonic and in-person) to PMO during our tour of duty. I also exercised general supervisory responsibilities over our lower ranking Marines. I answered to the Platoon Gunnery Sergeant who served as our watch commander, as well as two Staff Sergeant's (both of whom were reservists who had been activated as well as civilian police officers). One of the Staff Sergeant's was assigned as the Deputy Watch Commander and the other was the Patrol Supervisor. The Gunny always treated me very well. He seemed to respect the fact that I had been an active duty Marine, AND that I had become a police officer after completing active duty. I also got along very well with the two Staff Sergeants (one of whom was from Texas and the other from Baltimore). Both of them were great guys. The four of us comprised the NCO cadre of our platoon which consisted of about 20 Marines. The lower enlisted Marines were assigned to patrol and security duties. I also got along well with them. In short, I was treated like a Marine NCO while I was back on active duty. There was never any differentiation between the active duty Marines, the "active" reservists who had been ordered to duty, or those of us who had been called up from the IRR. We were all Marines, and we were treated as such. I can't close this post without noting one other thing about my activation for Operation Desert Storm. The Marine Corps during time of war is very different from the Marine Corps during peace time. Much of the ridiculous BS we had endured during my active duty days had gone out the window by the time I was recalled. In retrospect, if my initial 4 year enlistment had been like my reactivation time, I might have never left the Corps. I apologize for the length of this reply, I might have gotten carried away. Semper Fi!

[@NoQuestions4sked]

Great read. Great point about peacetime Marine Corps. Unfortunately or maybe fortunately I was born a few years too late to experience the 2001-2015 Marine Corps. It seems like your worst enemy is often times another Marine in peacetime.

[@hrfunk]

I seem to remember some things along those lines. Take care, and Semper Fi!

[@clutchcargo1239]

A 5906... I like mine, it's an older design, it has the peanut shaped trigger guard. It's probably not going to be your favorite, it's kind of heavy compared to many others, but it's accurate enough.

[@clutchcargo1239]

Oops, I misidentified a few of your pistols... Old eyes.👀

[@hrfunk]

No problem. The 5906 is a great pistol. Probably the only thing I would ding it for is it’s weight.

[@izsafe1]

For police work, S&W Mod 13, 66, 19, Colt Trooper, Cold 1911 45, S&W 659, Beretta, Kimber 1911 MM, Para 14 .45, Sig 226, and Sig M17. For the Army (pistols only) 1911A1 and M9.

[@krashdude1]

great presentation

[@hrfunk]

Thank you!

[@krashdude1]

@@hrfunk Also the fact that you went with the .40 is different than most gun people today. I saw a great video a couple years back where someone had a way of explaining the different characteristics of recoil between 9mm, 40, and 45 ACP. It displayed a graph of the recoil which included the "torque" of the recoil. which kind of translated to the type of movement from each caliber. What I took away was that 9mm and 45 acp, although different in amount, the type of recoil was similar. Whereas the .40 twisted from side to side significantly more.than the other two. Kind of like the 9 and 45 were more up and down, front to back, and the 40 included much more side to side movement. Cannot find that video at the moment. I still have my Glock 22.

[@richardlinares4616]

That great list of handguns.

[@mhlittleton6493]

Love your videos, Howard. I always learn something and truly enjoy watching them! Would love to see one on your all-time favorite off-duty CCW pistol as well.

[@hrfunk]

Thank you! I've had so many off-duty firearms over the years, and many of them are gone, so I don't think I could really put that one together. Sorry!

[@mhlittleton6493]

hrfunk No problem, that’s totally understandable. I’d say you’ve been through quite a few. Thanks anyway!

[@johncitizen3927]

my all time best carry, colt series 80, .45 cocked and locked...fer 35+ years....

[@LUVDOGS1954]

"1911 or "unsubscribe" !!! " said the grouchy old man.

[@walterminer4990]

Lol! I agree to a point. I carried them for 4 decades. Actually, to me a safer pistol to carry regarding striker pistols. Today, people are concerned with capacity? If you are a "hard spot" you most likely won't need 15 of 17 rounds of ammo. In 2-3 shots things are done 99% of the time. It will happen at close distance usually. Maybe in a parking lot 7-10 yards? Be good at those distances, hopefully you will be fine! Best to ya',,,,!

[@LUVDOGS1954]

@@walterminer4990 I was being a curmudgeon and teasing the Chief. I do like striker pistols and rely on them. It's just that I shot so much 1911 through the years. And yes, 7+1 in a 1911 is enough for me.

[@ftdefiance1]

@@walterminer4990 I got that. A Glock and Colt both have light take up 5 pound triggers

[@walterminer4990]

@@LUVDOGS1954 Well, with age I got into poly guns in 2015! So, I carry a higher capacity now too. But, being two 1911 guys I will admit a poly gun to me, just don't feel like a gun! Sounds weird but I know you understand! I know you understand a 1911 trigger will help many shooters shoot better, (If they try), than a poly gun! Your thoughts on this?

[@walterminer4990]

@@ftdefiance1 YES! However, any decent 1911 with the straight trigger pull aids a shooter! Only my opinion. Heck, I tried the new Taurus G3. That trigger to me is awesome! So I bought the G2C and the G3. Very accurate, no issues. In all honesty, I can't go to the range a shoot a few hundreds rounds a week today! My shop carries ammo. Priced a little high but fairly priced considering when the owner showed me his cost! I bought 50 rounds of Federal .124 grain HST which you know is +P and it was $50 a box. A $1.00 a round. Their target ammo $25 a box, That seems high, but I have seen it on-line for even more unless you buy a case lot! Best to ya',,,,!

[@tomtruesdale6901]

Great video H.R. , that was like watching a parent pick their favorite child. I know the 1911A1 I carried in the Marine Corps was made long before I was born and rattled like a box of rocks but I did shoot it very well. I have carried Model 66 4", S&W 6906, CS-1, Glock 17, G19 and G26 issued and I carried a personal Glock 22 and 27 for the last 10 years on the job. EDC now is my G27 or Ruger EC9s.

[@hrfunk]

That’s a great list in its own right Tom. Isn’t it amazing how they grow on us? It must have something to do with our living with them day in and day out. Not to mention trusting our lives to them!

[@tomtruesdale6901]

@@hrfunk You are correct Sir I just wish I could see and shoot as good as I did back in the 1987-2010.

[@davidhawthorne7423]

I found this one very informative, because I recognized, and used only one of the eight. I promise to watch again, slow you down and take notes.

[@hrfunk]

Thanks Dave!

[@derweibhai]

Nebraska County Sheriff here. Started initially carrying a S&W 386 .357 7 shot revolver. Completed Basic with a Glock 23, then carried a Beretta 96for a short time. Traded that for a CZ75 SAO in .40. Since I made Chief Deputy and now also as Sheriff I carry a Sig Sauer Traditional Match Elite 1911 in .40. Rifle quals with the pistol are a breeze. The only way I will switch again is if I find a deal on the same Sig in 9mm.

[@hrfunk]

That's an impressive line-up of handguns Sheriff! It sounds like you ended up with a winner too. Sigs have never been my cup of tea, but I'm glad yours works well for you. Thanks for watching!

[@derweibhai]

@@hrfunk Me either, but they make nice 1911's.

[@anthonybarkasysr5029]

I'm not in law enforcement, so for my purpose the m&p 40 with the surefire x400 light and Lazer serves the same way. A bit heavier than the core model .and I can still use the open sights if the lazer fails.

[@hrfunk]

I hope that continues to work well for you!

[@anthonybarkasysr5029]

@@hrfunk Thanks for the good words, I'm sure they would last forever. Both of them are built like a tanks. And thanks for your service Sir. Maybe you will do a series on wepons lights.

[@buckaroo550]

36 years as an LEO, carried 1911 Combat Commander and a S&W 686 .357 Mag. Never had to carry a dept issued Glock or Sig always was well armed

[@hrfunk]

Yep. It sounds like you were quite well armed!

[@arthuroubre7562]

My favorite duty pistol is my Springfield Range Officer Operator with a 38 Super barrel. My least favorite was my S&W 4006 with the aluminum frame.

[@hrfunk]

That Springfield chambered for the Super cartridge must be a great pistol. I have an American Classic II chambered for that cartridge and I love it!

[@82lowe36id]

You should check out the M2.0 optics ready LE only model. I'm really looking at the 5 inch 9mm model. They have suppressor height sights and true front serrations.

[@hrfunk]

I have yet to see one. When I finally do, I’ll be interested to see how much it’s improved from my 1.0.

[@danielberry6060]

I'd love to see you put a red dot on your 2od gen MP9 and then try to decide between the last two. I'd like to think I know your choise. Here's a thought for off duty, full size MP9 slide and bbl on a compact frame. 15 rd mag with a 17 rd w/ sleeve as reload.

[@70bonnevilleguy53]

I have a Brinks issued 4046 and love it.

[@jamesonlange7723]

I enjoy the M&P line greatly. My first handgun I purchased was an older M&P9 full-size. Then I picked up the M&P compact, which is now considered the sub-compact. However, after discovering a S&W SW99 in 9mm in a local pawn shop, and shooting said pistol, I enjoyed it so much that I ended up selling the M&P sub-compact to a buddy, to keep the SW99. My sights are definitely set on the M&P 2.0 compact, 4-inch barrel as my all around gun. Until I get one, however, I’ll keep carrying my SW99, and my Metro Arms American Classic Commander 1911 in .45. That one makes a great church/barbecue gun too.

[@hrfunk]

I carried an SW99 for 7 years as a duty pistol. I thought it was a pretty good pistol and I shot it well. The M&P pistols feel a little better in my hand, but the SW99 is still a good option. The only issue you might run into is replacing parts. I was trying to find a new recoil spring for mine a year or so ago, and they are difficult to locate.

[@jamesonlange7723]

hrfunk the SW99 is pretty ergonomic in my opinion, but I agree, the M&P overall has probably the best ergonomics in a stock striker-fired pistol platform. Thanks for the heads up about parts! Did you try Numrich Gun Parts? They often have parts for uncommon firearms.

[@hrfunk]

@@jamesonlange7723 No, I ended up getting the recoil spring assembly from Midway when they came in stock there.

[@Stoney_AKA_James]

Good video! When I started my LE career in 1984, I too carried a 1911A1. Then in 1990, I became a Federal contractor, and carried a S&W 66, then later a S&W 686. Later we switched to a Glock 17, then a G22, which I still carry. Since the FBI is going back to carrying 9mm pistols we (DHS) will probably be transitioning to a Glock 9mm as well (don't know which model yet). My personal EDC is a Glock 30S, I chose it because it can use my 13 round G21/G41 mags, and of course I'm a big 45ACP fan!

[@hrfunk]

That’s another great line up of LE handguns. If you have to switch back to the 9mm, you’re likely going to miss those big .45cartridges. Do you know which 9mm load the FBI is using?

[@Stoney_AKA_James]

@@hrfunk Sorry for the delayed response, we've been busy lately!! As a firearms instructor I did not recommend the 9mm for duty and carry due to a lack of good expanding bullets. But 10-15 years ago ammo manufacturers were "pressed" by agencies and citizens to develop better bullets/powder loads. And yes, you are correct about me missing my .45 ACP Federal HST 230gr +P JHP, although Iwill continueto carry those rounds in my G21 and G41!! Like with the FBI, we will probably switch to the Glock 17M and utilize Hornady Critical Duty 9mm 135-grain ammo, which is what I was told passed the FBI ballistic testing. Although I am not really a fan of their 15 inch penetration requirement into gel AFTER passing through barriers, I just think that is too close to being over penetration! I hope this helps!

[@hrfunk]

Thanks for the info. I was just curious. Best of luck with the new pistols and stay safe!

[@topg9555]

Awesome video and a trip down memory lane! I had roughly the same LE career span as you, although I was an investigator the entire time. At one time or another I have used all of those guns: S&W 459 9mm, S&W 1076 10mm, SW99 .40, S&W 3953 DAO and S&W M&P .40. Also used the S&W 645 .45 ACP, S&W SW40F .40, and SIG P220 .45. All useful sidearms in their own way. I have to disagree though, in that my favorite was a Glock - Model 23 .40. Concerning RDS pistols - I don't think they are quite ready for prime time with the vast majority of LE. For the expert, when properly set up, perhaps.... but nearly all are mounted too high on the pistol. Reliability is still an issue, as is speed/accuracy at typical close-in distances. This is especially true for the majority of LE which are NOT gun people, and have limited development of muscle memory and instinctive shooting for when the RDS is either not immediately visible, or mechanically/environmentally fails.

[@steveelrino1339]

One of my favorite videos of yours, I’ve watched it several times. I always wonder what your thoughts were at the time going from DA to the crisp m&p fully cocked striker trigger. Thank you for t your service and the nice videos.

[@hrfunk]

The SW99 was sort of a middle step. The M&P really was nice just for the fact that I only had to manage 1 trigger pull. Even so, the single-action trigger on the SW99 (P99) was really impressive.

[@mausercal65]

I’ve got the same problem, finally had to get glasses a year ago .

[@hrfunk]

So far, I only need reading glasses, but I’m afraid that will change someday.

[@jwilsonhandmadeknives2760]

same here. I’ve become extremely short armed... er farsighted. Now I am struggling between wearing glasses to see my front sight post or taking my glasses off to be able to see anything else.

[@straightpipec6099]

Nice 👍

[@hrfunk]

Thanks ✌

[@richki.24]

I like the entire line-up ...

[@hrfunk]

Thanks. I do too!

[@richardwaid4718]

I have a Canik TP9 sfx and absolutely love it. What a shooter! And value for what you get for your $.

[@hrfunk]

So I have heard. I have not had the opportunity to shoot one yet.

[@bates.k.r.]

Great video

[@azcop2]

I did the same. I carried a S&W 586, S&W 5903, Glock 19, and Glock 22. I served in LE for 32 years.

[@hrfunk]

That’s a great line-up. If I may ask, which was your favorite?

[@azcop2]

@@hrfunk I loved my 586, but was really limited for LE. Was a good choice at the time.