My Police Interaction Without an ID

[@Robin.Greenfield]

Hello Dear Friends For those interested in why I don't have an ID and for answers to the most commonly asked questions about my life without an ID, I wrote this article for you: www.robingreenfield.org/identification/ Love, Robin

[@hilly2777]

@@Robin.Greenfield I understand and respect your reasons for not having proper ID. But I don't think it would be a good idea if everyone did it for the reasons I gave in my comment.

[@jean6453]

​@@hilly2777 well good thing it is still legal to not have an ID, let's keep it that way and not make the US like Germany in the 2nd ww. We should All be free in our person.

[@FirstofallPure]

You could ask a friend to print a few copies of that article for any curious officers. It explains things beautifully.

[@RavenNMonster]

Things may not be so simple with Trump round 2.

[@King_Jones_Junk_Removal]

As a black man Robbie, thank you so much for sharing your experience. Myself been pulled over a couple times and because of the perception of who I am has made this happen. Luckily, I always been raised to become cool and collect, which allow me to tell my story to this day. I’ve never been locked up, never been arrested. I do have a GED, but also a masters degree and currently a educator. Yes the US has a misconception of people of color and we all know this. You cannot turn the blind eye and ignore the truth. Thanks for sharing your experience much love my brother.

[@goodandgreen]

no one is illegal. your approach speaking about your skin color and gender bringing you safety is crucial, and yet those are ideas some humans made up, both are true. thank you for speaking your truth. you have my respect and love. safe footsteps!

[@k1ng_chicken]

I’ve been hearing a lot of “your truth,” what does that mean?

[@xochipilli8238]

​@k1ng_chicken something people say to make eachother feel better about their white guilt social justice warrior nonsense

[@Boom-yu1ce]

@@k1ng_chicken ”your truth” is slang for “your lived experiences” To “speak your truth” means to speak openly and honestly about your lived experiences, with the understanding that many people have been taught to stay silent because their lived experiences are inconvenient or uncomfortable for others to hear. To “live your truth” means to make your life choices based on what makes most sense to you as opposed to basing those choices on shame and social stigma. Often times slang gets used really inconsistently, that does not seem to be the case here. I’ve seen people from a variety of cultural and political backgrounds use these words to mean essentially the same thing. The denotation is pretty consistent, the connotation less so-if you think someone’s “truth” sucks, you likely want to them to feel shame. To be clear, this is just my observation of how people use these turns of phrase. (I’m a bit of an etymology nerd)

[@jaieatsplants]

Jeanine here! As someone who identifies as a Black woman, I’m so grateful for you as a friend and for sharing, being able to see and speak on privilege. I would LOVE to be seen as a human. Period. We have a lot of isms around the world that don’t allow us to see one another as “a full human being”. Sending you love and a hug. Hope I get to connect with you again for a foraging event! Be well ❤

[@alicetulloch6945]

Love that the Non-Violent Communication techniques helped open up the conversation with the fuzz and the tourists……

[@lizpimentel2566]

Walking on roads should not be illegal or questioned. I wish our society made the roads more walkable and safe for pedestrians. Relying on cars is just a way for the government to control us, unfortunately. You handled this situation very well. I hope the rest of your journey is safe without anymore issues with law enforcement.

[@HoboGardenerBen]

It think it started out as capitalism, not some overarching conspiracy. The early auto manufacturers bought up and dismantled much of the preexisting rail in the country to force people to use cars. That had to include some political manuevering as well, but I don't think that was the origin of the wave, that came from the corporate structure and the pursuit of profit.

[@JacobsTrash]

The right to travel is a constitutionally protected right.

[@derrikarenal3308]

The road didn't build itself.. the point being: we all need to provide labor as material contribution towards any and all desires of improvement. No man should have the power to conjure money out of thin air, that another man has to labor to obtain in order to live.

[@mishaguevara]

Why are 8 Billion Human Beings FORCED at birth to be "citizens" of "Countries " ? Finally a Real Human Brother😊 Thank You❤

[@sweetlampe]

So the Government can have Control over us all. It all comes from our birth Certificates that our mothers signed at our births. Signing their children over to the authorities without knowing it. So we have certificates for everything. We are just numbers to them and Human Resources .🙄

[@susanw8471]

I believe it's something that's progressed from the old adage "it takes a village." Obviously I wasn't around (or certainly don't remember being around) when the first Bipeds morphed and morphed and morphed, but their is safety in numbers (if you're on the same page that is), different skill sets help a group and life is a little bit easier. We have definitely taken it to a ridiculous level, and although change is happening, we're certainly not going to dump countries anytime soon. Read the book when God was a woman sometime if you're interested...

[@humbleServant369]

This is invaluable information! Thank you for your documentation and God bless you!

[@lorrilaque7311]

I love you! The social Construct is based on belief systems that are instilled by the system. Thank you for sharing the awareness of authentic truth!

[@karicassellius3373]

Beautiful share, Robin. You are always an inspiration. I do want to point out to everyone that you're not legally required to show your identification to a cop if you haven't been accused of a crime, though. I love how you are open and honest with everyone.

[@westindz8840]

You are so deeply loved. Thank you for sharing your journey!

[@LMOfficialYT]

Love you Robin. Stay safe and strong ❤ Sending you so much love!

[@1111semprfi]

I walk everywhere, and I don't understand why I never ever ever ever see people out walking, I guess a few are at the local parks, I too hiked around the country when I was 32, it was a blast and I found work in every town to get to the next place, I too have used a 3 wheel baby buggy, they carry a good 30lbs, keep having fun!!

[@raina4732]

They don’t build sidewalks for foot travelers, they really prioritize cars in America. I live in Europe and my children and I walk everywhere or take publican transportation, and lots of parents with kids walk places, not necessarily far distances. But it is quite common to see families going from one village to another via the forest/ through fields, just to have a nice Saturday afternoon. That never happens in America where people drive their car down the street and won’t even walk one block in the sunshine. Edit to say: the police in America think people existing outside is suspicious. Walk or running is discouraged, go inside to a gym if you want to walk, they say. They want empty neighborhoods and roads full of cars and isolated people. It’s scary, it’s not a natural way of living. Also you can’t even pee in the forest there you have to pee in bathrooms built in the natural parks! I’m happy to live in Europe where we can pee even on the side of the road it’s completely legal, and be a little bit more in harmony with nature, picking mushrooms and climbing trees.

[@OnlyFactsPlease]

Excellence personified! True testament to human strength. Love you Robin

[@cosmicchatchant5367]

Right on! You are guiding us to drop our sense of separation - we are all One. Thank you, Robin! You inspire me daily! Best wishes on your beautiful, loving journey💖🙏

[@roykarseboom9185]

Wow, thank you for sharing and for the remainder of how much human beings we and others actually are. Have a great day

[@EcoLogicProject]

Stay strong 💪

[@commonsensepatriot9450]

I often wondered how that would go. I'm glad you had a good experience. Not all cops are created equal. Most are very nice, but not all.

[@givemorephilosophy]

5:20 So true so authentic and so pure. I am free from all delusions Robin and would love to help anyone in the journey to get rid of delusion🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@socksandsandalsASMR]

Thank you for sharing! ❤keep safe in your journey ❤

[@1amissingno]

Appreciate how you acknowledged your privilege and the message to see others as human beings.

[@infinitelove3221]

Robin, you're simply the best!! We love you too.👍👍

[@MamaEvaUSA]

Your “form of ID” is your online presence and definitely your written word! 💖

[@susiemartin6497]

And having a cellular account!

[@AadanmaxamadCusmaan-y8n]

Naa , maxaad aheeydeen🐒

[@AutisticMorty]

Google will eventually ask him to prove his identity and his account will get locked or banned from posting.

[@Darklightflash-z8j]

Not a valide ID ....

[@hugosandstrom4048]

Google account > Passport

[@thelittlehomeaustralia]

I was thinking PRIVILEGE PRIVILEGE PRIVILEGE through the first 5 mins and thankyou so much for your willingness and openness to talk so openly about your privilege in the second half of the video. It's such an important topic in this scenario! Also male versus female privilege and safety on the road is huge as well.... I travelled solo a number of times when I was younger, backpacking and living and the amount of negative/unwanted sexual interactions I experienced was down right petrifying.

[@givemorephilosophy]

@@thelittlehomeaustralia So so true🙏🙏🙏

[@laceras1611]

@@mustbetrue1602 not true lol

[@Wildflower1999]

Well I'm a woman and I do Bushcrafting and a nomad. I've never experienced any sexual harassment. Maybe cause I'm fat. And married. I always travel with my husband.

[@Dheeidjdndbd]

You should know that in all likelihood nothing happened in that town that prompted the officer to engage you. Often police will immediately engage with unrecognized transient humans, essentially to communicate that they are not welcome and are being watched. Stay safe Brother Robin - I am so glad you are a living example of dealing with every one you meet as a person you love and respect.

[@fa7842]

I agree and can i have a reese now?

[@reogrande8020]

Yup, I remember being pulled up as a teen because a group of young people matching our description was apparently smashing bottles, really a tiny girl in a cloak, a goth guy in a skirt and platform boots and a dreadlocked man in a poncho were around in the area doing crime and we hadn't seen them.

[@jean6453]

​@@reogrande8020 ha ha ha matching your description, amazing an identical trio were out and about, sure thing. 😂

[@reogrande8020]

@@jean6453 pretty impressive in a town of 21 thousand people.

[@feefawfern8240]

​@@reogrande8020 There was no crime, just lies and pretense.

[@zl1booker]

Retired law enforcement myself, and all I can say is: This is the response from an honest man. Thank you sir for being honest and sharing your content. You have gained a follower.

[@Robin.Greenfield]

I'm glad to hear from you my friend. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us! Health and happiness to you, Robin

[@nomzwakazi]

Also someone who is used to sharing about his life quite publically. People who tend to be more introverted and private might find that question to be invasive & not have such a straightfwd answer. Doesn't make them dishonest

[@grb1969]

Screw you for your disservice.

[@sharonhart3735]

Thank goodness your ID of concept was not denied ,be safe Robin.Thks.for all updates.

[@ginamarie5575]

So true . Stay safe on those roads . We are all naked human beings ❤😊

[@TroyTheForager]

Good job being able to use NVC in an anxiety inducing situation. It's another great example of its power.

[@HoboGardenerBen]

Yup, great point. Doesn't excuse it, but a lot of police beatings videos I've seen started with sass and resistance from the person. They are trained to act this way, the issue is systemic, some of the national trainers are insane, somehow wheedled their way in there and became standard. Corruption can express itself in weird ways, like fascist philsophy getting into the training docket.

[@thegnoles]

Oh boy! Welcome to Marin! The police there are *very* “curious” about any interesting things people may be “up to” there! I was back home for a visit last week and took my partner on a little drive through that exact road on Saturday 11/30. We saw a guy living his best life playing his guitar on the roof of his blue school bus, just watching the sunset over the pacific while playing his guitar. That’s what I love about West Sonoma and West Marin, lots of humans just being the humans they were meant to be…besides the most beautiful land I’ve ever seen. We totally would have stopped to say hi if we had crossed paths! Safe travels!!

[@margicain2477]

I love what you had to say about your encounters with law enforcement. What a positive & real reaction to your encounter. Thank you for sharing that. I hope that all that view your video will be touched, also. Blessings in your journey. Hope you get lots of hugs along the way. And if there is another encounter, that it goes as well.

[@Bliss-777]

thank you for sharing this, Robin! You are so wonderful and brave and a real human being! Thank you for shining light! Keep going, hope you can walk in peace from now on!

[@margueritebryant8433]

Wow, this was deep stuff. I especially loved your words about our shared humanity. It's such a beautiful and inspiring way to see things, and makes for gentler interactions. I'm glad they let you proceed and that it all turned out alright.

[@Adventur_inward]

Much love Robin. It is a continuous joy to witness your humanity along your journey.

[@alicetheegreet]

Coincidently, my business card says *"Human Being"* as my title under my name. We have some things in common, Robin Greenfield.

[@charitycabagui2271]

Mabuhay! From the Philippine Islands. Congrats you made through. Just be honest & do to be a service to others. There is no “law” against it.

[@RichardHaywardMelbourne]

Your values, principles and philosophy shine through in this video. I'm grateful that you had the opportunity to demonstrate this through your powerful communication of your experiences.

[@shaunnarochelle]

I appreciate you talking about the priveledge involved. when I was travelling I meet a few young men who seemed intent on proving that anyone can live their vagrant lifestyle all the while not acknowledging how much safer it is not just racially but by being male to sleep outside, walk in deserted places, hitchhike etc.

[@tmckmusic8584]

Just a small point: How we look. Is not who we ARE. 😊

[@tanyajohnston8262]

That is so true. Another gender, skin colour or race would make a big difference for how to be interacted with.

[@FarmedandForaged]

Robin, I met you years ago at Punta Mona and we got to spend some time together. You inspired me then with your words, and now all these years later as I revisit your life and watch your videos, you continue to inspire me. Your quest for truth and transparency is a beautiful thing and it helps me to contextualize my own life and place in this world as a human. Thanks for continuing to live this extreme lifestyle and experiment in the name of truth. 💚

[@liberatedlioness6478]

Good for you Robin, live your life in alignment with your beliefs❤

[@abbycausey8610]

Bless you, Robin 💜

[@Morrigan3339]

Great share Robin. Thank you. A woman no matter what colour or culture undertaking the journey you have been would be a very high risk for kidnapping, rape, assault or murder. So much needs to change. Have been following you for years. You are an incredible human being 🔥

[@AutisticMorty]

"So much needs to change." Imagine if there was thousands of Rob Greens walking down the highways making political activism videos. Do we really need that?

[@zelda8207]

​@@AutisticMortyYes. We need more people like him

[@givemorephilosophy]

@@Morrigan3339 Exactly. Woman is a complimentary human being and not just an object. That is the thought that needs to be adopted by the culture and tradition from humanity...

[@QFamilyAdventures]

We love watching your videos! My husband and I have been following your journey since you were in a closet in San Diego. We live in Camarillo, about an hour north of Los Angeles. We’d be happy to put you up for a night or two if you need a place to stay.

[@donnabootes7272]

Wow Robin you are such an inspiration thank you for sharing this wonderful video God bless you on this beautiful journey thank you bless you on your journey love and blessings from Australia ❤️

[@MerwinARTist]

I've been subscribed to your channel for a long time .. I'm glad you are doing what you are doing! You are making a very important point .. and you are raising awareness about a lot of issues. Keep up the good work .. I understood exactly what you have said. Issues about "marriage licenses" and "home funerals" are also something that is important to understand and know your rights. We are human beings .. not a number or a name!

[@imakinsb5549]

Thank you for your authenticity ❤

[@puggirl415]

Marin county is often overly vigilant. Glad you were able to meet them where they were.

[@philippianstamps2874]

Powerful stuff! Robin, blessings upon you my brother!

[@karlschreiber9286]

Robin Greenfield don't need any ID. You are the only real ID of yourself. Stay strong friend. You re Great! 💕

[@lisamcfall1210]

Happy that they didn’t get crazy and haul you off to jail 😂 I have wondered about what might happen in that situation. I no longer have any ID either. I guess where we have in the past, they can still search your name and see you aren’t a threat 😁

[@TimBrogan]

The first time I observed someone not give ID to the police (unlike your case, they had one but chose not to show it), I was like "is that even legal??" I realized I was completely ignorant and it was the genesis of my education on how to interact with the police in a polite but firm manner. I learned that day what I should have already been taught as a teenager, that you don't need to identify yourself to the police unless you are being detained or arrested.

[@catherineabou-sakher9537]

Take care , Robin. Thanks for all your updates.

[@lepapillonnoir2404]

I'm so happy people like you exist. It gives me hope.

[@charlenecarnes8139]

You're an incredible and beautiful human! I love what you are doing and the message you are relaying. As weird as it sounds I believe you're a modern day Prophet so to speak. The world needs to hear what you're saying. Even if we can't live exactly as you do the words you speak are Love. Hope you reach the masses❤❤❤

[@janetthoke8027]

You are such an inspiration! Thank you for sharing with us! 💕

[@rgcrockett]

First video of yours I have seen. I love the authenticity.

[@brandon637]

Love ya man. Glad to see your videos

[@Neprow3000]

Thank you and god speed to you.

[@nicolaslaino7504]

Glad you are ok and in the interaction was smooth.

[@RawVibrantHealth]

what a legend as always!

[@deansmith9232]

What a wonderful man you are on a true mission my respects and admiration of you!

[@ehopem4877]

Love you back, Robin

[@antarya7102]

Take care Robin 🌍💚

[@atxchaser]

Sending more positive energy your way!

[@LoriCrispin-z7q]

i love your videos, love what ur doing and how u live! u handled the police interaction perfectly 😊

[@lesleyfromkent6938]

From Kent, UK. Heartwarming, truly heartwarming. Xx❤

[@Residew]

The cops spoke with one another. Either directly or over the radio. Thats the reason you were stopped 2 times in 1 day. Also, if you're comfortable I'd recommend recording police encounters to hold them accountable and for your protection. You do not "legally" have to identify yourself if you haven't been suspected of a crime. Although they don't like hearing it, it is worth saying outloud to them in some instances. Best of luck with the rest of your walk Robin. Ive been thoroughly enjoying the videos.

[@kriskabin]

💯🎯 Yes, always video record a police stop.

[@HoboGardenerBen]

They usually apply more pressure to people who behave like that

[@jean6453]

​@@HoboGardenerBen well, if we all "behave like that" and state our civil rights, the cops will learn and get used to people being educated.

[@HoboGardenerBen]

@jean6453 A lot of drunks try to leverage that whole thing to avoid being searched and found out, so they have gotten used to pressuring people. I don't even like to watch those police pullover videos, just when a housemate is watching nearby, and I've seen drunks try to record themselves and assert rights and the cops increase the pressure in direct response to the resistance. If you haven't done anything and have no drugs or whatever, being passive is the best choice. Doing otherwise will change nothing and just get you screwed. Sometimes it's best to know when you're beat, not defeating the justice system.

[@carl8568]

​@@HoboGardenerBen Hello again. I don't think passive is the best approach, assertive would be ideal. Even if you don't record the interaction, it would be worth at least taking their name down should they act belligerent. Given the commercial nature of these interactions with agents of the state, it is good practice to keep your cool and stay honourable.

[@dbuc4671]

This is just generally a very fascinating topic, whether or not you are passionate about the environment and all that or not

[@The7rights]

That was so beautiful Robin

[@claradias4779]

Wooh!!!,you are a champion...😂😂😂❤❤❤to much man!!!!i love you man❤❤❤❤

[@emmma326]

Much love going your way. Please stay safe ❣

[@kristinapitts3341]

What you say resonates with me and life. And the systems society has created- not necessarily in service for every person. Thanks for doing what you are doing and opening our eyes. ❤

[@hunati31]

I’m honored to meet you in person at the spirulina farm. Unfortunately they closed after the last hurricane pushed them over the edge of survival mode.

[@dankslug]

So glad you acknowledged the privilege thing

[@youcanknowanything8489]

let's clarify .. yes he had a birth certificate...and yes he had a social security #. He has just disposed of the physical cards. The digital copies are still alive in govt records.

[@bobbilynngibson302]

Thank you Robin. This helped--a lot! 😊

[@tobysimmonds487]

The message is always, humans are humans Love from the UK!

[@myworldview3183]

Thank you!

[@ExitingTheFantasy]

A fellow truth Seekers, thanks for sharing truth.. we are exiting the fantasy world

[@carl8568]

Robin Greenfield is the legal name, an estate. The proper name, according to dictionaries is your first/Christian name only. This is a key point in how the government administers your estate, a living man or woman literally cannot be taxed or fined, only the legal fiction.

[@KatrinaRenee23]

Be careful Robin.

[@intouchwiththeheart]

AMEN to that closing statement 🥰

[@KokoraLife]

So interesting! Thanks for sharing your experience.

[@jackhemm98]

america is so carbrained that the police are called when they see someone walking

[@iforgiveyou3031]

Love you brother so much ❤❤❤❤

[@ionageman]

L.A. Is not currently the place to be a “ homeless “ traveller .. your freedom can easily be removed . Don’t let your strength undermine your ability to live as you want .

[@cziegle3794]

Yay top 535 and top 101 likes and comments. Love this channel. Best to you and your family. Thanks for making this video. Happy holidays!!!! 🎃 🦃 🎄

[@tordfalch7267]

Respect to you, my dear fellow human being.

[@troygoss6400]

I have the highest respect for your reality. 🕉♾️

[@sunshineandsmiles9668]

Hello,when I find myself being judgemental toward others I regroup and look at their skeletal structure, we are all lovely skeletons wrapped uniquely. Thanks for the anecdotal lesson.

[@beatricevandeborne3088]

We are hunabn beings so let us be!

[@unitedspiritsvillage]

Thank you for sharing your phenomenal journey. I appreciate that you acknowledge your privilege, my friend. I see how your journey impacts and highlights your well-being and authenticity and opens the eyes of curiosity in others. I know that while it isn't easy (what good stuff in life is actually easy), I dream of owning my autonomy and freedom. No Fico scores, away from the confines of "modern" thinking. I am not normally a fearful person, but I am apprehensive about expressing myself in that way in part due to my darker skin. I imagine crossing manmade borders to explore God's Earth without controlling "authorities" stopping me. I am being called. However, sometimes, it seems easier to conform for "safety" reasons. I am inspired to free up more. I am grateful for you❤

[@laugau9097]

Well done Robin 😊😊😊😊

[@donnabashline4933]

Good for you.

[@daisyzhang-gk9uy]

Hahaha😂you made me laugh ❤gave your hard copy book to hard cop 👮‍♂️ lol 😂

[@josh300]

You are a true modern hero. Probably one of the officers might have thought of you as the new Jesus 😂. Jokes aside, you inspire me. I've started a permaculture project in Mexico 8 months ago, and you have been one of my main inspirations since prior and to this day. Thanks for being you and showing the rest of society a different lens of humanity and life. I hope we meet some day. Best of luck!

[@herrerad3]

Sending love and strength from San Diego. If you ever need a spot in SD, it would be an honor. 🤜🤛

[@alexandrayiama1056]

AWESOME VIDEO!!!! CONGRATS!!!!