My Ideal Rheneas

[@TankEngine97]

I like your way of incorporating the whole pronouncing engines's names and location they're named after.

[@PowaOfTheFlowa]

FINALLY! A video where there are no arguments let’s go!!

[@LukeOfSodor22]

I had an idea about the narrow gauge representation Skarloey and Rheneas: Talyllyn railway Sir Handel and Peter sam: Corris railway Rusty: Represents all narrow gauge diesels Duncan: Royal Air force Narrow gauge engines Ivo Hugh: Bord na mona Duke: Ffestiniog railway Fred: National Coal Board

[@Cashtron-d8b]

still makes them carbon copies of the Talyllyn Railway, and if Duncan represents the Royal Air force narrow gauge engines, then why not have him work in a fort on sodor then, but still have him interact with the SKR engines.

[@LukeOfSodor22]

​@@Cashtron-d8b I think Duncan could be a replacement for the MOD engines sent out for the SKR during WW2 since Duncan's basis Douglas is an engine who worked for the RAF and eventually Duncan is purchased from the RAF

[@Cashtron-d8b]

@@LukeOfSodor22 I like that Idea too, though I don't think he would have a scottish accent since the reason why he talks that way in the RWS is because he worked in a factory in scotland. But I don't like the idea of Duncan being number three instead of Sir Handel, what I would do is have Duncan work at the MOD base on the SKR, it would be in one of two quarries that the SKR has in my headcanon. And he sometimes has to take trains away from the fort to either Crovan's Gate, or the wharf.

[@LukeOfSodor22]

​@@Cashtron-d8b IDK if awdry was planning to have Duncan be Scottish since unlike the Scottish twins or Neil, Duncan doesn't have any Scottish dialect I think the only reason Duncan is Scottish is because Willie Rushton gave him an accent. Also maybe there could be a connection from the MoD fort to the SKR since bad manorred himself said in his ideal Murdoch video there are a few parts of narrow gauge lines around the island so maybe one of those was the connection with the SKR and maybe in the late 50s the fort closes due to lack of traffic and Duncan was sold on to the SKR. And maybe the reason why Duncan is so grumpy and rebellious is because he got severe trauma from WW2 and he would be worked to death during the war and that's why he always says that he gets no rest.

[@WitchWerewolfEdd]

Ideal Sir Handel

[@ExtraEngine1]

Ideal George, I have seen Sir Topham Hatt’s railway and I like how George interacts with the standard gauge engines.

[@comicfan1324]

Bit of an out there idea, but what would be your ideal version of Billy? Would he be less annoying or would you dial up the annoying factor to such a degree where that’s the joke (making it that he’s intentionally a character no one is supposed to like)? Would he still have the same basis and color scheme or would he change drastically? Alternatively, you could just design him to be a pile of scrap metal in the scrapyard. That would also be welcome change.

[@comicfan1324]

0:54 Wait a minute, when did Smudger get here jokes aside, even though I would personally keep him red or orange, I applaud, thinking outside the box and doing your own thing. One thing I do definitely agree with having the running board and buffers be black. It’s just more distinct. (not to mention with the original models it was red on red, which just makes it blended too much) Also, I like the edit overall

[@TankEngine97]

For the next ideal character: I'd say Annie and Clarabel. I'm curious to hear if you have them in their RWS look or TVS look.

[@TobyOliverHenryFan]

Oddly enough, I have been thinking of either repainting my knock-off TWR Smudger to be Rheneas or just have Rheneas be green. Personally, I would repaint him, but into a very similar livery to James'.

[@karenfan010]

now he’s just smudger.

[@trainspeer3100]

real

[@ppikexwworld_9999]

True tho

[@PowaOfTheFlowa]

facts tho 🥶🥶🥶

[@ThomasSirHandel]

Especially in the Hit era if he were green he'd just be Smudger

[@joshuaW5621]

Smudger can’t exist for the same reason as Norman I guess.

[@PowaOfTheFlowa]

To be honest, We NEED Arthur, He is literally perfect for this series, And you already had done Murdoch so it would only be fair if you did Arthur next.

[@xtremeyoylecake]

Ur pfp and name are cool

[@Noah_Adams]

1 I got to say despite the fact i would Keep most of the characters in there TVS Livery's that Fully Black buffer beam look slick. 2 In terms of the next character the next few Skarloey railway engines make logical sense so probably Sir Handel or Falcon.

[@auraknight1004]

Very good edits. Now Rheneas looks like Smudger, but with his face still on him.

[@Cashtron-d8b]

I'd like to see Sir Handel next. Also now that I think of it, yeah the running board and buffer beam looks better when it's not red, mainly because it means the engine has more color separation, and black is probably the next best color for a running board and buffer beam.

[@TankEngineMedia]

It’s a nice compromise to have different pronunciations of the engine and location!

[@BringMayFlowers]

It's not "clyn", it's more like "hlyn", with the tongue pushed just a bit more up against the mouth than an L sound so that it almost whistles coming out. Similarly, "xh", not "ck" for the ch sound.

[@MJC19]

I wonder if when he decides to do Duke, he will go the opposite direction and instead of an England class he will do a Mainline Hunslet with a modified saddle tank? And I love what you did with the naming convention, keep on going

[@KippaCrash]

I'll say it again... WE NEED ARTHUR!!!!

[@Leonardo-cw1dd]

hm green face for rheneas…i keep getting shrek vibes

[@robobird3383]

A problem I have with painting the SR engines in TR liveries is that it makes it near impossible to distinguish the fictional and real locos. Not that I'm insulting your opinion, I just prefer the Skarloey Railway to have its own livery.

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

Don't worry from what I've seen on his deviantart account Brasspolish Peter Sam (and by extension Sir Handel) will probably sport their Corris Railway Red liveries

[@joshuaW5621]

This is why the people who take issue with Norman being the same class as Dennis are hypocrites for giving the Skarloey, Culdee Fell and Arlesdale railways a free pass.

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Perhaps you could do Sir Handel next?

[@noahmaybin1781]

Emily next! By the way, why are the engines' faces in your ideal verse colored?

[@Heres_Domix]

He just thinks they look nice.

[@Sudriantank743]

Have you considered making Oliver a metro tank?

[@daringpyrritator7163]

He wanted Oliver to be a unique tank engine to a side tank.

[@Sudriantank743]

But he could just be a 14xx rebuilt as a back tank

[@karenfan010]

well since you’ve done skalroey and rheneas it’s only fair you do sir handel and peter pam next that way the four little engines roster will be complete.

[@LukeOfSodor22]

Maybe Duke

[@hudsontrainguy1217]

Do Sir Handel next

[@deborah1116]

sir handle and Peter Sam please

[@CrazyFilms2024]

Ya got some Rhayonaise?

[@Aussie_TTTEFan_2008]

I kinda want to see what your ideal Stanley next

[@Bearthediesel]

Sir Handel please

[@PurplePurplePurple26]

I can’t be the only one who sees Smudger in this

[@CuldeeandGodred_p]

You could maybe do an ideal take on the Märklin Engine next, if he exists in your AU

[@caledonianproduction]

Great idea

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

He does actually, his name is Phillippe, he is a SECR 4-4-0 He is also the engine who was pulling the train that Henry crashed into in the flying kipper

[@reeceemms1643]

Continuing with my regular list: Lady Emily Diesel 10 Rosie Duke Cranky Splatter Dodge Arry Burt Sir Topham Hatt

[@CreativeTankEngine]

I think Sir Handel would be interesting to see next.

[@ScorchZaneTrains]

Sir Handel or Arthur would be nice to see

[@NVRacingProductions]

Let's do ideal Spencer, Neville, Arthur or Sir Handel. I found some basis's to your UNIQUE AU.

[@GreatEasternStudios123]

Ideal sir handel

[@ericAviles-hy9gm]

Rheneas basically became smudger

[@Peckettw42012]

Sir handel is probably next

[@mr.meloetta1939]

bit of a long shot, but I'd really love to see you do Salty at some point

[@EternityKingdomsHeadHoncho]

I see Smudger got eyebrow reduction surgery Glad to hear that you’re not entirely axing the Talyllyn rep on the SKR. And what better duo to keep as Talyllyn clones than the two who started the whole railway?

[@branchlineshunter]

Question. what's your opinion on 98462 otherwise known as Alfred the B12

[@jjcuriel]

I think you should do sir handle

[@Hayden-ph1ld]

Suger,sir hadel,Peter sam, rusty, duke,Dan ein and ivo hwho

[@HenryLongfellow-lw2gq]

Can we see elaboration on Eunice and Mildred

[@Pusherthepush]

Could you do Sir Handel?

[@theneogamer6917]

How about Duke?

[@Damon_Drawings]

Arthur would be pretty damn cool

[@E4ridingagain]

Actually curious on how you'll do Billy

[@sarahziegler1582]

Sir Handel Next

[@savagegardenfan9680]

How About Sir Handel.

[@nathanchan4653]

Ideal Thomas’ Special Coach a.k.a Roly

[@fireflowerfilms2010]

His ideal fat controller will be skinny

[@thatonedude_84]

Do Neville and/or Rosie next (suggestion: loaned during wartime for extra traffic)

[@mrbluebelltrain55]

Ideal Peter Sam and sir Handel next please

[@ExtraEngine1]

A bit unrelated but do the double ended diesel locomotives such as BoCo, Bear, Derek, etc have two faces on each end in your au or do they not? Sorry for my bad English.

[@MagicLampStudios]

Nope.

[@ExtraEngine1]

@@MagicLampStudiosSo if they have to take a train the other direction do they have to have their face pointed towards the train? Seems pretty awkward.

[@MagicLampStudios]

@@ExtraEngine1 If a one-cabbed tank engine can do it, a two-cabbed diesel can do it.

[@OhTheIndignity]

It would be nice if you could do Sir Handel next

[@ThatOneBaboon]

Can you do Sir Handel next?

[@jacobrumens9601]

Try Duncan next.

[@garrettwhitaker2517]

Can we do molly?

[@DaxProductions4124]

Could you do Neville

[@Changchun_CHINARAILWAY]

it's me💀💀☠️☠️

[@NexusWorks924]

Could you do toad next

[@SirEzaq60163]

Hey Badmanoredproductions can you post more often the video was amazing though

[@elliotthamilton1361]

Why do you color the faces?

[@Steamenginefan]

peter sam next?

[@LNERJ15]

Do Stanley (Great Discovery) next

[@scifiguy9000]

Ha! Knew he was going to be green! Wait, would your take on Peter Sam be green too? What if nearly ALL the Skarleoy Engines minus Duke and Rusty are green? Would Sir Handel even be green or go blue or red to be 'unique' until Rusty came along and Duke returned into his life? ...Or maybe I am overthinking this too much... Also, either Sir Handel or Peter Sam next.

[@Cashtron-d8b]

I think its safe to say his take on sir handel is red, along with his ideal petersam

[@npk765fan]

Sir Handel or Peter Sam next please

[@paulbogsinske]

He looks like a toy knockoff turned into something more developed

[@trainspeer3100]

you basicly made him into smuger, and something i dont like about these ideal thomas engines is that you make the face the same colour as the loco 'just saying and you're ideal engines are realy good'

[@Cashtron-d8b]

no he didn't make him into smudger, he just made him green to match skarloey.

[@trainspeer3100]

@@Cashtron-d8b true but im not the only one who sayed that

[@uncertain_tug]

duncan?

[@isakdahlgren8335]

yes fanely renas i love your vidios

[@PerpIsPerp]

Reminds me of something-

[@uncertain_tug]

ivo hugh?

[@uncertain_tug]

Sir Handel?

[@tred6292]

Why do you change the color of the face to resemble the engine’s paint color and not their smokebox color? This is not a complain. I am merely curious.

[@bobkolterjahn4266]

Is Sir Handel next?

[@therailwaymen2203]

I’d say Arthur or Sir Handel

[@jonathanthebigredengine]

Why Do I Wanna See His Ideal 98462 & 87546?

[@joshuaW5621]

I don’t know if that’s likely to happen given how obscure those two are.

[@funnytitanicfans6048]

Ideal sir handle Plz

[@ShuntersTruckStudios]

Duncan please

[@caledonianproduction]

Peter Sam please

[@thomaseadbhardmcqueen7511]

I'd like to see Terence

[@amymcphee6000]

Why is his face Green????????

[@RicardoGaming09]

Do Arthur or for April fools do Billy or charlie

[@Graysonthegreenivatt2MT]

Duncan plz

[@Dat-Mudkip]

I personally think you should have given Rheneas a black face. It would have matched his paintwork better. ...I also completely understand why you _didn't_ do that.

[@johnathonmcjohn3]

aw hell nah 💀💀💀

[@Dduedulz]

Make Ideal Ryan

[@uncertain_tug]

Peter Sam?

[@thewiseoldowlproductions6127]

Smudger!

[@SpilledCocoa457]

ITS SMUDGER

[@amymcphee6000]

No it's not read his nameplate

[@Siderodstudios]

Do emily or sir hanny

[@Ohiocentral1293-rf8xf]

Do Hank

[@PCMan8922]

Peter Sam or Duncan? In My Headcanon, Duncan Is a Blue Female. You Should Try The Same.

[@ppikexwworld_9999]

No

[@PCMan8922]

@@ppikexwworld_9999, Yes.

[@Imoptimusprimevlogs]

This is just smudger.

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

Who in turn was just Dolgoch

[@johnathonmcjohn3]

ttte fans when they go to the talyllyn railway and see dolgoch (they are green)

[@Imoptimusprimevlogs]

When you think about it, what if Dulgoch was made green in remembrance of his fallen brother

[@stevenmosco20]

aurthur or sir handle

[@therailwaymen2203]

I legit thought of Arthur or Sir Handle and commented it before seeing this comment lol

[@jonathantheexperimentalengine]

pheneyas

[@daniel4518]

Nex Arthur

[@SillyDartPony]

Oh! That's why they're green