My Favorite MAC Eyeshadows

[@virginia_plain_coquette]

Would you be able to put the shadows from your palette that you didn't talk about in the info bar? Awesome video and love your eye makeup here!

[@amandapotter9084]

I love your style. You're hair cut is absolutely amazing and fits your face shape perfectly

[@cayleemedlin9554]

You sold me on Plumage, and I'm so happy you did! I absolutley love it. Thanks!

[@melthompson2856]

+Caylee Medlin yay!!!!!!

[@shaunellmacgloan1087]

Sketch! Hands down BEST shadow for my hazel eyes💗👍I would NOT want to love without this shade...like ever!😊I will say I have been really diggin' Contrast in the outer V with Grain on the lid and Bamboo in the crease lately😊

[@emmagross6421]

Yesterday while searching for Natasha Denona, one of your vids popped up and oh my goodness lady, you are AMAZING. Can't stop watching your videos! You explain your techniques clearly, you create stunning looks, and hello, you are absolutely gorgeous.

[@melthompson2856]

+Emma Gross Thank you so much!!!!!!!

[@blackscorpiolady]

I keep watching your videos lately,you are AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!Please please please,make a purple smokey night out make up video!Love you!!!!!!!!Keep on just like that,be blessed!

[@mrsdoccjb]

Ellie and I just love you!! We are MAC addicts for sure! Loving our new palettes!!

[@melthompson2856]

I love you both!!!! I hope to see you again!!!

[@80sChicwithglasses]

This is great! I bought a Mac pre made palette, and going to exchange to make my own. It's a bit more expensive, but I'll have all colors that I know I'll use and love. Great suggestions as I wrote them all down to swatch for myself. I'm making a palette with neutrals and a few warm and cool pops of color. Thanks, this was awesome!

[@shaheily13]

omg! you have no idea how much I appreciate this video. it really hard to find a palette that I really like, sonic will build one and your favorites will definitely be part of it. thank you gorgeous.

[@melthompson2856]

+shaheily13 It's so much easier to just pick out your own. That way, you know that you like all the colors :)

[@donnalaz6777]

Hi puffins wife lol love mac shadows my go to . to many to mention but I'd love a smoked out winged liner tutorial if u could

[@AnaHernandez-td6nr]

I love the quality of your videos! I really appreciate that you do swaps on the side. :)

[@FuriedHearts]

OMG.... so I used to be into makeup artistry like five years ago and haven't been into it since. Randomly the other night I suddenly remembered your face and remember watching your videos but I couldn't remember your KZbin name and knew I had probably unsubbed. I just spent the last 30 minutes typing random things into the search bar "mac cosmetics review" and scrolling and scrolling and scrolling until I found this video. Seeing your videos again is so nostalgic. I'm not into makeup that much anymore but I used to be obsessed with your videos

[@DRmakeupgirl]

I'm a new subscriber to your channel and I'm loving your content. You have beautiful eyes! Just what I've always wanted instead of what I've got. As a makeup lover I appreciate the time and effort you put into your videos. I only have 2 MAC eye shadows- Blanc Type/Soft Brown. I think both are discontinued now. Do you have any recommendations for replacing those shades from another brand? I know some suggest Wet & Wilds Creme Brulee for Blanc Type and a Makeup Geek shade for the Soft Brown. Would you agree?

[@dianaschulz8101]

Thank you for the walk through of these shades. I have had so much fun with the eye colors since I have started watching your videos! I don't have Plumage yet, however, I would also like to see a look with that one. That will most likely be my next purchase in eye colors! XOXOXOX

[@melthompson2856]

+Diana Schulz I have gotten a few requests for that color! So it will happen!

[@debonolara]

I love woodwinked and sable.. Can you create an everyday a look using satin taupe pls?

[@katyj1120]

Your channel gives me life!😍 can I ask if you could possibly recommend an alternative for brightening under the eyes as I have the Nars concealer but shows my lines up so much. thanks!

[@melthompson2856]

+Katy Jay That's the reason i don't like to wear that concealer anymore too! I have been using the urban decay naked concealer. I like it a lot

[@huhawond]

How come you don't have more views? You're definitely my favorite makeup youtuber at the moment.

[@melthompson2856]

+janina luckier hopefully one day!!! XOXOXO thank you!

[@oceanequestrian11]

I would LOVE to see a tutorial on the makeup you have going on in this video 😍😍😍

[@melthompson2856]

+Ocean Equestrian There's one up for it :)

[@t0nibear]

I loved this video. I'm still in the process of filling up my palette & so far I've picked up deep damson after watching your video. I love it!!!!! Would you mind sharing just the names of the shadows that you didn't mention in the video???? :)

[@dsmrt8759]

Coquette look, pls! ;-) And Trax look too! Much love

[@dayanachaves4231]

Love those colors, great choices and faves! tfs

[@jmw9450]

My favorite Mac eyeshadows are: for a pop of color on my lowerlash line *freshwater *Shroom *Nylon *Greensmoke *Sumptuous Olive *Texture 😍 *Saddle *Soft Brown *Cranberry *Coppering *Sable 😍 *Satin taupe 😍 *Twinks *Antiqued *Star violet😍

[@melthompson2856]

+J MW Sumptuous Olive is so good!

[@jmw9450]

+Puffins Wife I forgot another favorite: Woodwinked!

[@sharonaviram24]

Please please please swatch all your palette like you did with these!!!! The colors come out just as they look irl! Pleaseeeee! x Also which eyeshadow along with Brun would be good for brows like yours? I have a duo palette I want to fill!

[@melthompson2856]

I do :) Every swatch I take is always in the some spot in my house, natural light :)

[@susanguerra8452]

Your eye look here is beautiful!

[@christinamendez9352]

Love your picks, and just at the right time w the price drop to $6 for pans!!! Also, what green shadow are u wearing? I love how it jumps out on camera!

[@melthompson2856]

+Christina Mendez MAC A Harvest of Green Mineralize Quad :)

[@flowercitaschnauzer1033]

Mel, love the video. .. have you ever tried Makeup Geek shadows and if so, how would you compare them to our beloved MAC? running to look at the names of all my mac favs..lol

[@melthompson2856]

+Flowercita Schnauzer I'm actually trying to buy manny's palette right now! No luck thus far. I figured it would be a good way to try them out..

[@aliciahuidor]

Omg!!! I'm just watching this video and Nylon is my favorite, can you do a look using Nylon and plumage?

[@jackieturner4144]

hay my angel I'm back again October 2023 miss your laugh your loving personality and your presents rip my beauty always ❤❤❤ xx

[@rodicahan4173]

i wish wish you talk more in details about your other favorite mac eyeshadow!

[@KaylaAston]

So many beautiful shadows! P.S. Loving that lipstick on you :)

[@melthompson2856]

+Kayla Aston Thank you!!!

[@LivingCavalier]

PLEASE do a look with Plumage. I have it and I never use it. Thank you

[@jesstar143]

+LivingCavalier I agree id love to see a look with this color as well!!

[@starrfeef]

I was 21 in 1998 and I just have to say, Nylon was a thing back then and there are/were WAAAAY more applications for it than just an inner corner highlighter..... : / It remains a favorite for me and my friends/associates..... I love Mel!! She has opened my eyes to so much stuff since I started watching make-up tutorials lately.... but she is the 2nd today that I have seen say that Nylon is best used for just an inner corner highlighter...LOL SMH. Tsk tsk tsk.....

[@juliabaker3194]

could you please do a dark lip, grungy tutorial? I have way too many ideas on how this could be done but I can't decide. lol p.s. rocking the green glitter shadow

[@maggiemay570]

can you do an eyeshadow tutorial using deep damson on crease with like gold or pink xoxoxo

[@suecone2198]

I hope I can find some of these colors since this isn’t a recent video! Thanks 🙏

[@KeishaCapers1279]

Thanks so much for this try to pick up a few :)

[@jslilimauve]

Taking notes. ❤️😊

[@darkynprincess2317]

Can you do a tutorial on the MAC eye gloss? I have the black, blue & cinderella white, I'm only missing the taupe i think but I don't know how to use them. I saw Chloe Morello had a tutorial and watched but she doesn't reply to her comments because several people asked if they transferred on hooded eyes and how to use them.

[@nadinekeating3255]

so sad they discontinued Brown Script 😯 They seem to discontinue their nicest shades! Like wtf would a makeup company discontinue their hands down most beautiful basic matte warm neutral?? Just makes absolutely no sense! ! 😕

[@melthompson2856]

It may not be discontinued anymore...a few shadows were taken off the "phase out" list....thankfully!

[@amberbarton2218]

No such thing as a dumb question... Yeah right I've got one haha 😂 that's a MAC palette without inserts right? How do the shadows stay in? I know... Please educate me! 😊

[@melthompson2856]

+Amber Barton lol, that's not dumb!!! It is! and they are magnetic so it just stays put because there's magnets on the back of the shadows and the palette is metal :)

[@Kmz_91]

Can you make a makeup geek favorite shadows?

[@jillmoore1455]

would love it if you listed all shadows on each side just for reference

[@ncsquared1006]

Hey Puffins Wifey!! If you didn't yet, maybe check out those MUFE Artist Shadows...they blend insanely well!! I bought like 30 of them...SIENNA & MORELLO CHERRY (check those two out) I can totally see you rockin' them!!! I'm in to the reds, warm caramel shades/oranges, as yourself. Thanks for the awesome tutorials, they really are good!!

[@melthompson2856]

+Nikki Cubito will do! Thank you!

[@cayleemedlin9554]

Holy shit! I remember you helping me out at the MAC store inside of the Nashville mall. How weird

[@melthompson2856]

+Caylee Medlin LOL!!! Small world, huh???

[@sithwinch]

I kept thinking I know this chica from somewhere...yep GH Mall... Nashville TN. Good to see you girlie 😊 I'm still collecting these palette ready beauties. And you helped me too. Xoxo

[@psydrlee]

Will you do a tutorial using plumage?

[@melthompson2856]

I think I could manage that 💜💜💜

[@dirtybloodyheart]

You're deep damson looks so much better than mine.

[@GBFandCo]

Ok I am going through your videos looking for Puffin. Bamboo use to be my jam with corduroy. I probably had them for 8 years. I am going to pull them out and put them back in rotation. So, where the heck is Puffin?

[@melthompson2856]

LOL, Puffin REFUSES to come on camera. He doesn't understand at all why anyone would want to see him lol. I sneak attack him on snap chat tho

[@ChitChatBFF]

Subscribed :)

[@melthompson2856]

+Irrri Descence Thank you!

[@trisharader7926]

🥰

[@blackandwhite1626]

Wait! What store?

[@cindypltnm]

I love bamboo for brow bone highlight on my skin tone. I was saddened to see Mac dc it. Why Mac, why must you do this?! lol

[@cindypltnm]

I do have a backup. But do you know of any other retailer still have bamboo in stock.

[@melthompson2856]

+cindypltnm agreeeeed!!!!!!

[@melthompson2856]

+cindypltnm I'm not sure. I would check online with places like Macy's, Nordstrom and Belk

[@sukhdeepsandhuvlogs]

Omg I love ❤️ your nature love on ur body

[@goldieadeline1228]

Miss you, Mel😔

[@melissaowens6031]

think of it like a peacock's plumes. PLUME- age

[@melissaowens6031]

and u r sooo stunning and gorg u can wear ne color. if i wore sum of those i wud look insane!!!!! (my eyes r blue, but brown eyed girls can WEAR ANYTHING!!!!)

[@melthompson2856]

+Melissa Owens Thank you, doll!!! Blue eyes are gorgeous all by themselves!!!

[@ilarialoforese6768]

make-up tutorial please

[@whitestripes101]

LOVE THIS!! wanna follow eachother!

[@julieanna7061]

💞🦉🐝🐦🐛✨